Balt. & Ohio R.R. Co. v. Kepner, 314 U.S. 44 (1941)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Balt. & Ohio R.R. Co. v. Kepner, 314 U.S. 44 (1941)
Full caption
BALTIMORE & OHIO RAILROAD CO. v. KEPNER.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Nov. 10, 1941
BALTIMORE & OHIO RAILROAD CO. v. KEPNER.
CERTIORARI TO THE SUPREME COURT OF OHIO.
No. 20. Reargued October 20, 1941.—Decided November 10, 1941.
1. Under § 6 of the Federal Employers Liability Act, as amended, the injured employee has the federal privilege of bringing his action in any district in which the railroad is doing business, though the district chosen be far from the district in which he resides, or in which the cause of action arose, and in another State. P. 52. 2. A state court may not validly exercise its equitable jurisdiction to enjoin a resident of the State from prosecuting a cause of action arising under the Federal Employers Liability Act in a federal court of another State where the Act gave venue, on the ground that the prosecution in that district is inequitable, vexatious and harassing to the carrier. P. 53.
137 Ohio St. 409; 30 N. E. 2d 982, affirmed.
Certiorari, 312 U. S. 671, to review a decree affirming the dismissal on demurrer of a bill by the railroad company to enjoin Kepner from further prosecution of a suit in the federal court for the Eastern District of New York seeking recovery of damages under the Federal Employers Liability Act for injuries resulting from an accident in Ohio. The judgment was affirmed here by an equally divided court, 313 U. S. 542; subsequently, a petition for •rehearing was granted, the judgment was vacated, and the case was restored to the docket for reargument, 313 U. S. 597.
Messrs. Harry H. Byrer and Morison R. Waite, with whom Messrs. Cassius M. Clay and William A. Eggers were on the brief, for petitioner.
Courts of equity have inherent power to restrain the prosecution of vexatious and harassing litigation, and it is the law of Ohio that its citizens are subject to the exercise of such power by its courts. Pomeroy’s Equity Jurisprudence, 3rd Ed., Vol. 4, § 1360; Vol. 6, § 670; Snook v. p. 4544 Argument for Petitioner.
Snetzer, 25 Ohio St. 516; New York, C. & St. L. R. Co. v. Matzinger, 136 Ohio St. 271; Cole v. Cunningham, 133 U. S. 107; Dehon v. Foster, 4 Allen 545 (Mass.); Steelman v. All Continent Corp., 301 U. S. 278, 291; Boston & M. R. Co. v. Whitehead, 29 N. E. 2d 916, and cases cited.
The Federal Employers’ Liability Act does not forbid, either expressly or by implication, this exercise of power by the courts, nor does it so completely cover the field as to preclude the application of state law. Douglas v. N. Y., N. H. & H. R. Co., 279 U. S. 377; Maurer v. Hamilton, 309 U. S. 598; Reid n. Colorado, 187 U. S. 137, 148; Federal Trade Commission v. Bunte Bros., 312 U. S. 349; United States v. Darby, 312 U. S. 100; Hines v. Davidowitz, 312 U. S. 52; Kelly v. Washington, 302 U. S. 1; Michigan Central R. Co. v. Mix, 278 U. S. 492.
The history of the amendment to § 6 of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act demonstrates that Congress did not intend to bar this equitable power, and that the exercise of such power would be in harmony with the purpose of the Act. Palmer v. Webster & Atlas Bank, 312 U. S. 156; Thornton’s Federal Employers’ Liability Act, 3rd Ed., Appendix B, pp. 576, 580; Cong. Rec., Vol. 45, Pt. 4, p. 4040.
The restraint of a party to a suit is not tantamount to the restraint of the court itself. Steelman v. All Continent Corp., 301 U. S. 278, 290; Bryant v. Atlantic Coast Line R. Co., 92 F. 2d 569.
The facts in the present case are sufficient to invoke the equitable powers of a court. Baltimore & Ohio R. Co. v. Kepner, 137 Ohio St. 409; Davis v. Farmers’ Cooperative Co., 262 U. S. 312; Michigan Central R. Co. v. Mix, 278 U. S. 492; Denver & R. G. W. R. Co. v. Terte, 284 U. S. 284; New York, C. St. L. R. Co. v. Matzinger, 136 Ohio St. 271; Erie R. Co. v. Tompkins, 304 U. S. 64.
The weight of authority supports the right to injunction. Reed’s Administratrix v. Illinois Central R. Co.,
Argument for Respondent. 314U.S.
182 Ky. 455; Ex Parte Crandall, 53 F. 2d 969, cert, den., 285 U. S. 540; Bryant v. Atlantic Coast Line R. Co., 92 F. 2d 569.
Whether the conduct of an Ohio citizen is equitable is a question of state law, which an Ohio court having jurisdiction of the citizen is to determine in accordance with that law, unless Congress within its delegated powers has made an enactment inconsistent with the Ohio law. Milliken v. Meyer, 311 U. S. 457.
Mr. Samuel T. Gaines, with whom Mr. Edward M. Ballard was on the brief, for respondent.
The Federal Employers’ Liability Act drew to itself the right of action for injuries or death of an employee within its purview. The action must be brought as prescribed in the Act. Moore v. C. & 0. Ry. Co., 291 U. S. 205; Breisch v. Central Railroad, 312 U. S. 484; Seaboard Air Line Ry. Co. v. Kenney, 240 U. S. 489.
The right of respondent to sue in the federal District Court in the district where petitioner is doing business is clear and unqualified, and compels such court to assume jurisdiction. Moore v. C. & 0. Ry. Co., supra; Southern Ry. v. Cochran, 56 F. 2d 1019; Rader v. B. & 0. R. Co., 108 F. 2d 980; Chicago, M. & St. P. Ry. Co. v. Schendel, 292 F. 326; Atchison, T. & S. F. Ry. Co. v. Sowers, 213 U. S. 55.
Nothing in either the language or the history of § 6 of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act sustains the contention that the right to invoke a federal court’s jurisdiction therein provided is subject to the equity powers of a state court.
The language is clear, and its obvious meaning controls. Railroad Commission v. Chicago, B. & Q. R. Co., 257 U. S. 563, 588, 589; Kuehner v. Irving Trust Co., 299 U. S. 445, 449.
The Ohio court had no jurisdiction of the subject of the action after District Court jurisdiction attached.
The grant of concurrent jurisdiction gives plaintiff a choice of the court. As an incident he is entitled to whatever remedial advantage inheres in the particular forum. Minneapolis <& St. Louis R. Co. v. Bombolis, 241 U. S.211; Missouri v. Taylor, 266 U. S. 200.
A state court is without power to arrest jurisdiction of the federal court. Sharon v. Terry, 36 F. 337, 355; Wallace v. McConnell, 13 Pet. 138.151; Terral v. Burke Construction Co., 257 U. S. 532; Pennsylvania Casualty Co. v. Pennsylvania, 294 U. S. 189, 197; Riggs v. Johnson County, 6 Wall. 166.
Mr. Justice Reed delivered the opinion of the Court.
We have for decision in this case the question whether a state court may validly exercise its equitable jurisdiction to enjoin a resident of the state from prosecuting a cause of action arising under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act in a federal court of another state where that Act gave venue, on the ground that the prosecution in the federal court is inequitable, vexatious and harassing to the carrier.
As the issue was deemed a federal question of substance,1 undecided by this Court, and concerning which there was lack of uniformity in the state court decisions,2 certiorari was granted, 312 U. S. 671, the decree below affirmed here by an equally divided court, 313 U. S. 542, and the petition for rehearing allowed, 313 U. S. 597.
1
Judicial Code, § 237b. 8 McConnell v. Thomson, 213 Ind. 16, 8 N. E. 2d 986, 11 N. E. 2d 183; Reed's Admrx. v, Illinois Central R, Co., 182 Ky. 455, 206 8. W. 794,
This proceeding originally was brought by the petitioner, an interstate railroad, in the Court of Common Pleas of Hamilton County, Ohio, against the respondent Kepner, an injured resident employee, to enjoin his continued prosecution of a suit in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act for his injuries. The accident, according to the petition, occurred in Butler County, Ohio, a county adjacent to that of respondent’s residence, through both of which counties petitioner’s railroad ran. The petition further showed that suitable courts, state and federal, were constantly open and that petitioner and the witnesses were available for process therein. It was stated the federal court chosen was seven hundred miles from the residence of the respondent and numerous witnesses; that to present the case properly required the personal attendance of approximately twenty-five locally available witnesses—the crew, inspectors and the medical attendants—at a cost estimated to exceed the cost of the presentation of the case at a convenient point by $4,000, with no resulting benefit to the injured employee. Petitioner asserted these facts established that the continued prosecution of the federal court action would be an undue burden on interstate commerce and an unreasonable, improper and inequitable burden upon petitioner itself.
The defendant railroad was doing business in the New York district where the damage suit was filed, as appears from a copy of the complaint in the federal case made a part of the petition.
Respondent demurred for failure to state a cause of action and lack of jurisdiction of the subject of the action. The trial court sustained the demurrer and dismissed the action, by an order which was sustained by the Court of Appeals and, on rehearing, by the Supreme
Court of Ohio.3 The basis for the decision below was that the respondent employee was privileged to enjoy, without interference from a state court, the venue allowed by the Federal Employers’ Liability Act.4
The statutory provision in regard to venue is in § 6, which so far as pertinent reads as follows:
“Under this chapter an action may be brought in a district court of the United States, in the district of the residence of the defendant, or in which the cause of action arose, or in which the defendant shall be doing business at the time of commencing such action.” (Apr. 5,1910, c. 143, § 1, 36 Stat. 291, as amended March 3, 1911, c. 231, § 291,36 Stat. 1167; 45 U. S. C. § 56.
When the second Employers’ Liability Act was enacted, venue of actions under it was left to the general venue statute, 35 Stat. 65, which fixed the venue of suits in the United States courts, based in whole or in part upon the Act, in districts of which the defendant was an inhabitant.5 Litigation promptly disclosed what Congress considered deficiencies in such a limitation of the right of railroad employees to bring personal injury actions,6 with the result that the present language was added.7
The reason for the addition was said to be the injustice to an injured employee of compelling him to go to the possibly far distant place of habitation of the defendant
8 First section of the act of March 3, 1875, 18 Stat. 470, as amended by the act of March 3, 1887, 24 Stat. 552, and act of August 13, 1888, 25 Stat. 433.
9 Cound v. Atchison, T. & S. F. Ry. Co., 173 F. 527; Macon Grocery Co. v. Atlantic Coast Line R. Co., 215 U. S. 501, 506. Senate Report No. 432, 61st Cong., 2d Sess., p. 4.
’April 5,1910, c. 143,36 Stat. 291.
428670°—42----- 4
carrier, with consequent increased expense for the transportation and maintenance of witnesses, lawyers and parties, away from their homes.8 The legislative history throws little light on the reason for the choice of the three standards for determining venue: the residence of the carrier, the place where it is doing business, or the place where the cause of action arose. At one time, the amendatory bill fixed venue as “the district of the residence of either the plaintiff or the defendant, or in which the cause of action arose, or in which the defendant shall be found at the time of commencing such action.” 9 Fears were expressed that so wide a choice might result in injustice to the carrier, p. 2257. No doubt this language was actually considered by the Senate Judiciary Committee, as well as the language of the general venue statute for which the Committee was providing an exception. Specific attention was called in the Senate report to the Macon Grocery case, interpreting the general venue statute. That statute placed venue in the residence of either party, where the jurisdiction was founded on diversity of citizenship alone. The language finally adopted must have been deliberately chosen to enable the plaintiff, in the words of Senator Borah, who submitted the report on the bill, “to find the corporation at any point or place or State where it is actually carrying on business, and there lodge his action, if he chooses to do so.”10
When petitioner sought an injunction in the Ohio court against the further prosecution of the federal court action in New York, the petition alleged that prosecution of the New York action would entail “an undue burden” on interstate commerce. No objection to the decree below, upon that explicit ground, appears in the petition for p. 51certiorari, either in the specification of errors or reasons for granting the writ. In petitioner’s brief on the merits, it is pointed out that this Court held in Denver & R. G. W. R. Co. v. Terte, 284 U. S. 284, that the disadvantages of litigation far from the scene of the accident are not substantial enough to justify a state court in forbidding the continuation of the litigation in a district where the lines of the carrier run. This accords with Hofjman v. Missouri ex ret. Foraker, 274 U. S. 21, where it was said the carrier must “submit, if there is jurisdiction, to the requirements of orderly, effective administration of justice, although thereby interstate commerce is incidentally burdened.” 11 Since the carrier’s exhibit of respondent’s New York petition shows an allegation that it is doing business in New York, we assume that business to be such as is contemplated by the venue provisions of § 6. There is therefore no occasion to consider further the suggestion that the suit in New York creates an inadmissible burden upon interstate commerce.
The real contention of petitioner is that, despite the admitted venue, respondent is acting in a vexatious and inequitable manner in maintaining the federal court suit in a distant jurisdiction when a convenient and suitable forum is at respondent’s doorstep. Under such circumstances, petitioner asserts power, abstractly speaking, in the Ohio court to prevent a resident under its jurisdiction
11 Cf. International Milling Co. v. Columbia Co., 292 U. S. 511, 517—21; St. Louis, B. & M. Ry. Co. v. Taylor, 266 U. S. 200, 207. Davis v. Farmers Co-operative Co., 262 U. S. 312, is limited to its particular facts, 292 U. S. 511 at 517; Michigan Central R. Co. v. Mix, 278 U. S. 492, and Atchison, T. & S. F. Ry. Co. v. Wells, 265 U. S. 101, turn on the absence or inconsequential character of business done within the states where the railroads were sued. The Mix case is differentiated from the Foraker and Taylor cases because the carrier’s lines or contracts did not run or call for performance in the territory over which the court where the objectionable action was filed had jurisdiction.
from doing inequity. Such power does exist.12 In the Matzinger case, the Supreme Court of Ohio exercised this power to prevent the continuation of a personal injury suit in Illinois, by a resident under its jurisdiction, on an Ohio cause of action. Such power has occasionally been exercised by one state over its citizens, seeking to enforce in other states remedies under the Employers’ Liability Act, against defendants locally available for the litigation.13 At times the injunction has been refused.14*
We read the opinion of the Supreme Court of Ohio to express the view that, if it were not for § 6 of the Employers’ Liability Act, the requested injunction would be granted, on the undisputed facts of the petition. Section 6 establishes venue for an action in the federal courts. As such venue is a privilege created by federal statute18 and claimed by respondent, the Supreme Court of Ohio felt constrained by the Supremacy Clause to treat § 6 as decisive of the issue. It is clear that the allowance or denial of this federal privilege is a matter of federal law, not a matter of state law under Erie Railroad Co. v. Tompkins, 304 U. S. 64, 72.16 Its correct decision depends upon a construction of a federal act.17 Consequently, the action of a state court must be in accord with the federal statute
“ New York, C. & St. L. R. Co. v. Matzinger, 136 Ohio St. 271, 25 N. E. 2d 349; Cole v. Cunningham, 133 U. S. 107; Simon v. Southern Ry. Co., 236 U. S. 115,123.
13 Kern v. Cleveland, C., C. & St. L. Ry. Co., 204 Ind. 595,185 N. E. 446; Reed’s Admrx. v. Illinois Central R. Co., 182 Ky. 455, 206 S. W. 794;Ex parte Crandall, 53 F. 2d 969.
14 Missouri-Kansas-Texas R. Co. v. Ball, 126 Kan. 745, 271 P. 313; Mobile & Ohio R. Co. v. Parrent, 260 Ill. App. 284; Lancaster v. Dunn, 153 La. 15, 95 So. 385.
M A contrary view as to injunctions against actions in state courts has been expressed. Roberts: Federal Liabilities of Carriers (2d Ed.) Vol. 2, § 962.
and the federal rule as to its application, rather than state statute, rule or policy.18
Petitioner presses upon us the argument that the action of Congress gave an injured railway employee the privilege of extended venue, subject to the usual powers of the state to enjoin what in the judgment of the state courts would be considered an improper use of that privilege. This results, says petitioner, because the Act does not in terms exclude this state power.19 As courts of equity admittedly possessed this power before the enactment of § 6, the argument continues, it is not to be lightly inferred that the venue privilege was in disregard of this policy. But the federal courts have felt they could not interfere with suits in far federal districts where the inequity alleged was based only on inconvenience.20 There is no occasion to distinguish between the power and the propriety of its exercise in this instance, since the limits of the two are here co-extensive. The privilege was granted because the general venue provisions worked injustices to employees. It is obvious that no state statute could vary the venue;21 and, we think, equally true that no state court may inter-
18 Calhoun Gold Mining Co. v. Ajax Gold Mining Co., 182 U. S. 499,. 505; Tulloch v. Mulvane, 184 U. S. 497, 505, 512-13; Cincinnati, N. 0. & T. P. Ry. Co. v. Rankin, 241 U. S. 319, 326-27; Chesapeake & Ohio Ry. Co. v. Martin, 283 U. S. 209, 213; Chesapeake & Ohio Ry. Co. v. Kuhn, 284 U. S. 44, 47; Federal Land Bank v. Priddy, 295 U. S. 229, 231; cf. Roberts, op. tit., supra.
Frankfurter, J., dissenting. 314 U. S.
fere with the privilege, for the benefit of the carrier or the national transportation system, on the ground of inequity based on cost, inconvenience or harassment. When the section was enacted it filled the entire field of venue in federal courts.22 A privilege of venue, granted by the legislative body which created this right of action, cannot be frustrated for reasons of convenience or expense. If it is deemed unjust, the remedy is legislative—a course followed in securing the amendment of April 5, 1910, for the benefit of employees. This Court held in Hoffman v. Missouri ex rel. Foraker, 274 U. S. 21, that the burden on interstate commerce would be disregarded where the carrier had lines in the distant state. The importance of unhampered commerce is at least as great as that of a carrier’s freedom from harassing incidents of litigation. Whatever burden there is here upon the railroad, because of inconvenience or cost, does not outweigh the plain grant of privilege for suit in New York.23
Affirmed.
Mr. Justice Frankfurt er, dissenting:
Disagreement with the views of the majority on the construction of a venue provision does not ordinarily call for expression. But inasmuch as the decision in this case unjustifiably limits long-settled powers of the state courts and thereby brings into disequilibrium the relationship of federal and state courts, I think it proper to express my views.
44 Frankfurter, J., dissenting.
The decision of the Court seems to be epitomized in this sentence: “A privilege of venue, granted by the legislative body which created this right of action, cannot be frustrated for reasons of convenience or expense.” As a general proposition, the suggestion that a privilege of venue granted by the legislative body which creates the right of action “cannot be frustrated for reasons of convenience or expense” would be as novel as it is untenable. To give unique scope to this venue provision different from the significance accorded all other provisions of venue “granted by the legislative body which created” the right is no less novel doctrine. For this departure from the effect customarily given to venue provisions, no warrant is avouched in the specific provisions of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, the general provisions of legislation defining the relationship between federal and state courts, the principles applied in the decisions of this Court, or settled doctrines of equity jurisdiction. None is avouched because none is available.
The opinion does not deny the historic power of courts of equity to prevent a misuse of litigation by enjoining resort to vexatious and oppressive foreign suits. See e. g., Cole v. Cunningham, 133 IT. S. 107, 118-20; Pere Marquette Ry. Co. v. Slutz, 268 Mich. 388, 256 N. W. 458; Mason v. Harlow, 84 Kan. 277,114 P. 218; Wilser v. Wilser, 132 Minn. 167, 156 N. W. 271; Northern Pacific Ry. Co. v. Richey & Gilbert Co., 132 Wash. 526,232 P. 355; O’Haire v. Burns, 45 Colo. 432, 101 P. 755; Miller v. Gittings, 85 Md. 601, 37 A. 372. Nor does it question the familiar doctrine of forum non conveniens, under which a court having statutory jurisdiction may decline its facilities to a suit that in justice should be tried elsewhere. See Canada Malting Co. v. Paterson Co., 285 U. S. 413, 422-23; Massachusetts v. Missouri, 308 U. S. 1, 19; Rogers v. Guaranty Trust Co., 288 U. S. 123, 130-31. These manifestations of a civilized judicial system are firmly imbedded
Frankfurter, J., dissenting. 314U.S.
in. our law. See Foster, Place of Trial in Civil Actions, 43 Harv. L. Rev. 1217; Blair, The Doctrine of Forum Non Conveniens in Anglo-American Law, 29 Col. L. Rev. 1. Nor does the decision give new currency to the discredited notion that there is a general lack of power in the state courts to enjoin proceedings in federal courts. Cf. Prin^ cess Lida v. Thompson, 305 U. S. 456,466; Warren, Federal and State Court Interference, 43 Harv. L. Rev. 345. Nothing in Article III of the Constitution or in the legislation by which Congress has vested judicial power in the federal courts justifies such a doctrine.
And so the basis of the decision of the Court must be found, if anywhere, in the terms of the venue provision of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act. The section provides, simply, that an action under the Act “may be brought in a District Court of the United States, in the district of the residence of the defendant, or in which the cause of action arose, or in which the defendant shall be doing business at the time of commencing such action,” that the jurisdiction of the federal courts shall be “concurrent” with that of the state courts, and that no action brought in a state court of competent jurisdiction shall be removed to a federal court. 36 Stat. 291; 45 U. S. C. § 56. The phrasing of the section is not unique: it follows the familiar pattern generally employed by Congress in framing venue provisions. E. g., 28 U. S. C. § 112 (suits based upon diversity of citizenship); 28 U. S. C. § 53 (suits by or against China Trade Act corporations); 28 U. S. C. i 104 (suite for penalties and forfeitures); 28 U. S. C. § 105 (suite for recovery of taxes); 28 U. S. C. § 41 (26) (b) (interpleader). The decision cannot rest, therefore, upon any peculiarities of the language of the provision.
Nor can justification for the Court’s conclusion be found in the legislative history of the section or the clearly expressed reasons of policy underlying its enactment. As the House and Senate committee reports show, H. Rept. p. 5744 Frankfurter, J., dissenting.
No. 513, pp. 6-7, S. Rept. No. 432, pp. 3-4, 61st Cong., 2d Sess., Congress was aware of the hardship by which, under the original Employers’ Liability Act of April 22,1908, 35 Stat. 65, the plaintiff could bring his action only at the railroad’s “residence.” Cound v. Atchison, T. 8. F. Ry. Co., 173 F. 527. The amendment of 1910 greatly enlarged the range of a plaintiff’s convenience in bringing suit. It is not disputed that the amendment was intended to open to a plaintiff courts from which he previously was barred. But that is not the question before us. The problem is whether the Act was intended to give a plaintiff an absolute and unqualified right to compel trial of his action in any of the specified places he chooses, thereby not only depriving state courts of their old power to protect against unjustly oppressive foreign suits, but also forbidding federal courts to decline jurisdiction “in the interest of justice” on familiar grounds of forum non conveniens. See Canada Malting Co. v. Paterson Co., 285 U. S. 413,422-23. Nothing in the history of the 1910 amendment indicates that its framers contemplated any such vast transformation in the established relationship between federal and state courts and in the duty of the federal courts to decline jurisdiction “in the interest of justice.” On the contrary, the expressed considerations of policy underlying the amendment were fundamentally the same as those underlying the equitable power to restrain oppressive suits and the reciprocal doctrine of forum non conveniens: It does not comport with equity and justice to allow a suit to be litigated in a forum where, on the balance, unnecessary hardship and inconvenience would be cast upon one party without any compensatingly fair convenience to the other party, but where, on the contrary, the suit might more conveniently be litigated in another forum available equally to both parties.
This doctrine of justice applies with especially compelling force where the conveniences to be balanced are not
Frankfurter, J., dissenting. 314 U. S.
merely conveniences of conflicting private interests but where there is added the controlling factor of public interest. The so-called “convenience” of a railroad concerns the important national function of which the railroads are the agency. As in other phases of federal railroad regulation, the interests of carriers, employees, and the public must be balanced. Because of the “direct concern of the public” in maintaining an economic and efficient railroad system, a unanimous Court, speaking through Mr. Justice Brandeis, held that a carrier may not be sued by a plaintiff where, under the circumstances of the particular facts, such suit would impose an unfair burden upon railroads and thereby upon the nation. Davis v. Farmers Co-operative Co., 262 U. S. 312. The declaration by Congress that a court has jurisdiction and venue is not a command that it must exercise*its authority in such a case to the unnecessary injury of a defendant and the public. This doctrine has been consistently followed in a series of unanimous decisions. Atchison, T. & S. F. Ry. Co. v. Wells, 265 U. S. 101; Michigan Central R. Co. v. Mix, 278 U. S. 492; Hoffman v. Foraker, 274 U. S. 21; Denver & R. G. W. R. Co. v. Terte, 284 U. S. 284? Of course, Congress, if it chose, could subject interstate carriers to the jurisdiction of the state courts, even in the situations in which this Court found that assumption of jurisdiction would be an injustice to the public. But Congress has not expressed a different view of the governing public interest—and these cases stand as unchallenged p. 5944 Frankfurter, J., dissenting.
1
International Milling Co. v. Columbia Co., 292 U. S. 511, did not restrict but expressly recognized the doctrine of the Davis case. In finding the scope of the Davis doctrine in the circumstances which gave rise to it, the opinion in the Milling Co. case only followed traditional technique in the use of precedents. It made precisely the same differentiation that Mr. Justice Brandeis, who articulated the doctrine in the Davis case, made in applying the principle of the case to subsequent situations. See St. Louis, B. & M. Ry. Co. v. Taylor, 266 U. S. 200, and Hoffman v. Foraker, 274 U. S. 21. The doctrine itself stands unchallenged. The present decision does not challenge it.
authorities that, notwithstanding the provision of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act conferring unqualified “concurrent jurisdiction” upon the state courts, a plaintiff may in some circumstances be barred from bringing his suit in one of the places specified by the Act. In this respect, at least, a plaintiff’s “privilege of venue, granted by the legislative body which created this right of action,” can “be frustrated for reasons of convenience or expense.”
The opinion of the Court attaches importance to a phrase taken from Senator Borah’s remarks on the floor of the Senate in submitting the bill to amend the Act: “The bill enables the plaintiff to find the corporation at any point or place or State where it is actually carrying on business, and there lodge his action, if he chooses to do so.” 45 Cong. Rec. 4034. The context of this statement is set out in the footnote.2
The intrinsic difficulties of language and the emergence, after enactment, of situations not anticipated by even the
’ “Mr. President, I wish to discuss very briefly the bill. The bill as it is now pending provides for three amendments to the employers’ liability law which is now upon the statute books. The first has reference to the venue . . . The objection which has been made to the existing law, and this objection arises by reason of the decision of some of the courts, is that the plaintiff may sometimes be compelled to go a great distance in order to have his cause of action against the defendant by reason of the fact that now the action must be brought in certain instances in the district in which the defendant is an inhabitant. In other words, the corporation being an inhabitant of the State which creates it, it might follow that the plaintiff would have to travel a long distance in order, under certain conditions, to bring his action against the defendant and come within the terms of the law. So, if this bill should be passed the law will be remedied in that respect, in enabling the plaintiff to bring his action where the cause of action arose or where the defendant may be doing business. The bill enables the plaintiff to find the corporation at any point or place or State where it is actually carrying on business, and there lodge his action, if he chooses to do so,” 45 Cong. Rec. 4034.
Frankfurter, J., dissenting. 314U.S.
most gifted legislative imagination reveal the doubts and ambiguities in statutes that so often compel judicial construction. To illumine these dark places in legislative composition all the sources of light must be drawn upon. But the various aids to construction are guides of experience, not technical rules of law. See Boston Sand Co. v. United States, 278 U. S. 41, 48. One of the sources which may be used for extracting meaning from legislation is the deliberative commentary of the legislators immediately in charge of a measure. Contemporary answers by those authorized to give answers to questions raised about the meaning of pending legislation obviously go a long way to elucidating doubtful legislative purpose. But this rule of good sense does not mean that every loose phrase, even of the proponent of a measure, is to be given the authority of an encyclical. The language of a chairman of a committee, like the language of all people, is merely a symbol of thought. A speaker’s casual, isolated general observation should not be tortured into an expression of disregard for an established, far-reaching policy of the law. Especially in the case of Senator Borah, such imputation should not be made. As is well known, he eyed most jealously the absorption of state authority by extension of federal power. It would have been easy to vest the enforcement of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act entirely in the federal courts. Instead, not only was concurrent jurisdiction given to the state courts in the enforcement of this federal right, but removal of a state action to the federal courts was prohibited. Instead of being deemed hostile to the purposes of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act and not to be entrusted with its administration, the state courts were accepted as the most active agencies for its enforcement. And yet, although nowhere in the course of the whole legislative history of the Act in question—the hearings, the reports in both houses, the debates on the floor—is there the slightest intimation that the problem before us entered the mind of any legis- p. 6144 Frankfurter, J., dissenting.
lator, we are asked to attribute to Senator Borah the uprooting of a doctrine which is an old and fruitful part of the fabric of the law of the states as well as the law of the land, by a general observation which has ncr relation to this doctrine and to which respectful meaning can be given without such distortion.
To read the venue provision of the Act as do the majority of the Court, is to translate the permission given a plaintiff to enter courts previously closed to him into a withdrawal from the state courts of power historically exercised by them, and into an absolute direction to the specified federal and state courts to take jurisdiction. The implications of such a construction extend far beyond the situation we now have here, of an attempt by a state court to enjoin an action brought in a federal court sitting in another state. It seems to be generally held that the grant to the state courts of jurisdiction concurrent with the federal courts does not deprive one state court of the power to enjoin an oppressive suit under the Act in a foreign state court.3 Moreover, this Court has expressly held that the venue provision of the Employers’ Liability Act does not prevent a state court from declining jurisdiction as a forum non conveniens. Douglas v. New York, N. H. & H. R. Co., 279 U. S. 377. To be sure, under the guise of applying local doctrines of equity jurisdiction, a state court cannot defeat the proper assertion of a federal right.
*
See Reed’s Admrx. v. Illinois Central R. Co., 182 Ky. 455, 206 S. W. 794; Chicago, M. & St. P. Ry. Co. n. McGinley, 175 Wis. 565,185 N. W. 218; State ex rel. New York, C. »Si. L. R. Co. v. Nortoni, 331 Mo. 764, 55 S. W. 2d 272; Kern v. Cleveland, C., C. & St. L. R. Co., 204 Ind. 595, 185 N. E. 446, with which compare McConnell v. Thomson, 213 Ind. 16, 8 N. E. 2d 986, 11 N. E. 2d 183; cf. Ex parte Crandall, 53 F. 2d 969. The lower federal courts have usually declined to enjoin suits under the Act brought in other federal courts. See Rader v. Baltimore & Ohio R. Co., 108 F. 2d 980, 985-86; Chesapeake & Ohio Ry. Co. v. Vigor, 90 F. 2d 7; Southern Ry. Co, v. Cochran, 56 F. 2d 1019, 1020.
Frankfurter, J., dissenting. 314 U. S.
Resort to this Court may always be had to lay bare such an unwarranted frustration. American Railway Express Co. v. Levee, 263 U. S. 19; Davis v. Wechsler, 263 U. S. 22. But such supervisory power by this Court over the determination of federal rights by state courts does not imply the denial of power in the state courts to make such determinations in the first instance. Second Employers’ Liability Cases, 223 U. S. 1, 56-57; Claflin v. Houseman, 93 U. S. 130,136-37; Robb v. Connolly, 111 U. S. 624, 637; cf. Warren, Federal Criminal Laws and State Courts, 38 Harv. L. Rev. 545, 596-97. The long history of leaving the effective enforcement of federal rights to state courts has proceeded on recognition of the power of the state courts to exercise in the first instance their settled doctrines of law and equity. The opinion of the Court ignores these settled principles. In an area demanding the utmost judicial circumspection, dislocating uncertainty is thereby introduced.
If the privilege afforded a plaintiff to bring suit under the Employers’ Liability Act in one place rather than in another is to be regarded as an absolute command to the federal courts to take jurisdiction regardless of any considerations of justice and fairness, why is not the same effect to be given the comparable general venue provisions of § 51 of the Judicial Code, 28 U. S. C. § 112? Nothing in the language or the history of the venue provision of the Act differentiates it from the numerous other venue provisions of the Judicial Code. Is the settled doctrine of forum non conveniens to be deemed impliedly repealed by every such venue provision? Surely, it is much more consonant with reason and right to read venue provisions in the familiar context of established law rather than to impute to Congress an unconsidered, profound alteration in the relationship between the federal and the state p. 6344 Syllabus. courts and in the relations of the federal courts inter se. Cf. Gay v. Rufj, 292 U. S. 25.
The Chief Justice and Mr. Justice Roberts join in this opinion.
INDIANAPOLIS et al. v. CHASE NATIONAL BANK, TRUSTEE, et al.*
CERTIORARI TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT.
Nos. 10 and 11. Argued February 6, 7, 1941. Reargued October 15, 16, 1941.—Decided November 10, 1941.
*
Together with No. 12, Chase National Bank, Trustee, v. Citizens Gas Co. et al.; and No. 13, Chase National Bank, Trustee, v. Indianapolis Gas Co. et al., also on writs of certiorari to the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.
1
To sustain federal jurisdiction on the ground of diversity of citizenship, there must exist an actual, substantial controversy, on one side of which the parties must all be citizens of States different from those of which the parties on the other side are citizens. P. 69.
2
Diversity jurisdiction can not be conferred upon the federal courts by the parties’ own determination of who are plaintiffs and who are defendants; and it is the duty of this Court, as well as of the lower courts, to look beyond the pleadings and arrange the parties according to their sides in the dispute. P. 69.
3
Whether there exists the necessary collision of interests to sustain diversity jurisdiction, must be ascertained from the principal purpose of the suit and the primary and controlling matter in dispute. P.69.
4
Upon the facts of this case, which was a suit brought, in a federal court of Indiana, by a New York bank against two Indiana gas companies and an Indiana city, this Court holds that the “primary and controlling matter in dispute” is whether a lease, whereby one of the gas companies conveyed all of its gas plant property to the other, was binding upon the city, to which the property had been afterwards conveyed by the lessee corporation pursuant to its franchise; that, with respect to that dispute, one of the gas companies and the city (“citizens” of the same State) are on opposite sides; and that, there-
Argument for the Bank. 314U.S.
fore, federal jurisdiction, which depends on diversity of citizenship, is lacking. Pp. 70, 74. 5. This Court’s earlier denial of certiorari to review a judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals reversing a judgment of the District Court which dismissed this suit for want of jurisdiction, could not confer on the federal courts a jurisdiction which Congress has denied. P. 75. 6. The policy of the statute conferring diversity jurisdiction upon the district courts calls for its strict construction. P. 76. 113 F. 2d 217, reversed.
Certiorari, 311 U. S. 636, 637, to review the reversal of a judgment which held a lease invalid. A petition for certiorari to review the case in an earlier phase, 96 F. 2d 363, was denied, 305 U. S. 600.
Mr. Howard F. Burns, with whom Messrs. John Adams and Harvey J. Elam were on the brief, for the Chase National Bank, at both hearings.
The Circuit Court of Appeals properly refused to realign Indianapolis Gas with Chase as a party plaintiff.
It is inconceivable that a party against whom plaintiff is entitled to recover a judgment for approximately $1,700,000 can be aligned with the plaintiff under any circumstances.
The City’s argument is based entirely on the fact that the City, as successor lessee, has been held primarily liable and Indianapolis Gas secondarily liable for the amount of the judgment, and that the City is well able to pay the judgment out of the funds of the public charitable trust. A parity of reasoning would require a realignment whenever a creditor sues a principal and surety on a debt.
The situation here is substantially the same as when a mortgagor sells the mortgaged property to a third person, who agrees to pay the mortgage debt. The mortgagor becomes the surety and the grantee of the mortgaged property becomes the principal debtor. Union p. 6563 Argument for the Bank.
Mutual Life Ins. Co. v. Hanford, 143 U. S. 187; Birke v. Abbott, 103 Ind. 1; Todd n. Oglebay, 158 Ind. 595.
The relationship of principal and surety is similarly involved where, as here, the mortgagor merely leases the property to a third person, who in turn agrees to pay the interest on the mortgage as rent. Central Trust Co. n. Berwind-White Coal Co., 95 F. 391.
When there has been an assumption of the mortgage obligations, either by a vendee or a lessee, and the mortgagee sues to recover the debt, he ordinarily joins as defendants both the original mortgagor and the vendee or lessee who has assumed the mortgage obligations. The mortgagor may be vitally interested in having an adjudication that his vendee or lessee did assume the mortgage and that he, the mortgagor, is merely a surety on the obligation; but that does not require a realignment of the mortgagor with the mortgagee. The mortgagee has a bona fide claim for relief against both defendants and it is wholly immaterial that one of them is liable only as surety.
The plaintiff here has a bona fide claim for unpaid interest against Indianapolis Gas, Citizens Gas, and the City, and they are all properly aligned as defendants, even though some of them may be primarily and others only secondarily liable.
The City has not cited a single case in which the plaintiff had even one substantial controversy with a defendant and such defendant was realigned with the plaintiff for jurisdictional purposes. The fact that plaintiff and such defendant may be in accord as to some of the other issues in the case is wholly immaterial. To be sure, realignment is required where there is no bona fide prayer for relief against a particular defendant, as in City of Dawson v. Columbia Trust Co., 197 U. S. 178, but that is not the situation in the case at bar.
Sutton v. English, 246 U. S. 199, supports federal jurisdiction of this case. See also Republic National Bank &
428670°—42-------5
Argument for the City. 314U.S.
Trust Co. v. Massachusetts Bonding & Ins. Co., 68 F. 2d 445,447; Detroit Tile & Mosaic Co. v. Mason Contractors’ Assn., 48 F. 2d 729, 731; Franz v. Franz, 15 F. 2d 797, 799; Feidler n. Bartleson, 161 F. 30, 35.
In each of those cases there was at least one controversy between the plaintiff and the defendant sought to be realigned, and this single controversy prevented such realignment, despite the fact that plaintiff and such defendant were in accord as to some of the other controversies. The rule of law applied in these cases and in the case at bar on the first appeal—that a defendant against whom plaintiff asks relief and with whom plaintiff has distinct conflicts of interests cannot be realigned with the plaintiff in determining federal jurisdiction—has been universally recognized. The federal courts have continued to apply this rule since the decision of the jurisdictional question in this case in 1938. See Rex Co. v. International Harvester Co., 107 F. 2d 767,768, citing Sutton n. English and the first decision of the Court of Appeals in the case at bar in support.
The City’s contention that the question as to the validity of the lease is the dominant controversy in this case and must govern the question of realignment, without regard to any other controversies, is based on the proposition that plaintiff and Indianapolis Gas are on the same side of that controversy. The fact is that plaintiff asks precisely the same relief against Indianapolis Gas on this issue that it asks against the City and Citizens Gas, namely, that the lease be held binding on each. The fallacy in the City’s argument is its assumption that a defendant can destroy the controversy upon which federal jurisdiction depends by admitting its liability, or even by consenting to have its liability enforced. The law is well settled to the contrary. Re Metropolitan Railway Receivership, 208 U. S. 90.
Mr. William H. Thompson, with whom Messrs. Perry E. O’Neal, Patrick J. Smith, and Edward H. Knight were on p. 6763 Argument for the City.
the brief, for the City of Indianapolis et al., at both hearings.
The suit was brought by Chase as mortgagee, i. e., trustee, under a deed of trust securing an issue of bonds of Indianapolis Gas. Chase sought a decree declaring that the ninety-nine year lease between Indianapolis Gas, lessor, and Citizens Gas, lessee, was binding upon and enforceable against the City.
The Circuit Court of Appeals correctly held that Indianapolis Gas was an indispensable party. Chase National Bank v. Citizens Ggs Co., 96 F. 2d 363.
The controlling controversy is whether the pleaded lease has become enforceable against the City. No other cause of action is alleged against the City except claims for damages which are dependent upon the determination of the validity of the lease.
The City contends that the lease is invalid and unenforceable against it; Chase maintains that the lease is valid and binding against the City; Indianapolis Gas maintains that the lease is valid and binding against the City. Chase and Indianapolis Gas thus have a similar and identical interest against the City on the question of the validity of the lease.
The City has been held bound by the lease and required to pay the obligations of Indianapolis Gas under the mortgage. No matter what the form of the judgment may be, no one can realistically suppose that Indianapolis Gas has been harmed by the entry of this judgment or that it will be required to pay a single penny as a result of it. On the contrary, it will have obtained exactly what it sought from the commencement of this litigation: a decree requiring the City to make the payments under the lease.
The other subsidiary relief asked against Indianapolis Gas by Chase has either not been prosecuted beyond the allegation in the complaint and prayers, is dependent p. 68upon a decision respecting the validity of the lease, or is relief against which Indianapolis Gas is completely insulated.
If the interests of Chase and Indianapolis Gas were not in accord, Indianapolis Gas would not have opposed review by this Court of a judgment against it for more than $1,000,000.
By arranging the parties according to their real interest in the case—viz., the enforceability of the 99 year lease against the City—it is clear that the interests of Indianapolis Gas and of Chase are identical. They should be realigned as parties plaintiff. Diversity of citizenship would thus be destroyed, and the sole ground of jurisdiction of the federal District Court would be lost. Compare City of Dawson v. Columbia Trust Co., 197 U. S. 178,181; Niles-Bement-Pond Co. n. Iron Moulders Union, 254 U. S. 77, 81.
Mr. William G. Sparks, with whom Mr. Paul Y. Davis was on the brief, for the Citizens Gas Co.
Mr. William R. Higgins for the Indianapolis Gas Co., at both hearings. Mr. Louis B. Ewbank was with him on the brief and at the first hearing.
Mr. Justice Frankfurter delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is a suit instituted by the Chase National Bank, a New York corporation, in the federal District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, naming as defendants the Indianapolis Gas Company, the Citizens Gas Company of Indianapolis (Indiana corporations), and the City of Indianapolis. (For brevity’s sake the parties will be referred to as Chase, Indianapolis Gas, Citizens Gas, and the City, respectively.) The power of the District Court to entertain this litigation was sustained by the Circuit
Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit under the provision of the Judicial Code conferring upon the district courts jurisdiction “Of all suits of a civil nature . . . where the matter in controversy exceeds . . . three thousand dollars, and ... is between citizens of different States . . .” 36 Stat. 1091; 28 U. S. C. § 41 (1). The correctness of this jurisdictional ruling must be determined before the merits of Chase’s claims can be considered. The specific question is this: Does an alignment of the parties in relation to their real interests in the “matter in controversy” satisfy the settled requirements of diversity jurisdiction?
As is true of many problems in the law, the answer is to be found not in legal learning but in the realities of the record. Though variously expressed in the decisions, the governing principles are clear. To sustain diversity jurisdiction there must exist an “actual,” Helm v. Zarecor, 222 U. S. 32, 36, “substantial,” Niles-Bement-Pond Co. n. Iron Moulders Union, 254 U. S. 77, 81, controversy between citizens of different states, all of whom on one side of the controversy are citizens of different states from all parties on the other side. Strawbridge v. Curtiss, 3 Cranch 267. Diversity jurisdiction cannot be conferred upon the federal courts by the parties’ own determination of who are plaintiffs and who defendants. It is our duty, as it is that of the lower federal courts, to “look beyond the pleadings and arrange the parties according to their sides in the dispute.” Dawson v. Columbia Trust Co., 197 U. S. 178, 180. Litigation is the pursuit of practical ends, not a game of chess. Whether the necessary “collision of interests,” Dawson v. Columbia Trust Co., supra, at 181, exists, is therefore not to be determined by mechanical rules. It must be ascertained from the “principal purpose of the suit,” East Tennessee, V. & G. R. v. Grayson, 119 U. S. 240, 244, and the “primary and controlling matter in dispute,” Merchants’ Cotton Press Co. n. Insurance Co,, p. 70151 U. S. 368, 385. These familiar doctrines governing the alignment of parties for purposes of determining diversity of citizenship have consistently guided the lower federal courts1 and this Court.12
And so we turn to the actualities of this litigation.
Chase is the trustee under a mortgage deed, to secure a bond issue, executed by Indianapolis Gas in 1902. In 1906 Citizens Gas was formed to compete with Indianapolis Gas in the distribution of light, heat, and power to the people of Indianapolis. Its franchise provided that after the expiration of twenty-five years and the performance of certain specified conditions, the company should be wound up and its property conveyed to the City subject to the company’s “outstanding legal obligations.” The competition between the two gas companies continued until 1913, when Indianapolis Gas leased all of its gas plant property to Citizens Gas for a term of ninety-nine years. Citizens Gas agreed to pay as rental (a) the interest on the lessor’s outstanding bonded indebtedness, and (b) annual sums equal to a six per cent return on Indianapolis Gas’s common stock. For twenty-two years thereafter Citizens Gas operated the mortgaged property and paid the interest on the bonds. In 1935, pursuant to its franchise, Citizens Gas conveyed its entire property, including that covered by its lease from Indianapolis Gas, to the City. But the City refused to regard itself bound by this lease. On March 2,
1E. g., Pittsburgh, C. & St. L. Ry. Co. v. Baltimore & Ohio R. Co., 61 F. 705; Cilley v. Patten, 62 F. 498; Board of Trustees v. Blair, 70 F. 414; Allen-West Commission Co. v. Brashear, 176 F. 119; Lindauer v. Compañía Palomas, 247 F. 428; DeGrafjenreid v. Yount-Lee Oil Co., 30 F. 2d 574.
2 In addition to the cases cited in the text, see Removal Cases, 100 U. S. 457, 468-70; Pacific R. Co. v. Ketchum, 101 U. S. 289, 298-99; Corbin V. Van Brunt, 105 U. S. 576; Evers v. Watson, 156 U. S. 527, 532; Doctor v. Harrington, 196 U. S. 579; Venner v. Great Northern Ry. Co., 209 U. S. 24; Steele v. Culver, 211 U. S. 26, 29; Lee v. Lehigh Valley Coal Co., 267 U. S. 542; Sutton v. English, 246 U. S. 199.
1936, the City and Indianapolis Gas agreed that, pending the settlement of the “presently existing controversy” between them as to whether the lease was valid and binding upon the City, the latter would deposit in escrow sums equal to the interest and dividend payments falling due. The agreement expressly provided that it was made without prejudice to either party’s “position or rights.”
Chase thereupon filed a bill of complaint in the District Court, naming as defendants Indianapolis Gas, Citizens Gas, and the City. It prayed that the lease from Indianapolis Gas to Citizens Gas be declared valid and binding upon the defendants, and as such be deemed part of the security for the performance of the mortgage obligations; that the City be ordered to perform all of the lessee’s obligations in the lease and to pay directly to the plaintiff all of the interest payments as they shall become due; that judgment for overdue interest be entered against the defendants “liable therefor”; and that the plaintiff be awarded costs and attorneys’ fees. The City and Citizens Gas specifically denied that the lease was valid and binding upon them; they alleged, further, that the controversy existed solely between Indianapolis Gas and the City, “citizens” of the same state. In its answer, Indianapolis Gas denied that it had “ever contended or admitted that the said ninety-nine year lease was not and is not a valid and binding obligation” upon the defendants.
Finding “no collision between the interests of the plaintiff and the interests of the Indianapolis Gas Company,” the District Court realigned the latter as a party plaintiff, and finding identity of citizenship between some of the plaintiffs and the remaining defendants, dismissed the suit for want of jurisdiction. The Circuit Court of Appeals reversed, one judge dissenting, 96 F. 2d 363, and certiorari was denied, 305 U. S. 600.
On remand to the District Court, Chase filed a supplemental bill alleging default as to interest payments falling p. 72due and praying judgment against the defendants in the amount of the unpaid coupons. It alleged that “neither The Indianapolis Gas Company nor Citizens Gas Company, nor both of them, have property sufficient to pay the interest in default on the Bonds, other than the property now in the possession and under the control of the City of Indianapolis.” This was admitted by Indianapolis Gas. The District Court held on the merits that the lease was not enforceable against either Citizens Gas or the City; that the former had no power under its franchise to bind the latter to the lease, and that by conveying the leased property to the City, Citizens Gas thereby discharged itself of its lessee obligations. Accordingly, the Court ordered that judgment be entered only against Indianapolis Gas for the amount of the unpaid interest.
Asserting that the District Court erred in not holding the lease valid and enforceable against the defendants, both Chase and Indianapolis Gas appealed. The Circuit Court of Appeals sustained their position and again reversed, 113 F. 2d 217. The court held, further, that Chase was entitled to a judgment for unpaid interest against the parties in the following order of liability: the City, Citizens Gas, and Indianapolis Gas. We granted certiorari, 311 U. S. 636, because of the important jurisdictional issue involved in the litigation.
The facts leave no room for doubt that on the merits only one question permeates this litigation: Is the lease whereby Indianapolis Gas in 1913 conveyed all its gas plant property to Citizens Gas valid and binding upon the City? This is the “primary and controlling matter in dispute.” The rest is window-dressing designed to satisfy the requirements of diversity jurisdiction. Everything else in the case is incidental to this dominating controversy, with respect to which Indianapolis Gas and the City,
“citizens” of the same state, are on opposite sides.3 That the case presents “only one fundamental issue” and that that is the obligation of the City under the lease, Chase admits and indeed insists upon in its brief on the merits. Chase and Indianapolis Gas have always been united on this issue: both have always contended for the validity of the lease and the City’s obligation under it. The opinion of the District Court lays bare the heart of this controversy:
“There can be no doubt that both plaintiff and the defendant, The Indianapolis Gas Company, have at all times asserted that the lease in question is valid and is binding upon the City, as Trustee. Neither is there any doubt as to their interest in sustaining the validity of such lease at the time of the institution of this action, prior hereto, and at all times subsequent thereto, and that many conferences have been held by and between them, through their attorneys, and many letters have passed between them relat-
3 It is contended that, notwithstanding their indissoluble bond on the controlling issue, there are “sufficient matters in controversy” between Chase and Indianapolis Gas to preclude their alignment on the same side. Chase, of course, did not bring this suit in order to obtain a declaration that, regardless of the validity of the lease, Indianapolis Gas is still ultimately responsible for the interest payments on its bonded indebtedness. That was not really in issue, and by its answer, Indianapolis Gas took it out of the case. The further argument is made that, by entering into the escrow agreement with the City, Indianapolis Gas has asserted a claim to the interest payments adverse to that of Chase and the bondholders. But the facts are against this contention. The agreement deals merely with the disposition of the interest falling due during the pendency of the litigation. Moreover, the lease between Indianapolis Gas and Citizens Gas contains no provisions requiring payment of the interest direct to Chase or the bondholders. Nor can diversity jurisdiction be rested upon so flimsy a basis as Chase’s prayer for reimbursement of costs and attorneys’ fees. The tail flies with the kite.
ing to this subject. . . . Later, when the parties [i. e., Indianapolis Gas and the City] were unable to adjust their differences and arrive at an agreement, it was decided by The Indianapolis Gas Company and the plaintiff that a suit should be instituted. The common stockholders of that company, of course, had a vital interest in the question of the validity of the lease because, if the lease is valid, they are assured of a six per cent return upon their stock for many years. If, however, a foreclosure suit should have been begun, or if the lease is invalid, no such return is assured. It was natural, therefore, that the Gas Company should take an active interest in the litigation and attempt to guide it along the course that would be most advantageous to it and to its stockholders.”
Plainly, therefore, Chase and Indianapolis Gas are, colloquially speaking, partners in litigation. The property covered by the lease is now in the City’s possession; Chase is simply acting to protect the bondholders’ security. As to Indianapolis Gas, if the lease is upheld, it will continue to receive a six per cent return on its capital, and the burden of paying the interest on its bonded indebtedness will be not upon it but upon the City. What Chase wants, Indianapolis Gas wants, and the City does not want. Yet, the City and Indianapolis Gas were made to have a common interest against Chase when, as a matter of fact, the interests of the City and of Indianapolis Gas are opposed to one another. Therefore, if regard be had to the requirements of jurisdictional integrity, Indianapolis Gas and Chase are on the same side of the controversy not only for their own purposes but also for purposes of diversity jurisdiction. But such realignment places Indiana “citizens” on both sides of the litigation and precludes assumption of jurisdiction based upon diversity of citizenship. We are thus compelled to the conclusion that the
District Court was without jurisdiction.4 And, of course, this Court, by its denial of certiorari when the case was here the first time, could not confer the jurisdiction which Congress has denied.
4 Compare Dawson v. Columbia Trust Co., 197 U. S. 178, a suit by a Pennsylvania mortgagee of a Georgia waterworks company to restrain a Georgia city from building a new waterworks and to compel specific performance of the city’s contract with the waterworks company. The latter was joined as a defendant, on the theory that it was a party to the contract sought to be enforced. The Court held that the bill should be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction: . . the court will look beyond the pleadings and arrange the parties according to their sides in the dispute. When that is done it is obvious that the Water Works Company is on the plaintiff’s side.” 197 U. S. at 180. Ayres v. Wiswall, 112 U. S. 187, and Coney v. Winchell, 116 U. S. 227, are not applicable here. They hold merely that in a foreclosure suit the mortgagee may join the mortgagor and his assignee as defendants; they did not involve any controversy between the mortgagor and the “assignee” as to whether the assignment is binding upon the latter.
Sutton v. English, 246 U. S. 199, clearly holds that the parties must be aligned according to their “attitude towards the actual and substantial controversy.” 246 U. S. at 204. The plaintiffs, who included all of the heirs of Mary Jane except Cora, sought to establish their right to certain property claimed to have belonged to Mary Jane. The claimants could not recover unless they proved that a residuary bequest to Cora was invalid—and, with respect to this issue, their position was completely adverse to Cora’s. “But, as already pointed out, even could complainants succeed in showing that Mary Jane Hubbard at the time of her death was entitled to the community property, her will giving all the residue of her property to Cora D. Spencer still stands in the way of their succeeding to it as heirs-at-law, and hence their prayer to have that will annulled with respect to the residuary clause is essential to their right to any relief in the suit.” 246 U. S. at
207. If the plaintiffs prevailed on this issue of the validity of the residuary gift to Cora, their interests and hers would then be the same with respect to the remaining issues in the case. But the Court held that in relation to the “actual and substantial controversy,” Cora and the plaintiffs were on opposite sides, thereby sustaining diversity jurisdiction. In Sutton v. English, alignment of the parties with respect
This is not a sacrifice of justice to technicality. For the question here is not whether Chase and Indianapolis Gas may pursue what they conceive to be just claims against the City, but whether they may pursue them in the federal courts in Indiana, rather than in its state courts. The fact that Chase prefers the adjudication of its claims by the federal court is certainly no reason why we should deny the plain facts of the controversy and yield to illusive artifices. Settled restrictions against bringing local disputes into the federal courts cannot thus be circumvented.
These requirements, however technical seeming, must be viewed in the perspective of the constitutional limitations upon the judicial power of the federal courts,5 and of the Judiciary Acts in defining the authority of the federal courts when they sit, in effect, as state courts. See Madisonville Traction Co. v. Mining Co., 196 U. S. 239, 255, and Ex parte Scholleriberger, 96 U. S. 369, 377. The dominant note in the successive enactments of Congress relating to diversity jurisdiction, is one of jealous restriction, of avoiding offense to state sensitiveness, and of relieving the federal courts of the overwhelming burden of “business that intrinsically belongs to the state courts,” in order to keep them free for their distinctive federal business. See Friendly, The Historic Basis of Diversity Jurisdiction, 41 Harv. L. Rev. 483,510; Shamrock Oil Corp. v. Sheets, 313 U. S. 100,108-09; Healy v. Ratta, 292 U. S. 263,270. “The policy of the statute [conferring diversity jurisdiction upon the district courts] calls for its strict construction. The power reserved to the states, under the
to their real interests sustained diversity; such alignment here precludes jurisdiction. That case and this are applications of the same principle.
63 Jackson, J., dissenting.
Constitution, to provide for the determination of controversies in their courts may be restricted only by the action of Congress in conformity to the judiciary sections of the Constitution. . . . Due regard for the rightful independence of state governments, which should actuate federal courts, requires that they scrupulously confine their own jurisdiction to the precise limits which the statute has defined.” Healy v. Ratta, supra, at 270. In defining the boundaries of diversity jurisdiction, this Court must be mindful of this guiding Congressional policy. See Hepbum & Dundas v. Ellzey, 2 Cranch 445; New Orleans v. Winter, 1 Wheat. 91; Morris v. Gilmer, 129 U. S. 315, 328-29; Coal Company v. Blatchford, 11 Wall. 172; Shamrock Oil Corp. v. Sheets, 313 U. S. 100; and compare Old Grant v. M’Kee, 1 Pet. 248; Elgin v. Marshall, 106 U. S. 578; Healy v. Ratta, 292 U. S. 263; McNutt v. General Motors Acceptance Corp., 298 U. S. 178.
Reversed.
Mr. Justice Jackson:
The Chief Justice, Mr. Justice Roberts, Mr. Justice Reed and I are unable to concur in this disposition of these writs, in view of what we consider to be the controlling facts of this controversy.
Chase is trustee under a mortgage executed in 1902 by Indianapolis Gas to secure a bond issue. The mortgage covered a public utility gas plant and distribution system, together with after-acquired property, including intangibles.
In 1913, Indianapolis Gas turned the mortgaged utility system over to Citizens Gas, a competitor, under a lease for a term of ninety-nine years. Citizens Gas undertook, among other things, to pay the interest “as the same shall from time to time fall due” on the bonds secured by the mortgage, and also to pay certain sums, subject to some variation by reference to the price received for gas, to the stockholders of Indianapolis Gas. Citizens Gas unified
Jackson, J., dissenting. 314U.S.
this leased plant with its own, and in 1935 conveyed to the City the entire property in conformity to statute which it is contended obligates the City to assume the obligations of the lease. The City took possession of the property but refused to accept the obligations of the lease. The City and Indianapolis Gas then agreed that, pending settlement of the controversy thus precipitated, sums payable under the lease as interest should be deposited in escrow, instead of being paid to Chase. Accordingly, there was default in the payment to the trustee of interest on the bonds.
For jurisdictional purposes, Indianapolis Gas, the mortgage debtor, and the City, whose possession of the property under the circumstances was alleged to result in an assumption of the debt, as well as Citizens Gas, the intermediate owner (which seems of no consequence to the issues under discussion), were all citizens of the State of Indiana, while Chase, the trustee, was a citizen of New York. Under these circumstances, Chase began an action in the federal District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, joining Indianapolis Gas, Citizens Gas, and the City as defendants. It asked that the interest of Indianapolis Gas in the lease be adjudged a part of its security for the performance of the mortgage obligations; that the lease be declared valid and binding upon all the defendants; that the City be ordered to pay directly to the trustee all of the interest payments as they fell due; that judgment for overdue interest be entered against the defendants liable therefor, including Indianapolis Gas; and that plaintiff be awarded costs and attorneys’ fees.
This Court now destroys federal jurisdiction of the case by a transposition of parties, the radical nature of which appears most clearly from the judgments rendered below. It forces into the position of co-plaintiff one party which the District Court adjudged entitled to recover over a million dollars, and another which the District Court ad- p. 7963 Jackson, J., dissenting.
judged solely liable to pay that sum. This same adversity was found by the Circuit Court of Appeals, which held the one entitled to receive, and the other obligated to pay, this sum with increase due to the lapse of time. It modified the judgment only by including two additional judgment debtors on whom it fixed primary and secondary liability, but continued the judgment against Indianapolis Gas with a tertiary liability for its satisfaction. The subtlety by which a judgment debtor is transfigured into a creditor for jurisdictional purposes deserves analysis, if for no other reason than because of its novelty.
The Court cannot resort to a decision of the merits of the case, over which it holds itself to be without jurisdiction, in order to justify its characterization of some of the trustee’s claims as “window dressing” and “artifice.” The measure of jurisdiction should be taken from the pleadings, unless the claims are frivolous on their face. That is not the case here. In ultimate effect, Chase alleged a cause of action and sought judgment against the City upon its personal undertaking to assume and pay the indebtedness upon the mortgage given by Indianapolis Gas to the plaintiff. It also alleged a cause of action and sought judgment against Indianapolis Gas for the amount of the coupon interest. Both demands were in excess of $3,000. If the plaintiff had asserted these demands in two separate actions, no one would doubt that both were within the jurisdiction of the District Court. In each, there is an adequate diversity of citizenship, and each involves the requisite jurisdictional amount, and each is “actual” and “substantial” enough to support the jurisdiction, if this means anything more than that a demand exceeding $3,000 must be involved. A United States District Court is not without jurisdiction to render a judgment exceeding $3,000 on confession if there is the requisite diversity of citizenship. Re Metropolitan Railway Receivership, 208 U. S. 90 at 108. The trustee’s right to judgment against the mort-
Jackson, J., dissenting. 314U.S.
gagor, even though uncontested, is a matter of substance, for the judgment is the important—indeed indispensable—means of pursuing the mortgaged property into the hands of the City, in the event that it should turn out in the suit against the City that it had not become personally liable for any part of the mortgage debt.
Jurisdiction of the federal courts is indeed a variable and illusory thing, if the jurisdiction which a District Court admittedly has of two separate causes of action is lost when they are united in one, agreeably to the federal rules of procedure, because the one defendant as a surety seeks to enforce its equitable right to be exonerated by the other, who is alleged to be the principal debtor.
The doctrine of realignment permits and requires a nominal defendant to be treated as a plaintiff for the purpose of defining the real controversy, where no real cause of action is asserted against him by the plaintiff; but it does not admit of such treatment of a defendant against whom the plaintiff asserts a cause of action within the jurisdiction of the court. The plaintiff cannot rightly be deprived of the benefit of that jurisdiction, conferred upon him by laws enacted pursuant to the Constitution of the United States, because the court may think that such a cause of action is relatively less important than that asserted against another defendant, or because one action “dominates” the other, or because one is more “actual” or “substantial” than the other. The statute itself sets up the criterion of substantiality by fixing the jurisdictional amount at $3,000. Moreover, in this case, whether either of the rights asserted is more substantial than the other depends on the outcome of the litigation, which can hardly be used to determine jurisdiction which must exist at the beginning of the litigation.
If we examine this controversy in detail, it appears that the conflicts between the trustee and its mortgagor were p. 8163 Jackson, J., dissenting.
not feigned or merely formal. While the mortgage and the debt, which created the opposition inherent in the relation of mortgagor and mortgagee or between debtor and creditor, were undenied, Chase was asking that its lien be judicially construed to cover not merely the physical property described therein but also the entire interest of Indianapolis Gas in the lease, which required payments to stockholders over and above the interest payments for the bondholders. Furthermore, Chase asked the Court to set aside the escrow agreement by which Indianapolis and the City had assumed to exclude Chase from dominion over the escrow funds. Chase demanded that Indianapolis Gas be denied future control over such funds and that they be paid directly to itself. These were conflicts as to the extent of its interest in, and control over, any cause of action against the City. TJiey existed between Chase and the defendant Indianapolis Gas, and concerned them alone.
There was also an issue as to the aggregate amount of the trustee’s claim, which all defendants had a common interest in minimizing. The trustee claimed to be entitled to interest at 6%, after default, on coupons which bore a 5% interest rate, and it also claimed interest on overdue interest. This Court has held that where the only issue concerns the amount of the debt, as to which a mortgagor agrees with the plaintiff, but the issue is contested only by another mortgagor who has assumed the entire mortgage debt, the mortgage and the debt are the real subject matter of the controversy; that the decree when the amount is ascertained must run against all debtors; and that the uncontesting mortgagor is a necessary party on the side opposite the mortgagee. Ayres v. Wiswdll, 112 U. S. 187.
There were other issues on which the defendants were in sharp conflict between themselves. Indianapolis Gas
428670°—42-------6
Jackson, J., dissenting. 314U.S.
and Chase both served their respective interests by contending against the City that its acts had the legal effect of binding it to the terms of the lease. But their common attitude in relation to this issue sprang from different legal origins. The rights of Chase had their source and their measure in the mortgage. The mortgage might or might not, depending upon the outcome of the litigation, be construed to give Chase a right to enforce for its own benefit the lease terms as against the City. Indianapolis Gas, on the other hand, derived no rights against the City from that instrument and was not, like Chase, limited by it. Indianapolis Gas’s rights had no other measure than that found in the terms of the lease itself.
We would be diligent, no less than the majority, to prevent imposition on the jurisdiction of the federal courts by means of “window dressing” or “artifice.” We find in this case nothing that warrants either characterization, and we think that the precedents invoked to support today’s action reveal the gap which divides the doctrine of realignment, as heretofore applied by this Court, from the application made of it today.
The majority opinion leans heavily on Dawson n. Columbia Trust Co., 197 U. S. 178. Mr. Justice Holmes in that case said: “. . . it is obvious that the Water Works Company is on the plaintiff’s side and was made a defendant solely for the purpose of reopening in the United States Court a controversy which had been decided against it in the courts of the State.” And he said again: “. . . when the arrangement of the parties is merely a contrivance between friends for the purpose of founding a jurisdiction which otherwise would not exist, the device cannot be allowed to succeed.” And so say we. But there is not the slightest indication of this kind of connivance in the case before us.
In Helm v. Zarecor, 222 U. S. 32, this Court refused to align with the plaintiffs a corporation although its board p. 8363 Jackson, J., dissenting.
and officers were in entire agreement with the position of complainants on the merits of the case. Another of the cases invoked is Niles-Bement Co. v. Iron Moulders Union, 254 U. S. 77. Here a New Jersey corporation sought to break a strike by filing a bill in an Ohio District Court against labor unions, individual strikers, and an Ohio corporation, all citizens of Ohio. The New Jersey plaintiff owned a controlling interest in the Ohio defendant, the two had common officers and directors, and no relief whatever was asked against the Ohio company, which the bill alleged was being delayed in delivery of goods because of the strike. The Court refused to allow such an imposition on its jurisdiction. In Sutton v. English, 246 U. S. 199, this Court held it to be error to align one of the defendants with the plaintiff for jurisdictional purposes where her interest was adverse to plaintiff on one out of four issues, although with plaintiff as to three of the four.
We take the statement in the opinion of the Court, that its basis is “not in legal learning but in the realities of the record,” to be another way of saying that it disagrees with the lower court’s view of the facts rather than with its view of the law. Review of facts is not the conventional function of this Court, and resort to it at this stage of this litigation is somewhat less than fair to the courts below as well as to the litigants.
Three years ago this Court refused to review the decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals that this controversy was within the federal jurisdiction. Indianapolis n. Chase National Bank, 305 U. S. 600. Of course, a denial of certiorari is not to be taken as a ruling on the merits of any question presented. However, where the case is again brought here after some years of litigation, jurisdiction ought not to be overturned on light or inconsequential grounds, or on disagreements with the court below on matters of fact. To do so here is likely to result in further and, as we see it, needless delay in settling the status of
Syllabus. 314 U.S.
an important utility and the obligations and rights of a populous municipality. We think it the duty of the Court to end this controversy by proceeding to judgment on the merits, and that nothing in this record justifies ousting these parties from the federal courts. If, as the opinion intimates, the forefathers are thought to have been unwise in creating a federal jurisdiction based on diversity of citizenship, we should think the remedy of those so minded would be found in Congressional withdrawal of such jurisdiction, rather than in the confusing process of judicial constriction.
We would follow the words of the jurisdictional statute when it is sought to restrict its application, quite as faithfully as when the effort is to enlarge it by recourse to doctrines which conflict with its words. Compare Healy v. Ratta, 292 U. S. 263, 270.