Boise Artesian Hot & Cold Water Co. v. Boise City, 213 U.S. 276 (1909)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
Boise Artesian Hot & Cold Water Co. v. Boise City, 213 U.S. 276 (1909)
Full caption
BOISE ARTESIAN HOT AND COLD WATER COMPANY v. BOISE CITY.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Apr. 5, 1909
BOISE ARTESIAN HOT AND COLD WATER COMPANY v. BOISE CITY.
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE DISTRICT OF IDAHO.
No. 131. Argued March 17, 1909.—Decided April 5, 1909.
Equity will not interpose where there is a remedy at law which is as complete, practicable and adequate as equity could afford.
As the defense of the unconstitutionality and illegality of a tax is open in a court of law, injunction should not issue against the enforcement of the tax merely because it is unconstitutional or illegal unless other circumstances bring the case within some clear ground of equity jurisdiction.
Even though some States may for convenience of remedy permit equity to enjoin the collection of a tax for mere illegality, courts of a different and paramount sovereignty should not do so, and Federal courts should not interfere by injunction with the fiscal arrangements of a State if the rights involved can be preserved in any other manner.
A municipality speaks through its council, and where the bill does not allege any facts showing threats to remove property of a complainant public service corporation such action will not be presumed so as to give equity jurisdiction.
A suit at law by a municipality to collect a license fee imposed by ordinance on a public service corporation contemplates continuance, and not restraint, of the business of such corporation, and, as the defense of unconstitutionality of the ordinance is open in that suit, equity should not interfere.
In order to make the fear of multiplicity of suits a ground for the interposition of a court of equity, more than one suit must have been commenced, and the court should not interfere unless it is clearly necessary to protect complainant from continued and vexatious litigation. Equity should not enjoin the collection of a tax on the ground of cloud on title when the tax can only be collected by a suit at law in which the defense of its illegality is open, and it does not appear that the tax is a lien on any of complainant’s property.
The facts are stated in the opinion.
213 U. S. Argument for Appellants.
Mr. Richard H. Johnson, with whom Mr. Edgar Wilson and Mr. Richard Z. Johnson were on the brief, for appellants:
An injunction should have been issued by the court below restraining the city from enforcing the ordinances, and from interfering with plaintiff’s use, according to its franchises, of the streets and alleys. The bill made out a proper case for the interposition of a court of equity. It shows that the city maintains and insists that the water company’s right to use the streets is a license only, which is subject to annulment and revocation at the will of the city, and that the city authorities have the right to compel the water company to discontinue the use of the streets and alleys, or to levy burdens and assessments for such use, at their pleasure, and that the city threatens and intends to impose further burdens and assessments on the water company for such use and to interfere with its use of the streets and alleys and has threatened to remove its pipes therefrom and its water works from the city.
The bill also alleged as additional grounds the unconstitutionality of the ordinance; the monthly presentation of bills, threats of suit, and the presentation of another bill after the suit had been commenced, showing danger of multiplicity of suits. It was also averred that the ordinances cast clouds upon the water company’s franchises and depreciate the value of its property, impair its credit, embarrass its business and reduce its net revenue to an unfair and unjust extent which will amount to confiscation of its property; and, moreover, that the enforcement of those ordinances will destroy the water company’s franchises and contract rights in violation of Art. I, § 10 of the Federal Constitution, and will deprive it of its property without due process of law, and deny it the equal protection of the laws.
As the ordinances which the city is seeking to enforce are in violation of the water company’s contract rights and are otherwise unconstitutional, an injunction against their enforcement is the proper remedy. Vicksburg Waterworks Co. v. Vicksburg, 185 U. S. 65, 82; Vicksburg v. Waterworks Co., 202 U. S. 453;
Argument for Appellee. 213 U. S.
Mr. William E. Borah and Mr. Charles M. Kahn, with whom Mr. Charles P. McCarthy, Mr. Charles C. Cavanah and Mr. John J. Blake were on the brief, for appellee:
The facts stated in the bill of complaint are insufficient to entitle plaintiff to any relief in, or to give jurisdiction to a court of equity.
Under the allegations of the bill the plaintiff has an adequate remedy at law.
The bill shows that plaintiff’s sole object is to secure a decree of the court declaring the ordinances to be franchises for a period of fifty years; that the ordinance requiring the plaintiff to pay a license fee be declared void, for a recovery of $2,000.00, with interest, for the use of water from its system, and declaring the rates established by the water commission, relating to said use be valid.
An action at law is, at this time, pending in the state court of Idaho, by the city against the company for the recovery of $1,730.00, alleged to be due as such license fee. In that action at law, the plaintiff can present to the court all questions as to the validity of the ordinances and whether it has a franchise to use the streets for fifty years. The plaintiff could, in said action at law, either set up its claim for $2,000.00 as a counter claim in the event the court held the license fee valid, or institute an independent action in a court of law for the recovery of said amount, as the city, under the allegations of the bill, seems to be solvent.
Where the relief prayed for is such as a court of law is competent to grant, a court of equity has no jurisdiction.
Suits in equity shall not be sustained in either of the courts of the United States, in any case where a plain, adequate and complete remedy may be had at law. 1 Stat. 82; Rev. Stat. § 723. And see Hipp v. Babin, 19 How. 271; Fussell v. Gregg,
It appears from the bill in this case that the plaintiff is seeking to restrain the defendant from proceeding with an action at law in the Idaho state court, brought to recover a certain sum alleged to be due as a license fee under the ordinance of June 7,1906. In such a case a Circuit Court of the United States will not interfere to enjoin a pending suit at law. Hapgood v. Hewitt, 119 U. S. 234; Buzard et al. v. Houston, 119 U. S. 351. See also 1 High on Injunctions (3d Ed.), §§89-93.
Mr. Justice Moody delivered the opinion of the court.
The appellant, a West Virginia corporation, brought in the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Idaho, this bill in equity against Boise City, a municipal corporation. There was a demurrer to the bill, which, upon consideration of the merits of the case set forth therein, was sustained by the judge of the Circuit Court and the bill dismissed. The company appealed directly to this court. The facts set forth in the bill and exhibits, and the relief and grounds of relief claimed, so far as necessary to develop the point decided, may conveniently be stated in narrative form.
The company was incorporated for and is engaged in supplying the city and its inhabitants with water for municipal and domestic purposes. It had acquired the property, franchises, rights and privileges of certain individuals and corporations, who had been, from time to time, granted by ordinance of the city the privilege of laying and maintaining pipes in the streets and supplying through them water for municipal and domestic uses. The company conducted its business by virtue of these ordinances, and has invested large sums of money. The ordinances need not be set forth in detail, and it is enough to say that the company contends that they are franchises for a term of not less than fifty years, and constitute a contract [p. 280] inconsistent with the license fee or tax hereafter referred to, while the city contends that they are mere permissions, revocable at any time. The rates are fixed by commissioners, acting under the authority of a law of the State, and are to remain in force three years from the date of their establishment. After the fixing of the rates and before the expiration of the three years, on the thirty-first day of May, 1906, the city enacted an ordinance requiring that the company “hereafter pay to said Boise City, on the first day of each and every month, a monthly license of $300, for the privilege granted ... to lay and repair water pipes in the streets and alleys of said city.” The ordinance then made a demand for the monthly payment of said license, and directed the city clerk to notify the company of the requirements of the ordinance.
The main object of the bill is to obtain an injunction against the enforcement of this ordinance, upon the grounds: (1) that other corporations, associations and individuals using the streets and alleys of the city for various purposes are not required to pay a license, and therefore there was, by the ordinance, a denial of the equal protection of the laws; (2) that the city, in pursuance of its claim that the ordinances grant only a revocable permission to occupy the streets, threatens and intends to impose further burdens and assessments, and threatens to remove the pipes and the works from the city; (3) that the city has presented monthly bills and has brought an action at law in the state court to recover the amount alleged to be due on account of the license fee imposed, and that there is therefore danger of a multiplicity of suits; (4) that the ordinance has cast a cloud upon the company’s franchises and right to supply water to the city and its inhabitants, and thereby depreciated the value of the company’s property, impaired its credit, embarrassed its business and confiscated its property; (5) that the ordinance impairs the obligation of the contract made by the ordinances granting the rights, privileges and franchises; (6) that the enforcement of the ordinance would deprive the company of its property without due process of law and abridge its privileges [p. 281] and immunities granted by the Fourteenth Amendment; (7) and that the ordinance violates the constitution and laws of the State.
A subordinate object of the bill is to recover from the city certain amounts due on account of water supplied to fire hydrants, which the city declines to pay, disputing its liability so to do.
The decree of the court below, dismissing the bill, proceeded upon a consideration of the merits of the controversy between the parties. We do not enter upon that subject, because there is a deeper question which seems to us decisive of the case. That question is whether the plaintiff is entitled, on the allegations of its bill, to relief in equity in the Federal courts.
It is obvious that the rights of which the company seeks to avail itself are rights cognizable in a court of law, and not rights created only by the principles of equity. The sum of the company’s contentions is that the imposition of the license fee was illegal, unconstitutional and void. All these contentions are open in a court of law. It is a guiding rule in equity that in such a case it will not interpose where there is a plain, adequate and complete remedy at law. This rule at an early date was crystallized into statute form by the sixteenth section of the Judiciary Act (Revised Statutes, § 723), which, if it has no other effect, emphasizes the rule and presses it upon the attention of courts. New York &c. Co. v. Memphis Water Co., 107 U. S. 205, 214. It is so well settled and has so often been acted upon that no authority need be cited in its support, though it must not be forgotten that the legal remedy must be as complete, practicable and efficient as that which equity could afford. Walla Walla v. Walla Walla Water Co., 172 U. S. 1,11.
A notable application of the rule in the courts of the United States has been to cases where a demand has been made to enjoin the collection of taxes or other impositions made by state authority, upon the ground that they are illegal or unconstitutional. The decisions of the state courts in cases of this kind are in conflict, and we need not examine them. It is a mere matter of choice of convenient remedy for a State to permit [p. 282] its courts to enjoin the collection of a state tax, because it is illegal or unconstitutional. Very different considerations arise where courts of a different, though paramount, sovereignty interpose in the same manner and for the same reasons. An examination of the decisions of this court shows that a proper reluctance to interfere by prevention with the fiscal operations of the state governments has caused it to refrain from so doing in all cases where the Federal rights of the persons could otherwise be preserved unimpaired. It has been held uniformly that the illegality or unconstitutionality of a state or municipal tax or imposition is not of itself a ground for equitable relief in the courts of the United States. In such a case the aggrieved party is left to his remedy at law, when that remedy is as complete, practicable and efficient as the remedy in equity. And the rule applies as well where the right asserted is by way of defense. Insurance Co. v. Bailey, 13 Wall. 616, 623.
In order to give equity jurisdiction there must be shown, in addition to the illegality or unconstitutionality of the tax or imposition, other circumstances bringing the case under some recognized head of equity jurisdiction, before the remedy by injunction can be awarded. The leading case on the subject is Dows v. Chicago, 11 Wall. 108. In that case the plaintiff sought to enjoin the collection of a tax levied upon shares of the capital stock of a national bank on the ground that the levy was unconstitutional under the state law, and that the property was not within the jurisdiction of the State. This court declined to pass upon the validity of the tax, saying, through Mr. Justice Field (p. 109):
“The illegality of the tax and the threatened sale of shares for its payment constitute of themselves alone no ground for such interposition. There must be some special circumstances attending a threatened injury of this kind, distinguishing it from a common trespass, and bringing the case under some recognized head of equity jurisdiction before the preventive remedy of injunction can be invoked. It is upon taxation that the several States chiefly rely to obtain the means to carry on [p. 283] their respective governments, and it is of the utmost importance to all of them that the modes adopted to enforce the taxes levied should be interfered with as little as possible.
“No Court of equity will, therefore, allow its injunction to issue to restrain their action, except where it may be necessary to protect the rights of the citizen whose property is taxed, and he has no adequate remedy by the ordinary processes of the law. It must appear that the enforcement of the tax would lead to a multiplicity of suits, or produce irreparable injury, or, where the property is real estate, throw a cloud upon the title of the complainant, before the aid of a Court of equity can be invoked.”
In the case last cited, Mr Chief Justice Fuller made the following important observation (p. 274):
It is quite possible that in cases of this sort the validity of a law may be more conveniently tested, by the party denying it, by a bill in equity than by an action at law; but considerations of that character, while they may explain, do not justify, resort to that mode of proceeding.”
In Shelton v. Platt, 139 U.S. 591, a bill was filed in the Circuit Court of the United States to restrain the collection of a license tax imposed by the State of Tennessee on the United States Express Company, upon the ground that it was unconstitutional. The bill alleged that the property of the company was employed in interstate commerce and was necessary to the conduct of it, and that if it were seized by the sheriff it would greatly embarrass the company in the conduct of its interstate business, subject it to heavy damage and the public to great [p. 284] loss and inconvenience, and that the company was without adequate remedy at law. A plea alleged that the only remedy under the laws of the State was to pay the taxes under protest and bring suit to recover them back. The plaintiff had an injunction from the lower court. This court reversed the decree upon appeal, upon the ground that the remedy in equity would not lie merely because the tax was unconstitutional, unless there were allegations in the bill otherwise bringing the case within some acknowledged head of equity jurisdiction, and that the allegations of the bill were not sufficient to do this. This case was followed in Allen v. Pullman’s Palace Car Co., 139 U. S. 658, and in Pacific Express Co. v. Seibert, 142 U. S. 339, where a tax was alleged to be unconstitutional because imposed upon interstate commerce, because it denied to the taxpayer the equal protection of the laws, and because it was void for repugnancy to the constitution of the State.
A brief reference to some cases cited by the company, in which this court has asserted the authority of equity to interfere, will define the rule quite as well as the cases in which the court has declined to exercise the power of injunction. In Walla Walla v. Walla Walla Water Co., supra, the city was about to construct, in violation of its contract, a competing water plant, and the resulting damage to the company would have been irreparable. The same conditions existed in Vicksburg Waterworks Co. v. Vicksburg, 185 U. S. 65. See same case, 202 U. S.
453. In Detroit v. Detroit Citizens’ St. Ry. Co., 184 U. S. 368, a schedule of rates for transportation of passengers was fixed in violation of the contract rights of the company, and possible suits would be limited only by the number of passengers. The same condition existed in Cleveland v. Cleveland City Ry. Co., 194 U. S. 517; and see Ex parte Young, 209 U. S. 123, where the grounds of the jurisdiction in equity in rate cases are fully set forth and discussed. In Ogden City v. Armstrong, 168 U.S. 224, not only was there danger of a multiplicity of suits, but the tax there in question was a lien upon realty and a cloud on the title.
It is safe to say that no case can be found where this court has deliberately approved the issuance of an injunction against the enforcement of an ordinance resting on state authority, merely because it was illegal or unconstitutional, unless further circumstances were shown which brought the case within some clear ground of equity jurisdiction.
These decisions make it clear that an injunction ought not to be granted unless the bill, besides alleging illegality and unconstitutionality of the ordinance imposing the license fee, sets forth other circumstances which bring the case within some acknowledged head of equity jurisdiction. The only suggestions of this kind which the bill presents are that the enforcement of the ordinance will lead to irreparable injury, to multiplicity of suits, and cast a cloud upon the company’s title to its franchises.
But there is nothing in the bill which leads us to suppose that any of these results would be brought about by leaving the company to its defense at law. If the city had taken any steps indicating a purpose to remove the pipes and works of the company from the streets of the city and to deny it the right to continue its business, there would be clear reason for the interposition of a court of equity, for if that were done illegally or unconstitutionally an injury would be inflicted for which the law could afford no adequate remedy. In such a case it would be the plain duty of a court of equity to arrest the destructive steps until their legality or constitutionality could be determined. Such a course would be for the best interests of both parties.
It is true that the bill contains a vague allegation that the city has threatened to remove the company’s pipes and works from the city, but no facts whatever are alleged showing such a threat. The city does not speak except by its council, and nothing has been said or done by it in this direction. On the contrary, the imposition of the license fee and the bringing of a suit for its recovery contemplate continuance and not restraint of the business of the company.
Nor do we think that there is any danger of a multiplicity
Opinion of the Court. 213 U. S.
of suits in the sense that would authorize the issuance of an injunction. One suit only has been brought, and that by direction of the city council. It remains pending, and when it reaches judgment it will determine finally every question in dispute between the parties. There is no need of any other suit except to prevent the running of the statute of limitations and nothing to indicate that any will be brought. Where the multiplicity of suits to be feared consists in repetitions of suits by the same person against the plaintiff for causes of action arising out of the same facts and legal principles, a court of equity ought not to interfere upon that ground unless it is clearly necessary to protect the plaintiff from continued and vexatious litigation. Something more is required than the beginning of a single action with an honest purpose to settle the rights of the parties. 1 Pomeroy’s Eq. Juris., 3d ed., § 254. Perhaps it might be necessary to await the final decision of one action at law (see for analogies Sharon v. Tucker, 144 U. S. 533; Boston &c. Mining Co. v. Montana Ore Co., 188 U. S. 632), but that we need not decide.
Nor do we think that the ordinance casts a cloud upon the title of the company to its franchises. It is not a lien upon them or upon any other property of the company. The city’s only remedy is that which it has employed—an action at law for the collection of the license fee. The plaintiff’s real point here is, not that the ordinance imposing a license fee casts a cloud upon its title, but that the reason alleged to have induced the ordinance, namely, the city’s claim that the company has no more than a mere permission to occupy the streets, unfavorably affects its property and impairs its credit. But we cannot restrain a belief or an expression of it and are not asked to. We are asked only to restrain an ordinance which in no way fixes a lien or cloud upon the plaintiff’s title. It is possible that the ordinance imposing the license fee could be sustained, without passing upon the nature of the company’s tenure of its privileges. On the other hand, it might be condemned without regard to that consideration.
Here is a case where every possible defense to the collection of the license fee, which has been suggested by the company, is available to it in the action at law pending in the courts of the State of Idaho, and there is no reason whatever shown why the law should not take its course. Presumably, the company, on the ground of diversity of citizenship, might have removed the case from the state court to the Circuit Court of the United States, if the attempt had been seasonably made. If, however, the litigation continues up to the court of final resort of the State of Idaho, and all claims under the Constitution of the United States are seasonably and properly made in the state courts and are denied, then the company would be entitled to a review by this court of the judgment of the state court.
The attempt to recover the hydrant rentals is so clearly a matter for a court of law that nothing need be said of it.
The Circuit Court dismissed the bill for entirely different reasons than those which have influenced us. We neither approve nor disapprove those reasons nor intimate any opinion whatever upon the questions passed on by the Circuit Court. It would be superfluous formalism to reverse the decree of the court below and remand the case to that court, with instructions to dismiss the bill for the reasons given in this opinion, for that court has already dismissed the bill. Therefore, the decree of the court below is
Affirmed.
MACFADDEN v. UNITED STATES.
APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT.
No. 14 Original. Submitted April 5, 1909.—Decided April 12, 1909.
The object of the act of March 3, 1891, c. 517, 26 Stat. 826, was to distribute the appellate jurisdiction of this court between it and the Circuit Court of Appeals, and to abolish the appellate jurisdiction of the Circuit Court.
Although where a real constitutional question exists a writ of error can be sued out directly from this court to the trial court under § 5 of the act of 1891, the right to do so is lost by taking an appeal to the Circuit Court of Appeals. Robinson v. Caldwell, 165 U. S. 359.
The Circuit Court of Appeals does not lose its jurisdiction of an appeal under § 6 of the act of 1891 because questions were involved which would have warranted a direct appeal to this court under § 5 of that act.
Where the case can be taken directly to this court under § 5, or to the Circuit Court of Appeals under § 6, and the latter appeal is taken, while a writ of error will lie to the Circuit Court of Appeals if the jurisdiction of the Circuit Court rests, as shown by plaintiff’s statement, on grounds, one of which is reviewable by this court, it will not lie if the only ground of jurisdiction is one where the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals is final.
The judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals in a criminal case is final, and is no less so because the appellate jurisdiction of this court might have been invoked directly under § 5 of the act of 1891.
The facts are stated in the opinion.
Mr. Henry M. Earle for petitioner for writ of error:
I. Whether or not a writ of error to this court may now be had for the purpose of reviewing the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals, is controlled by the Judiciary Act of March 3, 1891.
The interpretation of this act has been before this court in several instances; see Robinson v. Caldwell, 165 U. S. 359, in which case appellant attempted to avail himself of independ- [p. 289] 213 U. S. Argument for Petitioner.
ent and simultaneous appeals; See also Carter v. Roberts, 177 U. S. 496, in which appellant, after having appealed to the Circuit Court of Appeals from the Circuit Court, attempted to appeal from the Circuit Court directly to this court.
For an elaborate interpretation of the Judiciary Act see Spreckels Sugar Refining Co. v. McClain, 192 U. S. 397, 408, discussing whether the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals was so far final, within § 6 of the act of 1891, that it could not be reviewed here as of right by writ of error and whether the judgment of that court can be reexamined here in any way, except upon certiorari.
The Spreckels case arose under the revenue laws, and the case at bar arose under the criminal laws; both are within the same provision of the Judiciary Act, and consequently the conclusions of this court on the subject of its jurisdiction relative to one, are equally applicable to the other.
In the Spreckels case, Robinson v. Caldwell, 165 U. S. 359, was distinguished, as in the latter case appeals were taken from the Circuit Court both to the Circuit Court of Appeals and to this court.
The case before the court was one in which the jurisdiction of the Circuit Court is unquestionably established, and the case is within § 5 of the act of 1891. The judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals is not final within the meaning of § 6 of said act, as it involves the construction of the statute relating to the use of the mails—& criminal law—and also involves “ from the outset . . . the construction or application of the Constitution, or the constitutionality of an act of Congress.” Under the facts and conditions stated it would appear that the decision in the Spreckels case (supra) controls the jurisdiction to review the judgment in the case at bar, a right the reason for which in this case appears in the fact that the construction of the section of the act in question, 3893, Rev. Stat., by the courts was opposed to the construction of it established by this court in the case of Dunlop v. United States, 165 U. S. 486, and United States v. Swearingen, 161 U. S. 451, and that the vol. ccxiii—19
Argument for the United States. 213 U. S.
courts avoided or ignored the constitutional question; the exactness of both of these statements are obvious upon reference to the record.
II. A constitutional question does actually exist in this case. The question arising does not refer to the admitted right of Congress to regulate the mails, but to the uncertainty of some of the laws in this regard. The act in question is so framed that its administration contravenes constitutional rights. See Ex parte Jackson, 96 U. S. 727; Public Clearing House v. Coyne, 194 U. S. 507; United States v. Comerford, 25 Fed. Rep. 902; United States v. Morris, 14 Pet. 464; United States v. Wiltberger, 5 Wheat. 76.
The statute is uncertain, being expressed in abstract terms which depend for construction upon the ever varying personal standards of the court or jury in each particular case. Certain standards have been established by this court, but the examination of the reports show that the lower courts are so divided as to their meaning that the greatest uncertainty still exists, and no man may tell from reading the statute or from studying the varying decisions, what he may not do under it; a single instance illustrates this fact, viz.: the opinion in Hanson v. United States, 157 Fed. Rep. 749, follows Dunlop v. United States, 165 U. S. 486, and is directly opposed to Macfadden n. United States, 165 Fed. Rep. 51, 52, which is based on the case of Rosen v. United States 161 U. S. 29.
The Solicitor General for the United States:
This is not a case in which the constitutionality of a law of the United States is drawn in question, because this court has already declared that § 3893 is constitutional.
The mere allegation that an act is unconstitutional is not sufficient to draw in question the constitutionality of the act. The constitutional or other Federal claim must be real and [p. 291] substantial in order to give jurisdiction to this court; the bare averment of a Federal question is not sufficient; there must be at least color of ground therefor. Millingar v. Hartupee, 6 Wall. 258; New Orleans v. New Orleans Water Works Co., 142 U. S. 79; Hamblin v. Western Land Co., 147 U. S. 531; Fort Smith Ry. v. Merriam, 156 U. S. 483; Clarke v. McDade, 165 U. S. 172; Wilson v. North Carolina, 169 U. S. 595; Lampasas v. Bell, 180 U. S. 276; Sawyer v. Piper, 189 U. S. 154; American R. R. Co. v. Castro, 204 U. S. 453.
The mere allegation of the petitioner that it is unconstitutional cannot make a case in which the constitutionality of a law of the United States is drawn in question within the meaning of § 5 of the judiciary act of March 3, 1891. In a number of previous cases arising under § 3893, the points raised in this case by the petitioner were passed upon by this court and decided in favor of the constitutionality of the act. Ex parte Jackson, 96 U. S. 727, 736; Rosen v. United States, 161 U. S. 29, 42; Dunlop v. United States, 165 U. S. 486; United States v. Chase, 135 U. S. 255, 261.
This court has also considered convictions obtained under the act, without indicating any doubt as to its constitutionality. Grimm v. United States, 156 U. S. 604; Swearingen v. United States, 161 U. S. 446; Andrews v. United States, 162 U. S. 420; Price v. United States, 165 U. S. 311.
When this court decides a question of law, it makes the law, and thereafter there cannot be said to be any question of law in regard to that proposition which it has already decided. Kansas v. Bradley, 26 Fed. Rep. 289; Newburyport Water Co. v. Newburyport, 193 U. S. 561; Lampasas v. Bell, 180 U. S. 276; New Orleans Water Works Co. v. Louisiana, 185 U. S. 336, 344; Spreckels Sugar Refining Co. v. McClain, 192 U. S. 397, discussed and distinguished from the present case.
Mr. Justice Moody delivered the opinion of the court.
The petitioner, Bemarr Macfadden, was indicted in the [p. 292] District Court of the United States for the District of New Jersey for mailing obscene literature, in violation of § 3893 of the Revised Statutes. He pleaded not guilty, and upon trial before a jury was found guilty.
Various questions of law arose in the course of the trial, which need not be stated.
After the evidence was concluded the petitioner presented to the presiding judge many requests for instructions to the jury, which were refused, under exception. For the purposes of this case four only need to be referred to, and they summarily. The judge was requested to rule that the statute under which the indictment was returned was unconstitutional; (a) because it abridged the freedom of the press; (&) because it was uncertain and created no general rule of conduct, and therefore the indictment was without due process of law; (c) because it was an ex post facto law; (d) because it delegated legislative power to the court or jury.
There was a motion in arrest of judgment, which was overruled. Thereupon judgment was entered, and the petitioner sued out a writ of error to the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. That court affirmed the judgment.
After a denial of a petition for a writ of certiorari the petitioner made application to one of the justices of this court for a writ of error, directed to the Circuit Court of Appeals. The question of the right of the petitioner to such a writ of error has been referred to the full court, and, by direction of the court, briefs on the part of the United States and the petitioner have been filed and considered.
The object of the act of March 3, 1891, c. 517, 26 Stat. 826, was to distribute the appellate jurisdiction of the Supreme Court between it and the newly-created Circuit Courts of Appeal, and to abolish the appellate jurisdiction of the Circuit Courts. The first necessary step in this undertaking was to determine in what eases appeals (using the word in its broader sense) might be taken directly to this court. This was done in § 5, which is as follows:
“Sec. 5. That appeals or writs of error may be taken from the District Courts or from the existing Circuit Courts direct to the Supreme Court in the following cases:
“In any case in which the jurisdiction of the court is in issue; in such cases the question of jurisdiction alone shall be certified to the Supreme Court from the court below for decision.
“From the final sentences and decrees in prize causes.
“In cases of conviction of a capital or otherwise infamous crime.
“In any case that involves the construction or application of the Constitution of the United States.
“In any case in which the constitutionality of any law of the United States, or the validity or construction of any treaty made under its authority, is drawn in question.
“In any case in which the constitution or law of a State is claimed to be in contravention of the Constitution of the United States.”
Clause 3 of this section has been amended by the act of January 30, 1897, c. 69, 29 Stat. 492 by striking out the words “or otherwise infamous.”
Assuming, without decision, that the constitutional questions were real and substantial, it is clear that a writ of error might have been sued out originally directly from this court under clause 5. Loeb v. Columbia Township Trustees, 179 U. S. 472. But this was not done, and by the appeal to the Circuit Court of Appeals the right of direct appeal here was lost. Robinson v. Caldwell, 165 U. S. 359.
Section 6 of the act provides that the Circuit Courts of Appeal shall exercise appellate jurisdiction “in all cases other than those provided for in the preceding section of this act,” and the fact that there were in the case questions which would have warranted a direct appeal to this court does not deprive the Circuit Court of Appeals of its jurisdiction. American Sugar Co. v. New Orleans, 181 U. S. 277. In the case at bar the Circuit Court of Appeals has assumed jurisdiction and rendered judgment. May the petitioner have a writ of error directed to [p. 294] that judgment? The answer to this question depends upon whether the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals was final. The act contemplated that certain judgments of the Circuit Court of Appeals might be reviewed on writ of error in this court, and that certain other judgments could not be so reviewed. The line of division is marked in § 6 of the act. It is to be observed that the line of division between cases appealable directly to this court and those appealable to the Circuit Court of Appeals, made by § 5 of the act, is based upon the nature of the case or of the questions of law raised. But the line of division between cases appealable from the Circuit Court of Appeals to this court and those not so appealable, drawn by § 6, is different, and is determined, not by the nature of the case or of the questions of law raised, but by the sources of jurisdiction of the trial court, namely, the Circuit Court or the District Court, whether the jurisdiction rests upon the character of the parties or the nature of the case. Huguley Mfg. Co. v. Galeton Cotton Mills, 184 U. S. 290, where it was said by the Chief Justice, citing cases, “The jurisdiction referred to is the jurisdiction of the Circuit Court as originally invoked.” The difference in the test for determining whether a case is appealable from the trial court directly to this court, and the test for determining whether a case is appealable from the Circuit Court of Appeals to this court, is important, and a neglect to observe it leads to confusion.
The statute says that the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals “shall be final in all cases in which the jurisdiction is dependent entirely upon the opposite parties to the suit or controversy, being aliens and citizens of the United States or citizens of different States; also in all cases arising under the patent laws, under the revenue laws, and under the criminal laws, and in admiralty cases.” In all other cases there is a right of review by this court if the matter in controversy exceeds one thousand dollars.
As this is a case arising under the criminal laws, the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals rendered within its lawful [p. 295] jurisdiction is, by the very terms of the act, final. And so it was held in Cary Mfg. Co. v. Acme Flexible Clasp Co., 187 U. S. 427, this court saying, through the Chief Justice: “Although it is insisted that the judgment imposing the fine was a final judgment in a criminal matter, it is argued that it involved the denial of constitutional rights, and hence that this court has jurisdiction under § 5 of that act; but it is settled that even if a party might be entitled to come directly to this court under that section, yet if he does not do so, and carries his case to the Circuit Court of Appeals, he must abide by the judgment of that court,” and the writ of error to the Circuit Court of Appeals was accordingly dismissed. Unless this case has been overruled, it governs the case at bar.
But it is argued that the right to this writ of error is supported by the decision of this court in Spreckels Sugar Refining Co. v. McClain, 192 U. S. 397. An examination of that case, however, shows that the exact decision has no relevancy to the question now before us. The language of the opinion should be interpreted in the light of the facts of the case. The plaintiff there brought an action against the collector of internal revenue to recover certain taxes imposed by the revenue laws of the United States, paid by it under protest. The plaintiff’s claim as stated in his declaration was twofold; first, that the taxes were not due under the act as properly construed; and, second, that the act itself was unconstitutional. The jurisdiction, therefore, of the trial court was invoked upon two grounds; first, because it was a revenue case; and, second, because it arose under the Constitution and laws of the United States (25 Stat. 433), which means that the plaintiff’s case thus arose. Louisville & Nashville R. R. Co. v. Mottley, 211 U. S. 149, and cases cited. Judgment went against the plaintiff, and it was affirmed by the Circuit Court of Appeals. A writ of error from this court to the Circuit Court of Appeals was sued out, and the question was whether it would lie. That question, as we have seen it, is determinable by the jurisdiction of the trial court. If the jurisdiction depended solely upon the fact that it was a case arising [p. 296] under the revenue laws the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals was a final judgment. If, on the other hand, the jurisdiction depended solely upon the fact that it was a case arising out of the Constitution or laws of the United States, the jurisdiction of the Circuit Court of Appeals was not final, and it was reviewable upon the writ of error as matter of right in this court.
Here was a case, then, which in one aspect of the jurisdiction was reviewable by this court and in another aspect of the jurisdiction was not reviewable here. The precise case had not arisen before, and the statute was silent upon it. It was held that the writ of error could be maintained, as the jurisdiction of the trial court did not depend solely upon grounds which by the terms of the act would have made the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals final, but depended also upon grounds which would have permitted a writ of error from this court to the Circuit Court of Appeals. That this was the precise ground of the decision is clear from the whole trend of the reasoning and from the statement in the opinion, p. 410, that “the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals is not final, within the meaning of the sixth section, in a case which, although arising under a law providing for internal revenue and involving the construction of that law, is yet a case also involving, from the outset, from the plaintiff’s showing, the construction or application of the Constitution or the constitutionality of an act of Congress.” The case decides nothing more than that where the jurisdiction of the trial court is shown by the plaintiff’s statement of his own case to rest upon two distinct grounds; first, a ground where the appellate jurisdiction of the Circuit Court of Appeals was made final by the statute; and, second, a ground where the appellate jurisdiction of the Circuit Court of Appeals was made by the statute reviewable in this court, the latter ground of jurisdiction would control and the writ of error to the Circuit Court of Appeals would lie. Thus construed, the case is consistent with all the decisions and has no application here, because the only ground of jurisdiction of the District Court in the case [p. 297] 213 U. S. Argument for Petitioner
at bar was that it was a case arising under the criminal laws. In such a case the statute makes the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals final, and it is no less final because the petitioner here might, if he had been so advised, originally have invoked directly, under § 5 of the act, the appellate jurisdiction of this court.
We are of the opinion that the writ of error does not lie, and the application for it is
Denied.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access