Beadles v. Smyser, 209 U.S. 393 (1908)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Beadles v. Smyser, 209 U.S. 393 (1908)
Full caption
BEADLES v. SMYSER, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF PERRY, OKLAHOMA.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Apr. 6, 1908
BEADLES v. SMYSER, MAYOR OF THE CITY OF PERRY, OKLAHOMA.
ERROR TO AND APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF THE TERRITORY OF OKLAHOMA.
No. 150. Argued March 4, 1908.—Decided April 6, 1908.
While this court cannot review judgments of the Supreme Court of the Territory of Oklahoma unless the amount involved exceeds $5,000, where the judgment also directly involves the validity of other judgments the amount in controversy may be measured by the aggregate of such judgments.
The principles of right and justice upon which the doctrine of estoppel in pais rests, are applicable to municipal corporations.
Where public property of a municipality cannot be seized on execution and the municipality enters into a valid agreement with judgment creditors to apply the judgment fund to judgments in order of entry and complies therewith, it cannot, after the expiration of the statutory period when a judgment becomes dormant for failure to issue execution, plead the statute of limitations as a bar to those judgments not yet reached for payment under the agreement. The municipality is estopped both on the contract and on the ground of equitable estoppel, and so held as to judgments against a city in Oklahoma.
17 Oklahoma, 162, reversed.
The facts are stated in the opinion.
Mr. A. G. C. Bierer, with whom Mr. S. H. Harris and Mr. Frank Dale were on the briefs, for plaintiff in error and appellant:
The action being in mandamus to compel a city to recognize the validity of plaintiff’s judgments and to pay out the moneys already accrued in the judgment fund upon these judgments, and to continue to make levies to enforce the same, the statutory period of limitation fixed by law for civil actions does not run against the relief asked. Duke, Mayor, et al. v. Turner et al., 204 U. S. 623.
Argument for Appellant* 209 U. S.
The section of the Oklahoma statute permitting the enforcement of a judgment by execution and providing for the dormancy of such judgment if execution is not issued within five years, has no application to judgments against municipalities in this Territory which are collectible only by the levy of taxes which are required by the law to be made to create a judgment fund out of which to pay such judgments.
The cases of Hart v. City of New Orleans, 12 Fed. Rep. 292; State ex rel. Courier v. Buckles, 35 N. E. Rep. 846; Laredo v. Benavides, 25 S. W. Rep. 482, cited by Supreme Court of Oklahoma, reviewed and distinguished from the case at bar.
Oklahoma law provides for collecting judgments by tax instead of execution.
That it is and has been throughout the life of all these judgments the duty of the city of Perry to make a levy of five mills on the dollar to provide a fund with which to pay these judgments is clearly declared by our statute. Sec. 1, art. 5, p. 83, Statutes of 1897; Session Laws of 1899, § 1, c. 8, p. 103; Wilson’s Stat, of 1903, § 466.
The cases cited by the Oklahoma Supreme Court in the cases of Beadles v. Fry, 15 Oklahoma, 423, are inapplicable to the facts in the case at bar. Newton v. Arthur, 55 Pac. Rep. 446; Israel v. Nichols, 14 Pac. Rep. 438; Brockway v. Oswego Township, 4 Pac. Rep. 79; and Baker v. Hummer, 2 Pac. Rep. 808, discussed and distinguished.
Statutes of limitation do not run against municipal obligations of the character of judgments in Oklahoma. Barnes v. Turner, 14 Oklahoma, 284; Freehill v. Porter, 4 Pac. Rep. 646; Lincoln Co. v. Luning, 133 U. S. 529.
The placing of the obligations in question into judgments which are to be paid out of the judgment fund of the city, does not in any way affect the principles applied in the Barnes or Duke v. Turner case. United States v. County of Macon, 99 U. S. 582; A., T. & S. F. Ry. Co. v. Territory of New Mexico, 72 Pac. Rep. 14; Darcy v. Mumpford, 58 Georgia, 119; United States ex rel. Field v. Township of Oswego, 28 Fed. Rep. 55.
209. U. S, Argument for Appellees.
The city of Perry recognized these judgments as valid judgments and continued to levy taxes to provide money in the judgment fund to pay these judgments, and mandamus, which is the only execution against a municipality, could not have issued until the city refused to recognize and pay the judgments in 1905. Alter v. State, 86 N. W. Rep. 1080.
The city of Perry having ratified and approved the agreement among the judgment creditors to pay these judgments in their order of rendition, and having carried out this agreement in the levy of taxes and the payment out of the judgment fund of these tax moneys for all these years, should now be held to be estopped from pleading the dormancy of these judgments even if otherwise they could have become dormant.
Mr. A. N. Whiteside and Mr. H. B. Martin, for defendants in error and appellees, submitted:
This court has no jurisdiction of this action, because the amount involved is less than $5,000.00.
If the validity of plaintiff’s judgments were conceded, the only cause of action appearing upon the face of the alternative writ is against Fry, the treasurer of the city, and that said cause of action cannot involve more than the amount of money in the hands of the treasurer, which is less than the amount necessary to give this court jurisdiction of the subject-matter of the action.
A judgment against a city of the first class under the statutes of Oklahoma becomes dormant after five years from the date of its rendition if execution shall not be sued out within that time and such judgment cannot be revived without the consent of the judgment debtor unless it be revived within one year from the time it becomes dormant. Section 4337, statutes of Oklahoma, 1893; Lafayette County v. Wonderly, 92 Fed. Rep. 313; Beadles v. Fry, 82 Pac. Rep. 1041, and cases cited; Statutes of Oklahoma, 1893, §§4325 and 4332. All these statutes were adopted from the State of Kansas, whose courts have frequently construed them as we contend they p. 396should be. See Angell v. Martin, 24 Kansas, 334; Myers v. Kotham, 29 Kansas, 19; Tefft v. Citizens’ Bank, 36 Kansas, 457; Mawhinney v. Doane, 40 Kansas, 681; Tibbetts v. Deck, 41 Kansas, 492; Bradford v. Loan Co., 47 Kansas, 587; Raff v. State, 48 Kansas, 45; Railroad Co. v. Butts, 55 Kansas, 661; New Hampshire Bank Company v. Ball, 57 Kansas, 812; Reeves v. Long, 63 Kansas, 700; Steinback v. Murphy, 70 Kansas, 487.
As to the necessity of reviving judgments against municipal corporations within the statutory periods of time, see Brockway v. Oswego Township, 4 Pac. Rep. 79; Ware v. Pleasant Grove Township, 59 Pac. Rep. 1089; City of Chanute v. Trader, 132 U. S. 210; Field v. Township of Oswego, 28 Fed. Rep. 55; Coulan v. Doull, 133 U. S. 596; M’Aleer v. Clay Co., 42 Fed. Rep. 665; Lafayette Co. v. Wonderly, 92 Fed. Rep. 313.
Mr. Justice Day delivered the opinion of the court.
This is a proceeding to review the judgment of the Supreme Court of the Territory of Oklahoma, affirming the judgment of the District Court of Noble County in that Territory, denying a peremptory writ of mandamus to the plaintiff in error, also plaintiff below, seeking to compel the recognition of certain judgments and the levy of taxes by the city officers of the city of Perry, a city of the first class, in Noble County. The action was begun March 12, 1906, in the District Court upon a petition, which set forth the ownership in the plaintiff of judgments against the city of Perry, rendered, with two exceptions, in the year 1898; the other two rendered in January and March, 1899, and aggregating the sum of $16,304.51, including interest and costs.
The petition avers that these judgments were rendered on warrants issued by the city of Perry upon the general fund of the city; that no funds having been provided for the payment of plaintiff’s and certain other judgments, on December 3,1901, the judgment creditors of the city entered into an p. 397agreement with the city treasurer of the city by signing a certain paper writing, to wit:
“I, the undersigned, judgment creditor, holding judgment against the city of Perry, Noble County, Oklahoma Territory, hereby ask that the city treasurer pay all judgments against the city of Perry in order of rendition, hereby waiving right to payment pro rata, if such right exists, and this waiver shall apply to all grantees and assigns. Said judgments are in amounts and dates as follows:” [Here follows a list of the judgments.]
At that time the outstanding unpaid judgment indebtedness of the city of Perry amounted to $22,000, all of the owners of which, excepting the sum of $4,000, signed the agreement; that the waivers thus signed were presented to the city council of the city, which adopted the following resolution:
“Whereas, the judgment creditors holding judgments against the city of Perry have practically all signed written waivers of the right, if such right exists, to payment of said judgments pro rata, and therein consent to the payment of said judgments in the order of their rendition against said city:
“ Therefore, be it resolved, That the city treasurer is hereby authorized and directed to pay the said judgments existing against the city of Perry in the order of their rendition out of the funds now on hand and as they shall accrue in the judgment fund.”
That thereafter the city treasurer followed the plan thus outlined of paying judgments up to the early part of the year 1905, and the judgments prior to those sued upon by the plaintiff were paid off in that way. And it is averred that under the laws of the Territory of Oklahoma a judgment fund must be created to satisfy a judgment against a municipality, and a judgment of that kind can be paid in no other way. And that under the laws of Oklahoma no execution can be levied upon a judgment against the municipality, and that during the time since the rendition of the judgments the city of Perry p. 398has had no property subject to levy upon execution, and that the judgments of the plaintiff could not have been paid, and taxes levied for that purpose, because there had not been sufficient money in the judgment fund of the city of Perry to pay the judgments or any part thereof. That under the agreement of December 3, 1901, payments of judgments against the city have been made, but in the order of rendition the fund has been paid upon judgments prior to the plaintiffs. That under the law of the Territory, during the life of the said judgments, at least since the year 1899, it has been the duty of the city of Perry to levy annually a tax not to exceed five mills on the dollar on all the property of the said city, to create a judgment fund, and that said city has made said levy annually, and paid judgments down to the early part of 1905, since which time the city treasurer of the city of Perry, under the direction of the mayor and city council, has declined to pay the plaintiff’s judgments or any proportion of the same, and that there has accumulated in the hands of the city treasurer $2,286.96, the judgment fund of said city. And that at all times down to the beginning of the year 1905 the city of Perry has recognized the binding force and validity of said judgments; that the mayor and council and treasurer of said city decline and refuse to recognize the validity of the plaintiff’s judgments or pay any part thereof, and deny any liability thereon, solely on the ground that the same have become dormant and barred by the statute of limitations of the Territory of Oklahoma. And other averments are made as to the inability of the plaintiff to otherwise collect their money upon the judgments than by payment by a levy at five mills on the dollar of the taxable property of the city. And the plaintiff prayed a writ of mandamus against the mayor, city council and treasurer of said city, commanding them to recognize the said judgments and to continue to make the five-mill levy allowed by the law for the judgment fund for the payment of said judgments against the city, as provided by law.
An alternate writ of mandamus was issued, reciting the p. 399allegations of the petition, to which the defendant filed an amended answer, in which they set up that each and all of the judgments set out in the alternate writ of mandamus have become dormant because no execution was issued on any of said judgments, and no proceeding begun for the revival of any of them, and the same were barred by the statute of limitations of the Territory.
The plaintiff filed a motion for judgment upon the amended answer and prayed the issuance of a peremptory writ of mandamus upon the ground that the amended answer failed to state any legal reason why said peremptory writ should not be issued. The defendant moved the court for judgment on the pleadings, on the ground that all the judgments were barred by the statute of limitations. The court sustained the motion of the defendant and entered final judgment in the defendant’s favor, upon the ground that all the judgments set out in the alternate writ of mandamus have become dormant and are barred by the statute of limitations.
Upon proceedings in error in the Supreme Court of the Territory of Oklahoma this judgment was affirmed on the authority of Beadles v. Fry, 15 Oklahoma, 428. The present case is reported, 17 Oklahoma, 162.
The question is first made as to the jurisdiction of this court, because it is averred that the sum of $5,000 is not involved, but we are of the opinion that the issue made and decided involved the validity of the $16,000 and upwards, of judgments described in the petition and amended writ. The prayer of the petitioner was for a continuous levy of taxes for the amount permitted by law to be applied in payment of the judgments. The answer set up that all the judgments were barred by the statute of limitations, and the District Court of Noble County determined that the judgments and each and all of them set out in the petition and alternate writ of mandamus had become dormant and were barred by the statute of limitations. This judgment was affirmed by the Supreme Court of Oklahoma.
Appeals and writs of error are allowed from the Supreme Court of Oklahoma to this court where the value of the property or the amount in controversy, to be ascertained by the affidavit of either party or other competent witness, exceeds $5,000. Supplement U. S. Revised Stats, vol. 1, p. 724.
We think the judgment in this case involves the validity of all the plaintiff’s judgments, and that the amount in controversy is not simply the fund in the hands of the treasurer, but the amount of all the judgments concerning which relief was sought and which were directly adjudicated to be barred by the statute of limitations.
The question made in the case is whether the judgments are dormant by the statute of limitations of the Territory of Oklahoma "or failure to issue execution thereon for the period of five years, and because the same were not revived within one year after they became dormant. The statutes of Oklahoma in 2 Wilson’s Statutes of 1903, provide as follows:
Section 4635. “ If execution shall not be sued out within five years from the date of any judgment that now is or may hereafter be rendered, in any court of record in this Territory, or if five years shall have intervened between the date of the last execution issued on such judgment and the time of suing out another writ of execution thereon, such judgment shall become dormant, and shall cease to operate as a lien on the estate of the judgment debtor.”
Section 4623 is as follows:
“An order to revive an action against the representative or successor of a defendant shall not be made without the consent of such representative or successor unless in one year from the time it could have been first made.”
And section 4630 provides:
“If a judgment becomes dormant it may be revived in the same manner as prescribed for reviving actions before judgment.”
It is contended by the counsel for the appellant that this case is governed by the ruling of this court in Duke, Mayor
&c. n. Turner and others, 204 U. S. 623. We are of opinion that the question here involved was not determined in that case. There was no question of a judgment becoming dormant under the statute of limitations for want of execution within five years. The point decided in that case was that the petition for mandamus was not a* civil action within the meaning of the Oklahoma Code, barred by the three-year statute of limitations, and the question was whether the relator had slept upon his rights for such an unreasonable time as to prejudice the rights of the defendant and preclude relief by mandamus. In this case the underlying question is not as to whether a writ of mandamus is the proper remedy, but is, whether the judgment is dormant by reason of the statute of limitations and incapable of being enforced against the municipality.
The Supreme Court of Oklahoma held that the statute made no exception, and that notwithstanding the averment of the petition that the city of Perry had no property liable to be reached on execution, that unless execution were issued within the five years, or the judgment revived within one year, it had become dormant for failure to comply with the law.
There is some difference of view in the opinion of the courts upon the subject of executions against municipalities, and in some of them it is held that property of a municipality may be reached on execution which is held for profit and not charged with any public trust or use. It was held in this court that the public property of a municipal corporation cannot be seized upon execution. Klein v. New Orleans, 99 U. S. 149.
Judge Dillon, in his work on Municipal Corporations (4th ed.) notices the differences of ruling on the subject, and states as his own conclusion § 576:
“On principle, in the absence of statutable provision, or legislative policy in the particular State, it would seem to be a sound view to hold that the right to contract and the power to be sued give to the creditor a right to recover judgment; that judgment should be enforceable by execution against the vol. ccix—26 p. 402strictly private property of the corporation, but not against any property owned or used by the corporation for public purposes, such as public buildings, hospitals and cemeteries; fire engines and apparatus, waterworks, and the like; and that judgments should not be deemed liens upon real property except when it may be taken in execution.”
Accepting the decision of the Supreme Court of Oklahoma, rendered in 15 Oklahoma, supra, construing the statute so as to permit the issuance of execution against the municipality, with the right to levy upon the private property of the corporation if it has any, could the city take advantage of the failure to issue execution under the circumstances shown in this case? This subject was briefly disposed of in the opinion in that court, and of it the learned court said (15 Oklahoma, 436):
“ It is alleged that this agreement and resolution of the city council prevented the running of the statutes. This resolution was passed at a time when the plaintiff’s judgments were in full force and effect. The city council did not attempt to renew its liability on these judgments. Without expressing our views as to whether such judgments should be paid pro rata, or in order of priority as to date, we are of the opinion that the council could not change the law, and if the resolution purported to change it, it would be void; and if it was in conformity with the law it would not change the relation of the parties.”
That the principles of right and justice, upon which the doctrine of estoppel in pais rest, are applicable to municipal corporations, is recognized by textwriters and in well-con-sidered cases. In 1 Dillon on Municipal Corporations (4th ed.), in a note to § 417, that learned author says:
“Any positive acts (infra vires') by municipal officers which may have induced the action of the adverse party, and where it would be inequitable to permit the corporation to stultify itself, by retracting what its officers had done, will work an estoppel.”
And this case does not rest on the ground of equitable p. 403estoppel alone. The manner of liquidation of these judgments was the subject of express contract between the parties.
In the present case, by the action of the city council, the judgment creditors were so placed that during the time, at least while the city council were carrying out the arrangement of December 3, 1901, in good faith, they could not consistently with fair dealing and the terms of the contract on their part, issue an execution to seize the property of the municipality; had they undertaken to do so a court of equity would have promptly restrained such proceedings.
It is averred, and not denied, that up until the year 1905 the city council made a levy each year for the largest amount which the statute permitted, to create a judgment fund out of which to pay, and out of which was regularly paid, the outstanding judgments against the city, and that these payments continued until the plaintiff’s judgments were reached, which were next in order. While thus acting to the limit to which the law permitted, and in good faith carrying out the arrangement between the parties, it is perfectly apparent that the plaintiff was not in a position to seize by execution any property of the municipality.
If it could be held, as the authorities indicate (2 Dillon on Municip. Corp., 4th ed., §850, note 1), that when execution cannot be issued on a judgment against a municipality, mandamus may take its place, the action of the city council in making the arrangement in question would have equally prevented the plaintiffs from availing themselves of that writ.
In this case the agreement made by the parties in December, 1901, was being continuously carried out until 1905. And during that time the city of Perry was doing all it could be compelled by mandamus to do in levying taxes to the full amount required by law for the payment of judgments against the city. The court would have no power by mandamus to compel the levy of taxes which the law did not authorize. United States v. Macon County Court, 99 U. S. 582.
As we have said, the principles of natural justice and fair
Opinion of the Court. 209'U, S.
dealing are alike applicable to municipal corporations as to individuals, and to permit the city to escape the payment of judgments, whose validity is not otherwise questioned, for failure to issue execution or sue out a writ of mandamus during the time when the action of the city officers was such as to prevent the exercise of the right, would be to permit the action of the representatives of the city, who have had the benefit of the contract during the time both parties were observing its obligations, to work a gross injustice upon the creditors holding valid judgments against the municipality.
We have been referred to no case precisely in point. Analogous cases are not altogether wanting. In Mercantile Trust Co. v. St. L. & S. F. Rwy., 69 Fed. Rep. 193, it was held that a stay of execution in the record prevented the judgment becoming dormant. In Marshall v. Minter, 43 Mississippi, 678, it was held that the statute did not run during the time an injunction was in force, sued out by the adverse party and afterwards dissolved.
It is not argued at the bar in this case that the arrangement with the judgment creditors was void for want of power in the municipality to make the arrangement of December, 1901, and we fail to see any valid reason why the municipality might not enter into this arrangement. It was permitted by law to make an annual levy of five mills on, the dollar. 1 Wilson s Statutes, 1903, § 466. If the judgment creditors and the municipality saw fit to make an arrangement by which the amount of this annual levy might be distributed by the consent of the creditors among them in accordance with the priority of their judgments, we perceive no reason why this may not be legally done. The effect of this arrangement was to prevent the judgment creditor from taking such steps as the law permitted to collect his judgment, and, upon principles of common right and justice, it would not do to permit the city to carry out such an arrangement during nearly all the five years’ period, and then meet its obligation by a plea of the statute of limitations upon the ground that the judgments p. 405209 U. S. Argument for Plaintiffs in Error.
had become dormant, while both parties were recognizing their binding obl’gation and doing all that the law permitted, to effect their satisfaction, and had entered into a contract which prevented the judgment creditors from taking steps to avail themselves of their right to collect their judgments by execution or by writ of mandamus.
For these reasons the judgment of the Supreme Court of Oklahoma Territory is
Reversed, and the cause remanded to the Supreme Court of the State of Oklahoma for further proceedings in accordance with this opinion.
WARE AND LELAND v. MOBILE COUNTY.
WARE AND LELAND v. STATE OF ALABAMA.
ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF ALABAMA.
Nos. 173, 174. Submitted March 10, 1908.—Decided April 6, 1908.
Contracts for sales of cotton for future delivery, which do not oblige interstate shipments, are not subjects of interstate commerce, nor does the fact that a delivery may be made by means of interstate carriage make them so; and a state tax on persons engaged in buying and selling cotton for future delivery held in this case not to be a regulation of interstate commerce and as such beyond the power of the State. Paul v. Virginia (insurance policy case), 8 Wall. 168, followed; Lottery Case, 188 U. S. 321; Pearick v. Pennsylvania, 203 U. S. 507, distinguished. 146 Alabama, 163, affirmed.
The facts are stated in the opinion.
Mr. Burwell Boykin Boone for plaintiffs in error:
The license tax in question, sought to be collected from the plaintiffs in error, is a burden upon and a regulation of interstate commerce, and in conflict with Article I, Section 8, p. 406paragraph 3, of the Constitution of the United States. Champion v. Ames, 188 U. S. 351; Hanley v. Kansas City Southern R. R. Co., 187 U. S. 619; Stradford v. City Council of Montgomery, 110 Alabama, 619; Stockard v. Morgan, 185 U. S. 27; Brennan v. Titusville, 153 U. S. 289; Caldwell v. North Carolina, 187 U. S. 622.
No counsel appeared for defendants in error.
Mr. Justice Day delivered the opinion of the court.
These cases were submitted together and are in all respects similar, and involve the constitutional validity of subdivision 40 of an act of the legislature of Alabama imposing license taxes, “to better’ provide for the revenue of the State,” General Acts, 1903, p. 207, which reads as follows:
“For each person engaged in the business of buying and selling futures for speculation or on commission, either for themselves or for other persons, and each place of business commonly known as cotton exchanges, or stock exchanges, and sometimes called ‘ bucket shops,’ in towns and cities of twenty thousand inhabitants or more, five hundred dollars; in all other towns and cities, two hundred and fifty dollars; but this shall not be held to legalize any contract which would otherwise be invalid.”
In case No. 173 the action was brought by Mobile County for the recovery of the defendants’ license tax for the year 1903, for engaging in the business of buying and selling futures on commission for other persons in the city of Mobile. The other case (No. 174) was an action by the State. Plaintiffs recovered in the Circuit Court and both judgments were affirmed by the Supreme Court. 146 Alabama, 163.
The cases were submitted upon an agreed statement of the facts as follows:
“During the whole of the year 1903 defendants had an office in the city of Mobile, in the county of Mobile and State p. 407209 U. S. Opinion of the Court.
of Alabama: they also had offices in the city of New York in the State of New York, and in the city of New Orleans in the State of Louisiana, and in the city of Chicago in the State of Illinois, each of which offices was connected by private telegraph wires with said Mobile office. Said Mobile, Alabama, office was in the charge of their agent, one Robbins, and was engaged in the business of buying and selling cotton for future delivery, on commission, for the public generally and for special customers, said business being conducted in the following way and in no other way: They would undertake, through their agent, to buy or sell a cotton future contract for a customer in the Cotton Exchange in New York or in New Orleans, as he might select, he making at the time a deposit of money with them as a margin to protect them against loss in making such transaction for him. When the customer gave the order to Ware and Leland, either for a sale or a purchase of a future contract, it was not usual for anything to be said between them about an actual delivery of the cotton, but when the transaction was commenced by a purchase or sale of the cotton Ware and Leland would immediately furnish to the customer a memorandum thereof, partly written and partly printed, upon which the following stipulations were printed: ‘On all marginal business, we reserve the right to close transactions without further notice when margins are about exhausted, and to settle contracts in accordance with the rules and customs of the exchange on which the order is placed, it being understood and agreed in all trades that actual delivery is contemplated,’ and ‘All purchases and sales made by us for you are made in accordance with and subject to the rules, regulations and customs of the exchange on which the order is placed, and the rules, regulations and requirements of the board of managers of said exchange, and all amendments that may be made thereto.’ Such agent would thereupon transmit such order by their private telegraph line to the defendants’ office in the city without the State of Alabama selected for such transaction; that such order would be p. 408thereupon executed by defendants by the purchase or sale, as directed, of a future cotton contract for such customer in the cotton exchange of the city to which such order was sent, and subject to the rules and regulations of such cotton exchange, which rules and regulations may be introduced in evidence by defendants in this cause; that said contract would be held by defendants for such customer until he ordered the same closed out, when they would sell or buy another cotton contract against it as might be necessary to cover the same or close it out, or receive or deliver the cotton on said contract. If a profit was made on the transaction defendants remitted the same to its agent in Mobile, who paid it over to the customer; if a loss was made, it was taken by the agent out of the customers’ margin, or, if that was insufficient therefor, the customer was called on for the balance. Said business was done on a commission paid defendants by the customers.
“No actual delivery of cotton or grain was ever made on any such contracts, except in a few instances, when such deliveries were made where the contracts were executed, to wit: in New York, New York, or in New Orleans, Louisiana, or Chicago, Illinois. When any such delivery of cotton was made to defendants for the customer on a purchase by him, it was held by the defendants for account of the customer at the place of delivery, either in New York, New York, or in New Orleans, Louisiana, until ordered sold by the customer, and was then sold by them there for the account of the customer, and the proceeds accounted for by them to such customer. When they made delivery of cotton on a sale of futures made by them for a customer, the cotton was shipped by the customer for whom such sale was made from Alabama to the place of sale and there delivered through defendants to the buyer.
“A similar future grain business was done by defendants at their said office in Mobile, Alabama, for customers through their office in Chicago, in the State of Illinois—said orders being executed on the Chicago, Illinois, Board of Trade, and subject to its rules and regulations, which contemplated and p. 409provided for the actual receipt or delivery of grain bought or sold therein—such delivery to be made in Chicago, Illinois.
“ During the whole of the year 1903 said city of Mobile, Alabama, was a city of more than twenty thousand inhabitants.
“Defendant paid to plaintiff a license tax of one hundred dollars for doing such business in said city for the year 1903, which payment was made prior to the fourth day of March, 1903; they have not paid any further license tax to plaintiff for doing such business in said year.”
Upon the trial of the action, in addition to the foregoing agreed facts, the counsel for the plaintiff admitted that the rules and regulations of the New York Cotton Exchange, New Orleans Cotton Exchange and Chicago Board of Trade, respectively, provided “that contracts executed therein should be in writing; and also provided that in every cotton or grain contract for future delivery executed and entered into in said exchange or board of trade, it should be stipulated, agreed and understood that an actual receipt and delivery of the cotton or grain was to be had, and that said contracts were transferable and assignable.”
The sole question here presented is, whether the statute in question is an attempt to regulate interstate commerce, for if the plaintiffs in error are shown by the foregoing agreed facts to be engaged in interstate commerce then the statute is void, as an attempt by a State to regulate the commerce which the Constitution of the United States places within the exclusive control of Federal authority.
Interstate commerce must be such as takes place between States as differentiated from commerce wholly within a State. It must have reference to interstate trade or dealing, and if the regulation is not such, and comprehends only commerce which is internal, the State may legislate concerning it. In each case the recurring question is, on which side of the line does the commerce under investigation fall?
It is unnecessary to review the former decisions of this court, p. 410as that has been done in very recent cases, such as the Lottery case, 188 U. S. 321, where it was held that the transportation of lottery tickets was interstate commerce, and as such subject to regulation by act of Congress. In that case the Federal act, prohibiting the transmission of lottery tickets, was sustained, because of the actual carriage in interstate traffic of the tickets themselves, and in concluding the opinion of the majority of the court Mr. Justice Harlan said (p. 363):
“The whole subject is too important, and the questions suggested by its consideration are too difficult of solution, to justify any attempt to lay down a rule for determining in advance the validity of every statute that may be enacted under the commerce clause. We decide nothing more in the present case than that lottery tickets are subjects of traffic among those who choose to sell or buy them; that the carriage of such tickets by independent carriers from one State to another is therefore interstate commerce; that under its power to regulate commerce among the several States Congress—subject to the limitations imposed by the Constitution upon the ex - ercise of the powers granted—has plenary authority over such commerce and may prohibit the carriage of such tickets from State to State; and .that legislation to that end, and of that character, is not inconsistent with any limitation or restriction imposed upon the exercise of the powers granted to Congress.”
And in Leloup v. 'Mobile, 127 U. S. 640, it was held that a telegraph company, whose business is the transmission of messages from one State to another, invested with the powers and privileges conferred by Congress, could not be compelled to pay a license tax by the State. And in Pensacola Telegraph Co. v. Western Union Telegraph Co., it was held that interstate telegraphic communications, conducted by companies organized for that purpose, was commerce within the regulating power of Congress. The Pensacola case was affirmed in Telegraph Co. v. Texas, 105 U. S. 460, in which case Mr. Chief Justice Waite, speaking for the court, said, p. 464: “ A telegraph company occupies the same relation to commerce as p. 411209 U. S. Opinion of the Court.
a carrier of messages that a railroad company does as a carrier of goods.”
While the general principles applied in these cases are not to be denied, there is a class of cases which hold that contracts between citizens of different States are not the subjects of interstate commerce, simply because they are negotiated between citizens of different States, or by the agent of a company in another State, where the contract itself is to be completed and carried out wholly within the borders of a State, although such contracts incidentally affect interstate trade.
As in the cases involving insurance policies, it has been held that issuing them in one State and sending them to another, to be there delivered to the insured upon payment of premium, is not a transaction of interstate commerce. Paul v. Virginia, 8 Wall. 168; Hooper v. California, 155 U. S. 648; New York Life Insurance Co. v. Cravens, 178 U. S. 389.
In Paul v. Virginia, Mr. Justice Field, delivering the opinion of the court, said (p. 183):
“ Issuing a policy of insurance is not a transaction of commerce. The policies are simple contracts of indemnity against loss by fire, entered into between the corporations and the assured, for a consideration paid by the latter. These contracts are not articles of commerce in any proper meaning of the word. They are not subjects of trade and barter offered in the market as something having an existence and value independent to the parties to them. They are not commodities to be shipped or forwarded from one State to another, and then put up for sale. They are like other personal contracts between parties which are completed by their signature and the transfer of the consideration. Such contracts are not interstate transactions, though the parties may be domiciled in different States. The policies do not take effect—are not executed contracts—until delivered by the agent in Virginia. They are, then, local transactions, and are governed by the local law. They do not constitute a part of the commerce between the States any more than a contract for the purchase p. 412and sale of goods in Virginia, by a citizen of New York whilst in Virginia, would constitute a portion of such commerce.”
In Hooper v. California, 155 U. S. 648; it was said:
“If the power to regulate interstate commerce applied to all the incidents to which said commerce might give rise and to all contracts which might be made in the course of its transaction, that power would embrace the entire sphere of mercantile activity in any way connected with trade between the States; and would exclude State control over many contracts purely domestic in their nature. The business of insurance is not commerce. The contract of insurance is not an instrumentality of commerce. The making of such a contract is a mere incident of commercial intercourse, and in this respect there is no difference whatever between insurance against fire and insurance against ‘the perils of the sea.’ ”
These cases are not in conflict with those in which it is held that the negotiation of sales of goods in a State by a person employed to solicit for them in another State, the goods to be shipped from the one State to the other, is interstate commerce. Robbins v. Shelby County Taxing District, 120 U. S. 489; similar cases are Rearick v. Pennsylvania, 203 U. S. 507, and Caldwell v. North Carolina, 187 U. S. 622. In these cases goods in a foreign State are sold upon orders for the purpose of bringing them to the State which undertakes to tax them, and the transactions are held to be interstate commerce, because the subject-matter of the dealing is goods to be shipped in interstate commerce; to be carried between States and delivered from vendor to purchaser by means of interstate carriage.
But how stands the present case upon the facts stipulated? The appellants are brokers who take orders and transmit them to other States for the purchase and sale of grain or cotton upon speculation. They are, in no just sense, common carriers of messages, as are the telegraph companies. For that part of the transactions, merely speculative and followed by no actual delivery, it cannot be fairly contended that such contracts are p. 413the subject of interstate commerce; and concerning such of the contracts for purchases for future delivery, as result in actual delivery of the grain or cotton, the stipulated facts show that when the orders transmitted are received in the foreign State the property is bought in that State and there held for the purchaser. The transaction was thus closed by a contract completed and executed in the foreign State, although the orders were received from another State. When the delivery was upon a contract of sale made by the broker, the seller was at liberty to acquire the cotton in the market where the delivery was required or elsewhere. He did not contract to ship it from one State to the place of delivery in another State. And though it is stipulated that shipments were made from Alabama to the foreign State in some instances, that was not because of any contractual obligation so to do. In neither class of contracts, for sale or purchase, was there necessarily any movement of commodities in interstate traffic, because of the contracts made by the brokers.
These contracts are not, therefore, the subjects of interstate commerce, any more than in the insurance cases, where the policies are ordered and delivered in another State than that of the residence and office of the company. The delivery, when one was made, was not because of any contract obliging an interstate shipment, and the fact that the purchaser might thereafter transmit the subject-matter of purchase by means of interstate carriage did not make the contracts as made and executed the subjects of interstate commerce.
We are of the opinion that the Supreme Court of Alabama correctly held that the transactions of the plaintiffs in error were not interstate commerce, and the judgments in both cases are
Affirmed.