Iowa v. Rood, 187 U.S. 87 (1902)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Iowa v. Rood, 187 U.S. 87 (1902)
Full caption
IOWA v. ROOD.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Nov. 17, 1902
IOWA v. ROOD.
ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF IOWA.
No. 9. Argued October 14,15,1902.—Decided November 17,1902.
Where the title claimed by the State of Iowa to land formerly the bed of a lake rested solely upon the proposition that the State became vested, upon its admission into the Union, with sovereignty over the beds of all lakes within its borders, and upon the act of the General Government in meandering such lakes and excluding from its survey of public lands all such as lay beneath their waters, and the Supreme Court of the State as decided adversely to the State and in favor of one who claimed un er the act of Congress of September 28, 1850, known as the swamp an act, there is no question involving the validity of any treaty or statu e of the United States or the constitutionality of any state statute or authority which gives this court jurisdiction.
m aiticle III of the treaty with France ceding Louisiana, article IV, c ion of the Constitution of the United States, nor the act of Conwitli th admitting the State of Iowa into the Union on an equality iui « ! origiual States, has even a remote bearing upon the question of of the State of Iowa to the land beneath its lakes.
ConsKt Plaintiff in error asserts title under a clause of the Unit-ori °r an aC^ Congress, or that such act or a patent of the richt tit-i a al3Peais *n chain of title, does not constitute such a there’is ® or imniunity as to give the Federal courts jurisdiction, unless the ief«a pJausible foundation for such claim, or the title involves partv nn/UC-/°n °f the act Or the determination of the rights of the yaity under it. ° the lake«°^ g0Vemment surveyors in segregating and setting apart approval nf1 ^uestl0n by meander lines from the public lands and the was not an J*- ’SUrvey by the Commissioner of the General Land Office duly authori^udlmtlOU by the Government of the United States by its o ceis and agents, that the lake so segregated and set
apart was the property of the State of Iowa and not a part of the public domain. It was beyond the powers of a government surveyor to determine the title to such lands, or to adjudicate anything whatever upon the subject.
This was a controversy over about 800 acres of land lying in the bed of what is known as Owl Lake, in Humboldt County, Iowa. The original plaintiffs, the appellees in this case, claimed under the act of Congress of September 28, 1850, commonly known as the swamp land grant. Defendants’ position was that the lands were unsurveyed lands belonging to the national government, subject to entry under the homestead and preemption laws, under which they had made entry. The State of Iowa intervened and claimed to own the land in virtue of its right of sovereignty over the beds of all lakes meandered by the general government.
The suit was originally instituted by a petition in equity filed in the District Court of Humboldt County by Edwin 0. Rood and others against George A. Wallace and others, founded upon allegations : (1) that the lands were conveyed to the State under the swamp land act of September 28, 1850, and thence by intermediate conveyances to the plaintiff; (2) that at the date of this act the lands were in fact swamp and overflowed lands, and continued to be, until Pearsons, plaintiffs’ grantor, receive the title, marshy and unfit for cultivation, without artificia drainage. That in 1884, Pearsons began to reclaim the lan by ditches, building fences around it, and for several years use and occupied it for pasturage, and spent a large amount o money in draining, reclaiming it and making it fit for cultivation ; (3) that defendants have taken possession, and built a ca m upon the land, and are interfering with the plaintiffs in t eir use and enjoyment of it.
Wherefore an injunction was prayed. .
A demurrer to this bill was overruled and an answer fl e in general denial of the petition.
Thereupon the State of Iowa filed a petition of interven ion, alleging that the land in question was a part of the bed o w Lake, and did not constitute any part of the land whic United States government was authorized or empowere to
That the State was duly admitted into the Union in 1846, and, as a sovereign State, became the owner of all the lakes within its borders, subject to the right of the public to use the same, and that the title to the soil was in the State. That in surveying the public lands adjoining the lake the same was meandered, and the land up to the meander lines sold by the United States to different persons, and after such survey and sale the United States had no right, title or interest in any part of the lake bed, and that the same had passed to the State upon, its admission to the Union.
The petition denied that the land described was within the swampland grant, and averred that the act of the plaintiffs and their vendors in draining the said lake and drawing off the water was unlawful.
Wherefore the State prayed a decree against both plaintiffs and defendants, quieting its title to the land, and for a writ of possession removing both parties therefrom.
Defendants Wallace and others subsequently amended their answer to the effect that the lands were unsurveyed lands, subject to entry by settlers, and that defendants had entered the lands as homesteads, built houses thereon, and occupied t e same as homes. That, at the date of the swamp land act, the lands were covered by water from six to fifteen feet in epth, with well-defined shores and high banks upon the south and east sides, and navigable by ordinary steamboats.
at the lands were never swampy, and never came within e meaning of the grant as swamp and overflowed lands. And that whatever rights plaintiffs might have in the land were junior and inferior to those of defendants.
aintiffs thereupon amended their petition by averring that since the commencement of the suit the lands had been pat-State under the swamp land act of 1850; and nrnn^V116 petition of the intervenor, alleging that by the eondif- ° r r ?f the g°vernment the character, quality and nrovidfJ1]^ iSaid lands Were duly adjudicated in the manner thrnno-L, a?V’ and fhat the title of the United States passed tiffs’ n ain patents mentioned in amendments to plain-
P ition, and finally inured to the benefit of the p. 90plaintiffs, and that said patents have never been set aside nor canceled.
Testimony was taken by the plaintiffs, and a decree entered dismissing the intervenor’s petition, and quieting the title in this and several other cases involving the same facts, in the plaintiffs. On an appeal taken to the Supreme Court of Iowa, the judgment of the District Court was confirmed. 109 Iowa,
5. Whereupon the State sued out a writ of error from this court.
Mr. Charles Mullan, attorney general of the State of Iowa, for plaintiff in error.
Mr. R. M. Wright and Mr. J. P. Dolliver for defendants in error.
Me. Justice Brown, after making the foregoing statement, delivered the opinion of the court.
Motion is made to dismiss this case upon the ground that no Federal question is involved; or if there be such question, that thefe was another non-Federal question, the decision of which was sufficient to sustain the judgment, irrespective of what t e decision of the Supreme Court may have been upon sue Federal question.
1. From the foregoing abstract of the pleadings it will e seen that the title set up by the State rests solely upon te proposition that it became vested, upon its admission into * Union under the act of Congress of December 28, 1846, 9 • 117, with sovereignty over the beds of all lakes within its or ders, and by the act of the general government in mean ermg such lakes, and excluding from its survey of public lands a sue as lay beneath their waters. This clearly does not involve validity of any treaty or statute of the United States, or constitutionality of any state statute or authority, so a jurisdiction exists in this court, it must be by reason o claim of a title, right, privilege or immunity under t e on tution, or an authority exercised under the United Sta es, p. 91decision of which was against such title, right, privilege or authority.
The real question then is whether the sovereignty of the State over the beds of its inland lakes rests upon some statute or provision of the Constitution, or upon general principles of the common law which long antedated the Constitution, and had their origin in rights conceded to the Crown centuries before the severance of our relations with the mother country. If the latter, then the State must look to the decisions of this court, recognizing and defining such rights and determining how far they are inherited, first, by the United States as the successor of the Crown, and second, by the several States upon their admission into the Union. This would not involve a construction of the Constitution, nor of any title derived thereunder, but a determination of the title of the Crown to lands beneath the beds of inland lakes and of the respective rights of the States and. the general government as successors thereto.
In support of our jurisdiction the State relies (1) upon art. Ill of the treaty with France for the cession of Louisiana, 8 tat. 200, which merely provides that “ the inhabitants of the ceded territory shall be incorporated in the Union of the United tates and admitted as soon as possible, according to the principles of the Federal Constitution, to the enjoyment of all the a? ts’ advantages and immunities of citizens of the United ates, (2) the provision of the Constitution, art. IV, sec. 3, w ic merely declares, with certain immaterial qualifications, at new States may be admitted by the Congress into this tl?1^ ’ and uPon the act of Congress of 1846, admitting >e I?wa int° the Union, with the provision that it • °?. e Emitted on an equal footing with the original States ln aTU aspects whatsoever. Cou^^f ^eSe Provisions was questioned by the Supreme rp, °u °'Ta °Piniorb hut neither of them has even a tho earin& upon the question of the title of the State to bv thf a eneath its lakes. Indeed, the argument now made unon tk orney General, that the title of the State depends consistp^00^8^110-^11 ^ven this act of Congress, is quite inwit his first assignment of error upon the merits, p. 92which charges the court with error “ in not holding that the beds of all the meandered lakes and streams in the State of Iowa belong to said State in trust for the public by virtue of its sovereignty, and that this right does not depend upon any act of Congress or any grantfrom the United States. ” In other words, the State is put in the dilemma of insisting, for the purpose of sustaining the jurisdiction of this court, that the title of the State is dependent upon the proper construction of these three instruments, and, for the purpose of sustaining its case upon the merits, denying that the title depends upon either of them. This is an attempt to blow hot and cold upon the same question.
The mere fact that the plaintiff in error asserts title under a clause of the Constitution, or an act of Congress, is not in itself sufficient, unless there be at least a plausible foundation for such claim. A party may assert a right, title, privilege or immunity without even color for such assertion, and if that were alone sufficient to give this court jurisdiction, a vast number of cases might be brought here simply for delay or speculative advantage. New Orleans Waterworks Co. v. Louisiana, 185 U. S. 336?
It is equally clear that the mere fact that an act of Congress or a patent of the United States appears in a chain of title does not constitute such a right, title or immunity as gives the Federal court jurisdiction, unless such title involves the construction of the act or the determination of the rights of the party under it. De Lamar's Nevada G. N. Co. v. NesW, 177 U. S. 523.
The case of the City of New Orleans n. Armas, 9 Pet. 22, is directly in point. Plaintiffs claimed a parcel of land in t e city of New Orleans by incomplete title from the Spanish gov ernment, which was, however, confirmed under the laws oi United States and a patent issued therefor. The city claim the land as a part of a quay dedicated to the city in the orig inal plan of the town, and therefore not grantable by the kino-The state court gave judgment for the plaintiffs, which was affirmed by the Supreme Court, and the city sued out a writ o error. The court held, through Chief Justice Marshall, t a p. 93sustain its jurisdiction it must be shown that the title set up by the city was protected by the treaty ceding Louisiana to the United States (the treaty involved in this case), or by some act of Congress applicable to that title. It was held that the third article of the treaty, above quoted, did not embrace the case, and that the act of Congress admitting Louisiana into the Union, which is identical in language with the act admitting Iowa, could not be construed to give appellate jurisdiction to this court over all questions of title between citizens of Louisiana; that the case involved no principle upon which this court could take jurisdiction which would not apply to all the controversies respecting titles originating before the cession of Louisiana to the United States, and that “ it would also comprehend all controversies concerning titles in any of the new States, since they are admitted into the Union by laws expressed in similar language.” The writ of error was dismissed. This case is conclusive against the existence of a Federal question in the case under consideration.
2. We are also asked to sustain the jurisdiction of this court upon the ground that the action of the government surveyors in segregating and setting apart the lake in question by meaner lines from the public land, and the approval of such survey by the Commissioner of the General Land Office, was an a judication by the government of the United States, by its u y authorized officers and agents, that the lake so segregated an set apart was the property of the State of Iowa and not a part ot the public domain.
e do not so interpret the action of these officers. They n ou tedly did survey the lands adjoining this lake and mean- 1 ^Se^’ they determined nothing as to the title ha beneath its waters—a determination which would thn6 beyond their powers; but simply omitted Q Se. a ^rom tbe survey, and left their title to be subse-It w‘ h etermined either by state or Congressional action, er oflfh° y^°Us^ beyond the powers of a government surveyor, to aH' an<^ Office, to determine the title to these lands, or
H *7 tkCate whatever upon the subject.
e decision of the Supreme Court been adverse to the
Syllabus.
plaintiffs, who claimed title under the swamp land act, it is possible that a writ of error might have lain from this court, but we have frequently held that to sustain such writ, the decision must be adverse to a right claimed under an act of Congress, or to the exercise of an authority granted by the United States. Baker n. Baldwin, decided this term, ante, p. 61.
The writ of error must be
Dismissed.