Cartwright v. Howe, 42 U.S. (1 How.) 188 (1843)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Cartwright v. Howe, 42 U.S. (1 How.) 188 (1843)
Full caption
Elizabeth R. Cartwright, plaintiff in error, v. Alexander T. Howe, George F. Richards, and William Richards, defendants.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1843
Elizabeth R. Cartwright, plaintiff in error, v. Alex-
ander T. Howe, George F. Richards, and William Richards, defendants.
This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of the record from the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Columbia, holden in and for the county of Washington, and it having been stated by Mr. Bradley, of counsel for the defendant in error, that the matters in controversy had been agreed and settled between the parties, to which Mr. R. J. Brent, of counsel for the plaintiff in error, assented; it is thereupon now here ordered and adjudged by this court that this cause be and the same is hereby dismissed, with costs.
Bowman et al. r. Wathen et al.
*Isaac S. Bowman and George W. S. Bowman, -----
Brinker and Mary, his wife, formerly Mary Bowman, and Rebecca Bowman, by said Isaac S. and George W. S. Bowman, their next friend, the said Mary and Rebecca being infants under twenty-one YEARS OF AGE, AND ALBERT T. BURNLEY, APELlants, v. Athanasius Wathen, and the Mayor and Common Council of the City of Jeffersonville.
The doctrine laid down by Lord Camden, in the case of Smith v. Clay, 3 Brown’s Ch. Rep. in note, examined and confirmed, viz., “ That a court of equity, which never is active in relief against conscience or public convenience, has always refused its aid to stale demands, where the party has slept upon his rights for a great length of time. Nothing can call forth this court into activity but conscience, good faith, and reasonable diligence. Where these are wanting, the court is passive and does nothing; laches and neglect are always discountenanced; and therefore, from the beginning of this jurisdiction, there was always a limitation of suit in this court.”1 Also the doctrine laid down by Lord Redesdale, in Jlovenden v. Lord Annesley, 2 Sch. & L., 636, “that every new right of action, in equity, that accrues to a party, whatever it may be, must be acted upon at the utmost within twenty years.”2 And though the claimant may have been embarrasses by the frauds of others, or distressed, it is not sufficient to take the case out of the rule.3 The doctrine has also been ruled by this court, and should now be regarded as the settled law. • ... Ih this case, the complainants have so long slept upon their rights that this court must remain passive, and can do nothing; and this is equally true, . whether they knew of an adverse possession, or through negligence and a failure to look after their interests, permitted the title of another to grow into full maturity.4
This was an appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for the district of Indiana, sitting as a court of equity.
1
Applied. Maxwell v. Kennedy, successfully concealed by the trustee 8 How., 222. Followed. Wagner from the knowledge of the cestui que v. Baird, 7 How., 234. See also Ken- trust, followed. Badger n. Badger, 2 nedy v. Georgia State Bank, 8 Id., Wall., 87, 92. 586; De Lane v. Moore, 14 Id., 253. 3 A fraudulent sale took place Jan.
2
The dicta of Lord Erskine, that 1, 1836, but the fraud was not discov“no length of time can prevent the ered until January, 1840. A bill for unkennelling of a fraud,” and of Lord relief filed July 23d, 1841, was held Northington, in Alden v. Gregory, 2 not barred by lapse of time. Veazie Eden., 285: “The next question is, v. Williams, 8 How., 134, 158. But in effect, whether delay will purge a a court of equity applies the rule or , fraud? Never—while I sit here! Every laches according to its own ideas ot delay adds to its injustice and multi- right and justice. Every case is gov-plies its oppression,” controlled and erned chiefly by its own circumstances, limited; and the rule laid down by Whether the time the negligence has Story, J. in Prevost v. Gratz, 6 subsisted is sufficient to make it eiiect-Wheat., 481, that where an attempt is ual is a question to be resolved by the made to establish a stale trust on the sound discretion of the court. ground of fraud or concealment: v. County of Buena Vista,*5 Otto, iw. (1) The trust must be clearly estab- 4 See notes to McKmght v. lay tor, lished, and (2) The facts must be ante*, *161. shown to have been fraudulently and
JANUARY TERM, 1 843. 189