Pa. Gas Co. v. Pub. Serv. Comm'n, 252 U.S. 23 (1920)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
Pa. Gas Co. v. Pub. Serv. Comm'n, 252 U.S. 23 (1920)
Full caption
PENNSYLVANIA GAS COMPANY v. PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION, SECOND DISTRICT, OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, ET AL.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Mar. 1, 1920
PENNSYLVANIA GAS COMPANY v. PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION, SECOND DISTRICT, OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, ET AL.
ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK.
No. 330. Argued December 8, 9, 1919.—Decided March 1, 1920.
The transmission and sale of natural gas, produced in one State and transported and furnished directly to consumers in a city of another State by means of pipe lines from the source of supply in part laid in the city streets, is interstate commerce (p. 28); but, in the absence of any contrary regulation by Congress, is subject to local regulation of rates. P. 29. Public Utilities Commission v. Landon, 249 U. S. 236, distinguished. 225 N. Y. 397, affirmed.
Argument for Plaintiff in Error. 252 U. S.
The case is stated in the opinion.
Mr. John E. Mullin, with whom Mr. Marion H. Fisher was on the briefs, for plaintiff in error:
The State has no power to regulate the rates in question, for such action necessarily imposes a direct burden and restraint upon interstate commerce.
The State in effect proposes to meet the plaintiff in error at the state line and to deny it freedom to import for sale a legitimate commodity of commerce except at a price to be fixed by the State. Nay more, the State apparently proposes not only to restrict the right of sale, but to compel'the plaintiff in error to continue to import its Pennsylvania product for sale at the price fixed by the State. If such a regulation is not direct and substantial—if it does not restrain and burden interstate commerce, we can conceive of no action which would.
That a business is “regulated” when the return allowed on the business or the sale price of the commodity dealt in is fixed by governmental authority cannot be questioned, and such a regulation is far more substantial and burdensome than was the regulation of customers declared to be an unauthorized interference with bommeree in the Ticker Case, 247 U. S. 105, or the inspection charge declared invalid by this court in Western Oil Refg. Co. v. Lipscomb, 244 U. S. 346. It is more direct than the state license fees upon agents selling and delivering interstate merchandise declared repugnant to the Constitution in Stewart v. Michigan, 232 U. S. 665; Caldwell v. North Carolina, 187 U. S. 622, and in Rearick v. Pennsylvania, 203 U. S. 507.
The rate or price received for the transportation and supply of the natural gas is the vital part of the transaction. Short of flat prohibition, there is no way to strike more directly at the heart of a commercial transaction than to fix the price that is to be received in it. See
23. Argument for Plaintiff in Error.
The validity of state action does not rest upon the discretion or good judgment of the State, nor on the reasonableness of the regulation imposed. It depends solely on the question of power. Brown v. Maryland, 12 Wheat. 419, 439; Western Union Tel. Co. n. Kansas, 216 U. S. 1, 27; Railroad Commission v. Worthington, 225 U. S. 101, 107.
Federal functions may not be usurped under the police power, nor does the occupancy of highways by the plaintiff in error under local franchises authorize the State to regulate the price of gas moving in interstate commerce. Leisy v. Hardin, 135 U. S. 100, 108, 119-123; Lyng v. Michigan, 135 U. S. 161-166; Wabash, St. Louis & Pacific Ry. Co. v. Illinois, 118 U. S. 557.
Substantially parallel to the pipe line of the plaintiff in error, between the City of Warren, Pa., and the City of Jamestown, N. Y., an interurban trolley system is operated. This line is typical of many others, occupying city streets under local franchises. The State will hardly assert that it is able to regulate the interstate business or interstate rates of such trolley lines under the police power or because of the use of local franchises. The same rules and the same principles must be applied to the interstate business of the plaintiff in error.
This court has already held that the interstate gas business may not be regulated under the police power based on the use of highways. West v. Kansas Natural Gas Co., 221 U. S. 229. See Kansas Natural Gas Co. v. Haskell, 172 Fed. Rep. 545.
The interstate natural gas business conducted by plaintiff in error is national, not local, in character, and the proposed state regulation thereof is not local in its operation. An interstate transaction requires national control whenever it is of such character that one State cannot control it without in effect extending its regulations into another State, or in effect assuming jurisdiction over property in another State, or leaving the transaction subject to conflicting regulations of different States.
The power of a State to enforce common-law duties, or like statutory duties, of public utilities engaged in interstate commerce does not extend to prescribing rates for interstate commerce. Subjecting interstate rates to control by a state commission is not the same as enforcing the common-law duty to serve at reasonable rates.
In fixing intrastate rates, for an interstate public utility, the State has no right to take into consideration the business of the company outside of the State, or base them on the value of the property outside the State. In fixing the gas rates in question, the State necessarily regulates the rate or return for the interstate transportation of the gas, and that is beyond its power.
Mr. Ledyard P. Hale for Public Service Commission, defendant in error.
Mr. Louis L. Thrasher for City of Jamestown et al., defendants in error.
Mr. Justice Day delivered the opinion of the court.
This writ of error brings before us for consideration the question whether the Public Service Commission of the State of New York has the power to regulate rates at which natural gas shall be furnished by the Pennsylvania Gas Company, plaintiff in error, to consumers in the city of Jamestown in the State of New York. The Court of
Appeals of New York (225 N. Y. 397) held that the Commission had such authority.
The statute of the State of New York, § 65, Public Service Commission Law, Laws 1910, c. 480, provides: 11 Every gas corporation, every electrical corporation and every municipality shall furnish and provide such service, instrumentalities and facilities as shall be safe and adequate and in all respects just and reasonable. All charges made or demanded by any such gas corporation, electrical corporation or municipality for gas, electricity or any service rendered or to be rendered, shall be just and reasonable and not more than allowed by law or by order of the commission having jurisdiction. Every unjust or unreasonable charge made or demanded for gas, electricity or any such service, or in connection therewith, or in excess of that allowed by law or by the order of the commission is prohibited.”
Consumers of gas, furnished by the plaintiff in error in the city of Jamestown, New York, filed a complaint demanding a reduction of gas rates in that city. The Public Service Commission asserted its jurisdiction which, as we have said, was sustained by the Court of Appeals of New York.
The federal question presented for our consideration involves the correctness of the contention of the plaintiff in error that the authority undertaken to be exercised by the Commission, and sustained by the court, was an attempt under state authority to regulate interstate commerce, and violative of the constitutional power granted to Congress over commerce among the States. The facts are undisputed. The plaintiff in error, the Pennsylvania Gas Company, is a corporation organized under the laws of the State of Pennsylvania and engaged in transmitting and selling natural gas in the State of New York and Pennsylvania. It transports the gas by pipe-lines about fifty miles in length from the source [p. 28] of supply in the State of Pennsylvania into the State of New York. It sells and delivers gas to consumers in the city of Jamestown, in the town of Ellicott, and in the village of Falconer, all in Chautauqua County, New York. It also sells and delivers natural gas to consumers in the cities of Warren, Corry and Erie in Pennsylvania.
We think that the transmission and sale of natural gas produced in one State, transported by means of pipe-lines and directly furnished to consumers in another State, is interstate commerce within the principles of the cases already determined by this court. West v. Kansas Natural Gas Co. 221 U. S. 229; Haskell v. Kansas Natural Gas Co., 224 U. S. 217; Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Foster, 247 U. S. 105.
This case differs from Public Utilities Commission v. Landon, 249 U. S. 236, wherein we dealt with the piping of natural gas from one State to another, and its sale to independent local gas companies in the receiving State, and held that the retailing of gas by the local companies to their consumers was intrastate commerce and not a continuation of interstate commerce, although the mains of the local companies receiving and distributing the gas to local consumers were connected permanently with those of the transmitting company. Under the circumstances set forth in that case we held that the interstate movement ended when the gas passed into the local mains; that the rates to be charged by the local companies had but an indirect effect upon interstate commerce and, therefore, the matter was subject to local regulation.
In the instant case the gas is transmitted directly from the source of supply in Pennsylvania to the consumers in the cities and towns of New York and Pennsylvania, above mentioned. Its transmission is direct, and without intervention of any sort between the seller and the buyer. The transmission is continuous and single and is, in our opinion, a transmission in interstate commerce and [p. 29] therefore subject to applicable constitutional limitations which govern the States in dealing with matters of the character of the one now before us.
The general principle is well established and often asserted in the decisions of this court that the State may not directly regulate or burden interstate commerce. That subject, so far as legislative regulation is concerned, has been committed by the Constitution to the control of the Federal Congress. But while admitting this general principle, it, like others of a general nature, is subject to qualifications not inconsistent with the general rule, which now are as well established as the principle itself.
In dealing with interstate commerce it is not in some instances regarded as an infringment upon the authority delegated to Congress, to permit the States to pass laws indirectly affecting such commerce, when needed to protect or regulate matters of local interest. Such laws are operative until Congress acts under its superior authority by regulating the subject-matter for itself. In varying forms this subject has frequently been before this court. The previous cases were fully reviewed and deductions made therefrom in the Minnesota Rate Cases, 230 U. S.
352. The paramount authority of Congress over the regulation of interstate commerce was again asserted in those cases. It was nevertheless recognized that there existed in the States a permissible exercise of authority, which they might use until Congress had taken possession of the field of regulation. After stating the limitations upon state authority, of this subject, we said (p. 402): “But within these limitations there necessarily remains to the States, until Congress acts, a wide range for the permissible exercise of power appropriate to their territorial jurisdiction although interstate commerce may be affected. It extends to those matters of a local nature as to which it is impossible to derive from the constitutional grant an intention that they should go uncontrolled
Opinion of the Court. 252 U. S.
pending Federal intervention. Thus, there are certain subjects having the most obvious and direct relation to interstate commerce, which nevertheless, with the acquiescence of Congress, have been controlled by state legislation from the foundation of the Government because of the necessity that they should not remain unregulated and that their regulation should be adapted to varying local exigencies; hence, the absence of regulation by Congress in such matters has not imported that there should be no restriction but rather that the States should continue to supply the needed rules until Congress should decide to supersede them. \ . . Our system of government is a practical adjustment by which the National authority as conferred by the Constitution is maintained in its full scope without unnecessary loss of local efficiency. Where the subject is peculiarily one of local concern, and from its nature belongs to the class with which the State appropriately deals in making reasonable provision for local needs, it cannot be regarded as left to the unrestrained will of individuals because Congress has not acted, although it may have such a relation to interstate commerce as to be within the reach of the Federal power. In such case, Congress must be the judge of the necessity of Federal action. Its paramount authority always enables it to intervene at its discretion for the complete and effective government of that which has been committed to its care, and, for this purpose and to this extent, in response to a conviction of national need, to displace local laws by substituting laws of its own. The successful working of our constitutional system has thus been made possible.”
The rates of gas companies transmitting gas in interstate commerce are not only not regulated by Congress, but the Interstate Copunerce Act expressly withholds the subject from federal control. C. 309, § 7, 36 Stat. 539,544.
The thing which the State Commission has undertaken to regulate, while part of an interstate [p. 31] transmission, is local in its nature, and pertains to the furnishing of natural gas to local consumers within the city of Jamestown in the State of New York. The pipes which reach the customers served are supplied with gas directly from the main of the company which brings it into the State, nevertheless the service rendered is essentially local, and the sale of gas is by the company to local consumers who are reached by the use of the streets of the city in which the pipes are laid, and through which the gas is conducted to factories and residences as it is required for use. The service is similar to that of a local plant furnishing gas to consumers in a city.
This local service is not of that character which requires general and uniform regulation of rates by congressional action, and which has always been held beyond the power of the States, although Congress has not legislated upon the subject. While the manner in which the business is conducted is part of interstate commerce, its regulation in the distribution of gas to the local consumers is required in the public interest and has not been attempted under the superior authority of Congress.
It may be conceded that the local rates may affect the interstate business of the company. But this fact does not prevent the State from making local regulations of a reasonable character. Such regulations are always subject to the exercise of authority by Congress enabling it to exert its superior power under the commerce clause of the Constitution.
The principles announced, often reiterated in the decisions of this court, were applied in the judgment affirmed by the Court of Appeals of New York, and we agree with that court that, until the subject-matter is regulated by congressional action, the exercise of authority conferred by the State upon the Public Service Commission is not violative of the commerce clause of the Federal Constitution.
Affirmed.
Argument for Petitioner. 252 U. S.
EX PARTE IN THE MATTER OF J. RAYMOND TIFFANY, AS RECEIVER, ETC., PETITIONER.
PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS OR PROHIBITION.
No. 26, Original. Argued January 19, 1920.—Decided March 1, 1920.
Where the District Court, in a case depending on diverse citizenship, having appointed a receiver to take charge of and disburse and distribute the assets of an insolvent state corporation, permitted a receiver later appointed for the same corporation by a court of the State to intervene and, after full hearing, denied his application to vacate the federal receivership and to have the assets turned over to him upon the ground that the proceedings in the state court had deprived the District Court of jurisdiction, held, that the order of the District Court denying the application was a final decision, within the meaning of Jud. Code, § 128, appealable to the Circuit Court of Appeals. P. 36.
The words “final decision” in that section mean the same thing as “final judgments and decrees,” used in former acts regulating appellate jurisdiction. Id.
When there is a right to a writ of error or appeal, resort may not be had to mandamus or prohibition. P. 37.
Rule discharged.
The case is stated in the opinion.
Mr. Merritt Lane, with whom Mr. Dougal Herr was on the brief, for petitioner:
The order of the District Court was not appealable under § 129 of the Judicial Code.
The application of the receiver in chancery was not to dissolve the injunction but that the District Court should instruct its receiver to turn over the assets to the chancery receiver before distribution to creditors.
And if application had been made to dissolve the injunctive order contained in the order appointing the receiver it would not have been appealable under § 129.
32. Argument for Respondent.
An order refusing to vacate a receivership is not made appealable under § 129.
The action of the District Court is not appealable under § 128. That section applies only to final judgments or decrees. The opinion of the District Court in denying petitioner’s application is not appealable.
The present application is similar to that made by the petitioners in Re Metropolitan Railway Receivership, 208 U. S. 90, which this court determined on the merits.
If the award of the writ prayed for be a matter of discretion, we respectfully submit that the discretion should be exercised, because the matter involves a conflict between the federal and state courts which should ultimately be settled in some form of proceeding in this court. The applicant in fact represents the Court of Chancery of New Jersey, which in its turn represents the State in its sovereign capacity.
Moreover, before proceedings on appeal could be determined in the Circuit Court of Appeals, and in this court, the assets would be distributed and the questions involved would become merely academic.
Mr. Samuel Heyman for respondent:
The application to the District Court made by the chancery receiver was for an order dissolving the injunction issued by it against the corporation and its officers and for an order vacating the receivership. Such an order comes within § 129 of the Judicial Code.
The order was therefore appealable to the Circuit Court of Appeals under that section.
The order was also appealable under § 128 of the Judicial Code.
It totally excluded the chancery receiver from any [p. 34] participation in the estate of the defunct corporation. Upon a final distribution of the assets, he would be totally ignored and distribution would be made to creditors direct. As he claimed title to the assets under the provisions of the New Jersey Corporation Act, the order was, as to him, a final judgment depriving him of his property and under § 128 of the Judicial Code he had the right to appeal to the Circuit Court of Appeals from this order as a final judgment. Gumbel v. Pitkin, 113 U. S. 545; Savannah v. Jesup, 106 U. S. 563; Dexter Horton Bank v. Hawkins, 190 Fed. Rep. 924; s. c. 194 U. S. 631.
The writ of mandamus should not be used for the purpose of appeal and should be refused where the petitioner has other appellate relief. Ex parte Oklahoma, 220 U. S. 191; Ex parte Harding, 219 U. S. 363; In re Moore, 209 U. S. 490.
Mr. Justice Day delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an application of J. Raymond Tiffany as receiver, appointed by the Court of Chancery of New Jersey, of William Necker, Inc., for a writ of mandamus, or in the alternative a writ of prohibition, the object of which is to require the District Judge and the District Court of the United States for the District of New Jersey to order the assets of the corporation, in the hands of a federal receiver, to be turned over to applicant for administration by him as receiver appointed by the New Jersey Court of Chancery.
An order to show cause why the prayer of the petition should not be granted was issued, a return was made by the District Judge and the matter was argued and submitted. The pertinent facts are: On September 30, 1916, creditors and shareholders of William Necker, Inc., a corporation of the State of New Jersey, filed a bill in the United States District Court of New Jersey alleging the [p. 35] insolvency of the corporation, praying for the appointment of a receiver, and a distribution of the corporate assets among the creditors and shareholders. The bill alleged diversity of citizenship as a ground for jurisdiction. The defendant corporation appeared and answered, admitting the allegations of the bill, and joined in the prayer that its assets be sold and distributed according to law. Upon consent the District Court appointed a receiver. The estate is insolvent, and the assets in the hands of the federal receiver are insufficient to pay creditors, and shareholders will receive nothing. On March 28, 1919, two and one-half years after the appointment of the federal receiver, creditors of William Necker, Inc., filed a bill in the Court of Chancery of New Jersey alleging the corporation’s insolvency, praying that it be decreed to be insolvent, that an injunction issue restraining it from exercising its franchises, and that a receiver be appointed to dispose of the property, and distribute it among creditors and shareholders. A decree was entered in said cause adjudging the corporation insolvent, and appointing the petitioner, J. Raymond Tiffany, receiver. Thereupon Tiffany made application to the United States District Court asking that its injunction enjoining the corporation and all of its officers, and all other persons from interfering with the possession of the federal receiver, be dissolved; that the federal receivership be vacated, and that the federal receiver turn over the assets of the company then in his hands, less administration expenses, to the chancery receiver for final distribution,—the contention being that the appointment of the chancery receiver and the proceedings in the state court superseded the federal proceeding, and deprived the federal court of jurisdiction.
The federal receiver had made various reports and conducted the business of the corporation up until the time of the application in the Court of Chancery of New
Opinion of the Court. 252 U. 8.
Jersey, in which the applicant was appointed receiver. It appears that the applicants in the state court also filed their verified claims with the federal receiver, and that no creditor or shareholder made objection to the exercise of the jurisdiction of the federal court until the application in the state court.
The Federal District Court permitted the chancery receiver to intervene, heard the parties, and delivered an opinion in which the matter was fully considered. As a result of such hearing and consideration an order was entered in which it was recited that Tiffany, the state receiver, had made an application to the Federal District Court for an order directing it to turn over to the chancery receiver all of the assets of the corporation in the possession of the federal receiver, and the District Court ordered, adjudged and decreed that the said application of J. Raymond Tiffany, receiver in chancery “be and the same hereby is denied.”
By the Judicial Code, § 128, the Circuit Court of Appeals is given appellate jurisdiction to review by appeal or writ of error final decisions in the District Courts, with certain exceptions not necessary to be considered. It is clear that the order made in the District Court refusing to turn over the property to the chancery receiver was a final decision within the meaning of the section of the Judicial Code to which we have referred, and from which the chancery receiver had the right to appeal to the Circuit Court of Appeals. By the order the right of the state receiver to possess and administer the property of the corporation was finally denied. The words: “final decisions in the district courts” mean the same thing as “final judgments and decrees” as used in former acts regulating appellate jurisdiction. Loveland on Appellate Jurisdiction of Federal Courts, § 39. This conclusion is amply sustained by the decisions of this court. Savannah v. Jesup, 106 U. S. 563; Gumbel v. Pitkin, 113 U. S. 545;
32. Syllabus.
Krippendorf v. Hyde, 110 U. S. 276, 287. See also a well considered case in the Circuit Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit—Dexter Horton National Bank v. Hawkins, 190 Fed. Rep. 924.
It is well settled that where a party has the right to a writ of error or appeal, resort may not be had to the extraordinary writ of mandamus or prohibition. Ex parte Harding, 219 U. S. 363; Ex parte Oklahoma, 220 U. S. 191. As the petitioner had the right of appeal to the Circuit Court of Appeals he could not resort to the writ of mandamus or prohibition. It results that an order must be made discharging the rule.
Rule discharged.
SHAFFER v. CARTER, STATE AUDITOR, ET AL.
APPEALS FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF OKLAHOMA.
Nos. 531, 580. Argued December 11, 12, 1919.—Decided March 1, 1920.
When, upon application for a preliminary injunction, the District Court not only refuses the injunction but dismisses the bill, appeal to this court should be under Jud. Code, § 238, from the final decree, and not under § 266. P. 44.
Equity may be resorted to for relief against ah unconstitutional tax lien, clouding the title to real property, if there be no complete remedy at law. P. 46.
Quaere: Whether the Oklahoma laws afford an adequate legal remedy in a case where the constitutionality of the state income tax law is in question. Id.
The Oklahoma taxing laws afford no legal remedy for removing a cloud caused by an Invalid lien for an income tax. P. 48.
Having acquired jurisdiction, equity affords complete relief. Id. Governmental jurisdiction in matters of taxation depends upon the power to enforce the mandate of the State by action taken within its borders either in personam or in rem. P. 49.
Argument for Appellant. 252 U. S.
A State may tax income derived from local property and business owned and managed from without by a citizen and resident of another State (pp. 49-55): such power is consistent with Const., Art. IV, § 2, guaranteeing privileges and immunities and the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Pp. 53-56.
The constitutionality of such a tax depends on its practical operation and effect, and not on mere definitions or theoretical distinctions respecting its nature and quality. P. 54.
The fact that the Oklahoma income tax law permits residents to deduct from their gross income losses sustained without as well as those sustained within the State, while non-residents may deduct only those occurring within it, does not make the law obnoxious to the privileges and immunities clause, supra, or the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. P. 56.
Net income derived from interstate commerce is taxable under a state law providing for a general income tax. P. 57.
The Oklahoma gross production tax, imposed on oil and gas producing companies, was intended as a substitute for the ad valorem property tax, and payment of it does not relieve the producer from taxation under the state income tax law. Id.
The Constitution, including the Fourteenth Amendment, does not forbid double taxation by the States. P. 58.
Without deciding whether it would be consistent with due process to enforce a tax on the income derived by a non-resident from part of his property within a State by imposing a lien on all his property, real and personal, there situate, held, that in this case the State was justified in treating the various properties and business of a producer of oil and natural gas, who went on with their operation after the income tax law was enacted, as an entity, producing the income and subject to the lien. Id.
No. 531, appeal dismissed.
No. 580, decree affirmed.
The case is stated in the opinion.
Mr, Malcolm E. Rosser, with whom Mr. George 8. Ramsey, Mr. Edgar A. de Meules, Mr. Villard Martin and Mr. J. Berry King were on the brief, for appellant:
The tax is directed against the income as such, entirely separate from the business or property out of which it
37. Argument for Appellant.
arises. Therefore it is not an excise tax within the meaning of the Oklahoma constitution; but, even if it were, it cannot be lawfully laid unless the situs of the income is in Oklahoma.
This tax is not laid on any theory of protection but on ability to pay. Income Tax Cases, 148 Wisconsin, 456. Its very nature shows that it is directed against wealthy people. A thousand whose combined income equals appellant’s would have no income tax to pay, though their income was from the same sort of business. Appellant’s income is taxed only because it is large and is all going to one man. Appellant is not in Oklahoma; therefore the State does not protect him. It protects his property and business, but no more than if they were owned by a thousand instead of one. It gives his income, as such, no protection at all, but on the other hand seeks to diminish it merely because it is large. Appellant’s income is from a number of leases. If the income from each lease went to a different man there would be no tax. What difference can it make to Oklahoma whether it all goes to one man or not, if the recipient does not Eve.in Oklahoma? Maguire v. Tax Commissioner, 230 Massachusetts, 503; Brady v. Anderson, 240 Fed. Rep. 665.
The provisions of the law show that the tax is intended as a tax on persons rather than property. So the similar law of Wisconsin has been construed. Manitowoc Gas Co. v. Wisconsin Tax Commission, 161 Wisconsin, 111; State ex rel. Sallie F. Moon Co. v. Wisconsin Tax Commission, 166 Wisconsin, 287; U. S. Glue Co. v. Oak Creek, 161 Wisconsin, 211; s. c. 247 U. S. 321; Peck & Co. v. Lowe, 247 U. S. 165. And see Brady v. Anderson, supra.
Under the facts of this case appellant’s income is never in Oklahoma. Its situs is in Illinois. It appears that the appellant manages his business from his office in Chicago; devotes his time, energy and judgment to
Argument for Appellant. 252 U. S.
it; makes his purchases of supplies and materials, with minor exceptions, from that office, buying outside of Oklahoma and having his purchases shipped in; the contracts for the sale of oil are made by him in Chicago with non-residents of Oklahoma, and these non-residents pay him by checks drawn at their offices, outside of Oklahoma, on banks outside of that State and send the checks to him in Chicago. The actual money constituting his income is never in Oklahoma. The net income, which is all the State is attempting to tax, is never there. He does not call on the State to assist him in collecting his income, and if any of the non-residents to whom he sells oil should breach their contracts he would not call on the courts of Oklahoma for redress. Unless the income tax is a tax on the source of the income, and not on the income itself, considered as a separate entity, the subject of taxation in this case is in Chicago.
An income is not a chose in action—a mere promise or expectation. It is something already derived or received, in the hands of the owner at the time it is derived. It springs into existence when received; or if there is a difference, the money from which the income is made up is with the owner before it has taken the form of net income. The owner gets the gross proceeds, pays some expenses, and the remainder constitutes the taxable income under the Oklahoma law. There is no taxable income until the owner has received the money and paid expenses out of it.
The property or business out of which an income arises is in no way representative of the income. The value of the property, or the volume of the business, has no necessary relation to the amount of net income. A man may have property and business and lose money on both.
The income is not a chose in action but in possession and in this case, in fact as well as in law, is at the resi-
37. Argument for Appellant.
dence of the owner. The usual rule that movables follow and have their situs at the residence of the owner is in some cases a mere fiction adopted for the purpose of convenience and can be changed by the legislature when it has any jurisdiction at all. But there is a limit to this power. Situs is determined by the facts. See Adams v. Colonial &c. Mortgage Co., 82 Mississippi, 263.
It is not possible to escape the conclusion that the law is attempting to tax appellant simply because he made money in Oklahoma. The State has no jurisdiction over either his person or his income and it cannot tax his business for the reason that it is not taxing any similar business of residents, except by the gross production tax, and appellant has paid that.
Oklahoma cannot tax property not in the State. To do so would be to take property without due process of law. Inheritance taxes rest on entirely different bases. Blackstone v. Miller, 188 U. S. 189; United States v. Perkins, 163 U. S. 625; Union National Bank v. Chicago, 3 Biss. 82.
The jurisdiction of the State over incomes of non-residents is not like that of the Federal Government over incomes of aliens.
Oklahoma cannot tax the business, skill, ability and energy of appellant. Strattoris Independence v. Howbert, 231 U. S. 399. There is a difference between corporations and individuals in this regard. Adams Express Co. v. Ohio, 166 U. S. 185.
The provisions of the statute attempting to create a lien on all of appellant’s property in Oklahoma to secure payment of the income tax are void. Dewey v. Des Moines, 173 U. S. 193; City of New York v. McLean, 170 N. Y. 374.
If the tax is held to be an excise, the payment by appellant of the gross production tax required by c. 39, Laws of 1916, relieves him from liability. That chapter
Argument for Appellant. 252 U. S.
repeals the income tax law so far as the income is derived from the production of oil and gas.
If the tax is an excise, it is void because it deprives appellant of privileges and immunities enjoyed by citizens of Oklahoma, and because it denies him the equal protection of the laws and takes his property without due process of law. County of Santa Clara v. Southern Pacific R. R. Co., 18 Fed. Rep. 385; Slaughter-House Cases, 16 Wall. 36; Ward v. Maryland, 12 Wall. 418; Chalker v. Birmingham & Northwestern Ry. Co., 249 U. S. 522; Wiley v. Parmer, 14 Alabama, 627; Sprague v. Fletcher, 69 Vermont, 69.
The income tax law of Oklahoma permits residents to deduct from their gross income, not only losses within the State, but also losses from business or in any other way, sustained outside of Oklahoma. It does not permit non-residents to deduct their losses from their business outside of the State, from their profits on business carried on inside of the State. It seems to us that this question is controlled by the Slaughter-House Cases, supra; Ward v. Maryland, supra; and Southern Ry. Co. v. Greene, 216 U. S. 400. If the resident can deduct losses outside of the State while the non-resident is not permitted to do so, there is discrimination. Here there is no subject-matter to uphold the tax as a privilege unless the court shall hold that there are two distinct privileges in every business, one to run the business and another to make money out of it. An excise tax on the business of a natural person, the business being lawful, not the subject of license nor exercised through a franchise, cannot be graduated in proportion to the net profits. Flint v. Stone Tracy Co., 220 IT. S. 107, and Magoun v. Illinois Trust & Savings Bank, 170 U. S. 283, distinguished.
A great part of the net profit is earned outside of the State. There is no way to divide the profits between Oklahoma and Chicago, and Oklahoma has not at-
37. Opinion of the Court.
tempted to formulate a plan. Under any view this tax must fall. Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Kansas, 216 U. S. 1, 30.
If the tax is a privilege or excise tax it is void because it lays a burden on interstate commerce. Crew Levick Co. v. Pennsylvania, 245 U. S. 292; Postal Telegraph Cable Co. v. Adams, 155 U. S. 688, 695; Minnesota Rate Cases, 230 U. S. 352; Kansas City &c. Ry. Co. v. Kansas, 240 U. S. 227; Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Kansas, 216 U. S. 1. If the tax is considered an excise on business, rather than an income tax proper, it is not governed by U. S. Glue Co. v. Oak Creek, supra; nor by Peck & Co. v. Lowe, supra.
Mr. S. P. Freeling, Attorney General of the State of Oklahoma, and Mr. C. W. King, Assistant Attorney General of the State of Oklahoma, with whom Mr. W. R. Bleakmore, Assistant Attorney General of the State of Oklahoma, was on the brief, for appellees.
Mr. Justice Pitney delivered the opinion of the court.
These are two appeals, taken under circumstances that will be explained, from a single decree in a suit in equity brought by appellant to restrain the enforcement of a tax assessed against him for the year 1916 under the Income Tax Law of the State of Oklahoma, on the ground of the unconstitutionality of the statute.
A previous suit having the same object was brought by him in the same court against the officials then in office, in which an application for an interlocutory injunction heard before three judges pursuant to § 266, Judicial Code, was denied, one judge dissenting. Shaffer v. Howard, 250 Fed. Rep. 873. An appeal was taken to this court, but, pending its determination, the terms of office of the defendants expired, and, there being no law of the
Opinion of the Court. 252 U. S.
State authorizing a revival or continuance of the action against their successors, we reversed the decree and remanded the cause with directions to dismiss the bill for want of proper parties. 249 U. S. 200.
After such dismissal the present defendant Carter, as State Auditor, issued another tax warrant and delivered it to defendant Bruce, Sheriff of Creek County, with instructions to levy upon and sell plaintiff’s property in that county in order to collect the tax in question; and the sheriff having threatened to proceed, this suit was commenced. An application for an interlocutory injunction, heard before three judges, was denied upon the authority of the decision in 250 Fed. Rep. and of certain recent decisions of this court. The decree as entered not only disposed of the application but dismissed the action. Plaintiff, apparently unaware of this, appealed to this court under § 266, Judicial Code, from the refusal of the temporary injunction. Shortly afterwards he took an appeal under § 238, Judicial Code, from the same decree as a final decree dismissing the action. The latter appeal is in accord with correct practice, since the denial of the interlocutory application was merged in the final decree. The first appeal (No. 531) will be dismissed.
The constitution of Oklahoma, besides providing for the annual taxation of all property in the State upon an ad valorem basis, authorizes (Art. 10, § 12) the employment of a variety of other means for raising revenue, among them income taxes.
The act in question is c. 164 of the Laws of 1915. Its first section reads as follows: “Each and every person in this State, shall be liable to an annual tax upon the entire net income of such person arising or accruing from all sources during the preceding calendar year, and a like tax shall be levied, assessed, collected and paid annuafiy upon the entire net income from all property owned, and of every business, trade or profession carried on in this
State by persons residing elsewhere.” Subsequent sections define what the term “income” shall include; prescribe how net income shall be computed; provide for certain deductions; prescribe varying rates of tax for all taxable incomes in excess of $3,000, this amount being deducted (by way of exemption) from the income of each individual, and for one living with spouse an additional $1,000, with further deductions where there are children or dependents, exemptions being the same for residents and non-residents; require (§ 2) a return on or before March first from each person liable for an income tax under the provisions of the act for the preceding calendar year; provide (§ 9) that the State Auditor shall revise returns and hear and determine complaints, with power to correct and adjust the assessment of income; that (§ 10) taxes shall become delinquent if not paid on or before the first day of July, and the State Auditor shall have power to issue to any sheriff of the State a warrant commanding him to levy the amount upon the personal property of the delinquent party; and (by § 11) “If any of the taxes herein levied become delinquent, they shall become a lien on all the property, personal and real, of such delinquent person, and shall be subject to the same penalties and provisions as are all ad valorem taxes.”
Plaintiff, a non-resident of Oklahoma, being a citizen of Illinois and a resident of Chicago in that State, was at the time of the commencement of the suit and for several years theretofore (including the years 1915 and 1916) engaged in the oil business in Oklahoma, having purchased, owned, developed, and operated a number of oil and gas mining leases, and being the owner in fee of certain oil-producing land, in that State. From properties thus owned and operated during the year 1916 he received a net income exceeding $1,500,000, and of this he made, under protest, a return which showed that, [p. 46] at the rates fixed by the act, there was due to the State an income tax in excess of $76,000. The then State Auditor overruled the protest and assessed a tax in accordance with the return; the present Auditor has put it in due course of collection; and plaintiff resists its enforcement upon the ground that the act, in so far as it subjects the incomes of non-residents to the payment of such a tax, takes their property without due process of law and denies to them the equal protection of the laws, in contravention of § 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment; burdens interstate commerce, in contravention of the commerce clause of § 8 of Art. I of the Constitution; and discriminates against non-residents in favor of residents, and thus deprives plaintiff and other non-residents of the privileges and immunities of citizens and residents of the State of Oklahoma, in violation of § 2 of Art. IV. He also insists that the lien attempted to be imposed upon his property pursuant to § 11 for taxes assessed upon income not arising out of the same property would deprive him of property without due process of law.
As ground for resorting to equity, the bill alleges that plaintiff is the owner of various oil and gas mining leases covering lands in Creek County, Oklahoma, and that the lien asserted thereon by virtue of the levy and tax warrant creates a cloud upon his title. This entitles him to bring suit in equity (Union Pacific Ry. Co. v. Cheyenne, 113 U. 8. 516, 525; Pacific Express Co. v. Seibert, 142 U. S. 339, 348; Ogden City v. Armstrong, 168 U. 8. 224, 237; Ohio Tax Cases, 232 U. 8. 576, 587; Greene v. Louisville & Interurban R. R. Co., 244 U. 8. 499, 506), unless the contention that he has a plain, adequate, and complete remedy at law be well founded.
This contention is based, first, upon the provision of § 9 of c. 164, giving to the State Auditor the same power to correct and adjust an assessment of income that is given to the county board of equalization in cases of ad
SHAFFER v. CARTER. ***
valorem assessments, taken in connection with c. 107 of the Laws of 1915, which provides (Art. 1, Subdiv. B, § 2, p. 147) for an appeal from that board to the district court of the county. In a recent decision (Berryhill v. Carter, 76 Oklahoma, 248), the Supreme Court of the State held that an aggrieved income taxpayer may have an appeal under this section, and that thus “all matters complained of may be reviewed and adjusted to the extent that justice may demand.” But the case related to “correcting and adjusting an income tax return,” and the decision merely established the appeal to the district court as the appropriate remedy, rather than an application to the Supreme Court for a writ of certiorari. It falls short of indicating—to say nothing of plainly showing—that this procedure would afford an adequate remedy to a party contending that the income tax law itself was repugnant to the Constitution of the United States.
Secondly, reference is made to § 7 of Subdiv. B, Art. 1, of c. 107, Oklahoma Laws 1915, p. 149, wherein it is provided that where illegality of a tax is alleged to arise by reason of some action from which the laws provide no appeal, the aggrieved person on paying the tax may give notice to the officer collecting it, stating the grounds of complaint and that suit will be brought against him; whereupon it is made the duty of such officer to hold the tax until the final determination of such suit if brought within thirty days; and if it be determined that the tax was illegally collected, the officer is to repay the amount found to be in excess of the legal and correct amount. But this section is one of several that have particular reference to the procedure for collecting ad valorem taxes; and they are prefaced by this statement (p. 147): “Subdivision B. To the existing provisions of law relating to the ad valorem or direct system of taxation the following provisions are added:” Upon this ground, in Gipsy [p. 48] Oil Co. v. Howard and companion suits brought by certain oil-producing companies to restrain enforcement of taxes authorized by the gross production tax law (Sess. Laws 1916, c. 39, p. 102), upon the ground that they were an unlawful imposition upon federal instrumentalities, the United States District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma held that the legal remedy provided in § 7 of c. 107 applied only to ad valorem taxes, and did not constitute a bar to equitable relief against the production taxes. Defendants appealed to this court, and assigned this ruling for error, inter alia; but they did not press the point, and the decrees were affirmed upon the merits of the federal question. Howard v. Gipsy Oil Co., 247 U. S. 503.
We deem it unnecessary to pursue further the question whether either of the statutory provisions referred to furnishes an adequate legal remedy against income taxes assessed under an unconstitutional law, since one of the grounds of complaint in the present case is that, even if the tax itself be valid, the procedure prescribed by § 11 of the Income Tax Law for enforcing such a tax by imposing a lien upon the taxpayer’s entire property, as threatened to be put into effect against plaintiff’s property for taxes not assessed against the property itself and not confined to the income that proceeded from the same property, is not “due process of law,” within the requirement of the Fourteenth Amendment. For removal of a cloud upon title caused by an invalid lien imposed for a tax valid in itself, there appears to be no legal remedy. Hence, on this ground at least, resort was properly had to equity for relief; and since a court of equity does not “do justice by halves,” and will prevent, if possible, a multiplicity of suits, the jurisdiction extends to the disposition of all questions raised by the bill. Camp v. Boyd, 229 U. S. 530, 551-552; McGowan v. Parish, 237 U. S. 285, 296.
This brings us to the merits.
Under the “due process' of law” provision appellant makes two contentions: first, that the State is without jurisdiction to levy a tax upon the income of non-residents; and, secondly, that the lien is invalid because imposed upon all his property real and personal, without regard to its relation to the production of his income.
These are separate questions, and will be so treated. The tax might be valid, although the measures adopted for enforcing it were not. Governmental jurisdiction in matters of taxation, as in the exercise of the judicial function, depends upon the power to enforce the mandate of the State by action taken within its borders, either in personam or in rem according to the circumstances of the case, as by arrest of the person, seizure of goods or lands, garnishment of credits, sequestration of rents and profits, forfeiture of franchise, or the like; and the jurisdiction to act remains even though all permissible measures be not resorted to. Michigan Trust Co. v. Ferry, 228 U. S. 346, 353; Ex parte Indiana Transportation Co., 244 U. S. 456, 457.
It will be convenient to postpone the question of the lien until all questions as to the validity of the tax have been disposed of.
The contention that a State is without jurisdiction to impose a tax upon the income of non-residents, while raised in the present case, was more emphasized in Travis v. Yale & Towne Mfg. Co., decided this day, post, 60, involving the income tax law of the State of New York. There it was contended, in substance, that while a State may tax the property of a non-resident situate within its borders, or may tax the incomes of its own citizens and residents because of the privileges they enjoy under its constitution and laws and the protection they receive from the State, yet a non-resident, although conducting a business or carrying on an occupation there, cannot [p. 50] be required through income taxation to contribute to the governmental expenses of the State whence his income is derived; that an income tax, as against non-residents, is not only not a property tax but is not an excise or privilege tax, since no privilege is granted; the right of the non-citizen to carry on his business or occupation in the taking State being derived, it is said, from the provisions of the Federal Constitution.
This radical contention is easily answered by reference to fundamental principles. In our system of government the States have general dominion, and, saving as restricted by particular provisions of the Federal Constitution, complete dominion over all persons, property, and business transactions within their borders; they assume and perform the duty of preserving and protecting all such persons, property, and business, and, in consequence, have the power normally pertaining to governments to resort to all reasonable forms of taxation in order to defray the governmental expenses. Certainly they are not restricted to property taxation, nor to any particular form of excises. In well-ordered society, property has value chiefly for what it is capable of producing, and the activities of mankind are devoted largely to making recurrent gains from the use and development of property, from tillage, mining, manufacture, from the employment of human skill and labor, or from a combination of some of these; gains capable of being devoted to their own support, and the surplus accumulated as an increase of capital. That the State, from whose laws property and business and industry derive the protection and security without which production and gainful occupation would be impossible, is debarred from exacting a share of those gains in the form of income taxes for the support of the government, is a proposition so wholly inconsistent with fundamental principles as to be refuted by its mere statement. That it may tax the land but not the crop, the tree but not the
SHAFFER v. CARTER. 51
fruit, the mine or well but not the product, the business but not the profit derived from it, is wholly inadmissible.
Income taxes are a recognized method of distributing the burdens of government, favored because requiring contributions from those who realize current pecuniary benefits under the protection of the government, and because the tax may be readily proportioned to their ability to pay. Taxes of this character were imposed by several of the States at or shortly after the adoption of the Federal Constitution. New York Laws 1778, c. 17; Report of Oliver Wolcott, Jr., Secretary of the Treasury, to 4th Cong., 2d sess. (1796), concerning Direct Taxes; American State Papers, 1 Finance, 423, 427, 429, 437, 439.
The rights of the several States to exercise the widest liberty with respect to the imposition of internal taxes always has been recognized in the decisions of this court. In McCulloch v. Maryland, 4 Wheat. 316, while denying their power to impose a tax upon any of the operations of the Federal Government, Mr. Chief Justice Marshall, speaking for the court, conceded (pp. 428-429) that the States have full power to tax their own people and their own property, and also that the power is not confined to the people and property of a State, but may be exercised upon every object brought within its jurisdiction; saying: “It is obvious, that it is an incident of sovereignty, and is co-extensive with that to which it is an incident. All subjects over which the sovereign power of a State extends, are objects of taxation,” etc. In Michigan Central R. R. Co. v. Powers, 201 U. S. 245, the court, by Mr. Justice Brewer, said (pp. 292, 293): “We have had frequent occasion to consider questions of state taxation in the fight of the Federal Constitution, and the scope and limits of National interference are well settled. There is no general supervision on the part of the Nation over state taxation, and in respect to the latter the State has, speaking generally, the freedom of a sovereign both as to [p. 52] objects and methods.” That a State may tax callings and occupations as well as persons and property has long been recognized. “The power of taxation, however vast in its character and searching in its extent, is necessarily limited to subjects within the jurisdiction of the State. These subjects are persons, property, and business. ... It [taxation] may touch business in the almost infinite forms in which it is conducted, in professions, in commerce, in manufactures, and in transportation. Unless restrained by provisions of the Federal Constitution, the power of the State as to the mode, form, and extent of taxation is unlimited, where the subjects to which it applies are within her jurisdiction.” State Tax on Foreign-Held Bonds, 15 Wall. 300, 319. See also Welton v. Missouri, 91 U. S. 275, 278; Armour & Co. v. Virginia, 246 U. S. 1, 6; American Mfg. Co. v. St. Louis, 250 U. S. 459, 463.
And we deem it clear, upon principle as well as authority, that just as a State may impose general income taxes upon its own citizens and residents whose persons are subject to its control, it may, as a necessary consequence, levy a duty of like character, and not more onerous in its effect, upon incomes accruing to non-residents from their property or business within the State, or their occupations carried on therein; enforcing payment, so far as it can, by the exercise of a just control over persons and property within its borders. This is consonant with numerous decisions of this court sustaining state taxation of credits due to non-residents, New Orleans v. Stempel, 175 U. S. 309, 320, et seq.; Bristol v. Washington County, 177 U. S. 133, 145; Liverpool &c. Ins. Co. v. Orleans Assessors, 221 U. S. 346, 354; and sustaining federal taxation of the income of an alien non-resident derived from securities held in this country, De Ganay v. Lederer, 250 U. S. 376.
That a State, consistently with the Federal Constitution, may not prohibit the citizens of other States from carrying on legitimate business within its borders like its own [p. 53] citizens, of course is granted; but it does not follow that the business of non-residents may not be required to make a ratable contribution in taxes for the support of the government. On the contrary, the very fact that a citizen of one State has the right to hold property or carry on an occupation or business in another is a very reasonable ground for subjecting such non-resident, although not personally yet to the extent of his property held, or his occupation or business carried on therein, to a duty to pay taxes not more onerous in effect than those imposed under like circumstances upon citizens of the latter State. Section 2 of Art. IV of the Constitution entitles him to the privileges and immunities of a citizen, but no more; not to an entire immunity from taxation, nor to any preferential treatment as compared with resident citizens. It protects him against discriminatory taxation, but gives him no right to be favored by discrimination or exemption. See Ward v. Maryland, 12 Wall. 418, 430.
Oklahoma has assumed no power to tax non-residents with respect to income derived from property or business beyond the borders of the State. The first section of the act, while imposing a tax upon inhabitants with respect to their entire net income arising from all sources, confines the tax upon non-residents to their net income from property owned and business, etc., carried on within the State. A similar distinction has been observed in our federal income tax laws, from one of the earliest down to the present.1 The Acts of 1861 (12 Stat. 309) and 1864 (13 Stat. [p. 54] 281,417) confined the tax to persons residing in the United States and citizens residing abroad. But in 1806 (14 Stat. 137-138) there was inserted by amendment the following: “And a like tax shall be levied, collected, and paid annually upon the gains, profits, and income of every business, trade, or profession carried on in the United States by persons residing without the United States, not citizens thereof.” Similar provisions were embodied in the Acts of 1870 and 1894; and in the Act of 1913 (38 Stat. 166), after a clause imposing a tax upon the entire net income arising or accruing from all sources (with exceptions not material here) to every citizen of the United States, whether residing at home or abroad, and to every person residing in the United States though not a citizen thereof, the following appears: “and a like tax shall be assessed, levied, collected, and paid annually upon the entire net income from all property owned and of every business, trade, or profession carried on in the United States by persons residing elsewhere.” Evidently this furnished the model for § 1 of the Oklahoma statute.
1
Acts of August 5,1861, c. 45, § 49,12 Stat. 292,309; June 30,1864, c. 173, § 116,13 Stat. 223,281; July 4,1864, Joint Res. 77,13 Stat. 417; July 13, 1866, c. 184, § 9, 14 Stat. 98, 137-138; March 2, 1867, c. 169, § 13,14 Stat. 471, 477-478; July 14,1870, c. 255, § 6,16 Stat. 256, 257; August 27, 1894, c, 349, § 27,28 Stat. 509, 553; October 3,1913, c. 16, § II, A. Subd. 1, 38 Stat. 114, 166; September 8, 1916, c. 463, Title I, Part I, § 1, a, 39 Stat. 756; October 3,1917, c. 63, Title I, §§ 1 and 2, 40 Stat. 300; February 24,1919, c. 18, §§ 210,213 (c), 40 Stat. 1057,1062, 1066.
No doubt is suggested (the former requirement of apportionment having been removed by constitutional amendment) as to the power of Congress thus to impose taxes upon incomes produced within the borders of the United States or arising from sources located therein, even though the income accrues to a non-resident alien. And, so far as the question of jurisdiction is concerned, the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment imposes no greater restriction in this regard upon the several States than the corresponding clause of the Fifth Amendment imposes upon the United States.
It is insisted, however, both by appellant in this case and by the opponents of the New York law in Travis v. Yale & Towne Mfg. Co., that an income tax is in its nature a personal tax, or a “subjective tax imposing personal liability upon the recipient of the income;” and that as to a [p. 55] non-resident the State has no jurisdiction to impose such a liability. This argument, upon analysis, resolves itself into a mere question of definitions, and has no legitimate bearing upon any question raised under the Federal Constitution. For, where the question is whether a state taxing law contravenes rights secured by that instrument, the decision must depend not upon any mere question of form, construction, or definition, but upon the practical operation and effect of the tax imposed. St. Louis Southwestern Ry. Co. v. Arkansas, 235 U. S. 350, 362; Mountain Timber Co. v. Washington, 243 U. S. 219, 237; Crew Levick Co. v. Pennsylvania, 245 U. S. 292, 294; American Mfg. Co. v. St. Louis, 250 U. 8. 459, 463. The practical burden of a tax imposed upon the net income derived by a non-resident from a business carried on within the State certainly is no greater than that of a tax upon the conduct of the business, and this the State has the lawful power to impose, as we have seen.
The fact that it required the personal skill and management of appellant to bring his income from producing property in Oklahoma to fruition, and that his management was exerted from his place of business in another State, did not deprive Oklahoma of jurisdiction to tax the income which arose within its own borders. The personal element cannot, by any fiction, oust the jurisdiction of the State within which the income actually arises and whose authority over it operates in rem. At most, there might be a question whether the value of the service of management rendered from without the State ought not to be allowed as an expense incurred in producing the income; but no such question is raised in the present case, hence we express no opinion upon it.
The contention that the act deprives appellant and others similarly circumstanced of the privileges and immunities enjoyed by residents and citizens of the State of Oklahoma, in violation of § 2 of Art. IV of the [p. 56] Constitution, is based upon two grounds, which are relied upon as showing also a violation of the “equal protection” clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
One of the rights intended to be secured by the former provision is that a citizen of one State may remove to and carry on business in another without being subjected in property or person to taxes more onerous than the citizens of the latter State are subjected to. Paul v. Virginia, 8 Wall. 168, 180; Ward v. Maryland, 12 Wall. 418, 430; Maxwell v. Bugbee, 250 U. S. 525, 537. The judge who dissented in Shaffer v. Howard, 250 Fed. Rep. 873, 883, concluded that the Oklahoma income tax law offended in this regard, upon the ground (p. 888) that since the tax is as to citizens of Oklahoma a purely personal tax measured by their incomes, while as applied to a non-resident it is “essentially a tax upon his property and business within the State, to which the property and business of citizens and residents of the State are not subjected,” there was a discrimination against the non-resident. We are unable to accept this reasoning. It errs in paying too much regard to theoretical distinctions and too little to the practical effect and operation of the respective taxes as levied; in failing to observe that in effect citizens and residents of the State are subjected at least to the same burden as non-residents, and perhaps to a greater, since the tax imposed upon the former includes all income derived from their property and business within the State and, in addition, any income they may derive from outside sources.
Appellant contends that there is a denial to non-citizens of the privileges and immunities to which they are entitled, and also a denial of the equal protection of the laws, in that the act permits residents to deduct from their gross income not only losses incurred within the State of Oklahoma but also those, sustained outside of that State, while non-residents may deduct only those incurred within the
SHAFFER v. CARTER. 57
State. The difference, however, is only such as arises naturally from the extent of the jurisdiction of the State in the two classes of cases, and cannot be regarded as an unfriendly or unreasonable discrimination. As to residents it may, and does, exert its taxing power over their income from all sources, whether within or without the State, and it accords to them a corresponding privilege of deducting their losses, wherever these accrue. As to non-residents, the jurisdiction extends only to their property owned within the State and their business, trade, or profession carried on therein, and the tax is only on such income as is derived from those sources. Hence there is no obligation to accord to them a deduction by reason of losses elsewhere incurred. It may be remarked, in passing, that there is no showing that appellant has sustained such losses, and so he is not entitled to raise this question.
It is urged that, regarding the tax as imposed upon the business conducted within the State, it amounts in the case of appellant’s business to a burden upon interstate commerce, because the products of his oil operations are shipped out of the State. Assuming that it fairly appears that his method of business constitutes interstate commerce, it is sufficient to say that the tax is imposed not upon the gross receipts, as in Crew Levick Co. v. Pennsylvania, 245 U. S. 292, but only upon the net proceeds, and is plainly sustainable even if it includes net gains from interstate commerce. U. 8. Glue Co. v. Oak Creek, 247 U. S. 321. Compare Peck & Co. v. Lowe, 247 U. S. 165.
Reference is made to the gross production tax law of 1915 (c. 107, Art. 2, Subdiv. A, § 1; Sess. Laws 1915, p. 151), as amended by c. 39 of Sess. Laws 1916 (p. 104), under which every person or corporation engaged in producing oil or natural gas within the State is required to pay a tax equal to 3 per centum of the gross value of such product in lieu of all taxes imposed by the State, counties, or municipalities upon the land or the leases, mining rights, [p. 58] and privileges, and the machinery, appliances, and equipment, pertaining to such production. It is contended that payment of the gross production tax relieves the producer from the payment of the income tax. This is a question of state law, upon which no controlling decision by the Supreme Court of the State is cited. We overrule the contention, deeming it clear, as a matter of construction, that the gross production tax was intended as a substitute for the ad valorem property tax but not for the income tax, and that there is no such repugnance between it and the income tax as to produce a repeal by implication. Nor, even if the effect of this is akin to double taxation, can it be regarded as obnoxious to the Federal Constitution for that reason, since it is settled that nothing in that instrument or in the Fourteenth Amendment prevents the States from imposing double taxation, or any other form of unequal taxation, so long as the inequality is not based upon arbitrary distinctions. St. Louis Southwestern Ry. Co. v. Arkansas, 235 U. S. 350, 367-368.
The contention that there is a want of due process in the proceedings for enforcement of the tax, especially in the hen imposed by § 11 upon all of the delinquent’s property, real and personal, reduces itself to this: that the State is without power to create a Hen upon any property of a non-resident for income taxes except the very property from which the income proceeded; or, putting it in another way, that a lien for an income tax may not be imposed upon a non-resident’s unproductive property, nor upon any particular productive property beyond the amount of the tax upon the income that has proceeded from it.
But the facts of the case do not raise this question. It clearly appears from the averments of the bill that the whole of plaintiff’s property in the State of Oklahoma consists of oil-producing land, oil and gas mining leaseholds, and other property used in the production of oil and gas; and that, beginning at least as early as the year 1915,
37. Dissent.
when the act was passed, and continuing without interruption until the time of the commencement of the suit (April 16, 1919), he was engaged in the business of developing and operating these properties for the production of oil, his entire business in that and other States was managed as one business, and his entire net income in the State for the year 1916 was derived from that business. Laying aside the probability that from time to time there may have been changes arising from purchases, new leases, sales, and expirations (none of which, however, is set forth in the bill), it is evident that the lien will rest upon the same property interests which were the source of the income upon which the tax was imposed. The entire jurisdiction of the State over appellant’s property and business and the income that he derived from them—the only jurisdiction that it has sought to assert—is a jurisdiction in rem; and we are clear that the State acted within its lawful power in treating his property interests and business as having both unity and continuity. Its purpose to impose income taxes was declared in its own constitution, and the precise nature of the tax and the measures to be taken for enforcing it were plainly set forth in the Act of 1915; and plaintiff having thereafter proceeded, with notice of this law, to manage the property and conduct the business out of which proceeded the income now taxed, the State did not exceed its power or authority in treating his property interests and his business as a single entity, and enforcing payment of the tax by the imposition of a lien, to be followed by execution or other appropriate process, upon all property employed in the business.
No. 531. Appeal dismissed. No. 580. Decree affirmed.
Mr. Justice McReynolds dissents.
Syllabus. 252 U. S.
TRAVIS, AS COMPTROLLER OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, ,v. YALE & TOWNE MANUFACTURING COMPANY.
APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK.
Nos. 548. Argued December 15, 16, 1919.—Decided March 1, 1920.
Shaffer v. Carter, ante, 37, followed, to the effect that a State may tax incomes of non-residents arising within her borders and that there is no unconstitutional discrimination against non-residents in confining the deductions allowed them for expenses, losses, etc., to such as are connected with income so arising while allowing residents, taxed on their income generally, to make such deductions without regard to locality. P. 75.
Such a tax may be enforced as to non-residents working within the State by requiring their employers to withhold and pay it from their salaries or wages; and no unconstitutional discrimination against such non-residents results from omitting such a requirement in the case of residents. P. 76.
A regulation requiring that the tax be thus withheld is not unreasonable as applied to a sister-state corporation carrying on local business without any contract limiting the regulatory power of the taxing State; nor is the power to impose such a regulation affected by the fact that the corporation may find it more convenient to pay its employees and keep its accounts in the State of its origin and principal place of business. Id.
The terms “resident” and “citizen” are not synonymous, but a general taxing scheme of a State which discriminates against all non-residents necessarily includes in the discrimination those who are citizens of other States. P. 78.
A general tax laid by a State on the incomes of residents and non-residents, which allows exemptions to the residents, with increases for married persons and for dependents, but allows no equivalent exemptions to non-residents, operates to abridge the privileges and immunities of citizens of other States, in violation of § 2 of Art. IV, of the Constitution. P. 79.
Held, that such a discrimination in the income tax law of New York is
60. Argument for Appellant.
not overcome by a provision excluding from the taxable income of non-residents annuities, interest and dividends not part of income from a local business, or occupation, etc., subject to the tax. P. 81. An abridgment by one State of the privileges and immunities of the citizens of other States cannot be condoned by those States or cured by retaliation. P. 82. 262 Fed. Rep. 576, affirmed.
The case is stated in the opinion.
Mr. James S. Y. Ivins and Mr. Jerome L. Cheney, with whom Mr. Charles D. Newton, Attorney General of the State of New York, and Mr. E. C. Aiken were on the brief, for appellant:
It might be argued that an income tax is sui generis—neither a tax on property, on a privilege, nor on the person—but a tax on the right to receive income (JPeck & Co. v. Lowe, 247 U. S. 165); or it might be argued that it is a commutation tax or a composite tax. As a composite tax it might be said that in so far as it taxes the rent from real property it is a real property tax; in so far as it is a tax on the increased value of personalty, it is a personal property tax; in so far as it is a tax on the profits from the purchase and sale of property, it is an excise on sales or on commerce; in so far as it is a tax on income from trade, profession or labor, it is a privilege tax; and in so far as it taxes residents on income from sources without the territorial jurisdiction of the sovereign, it is a pure personal tax. The characterization of a tax by administrative officers, by the phraseology of the statute, or the opinion of other courts, is not controlling. This court will look only at the practical effect of the tax as it is enforced. Crew Levick Co. v. Pennsylvania, 245 U. S. 292, 294.
It is obvious that the tax on residents and non-residents is the same, regardless of the different phraseology, so far as both are taxed. In so far as the tax extends to income of residents from sources without the State,
Argument for Appellant. 252 U. S.
there is no similar tax upon non-residents, but that is nothing for the latter to complain of. It really does not matter whether this tax be regarded (so far as non-residents are concerned) as direct or indirect, a tax on the person, on property, or on privilege. States can and do levy all three kinds. The only question is whether the State has power to enforce this tax, and its nature does not assist in determining that question.
Whether or not sovereign power to enforce a tax exists, depends solely on the ability of the State to collect it without extending its jurisdiction beyond its territorial boundaries. The sovereign can levy taxes on property which is tangible and within its boundaries, by its physical possession of that property. It can enforce taxes on privileges or rights, through preventing their exercise within its boundaries by those who do not pay. It can extend personal taxes to those over whom it has personal jurisdiction, compelling them to submit or move out. This inherent power in the sovereign extends equally to residents and to non-residents, to citizens and to aliens. Duer v. Small, 4 Blatchf. 263. It exists in each of the States except as restricted by the Federal Constitution. State Tax on Foreign-Held Bonds, 15 Wall. 300, 319.
With the exception of matters prohibited by the Constitution specifically (such as exports, or interstate commerce), or impliedly (such as the activities of the national government), there is no doubt of the right of the State to tax anything which is within its territorial jurisdiction. The only constitutional questions that ordinarily arise in respect to modern taxation are (1) those of the situs of intangibles, (2) those of the equal application of taxing statutes under Art. IV of Constitution and the Fourteenth Amendment, and (3) those of due process of law.
The question of the right to impose a tax on incomes of non-residents is not a question of the nature of the tax nor is it a question of whether income is property or
TRAVIS v. YALE & TOWNE MFG. CO. 63
60. Argument for Appellant.
the acquisition of it a right or a privilege; but it is a question of the situs of the income. The doctrine that movable property follows the person for purposes of taxation has given way to the doctrine that where property has a situs, there it is taxable. Bristol v. Washington County, 177 U. S. 133.
The reason for regarding the situs of intangible property as the domicile of the person depends not on the meaning of property, but on the meaning of situs. That property is said to be taxable only at its situs is because where property is taxable—that is, wherever a sovereign can enforce a tax against it—there it has a situs. In determining whether income has a situs for purposes of taxation in a given State, we should begin, not by saying: “Where is its situs? ” that we may determine whether it is taxable, but rather: 1 ‘ Can it be reached by taxation?-” to determine whether it has a situs there. If it can be reached by taxation by a State—if the State can enforce a tax against it by due process of law—then it has a situs for taxation in that State. See State Tax on Foreign-Held Bonds, supra; Fidelity & Columbia Trust Co. v. Louisville, 245 IT. S. 54; Kirtland v. Hotchkiss, 100 U. S. 491; Tappan v. Merchants’ National Bank, 19 Wall. 490; Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. New Orleans, 205 IT. S. 395; Liverpool &c. Ins. Co. v. Orleans Assessors, 221 IT. S. 346, 355; Blackstone v. Miller, 188 IT. S. 189; New Orleans v. Stempel, 175 IT. S. 309; Board of Assessors v. Comptoir National, 191 IT. S. 388; Rogers v. Hennepin County, 240 IT. S. 184, 191.
A person receives income in one of three ways: It is
(1) the product of property, or the money realized by the sale of such product, (2) the profit gained in the purchase and sale of property, or (3) the compensation for personal service. In each of these cases the State has power to enforce its taxes equally against residents and against non-residents. •
Argument for Appellant. 252 U. 8.
The New York law does not deny to citizens of any State any of the privileges or immunities of citizens of the several States. Citizens of other States, as citizens, and only as such, are protected by Art. IV, § 2, cl. 1. So, if there is no discrimination against them as citizens, the provision is not violated. Distinctions are drawn between residents and non-residents, but this is regardless of citizenship—non-resident citizens of New York are treated like all other non-residents, and citizens of other sovereigns who are resident in New York are treated exactly like resident citizens. The term “ reside ” in the Fourteenth Amendment probably means to “be domiciled ”; or to “maintain a voting residence.” It does not mean to “have a place of abode,”—especially if one has several places of abode. • The terms resident and citizen are not normally synonymous and are not rendered exclusively so by the use in the Fourteenth Amendment of the word “resident” in one of its many meanings. La Tourette v. McMaster, 248 U. S. 465, 470. It is settled that where residence is a proper basis for classification, the adoption of such basis is not violative of Art. IV, §2, cl. 1. Travellers’ Ins. Co. v. Connecticut, 185 U. S. 364; Frost v. Brisbin, 19 Wend. 11; Chemung Canal Bank v. Lowery, 93 U. S. 72, 76; Field v. Barber Asphalt Paving Co., 194 U. S. 618; Central Loan & Trust Co. v. Campbell Commission Co., 173 U. S. 84; Blake v. McClung, 172 U. S. 239, 256, 257.
This classification may discriminate between classes in rates of taxation, Magoun v. Illinois Trust & Savings Bank, 170 U. S. 283; Michigan Central R. R. Co. v. Powers, 201 U. S. 245; or in exemptions from taxation,
60. Argument for Appellant.
Beers v. Glynn, 211 U. S. 477; Bell’s Gap R. R. Co. v. Pennsylvania, 134 U. S. 232, 237; Citizens’ Telephone Co. v. Fuller, 229 U. S. 322, 329. A taxing statute is not invalid because of simple inequality between classes. International Harvester Co. v. Missouri, 234 U. S. 199, 210. It would seem that the only restriction on the power of classification is that there must be real differences between the situations of the different classes. Northwestern Mutual Life Ins. Co. v. Wisconsin, 247 U. S. 132, 138. What constitutes a real difference depends upon the purpose and extent of the legislation and all the circumstances of the subjects and objects thereof. Tanner v. Little, 240 U. S. 369, 382, 383.
The classification of residents and non-residents by the New York law is reasonable. La Tourette v. McMaster, supra; Northwestern Mutual Life Ins. Co. v. Wisconsin, supra. Travellers’ Ins. Co. v. Connecticut, supra, is directly in point.
If the power to levy a tax exists, the rate fixed will not render it unconstitutional. Tanner v. Little, supra. The power to exempt certain things to the exclusion of others follows the same rules as the power to tax certain things, to the exclusion of others—it is only another way of stating the same proposition. And if the rate is immaterial in determining constitutionality as to taxation, so the rate of exemption is immaterial.
The different methods of collection provided by the statute for the tax on income received by way of compensation for personal services by residents and by non-residents, does not deprive any person of the equal protection of laws. St. John v. New York, 201 U. S. 633, 637. There are many decided cases in which different methods of procedure against residents and against non-residents have been upheld. Tappan v. Merchants’ National Bank, supra, 505; District of Columbia v. Brooke, 214 U. S. 138; Central Loan & Trust Co. v. Campbell Commission Co.,
Argument for Appellee. 252 U. S.
supra, 84, 97, 98. Many statutes taxing corporate shares and requiring the corporation to withhold at the source against non-residents but not against residents have been upheld. Travellers’ Ins. Co. v. Connecticut, supra; Merchants’ & Manufacturers’ Bank v. Pennsylvania, 167 U. S. 461, 463.
The law does not deny due process of law; violate the commerce clause; or impair the obligation of contracts.
Mr. Louis H. Porter and Mr. Archibald Cox for appellee:
The appellee’s factory and principal place of business is in Connecticut. It is authorized to do business in New York and owns property there, but it is a citizen and resident of Connecticut; and the statute, of course, applies equally to an individual in its position. It employs sundry persons, including citizens and residents of Connecticut and New Jersey, to work for it, and has contracted to pay them definite salaries for their services. These salaries are paid in different ways, in some instances by checks mailed from the office in Connecticut to the employees outside the State of New York, if that is material. And they are in accordance with contracts of employment entered into before the enactment of the law. The statute seeks to impose on the appellee a personal liability as the means of compelling it to obey.
The invalidity of the provisions for withholding the tax from the salaries seems to be directly established by New York, Lake Erie & Western R. R. Co. v. Pennsylvania, 153 U. S. 628.
A corporation, by securing authority to transact business within a State, does not thereby bring within the jurisdiction of that State transactions and properties wholly outside. It is not a matter of convenient collection, but a matter of jurisdiction. Distinguishing: Hatch v. Reardon, 204 IT. S. 152; Merchants’ & Manufacturers’ Bank v. Pennsylvania, 167 U. S. 461; Travellers’ Ins. Co.
60. Argument for Appellee.
To determine the constitutionality of this tax, it is accordingly necessary to ascertain, not colloquially but from a jurisdictional standpoint, what is taxed, and whether that is within the jurisdiction of the State of New York.
The tax is a subjective tax imposing personal liability upon the person receiving the “net income” which merely measures the burden imposed on the taxpayer in personam. Brady v. Anderson, 240 Fed. Rep. 665; State ex rel. Sallie F. Moon Co. v. Wisconsin Tax Commission, 166 Wisconsin, 287; Income Tax Cases, 148 Wisconsin, 456.
The liability is measured with reference to the net balance. And that net, from the year’s experience, is used only as a measure of the general financial condition of the individual and his personal liability to pay from any resources he can control.
Even the amount of the tax varies according to the person of the recipient, and is not based upon the property or amount thereof. Thus, if the amount of income is twenty thousand dollars, it is taxed at one rate when received by one person, at another rate when received by two persons, and it is free from tax when received by twenty persons. This tax is not even measured strictly by the amount of income which a person receives. It is measured with a view to securing equality of sacrifice among taxpayers. Income Tax Cases, 148 Wisconsin, 456. And that the tax is personal is confirmed by the provisions for its collection, none of which sound in rem and all of which impose personal liability. That a tax with respect to “net incomes” is a personal tax, from the point of view of jurisdiction similar to a poll tax, is well indicated in Maguire v. Tax Commissioner, 230 Massachusetts, 503. Individual income as such, dissociated from the person of the owner, has no existence and is a purely fanciful conception.
Argument for Appellee. 252 U. S.
A statute imposing a personal tax on persons over whom the State has no jurisdiction conflicts with the Fourteenth Amendment and is a taking of property without due process of law. United States v. Erie Ry. Co., 106 U. S. 327; Railroad Co. v. Collector, 100 U. S. 595; Dewey v. Des Moines, 173 U. S. 193; City of New York v. McLean, 170 N. Y. 374; Barhyte v. Shepard, 35 N. Y. 237. The text writers are unanimous in this limitation on the taxing power of the States. Cooley, Taxation, 3d ed., p. 24; Brown, Jurisdiction of Courts, 2d ed., pp. 549, 550. See State v. Ross, 23 N. J. L. 517, 521. The source of the income does not in any respect change the nature and character of the tax imposed upon the recipient, and it is as much beyond the power of the State to impose such a personal tax upon a non-resident as it is to impose a capitation tax on him. If the State has not jurisdiction to impose a personal liability for tax on a non-resident, it is immaterial whether that non-resident is engaging in an occupation in the State from which he derives a large income or not. So, also if the State has the jurisdiction to impose a tax, it is immaterial whether the non-resident’s occupation in the State is gainful in money or in health or in pleasure. The State either has or has not the jurisdiction to impose a personal liability against a non-resident for the payment of taxes. The situation here presented in its inevitable effect upon the integrity of the Union is of the same character as that considered by this court in Crandall v. Nevada, 6 Wall. 35. See Robbins v. Shelby County Taxing District, 120 U. S. 489.
The argument that it is fair that a citizen of Connecticut earning his income in New York should pay a tax to that State for the protection afforded him therein is political and legislative rather than judicial. If this argument can be properly considered by the court, it must be weighed against the mischievous effects upon the integrity of the Union and from this standpoint the tax in question would
60. Argument for Appellee.
seem inconsistent with the very spirit of the Constitution. The provisions of the statute here cannot be sustained as a tax on property.
A “net income” under this statute is but a measure of the condition of the person receiving and enjoying it. A debt of ten thousand dollars may be paid to one person or to ten, but remains a fixed measurable amount. Ten thousand dollars paid in gross salaries means nothing as to the net income of the recipients without consideration of their number and personality. Ten thousand dollars in salaries paid to a number of recipients may after the computation yield an aggregate of net incomes entirely different from that which it yields if paid to one. The personal condition of the recipient, and not the amount or character of the payment made, constitutes and determines the fact of net income. It seems, therefore; impossible to conceive a net income for purposes of this taxation separate and distinct from the person receiving it.
The laws of New York do not create, give validity to, or affect, the income of appellee’s non-resident employees. They are employed and paid in Connecticut, whose laws govern the contract of employment and whose courts enforce the contract. The services rendered are not income. The services are performed in whole or in part in New York. The net income never has any existence in New York. The gross salary here is not owing by, or to, anyone in New York. The fact that the appellee can legally transact business in New York obviously makes no difference in the situs of the obligation.
Moreover, property to be taxable in a State must have some permanency there, and not be merely temporarily within the State. Ayer & Lord Tie Co. v. Kentucky, 202 U. S. 409; Buck v. Beach, 206 U. S. 392; Union Refrigerator Transit Co. v. Kentucky, 199 U. S. 194.
In each of those cases such as Tappan v. Merchants1 National Bank, 10 Wall. 490, where a tax has been sus-
Argument for Appellee. 252 U. S.
tamed on property of a non-resident, there were present two factors which have been universally recognized as essential to jurisdiction—(1) some definite and specific property in existence, (2) having in a real sense a situs in the taxing State. State Tax on Foreign-Held Bonds, 15 Wall. 300; Board of Assessors v. New York Life Ins. Co., 216 U. S. 517; Hawley v. Malden, 232 U. S. 1; Fidelity & Columbia Trust Co. v. Louisville, 245 U. S. 54; Southern Pacific Co. v. Kentucky, 222 U. S. 63.
The cases in which the courts have held that choses in action may acquire a situs different from the residence of the owner are not in point. A chose in action has not yet been paid. The debtor has only promised to pay it, and its value depends on the promise of the debtor. The actual money to pay the chose in action is in the State where he resides. Furthermore, the income tax is not assessed upon all money that comes to the recipient. It is only after the net amount has been determined after deducting from the gross receipts certain allowable expenses by way of deductions that the taxable amount is determined. Before that amount is determined and before any assessment can be laid thereon, most of the income, both gross and net, has been expended. The theory of a property tax is that it is a lien on the property taxed. Obviously the State cannot lawfully impose a tax lien upon property which is not itself in existence. The proposition is necessarily a contradiction in terms. De Ganay v. Lederer, 250 U. S. 376, distinguished.
The distinction between a tax on the income from property and a tax on the income from occupations and professions was clearly pointed out in Pollock v. Farmers1 Loan & Trust Co., 158 U. S. 635, 637. The distinction between the rights of the citizens of the several States, which are assured by the Constitution, and those of foreigners, who may be completely excluded from the United States, is pointed out in United States v. Bennett,
60. Argument for Appellee.
The provisions of the statute taxing non-residents cannot be sustained as imposing a privilege or license tax; nor on the theory that the State of New York has in fact power to collect the tax. It is not going too far to say that in every case in which this court has held unconstitutional a state law imposing a tax on persons or property outside its jurisdiction, the'State had power to enforce the tax, because otherwise the case would not have been brought. Board of Assessors v. New York Life Ins. Co., supra; New York, Lake Erie & Western R. R. Co. v. Pennsylvania, supra; Morgan v. Parham, 16 Wall. 471; Louisville &c. Ferry Co. v. Kentucky, 188 U. S. 385.
As between nations, the proposition that power to collect is the test of right to tax may be correct. Just as foreigners may be completely excluded from the United States {United States v. Bennett, supra), so anything that the United States can in fact seize it may perhaps tax. But the power of the individual States of the Union is limited by the Federal Constitution.
The tax on non-residents cannot be sustained on any theory that the State of New York protects their net income.
The provisions of the statute taxing non-residents are unconstitutional because they discriminate against citizens and residents of Connecticut and New Jersey. A materially higher tax is imposed on non-residents than upon residents.
The provisions operating to discriminate against appellee’s non-resident employees conflict with § 2 of Art. IV of the Constitution and the privileges and immunities clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. A statute which in fact operates to defeat rights secured by the Constitution cannot be justified by invoking
Opinion of the Court. 252 U. S.
the necessity of classification in taxation or by the fact that the words of the Constitution do not appear in the statute. Chalker v. Birmingham & Northwestern Ry. Co., 249 U. S. 522.
There is no relevancy in cases where the State is dealing with a privilege which it may grant or withhold, such as those relating to foreign corporations doing business in the State, or succession taxes, or the nation’s treatment of foreigners, because they do not deal with discrimination against persons having rights secured by the Constitution. La Tourette v. McMaster, 248 U. S. 465; People v. Weaver, 100 U. S. 539; Sprague v. Fletcher, 69 Vermont, 69.
Mr. John W. Griggs, by leave of court, filed a brief as amicus curiae.
Mr. Laurence Arnold Tanzer, Mr. William P. Burr, Mr. William S. Rann and Mr. William J. Wallin, by leave of court, filed a brief as amid curiae.
Mr. Justice Pitney delivered the opinion of the court.
This was a suit in equity, brought in the District Court by appellee against appellant as Comptroller of the State of New York to obtain an injunction restraining the enforcement of the Income Tax Law of that State (c. 627, Laws 1919) as against complainant, upon the ground of its repugnance to the Constitution of the United States because violating the interstate commerce clause, impairing the obligation of contracts, depriving citizens of the States of Connecticut and New Jersey employed by complainant of the privileges and immunities enjoyed by citizens of the State of New York, depriving complainant and its non-resident employees of their
60. Opinion of the Court.
property without due process of law, and denying to such employees the equal protection of the laws. A motion to dismiss the bill—equivalent to a demurrer—was denied upon the ground that the act violated § 2 of Art. IV of the Constitution by discriminating against non-residents in the exemptions allowed from taxable income; an answer was filed, raising no question of fact; in due course there was a final decree in favor of complainant; and defendant took an appeal to this court under § 238, Judicial Code.
The act (§ 351) imposes an annual tax upon every resident of the State with respect to his net income as defined in the act, at specified rates, and provides also: “A like'tax is hereby imposed and shall be levied, collected and paid annually, at the rates specified in this section, upon and with respect to the entire net income as herein defined, except as hereinafter provided, from all property owned and from every business, trade, profession or occupation carried on in this state by natural persons not residents of the state.” Section 359 defines gross income, and contains this paragraph: “3. In the case of taxpayers other than residents, gross income includes only the gross income from sources within the state, but shall not include annuities, interest on bank deposits, interest on bonds, notes or other interest-bearing obligations or dividends from corporations, except to the extent to which the same shall be a part of income from any business, trade, profession or occupation carried on in this state subject to taxation under this article.” In § 360 provision is made for deducting in the computation of net income expenses, taxes, losses, depreciation charges, etc.; but, by paragraph 11 of the same section, uIn the case of a taxpayer other than a resident of the state the deductions allowed in this section shall be allowed only if, and to the extent that, they are connected with income arising from sources within the state; . . .” By [p. 74] § 362, certain exemptions are allowed to any resident individual taxpayer, viz., in the case of a single person a personal exemption of $1,000, in the case of the head of a family or a married person living with husband or wife, $2,000; and $200 additional for each dependent person under 18 years of age or mentally or physically defective. The next section reads as follows: “§ 363. Credit for taxes in case of taxpayers other than residents of the state. Whenever a taxpayer other than a resident of the state has become liable to income tax to the state or country where he resides upon his net income for the taxable year, derived from sources within this stat£ and subject to taxation under this article, the comptroller shall credit the amount of income tax payable by him under this article with such proportion of the tax so payable by him to the state or country where he resides as his income subject to taxation under this article bears to his entire income upon which the tax so payable to such other state or country was imposed; provided that such credit shall be allowed only if the laws of said state or country grant a substantially similar credit to residents of this state subject to income tax under such laws. ” Section 366 in terms requires that every “withholding agent” (including employers) shall deduct and withhold 2 per centum from all salaries, wages, etc., payable to non-residents, where the amount paid to any individual equals or exceeds $1,000 in the year, and shall pay the tax to the Comptroller. This applies to a resident employee, also, unless he files a certificate showing his residence address within the State.
Complainant, a Connecticut corporation doing business in New York and elsewhere, has employees who are residents some of Connecticut others of New Jersey but are occupied in whole or in part in complainant’s business in New York. Many of them have annual salaries or fixed compensation exceeding $1,000 per year, and the [p. 75] amount required by the act to be withheld by complainant from the salaries of such non-resident employees is in excess of $3,000 per year. Most of these persons are engaged under term contracts calling for stipulated wages or salaries for a specified period.
The bill sets up that defendant, as Comptroller of the State of New York, threatens to enforce the provisions of the statute against complainant, requires it to deduct and withhold from the salaries and wages payable to its employees residing in Connecticut or New Jersey and citizens of those States respectively, engaged in whole or in part in complainant’s business in the State of New York, the taxes provided in the statute, and threatens to enforce against complainant the penalties provided by the act if it fails to do so; that the act is unconstitutional for the reasons above specified; and that if complainant does withhold the taxes as required it will be subjected to many actions by its employees for reimbursement of the sums so withheld. No question is made about complainant’s right to resort to equity for relief; hence we come at once to the constitutional questions.
That the State of New York has jurisdiction to impose a tax of this kind upon the incomes of non-residents arising from any business, trade, profession, or occupation carried on within its borders, enforcing payment so far as it can by the exercise of a just control over persons and property within the State, as by garnishment of credits (of which the withholding provision of the New York law is the practical equivalent); and that such a tax, so enforced, does not violate the due process of law provision of the Fourteenth Amendment, is settled by our decision in Shaffer v. Carter, this day announced, ante, 37, involving the income tax law of the State of Oklahoma. That there is no unconstitutional discrimination against citizens of other States in confining the deduction of expenses, losses, etc., in the case of non-resident taxpayers, to such as are
Opinion of the Court. 252 U. S.
connected with income arising from sources within the taxing State, likewise is settled by that decision.
It is not here asserted that the tax is a burden upon interstate commerce; the point having been abandoned in this court.
The contention that an unconstitutional discrimination against non-citizens arises out of the provision of § 366 confining the withholding at source to the income of non-residents is unsubstantial. That provision does not in any wise increase the burden of the tax upon non-residents, but merely recognizes the fact that as to them the State imposes no personal liability, and hence adopts a convenient substitute for it. See Bell’s Gap R. R. Co. v. Pennsylvania, 134 U. S. 232, 239.
Nor has complainant on its own account any just ground of complaint by reason of being required to adjust its system of accounting and paying salaries and wages to the extent required to fulfill the duty of deducting and withholding the tax. This cannot be deemed an unreasonable regulation of its conduct of business in New York. New York, Lake Erie & Western R. R. Co. v. Pennsylvania, 153 U. S. 628, cited in behalf of complainant, is not in point. In that case the State of Pennsylvania granted to a railroad company organized under the laws of New York and having its principal place of business in that State the right to construct a portion of its road through Pennsylvania, upon prescribed terms which were assented to and complied with by the company and were deemed to constitute a contract, not subject to impairment or modification through subsequent legislation by the State of Pennsylvania except to the extent of establishing reasonable regulations touching the management of the business done and the property owned by the company in that State, not materially interfering with or obstructing the substantial enjoyment of the rights previously granted. Afterwards, Pennsylvania undertook by statute to [p. 77] require the company, when making payment of coupons upon bonds previously issued by it, payable at its office in the City of New York, to withhold taxes assessed by the State of Pennsylvania against residents of that State because of ownership of such bonds. The coupons were payable to bearer, and when they were presented for payment it was practically impossible for the company to ascertain who were the real owners, or whether they were owned by the same parties who owned the bonds. The statute was held to be an unreasonable regulation and hence to amount to an impairment of the obligation of the contract.
In the case at bar complainant, although it is a Connecticut corporation and has its principal place of business in that State, is exercising the privilege of carrying on business in the State of New York without any contract limiting the State’s power of regulation. The taxes required to be withheld are payable with respect to that portion only of the salaries of its employees which is earned within the State of New York. It might pay such salaries, or this portion of them, at its place of business in New York; and the fact that it may be more convenient to pay them in Connecticut is not sufficient to deprive the State of New York of the right to impose such a regulation. It is true complainant asserts that the act impairs the obligation of contracts between it and its employees; but there is no averment that any such contract made before the passage of the act required the wages or salaries to be paid in the State of Connecticut, or contained other provisions in anywise conflicting with the requirement of withholding.
The District Court, not passing upon the above questions, held that the act, in granting to residents exemptions denied to non-residents, violated the provision of § 2 of Art. IV of the Federal Constitution: “The Citizens of each State shall be entitled to all Privileges and Immunities of Citizens in the several States”; and, [p. 78] notwithstanding the elaborate and ingenious argument submitted by appellant to the contrary, we are constrained to affirm the ruling.
The purpose of the provision came under consideration in Paul v. Virginia, 8 Wall. 168, 180, where the court, speaking by Mr. Justice Field, said: “It was undoubtedly the object of the clause in question to place the citizens of each State upon the same footing with citizens of other States, so far as the advantages resulting from citizenship in those States are concerned. It relieves them from the disabilities of alienage in other States; it inhibits discriminating legislation against them by other States; it gives them the right of free ingress into other States, and egress from them; it insures to them in other States the same freedom possessed by the citizens of those States in the acquisition and enjoyment of property and in the pursuit of happiness; and it secures to them in other States the equal protection of their laws. It has been justly said that no provision in the Constitution has tended so strongly to constitute the citizens of the United States one people as this.” And in Ward v. Maryland, 12 Wall. 418, holding a discriminatory state tax upon non-resident traders to be void, the court, by Mr. Justice Clifford, said (p. 430): “Beyond doubt those words [privileges and immunities] are words of very comprehensive meaning, but it will be sufficient to say that the clause plainly and unmistakably secures and protects the right of a citizen of one State to pass into any other State of the Union for the purpose of engaging in lawful commerce, trade, or business without molestation; to acquire personal property; to take and hold real estate; to maintain actions in the courts of the State; and to be exempt from any higher taxes or excises than are imposed by the State upon its own citizens.”
Of course the terms “resident” and “citizen” are not synonymous, and in some cases the distinction is important
(La Tourette v. McMaster, 248 U. S. 465, 470); but a general taxing scheme such as the one under consideration, if it discriminates against all non-residents, has the necessary effect of including in the discrimination those who are citizens of other States; and, if there be no reasonable ground for the diversity of treatment, it abridges the privileges and immunities to which such citizens are entitled. In Blake v. McClung, 172 U. S. 239, 247; 176 U. S. 59, 67, the court held that a statute of Tennessee, declaring the terms upon which a foreign corporation might carry on business and hold property in that State, which gave to its creditors residing in Tennessee priority over all creditors residing elsewhere, without special reference to whether they were citizens or not, must be regarded as contravening the “ privileges and immunities” clause.
The nature and effect of the crucial discrimination in the present case are manifest. Section 362, in the case of residents, exempts from taxation $1,000 of the income of a single person, $2,000 in the case of a married person, and $200 additional for each dependent. A non-resident taxpayer has no similar exemption; but by § 363, if liable to an income tax in his own State, including income derived from sources within New York and subject to taxation under this act, he is entitled to a credit upon the income tax otherwise payable to the State of New York by the same proportion of the tax payable to the State of his residence as his income subject to taxation by the New York Act bears to his entire income taxed in his own State; “provided that such credit shall be allowed only if the laws of said state . . . grant a substantially similar credit to residents of this state subject to income tax under such laws.”1
1
Reading the statute literally, there would appear to be an additional discrimination against non-residents in that under § 366 the “withholding agent” (employer) is required to withhold 2 per cent, from all salaries, wages, etc., payable to any individual non-resident residents (indeed, upon non-residents likewise, so far as this section goes), is only one per centum upon the first $10,000 of net income. It is said, howeyer, that the discrepancy arose through an amendment made to § 351 while the bill was pending in the legislature, no corresponding amendment having been made in § 366. In view of this, and taking the whole of the act together, the Attorney General has advised the Comptroller that § 366 requires withholding of only one per centum upon the first $10,000 of income. And the Comptroller has issued regulations to that effect. Hence we treat the discrepancy as if it did not exist.
In the concrete, the particular incidence of the discrimination is upon citizens of Connecticut and New Jersey, neither of which States has an income tax law. A considerable number of complainant’s employees, residents and citizens of one or the other of those States, spend their working time at its office in the city of New York, and earn their salaries there. The case is typical; it being a matter of common knowledge that from necessity, due to the geographical situation of that city, in close proximity to the neighboring States, many thousands of men and women, residents and citizens of those States, go daily from their homes to the city and earn their livelihood there. They pursue their several occupations side by side with residents of the State of New York—in effect competing with them as to wages, salaries, and other terms of employment. Whether they must pay a tax upon the first $1,000 or $2,000 of income, while their associates and competitors who reside in New York do not, makes a substantial difference. Under the circumstances as disclosed, we are unable to find adequate ground for the discrimination, and are constrained to hold that it is an unwarranted denial to the citizens of Connecticut and New Jersey of the privileges and immunities enjoyed by citizens of New York. This is not a case of occasional or accidental inequality due to circumstances personal to the taxpayer (see Amoskeag
amounting to $1,000 or more in the year; whereas by § 351 the tax upon [p. 81] Savings Bank v. Purdy, 231 U. S. 373, 393-394; Maxwell v. Bugbee, 250 U. S. 525, 543); but a general rule, operating to the disadvantage of all non-residents including those who are citizens of the neighboring States, and favoring all residents including those who are citizens of the taxing State.
It cannot be deemed to be counterbalanced by the provision of par. 3 of § 359 which excludes from the income of non-resident taxpayers “annuities, interest on bank deposits, interest on bonds, notes or other interest-bearing obligations or dividends from corporations, except to the extent to which the same shall be a part of income from any business, trade, profession or occupation carried on in this state subject to taxation under this article.” This provision is not so conditioned as probably to benefit non-residents to a degree corresponding to the discrimination against them; it seems to have been designed rather (as is avowed in appellant’s brief) to preserve the preeminence of New York City as a financial center.
Nor can the discrimination be upheld, as is attempted to be done, upon the theory that non-residents have untaxed income derived from sources in their home States or elsewhere outside of the State of New York, corresponding to the amount upon which residents of that State are exempt from taxation under this act. The discrimination is not conditioned upon the existence of such untaxed income; and it would be rash to assume that non-residents taxable in New York under this law, as a class, are receiving additional income from outside sources equivalent to the amount of the exemptions that are accorded to citizens of New York and denied to them.
In the brief submitted by the Attorney General of New York in behalf of appellant, it is said that the framers of the act, in embodying in it the provision for unequal treatment of the residents of other States with [p. 82] respect to the exemptions, looked forward to the speedy adoption of an income tax by the adjoining States; in which event, injustice to their citizens on the part of New York could be avoided by providing similar exemptions similarly conditioned. This, however, is’ wholly speculative; New York has no authority to legislate for the adjoining States; and we must pass upon its statute with respect to its effect and operation in the existing situation. But besides, in view of the provisions of the Constitution of the United States, a discrimination by the State of New York against the citizens of adjoining States would not be cured were those States to establish like discriminations against citizens of the State of New York. A State may not barter away the right, conferred upon its citizens by the Constitution of the United States, to enjoy the privileges and immunities of citizens when they go into other States. Nor can discrimination be corrected by retaliation; to prevent this was one of the chief ends sought to be accomplished by the adoption of the Constitution.
Decree affirmed.
Mr. Justice McReynolds concurs in the result.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access