United States v. Bank of the Metropolis, 40 U.S. (15 Pet.) 377 (1841)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
United States v. Bank of the Metropolis, 40 U.S. (15 Pet.) 377 (1841)
Full caption
United States, Plaintiffs in error, v. The Bank of the Metropolis, Defendant in error.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1841
*United States, Plaintiffs in error, v. The Bank of the Metropolis, Defendant in error.
Bills of exchange.—Acceptance—Condition.—Estoppel.—Treasury department.
The United States instituted a suit against the Bank of the Metropolis, claiming $27,881.57, the balance, according to the statements of the treasury, due to the United States ; the defendant claimed credits amounting to $23,000, exclusive of interest, which had been presented to the proper accounting officers, for acceptances of the post-office department of the drafts of mail-contractors, and an item of $611.52, over-draft of an officer of the post-office department, on the Bank of Metropolis. The drafts of the contractors, accepted by the post-office department, were discounted by the bank, in the way of business; one draft was accepted unconditionally; the other drafts were accepted, “ on condition, that the contracts be complied with Held, that the bank became the holder of the draft, unconditionally accepted, for valuable consideration ; and its right to charge the United States with the amount cannot be defeated by any equities between the drawers and the post-office.
When the United States, by its authorized officer, become a party to negotiable paper, they have all the rights, and incur all the responsibilities, of individuals who are parties to such instruments ; there is no differenct, except that the United States cannot be sued. But if the United States sue, and the defendant holds its negotiable paper, the amount of it may be claimed as a credit, if, after being presented, it has been disallowed by the accounting officers of the treasury ; and if the liability of the United States on it be not discharged by some of those causes which discharge a party to commercial paper, it should be allowed by a jury as a credit against, a debt claimed by the United States; this is the privilege of the defendant for all equivalent credits, under the act of March 3d, 1797. United States v. Dunn, 6 Pet. 51, cited. From the daily, and almost unavoidable, use of commercial paper by the United States, they are as much interested as the community at large can be, in maintaining the principles of commercial law involved in this case.
It was no matter, how the account of the drawer of the draft, unconditionally accepted, stood with the post-office department whether he was a debtor or a creditor; whether the bank knew one or the other; an unconditional acceptance was tendered to the bank for discount; it was not the duty of the bank to inquire, how the account stood, or for what purpose the acceptance was made; all it had to look to was, the genuineness of the acceptance, and the authority of the officer to give it.1 The rule is, that the want of consideration between the drawer and the acceptor is no defence against the rights of a third party, who has given a consideration for the bill; and this, even though the acceptor has been defrauded by the drawee, if that be not known to such third party.
If one purpose making a conditional acceptance only, and commit that acceptance to writing, he *3'781 should be careful to express the condition therein ; he cannot use general *terms, and
J then exempt himself from liability, by relying upon particular facts which have already happened, though they are connected with the conditional acceptance. By express terms, the acceptor might have guarded against any construction, other than that which was intended by, or was the apparent meaning of the words of, the acceptance; it matters not what the acceptor meant by a cautious and precise phraseology, if it be not expressed as a condition.
Nothing out of the condition expressed in the words of the acceptance can be inferred; unless it be in a case where the words used are so ambiguous as to make it necessary that parol evidence should be resorted to, to explain them.
It must be conceded, as a general principle, that one having knowledge of particular facts upo>, which he intends to rely, to exempt him from a pecuniary obligation about to be contracted with another, of which facts the other is ignorant, and can only learn from him, or from documents in his keeping, that the fact of his knowledge raises the obligation to tell it.
If two persons deal in relation to the executory contract of a third, and one of them, being the obligee, induces the other to advance money, “ upon condition that his contracts be complied with,” and he knows that forfeitures have been already incurred by the obligor, for breaches of his contract, and does not say so; he will not be permitted, afterwards, to get rid of his p. 241liability, by saying, “ I cannot pay you, for when I accepted, there was already due to me from the drawer of the bill, more than I accepted for; you did not chose to make inquiry.”
1
See the case of the Floyd Acceptances, 7 Wall. 666.
The terms “ accepted, when the contracts of the drawer of the bill are complied with,” are not retroactive ; they do not refer to past transactions, but to the subsequent performance of the contractors.
The postmaster-general has the same power, and no more, over the credits allowed by his predecessor, if allowed within the scope of his official authority, as given by law to the head of the department; this right in an incumbent of reviewing a predecessor’s decisions, extends to mistakes in matters of fact, arising froin errors in calculation, and to cases of rejected claims, in which material testimony is afterwards discovered and produced. But if a credit has been given, or an allowance made, by the head of a department, and it is alleged to be an illegal allowance, the judicial tribunals must be resorted to, to construe the law under which the allowance was made ; and to settle the right between the United States, and the party to whom the credit was given ; it is no longer a case between one officer’s judgment, and that of his successor. No statute is necessary to authorize the United States to sue in such a case ; the right to sue is independent of statute, and it may be done by the direction of the incumbent of the department.
It is certainly the treasury of the United States, where its money is directed by law to be kept; but if those whose duty it is to disburse appropriations made by law, employ, or are permitted by law to employ, either for safe-keeping or more convenient disbursement, other agencies, and it shall be necessary for the United States to sue for the recovery of the fund, the defendant may claim against the demand for which the action has been brought, any credits to which he shall prove himself entitled, if they have been previously presented to the proper accounting officers of the treasury department, and have been rejected; this right was early given to defendants, in all suits brought by the United States.
When any instructions to the jury are asked of the court, on the trial of a cause, they should be precise and certain to a particular intent, that the point intended to be *raised may be distinctly seen by the court; and that error, if one be made, may be distinctly assigned. L
Error to the Circuit Court of the District of Columbia and county of Washington. The United States, on the 25th of June 1838, instituted an action of assumpsit against the President and Directors of the Bank of the Metropolis, for the recovery of $27,881.50, for sundry matters properly chargeable in an account, as by an account annexed to the declaration appeared. The declaration contained the usual counts in an action of assumpsit.
The account referred to contained numerous items of deposits made in the Bank of the Metropolis, from the post-office department, leaving a balance due to the United States of the sum stated in the declaration. The defendants pleaded the general issue.
The defence to the claim of the United States, was founded on credits which amounted to $23,000, exclusive of interest, which had been presented to the accounting officers of the treasury, and which had been refused allowance. They were for acceptances of the post-office department of drafts drawn upon the post-office department, and an over-draft by E. F. Brown, an agent of the post-office department. The jury found a verdict for the defendant, and certified that there was due from the United States to the bank, $3371.94, with interest from March 6th, 1838.
The plaintiffs, on the trial, asked the court to give certain instructions to the jury, which was refused, to which the plaintiffs excepted. These are stated in the opinion of the court. The United States prosecuted this writ of error to the judgment of the circuit court, entered on the verdict. The case is fully stated in the arguments of the counsel, and in the opinion of the court.
The case was argued by Gilpin, Attorney-General, for the United States ; and by Coxe, for the defendant.
Gilpin, Attorney-General, for the United States.—In the year 1836, the * - Bank of the Metropolis was a depositary *of public moneys, which
J were in the treasury of the United States. On the 2d July, an act of congress (5 U. S. Stat. 80) was passed, ordering that all the public revenue derived from postages should be deposited, when collected, “ in the treasury of the United States,” as the rest of the revenue was; and that it should be there held by the treasurer, to pay such appropriations as might be directed by congress “ for the service of the post-office department.” On the 16th July, deposits were made, under this act, in the Bank of the Metropolis ; and when they were so made, written instructions were given by the postmaster-general, and acceded to by the bank, that the post-office revenue, as deposited, was to be kept in the name ef the “ treasurer of the United States for the service of the post-office department ; ” to be paid on his warrants, to be reported monthly, and settled quarterly, with him ; and that il there was to be no credit, deduction or set-off admitted, except for moneys drawn out on the treasurer’s warrant.” At the monthly return of 1st October 1837, there was a balance of revenue deposited to the credit of the treasurer of the United States of 842,171.88. During that month, the deposit was increased by the sum of 81317.57, and warrants of the treasurer, amounting to 816,132.88, were paid; thus leaving a balance to the treasurer of 827,356.57. Instead of reporting this balance on the 1st November 1837, the bank admitted a balance only of 81031.97, having deducted therefrom the amount, with interest, of a draft for 810,000, drawn on the 14th April 1835, at ninety days, by Edwin Porter, on Richard C. Mason, treasurer of the post-office department,” and accepted by him, as “ treasurer ; ” and also of four drafts for 813,000, drawn in October 1835, at ninety days, by James Reeside, on Amos Kendall, postmaster-general, and accepted by him “ on condition that his contract be complied with.” All these drafts had been discounted by the bank, before they became due ; but *3811 had no^ ^een Paid by the acceptors. The bank also deducted *8611.52, J which sum was overdrawn, in the year 1835, by E. F. Brown, the agent for disbursing the contingent fund of the post-office department. These credits were claimed at the treasury and disallowed.
At June term 1838, a suit was brought by the United States to recover the whole balance of 827,356.57. On the trial, the bank proved the facts above stated, and claimed the credits which had been disallowed. The district-attorney of the United States requested the court to charge the jury on three points ; which were, substantially, as follows : 1. That if they believed there was nothing due to Porter and Reeside, at the time of the acceptance of their drafts, or at the time they became due, the bank was not authorized by law to set off such draft againt the deposit of “ the treasurer of the United States.” 2. That if the accounts of Porter and Reeside were not finally settled at the department, it was the duty of the postmaster-general to have them settled ; and in such settlement, he ought not to allow credits for illegal extra allowances, where such allowances had been merely entered in the journal, but never brought into the ledger. 3. That the over-draft of the agent for disbursing the contingent fund could not, by p. 243law, be set off against the deposit of “ the treasurer of the United States.” These instructions the court refused to give ; and it is submitted, that they erred in so doing.
I. When Porter’s draft became due, was it a just claim against the United States? would the acceptor have been justified, by law, in paying it to the drawer ? He accepted the draft as a public officer—as “ treasurer of the post-office department.” He wTas to pay it out of the public money in his hands, appropriated by law to pay the drawer, when it became due. It was an arrangement between the department and a contractor, for the benefit of the latter. It wras an acknowledgment in advance. When the day of payment arrived, the money had not been earned ; no debt -was due from the United States to Porter ; there is, consequently, no appropriation by law to pay him. If paid, he receives, from the public treasury, money not *appropriated to him. Could the acceptance of a public officer, made under a misapprehension of the facts, authorize this ? If it be a principle not doubted, that the neglect of a public officer cannot deprive the United States of their right to recover money from their debtors ; is it not a principle equally well founded, that they cannot be made to pay money twice, by his error or indiscretion ? Can the treasurer of the post-office department, or any other officer, promise to pay a sum of public money, ninety days hence, and then draw it from the public treasury, whether justly due or not? Under the instruction, as asked, the question whether the money was owing or not to Porter, on the day when the draft became due, does not arise ; for it was requested, in the event of the jury believing that nothing was owing ; but the evidence shows, that when that day arrived, everything to which he was entitled had already been absorbed by forfeitures and drafts previously drawn and accepted. A payment made to him, then, would not have been made, because he was entitled to the money, but only because the treasurer of the post-office department had accepted his draft. The constitution, art. I. § 9, par. 6, forbids the payment of any money from the treasury, but in pursuance of appropriations made by law. The appropriation for the benefit of Porter w^s exhausted. He had received from it all that he was entitled to. To pay him more would be to pay that for which there was no appropriation. United States v. Barney, 3 Hall’s Law Jour. 130 ; United States v. Nicoll, 1 Paine 649.
If, then, it be established, that the United States would not have been bound to pay Porter himself, notwithstanding his possession of the acceptance, were they bound to pay the bank to whom he transferred it? An illegal payment is not authorized, by the constitution or law, to be made to a transferee, any more than to the claimant himself. Every principle which forbids double payment to one, forbids it to the two. It is not requisite to controvert the general rule of commercial law, discussed before this court in the case of Townsley v. Sumrail, 2 Pet. 183, 185, as to the liability of an acceptor, whether he has funds or not, for an unconditional acceptance ; nor is it necessary to examine how far the ordinary responsibility, which attaches to parties to negotiable paper, can be imposed, by the *acts of their officers, on the United States ; nor how far such rules can be applied to them, in a case where they have the effect to draw money from the treasury, without an appropriation (12 Wheat. 561 ; 4 W. C. C. 464) ; because, in this instance, the aceptance was clearly of such a nature as to p. 244put the acceptor on his guard. If it was not strictly conditional, in terms, it was so in substance. The bank knew, when it received the draft, that it was payable out of a public fund ; and that the payment could not be made, unless there was money, appropriated by law for .that purpose, in the hands of the acceptor. They knew the acceptance was given by the acceptor “ as treasurer and that the law of the land gave public notice that the treasurer could not bind the United States, beyond the funds appropriated for the use of the drawer. Suppose, an agent accepts as agent, will it be pretended, that the principal is bound beyond the extent of his agency? The holder must inquire into that extent; must see the acceptor’s authority ; must know how far the acceptance binds the principal. 1 Pet. 283, 290. There is no hardship or injustice in this ; the bank, like any other holder, had ample opportunity, before it discounted the draft, to ascertain the exact extent of the obligation assumed by the acceptor. This principle, which is just in every case, is peculiarly proper in that of .the United States. How can they guard themselves against acts of their agents, either intentionally or accidentally wrong, except by their laws ? These are notice to every person dealing with their officers. These make their acceptances, special acceptances, whether so declared in terms or not. Not only, however, did the bank know the special and conditional character of the acceptance ; but they knew also that it was payable on a contingency, and out of a particular fund ; that if that fund was previously exhausted, the acceptor could not pay it. On settled principles of commercial law, therefore, the bank was not entitled to payment, any more than the drawer himself, if the fund was exhausted. If they advanced their money imprudently, it was yet done advisedly ; they could have easily guarded against the loss ; they can now only repair it, so far as the United States are concerned through the action of the legislature. * -| II. These principles apply more strongly to the acceptances *of
J Reeside’s drafts, because they were conditional in express terms. They were only to be paid “ on condition that his contracts were complied with.” The bank need not have discounted a conditional acceptance, but having done so, it assumed the burden of showing that the condition has been performed, before it can charge the acceptor. 4 Maule & Selw. 466 ; 2 W. C. C. 514. Has it done so? The only evidence adduced by them is, that Reeside performed, in the year 1835, the mail services for which he contracted. That a “compliance” with all the terms of his contracts has been shown, will scarcely be pretended. If it were, evidence, adduced by the bank itself, sufficiently refutes it. It is proved, that stipulations were expressly made by him, not only to perform mail services, but to “pay all forfeitures,” and to “ repay all advances.” Was his contract complied with, if forfeitures were unpaid, and advances not refunded ? Had such a contract existed between man and man, and such an acceptance been given and received, could the holder, in the face of such proof, recover from the acceptor? How, then, can it be sufficient, when that acceptor is a public officer, to make him twice pay the money from the public treasury ?
III. As if aware of the force of these objections, it has been strenuously argued, that there were, in fact, moneys due, which were sufficient to pay all these acceptances. If this were so, it is immaterial as to the error in the charge of the court, because, in the instruction prayed, that was left as a p. 245matter of fact for the jury. But how is it attempted to be shown that it was so ? It is not by proving that the forfeitures were not incurred, or that the advances were returned ; but it is said, that allowances, sufficient to cover them, were made by the former postmaster-general. It is true, that such allowances are found to be entered in the journal; bnt they were never finally credited in the settlement of the accounts. It may be admitted, as has been argued, that when the head of an executive department has finally acted upon a matter within the scope of his authority, his decision cannot be reversed by his successor, to the disadvantage of a third person, without the disclosure of material error, otherwise than by resorting to judicial proceedings. But such is not the case here. These were merely journal memorandums, such as must necessarily be made in the course of proceedings between *a mail contractor and the post-office department ; they were left to be finally settled, when the account was •- 0 adjusted. Would it be contended, if the contractor had, in his own journal, charged himself with a payment he had not received, or a forfeiture he not incurred, that the error could not be corrected in the final settlement ? In the case of Ex parte Randolph, 9 Pet. 15, which is relied on, the account had been entirely settled ; it had passed through all the forms of the treasury ; it reposed in the register’s office as a final and conclusive adjustment. The ground taken, therefore, does not sustain the assertion that the money was due ; and the court below should have instructed the jury to that effect. They should have instructed them, that the mere fact of there having been allowances made in the journal, and while the account was unsettled, which allowances are alleged to be illegal and contrary to the contract, and were rescinded as such, before the account was closed, cannot of itself authorize the admission of a credit for their amount.
But it is said, that even if these forfeitures and advances might be lawfully recharged, yet that the condition of the acceptances had no reference to them ; that it was not retrospective, but had relation merely to the performance of future duties under the contract. Such a distinction, between the several duties to be performed under the contract, is not warranted by the language of the condition, which is general. The condition was inserted for the safety of the acceptor ; the acceptance was for the benefit of the contractor ; in conferring that benefit, the protection of the acceptor was to be provided for; the bank knew this to be the case; the advance of money by it was a voluntary act, for its own advantage, and in making it, there was no pretext for overlooking the safety of the acceptor ; this depended no less on the repayment of past advances, than on the performance of future services. Why should the acceptor, in seeking to protect himself, guard less against one than the other ? The condition referred to the contract, the whole contract; that condition was submitted to the bank, before its money was advanced ; the whole contract, therefore, was, or might and ought to have been, known ; and it would be a .great injustice to the acceptor, when he states his condition in terms so broad as clearly to secure for himself the performance of every stipulation *of the contract, were the party that obtains his guarantee for the payment, to be permit- L ted to diminish that security in regard to some of the most essential of those stipulations. It is not possible, in an acceptance, to state all the particulars of a contract; it is sufficient to embrace it entirely, by general and p. 246comprehensive words, not susceptible of being misunderstood. When this is done, no one has a right to allege ignorance of any part of that which he might easily have known. How could the acceptor apprise every one, into whose hands the draft might pass, of every stipulation of the contract ? It was sufficient, that he apprised him, before he incurred any responsibility, that a contract existed between the drawer and the acceptor, which might be ascertained, and must be performed in all its parts, before the latter either intended or engaged to be responsible.
IV. The claim to be repaid the over-draft of E. F. Brown, cannot be sustained. He deposited in the bank, on the 30th of April 1835, the sum of $7070.24 ; he drew checks on this till the 2d December 1835, when he had received thereon $7671.76 ; that is, $611.24 more than he had deposited. There is no proof, nor even an allegation, that this latter sum was applied to the use of the United States. The sole grounds of claim are, that, from June 1835, the checks of Brown were countersigned by the accountant of the department ; and that, after the contingent fund was exhausted, and previous to the passage of the annual appropriation act, some ordinary bills, certified by the accountant, were paid by the bank. In what manner do these acts recognise the over-draft? In itself, it was wrong. It was a transaction known only to the bank and Brown. It might have been prevented by the former. It is excused by no proof that such agents as he was, were usually, oi’ ever, permitted to make over-drafts. The counter-signature by the accountant, and the payment of bills, at the express request of the postmaster-general, are proofs that any deviation from the usual mode was only to be made by express authority. None such is exhibited for this over-draft. It was therefore, an act voluntarily done by the bank, not for the benefit of the United States, and with which it has no right to charge them.
, *V. But suppose, all these sums are legal credits, can they be set -• off or deducted from moneys deposited in the bank, after the 2d of July 1836, to the credit of “the treasurer of the United States, for the service of thé post-office department ?” That was public money in the treasury. It could be drawn out in no way but by a warrant, under an appropriation made by act of congress. It was not under the control of the postmaster-general. It was not money which he had received in order to disburse ; nor was it under the control of the treasurer himself, except to pay it on such a warrant. He could have no other voucher to discharge himself, if the money was not in the treasury. 1 Story’s Laws 46. These provisions of law were known to the bank, when it received the deposit from the treasurer. They cannot charge against it a claim which, if the treasurer himself had paid, he would not be credited with.
The debts do not arise in the same right, nor are they of the same nature. It is true, that the United States are, eventually, the parties ; but the public funds, distributed for different objects, are separate funds in the transactions between a claimant and the various officers of the government. Such a distinction is indispensable. The relations between a bank and the treasurer as a public depositary, are totally distinct from those between a bank and the head of an executive department, in relation to contracts existing between them. The settlement of its account with one, would have no reference to that with the other. They are, therefore, in fact, debts that p. 247do not arise between the same parties, or in the same right. In every case of set-off recognised by this court, it has been for moneys properly payable out of the same fund which the United States sought to recover.
An agent intrusted with money cannot pay off his principal’s debts, and then set off the payment. This is here attempted, for it is the payment of a debt to Porter and Reeside, -with funds with which the agent is intrusted for a different purpose. 1 Rawle 330. Nor can an agent convert to one purpose, funds deposited with him for another. Nor can he avail himself of the advantages of his agency, to do, for his own benefit, that which injures or affects his principal. 1 Johns. Ch. 394 ; 6 Pick. 204.
The inability, thus established, to sustain, upon general principles of law, such a right of set-off as is now contended for, is confirmed *by the peculiar facts of this case. The whole claim of the bank was ascer- L °° tained and liquidated in January 1836. This deduction is made out of money placed in its hands subsequent to that time, under a promise, both express and implied, that it would not be appropriated to the payment of that claim. Before so depositing the money, the postmaster-general, in his letter of 16th July 1836, stipulated, that it should “ be paid out only on the checks of the treasurer,” and that, in accounting for the sums thus deposited, “ no other credit, set-off or deduction would be admitted.” On this condition, and on this alone, did the bank receive the money ; and that, at a time when both parties knew that there was this actual pending claim to a credit, set-off and deduction, existing and disputed between them. Even if the bank had not agreed to this express stipulation, when it received the money, would not their consent to transfer the fund they then had to a new account, their silent acquiescence, their settlement of repeated monthly and quarterly accounts, without an allusion to a claim of right to make this deduction, have proved, by an implication, not to be resisted, that they did not mean to assert any such right ? Did not their special acceptance of the fund, their voluntary agreement to hold it for a special purpose, deprive them of any general claim they might previously have had upon it ? 16 Ves. 279-80 ; 5 Maule & Selw. 186 ; 15 Mass. 397.
However broad the terms of the act of congress (1 Story’s Laws 464) are, therefore, in allowing equitable off-sets ; and if they were not meant to be exclusively applicable to disbursing officers, and to cases where the claim, if just, would have been paid out of the fund in controversy (9 Cranch 236 ; 6 Wheat. 163 ; 7 Pet. 1), still, the positive agreement of the party, after the claim has arisen, and before the money was paid, put into his hands, that the latter was not to be applied to the former, must, on every principle of law, prevent his present resort to a privilege which he thus consented to forego.
Coxe, for the defendant in error.—For many years, the government of the United States have made use of the banks in the city of Washington in their financial operations ; and the Bank of the Metropolis was for a long time one of these banks. In 1835, Mr. Kendall became *postmaster- # general; and up to the period of his entering on the duties of his l $$$ office, there were no matters with the bank unsettled in the post-office. The post-office was in the practice of giving acceptances on drafts of contractors ; p. 248and sometimes, the Bank of the Metropolis was resorted to for the immediate exigencies of the post-office.
The position assumed is, that the instructions asked for by the plaintiffs in the circuit court were not such as the court should have given, being informal, and rather a demurrer to the evidence on the part of the defendant. The party asking the instructions of the court is bound to place them in proper form ; and the court are not to modify and adapt them to the case. In this case, all the grounds of the defence were placed together, and if any of the items were good as set-off to the claim of the United States, the instructions asked for were improper ; and the court will give the defendant judgment. The other instructions are equally defective.
The credits allowed by the postmaster-general, before the office was held by Mr. Kendall, were final. When entered in the journal, this was the effect of such entry ; and the head of the department cannot afterwards alter them. Entries in the ledger have no effect on those credits. One of the instructions asked for by the plaintiff was, that, as the entries in the ledger were made by a clerk, they were of no effect ! If allowances had been made by the postmaster-general, which were deemed illegal by his successor, the proper course would have been to institute an action to surcharge and falsify the settlement. But it is not in the power of the successor to re-open the account, and to revise and alter it. This was decided in this court in the United States v. Fillebrown, 7 Pet. 1 ; and in 8 Ibid. 383-4. The act of congress of March 1836, which directs the postmaster-general to institute suits for money improperly credited, does not allow that officer to charge a contractor with money which had been allowed and credited to him, and thus, by his own act, decide the propriety of the charge.
The acceptances of the post-office department, which were charged by the defendants to the United States, should be governed by the same rules and *390' Pr^ncT^es law which operate in *relationto such contracts, in their J usual employment in commercial transactions. The United States
submit themselves to these rules, when such contracts are entered into for them, by their authorized agents.
Mr. Coxe also contended, that if the contracts of the persons whose drafts had been, accepted by the post-office department had not been performed, it was the duty of the department to have given the defendants notice of the same, and to have proved the non-performance. As to the acceptance of the draft of Edwin Porter, certainly, no debts due by him before the date of the acceptance could be set off against the claim of the bank on the acceptance. It was a general and an unqualified acceptance.
Wayne, Justice, delivered the opinion of the court.—This is an action of assumpsit brought by the United States to recover the sum of $27,881.57. The defendants pleaded the general issue. On the trial of the cause, the defendants claimed credits, amounting to $23,000, exclusive of interest and costs. The items had been presented to the proper accounting officer and were not allowed. They were acceptances of the post-office department, of the drafts of mail-contractors, and an item of $611.52, called in the record “ E. F. Brown’s over-draft.”
The jury found for the defendants, and certified there was due to them by the United States $3371.94, with interest from the 6th March 1838
The errors assigned are, that the court refused to give to the jury the following instructions, which were asked after the evidence had been closed on both sides.
1. That upon the evidence aforesaid, the defendants are not entitled in this action to set off against the plaintiff’s demand, the amount of the acceptances given in evidence by the defendants, nor the amount of the over-draft of E. F. Brown.
2. If the jury believe, from the evidence, that when the acceptance of the draft of E. Porter was given by the then treasurer *of the department, there was nothing due to Porter standing on the books of the L post-office department, and that on the department, when the acceptance fell due, there was nothing due to him ; then the defendants cannot set off the amount of said acceptance against the plaintiff’s claim in this action.
3. That if the accounts of E. Porter and Reeside, as contractors with the post-office department, were not finally settled on the books of the post-office department, when the present postmaster-general came into office, it was his duty to have said accounts settled ; and if, in such settlement, there were credits claimed by them, as allowed by order of Mr. Barry, when postmaster-general, and entered on the journal, but not carried into these accounts in the ledger, and finally entered as credits in these accounts, which credits were for extra allowances which the said postmaster-general was not legally authorized to allow them, then it was in the power and was the duty of the present postmaster-general, to disallow such items of credit.
We will consider the instructions asked, in connection, and upon the merits of the case ; but before we conclude, will express an opinion upon the form of the first. It appears, that the five drafts claimed as credits were drawn on the post-office department by contractors for carrying the mails. That they were accepted, and were discounted at the’ Metropolis Bank, in the way of business. Porter’s draft was at ninety days after date, for $10,000, payable at the Metropolis Bank, to his own order, to be charged to account, and was unconditionally accepted by R. C. Mason, signing himself treasurer of the post-office department. It is admitted, that he was so. Reeside drew four drafts. One on the 17th October 1835, for $4500 ; another on the 20th October 1835, for $1000 ; a third on the 23d October 1835, for $4500; and the fourth on the 28th October 1835, for $3000. They were payable to his own order, ninety days after date, for value received ; to be charged to his account for transporting the mail, and addressed to the postmaster-general. The following was the form of all of them, and of the acceptances of the postmaster-general.
*$ 4500. Washington City, October 17th, 1835.
Sir :—Ninety days after date, please to pay to my own order, four L thousand five hundred dollars, for value received, and charge to my account, for transporting the mail. Respectfully yours, James Reeside.
Hon. Amos Kendall, Postmaster-General.
Accepted, on condition that his contracts be complied with.
Amos Kendall.
Porter’s draft was unconditionally accepted. It was discounted by the defendants, upon his indorsement. The bank became the holder of it, for p. 250valuable consideration, and its right to charge the United States with the amount cannot be defeated by any equities between the drawer and the post-office department, of which the bank had not notice. When the United States, by its authorized officer, become a party to negotiable paper, they have all the rights, and incur all the responsibility of individuals who are parties to such instruments. We know of no difference, except that the United States cannot be sued. But if the United States sue, and a defendant holds its negotiable paper, the amount of it may be claimed as a credit, if, after being presented, it has boen disallowed by the accounting officers of the treasury ; and if the liability of the United States upon it, be not discharged by some of those causes which discharge a party to commercial paper, it should be allowed by a jury, as a credit against the debt claimed by the United States. This is a privilege of the defendant, for all equitable credits given by the act or March 3d, 1797. 1 Story 464. This, and the liability of the United States, in the maner it has been stated, has been repeatedly declared, in effect, by this court. It said, in the case of the Bank of the United States v. Bunn, 6 Pet. 51, 11 the liability of parties to a bill of exchange or promissory note, has been fixed on certain principles, which are essential to the credit and circulation of such paper ; these principles originated in the convenience of commercial transactions, and cannot now be departed from.” From the daily and unavoidable use of commercial paper by the United States, they are as much interested as the community at large can be, in maintaining these principles. * . *It was held in the case of the United States n. Barker, 4 W. C. C.
J 464, that the omission of the secretary of the treasury, for one day, to give notice of the dishonor of bills, which were purchased by the United States, discharged the drawer. And this court said, when that case was brought before it, there was no right to recover ; on the account of the neglect in giving notice after the return of the bills. 12 Wheat. 561. That, and other cases like it, show how rigidly those principles have been applied in suits on bills and promissory notes, in which the United States was a party. The acceptance of Porter’s draft was unconditional, and there is nothing in the evidence to discharge the acceptor. There is neither waiver, express or implied, of his liability. There was no understanding nor communication concerning it between the bank, and any officer of the post-office department, before it was discounted. The bank advanced the money, which it was the object of the bill to obtain. It cannot be doubted, the acceptance was given for that purpose. The want of consideration, then, between the drawer and the acceptor, can be no defence against the right of the indorsee, w’ho gave a valuable consideration for the bill.
It does not matter how the drawer’s account stood. Whether he was a debtor or a creditor of the department; whether the bank knew one or the other. An unconditional acceptance was tendered to it for discount. It was not its duty to inquire how the account stood, or for what purpose the acceptance was made. All it had to look to was the genuineness of the acceptance, and the authority of the officer to give it. The rule is, that a want of consideration between the drawer and acceptor, is no defence against the right of a third party, who has given a consideration for the bill, and this, even though the acceptor has been defrauded by the drawer ; if that be not known by such third party, before he gives value for it. The p. 251evidence, then, concerning Porter’s account, was immaterial and irrelevant to the issue. It cannot affect the rights of the bank, and did not lessen the obligation of the department to pay the acceptance when it became due.
But the evidence does not show that anything was due by Porter, when the draft was accepted, or when it came to maturity. Mason, the witness, says, “that in the interim, a sufficient *sum had been raised and car- . ried to the credit of Porter, to pay the draft; but that he had also, *- within the dates, been charged with the amount of a draft, drawn upon him by the postmaster at Mobile, accepted by him, which draft was payable in 1833, and that he was charged with failures and forfeitures incurred as contractor, in 1833 ; which charges were made by order of Mr. Barry, then postmaster-general. It was certainly right, to debit Porter with these charges, if they were due by him ; but that did not change the relative rights and obligations of the bank and the department upon his bill. If either are to lose by Porter, shall it be that party, who was bound to know the state of the account, before it gave an unconditional acceptance, for the purpose of accommodating its own agent; or the other, who placed faith in the acceptance, advanced the money upon it, which it was intended to raise ; and who could not have learned what was the state of Porter’s account, as it is proved that the charges which it is now said should have priority of payment over the bill, were uot made against Porter, until after his bill had been accepted. Certainly, the loss should fall upon the first. It cannot be otherwise, unless it would be affirmed, that an acceptor may claim to be discharged, on account of his own negligence, and that having induced a third party to advance money upon his acceptance, he shall be permitted to intervene between himself and the indorsee of the paper, a debt due to him by the drawer. The evidence offered to invalidate this credit was done from ignorance of the legal consequences incurred by such an acceptance. In such a case, the bank rightfully looked to the United States for payment of this bill; and if Porter owes anything for forfeitures incurred as contractor, or on account of the Mobile draft, the United States must look to him. There is no proof on the record, however, of anything being due by Porter on those accounts ; and we do not intend to express any opinion upon his liability, or the rights of the United States, in respect to them, one way or the other.
What are the merits of the case, upon Reeside’s drafts ? They were drawn on the postmaster-general, at ninety days, payable to the order of the drawer, and were to be charged to his account for transporting the mail. They were “ accepted, on condition that his contracts be complied with.” This is, of course, *as binding as an absolute acceptance, if the condition has been performed. What is the proof of performance ? L and how shall this conditional acceptance be construed ? Mason, the witness, says, “ Reeside, in fact, performed the services for which he was contractor, in the year 1835 ; and the money which he earned upon his contracts was applied, to an extent exceeding the amount due upon his drafts, to the extinguishment of balances created against him, by recharging him with sums of money which had been allowed to him by Mr. Barry, the former postmaster-general, as contractor for carrying the mail, by giving him credit therefor in a general account-current on the journal, but not entered in the ledger, where his account remained unsettled when the present post-
395 SUPREME COURT [Jaii’y
master-general came into office.” It is said, this does not cover the condition of the acceptance, because Reeside stipulated, by his bond, to pay forfeitures, and repay advances ; and that he owed the department on both accounts, when these acceptances were given ; and that in this sense, his contracts were not complied with. If this be so, in one sense, the contracts would not be complied with ; but is that the construction which should be put upon such a condition, when the subject-matter to which it relates is considered ?
If one purpose making a conditional acceptance only, and commit that acceptance to writing, he should be careful to express the condition therein. He cannot use general terms, and then exempt himself from liability, by relying upon particular facts which have already happened, though they are connected with the condition expressed.« Why ? Because the particular fact is, of itself, susceptible of being made a distinct condition. This case furnishes as good an illustration of the rule as any other can do. Instead of the words being used, “ accepted, on condition that his contracts be complied with,” could it not have been as easily said, accepted, on condition “ that forfeitures already incurred shall be paid, and that advances made shall be refunded.” This would have conveyed a very different meaning ; and would have put the bank, when the drafts were offered to it for discount, on inquiry. If they had been discounted, without inquiry, it would have been done, at the risk that the earnings upon the contracts, and such as *qoc 1 he earned between the date of *the acceptances and the times
J of payment, would be enough to pay forfeitures, repay advances and to take up the bills. It matters not, what the acceptor meant, by a cautious and precise phraseology, if it be not expressed as a condition. And when we are told, as we are in this case, by the person making these acceptances, that the form of words was devised expressly for that purpose, meaning for the purposes of having forfeitures paid and advances refunded, and to avoid promising to pay anything to the order of contractors, so long as anything should be due from them to the department ; we think it will be admitted, that the purpose explained is larger than the condition expressed. And from the passage in the evidence just cited, how just does the rule appear, which has been laid down by the court, that in the case of acceptances of commercial paper, that which can be made a distinct condition must be so expressed ; nor can anything out of the condition be inferred, unless it be in a case where the words used are so ambiguous as to make it necessary that parol evidence should be resorted to, to explain them. Then the onus of the proof would be on the acceptor, and the proof would be of no avail, if the holder, or any person under whom he claims, took the bill, without notice of such conditions, and gave a valuable consideration for it. The error in this case arose from the acceptor supposing that the defendants did know, and if they did not, they were bound, upon such an acceptance, to inquire into the stipulations and conditions of Reeside’s contracts, before they discounted the bills ; and it is said, they did not use “due diligence to acquire infoimation.” The objection then implies that information of these forfeitures and advances could have been given, and that it was not given, when these acceptances were made. This makes it, then, a question of due diligence between the acceptor and the defendants,
18411 OF THE UNITED STATES. 396
as to his obligation to communicate what he knew ; and their want of caution in not making the inquiry.
We think it will be conceded to be'a general principle, that one having knowledge of particular facts upon which he intends to rely to exempt him from a pecuniary obligation, about to be contracted with another—of which facts that other is ignorant, and can only learn them from the first, or from documents in his keeping—that the fact of knowledge raises the obligation upon *him to tell it. This would be the law in such a case, and it is in this case. Inquiry by the defendants would, at most, have resulted in obtaining what was already known to the acceptor. He held the contracts ; he knew, or should have known, officially, the state of the accounts between the contractor and the department, and when he conditionally accepted his drafts, which were to be charged to his account for transporting the mail; as his liability to pay them would occur in ninety days, it was but reasonable, that he should have said in plain terms, when giving his acceptances, “ If the earnings of the contractor from this time to the maturity of the draft, shall be sufficient to pay what he owes, and the debt he may incur until then, then these drafts will be paid.” This would have been a condition about which there would have been no mistake.
But further, if two persons deal in relation to the executory contracts of a third (as these contracts were) ; and one of them, being the obligee, induces the other to advance money to the obligor, upon “ condition that his contracts be complied with and he knows that forfeitures have been already incurred by the obligor, for breaches of this contract, and does not say so ; shall he be permitted afterwards to get rid of his liability, by saying to the person making the advance, “ I cannot pay you, for when I accepted there was already due to me from the drawer of the bill more than I accepted for. I had knowledge of it then, and so might you have had, if you had made the inquiry, but you did not choose to inquire ; so I will pay myself first, because my acceptance was on condition that his contracts be complied with ?”
Such is the case before us, as it was presented by the argument; and we cannot doubt, it will be thought decisive, that it was the duty of the acceptor, in this instance, to communicate what he knew of Reeside’s account, if he had any conversation with the defendants, before the drafts were discounted, and that it was not the duty of the defendants to inquire. It cannot be answered, by saying, the words of the acceptance were intended to provide for what might exist, but what was not then known, or for breaches of the contracts which had already occurred, but which had not been charged with a penalty ; for either would be an admission that inquiry by the defendants, when the acceptances *were made, could not have resulted in getting the information at the department. L
But again, will the terms of the acceptance admit in any way of retroactive construction ? The words must be taken according to the ordinary import of them. They are “ accepted, on condition that his contracts be complied with.” Can there be compliance with an executory contract, but in future, if breaches have already happened^? Supposing no breaches to have occurred, necessarily implies such as may occur in future, and subsequent compliance. If both past and future breaches, then, are, as contended for, to be comprehended within the condition of this acceptance, why may p. 254not the condition be extended to such as may happen after the maturity of the drafts, as well as to such as had occurred before they were accepted ? A literal interpretation must lead to. both, and that will not be contended for. But the argument is, that the, defendants should have inquired into the “ stipulations of the contracts and the extent of the condition and it is said, “the bank would have been informed, that the department expected Mr. Reeside to renew his drafts, until the accumulation of his current pay would be sufficient to meet them ; and had his pledge to take them up himself, if earlier payment should be required.” Be it so ! Can there be a plainer admission than there is in the preceding sentence, written by the acceptor, that it is necessary to go out of the condition of the acceptance to ascertain his meaning, and that his construction rests upon facts, known by himself and Mr. Reeside, which the defendants could not have known but from one or the other of them ? facts out of the condition, and which could alone become a condition, by being so expressed. Again, it is taken for granted in the argument, if the defendants had inquired into the stipulations of the contracts and the bond, that they would have been informed of the forfeitures which had been incurred. But that would not follow. Before such knowledge could have been obtained, it would have been necessary to take one step further beyond the condition—an inquiry into the accounts. Where shall such construction stop, if it be allowed at all. The law does not permit a conditional acceptance to be construed by anything extraneous to it, unless where the terms used are so ambiguous that it cannot be otherwise ascertained. * *We will suppose, however, that the stipulations of Reeside’s con-
J tract and his bond, had been known to the defendants. Might they not very justifiably have concluded, that his drafts were accepted, to aid him with an advance to fulfil his engagements ? The bond in evidence shows that a necessity for advances was contemplated. It had been the habit of the department, to make them to contractors. Its exigencies, it is said, required advances to be made. The witness, Mason, says, “ From the year 1830, the pecuniary affairs of the department were much deranged, and it was frequently unable to pay debts due by it to contractors. Under such circumstances, the department was in the practice of giving to contractors acceptances for sums less than was actually standing to their credit, unconditionally ; and such acceptances were always taken up at maturity, prior to May 1835. That, occasionally, and with the special approbation of the postmaster-general, acceptances were given, upon the faith of existing contracts, conditional upon the performance of the contracts, which were understood to become absolute, if the contractor performed the services stated in the contract.” The defendants, in the year 1835, held acceptances of the same character, for more than $70,000, all of which were under protest for non-payment, but subsequently paid, prior to the institution of this suit, except those in dispute in this case. The witness further says, the Bank of the Metropolis, and other banks in the city of Washington and elsewhere, have been, for many years, in the practice of discounting such acceptances. That it was often done for the accommodation of the department, often for the accommodation of the drawer, and frequently, of both. This testimony brings the department of the bank in connection upon acceptances of the former for contractors ; shows the course of business upon them ; - and aids
1841] OF THE UNITED STATES. 39fi
to give a proper construction to the acceptances under consideration. When it is remembered also, that these acceptances were given to renew others of the department, which were over-due, we think it cannot be doubted, that the terms, “ accepted, on condition that his contracts be complied with,” cannot retroact to embrace forfeitures which had been incurred, and to refund advances said to have been made before the date of these acceptances. The argument upon this point was made upon the false assumption, *that there had been a communication between the postmaster-general * and the defendants, concerning these acceptances, before they were *- discounted ; or that there was an obligation upon the part of the defendants to make an inquiry into the state of Reeside’s contracts, and his fulfilment of them, because the acceptances were conditional. It did not exist here, nor does it in any case of a conditional acceptance. The acceptor is bound by his contract, as it is expressed ; and so it may be negotiated ; without any further inquiry.
Having fully canvassed the argument upon the point of the obligation of the defendants to inquire into the condition of the acceptance ; we turn, for a moment, to the case as it is shown to be by the evidence. Reeside’s earnings, between the date of the acceptances and the time for the payment of them, were not applied to pay forfeitures, or refund advances. They were exhausted, by recharging him with sums of money, which Mr. Barry had allowed to him as contractor for carrying the mail, which were credited in the journal, but not entered into the ledger. That they were not posted, cannot affect Reeside’s right to such allowances ; and something more must appear than the testimony in this case discloses, before it can be admitted, that credits given by Mr. Barry were legally withdrawn by his successor. There is no evidence in this cause, to impeach the fairness and legality of the allowances credited by Mr. Barry ; no proof that Reeside had incurred forfeitures, or that advances had been made to him. Proofs should have been given, if it was intended to justify the recharges for the causes stated. No attempt was made to do so. The allowances, then, are credits in Reeside’s account, which the defendants may use to prove his performance of the conditions of the acceptance ; and they do show performance, as the amount earned would have paid his drafts, if it had not been diverted.
The third instruction asked the court to say, among other things, if the credits given by Mr. Barry, were for extra allowances, which the said postmaster-general was not legally authorized to allow, then it was the duty of the present postmaster-general to disallow such items of credit. The successor of Mr. Barry had the same power, and no more, than his predecessor ; and the power of the former did not extend to *the recall of credits or allowances made by Mr. Barry, if he acted within the scope of official authority given by law to the head of the department. This right in an incumbent of reviewing a predecessor’s decisions, extends to mistakes m matters of fact, arising from errors in calculation, and to cases of rejected claims, in which material testimony is afterwards discovered and produced. But if a credit has been given, or an allowance made, as these were, by the head of a department, and it is alleged to be an illegal allowance, the judicial tribunals of the country must be resorted to, to> construe the law under which the allowance was made, and to settle the rights between the United States and the party to whom the credit was given. It is no longer p. 256401 SUPREME COURT fJan’y
a case between the correctness of one officer’s judgment and that of his successor. A third party is interested, and he cannot be deprived of a payment, on a credit so given, but by the intervention of a court to pass upon his right. No statute is necessary to authorize the United States to sue in such a case. The right to sue is independent of statute, and it may be done by the direction of the incumbent of the department. The act of 2d July 1836, entitled “ an act to change the organization of the post-office department,” is only affirmative of the antecedent right of the government to sue, and directory to the postmaster-general to cause suits to be brought in the cases mentioned in the 17th section of that act. It also excludes him from determining, finally, any case which he may suppose to arise under that section. His duty is to cause a suit to be brought. Additional allowances, the postmaster-general could make, under the 43d section of the act of March 2d, 1825 (3 Story 1985), and we presume it was because allowances were supposed to have been made contrary to that law, that the 17th section of the act of 2d July 1836, was passed. In this last, the extent of the postmaster-general’s power in respect to allowances, is too plain to be mistaken.
We cannot say, that either of the sections of the acts of 1825 and 1836, just alluded to, covers the allowances made by Mr. Barry to Reeside. But if the postmaster-general thought they did, and that such a defence could have availed against the rights of the bank to claim these acceptances, as credits in this suit, the same proof which would have justified a recovery in * _ *an action by the United States, would have justified the rejection of them as credits when they are claimed as a set-off.
We pass to the credit claimed, and called E. F. Brown’s overdraft. But why it is so called, we do not know ; for certainly no over-draft occurred when he checked alone upon the contingent fund of the department deposited to his credit in the bank : $7070.24, on the 30th of April 1835, were deposited to his credit; by 7th of June, he had drawn of that sum $3076.97. Then, the postmaster-general directed the bank not to pay Brown’s checks, unless they were approved by Robert Johnson, the accountant of the department. It is in proof, that no check of Brown’s was afterwards paid, without Johnson’s approval. On the 2d of December following, the original deposit to Brown’s credit was drawn out on his checks, approved by Johnson, and it was found there had been an over-draft of something over $600. We do not say, that an over-draft out of the bank, by authorized officers of the United States, is in any case chargeable to the United States, unless it can be shown that the money over-drawn has been applied to the use of the United States ; but in the present instance, we think no proof of such application was necessary, and we cannot resist the conclusion, that the defendants are, in equity, entitled to this credit, for the proof is, that on the day that the over-draft was known, the postmaster-general wrote a letter to the cashier of the bank, stating that “ the contingent fund of the department was exhausted, but the public service requires that a number of bills chargeable to that appropriation, shall be paid sooner than the usual sum can be obtained from congress ; I, therefore, request the favor of our bank, to pay such bills against the department, of that character, as may be presented, with the certificate that the amount is allowed, signed by Robert Johnson, accountant of this department.” The request was complied with, p. 257and the bank advanced, until the 14th of May 1836, more than $6000, to pay claims on the contingent fund. In this case, as in those of more humble dealings, the course of business between parties must be used, when it can apply, to explain their understanding of past transactions. Nor can the inference be resisted, that when the postmaster-general *discovered the contingent fund had been over-drawn, and requested that other L over-drafts might be made on the same account, that it was an admission of the correctness of the first. We think, then, that the United States was a debtor to the defendants for Porter’s draft, and Reeside’s drafts, and for the over-draft on the contingent fund, principal, interest and costs.
But it is said, though the credits claimed by the defendants shall be found to be due by the United States, they cannot be set off in this suit. This was the first instruction asked, and refused by the court. It is urged, that to allow them as credits in this suit is, in effect, to permit money to be taken from the treasury, otherwise than it is directed to be disbursed by law. That the money previously held by the defendants had been passed to the account of the treasurer of the United States, by direction of the postmaster-general, in conformity with the act of the 2d of July 1836. 4 Story 2464. That when the defendants complied with the letter of instruction, written to them by the postmaster-general, on the 16th of July 1836, and transferred the money then on deposit to the credit of the department to the treasurer of the United States, for the service of the post-office department; and when they consented to receive future deposits according to a form sent, and to transact the business according to the regulations contained in the letter of the 16th of July 1836 ; that the defendants cannot legally charge their claims against that account, by way of set-off in this suit.
To the foregoing objections, a brief but conclusive answer may be given. That is certainly the treasury of the United States, where its money is directed by law to be kept; but if those whose duty it is to disburse appropriations made by law, employ, or are permitted by law to employ, either for safe-keeping, or more convenient disbursement, other agencies, and it shall become necessary for the United States to sue for the recovery of the fund, that the defendant in the action may claim, against the demand for which the actiop has been brought, any credits to which he shall prove himself entitled to, if they have been previously presented to the proper accounting officers of the treasury, and been rejected. Such is the law, as it now stands. This right was early given by an act of congress to all defendants *in suits brought by the United States. It has been repeat- ’ edly before this court. The decisions upon it need not be cited. They l apply to this case. The transfer of the deposit to the treasurer of the United States ; the letter of the postmaster-general directing it to be done ; his regulations for keeping the account, and for disbursing it, were directory to the defendants ; and their compliance with such directions, was an acknowledgment that the postmaster-general had the right to give them, as the conditions upon which they were to continue the depository of the fund. But it cannot be inferred, either from the act of 2d of July 1836, requiring that when the revenues of the post-office department have been collected, that they shall be paid, under the direction of the postmaster-general, into the treasury of the United States ; or because appropriations for p. 258the service of the department, shall be disbursed by the checks of the treasurer indorsed upon warrants of the postmaster-general, and countersigned by the auditor for the post-office department, under the words “ registered and charged; ” or from the declaration in the postmaster-general’s letter to the defendants, that no other credit, set-off or deduction will be admitted in this account. It cannot be inferred, that the defendants accepted the postmaster-general’s letter as a contract to surrender the right secured to them by the statute, to claim credits in a suit brought against them by the United -States ; or that it imposed upon them any legal obligation not to do so.
From the previous and contemporaneous correspondence between the bank and the postmaster-general, concerning these drafts, it is clear, such, was not the apprehension of the defendant, when the account was opened with the treasurer of the United States, in compliance with the postmaster-general’s letter. That was done in compliance with’the law, changing entirely the fiscal arrangements of the department; and for that purpose, the postmaster-general was the proper organ to direct it to be done ; but any condition in that letter, not required by the act of congress, under which he was acting, though officially made, is rather an evidence of what be wished to do, than a conclusion that he had the power to impose it; or that the defendant had consented to look to congress for the reimbursement of the debt due them, and not to the courts of justice. When the account was *40^1 changed *to the treasurer of the United States, there was a large J balance on deposit to the credit of the post-office department. The fund, however, was not the less that of the United States, in the one case or the other. The change, then, made no difference as to the ownership of the fund, in their right to retain, if the defendants had any right all to retain it for their debt. They had been dealing with the executive branch of the government in a matter of money, and could not be turned to the legislature, without their consent, to ask it to do as a favor, what the judiciary could settle as a right. If the defendants had supposed such was to be the consequence of carrying the fund to the treasurer’s account, it is manifest from the evidence in the case, that it would not have been done. That they did not do so, it is to be inferred also from the evidence, arose from an indisposition to enforce a right, until every effort had been made,to obtain it by amicable adjustment; and from an indisposition to embarrass a department which had been severely pressed, and was then just beginning to be relieved. The postmaster-general says, in his letter of March 19th, 1838, that, “ excepting the refusal, in common with other banks, to pay the warrants of this department in gold and silver, or an equivalent, commencing in May last, and the seizure of both a general and special deposit of moneys in the treasury to meet alleged claims, under the circumstances exhibited in the annexed papers, the Bank of Metropolis has faithfully discharged its duties as a deposit bank for this department.” The circumstances alluded to are those which have been the subject of comment in this case; and it is our opinion, that they confirm the right of the defendants to the credits claimed. There was no error, then, in the court not giving the instructions asked for, and the judgment is affirmed.
It is proper for us to say, however, if the law and the merits of the case were not with the defendants, that the court might well have refused to p. 259give the first instruction, from the manner in which it is asked. After the evidence had been closed on both sides, the court was asked to say, “ that upon the evidence aforesaid, the defendants are not entitled, in this action, to set off against the plaintiffs’ demand, the amount of acceptances aforesaid, so given in evidence by the defendants, nor the amount of the over-draft of E. F. Brown.” It raises all the issues, both of *Iaw and fact, in the case, and requires the court to adjudge the case for the plain- ‘ tiffs. This the court could not do, as there were contested facts in the case, which it was the province of the jury to decide. The court could only have said, alternatively, what was the law of the case, accordingly as the jury did or did not believe the facts ; and this, it will be admitted, would have been equivalent to a refusal of the instruction. When instructions are asked, they should be precise and certain, to a particular intent; that the point intended to be raised may be distinctly seen by the court, and that error, if one be made, may be distinctly assigned.
This cause came on to be heard, on the transcript of the record from the circuit court of the United States for the district of Columbia, holden in and for the county of Washington, and was argued by counsel: On consideration whereof, it is now here ordered and adjudged by this court, that the judgment of the said circuit court in this cause be and the same is hereby affirmed.
*
United States, Plaintiffs in error, ®. John Fitzgerald and [*407 Hipolite Fitzgerald, Defendants in error. Public lands. John Fitzgerald had been appointed, in 1833, inspector of the customs for the district of Mississippi ; and by the collector at New Orleans, he had been employed as boarding-officer at the south-west pass on the Mississippi river, and went into possession of a tract of land which had been occupied by a former boarding-officer in the service of the United States. The collector was not instructed by the treasury department to place the boarding-officer on that or any other tract of land; nor was he bound to reside there ; the United States had provided no accommodations for the boarding-officer; the collector had never, before possession was so taken, requested that the land should be reserved for the use of the boarding-officer, or of the custom-house at New Orleans. John Fitzgerald, on the 18th June 1836, entered the tract of land with the register of the land-office in New Orleans, eand he and Hipolite Fitzgerald, his wife, expended their own money on the improvement of the tract, and complied with all the requisitions of the laws of the United States granting pre-emption rights; proof was made, before the register of the land-office, of the possession and cultivation of the tract of land in 1833 ; and the purchase-money was paid to the United States. The acting commissioner of the land-office, on the 3d November 1836, wrote to the register of the land-office at New Orleans, stating that the secretary of the treasury had directed that the land should be reserved from sale, for the use of the custom-house at New Orleans, and requesting that it should be marked as reserved from sale, on the plats of land in his office. The circuit court of Louisiana dismissed the petition which had been presented by the United States, claiming this land, and decreed, that John and Hipolite Fitzgerald should be quieted in the possession of the land; and on appeal to the supreme court, the decision of the circuit court was affirmed, ho law is known to exist, which deprives an officer in the service of the United States of a right to acquire a portion of the public lands, by any mode of purchase common to other citizens. If a tract of land has been severed from the public domain, by a legal appropriation of it for any public purpose, no right can be acquired to it by cultivation or possession; because the land thus severed is not subject to the pre-emption law.
407 SUPREME COURT' [Jan’y
It cannot be pretended, that the land held by John and Hipolite Fitzgerald was reserved from sale, by an act of congress, or by order of the president; the direction of the secretary of the treasury, to reserve it from sale, several months after it had been sold and paid for, would not amount to such a reservation.
No appropriation of public land can be made for any purpose, but by authority of an act of congress. By the 3d section of the constitution of the United States, power is given to congress to dispose of, and make all needful rules and regulations respecting, the territory or other property of the United States. No authority is known to exist in any collector, under a law of congress, to make an appropriation of land for the use of the United States.1 w _ *If an act of congress had directed a light-house to be erected on the tract of land held by
J John and Hipolite Fitzgerald, before they had entered it, according to the decision of
this court in the case of Wilcox v. Jackson, 13 Pet. 498, this would have been an appropriation of the tract to the use of the United States, within the meaning of the act of congress of 29th of May 1830 ; and would have taken away the right of pre-emption.
Erkob to the Circuit Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana. The United States, by petitory action in the circuit court of Louisiana, claimed a tract of land, situated in the parish of Plaquemine, on the river Mississippi, below the port of New Orleans. This land, 160 acres, had been entered by the defendants in error, under a pre-emption right alleged to be founded on the possession and cultivation of the tract, commencing in 1833. The entry had been regularly made in the office of the register of public lands, in Louisiana, under the act of congress of 1834, on the 18th of June 1836, and the purchase-money paid to the United States.
John Fitzgerald on the 6th of May 1833, had been appointed an inspector of the customs for the port of New Orleans, and was dispatched by the collector of that port to the south-west pass of the Mississippi river, in order to discharge the duties of boarding-officer. He was stationed at a proper point on the river, and himself and his wife took possession of a house which had been occupied by a former boarding-officer, on the public lands of the United States. The government had provided no place for the residence of the boarding-officer. The land was cultivated and improved by John Fitzgerald and Hipolite Fitzgerald, his wife, in the manner which, by the laws of the United States, gave them a pre-emption right to the same, unless there had been a previous appropriation,- by the United States, of the tract for public purposes. Some months after the entry of the land and the payment of the purchase-money, the secretary of the treasury, through the acting commissioner of public lands, directed the tract to be reserved from sale for the use of the United States. *4091 The United States proceeded, by this action in the circuit court, *to
■ establish their right to the land ; alleging that Fitzgerald and his wife had acquired no right or title to the land, but that the same continued a part of the public lands of the United States. They averred, that the possession which had been taken of the land by John Fitzgerald and his .wife, had been for the use of the United States; John Fitzgerald being at the time an officer in the service of the United States.
The circuit court ordered the petition of the United States to be dismissed ; and decreed that the defendants in error should be confirmed in their title to the land. The United States prosecuted this writ of error
The case was argued by Gilpin, Attorney-General, for the United States ; and by Bell, for the defendants in error.
Gilpin, for the United States.—The mouth of the Mississippi river consists, as is well known, of five outlets or “ passes,” as they are called, which run through the narrow banks or tongues of alluvial land that stretch into the Gulf of Mexico. The principal of these, the south-west pass, extends for almost fifteen miles into the ocean, having on each side a narrow margin, chiefly of swamp. In some places, this bank between the river and the ocean, is not more than three or four hundred yards in width. Tn other places, it has greatei’ breadth. On this narrow strip, on the west side of the river, a short distance above the Balize, or extreme mouth of the Mississippi, is a spot which afforded a small space sufficiently protected to enable the boarding-officer attached to the custom-house at New Orleans, to have a sort of land station. It was so occupied, as is in evidence in this cause, as early as the year 1830 ; and by common repute, and without doubt, it had been so occupied long before. On the 2d of March 1829, congress, by law, directed a survey of the passes of the Mississippi, with a view to the improvement of their navigation, and the building of light-houses (8 Laws U. S. 202); and on the 3d of March 1831, they passed an act appropriating $40,000 for building a light-house on the south-west pass, and another near the Balize. The boarding-station at the former place may be regarded as being, in the contemplation of congress, the spot *for the former, it being, as the evidence in this case states, the only spot in that region L where such a station could be made. In the year 1833, four years after the survey, and two years after the appropriation for building the light-house, the collector of the customs at New Orleans, employed the defendant, John Fitzgerald, as an inspector, and stationed him, as the boarding-officer, in the cruising vessel at the south-west pass. He was allowed to be occasionally on shore, at a convenient place on the pass, and the spot in question had always been used for that purpose. There was a house there ; but by whom originally built does not appear. There is no evidence of its being built by the United States, nor any of its erection by the defendant. The collector says, that finding this place “so used by the boarding-officer, he continued him there, without any special instruction from the president, or the secretary of the treasury.” On the 6th of March 1834, the legislature of Louisiana passed a law, ceding the civil and criminal jurisdiction over the land to the United States.
On the 29th May 1830, an act of congress was passed (4 Story’s Laws 2213), to grant pre-emption rights to settlers on the public lands. The provisions of that act were, that every “ settler or occupant ” of the public lands, who was then in possession, and had cultivated it, in the year 1829, might enter at the land-office not more than 160 acres, to include his improvement, at the minimum price. If there were two or more persons settled on the same quarter section, it might be divided between them, and each enter eighty acres elsewhere. Before entry under the act, proof of settlement or improvement was to 'be made to the register and receiver, agreeable to the rules prescribed by the general land-office. No entry was to be made under the act, of any land which was either “ reserved for the use of the United States, or either of the several states, or reserved from sale by act of congress, or by order of the president, or which might have been appropriated for any purpose whatever.” This law was to expire in one year from its date. On the 10th June 1830, and the 14th September 1830, p. 262full rules were prescribed by the commissioners of the general land-office relative to the execution of this law, directing the precautions to be taken
- I in regard to proof of occupancy and *cultivation, what was the meanJ ing of those terms, and requiring actual payment. 2 Birchard’s Land Laws, 539, 545. On the 10th June 1834, an act was passed to .revive the pre-emption act of 1830, which gave, for two years from its passage, al the privileges of that act to every settler or occupant of the public lands who was then in possession, and had cultivated any part thereof, in the year 1833. On the 22d of July 1834, full rules were issued by the commissioner of the general land-office (2 Birchard’s Land Laws 589), as the law required, and directions were given as to the nature and mode of proof by which the pre-emptor’s right was to be ascertained. On the 29th‘ February 1836, additional rules (Ibid. 624) on the same subject were issued, as the period at which this privilege was about expiring approached ; in this, the regulations as to proof were more fully set forth, especially, in the cases where floating rights were claimed by an alleged settlement of more than one person. On the 2d June 1836, John Fitzgerald and Hipolite Fitzgerald his wife, made an affidavit before W. B. G. Taylor, a justice of the peace in the parish of Plaquemines, annexed to an application to the register and receiverat New Orleans to become the purchasers of 160 acres of land, being section 8, of township 24, range 30 east, under the provisions of the act of 19th June 1834, and stated that they had cultivated the same and were in actual possession and occupancy thereof at the date of the law. On the 3d June, the day after, a deposition was made by two persons before the same justice, stating, generally, that the facts set forth in the application of Fitzgerald and his wife were true. On the 18th of June, the day on which the act expired, an application for a float for 160 acres in addition, appears to have been made, but is not signed by either Fitzgerald or his wife. On the same day is a certificate signed by the register at New Orleans, stating, “that the foregoing lots contain 327| acres, as stated in the foregoing application, according to the returns of the surveyor-general, and that the price agreed upon is one dollar and twenty-five cents an acre.” On the 3d of November 1836, a letter was addressed to the register, by the commissioner of the general land-office, stating that the application of “John _ Walker” to enter section 8, *township 24, range 30 east, had been J received from him, but that the secretary of the treasury has directed it to be reserved from sale, as important for the use of the custom-house, and he directs him to apprize Mr. Walker, and Messrs. John and Hipolite Fitzgerald, that no entry whatever can be permitted. Fitzgerald, however, subsequent to the termination of his office as an inspector, continued to assert his right to the property as pre-emptor, which had become valuable from the light-house being erected upon it; and on the 5th of January 1837, a petition wras filed, by the district-attorney, in the circuit court of the United States, in Louisiana, setting forth this claim, denying its legality, and praying that they should be adjudged to deliver up possession of the land to the United States. On the 20th February 1837, the defendants filed their answer, in which John Fitzgerald admitted, that he was boarding-officer at the south-west pass, and stated, that he was under the necessity of “ procuring accommodations ” there, the same not being furnished by the United States ; and that he was entitled to the benefits of the pre-emption p. 263law ; they, therefore, prayed that the suit might be dismissed, and all other relief granted that the nature of the case might require. On the 29th December 18.39, the circuit court, the district judge alone sitting, gave judgment “ that the defendants be quieted in their possession of the premises in dispute, and that the plaintiffs take nothing by their petition.” On the 21st April 1840, a writ of error was issued from this court.
It is submitted, that this judgment was erroneous, because : 1. A decree to quiet the possession of the defendant, was not one which the court could properly render in this suit against the United States. 2. The defendant could not, at the time this suit was brought, claim the benefits of a pre-emptor in the land mentioned in the declaration. 3. The land mentioned in the declaration was not subject to entry, under the act of 19th June 1834.
I. A decree to quiet defendants’ possession, is not one that the court ought to have made. It is given as a mere interlocutory proceeding, while a suit to try the right of possession is pending (2 Story’s Equity 161), but in this case, it is a final decree, barring the plaintiff’s right. York v. Pilkington, 1 Atk. 284 ; * Past India Company v. Sandys, 1 Vern. 129 and note ; Anon., 2 Ves. sen. 414 ; Belknaps. Belknap, 2 Johns. •- Ch. 472. Nor was such a decree asked for by the defendants. The United States claimed the land ; the defendants were in possession ; the United States were to establish their title ; if good, to get possession ; if bad, to be refused it, and dismissed. What necessity was there for the court to give any other judgment ? It was totally uncalled for ; and if given in accordance with any peculiar practice of Louisiana, let that be shown. Such would not seem to be the case, judging from the decision of the supreme court of that state, in the ease of Cullivec v. Gavick, 11 La. 89. Unless sustained by such local practice, the precedent is a dangerous one. In ejectment, the plaintiff relies on his own title. He is prepared only to examine and present that. If he fails to make it good, his suit is lost. If the court, passing beyond this, decides upon the defendants’ title, they decide a point not necessarily before them, and which the plaintiff was not warned would be presented, or prepared to meet.
If, however, the defendants’ title was properly before the court, on what ground could it adjudge that they were entitled to possession ? Under what right were they ? It is admitted, that they had no legal title; that remained in the United States. At the most, they could have had nothing more than an equitable claim to a title ; and they had not, in fact, even that. If they had a register’s certificate, in due form, it gave them no title ; it proved merely a few facts, necessary, indeed, to theii- procuring a title, but by no means sufficient or conclusive. But by this judgment, they obtain, on such a ground, an absolute and complete title. They have a decree of a court, awarding to them a possession that nothing is to disturb. This, too, they obtain against those who have, and never have parted with, the actual fee. A patent could give them no more. This decree, therefore, to 11 quiet the defendants’ possession,” is a title equivalent to a patent, against the owner who still holds the patent ; for the United States, never having issued it, are as fully the holders of it as their grantees could be. Now, when has it been heard, that a register’s certificate is to prevail against a patent ? The acts of congress, from the beginning of the government, recognise a . patent as the complete evidence of title to the public domain ; *and *• p. 264nothing else. 1 Story’s Laws 424, 787, 818 ; 2 Ibid. 896, 1022, 1067, 1201, 1239, 1417. The holder of an unpatented location cannot dispossess him who holds under a patent; much less can he dispossess the United States, who have never issued a patent. Terrett n. Taylor, 9 Cranch 43 ; Polk n. Wendall, Ibid. 87 ; Russell v. Transylvania University, 1 Wheat. 432 ; McClung n. Silliman, 6 Ibid. 605 ; Ross v. Doe, 1 Pet. 664 ; Bagnell v. Broderick, 13 Ibid. 450 ; Wilcox n. Jackson, Ibid. 517 ; Ritchie v. Woods, 1 W. C. C. 11 ; Depassau v. Winter, 7 La. 6 ; Boatner v. Ventris, 8 La. (N. S.) 653. It was never the intention of the law, from which alone these certificates gain any force, that they should take the place of patents. They are inferior evidence. They establish certain facts ; they do not confer title. Can the district judge change their character ? Could he make them what the law never intended them to be ? He should have dismissed the plaintiffs’ application, if he deemed the evidence insufficient to sustain it; but he had no right to decree the sufficiency of the defendant’s title. In this there was error.
II. The defendant, Fitzgerald, could not, at the time the suit was brought, establish any possessory title, under the pre-emption law of 1834. He had neither done what was necessary to entitle him to its privileges, nor had he, in fact, received from any authorized officer, any legal recognition to that effect. He was not a settler ; he had made no improvement or cultivation ; he had offered no proof satisfactory to the register and receiver ; he had made no entry; and he had received no certificate. A settler is a person who takes possession, for the purposes of cultivation ; who personally occupies the land, and makes it his home, not occupying it for a cause merely temporary ; he must use it for farming purposes. In the case of Henderson v. Poindexter, 12 Wheat. 530, this court considered settlement as meaning an actual bond fide residence. Now, the evidence in this case shows, that the settlement of Fitzgerald bore no resemblance, whatever, to such occupation. Even if he cultivated this remote, inhospitable strip nf land, jutting into the ocean, it was done with no such intention on his part. He went there from necessity, as a public officer, for a public purpose. He did not go even voluntarily ; he was sent there. Can a public officer, sent for a * *public object, on to a part of the public domain, oe considered as
J a settler? Could a body of troops, stationed through the winter on public land, near the frontiers, acquire the pre-emption rights of settlers ? Do the commanders of temporary posts acquire all those rights ? Fitzgerald admits, that he went to this place as the boarding-officer ; that he took possession as such ; that he occupied the cabin as such. The collector proves, that in such capacity, he allowed such occupation. If this gives a pre-emption right, there is no occupation of public soil, for public purposes, by an officer sent upon them, that will not give it. Nor did Fitzgerald make any improvement. The house was there, when he was sent to the station ; and it is evident, that, so far from seeking to improve it, he used it merely as a temporary residence, in the intervals of his duty as the boarding-officer.
But it is not sufficient, that these things were done, had that been the case. They must have been proved, within the time limited by law, “ to the satisfaction of the register and receiver,” agreeable to the established rules. Now, of this having been done, there is not the slightest evidence.
The signature of the register does not appear to a single paper to that effect; that of the receiver is not affixed to any other document than a mere receipt for money paid. Surely, the examination by these officers, of the facts on which so great a privilege rests, as that which the law accords to preemptors, is not to be thus lightly dispensed with. 2 Birchard's Land Laws 589. Nor does this defect stop here. So far as the record enables us to discover, Fitzgerald never made any entry at all. There is evidence of an application to enter ; but there the record stops ; there is no certificate of its having been made or allowed. The document, which, in the case of Wilcox v. Jackson, 13 Pet. 505, showed so fully a compliance with all the necessary forms, is here totally wanting.
It is unnecessary to comment upon another fact connected with this pre-emption claim ; that is, the right to a float derived from an alleged separate settlement by Fitzgerald’s own wife ; because the present decree of the court does not extend to the entry under that claim.
III. But suppose, that the defendant’s right to a pre-emption was not affected, for any of the reasons stated ; could it be *located on this tract of land ? The terms of the law are very broad ; they positively L exclude, from any such location, all land reserved for the use of the United States ; or reserved from sale by any act of congress ; or appropriated for any public purpose. 4 Story’s Laws 2213. Now, what appropriation for a public purpose can be more complete than this very act of Fitzgerald’s. He is sent to the land by the collector, for a public purpose ; necessarily occupies it for that purpose. Is not this an appropriation ? In fact, the whole evidence shows, that for years and years before, it had been so used, so appropriated. The testimony of the collector at New Orleans is positive upon this point. The language of this court, in the case of Wilcox v. Jackson, 13 Pet. 511—12, shows, that wherever there is a real and permanent use of a part of the public domain for a public purpose, it is such an appropriation of it as the law intended. It is quite apparent, from the words of the act, that they were inserted for the express purpose of protecting from pre-emption settlements, such spots on the public domain as the public convenience had made it necessary, from time to time, to use ; and which, as all the land belonged to the United States, operated injuriously to no one. The act reserved from pre-emption, in express terms, every tract that had been set apart for the use of the United States, either by the president (of course, embracing the acts of the executive departments, under his actual or implied direction) or by act of congress. It then proceeded to reserve an additional class, that is, such spots as were then actually appropriated, or used for a public purpose. Of course, the positive reservation by the executive, or by law, was not necessary in the latter class of cases. This was meant to refer to cases of actual appropriation, not arising from definite and specific acts, as distinguished from reservations made by the former.
But, in fact, there does appear to have been an express reservation of this piece of ground, by the secretary of the treasury. As soon as information reached the general land-oflice, of Fitzgerald’s application, the register was informed that “ the secretary of the treasury had directed that tract of land to be reserved from sale, as it was important for the use of the custom-house, at New Orleans.” This language has evident reference, not |.$ to a reservation then first made, but to one that had been *pre- L p. 266viously made, for a well-ascertained object, of which the importance was fully recognised and already known. The light-house, too, though on an island, separated by a narrow channel from the particular spot where the cabin occupied by Fitzgerald stood, was, in fact, to be regarded as a part of the same premises. It was all a piece of land embracing a few acres, in a narrow circuit, stretching into the ocean, where alone these public objects connected with commerce could be attained. These acts, if not reservations within the express terms of the act of congress, are yet clearly such as are held to be sufficient, under the opinion of this court, in the case of Wilcox v. Jackson, 13 Pet. 498.
On the whole, therefore, it is submitted, that the court below erred, in giving, by its decree, an absolute title to the defendant, instead of merely dismissing the plaintiff’s bill ; and that, on the merits, the defendants had shown neither a sufficient title under the pre-emption law, nor a right to locate it upon the land they claimed.
licit, for the defendants in error, contended, that the land in controversy was, in 1833, part of the public land of the United States, and was subject to entry and sale, under pre-emption rights. When John Fitzgerald went to the land, and took possession of the building upon it, he did so for his own personal accommodation, and not for the use of the United States ; while it was certainly the province, in all justice, of the government, to provide a residence for the boarding-officer, at a place most convenient for the performance of his duty ; yet, having failed to do so, it became necessary for him to procure one for himself. In this, he did not act for the government ; he had no authority to act for them ; and all he did, was at his own private cost, and inured to his own personal benefit. May not a public officer purchase public lands for his individual account ? May he not cultivate and improve public land, and entitle himself to the privileges and rights of a pre-emptor ? The questions can receive but one answer: although an officer in the service of the United States, no exclusion from such rights exists by law. He enjoys them in common with every citizen of the United States.
*In fact, no appropriation of this land for public purposes, has evei -* been made. Although the directions of the secretary of the treasury
to reserve this land from sale, were given after the defendants in error had acquired a full title to the land; yet, if they had not acquired such title, the public lands cannot be appropriated to the use of the United States, by any act of the secretary of the treasury, unless specially thereto authorized by law. The public lands are, by the constitution, placed in the hands of congress ; and an act of congress is required to authorize any and every severance of any part of them from the great body of the public domain, for the special use of the government. While the president of the United States is authorized, in particular cases, to appropriate portions of the land, for the purpose and use of the government, no such right or privilege is given to the head of the treasury department.
McKinley, Justice, delivered the opinion of the court.—This is a petitory action, brought by the plaintiffs, in the circuit court of the United States for the eastern district of Louisiana, to recover 160 acres of land, claimed by the defendants, under the pre-emption law of the 19th p. 267of June 1834. In their petition, the plaintiffs allege, that the defendants, under the pretence that they were entitled to section No. 8, containing 160 acres in township 24, of range 30, by right of pre-emption, on the 18th day of June 1836, entered it with the register of the land-office at New Orleans; that the defendant, John Fitzgerald, took possession of the land as an officer of the customs, by direction of the collector at New Orleans, and not as a settler ; and that the land had, long previous to the entry, been appropriated to public purposes, and attached to the custom house at New Orleans.
The defendants admit in their answer, that John Fitzgerald was an officer of the customs, and discharged the duties of boarding-officer at the south-west pass ; where, finding no accommodations or dwelling provided for them by the United States, they were under the necessity of procuring one for themselves, in which they expended their own money That having complied with all the requisitions of the laws of the United ‘'States granting pre-emption rights, they entered the said tract of land ; and insist that, by the laws of the United States, they are entitled to it.
It was proved on the trial, that the defendant, John Fitzgerald, had been appointed, by the secretary of the treasury, inspector of customs for the district of Mississippi ; and by the collector at New Orleans, he had been appointed boarding-officer, at south-west pass, on the Mississippi river, and put into possession of the tract of land in controversy, which had been occupied by former boarding-officers. The collector was not instructed, by the treasury department, to place the boarding-officer on that tract of land, nor was he bound to reside there ; but might reside at any other place, convenient for the discharge of his duties. The collector had never requested that this land should be reserved for the use of the boarding-officer. A letter from the acting commissioner of the general land-office, dated the 3d of November 1836, directed to the register of the land-office, at New Orleans, stating that the secretary of the treasury had directed that this tract of land should be reserved from sale, for the use of the custom-house at New Orleans, and requesting the register to note upon his plats, that it was so reserved from sale, and to give notice of the fact to the defendants, was also read as evidence.
The defendants proved, that they had made proof of their possession and cultivation of the tract of land in controversy, before the register and receiver, according to law, and had entered it with the register and paid the purchase-money. Whereupon, the court below, according to the usual form of rendering judgment in such cases in Louisiana, decreed that the defendants be quieted in their possession of the premises in dispute, and that the plaintiffs take nothing by their petition. To reverse this judgment, the United States have prosecuted this writ of error.
Two objections have been taken to the judgment. 1. The defendant, John Fitzgerald, being in the service of the United States, while residing on the public land, could not, by cultivation and possession, acquire a right of pre-emption ; and if he could, this land was not subject to pre-emption, it having been appropriated to public use. *2. The court had no r*.9n power to quiet the defendants in their possession of the premises in l dispute, the fee in the land being in the United States.
No law has been produced, to show that an officer of the United States is deprived of the benefit of the pre-emption laws ; nor do we know of any
420 SUPRÊME COURT [Jan’y
law which deprives him of the right to acquire a portion of the public land, by any mode of purchase common to other citizens. Had this tract of land been severed from the public domain, by a legal appropriation of it, for any public purpose,* Fitzgerald could have acquired no right to it by cultivation and possession ; not because he was an officer of the United States, but because the land would not have been subject to the pre-emption law. Was this land so appropriated ? The pre-emption law of the 19th of May 1830, which was revived by the act of the 19th of June 1834, declares, that the right of pre-emption shall not extend to any land which is reserved from sale by act of congress, or by order of the president, or which may hava been appropriated for any purpose whatever. 4 Story’s Laws 2213. The first section of the act of the 19th of June 1834, gives to every settler or occupant of the public lands, prior to the passage of that act, who was then in possession and cultivated any part thereof, in the year 1833, all the benefits and privileges provided by the act, entitled an act to grant pre-emption rights to settlers on the public lands, approved the 29th of May 1830, and which act was thereby revived. The reservation and appropriation mentioned in the act of the 29th of May 1830, must have been valid and subsisting at the date of the act of the 19th of June 1834, to deprive the defendants of their right of pre-emption. It cannot be pretended, that the land in controversy was reserved from sale by any act of congress, or by order of the president, unless the direction of the secretary of the treasury to reserve it from sale, several months after it had been actually sold and paid for, could amount to such an order. As no reservation or appropriation of the land made, after the right of the defendants accrued, under the act of the 19th of June 1834, could defeat that right, it is useless to inquire into the authority by which the secretary of the treasury attempted to make the reservation. * , *The remaining question, under the first objection is, whether
J there had been any appropriation of this land for any purpose whatever, prior to the passage of the act of the 19th of June 1834. No appropriation of public land can be made for any purpose, but by authority of congress. By the third section of the fourth article of the constitution of the United States, power is given to congress to dispose of, and make all needful rules and regulations respecting the territory or other property belonging to the United States. As no such authority has been shown, to authorize the collector at New Orleans to appropriate this land to any use whatever, it is wholly useless to inquire whether his acts, if they had been authorized by law, would have amounted to an appropriation.
But it has been contended, in argument, that the act of the 3d of March 1831, authorizing the erection of a light-house at the mouth of the south-west pass, was an appropriation of this land for that purpose. By the plat, found in the record, it appears, that there are between forty and fifty tracts of land, containing 160 acres each, including the tract in controversy, all fronting on the south-west pass. If the act had directed that the light-house should be built on this particular tract, according to the decision of this court in the case of Wilcox n. Jackson, 13 Pet. 498, it would have been such an appropriation, within the meaning of the act of the 20th of May 1830, as would have deprived the defendants of their right of pre-emption. But the same plat shows, that the light-house was built on Wagoner’s Island,
Minis v United States.
which appears to be at the mouth of the south-west pass, and not included or connected with this or either of the other tracts of land exhibited on the plat. From this examination of the case, it is clear, that the land in controversy was neither reserved from sale nor appropriated to any purpose whatever.
As the United States have placed their right to recover in this case upon the single ground, that the land was not subject to the pre-emption right of the defendants, because it had been previously appropriated for the use of the officers attached to the custom-house at New Orleans, that point being decided against them, they ought not to prevail upon the second objection urged against the judgment; even if the judgment *were technically defective ; but it being in the usual form of judgments, in the courts L of Louisiana, and not inconsistent with the justice of the case, we think it ought not to be disturbed.
It hasnhowever, been suggested, that fraud has been practised, in some way, by the defendants, in obtaining the land in controversy. Everything on the face of the record appears to have been perfectly fair; and, so far as we can perceive, the defendants are legally entitled to a patent for the land. But if fraud has been practised upon the plaintiffs, the courts of chancery are open to them to seek a rescission of the contract. The judgment of the court below is affirmed.
This cause came on to be heard, on the transcript of the record from the circuit court of the United States for the eastern district of Louisiana, and was argued by counsel: On consideration whereof, it is now here ordered and adjudged by this court, that the judgment of the-said circuit court in this cause be and the same is hereby affirmed.