Freeland v. Heron, Lenox & Co., 11 U.S. (7 Cranch) 147 (1812)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
Freeland v. Heron, Lenox & Co., 11 U.S. (7 Cranch) 147 (1812)
Full caption
Archibald Freeland v. Heron, Lenox & Company.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1812
Archibald Freeland v. Heron, Lenox & Company.
Account stated.
An account-current, sent by a foreign merchant to a merchant in this country, and not objected to for two years, is deemed an account stated, and casts the burden of proof upon him who received and kept it without objection.1
This cause having been argued by Winder, for the appellant, and P. D. Key, for the appellees—
All the judges being present, Duval, Justice, delivered the opinion of *1481 th6 court as f°ll°ws :—*This case comes up by appeal from the
J decree of the Circuit Court for the District of Virginia. The record presents the following state of facts :
A bill in equity was filed by Heron, Lenox & Company against Archibald Freeland, the appellant, in the circuit court, in the month of December 1798. It stated, that the company consisted of Nathaniel Heron, a subject of Great Britain, Samuel Lenox, also a subject of Great Britain, and James Freeland and William Gillin. That articles of copartnership between the said company and Archibald Freeland, of Virginia, were entered into, on the 15th of February 1789, to commence on the first day of April following, and to continue for five years, unless sooner dissolved by mutual consent. It was stipulated by the articles, that the business of the copartnership should be managed and carried on, in the town of Manchester, in Virginia, by Archibald Freeland, under the firm of James Freelapd. That there should be no advance put on the goods furnished, but the charges and commission in Britain, and that all bounties, discounts and abatements which might be received, should be credited. The complainants, in their bill, further stated, that Archibald Freeland had the sole management of the affairs of the company, and the care and custody of the books and funds. That during the existence of the copartnership, Heron, Lenox & Company remitted to James & A. Freeland goods, wares and merchandise, to the amount of several thousand pounds sterling, and had received some payments, but that a considerable balance remained due to them on account of those remittances: that J. & A. Freeland had been frequently called on to account and pay the balance due. That the firm of J. & A. Freeland had been long since dissolved, by mutual consent; and that A. Freeland, retaining all the books and effects of the company, had refused to account and pay the balance due ; and they prayed relief.
To this bill, A. Freeland filed his answer, admitting the copartnership as stated, and that the business of the concern had been conducted by him, at Manchester, until the 10th day of April 1795, when, by contract, the whole of the property of the copartnery was vested in *him, for his own r* 14q use and benefit, upon the conditions therein expressed: and he in- *■ sisted that upon a fair settlement of the accounts between the complainants and him, agreeable to the custom of merchants in London, as stipulated by the said contract, he owed nothing.
It further appeared, that shipments of merchandise by Heron, Lenox & Company were made, from time to time, during the first four years of the concern, amounting in the whole to more than 19,000?. sterling, and that remittances were made by A. Freeland, in bills of exchange and country produce, during the same period, to a large amount; and that in the year 1793, the partnership was dissolved by mutual consent. A. Freeland continued to settle and liquidate the accounts of the firm, at Manchester ; and in September 1796, wrote a letter to Freeland and Gillin, of which the following is an extract : “ Your claim will be among the first of my debts that is paid—for the indulgence I have met with, I have to thank you, and mean to exert myself in order to pay off the whole as early as possible.”
During the pendency of this suit in the circuit court, a cross-bill was filed by A. Freeland against Heron, Lenox & Company for discovery, which they answered, by denying the allegations in the bill, without disclosing the evidence 'sought for. No exception, however was taken to the answer.
An order passed, directing an account to be stated by a commissioner [p. 94] appointed for the purpose, who reported that there was due from A. Freeland to Heron, Lenox & Company a balance of 1160Z. 17s. 10<?. sterling ; to which report, various exceptions were taken by the defendant. On the 14th of December 1809, the cause came on to be heard in the circuit court, upon 'the bill, answer and exhibits, and the report of the commissioner, when it was adjudged, ordered and decreed, that the defendant, A. Freeland, pay to the plaintiffs, Heron, Lenox & Co., the sum reported to be due by the commissioner, at certain specified periods, with interest from the first day of * June 1^98, and costs : and the cross-bill was *dismissed, with costs.
-* From which decree, the defendant appealed.
The exceptions taken to the report of the commissioner, in the court below, have been urged on the part of the appellant in this court, and may be comprised under the following heads :
1. That he has not given the defendant credit for all the bounties, drawbacks and duties which were allowed to the complainants on the purchase and shipment of the goods in England, which he ought to have allowed, agreeable to the contract of copartnership.
2. That the commissioner adopted a mode of calculating interest contrary to the agreement of the parties in April 1795, and prejudicial to the defendant.
3. That he allowed the complainants a commission on the sales of produce shipped directly to Cadiz, Lisbon and other places, where the property was consigned directly to persons residing in those several places ; by them sold, and who charged the ordinary commission, and who remitted the proceeds to the complainants, in London.
4. That he has not given credit to the defendant for twenty-five hogsheads of tobacco. There was another exception, but as it was abandoned in the argument by the counsel, it will not be noticed.
The appellant claims a credit of 764Z. 10s. 5d. sterling, on account of bounties, drawbacks and discounts : he has been allowed upwards of £300 sterling, and the appellees deny that he is entitled to more credit than is *1511 giyen’ ave™8 that more has not been received by *them. Each
-* insists that the onus probandi ought to be thrown on his adversary.
It is proper to observe, that it appears by the record, that Heron, Lenox & Company furnished A. Freeland with an account-current, annually, for the first four years of their transactions, and that no objection was made to them. This circumstance, combined with the promise contained in A. Freeland’s letter of September 1796, to pay the whole balance due, affords room for the application of a rule of the chancery court, and of merchants, to decide the controversy : it is this—When one merchant sends an account-current to another, residing in a different country, between whom there are mutual dealings, and he keeps it two years, without making any objections, it shall be deemed a stated account, and his silence and acquiescence shall bind him, at least, so far as to cast the onus probandi on him.
With respect to the first, third and fourth exceptions, the record does not furnish the evidence necessary to enable the court to form a correct decision from the facts. The positive assertions of the appellant are denied by the appellees ; and in proof, both are equally defective. The same rule is applicable to the third exception. After an acquiescence of several years, the account is considered as binding upon him, as he has failed to falsify [p. 95] the allegations of the appellees, that the shipments of produce to Cadiz, Lisbon and Bordeaux were made pursuant to their orders and under their superintendence.
He has failed also to prove that he is entitled to the credit insisted on in his fourth exception. To be entitled to the credit, it is incumbent on him to prove that the twenty-five hogsheads are exclusive of the eighty hogsheads of tobacco shipped in the Mercury. The record affords no testimony whatever.
With respect to the second exception, it is considered by this court, that the circuit court erred in sustaining the report of the commissioner as to the manner of stating the account between the parties. The commissioner adoped the mode established in Virginia, and which it is believed prevails generally throughout the United States : but by the written agreement of the parties, in April 1795, it is stipulated, that the interest shall be charged agreeably to the custom and manner of settling accounts in London. In all other respects, the opinion of the circuit court is affirmed.
*It is, therefore, the opinion of this court, that the decree of the circuit court with respect to the second exception be reversed, *- and that the cause be remanded to the circuit court, in order that an account may be taken pursuant to the written agreement of the parties, agreeable to the custom and manner of settling accounts in London.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access