Riddle v. Moss, 11 U.S. (7 Cranch) 206 (1812)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
Riddle v. Moss, 11 U.S. (7 Cranch) 206 (1812)
Full caption
Riddle v. Moss.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1812
Riddle v. Moss, (a)
Competency of witness.
The principal obligor in a bond is not a competent witness for the surety, in an action upon the bond; the principal being liable to the surety for costs, in case the judgment should be against him.
Error to the Circuit Court for the district of Columbia. This was an action of debt on a joint bond, given by John Welch, as principal obligor, and the defendant Moss, as his surety. The suit abated as to Welch, by the return of the marshal, that he was no inhabitant of the district. The defendant, Moss, pleaded specially certain facts in avoidance of the bond as to him alone ; upon which issue was joined ; and upon the trial, the defendant Moss offered as a witness the said John Welch, the principal obligor, who was permitted by the court below to testify for the defendant, and upon his cross-examination confessed, that he had made over to Moss all his property, as security to indemnify him against the event of this suit. The plaintiff took a bill of exceptions, and the verdict and judgment being against him, brought his writ of error to this court.
E. J. Lee and Jones, for the plaintiff in error.—Welch was clearly an interested witness. By relieving Moss from this suit, he would relieve his property from the lien which Moss held upon it. If the plaintiff recovered against Moss, the latter could immediately recover judgment against Welch for the whole debt, together with the costs of this suit. Laws of Virg., Rev. Co. 292 ; Buckland v. Tankard, 5 T. R. 578 ; Bull. N. P. 283 ; 5 Burr. 2727 ; 3 Atk. 402 ; 1 Day 81. * Welch is also interested to the amount of his legal fees for attendance as a witness. It appears upon the record, that he was regularly summoned, and is by law entitled to demand of Moss one dollar and a quarter per diem. If the plaintiff should be defeated, he will retain this to his own use, but if the plaintiff should recover judgment, he will have to refund it to Moss.
C. Lee, contrA.—The defence set up by Moss did not affect Welch’s liability upon the bond. He was bound at all events. He was not a party to this suit. Neither the verdict nor judgment could affect him. He would be
(a) March 6th, 1812. Present, all the judges.
obliged to pay either Riddle or Moss, and it was immaterial to him, which of them should recover against him. If the plaintiff should be defeated by Moss, he would sue Welch, and recover judgment, with costs ; so that it was immaterial to him, whether he paid costs to one or the other. He, therefore, stood indifferent as to interest. In chancery, one defendant is a good witness for another, and it would be as good a rule at law. Courts of law have, of late, inclined to refer all cases of doubtful interest, to the credibility, rather than to the competency of the witness. The interest should be immediate and direct, in order to exclude the witness. 3 Esp. Rep. 60.
The statute of Virginia, which gives to a surety a remedy against his principal, does not alter the case. He had an equal remedy before. In the case of Pawling v. United States, 4 Cranch 219, the point was made by a bill of exceptions to the refusal of the district court of Kentucky to admit a co-obligor as a witness, but was not decided, the judgment having been reversed upon other grounds.
March 10th, 1812. All the judges being present, Marshall, Ch. J., delivered the opinion of the court, to the following effect:—The court is of opinion, that Welch, the co-obligor, was interested, and was, therefore, an incompetent witness. *It was a consideration of some importance,
J that he had given Moss a deed of trust of his effects to indemnify him against this suit; but the principal circumstance was, that Welch’s liability would be increased, to the extent of the costs of this suit, if the judgment should be against Moss, (a)
Judgment reversed.
Sheehy v. Mandeville. (5)
Action on promissory note.— Ya/ria/nce.
A note payable at sixty days, cannot be given in evidence to support a count upon a note, which count does not state when the note was payable; the variance is fatal.
Upon executing a writ of inquiry, in Virginia, in an action of assumpsit upon a promissory note, it is necessary to produce a note corresponding with that stated in the declaration; but it is not necessary to prove the note.
The plaintiff cannot give evidence that the variance was the effect of mistake or inadvertence of the attorney, and that the note produced was that which was intended to be described in the declaration.
Error to the Circuit Court for the district of Columbia, sitting at Alexandria.
This cause having been sent back to the circuit court, by the mandate of this court, at February term 1810 (6 Cr. 253), commanding that court to render judgment for the plaintiff on his first count, and to award a writ of inquiry of damages, upon executing that writ of inquiry, the plaintiff produced the following note.
(a) The same point was also decided in the case of the Governor of Virginia v. Evans and others, at this term; which was the case of a bond with collateral condition. It was a joint action; and all the defendants were taken, but pleaded separately.
(5) March 6th, 1812. Present, all the judges.
“Alexandria, 17th July 1804.
“Sixty days after date, I promise to pay to Mr. James Sheehy, or order, six hundred and four dollars and ninety-one cents, for value received, negotiable in the bank of Alexandria. R. B. Jameson.”
The note was thus described in the declaration, “ And whereas, the said defendants, under the name, firm and style aforesaid, did, on the said 17th of July 1804, make their certain note in writing, called a promissory *note, subscribed by them under the name, style, title and firm of Robert B. Jameson, bearing date the same day and year, and then L and there delivered the said note to the plaintiff, and by the said note, did, under their firm aforesaid, promise to pay to the said plaintiff, or to his order, six hundred and four dollars and ninety-one cents for value received, negotiable at the bank of Alexandria, by reason whereof and by virtue of the law in such cases made and provided, the said defendants became liable to pay to the said plaintiff the said sum contained in the said note, according to the tenor and effect of said note;” and being so liable, &c.
Which note the court below refused to suffer the plaintiff to read in evidence to the jury, because it varied from that set forth in the declaration; to this refusal, the plaintiff excepted. The plaintiff then contended before the jury, that the existence, the execution, the amount, and the validity of the note set out in the declaration, were determined by the judgment of the court upon the demurrer, and claimed damages to the full amount of that note, without producing it. But the court, upon the motion of the defendant, instructed the jury, that it was necessary for the plaintiff to produce the note, or sufficiently account for its non-production, otherwise, the jury may and ought to presume that the note has been paid, or has been passed away by the plaintiff to a third person, for value received, and in such case, ought to assess only nominal damages. To this instruction, the plaintiff also excepted.
The plaintiff, then, in order to rebut the presumption that the note mentioned in the declaration had been paid or passed away to a third person, for a valuable consideration, produced and offered to show to the court and jury, the record and judgment on the defendant’s first and second pleas, which had been adjudged bad upon demurrer, and also the same note in the said pleas mentioned to have been the foundation of the suit and judgment set forth in the said pleas (which was a separate suit and judgment against R. B. Jameson, upon the same note, as the sole note of Jameson, and which judgment Mandeville had pleaded in bar to the present action, averring the note be the same, but which *plea was by this court adjudged bad r* 2io on demurrer), and also the fieri facias issued against Jameson upon L that judgment, with the return of nulla bona; and also offered to prove by a competent witness, that the promissory note produced to the jury, and in the said record of the suit against Jameson mentioned, is the same promissory note upon which the present declaration was founded, and the same which was intended to have been therein set out and described, and that the omission to state in the declaration, the time in which the said note was originally made payable, arose from a mere oversight of the attorney who drew the declaration, and that there was no other note ever intended to have been described in that declaration, or answering the description therein con- [p. 132] 210 L SUPREME COURT [Feb’y
tained, but the court rejected the whole of the said evidence as incompetent ; to which the plaintiff also excepted.
It being the prime object of courts to do justice, the court will decide in favor of the plaintiff, if the justice of the case be with him, unless there be some technical rule so strong as to leave the court no ground in his favor.
The jury assessed the plaintiff’s damages, and judgment was rendered accordingly at one cent only ; whereupon, he brought his writ of error.
E. J. Lee, for the plaintiff in error.—1. The first question is, whether there be any variance between the note declared upon, and that produced before the jury on the execution of the writ of inquiry ? What is, in law, a variance ? The rule is, that the allegata and probata must correspond in all material points. The note produced was payable “.sixty days after date.” The declaration does not state when it was payable. There is, therefore, no repugnance, no inconsistency, between them. To have made it a variance, the declaration should have expressly averred that the note Was payable on demand. The omission to state a fact, without a direct averment of a different fact, is not a variance. 1 Bos. & Pul. 225. He911q *The declaration leaves it uncertain when the note was payable ;
J but the note itself renders that certain which had been left uncertain on the face of the declaration. An averment is a positive statement : and is used in opposition to argument, or inference. Cowp. 683-84. From the statement in the declaration, it is only matter of inference, that the note was payable on demand. But there is no variance between the assumpsit laid and the note offered. The statement of the note in the declaration is only inducement; but in the assumpsit, it does not say when the money was to be paid. In setting forth the matter of inducement, exact certainty is not required. 5 Com. Dig. 35, C, 30.
The declaration states what, in law, is considered as a parol agreement, and the action is a general, and not a special, indebitatus assumpsit. Under the count of general indebitatus assumpsit, any evidence substantially corresponding with the cause of action set forth in the declaration, may be given in evidence. There is no variance, whenever the time or date is uncertainly set forth or omitted. It may be supplied by pleading, or by finding, and therefore, in order to render, by finding, that certain, which is omitted, or which does not correspond with the statement in the' narration, evidence must be heard. Cromwell v. Grumsden, 1 Lord Raym. 335. If a patent be pleaded without a date, and the one produced has a date, it is not a variance. 5 Com. Dig. 395. Everything is form, without which the right of action appears to the court. Hob. 233-35 ; Com. Dig. 139. This suit was brought, after the note became due, therefore, the time of payment was then not material to the plaintiff’s right of action. The promise, for a valuable consideration, gives the right of action. The time of payment was not material, and could not have been put in issue. 5 Com. Dig. 27.
The omission is cured by the statute of jeofails. Virg. Laws, 112, § 26. .. If, after verdict, the plaintiff could not be required to *show such a J note as is set forth in the declaration, so, upon a judgment by confession, nil dicit, or non sum informatus, he is not bound to show such a note.
2. If there be a variance, it is not a material one. Evans v. Smith, • [p. 133] 1 Wash. 72. In the bond in that case, the obligor was stated to be “ of the county of Essex,” which part of the description was omitted in the declaration, and it was held to be an immaterial variance.
It is only necessary to prove substantially the cause of action declared upon. Me Williams v. Willis, 1 Wash. 199. In that case, the agreement •was made by Willis, “ as treasurer of the jockey-club.” The declaration omitted1 this description, and it was holden no variance. The reason was, that he was equally liable, whether he contracted as treasurer or not. So, in this case, the defendant was equally liable, whether the note was payable in sixty days, or on demand, the sixty days having expired before the suit was brought.
In the case of Peter v. Cocke, 1 Wash. 257, the suit was upon a bond given to U. P. “ of the county of Surrey, on account of Messrs. G. & P., merchants in Glasgow.” The declaration stated the bond to be given to W. P., without stating on whose account; yet it was holden no variance.
In the case of Wroe v. Washington and others, 1 Wash. 357, the declaration stated an agreement by which the appellant was to rent and furnish a house in Leedstown, and entertain one of the appellees, two of their storekeepers, and a servant, with meat and drink, for one year, for which the appellees agreed to pay him, for the first three, 25?. each, and for the last, 8?. The evidence offered did not show any agreement respecting the renting of a house at Leedstown ; but it showed an agreement to pay 83?. in gross : held, no variance.
The date of a deed is not of its substance. Goddard's Case, 2 Co. 5 a. Upon the same principle, the time of payment is not of the substance of a contract. A variance between the date of the bond declared *upon, r*2ig and that cited in the award, is not fatal, if they agree in every other L particular. Ross v. Overton, 3 Call 309 ; Lyons v. Gregory, 3 Hen. & Munf. 237. In the case of Baptiste n. Cobbold, 1 Bos. & Pul. 7, the contract stated in the declaration was for 52?. 10s. for rum-money ; the evidence was a note by which the defendant agreed to allow the plaintiff the above sum ; together with a pint of ruin per day ; and held no variance.
The grounds upon which the law requires that the probata should agree with the allegata, are, 1. To apprise the defendant of the nature of the charge ; and 2. To enable him, by a reference to the record itself, to plead the judgment in bar of another action for the same cause. The declaration in this case did apprise the defendant of the nature of the charge ; for he appeared and pleaded to the action, and by his plea identified the note. The second object is obtained by the record, by which it appears, that the note offered in evidence is that which was declared upon. If this note had been received in evidence, it would have been filed, and formed a part of the proceedings which the clerk is bound, by the statute of Virginia, to retain. If the reason of the rule requiring the allegata and probata to correspond, is attained in this case, and if there was no danger of a second suit being maintained upon the came cause of action, against the defendant, the variance cannot be material.
3. The plaintiff was not bound to produce, upon the execution of the writ of inquiry, the note or the evidence of the debt. Where there is judgment by default, in an action upon the case on a promissory note, the court will (without a jury) direct the clerk to ascertain the damages. 1 H. Bl. [p. 134] 252, 529, 541. These cases were decided upon the ground, that the amount claimed in the declaration is admitted in the same manner, as if the action was debt; because a sum certain is demanded, and it is not like the case, where the cause of action sounds in damages, and not in contract, ascertain, ing on its face the amount claimed.
*Upon executing a writ of inquiry, the plaintiff is not bound to
J prove his cause of action, because it is admitted as laid. Cro. Jac. 220. If the cause of action is admitted, and the note not required to be proved, and it is to be produced for no other purpose than to see whether there is any credit on it, and there should be a difference in the date ; yet it is not a variance, because a variance can exist only where proof is to be made.
The case of Green v. Hearne, 3 T. R. 301, shows that upon a writ of inquiry, it is not necessary to prove the bill of exchange ; that a variance between that declared upon, and that produced, is not material, and that evidence dehors the bill is admissible, to prove that the bill produced is that which was declared upon. Mills v. Lyne, Bayley on Bills, appendix No. 7, p. 74; Kyd on Bills 155 ; 2 W. Bl. 748 ; Bevis v. Lindsell, 2 Str. 1149 ; Bayley 66-7. All these cases show, that after judgment by default, a promissory note set out in a declaration need not be produced. Sayer on Damages 112, 113, says, where there is judgment upon demurrer, the justices may award damages ; the amount of the damages laid in the declaration is admitted.
4. The court erred in directing the jury, that they were bound to presume, from the non-production of the note declared upon, that it was paid or had been assigned away by the plaintiff to a third person, for a valuable consideration, unless the non-production was sufficiently accounted for. The non-production of the note was only a circumstance to be left to the jury, to draw such inference from, as they should think proper, under the whole of the circumstances attending the cas'e. The court undertook to decide on the weight and effect of this negative kind of evidence. Presumptive evidence is always left to the jury. Hull v. Horner, Cowp. 109.
5. The court ought to have admitted the evidence offered, to show that this was the note intended by the description in the declaration ; especially, *2151 defendant’s own pleas, in which he affirms the note described in*
J the declaration to be the same note upon which judgment was obtained against Jameson, which is the same note which was produced to the jury on the execution of this writ of inquiry. In the former opinion, the court admitted the principle, that it was competent for the plaintiff to account for the non-production of such a note as is described in the declaration ; and yet when the plaintiff offers evidence to account for its non-production, the court reject it.
A finding by a special verdict, or an admission in former pleadings is good evidence, unless the contrary appears. Lee v. Boothby, 1 Keble 720, pl. 50.
Swann, contra.—No time of payment being mentioned in the note, it is to be taken as a note payable on demand. The note produced was payable at sixty days. Such a variance is fatal upon an issue. 3 Selwyn’s Nisi Prius 999.
The principal question is, whether it be necessary to produce the note, on the execution of a writ of inquiry. The practice in Virginia is, to produce [p. 135] the note. Such also is the practice in England. Esp. N. P. 180, tit. Assumpsit; 2 Str. 1149. The cases from Bayley, &c., only show that the note need not be proved ; this we admit; but still we contend, it ought to be produced. The judgment upon the demurrer does not admit the amount of the damages.
Jones, in reply.—1. There was no material variance. The description of the note in the declaration, as far as it goes, is correct. The time and mode of payment are no part of the substance of the contract necessary to be set forth. It is only necessary to sdt forth the legal effect of the note, and as the sixty days had expired before the suit was brought, it was in effect a note payable on demand. Bristow v. Wright, 2 Doug. 670. *2. Upon such special counts, for a precise sum, it is not necessary to produce proof *■ upon the writ of inquiry. The judgment by default confesses the whole sum, as well as the cause of action. In debt, and indebitatus assumpsit, you could not recover less than the precise sum stated in the declaration ; and therefore, a judgment by default confessed the whole. And although the courts have relaxed as to those counts, and you may now recover less, yet when the declaration is for a precise sum, a judgment by default carries the whole. The rule to produce the note is only a matter of discretion; a mere rule of practice, intended to prevent injustice.
March 14th, 1812. All the judges being present, Marshall, Ch. J., delivered the opinion of the court, as follows :—This suit was instituted on a promissory note, executed by the defendant, and made payable to the plaintiff. After describing the note accurately, with the exception of the time when it became payable, which is altogether omitted, the declaration proceeds, in the usual form, to state, that the defendant, being so liable, assumed to pay the sum mentioned in the note, when he should be thereunto required, &c. To this count, a special plea was filed, which, on demurrer, was held sufficient. Judgment, on the demurrer, being rendered for the plaintiff, and writ of inquiry was awarded. On executing this writ, the plaintiff produced a note payable sixty days after date, and offered to prove that it was the note on which the suit was instituted, and that the omission to state the day of payment in the declaration was the mistake of counsel. The court refused to permit the note to go to the jury ; and also instructed them, that unless a note conforming to the declaration should be adduced, or its absence accounted for, they must presume it to have been passed away or paid. The jury, under these instructions *found one cent damages, for which r* 917 judgment was rendered. To this judgment, the plaintiff has sued out a writ of error.
The errors assigned are, 1st. That the variance was not fatal; 2d. That on a writ of inquiry the production of the note was unnecessary. Courts, being established for the purpose of administering real justice to individuals, will feel much reluctance at the necessity of deciding a cause on a slip in pleading, or on the inadvertence of counsel. They can permit a cause to go off on such points, only when some rule of law, the observance of which is deemed essential to the general administration of justice, peremptorily requires it. One of these rules is, that in all actions on special agreements or written contracts, the contract given in evidence must correspond with that stated in the declaration. The reason of this rule is too familiar to every lawyer, to require that it should be repeated.
It is not necessary to recite the contract in haic verba, but if it be recited, the recital must be strictly accurate. If the instrument be declared on, according to its legal effect, that effect must be truly stated. If there, be a failure in the one respect, or the other, an exception, for the variance, may be taken, and the plaintiff cannot give the instrument in evidence. The plea of non assumpsit denies the contract; and an instrument, not conforming to the declaration, either in words, where it is recited, or according to its legal effect, where the legal effect is stated, although proved to be the act of the defendant, is not the same act, and therefore, does not maintain the issue on his part.
In this case, the legal effect of the promissory note is stated ; and that effect, on a note, having no day of payment, would be, that it was payable immediately. This declaration goes on that idea, and avers a promise to pay, when required. A note payable sixty days after date, is a note differ* ent from one payable immediately, *and would not support the issue,
J had non assumpsit been pleaded, and issue joined on this plea.
Now, what difference is produced by the default of the defendant ? He confesses the note stated in the declaration, but he confesses no other note. The necessity, then, of showing a note conforming to the declaration, is precisely as strong on executing a writ of inquiry, as on trying the issue. No reason is perceived why a variance which would be fatal in the one case, would not be equally fatal in the other.
The cases cited by the plaintiff’s counsel have been considered, but they do not come up to this. They are not cases where the legal effect of the written instrument, offered on executing the writ of inquiry, has differed from that of the instrument stated in the declaration.
The court is also of opinion, that the production of the note, on executing the writ of inquiry, was necessary. The default dispenses with the proof of the note, but not with its production. In England, damages have* in some circumstances, been assessed without a jury, but it is not stated, that those damages have been assessed, without a view of the note. The practice of this country is, to require that the note should be produced; or its absence accounted for, and the rule is a safe one.
Judgment affirmed.
1
To make an instrument, in the nature of from the circumstances. Wheeland v. Swartz, a mortgage, a conditional sale, the intention 1 Yeates 579. In a doubtful case, it will of the parties, at the time of contracting, be construed as a mortgage, rather than a must be clearly proved, or necessarily implied conditional sale. Matthews v. Sheehan, 69
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access