VriLLiAM & James Brown & Co. v. McGran, 39 U.S. (14 Pet.) 479
Case details
Bluebook Citation
VriLLiAM & James Brown & Co. v. McGran, 39 U.S. (14 Pet.) 479
Full caption
VriLLiAM and James Brown & Co., Plaintiffs in error, v. Thomas McGran, Defendant in error.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
*479] *VriLLiAM and James Brown & Co., Plaintiffs in error, v. Thomas
McGran, Defendant in error.
Principal andfactor.—Construction of instruments.
An action was instituted against the consignees of 200 bales of cotton, shipped, by the direction of the owner, to Liverpool, on which the owner had received an advance by an acceptance of his bills on New York; which acceptance was paid out by bills drawn on the consignees of the cotton in Liverpool. Some time after the shipment of the cotton, the owner wrote to the consignees in Liverpool, expressing his “ wishes ” that the cotton should not be sold, until they should hear further from him ; in answer to this letter, the consignees said, “ your wishes in respect to the cotton are noted accordingly no other provision than from the sale of the cotton, for the payment of the advance, was made by the consignor, when the same was shipped; and no instructions for its reservation from sale were, given, when the shipment was made. Immediately after the acceptance of the bill drawn against the cotton, on the consignees in Liverpool, they sold the same for a profit of about ten per cent, on the shipment r cotton rose in price, in Liverpool, to more than fifty per cent, profit on the invoice, between t e p. 403acceptance of the bill of exchange, and the arrival of the same at maturity. The shipper instituted an action against the consignees, for the recovery of the difference between the actual sales and the sum the same would have brought, had it been sold at the subsequent high prices at Liverpool.
It is certainly true, as a general rule, that the interpretation of written instruments properly belongs to the court, and not to the jury; but there certainly are cases, in which, from the different senses of the words used, or their obscure or indeterminable reference to unexplained circumstances, the true interpretation of the language may be left to the consideration of the jury, for the purpose of carrying into effect the real intention of the parties. This is especially applicable to cases of commercial correspondence, where the real objects, and intentions and agreements of the parties are often to be arrived at, only by allusions to circumstances which are but Imperfectly developed.1 There can be no reasonable doubt, that in particular circumstances, a wish expressed by a consignor to a factor, may amount to a positive command.
In the case of a simple consignment of goods, without any interest in the consignee, or any advance or liability incurred on account thereof, the wishes of the consignor may fairly be presumed to be orders; and the “ noting the wishes accordingly,” by the consignees, an assent to follow them ; but very different considerations apply where the consignee is one clothed with a special interest, and a special property, founded upon advances and liabilities. Whenever a consignment is made to a factor, for sale, the consignor has a right, generally, to control the sale thereof, according to his own pleasure, from time to time, if no advances have been made, or liabsiities incurred, on account thereof; and the factor is bound to obey his orders; this arises from the ordinary relation of principal and agent. If, however, the factor makes advances, or incurs liabilities on account of the consignment, by which he acquires a special property in the goods, then the factor has a right to sell so much of the consignment as may be necessary to reimburse such advances, or meet such liabilities; unless there be some agreement between himself and the consignor which contracts or varies the right.2 If, contemporaneously with the consignment and advances or liabilities, there are orders given by the consignor, which are assented to by the factor, that the goods shall not be sold, before a fixed time, in such a case, the consignment is presumed to be received, subject to su h order; and the factor is not at liberty to sell the goods to reimburse his advances, until after that time has elapsed. So, when orders are given, not to sell below a fixed price ; unless the , consignor shall, after due notice and request, refuse to provide other means to reimburse the factor. In no case, will the factor be at liberty to sell the consignment, contrary to the
1
2
Where factors have made large advances, imbursement of his advances. And where the or incurred expenses on account of the con- consignor does not desire to subject himself to signment, the principal cannot, by any sub- such liabilities, he should make special arrange-sequent orders, control their right to sell, ments to meet his own views in relation thereat such time, as in the exercise of a sound to. After receiving an advance on his goods, discretion, and in accordance with the usage the power of the consignor, in the absence of of trade, they may deem best to secure indem- a special agreement to limit the prices at which nity to themselves and to promote the interests they shall be sold, is at an end. He can imof the consignor; they acting, of course, in pose no new terms on his consignee; the latter good faith and with reasonable skill. Field v. is bound no further to his principal, than to Farrington, 1 Pars. 141. There is no doubt, use all due and proper diligence, skill and that such a course of dealing may exist between attention, in selling the goods thus consigned, consignor and consignee, as would restrain the at the best rate the market affords, and in the latter from selling at less than the invoice manner required by the established customs prices, without further advice; but all such and usages of trade. Smedley v. Williams, 1 cases must depend on their own special cir- Pars. (Pa.) 364-5. King, P. J. Nor can an cumstances, such ns the usual course of previous attaching creditor of the consignor arrest the dealings between the parties, the usages of the sale, without tendering to the consignee a re-particular business, &c. The consignment of payment of his advances. Baugh v. Kirkgoods on which advances are asked and receiv- patrick, 54 Penn. St. 84. And see Blackwell sd, involves the right in the consignee to sell v. Thomas, 28 N. Y. 67 ; Williams v. Tilt, 36 the goods in the usual and accustomed manner, Id. 319. and at the regular market rates, in order to residing in that state. The defendants pleaded the general issue, and the cause having been tried in the circuit court, the jury gave a verdict for the plaintiff, Ihomas
orders of the consignor, although he has made advances or incurred liabilities thereon, if the consignor stands ready and offers to reimburse and discharge such advances and liabilities. When the consignment is made, generally, without any specific orders as to the time and mode
of sale, and the factor makes advances or incurs liabilities on the footing of such *con-
J signment, the legal presumption is, that the factor is intended to be clothed with the
ordinary rights of factors, to sell, in the exercise of a sound discretion, at such time, and in such manner, as the usage of trade and his general duty require, and to reimburse himself for his liabilities, out of the proceeds of the sale; and the consignor has no right, by any subsequent orders, given after advances have been made, or liabilities incurred, by the factor, to suspend or control this right of sale, except so far as respects the surplus of the consignment, not necessary for the reimbursement of such advances or liabilities.
If a sale of cotton in Liverpool, by a factor, has been made on a particular day, tortiously, and against the orders of the owner, the owner has a right to claim damages for the value of the cotton on the day the sale was made, as for a tortious conversion; if the sale of the cotton by the factor was authorized, on a subsequent day, and the cotton had been sold against orders, before that day, the damages to which the owner would be entitled would be regulated by the price of cotton on that day; but the rate of damages is not to be obtained from the prices of cotton at any time between the day when the cotton was sold, against the orders of the owner, and the day on which the sale was authorized by him.
Error to the Circuit Court of Georgia. In the inferior court of Richmond county, in the state of Georgia, Thomas McGran, the defendant, instituted a suit, by attachment, against the plaintiffs in error, to recover damages for the sale of two hundred bales of cotton, shipped by him to the plaintiffs in error, as his factors ; the cotton having been sold for a less price than the same would have produced, had the sales been made according to the instructions of the shipper.
The declaration contained three counts, all upon the shipment of the two hundred bales of cotton, by Thomas McGran to William and James Brown & Company, at Liverpool, as the factors of the shipper. The first count alleged, that while the cotton remained in the hands of the consignees, the shipper ordered him to hold the cotton until they should hear from him again ; but the same was sold in violation of the order, and to the damage of the shipper. The second count charged the consignees with not having exercised reasonable diligence in keeping and selling the cotton ; but that they dealt with the same so negligently and carelessly, so that it was sold at a loss to the shipper. The third count alleged, that the consignees did not sell the cotton to the best interests of the shipper, nor did they obey his instructions ; but on the contrary, managed the same carelessly and negligently, and sold the same, contrary to orders, with a reasonable prospect of rise of the article, for $3000 less than the value of the cotton, at the time the same was sold.
The case was removed, under the provisions of the judiciary act of 1789, to the circuit court of the United States for the district of Georgia; the defendants below not being citizens of the state of Georgia, and not p. 405at Liverpool, as his factors, to be sold by them under a del credere commission. That this cotton was received by them, about the 9th of April 1833, and cost, per invoice, $9151.77. That the plaintiffs in error, through Brown, Brothers & Company, their house in New York, accepted, early in March 1833, a draft of defendant in error, for $9000, drawn against said cotton, upon their said house in New York ; that when this draft arrived at maturity, the said house in New York paid the same, and in order to reimburse themselves, and in pursuance of an arrangement between plaintiffs in error and defendant in error, drew upon the plaintiffs in error, at Liverpool at sixty days’ sight, for 187U. Os. ^d. This draft was dated May 7th, 1833, was accepted by plaintiffs in error, at Liverpool, June 3d, 1833, and fell due and was paid by them on the 5th of August following. That by the contract between the plaintiffs in error, and the defendant in error, the cotton in question became pledged by the defendant in error to the plaintiffs in error, to enable them to meet their acceptances and repay their advance thereon. After shipping the cotton and drawing against it as aforesaid, the defendant in error became insolvent.
*
, McGran, under the directions of the court, for $4975.57.* *The defend$1-1 ants excepted to the ruling of the circuit court, on questions su - mitted during the trial of this cause, and they prosecuted this writ o error. On the trial, it was given in evidence, that two hundred bales of cotton were shipped by defendant in error, from Mobile, to the plaintiffs in error.
On June 3d, 1833, plaintiffs in error sold said two hundred bales of cotton for 2073Z. 4s. ^d., cash, September 16th, 1833 ; being a profit of about ten per cent. On the same day on which they sold this cotton, they sold 677 bales, in which their Baltimore house was interested ; and, in a wreek previous, had sold 216 bales, in which their Baltimore house was also interested. At the time of the sale of the 200 bales of cotton, the defendant in error was indebted to plaintiffs in error in a large sum. During the week in which the 200 bales were sold, the sales of cotton amounted to 47,250 bales ; a larger amount than in any previous week for about eight years. '
On April 20th, 1833, the defendant in error wrote to plaintiffs in error : “If you have any cottons on hand, when this reaches you, in which I am interested, I wTish you to hold them until you hear from me again.” This letter was received by William and James Brown & Company, on the 23d of May 1833 ; and on the day following, the 24th of May 1833, they wrote to Thomas McGran : “We are in possession *of your esteemed favor r*.R9 of the 20th ultimo, and your wishes in respect to the cotton we now hold on your account, are noted accordingly.” On June 9th, following, the plaintiffs in error wrote to defendant, annexing a circular, showing the extensive business done in cotton during the week, and a material improvement in prices ; and informed him, that, believing this advance would probably equal the expectations he had formed when he last wrote, and thinking it desirable to close his cotton in their bands, as they had then been drawn upon for the advance on it, they had taken advantage of this brisk demand to dispose of the 200 bales at an advance of one-half to five-eighths of a penny per pound upon its value when first landed. On July 30th, 1833, the defendant in error replied to the last letter, referring to his previous letter of April 20th, and asked of plaintiffs in error, “ why did you sacrifice my cottons, as the draft drawn by Brown, Brothers & Company, at sixty days, on account of these cottons, could not have been accepted more than a day or two before? Therefore, you had sixty days before you had any money to pay for me.” He adds, “ I do not recognise the sale ; and do not consider you authorized to sell the cotton before the time the draft drawn on you by Brown, Brothers & Company, against this cotton, falls due. If the p. 406price is higher ou that day than the day you sold it, I will expect you to allow me the difference ; and if it is lower, I will be prepared to pay you any balance J may owe you.” On September 4th, 1833, the plaintiffs in error replied, that there had been a balance due to them from defendant; that the 200 bales were sold at an advance, and barely squared the accounts. That defendant had been obliged to stop payment, that any loss would be certain to fall on them, and profit not likely to go to him, but to his creditors. That the cotton was not sacrificed, but sold at a profit, such as is not frequently realized on that article ; that they sold some on account of their Baltimore house, and some immediately before, and immediately after, in which their said Baltimore house was interested. That near 50,000 bales changed hands in the same week. That, situated as the defendant in error then was, he could not reasonably have expected them to hold the cotton, without pointing out in what manner they should be indemnified in event of loss thereby. That the fact that Brown, Brothers & Company’s draft was not due, did not alter the case, as they had become responsible some months before, by Brown, Brothers & Company’s acceptance of the draft of the shippers. On July 22d, 1833, the defendant in error wrote to plaintiffs, that he had received their favor of the 24th of May, and noted the contents. That they would please to sell the 200 bales soon after the receipt of the letter, unless they were of opinion they could do better by holding a little longer. This letter was received by the plaintiffs in error, August 23d, 1833.
*The counsel for the defendant below prayed the court to
J instruct the jury, that the matters given in evidence on the part of the defendants were sufficient, and ought to be admitted to bar the plaintiff’s action ; which instruction the court refused to give.
And the court further refused to instruct the jury : 1. That the advance by the house of Browns, in New York, was in effect an advance by the house in Liverpool; and after the advance so made, the shipper had no right to alter the instructions which were given at the time of such advance. 2. That the house in Liverpool having advanced so large an amount on this cotton, having a large previous unsettled claim against the shipper, and the said shipper having afterwards, and before the sale of the cotton, become insolvent ; the house in Liverpool had a right to sell for their reimbursement, notwithstanding the subsequent orders of the shipper.
And the court instructed the jury, that it was their exclusive province to decide from the evidence in the cause, whether the defendants had advanced any money to the plaintiff on the cotton shipped by the Mary and Harriet. Whether, when the defendants sold said cotton, the plaintiff was indebted to them upon a previous unsettled claim, and whether the plaintiff had become insolvent before the sale of said cotton ; and also further instructed the jury, that if they found from the evidence in the cause, that the plaintiff had given instructions to the defendants, by his letter of the 20th of April 1833, not to sell any cottons which the defendants might have on hand when that letter reached them, in which the plaintiff was interested, until the defendants heard from him again, and that such instructions weie received and recognised by the defendants, by the evidence in the cause, and particularly by a letter given in evidence as one from the defendants to the plaintiff, dated the 24th of May 1833, in reply to the plaintiffs letter p. 407to them of the, 20th of April 1833 ; that then the defendants were not justifiable in law in the sale of the 3d of June 1833, on account of the defendants having on that day accepted Brown, Brothers & Company’s draft for 18714 Os. 9c?., dated 7th of May 1833, at sixty days’ sight. And the court further instructed the jury, that if they found from the evidence in the cause, that cottons were selling for a higher price from the 3d June 1833, when the draft was accepted, and when the cotton was sold, until the time when the said draft was mature and payable, and if the evidence in the cause ascertained, at any time before the maturity of the draft, what such higher price was, and that the cotton belonging to the plaintiff could have been sold for such higher price ; that then the plaintiff was entitled to recover from the defendants the difference in price between the sum for which the defendants sold the plaintiff’s cotton, and the sum at which it might have been sold before or at the maturity of the draft. The defendants In the circuit court excepted to these instructions.
*The case was argued by G. W. Brown, for the plaintiffs in error ; and by Jones, for the defendant. L
Brown contended : 1. That although an agent is generally bound to conform to the instructions of his principal, the circumstances of this case were such as to give the plaintiffs in error a right to sell the cotton in question, notwithstanding the letter of the defendant in error, of April 20th, 1833. The cotton was shipped by McGran to the Browns, as his factors ; and this circumstance alone was equivalent to an authority to sell. The definition of a factor is, “ an agent who is commissioned by a merchant or other person to sell goods for him, and to receive the proceeds.” Selw. N. . P. 827. If, at the time when the consignment "was made, the consignor had given instructions as to the manner or time of sale, the consignees would have been bound to comply with them. But no such instructions were given. This was a general consignment ; and the evidence discloses the fact, that, upon the faith of this consignment, the Browns accepted bills to the amount of nearly the full value of the cotton. The invoice cost of the cotton was $9151.77 ; the bill drawn against it amounted to $9000. The evidence further shows (and all the evidence in the case was offered by the defendant in error) that this bill was accepted by the plaintiffs in error, through their house in New York of Brown, Brothers & Company. When this bill arrived at maturity, it was paid by the house in New York, who, in order to reimburse themselves, drew a bill upon the plaintiffs in error, dated May 7th, 1833, at sixty days’ sight, for 18714 0s. 9<4, which was accepted by them, June 3d, 1833, and fell due and was paid on the 5th of August following. This arrangement was in conformity with the contract made by the parties, was in accordance with the regular course of trade, and was highly advantageous to the shipper. The cotton arrived at Liverpool, April 9th, 1833, and was not sold until June 3d—a period of fifty-five days. At the time of the sale, McGran was indebted to the plaintiffs in error in a considerable balance, and had become insolvent.
Under these circumstances, it is contended, that the plaintiffs in error ; acquired a special property in the cotton, with a power of sale, in order to reimburse themselves for the advance made through their house in New York, and to put themselves in funds to meet their acceptance of the bill p. 408drawn by said house against the shipment. 2 Kent’s Com. 640, 642 ; Story ii on Bailments 204-5, 218 ; Story on Agency 382 ; Parker v. Brancher, 22"
Pick.; 40 ; 3 Chitty on Com. & Manuf. 551; Pothonier v. Dawson, Holt 383^ Zoit v. Millauden, 16 Mart. 470.
The contract of the consignees with the consignor, in effect amounted to this : “We will consent to accept to such an amount *upon your
-I consignment, provided we have the right of selling, in order to put ourselves in funds to meet our acceptance.” That such a right to sell existed, seems to be admitted by McGran throughout the correspondence notwithstanding his complaints as to the time when the sale was made. Upon the principles of commercial law, McGran, having drawn upon the Messrs. Brown without having funds in their hands, was bound to put them in funds to meet the bill so drawn. Bainbridge n. Wilcocks, 1 Bald. 538.
There is a strong analogy between the case of a consignment of goods,, to secure an acceptance or advances, and the case of a mortgage with a
power to sell annexed. Drinkwater v. Goodwin, Cowp. 256. In both cases,,
there is a power to sell, coupled with an interest or estate in the thing
203. This power was irrevocable ; it could not be affected by the express
revocation of McGran, nor by the death of bankruptcy of the consignor or
consignees. Story on Agency 387, 504 ; 1 Bell’s Com. § 413 (4th edit.).
And, d fortiori, it could not be revoked by the mere expression of McGran’s
wishes, contained in his letter of April 20th. McGran does not “ order”
nor “ directhe does not even “ request;” but makes use of the mildest
word that can express the idea of desire ; he simply “wishes.” But it will
be contended, that McGran’s wishes became binding upon the plaintiffs in
error, upon their supposed assent contained in their reply of May 24th, 1833.
They there say, that they had received the letter of defendant in error, and
that his wishes in respect to the cotton they then held on his account were
“ noted accordingly.” The expression means nothing more than that they
observed the wishes of their correspondent, as contained in his letter;.
they do not promise to comply with them in all events; they reserve to them-
selves the privilege of giving effect to them or not, as might be consistent
with the protection of their own interests and legal rights. The expression
“to note” never properly means to assent; and no usage can be found to
justify our attaching to it such a signification in this case. Crabbe’s Syn.;
Webster’s Diet. There are many much stronger cases in the law, where similar expressions have been decided not to be equivalent to an assent. Perring v. Hone, 4 Bing. 18, Opinion of Best, J.; Rees n. Warwick, 2 Barn. & Aid. 133 ; observed upon by Parke, J., in Fairlie v. Herring, 13 Eng. C. L. 78 ; Powell v. Jones, 1 Esp. 17 ; 2 Pardessus, Cours de Droit Commercial, 171.
But if, in mercantile language, the expression conveys the idea of assent, there should be some evidence offered of that fact. The learned judge before whom the case was tried, erred in leaving it to the jury to say : 1st. Whether the defendant in error, by his letter of April 20th, instructed the plaintiffs in error ; and 2d. Whether the plaintiffs in error recognised these instructions; when no evidence whatever was laid before the jury to * ~ en^g^ten them as to the meaning of the expressions used. Story on
-* Agency, 63, 72, note 1 ; * Ekins v. Macklish, Ambl. 184-5 ; Mechan- p. 4091840] OF THE UNITED STATES. W
ics* Bank v. Bank of Columbia, 5 Wheat. 326 ; Lucas v. Groning, 7 Taunt, 164; Macbeath v. Haldlmand, 1 T. R. 172. McGran, in his letter of July 30th, in which he complains of the sale of the cotton, really admits the right© of the Browns to sell,* in order to meet the bill drawn on them. He says, “ I do not recognise the sale, and do not consider you authorized to sell the cotton before the draft drawn on you by Brown, Brothers & Company, against this cotton, falls due. If the price is higher on that day than the day you sold it, I will expect you to allow me the difference ; and if it is lower, I will be prepared to pay you any balance I may owe you.” Now, this abandons the whole ground. McGran, by his letter of April 20th, had instructed, as it is contended on the other side, the plaintiffs in error, not to sell until they heard from him again. They did not hear from him again until August 23d, when his next letter, dated July 22d, and ordering them to sell, was received. Now, the plaintiffs in error were bound by the instructions of McGran, or they were not. If they were bound, they had no right to sell until August 23d, when his orders to sell were received. If they were not bound, as McGran admits (for he concedes that they had a right to sell at the date af the maturity of the draft, August 5th), then they were to use their own discretion, as skilful and honest factors, as to the time of sale. McGran admits they had a right to sell, in order to meet the bill, notwithstanding his instructions ; but limits them to a single day —that of the maturity of the draft. This position is absurd. On that day, it might have happened, that no purchasers could be found, or that the cotton had fallen so low that the whole would not produce enough to meet the bill. Again, if McGran had the right to instruct his factors to hold his cotton for four months, he would have had the same right to instruct them to hold it for four years. He might have done so with little inconvenience to himself ; for he had received as an advance nearly the whole invoice cost. This argument derives much additional force, from the fact that McGran,• _ at the timee when the • order not to sell was O'given, had become insolvent, and was in debt to plaintiffs in error.
The policy of the law will induce the court to uphold the sale. The Messrs. Brown acted in good faith, and, no doubt, with prudence, although the result proved unsatisfactory. They did all that could be expected, for they acted for McGran precisely as they did for themselves. On the same day, they sold 677 bales, on account of nine different parties, in part of which their Baltimore house was interested ; and, within a wreek previously, 215 bales, in which the Baltimore house was also concerned. A larger business was done at Liverpool in cotton, during the week in which the sale was made, than had been done in any one week for the preceding eight years. The cotton was held upwards of fifty days, and sold at a profit of nearly ten per cent, more, according to the testimony, than is generally realized in that article. Where no fraud is chargeable on an agent, his conduct ought to receive a liberal and favorable construction. Drummond v. Wood, 2 Caines 310. But if the plaintiffs in error did recognise the instructions of the defendant in error, it was merely an admission as to the egal effect of a contract, and cannot conclude them. 2 Phil, on Evid. (4th edit.), and cases there cited.
But conceding, for the sake of argument, that the correspondence in the case amounts to an agreement on the part of the plaintiffs in error, that they p. 410would hold the cotton until instructed by McGran to sell; it is contended, that such an agreement would not be binding, because it was made without consideration. A valuable consideration had already passed between the parties. McGran had shipped cotton to plaintiffs in error, who, upon the faith of the shipment, had come under an advance and acceptance to a large amount ; the contract was then concluded, and binding upon both parties, and no new agreement could be engrafted upon it, without a new consideration. To make a contract binding, the consideration must be either a benefit tb the party promising, or some trouble or prejudice to the party to whom the promise is made ; but here there was merely a gratuitous undertaking on the part of the plaintiffs in error to comply with the wishes of the defendant in error. Suppose, that McGran, in his letter of the 20th of April, had written to the Messrs. Brown, that he had become dissatisfied with their -conduct as his factors, and requested them, upon the receipt of his letter, *to deliver the cotton to some other agent named by him, and that the Messrs. Brown had replied, that they had received his letter, and noted his wishes accordingly. Could it be, for a moment, contended that upon the strength of this supposed assent, McGran could sustain an action of trover against the plaintiffs in error for the cotton, without paying the amount of their advances ? But if the assent of the plaintiffs in error in the case at bar, was sufficient entirely to destroy their rights over the cotton in question, there is no reason why it should not do so in the case supposed.
2. But it is contended, that the court erred in instructing the jury that the measure of damages was the difference between the price for which the cotton was sold, and that which could have been obtained at any time from the day of sale to the period when the bill arrived at maturity. The cotton was sold June 3d. On the same day, the bill was accepted, and became due August 5th. But McGran had, as he alleges, by his letter of April 20th, forbidden the Messrs. Brown to sell, and his next letter, authorizing them to sell upon its being received, was not received until August 23d. If, then, the plaintiffs were bound by his instructions, they were not authorized to sell until August 23d ; and the damage, if any, sustained by him, is for their not selling on or after that day. But there is no evidence in the case to show *4881 *w^a^ was cotton on or after that day, and therefore, it
J does not appear that McGran had sustained any damage whatever. The relation of principal and agent is governed by the general rules of the law, founded on reason ; and if the principal suffers through the remissness or negligence of the agent, the actual loss sustained by the principal, in consequence of such misconduct, is the standard by whicjh his damages must be measured. Hamilton v. Cunningham, 2 Brock. 366.
3. It is also contended, that the court erred in instructing the jury, that if they found from the evidence in the cause, that cottons were selling for a highei- price from the 3d June 1833, when the draft was accepted, and when the cotton was sold, until the time when the draft was mature and payable, and if the evidence in the cause ascertains, at any time before the maturity of ■ the draft, what such higher price was, and that tho cotton belonging to the defendant in error could have been sold for such higher price, that then the defendant in error was entitled to recover from the plaintiffs in error the difference in price between the sum for which the plaintiffs in error sold the cotton of defendant in error, and the sum for which it might have been
«old, before or at the maturity of the draft, without making it necessary for them to find any other fact. This instruction is entirely independent of, and unconnected with, the preceding instructions of the court. Upon finding simply the facts mentioned in it, the jury were told, that they must bring in a verdict for the defendant in error, without reference to any of the other important facts proved in the case. This instruction was calculated to mislead the jury, and is therefore erroneous. Gist v. Cockey, 1 Har. & Johns. 141.
Jones, for the defendant, denied that the acceptance of a draft, drawn by the owner or consignor against goods shipped to the factor, gives a right to the factor to sell the goods, before the draft is payable. He cited, 6 Barn. & Cres. 36 ; 1 Camp. 410 ; 2 Stark. 272 ; 2 Saund. Plead, and Evid. 641. He contended, that the letter of .the plaintiffs in error, of the 24th May 1833, in answer to the letter of Thomas McGran, of the 20th of April 1833, in which they say, “your wishes in respect to the cotton we now hold on your account, are noted accordingly,” was a contract not to sell the cotton, until further instructions from the owner of the same. That it amounted to an unequivocal accession, in terms, to the order of the 20th of April, and to the clearest implication to abide by it. Yet, on the 23d June, when the time had arrived when the duties on cotton were reduced, a period when the prices of cotton would increase, and before the effects of that, and othei’ concurring causes of a rapidly increasing demand, and proportional advance of prices, could be fairly developed, they forced his coton into market, in the *teeth of his order, and of their unquali- r:fc fied accession to its terms, only ten days before. Cotton continued to L advance in the Liverpool market after the sale ; and at the time the plaintiffs in error were authorized by the subsequent letter of Thomas McGran to make sales, it had risen to a price which fully authorized the verdict of the jury.
But there was no occasion, nor was there any right, to sell the cotton shipped by the defendant in error, for the purpose of reimbursement, until the acceptance of the bill drawn in New York should be matured. No advances in cash had been made by the house in New York, and nothing had been paid by the house in Liverpool. The whole accommodation afforded to the shipper of the cotton was mere paper facilities, by acceptances in New York ; and when those acceptances became due, by a draft on Liverpool.
Mr. Jones considered that the proper test of the amount of the damages to which the defendant was entitled, was that which, under the instructions of the circuit court, had been adopted by the jury. The evidence showed the rise of the price of cotton, and as the plaintiffs in error were bound to keep it,after their receipt of the lettei' of the 20th of April, the j rices, until the draft was paid, should be considered as those to which the owner of the cotton was entitled. He argued : 1. That as to the instructions rejected by the court, they were both in form and substance, in all their premises, and in all theii’ conclusions, utterly inadmissible. 2. That the instructions actually given by the court to the jury, so far from supplying any cause of complaint, were even more favorable to defendants than any they were strictly entitled to ask, and in all other respects unexceptionable.
Brown, in reply.—The argument of the learned counsel for the p. 412defendant in error proceeds upon the ground, that the plaintiffs in error had a mere lien on the cotton in question, which could be waived by such an assent as is supposed to be implied by their letter of May 24th. But the authorities cited show, that factors, under the circumstances existing in this case, have something more than a naked lien ; they have a special property in the thing itself—a power of sale, coupled with an interest; and such a right cannot be waived, without at least an intention to do so being clearly and unequivocally expressed.
Story, Justice, delivered the opinion of the court.—This is a writ of error to a judgment of the circuit court of the district of Georgia, rendered in an action in which McGran, the defendant in error, was originally plaintiff. In the spring of 1833, McGran, a merchant in Georgia, shipped two hundred bales of cotton, consigned to the plaintiffs in error, a house of trade iu Liverpool, England, there doing business under the firm of William and *4onl James Brown & Company, for sale on *his account. The shipment J was made under an arrangement with the house of Brown, Brothers & Company, of New York, composed (as seems admitted) either wholly or in part of the partners in the Liverpool house, by which the New York house accepted a draft drawn upon them by McGran for $9000, the invoice value of the cotton being only $9151.77 ; and were to reimburse themselves by a draft on the Liverpool house. Accordingly, the New York house, on the 12th of March 1833, addressed a letter to the Liverpool house, in which they state : “ We inclose a bill of lading for two hundred bales of cotton, shipped by McLoskey, Hagar & Company, of Mobile, per ship Mary and Harriet, on account of Mr. Thomas McGran, of Augusta, on which you will please effect insurance. This cotton cost, per invoice, $9151.77. We have accepted Mr. McGran’s draft against this cotton, for $9000, for which we shall draw on you for our reimbursement, when it matures. In handing this draft for acceptance, Mr. McGran says, he would not have drawn for so large an advance, were it not that there is a balance at his credit with you, which has accumulated within the past two years ; so that if this should not produce enough to meet the advance, it will be covered by what is at his credit.” The existence of any such balance was utterly denied at the trial ; and the Liverpool house contended, that there was a balance the other way.
The cotton duly arrived at Liverpool, on or about the 9th of April 1833. The New York house drew on the Liverpool house for their reimbursement, a bill dated the 7th of May 1833, for 1871Z. 0s. 9<Z., at sixty days’ sight, being the amount of the advance ; and that bill was accepted by the Liverpool house, on the 3d of June 1833, and became payable, and was paid, on the 5th of August following. On the 3d of June 1833, the very day of the acceptance, the Liverpool house sold the 200 bales of cotton (the market then being on the rise), on a credit, for the nett sum of 20734 4s. Qd. After deducting the charges (which amounted to nearly twenty-five per cent.), which became due and payable on the 16th of September 1833 ; and according to an account-current rendered to McGran, by the Liverpool house, on ♦he 29th of June 1833, the whole transactions between the parties, including the sale of this cotton, left a balance of 3924 15s. Sd., due to McGran.
At the time when the shipment was made, and the advance arranged p. 413therefor, no instructions were given by McGran, touching the sale of the cotton. It accordingly went to the consignees, as factors for sale, the advances having been, as above mentioned, without any other contract than that implied by law as between a principal and a factor making advances ; that is to say, that the factor is to make *sale of the goods consigned ■.* to him, according to his own judgment, in the exercise of a sound *- I discretion as to the time and mode of sale, having regard to the usages of ' trade at the place of sale ; and to reimburse himself out of the proceeds for ’ his advances, and other balance due him.
After th§ shipment and advance were so made, viz., on the 20th April 1833, McGran addressed a letter to the Liverpool house, in which, after acknowledging the receipt of letters of the 4th and 5th of March, from them, he added : “If you have any cottons on hand, when this reaches you, - in which I am interested, I wish you to hold them until you hear from me again.” The Liverpool house, in a reply to this letter, on the 24th of May 1833, used the following language : “We are in possession of your esteemed favor of the 20th ultimo, and your wishes in respect to the cotton - we now hold on your account, are noted accordingly.” At this time, by advices received from other correspondents, the Liverpool house were in possession of information that, at least as early as the 8th of April 1833, - McGran had failed in business. On the 22d of July 1833, McGran wrote a letter to the Liverpool house, acknowledging the receipt of their letter of the 24th of May, in which he says : “I have your favor of the 31st (the 24th) of May, and note the contents. You will please sell two hundred bales of cotton, soon after the receipt of this, unless you are of opinion you can do better by holding a little longer.” This letter was received by the Liverpool house, on or about the 23d day of August 1833. On the 7th of June 1833, the Liverpool house informed McGran of the sale of the cotton ; and in a letter, under date of the 30th of July 1833, in reply thereto, McGran expressed his surprise at the sale ; and added, “I beg leave to refer you to my letter of the 20th of April last, the receipt of which you have acknowledged, instructing you not to sell any cottons you had on hand, in which I am interested, until you heard from me again. Why did you sacrifice my cottons, as the draft drawn by Brown, Brothers & Company, at sixty _ days, on account of these cottons, could not have been accepted more than a day or two before, as it went forward by the packet of the 8th of May ? Therefore, you had sixty days before you had any money to pay for me.” - And after some other remarks in the style of complaint, he adds, “ You will please take notice, that I do not recognise the sale, and do not consider - you authorized to sell the cotton, before the time the draft drawn on you by Brown, Brothers & Company against this cotton falls due. If the price is ' higher on that day than the day you sold it, I will expect you to allow the. difference ; and if it is lower, I will be prepared to pay you any balance I may " owe you.” To this letter, the Liverpool house replied, by a letter dated the 4th - of September 1833, in which they vindicated their conduct, and among other things said : “We beg you to bear in mind, that there wras a balance due _ us from you, on joint transaction from Mr. Clarke ; that the two hundred*bales in question were sold after the market had advanced one-half penny per pound, and that it barely squares the account. .You had, L unfortunately, been obliged to stop payment. We had the opportunity of
492 ' SUPREME COURT [Jan’jr
paying ourselves, by selling your cotton in a brisk market, to a profit of ten per cent. ; and we ask whether it, was reasonable, under such circumstances, to expect us to hold the cotton for the chance of further profit, when the loss, if any, was certain to fall on us, and the profit not likely to go to you, but to your creditors, as was supposed, of whom we knew nothing. This would have been the extreme of unjustice towards ourselves and our absent partners, without being any advantage to you.” And after some other remarks vindicating their conduct, they further said, “ We think you must admit, that situated as you then were, you could not reasonably have expected us to hold the cotton, without pointing out in what manner we should be indemnified in event of loss thereby. That Brown, Brothers & Company’s draft was not due, does not alter the case. We had become responsible, some months before, by Brown, Brothers & Company’s acceptance of the draft of the shippers.”
Here the correspondence between the parties seems to have closed. The present action was brought to recover damages against the Liverpool house, for a supposed breach of orders, and of their duty as factors. At the trial, there was an account-current between the parties, and other evidence before the jury ; the whole evidence in the case, however, was introduced by McGran. Among other questions before the jury, were the following : whether the advance made by the New York house, was in effect, an advance by the Liverpool house, either as agents, or as partners in the latter ? whether there was any balance due to the Liverpool house upon the former transaction ? whether McGran was insolvent or not, according to the advices received by the Liverpool house ? and whether under the circumstances disclosed in the evidence, the Liverpool house had a right to sell the two hundred bales of cotton for their reimbursement, notwithstanding the ■wishes or orders contained in the letter of the 20th of April ?
The jury, at the trial, found a verdict for the plaintiff (McGran), for $4978.57, under certain instructions given by the court, upon which verdict judgment was accordingly rendered ; and a bill of exceptions having been taken by the original defendants, the cause now comes before us for revision, upon the points made and instructions given at the trial.
The counsel for the defendants asked the court to instruct the jury: 1. That the advance by the house of Brown, in New York, was, in effect, an advance by the house in Liverpool; and after the advance so made, the shipper had no right to alter the instructions which were given at the time of such advance. 2. That the house in Liverpool having advanced so large an amount on this cotton, having a previous unsettled claim against the shipper, and the *shipper having afterwards, and before the sale of the cotton,
■* become insolvent, the house in Liverpool had a right to sell for their reimbursement, notwithstanding the subsequent orders of the shipper. The court refused to give these instructions ; and, in our judgment, with great propriety ; as each of them involved matters of fact in controversy before the jury upon which it was exclusively their province to decide. If the defendants meant to draw from the court an opinion in point of lawT upon the assumed facts, the proper mode would have been to have asked the court to instruct the jury, that if they found the facts to be as thus assumed, then that the lawr was as these instructions stated.
The court then proceeded to instruct the jury, that if they found from p. 4151840] OF THE UNITED STATES. 49$
the evidence in the cause, that the plaintiff had given instructions to the defendants, by his letter of the 20th of April 1833, not to sell any cottons' which the defendants might have on hand when that letter reached them,, in which the plaintiff was interested, until the defendants heard from him again ; and that such instructions were received and recognised by the defendants, by the evidence in the cause, and particularly, by a letter given in evidence as one from the defendants to the plaintiff, dated the 24th of May 1833, in reply to the plaintiff’s letter to them of the 20th of April 1833 ; that then the defendants were not justifiable in law in the sale of the 3d of June 1833, on account of the defendants having on that day accepted Brown, Brothers & Company’s draft for 18711. Os. Od., dated the 7th of May 1833, at sixty days’ sight. It is observable, that this instruction is given in absolute terms, without reference to any other facts in the cause which might be found by the jury, upon the evidence before them ; and therefore, must be deemed to apply to every posture of the facts which the evidence might warrant. It must, therefore, be deemed to apply to the case, although the advance was originally made by the New York house for and on account of the Liverpool house, as agents or partners thereof ; or the Liverpool house had entered into engagements, prior to the advance, to become responsible for the reimbursement thereof to the New York house, in the manner stated in the evidence ; and although the plaintiff was, before the writing of the letters, actually insolvent, and had failed in business ; and that fact was known to the defendants.
One objection taken to this instruction is, that it leaves to the jury the construction of the language of the letters of the 20th of April, and 24th of May. It is certainly true, as a general rule, that the interpretation of written instruments properly belongs to the court, and not to the jury. But there certainly are cases, in which, from the different senses of the words used, or their obscure and indeterminate reference to unexplained circumstances, the true interpretation of the language may be left to the consideration of the jury, for the purpose of carrying into effect the real intention of the parties. This is especially applicable to cases of commercial correspondence, *where the real objects, and intentions, and agreements of the [-*. q. parties, are often to be arrived at only by allusions to circumstances *■ which are but imperfectly developed. The present case sufficiently illustrates the distinction. McGrah, in the letter of the 20th of April, says, that he wishes the defendants to hold any cottons on hand, until they hear from him again. Now, this language, certainly, ordinarily imports only a desire, and not an order; and yet there can be no reasonable doubt, that under particular circumstances, a wish expressed by a consignor to a factor may amount to a positive command. So, in the reply of the 21th of May, the defendants say, “ your wishes in respect to the cotton we now hold on your account, are noted accordingly.” Here again, the point is open, whether the language imports that the defendants construed the wishes of the plaintiff to be simply a strong expression of desire or opinion, or a positive order ; and also, whether the words “noted accordingly,” import that the defendants took notice thereof, or took notice of, and assented to obey, the wishes or order of the plaintiff. The language is susceptible of either interpretation, according to circumstances.
If the case had been one of simple consignment, without any interest in p. 416the consignee, or any advance or liability incurred on account thereof, the wishes might fairly be presumed to be orders ; and the noting the wishes, accordingly, an assent to follow them. But very different considerations might apply, where the consignment should be, as the present is, one clothed with a special interest and a special property, founded upon advances and liabilities. We think, therefore, that this objection is not, under the circumstances of the case, maintainable. It would be quite another question, whether the court might not, in its discretion, have assumed upon itself the right and duty of construing t^es^ letters. There is no novelty in this doctrine. It will be found recognised in Ekins v. Macklish, Ambl. 184-5 ; Lucas n. Groning, 'I Taunt. 164; and Hees v. Warwick, 2 Barn. & Aid. 113, 115.
But the main objection to the instruction is of a more broad and comprehensive character. The instruction, in effect, decides, that in the case of a general consignment of goods to a factor for sale, in the exercise of his own discretion, as to the time and manner of sale, the consignor has a right, by subsequent orders, to suspend or postpone the sale, at his pleasure ; notwithstanding the factor has, in consideration of such general consignment, already made advances, or incurred liabilities for the consignor, at his request, trusting to the fund for his due reimbursement. We are of opinion, that this doctrine is not maintainable in point of law. We understand the true doctrine on this subject to be this : whenever a consignment is made to a factor for sale, the consignor has a right, generally, to control the sale thereof, according to his own pleasure, from time to time, if no advances have been made or liabilities incurred •on account thereof ; and the factor is bound to obey his orders ; this arises from the ordinary relation of principal and agent. If, however, i ^he factor *makes advances, or incurs liabilities on account of the J consignment, by which he acquires a special property therein ;
then the factor has a right to sell so much of the consignment as may be necessary to reimburse such advances or meet such liabilities ; unless there be some existing agreement between himself and the consignor, which controls or varies this right. Thus, for example, if, contemporaneously with the consignment and advances or liabilities, there are orders given by the consignor, which are assented to by the factor, that the goods shall not be sold until a fixed time, in such a case, the consignment is presumed to be received by the factor subject to such orders ; and he is not at liberty to sell the goods to reimburse his advances or liabilities, until after that time has elapsed. The same rule will apply to orders not to sell below a fixed price; unless, indeed, the consignor shall, after due notice and request, refuse to provide any other means to reimburse the factors. And in no case will the factor be at liberty to sell the consignment, contrary to the orders of the consignor, although he has made advances, or incurred liabilities thereon, if the consignor stands ready, and offers to reimburse and discharge such advances and liabilities. On the other hand, where the consignment is made generally, without any spe-cific orders as to the time or mode of sale, and the factor makes advances nr incurs liabilities on the footing of such consignment, there the legal presumption is, that the factor is intended to be clothed with the ordinary rights of factors, to sell in the exercise of a sound discretion, at such time p. 417and in such mode as the usage of trade and his general duty require ; and. to reimburse himself for his advances and liabilities, out of the proceeds of the sale ; and the consignor has no right, by any subsequent orders, given after advances have been made or liabilities incurred by the factor, to suspend or control this right of sale, except so far as respects the surplus of the ■consignment, not necessary for the reimbursement of such advances or liabilities. Of course, this right of the factor to sell to reimburse himself for his advances and liabilities, applies with stronger force to cases where the consignor is insolvent, and where, therefore, the consignment constitutes the only fund for indemnity.
Such then being the relative rights and duties of the parties, we are of opinion, that the instruction given to the jury by the learned jndge in the •circuit court, is not maintainable in point of law. The consignment was general to the Liverpoolhouse, for sale ; the advances and liabilities were contemporaneous with the consignment ; there were no contemporaneous orders, limiting or qualifying the general rights of the factors, resulting from these circumstances ; the consignor, subsequently, either failed in business, or was believed to have failed ; the wishes subsequently expressed by the letter of the 20th of April, even admitting them to have the force of ■orders, were unaccompanied with any other means of idemnity, or even with any offer of reimbursement of the advances or liabilities. Unless, then, upon the established principles of law’, the consignor had a *clear J-* right to control the sale of the consignment, by any orders w’hich he might, in his discretion, choose to give, notwithstanding such advances and liabilities (which, we are of opinion, he had not), the instruction was erroneous. We have not thought it necessary to enter upon any general examination of the authorities w’hich support the doctrines w’hich have been thus stated by us. But the opinion of Lord Chief Justice Gibbs, in Pothonier v. Dawson, Holt. 383, and the opinions of the judges in Graham n. Dyster, 6 Maule & Selw. 1, 4,5, will be found fully to recognise some of the leading principles.
Another instruction was given by the court to the jury upon the question of damages, supposing the Liverpool house, by the sale, had violated their proper duty. It was, that if the jury found, from the evidence in the cause, that cottons were selling for a higher price, from the 3d of June 1833, when the draft was accepted, and when the cotton was sold, until the time when the said draft was mature and payable, and if the evidence in the cause ascertained, at any time before the maturity of the draft, w’hat such higher price was, and that the cotton belonging to the plaintiff could have been sold for such higher price ; then the plaintiff was entitled to recover from the defendants the difference in price between the sum for which the defendants sold the cotton, and the sum at which it might have been sold, before or at the maturity of the draft. This instruction was, doubtless, framed, upon the ground, that this was the claim of damages which the plaintiff asserted by his letter of the 30th of July 1833. But as that letter ■was not assented to, or the claim recognised by the defendants, this claim could, in no just sense, be obligatory upon them ; and as a general rule of aw, applicable to damages, under like circumstances, we think that it cannot be maintained. Supposing the sale made by the defendants on the 3d of * une to have been tortious, and in violation of orders, the plaintiff had his p. 418election either to claim damages for the value of the cotton on that day, as. a ease of tortious conversion, or for the value of the cotton on the 23d of August following, when the letter of the plaintiff of the 22d of July was-received, which authorized a sale. If the price of cotton was higher on that day, than at any intermediate period, he was entitled to the benefit thereof. If, on the other hand, the price was then lower, he could not justly be said to be damnified to any extent beyond what he would lose by the difference of the price of cotton on the 3d of June, and the price on the 23d of August.
For these reasons, we are of opinion, that both the instructions given by the circuit court to the jury were erroneous ; and therefore, the judgment ought to be reversed, and the cause remanded, with instructions to the-court to award a venire facias de novo.
Wayne, Justice, and Catron, Justice, dissented.
Judgment reversed.