McAfee v. Doremus, 46 U.S. (5 How.) 53 (1847)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
McAfee v. Doremus, 46 U.S. (5 How.) 53 (1847)
Full caption
Morgan McAfee, Plaintiff in error, v. Thomaspro C. Doremus, James Suydam, Cornelius R. Suy- '' dam, and John Nixon.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1847
•Morgan McAfee, Plaintiff in error, v. Thomas pro C. Doremus, James Suydam, Cornelius R. Suy- '' dam, and John Nixon.
By the laws of Louisiana, a notary is required to record in a book kept for that purpose, all protests of bills made by him and the notices given to the drawers or indorsers, a certified copy of which record is made evidence.
McAfee u. Doremus et al.
Under these statutes, a deposition of the notary, giving a copy of the original bill, stating a demand of payment; a subsequent protest and notice to the drawers and indorsers respectively, is good evidence.1 The original protest must be recorded in a book. Its absence at the trial is therefore sufficiently accounted for.
Where a joint action against the drawers and indorser was commenced under the statute of Mississippi (which statute this court has heretofore, 16 Pet., 89, held to be repugnant to an act of Congress), the plaintiffs may discon tinue the suit against the drawers and proceed against the indorser only.2
This case was brought up, by writ of error, from the Dis trict Court of the United States for the Northern District of Mississippi.
On the 8th of December, 1839, the following bill of ex change was drawn.
$4,000. Locopolis, Miss., Dec. Sth, 1839.
Ninety days after date of this my first of exchange (second of same tenor and date unpaid), pay to the order of Morgan McAfee, four thousand dollars, value received, and charge the same to account of your obd’t servants.
Clymer, Polk, & Co.
Messrs. Keys & Roberts, New Orleans.
1
“A notary, registrarius, actuarius, such copy is not evidence of notice scrivenarius, was anciently a scribe that unless provided by statute. Harrison only took notes or minutes, and made v. Robinson, 4 How., 336; Walker v. short drafts of writings and other in Turner, 2 Gratt. (Va.), p. 536 ; Lloyd struments, both public and private. v. MeGair, 3 Pa. St., 482; Miller v. He is at this day a public officer of Hackley, 5 Johns. (N. Y.), 384; Dick the civil and common law, appointed ens v. Heal, 10 Pet., 582; Bank of by the Archbishop of Canterbury, who, Rochester v. Gray, 2 Hill (N. Y.), 231; in the instrument of appointment, de Williams v. Putnam, 14 N. H., 540; crees 1 that full faith be given, as well Swayze v. Britten, 17 Kan., 625; Couch in as out of judgment to the instru v, Sherrill, Id., 624; Rives v. Parmley, ments by him to be made.’ [Ayliffe’s 18 Ala., 256. Parergon, 385; Burns’ Eccl. Law, 1.] But the protest is only prima facie This appointment is also registered evidence of the facts stated therein. and subscribed by the clerk of her Nelson v. Fotterall, I Leigh (Va.), majesty for faculties in Chancery." 180; Union Bank v. Fowlker,2 Sneed Byles on Bills, 262 (7 Am. ed.). Cer (Tenn.), 555; Spence v. Crockett, 5 tified copies of the acts of notaries Baxt. (Tenn.), 576; Howard Bank v. prove themselves, and are admissible Carson, 50 Md., 27 ; Rickett v. Pendle in all courts as prima Jude evidence ton, 14 Md., 320; and although the of the facts therein stated. Anon., 12 notary, when examined, has no recol Mod., 345; Halliday v. McDougal, 20 lection of the facts stated therein, it Wend. (N. Y.), 81; Townsley v. Sum- is still prima facie evidence until con rail, 2 Pet., 170; Nicholls v. Webb, 8 tradicted. Sherer v. Easton Bank, o3 Wheat., p. 333; Dewolf v. Murray, 2 Pa. St., 134. Sandf. (N. Y.), 160; Townsend v. Lo 2 Followed. Coffee v. Planters rain Bank, 2 Ohio St., 345; Chase v. Bank of Tennessee, 13 How., 189. Taylor, 4 liar. & J. (Md.), 54. But
JANUARY TERM, 184 7. 53
McAfee v. Doremus et al.
The firm of Clymer, Polk, & Co., consisted of Isaac Clymer, Benjamin C. Polk, William C. Ivins, and Hiram Clymer.
McAfee indorsed it, and it came to the hands of the defend ants in error, merchants and partners in New York, trading under the firm of Doremus, Suydams, and Nixon.
When the bill became due it was not paid, and was pro tested under the circumstances set forth in the first bill of exception.
Tn May, 1842, Doremus, Suydams, and Nixon brought a suit against the four makers and also against McAfee, the indorser. The action was a joint one, as required by a stat ute of Mississippi, passed on the 13th of May, 1837, which was as follows.
“Section 1. Be it enacted by the legislature of the State of Mississippi, that in all actions founded upon bills of ex change and promissory notes, the plaintiff shall be compelled to sue the drawers and indorsers living and resident in this State in a joint action ; and such suit shall be commenced in the county where the drawer or drawers reside, if living in the State; and if the drawer or drawers be dead, or reside out of the State, the suit shall be brought in the county where the first indorser resides.
“ Sec. 2. Be it further enacted, that in all cases where any drawer, acceptor, or indorser shall have died before the com mencement of *the suit, a separate action may be p-. brought against the representatives of such drawers, indorsers, and acceptors.
“ Sec. 3. Be it further enacted, that the court shall receive the plea of non-assumpsit and no other, as a defence to the merits, in all suits brought in pursuance of this act; and all matters of defence may be given in evidence under the said plea. And it shall be lawful for the jury to render a verdict againts part of the defendants, and in favor of the others, if the evidence before them require such a verdict, and the court shall enter up the proper judgment in such verdicts against the defendants ; which judgments and verdicts shall not be reversed, annulled, or set aside for want of form.
“ Sec. 4. Be it further enacted, that new trials shall alone be granted to such defendants as the verdicts may have been wrongfully rendered against; and judgments shall be entered against all the other defendants in pursuance of the verdict.
“ Sec. 5. Be it further enacted, that the clerk shall issue duplicate writs to the several counties where the various detendants may reside, and shall indorse on all executions the names of the drawers and indorsers, particularly specifying the first, second, and third indorsers.
McAfee u. Doremus et al.
“Sec. 6. Be it further enacted, that it shall be the duty of the sheriff, in all cases, to make the money on the executions, out of the drawer or drawers, acceptor or acceptors; and in no case shall a levy be made on the property of any security or securities, indorser or indorsers, unless an affidavit from some credible person be made and filed among the papers in the case, setting forth that the principal or principals have no property in this State, out of which the plaintiff’s money and costs can be made ; and in such event the plaintiff may proceed with the executions against the defendants next liable, and so on until his executions be satisfied.
“Sec. 7. Be it further enacted, that no sheriff, or other officer, shall take more than one forthcoming bond, in any case, for the same cause of action.
“ Sec. 8. Be it further enacted, that any plaintiff shall have the right to discontinue his suit against any one or more of the indorsers or securities, that he may sue in any joint action, before verdict, on payment of the costs that may have accrued by joining said defendant in such suit.
“ Sec. 9. Be it further enacted, that in all suits brought under the provisions of this act, the defendants shall not be allowed to sever in their pleas to the merits of the action, and no plea of abatement shall be allowed to be filed in any cause, unless affidavit be made of the truths of the facts pleaded in the plea of abatement.
“ Sec. 10. Be it further enacted, that if any plaintiff or plaintiffs shall cause to be levied an execution on any se curity, or their indorsers or their property, when the princi pal has sufficient property in this State to satisfy such execution, the party so offending shall *be deemed a tres-
J passer, and shall be liable to an action from the party aggrieved, and exemplary damages shall, in all such cases, be awarded by the jury trying the same. Approved, May 13, 1837.”
This Statute was, in part, adopted by a rule of court in 1839, as follows:—
“ Rule XXX. The practice and proceedings in action at law, by the laws of this State, and the rules of practice for the government of the courts of law, made by the late Supreme Court, where not incompatible with the laws of the United States, the rules which may be prescribed by the Supreme Court of the United States for the government oi this court, or with the existing rules of this court, shall be considered the rules and practice of this court: provided, however, and it is hereby expressly understood, that this rule does not adopt the whole of the act entitled ‘ An act to
McAfee v. Doremus et al.
amend the laws respecting suits to be brought against in dorsers of promissory notes,’ approved May 13th, 1837 ; but that all of said act, except the tenth section thereof, is, and it is intended to be, adopted.”
At June term, 1842, McAfee pleaded the general issue.
In June, 1843, three of the four drawers of the bill having been served with process and the remaining one not, the suit was discontinued as to the drawers, and continued against McAfee alone.
In December, 1843, the cause came on for trial, when a verdict was found for the plaintiffs. During the trial, how ever, the two following bills of exception were taken.
First Exception.
Be it remembered, that on the trial of this cause, on this 8th day of June, 1844, the plaintiffs in this case offered in evidence a bill of exchange in these words:—
$4,000 Locopolis, Miss., Dec. 8th, 1839.
Ninety days after date of this my first of exchange (second of same tenor and date unpaid), pay to the order of Morgan McAfee, four thousand dollars, value received, and charge the same to account of your ob’t servants.
Clymer, Polk, & Co.
Messrs. Keys & Roberts, New Orleans.
Having indorsed thereon the following names, three of which were erased:—
“Pay to Doremus, Suydams & Nixon, or order. Morgan McAfee, Charleston P. O., Miss.”
“A. H. Davidson, Charleston P. O., Miss.; G. Davidson, Charleston P. O., Miss.; M. L. Cooper & Co.”
The plaintiff then proved that the names of A. H. David son and G. Davidson had been erased before the maturity of the bill. The plaintiff then offered in evidence the copy of the original * pro test, accompanied by the deposition r*;- of the notary public, in these words:— t ' °
United States of America, Eastern District of Louisiana, City of New Orleans, ss:—
Be it remembered, that on this thirteenth day of May, in the year ol our Lord one thousand eight hundred and forty-our, before me, M. M. Cohen, a commissioner duly ap pointed on the 19th of April, 1842, by the Circuit Court of ie United States in and for the Eastern District of Louisi ana, under and by virtue of the acts of Congress, entitled,
McAfee v. Doremus et al.
“Aii act for the more convenient taking of affidavits and bail in civil causes depending in the courts of the United States,” passed Feb. 20, 1842, and the act of Congress, en titled “ An act in addition to an act entitled ‘ An act for the more convenient taking of affidavits and bail in civil causes depending in the courts in the United States,’ ” passed March 1, 1817, and the act, entitled “An act to establish the judicial courts of the United States,” passed Sept. 24, 1789, personally appeared H. B. Cenas, a person of sound mind and lawful age, a witness for the plaintiff in civil suit now depending in the District Court of the United States, in and for the Northern District of Mississippi, wherein Doremus, Suydams, and Nixon are plaintiffs, and Clymer, Polk, & Co. (drawers), and Morgan McAfee (indorser) are defendants; and the said H. B. Cenas being by me first carefully exam ined, and cautioned, and sworn to testify the whole truth and nothing but the truth, did depose and say. that he is a notary public, duly commissioned and sworn, in and for the city and parish of New Orleans, State of Louisiana; that he held said office on the tenth day of March, A. I). 1840, on which day, at the request of the Commercial Bank of New Orleans, holder of the original draft, of which the following is a copy, to wit:—•84,000. Locopolis, Mius., December 8th. 1839.
Ninety days after date of this my first of exchange (second of same tenor and date unpaid), pay to the order of Morgan McAfee four thousand dollars, value received, and charge the same to account of your obedient servants.
Clymer, Polk, & Co.
Messrs. Keys and Roberts, New Orleans. T. , Morgan McAfee. Charleston P. 0. indorsed:— Messrs< M D Cooper & Co.
He, the said notary, presented said draft to a clerk of the drawees at their counting-room (said drawees not being in) and demanded payment thereof, and was answered that the same could not be paid; whereupon he, the said notary, did publicly and solemnly protest said draft for non-payment, and of protest did give notice to Clymer, Polk, & Co., drawers, and to Morgan McAfee, indorser, and M. D. Cooper & Co,, indorsers, by letters to the *drawer and first indorser severally
J written and addressed, informing them of said protest, and that the holders looked to them for payment; which let ters he, the said notary, did direct to the said drawers and said first indorsers, respectively, as follows:—the one for Clymer, Polk, & Co., drawers, to them at Locopolis, Mississippi, and
McAfee v. Doremus el at
that for the said Morgan McAfee, the first indorser, to him at Charleston P. O., Mississippi, and by delivering that for the last indorsers to themselves. Which letters he, the said notary, did put into the post office at New Orleans aforesaid, on the day and date of said protest. All of which was done under the hand of said notary, and recorded in presence of competent witnesses and in due form of law.
The notary’s fees for said protest and notices amounted to $3.50.
The document A., M. M. Cohen, United States commis sioner, is sworn to by me,
II. B. Cenas, Notary Public.
United States of America, North Circuit and Eastern Dis trict of Louisiana, City of New Orleans, ss:—
I, M. M. Cohen, a commissioner duly appointed on the 19th of April, 1842, by the Circuit Court of the United
States for the Ninth Circuit and Eastern District of Louisi
ana, under and by virtue of the acts of Congress, entitled
“An act for the more convenient taking of affidavits and
bail in civil causes depending in the courts of the United
States,” passed February 20th, 1812, and the act of Con
gress, entitled “ An act in addition to an act entitled 1 An
act for the more convenient taking of affidavits and bail in
civil causes depending in the courts of the United States,’”
passed March 1st, 1817, and the act entitled “An act to es
tablish the judicial courts of the United States,” passed Sep
tember 24th, 1789, do hereby certify, that the reason for
taking the foregoing deposition is, anil the fact is, that the
witness lives in New Orleans, State of Louisiana, more than
one hundred miles from Pontotoc, State of Mississippi, the
place of trial of the cause for and in which said deposition
is taken and is necessary. I further certify, that no notifica
tion was made out and served on the defendants, or adverse
parties, their agent or attorney, to be present at the taking
of the deposition, and to put interrogatories if he or they
may think fit, and that no notification of the time and place
of taking the said deposition was made out and served on
said defendants or adverse parties, because neither the said
adverse parties, nor any attorney or agent of said adverse
parties was, at the time of taking said deposition, within
(100) one hundred miles of the said city of New Orleans,
the place of taking the said deposition. I further certify,
that, on this thirteenth day of May, A. D. 1844,1 was by the
witness, who is of sound mind and lawful age, and the wit-
McAfee v. Doremus et al.
^s-. ness was by *ine carefully examined and cautioned,
J and sworn to testify the whole truth, and the deposi tion was by me reduced to writing in the presence of the witness; and after carefully reading the same to the witness, he subscribed the same in my presence.
I have retained the said deposition in my possession for the purpose of sealing up, directing, and forwarding the same with my own hands to the court for which the same was taken.
I further certify, that I am not of counsel or attorney to either of the parties in said deposition and caption named, or in any way interested in the event of the said civil cause named in the caption.
In testimony whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and seal, the words “are plaintiffs” being first interlined on page 1, ante.
M. M. Cohen, [l. s.J
U. /S'. Commissioner Circuit and District Court United States for the Ninth Circuit and Eastern District of Louisiana.
Commissioner’s fee, B10 00) Notary for copy annexed, 2 59 j Paid ^ PlaiIlt^
M. M. Cohen, U. S. C.
United States of America, State of Louisiana:—
By this public instrument of protest be it known that, on this tenth day of March, in the year one thousand eight hun dred and forty, at the request of the Commercial Bank of New Orleans, holder of the original draft, whereof a true copy is on the reverse hereof written, I, Hilary Breton Cenas, a notary public in and for the city and parish of New Orleans, State of Louisiana aforesaid, duly commissioned and sworn, presented said draft to a clerk of the drawees at their count ing-room (said drawees not being in), and demanded payment thereof, and was answered that the same could not be paid. Whereupon I, the said notary, at the request aforesaid, did protest, and by these presents do publicly and solemnly pro test, as well against the drawer or maker of the said draft, as against all others whom it doth or may concern, for all ex change, reexchange, costs, charges, and interests, suffered or to be suffered, for want of payment of the said draft. I bus done and protested in the presence of Law. Dornan and Ernest Granet, witnesses.
In testimony whereof, I grant these presents under my
McAfee v. Doremus et al.
signature, and the impress of my seal of office, at the city r - of New Orleans, on the day and year first above LL' S,J written.
H. B. Cenas, Notary Public.
Original signed,—Law. Dornan,
E. Granet.
$4,000. Locopolis, Miss., Dec. 8th, 1839.
Ninety days after date, of this my first of exchange (second of same tenor and date unpaid), pay to the order of Morgan McAfee *four thousand dollars, value received, and r*^ charge the same to account [of] your obedient ser- L vants.
Clymer, Polk, & Co.
Messrs. Keys & Roberts, New Orleans. Indorsed,—Morgan McAfee, Charleston P. 0., Miss., M. D. Cooper & Co.
I, the undersigned notary, do hereby certify that the par ties to the draft, whereof a true copy is embodied in the accompanying act of protest, have been duly notified of the protest thereof by letters to them by me written and addressed, dated on the day of said protest, and served on them respec tively this day, in the manner following, viz. by depositing those for the drawers and first indorsers in the post office in this city on the same day as this protest, directed to them respectively as follows:—that for the drawers, to them at Locopolis, Miss.; and that for the first indorser, to him at Charleston P. O., Miss.; and by delivering that for the last indorsers to themselves.
In faith whereof, I hereunto sign my name, together with Law. Dornan, and Ernest Granet, witnesses, at New Orleans, this 11th day of March, 1840.
Original signed,—Law. Dornan, E. Granet.
H. B. Cenas, Not. Pub.
I certify the foregoing to be a true copy of the original protest, draft, and memorandum of the manner in which the notices were served on file and of record in my office.
In faith whereof I grant these presents, under my signa ture, and the impress of my seal of office, at New Orleans, [l. s.l 011 ^hs ninth day of November, in the year of our
Lord one thousand eight hundred and forty-three.
II. B. Cenas, Not. Pub. Sworn to before me.
M. M. Cohen, U. S. C.
MeAlee v- Doremus et al.
To the introduction of which copy the defendant by coun sel objected, but such objection was overruled by the court, and said copy allowed to be read: to which opinion of the court the defendant excepted, and this his bill of exceptions, before the jury retired from the box, was signed and sealed by the court, and ordered to be made a part of the record.
S. J. Gholson, [seal.]
Second Exception.
The second bill of exceptions referred to the statute and rule abovementioned, and to the discontinuance of the suit against the drawers of the bill, after three of them had been served with process. A motion was made in arrest of judg ment, which was overruled by the court, to which overruling the second exception was taken.
*The cause was argued by Mr. Chalmers and Mr. J Coxe, for the plaintiff in error, and by Mr. Stanton and
Mr. Z. Collins Lee, for the defendants in error.
Mr. Chalmers and Mr. Coxe contended that the paper ad mitted in evidence by the court below, purporting to be a copy of the protest of the bill of exchange sued upon, was not duly proved to have been a copy of the protest of the bill of exchange, but a copy of an entry in the notary’s book, and that it was not duly proved, even as a copy of the entry in the book.
Secondly, if proved as a copy, it was not admissible as evi dence, without laying ground for it by showing the loss of the original, which was not done.
A protest is, properly speaking, a solemn declaration on behalf of the holder against any loss to be sustained by non-acceptance or non-payment (Story, Bills, § 276, p. 301), must be in writing, signed, and sealed by the notary (Chit., Bills, 490, 642), and annexed to the bill itself, if it can be obtained or otherwise a copy (Chit., Bills, 362), with all the indorse ments transcribed verbatim, with the reasons given by the party why he does not honor the bill: and this is so indis pensably necessary, by the custom of merchants, that it can not be supplied by witnesses or oath of the party, or in any other way, and, as is said, is part of the constitution of a foreign bill of exchange, because it is the solemn declaration of a notary, who is a public officer, recognized in all parts of Europe, that a due presentment and dishonor has taken place, and all countries give credit to his certificate of the facts. Chit., Bills, 490. It must be made according to the laws
JANUARY TERM, 1 84 7. GO
McAfee w. Doremus et al.
of the place where the payment ought to have been made. Story, Bills, p. 105, § 278; Chit., Bills, 490. By the laws of Louisiana, where this bill was payable, it is enacted, page 41, Ball. & C. Dig., Laws of Louisiana, that
“ The notaries shall keep a separate book in which they shall transcribe and record, by order of date, all the protests by them made, minutes of notices, &c., &c., made by them, which declaration, duly recorded under signature of such notary and two witnesses,” &c.
This book, from which tire copy admitted was obtained, is a new transcription of the original protest,—a copy, ■wholly inadmissible itself, without accounting for the non-produc tion of the original, and yet the court admitted a copy of this copy, without showing the loss, destruction, or that the ori ginal was not within the control of the party offering the copy. See Sebree v. Dorr, 9 Wheat., 558; Brooks v. Mar bury, 11 Id., 78.
Secondly, the court below erred in overruling plaintiff in error’s motion to arrest the judgment. This suit in the court below was Commenced jointly against the drawers and indorsers of the bill of exchange sued upon under and c by virtue of the provisions of an act of the Legislature of the State of Mississippi, and a long count of the declaration is framed upon that act, which provides, that “in all actions founded upon bills of exchange and promissory notes the plaintiff shall be compelled to sue the drawers and indorsers living and resident within the State in a joint action.” Act of May 13, 1837, Laws of Mississippi, 717 ; and by a rule of the District Court of the United States for the State of Mis sissippi, this act was adopted (see Rule XXX.), and, so far as it is not inconsistent with the laws of Congress and the rules of practice prescribed by the Supreme Court of the United States, became by that rule the law of the court, this being the case unless the act of the legislature of Mis sissippi, in its application to this case, was incompatible with the laws of Congress, or the rules prescribed by the Supreme Court ot the United States, or the existing rules of the Dis trict Court for Mississippi, the dismissal entered as to defendants below, Isaac Clymer, William C. Ivins, and Benjamin । ^°^, the makers, and taking judgment against McAfee, the plaintiff in error and indorser of the bill sued upon, was manifest error, tor which the judgment should have been ar^^d- Sec Wilkinson and Turney v. Tiffany, Duvall, $ Co., a How. (Miss.), 411. Was the act of Mississippi, adopted by the District Court in its application to this case, a viola tion of the judiciary act of 1789, ch. 20 ? The eleventh sec- [p. 72] G1 SUPREME COURT.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access