United States v. Preston, 28 U.S. (3 Pet.) 57 (1830)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
United States v. Preston, 28 U.S. (3 Pet.) 57 (1830)
Full caption
United States, Appellants, v. Isaac T. Preston, Attorney-General of Louisiana, Appellee.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1830
*United States, Appellants, v. Isaac T. Preston, Attorney- [*57 General of Louisiana, Appellee.
Slave-trade.—Decree in admiralty.—Repeal of statute.
The offence against the law of the United States, under the seventh section of the act of con gress, passed the 2d of March 1807, entitled “ an act to prohibit the importation of slaves into any port or place within the jurisdiction of the United States, from and after the 1st of January 1808,” is not that of importing or bringing into the United States persons of color, with intent to hold or sell such persons as slaves, but that of hovering on the coast of the United States, with such intent; and although it forfeits the vessel and any goods or effects found on board, it is silent as to the disposing of the colored persons found on board, any more than to impose a duty upon the officers of armed vessels who make the capture, to keep them safely, to be delivered to the overseers of the poor, or the governor of the state, or persons appointed by the respective states to receive the same. p. 65.
The Josefa Segunda, having persons of color on board of her, was, on the 11th of February 1818, found hovering on the coast of the United States, and was seized and brought into New Orleans, and the vessel and the persons on board were libelled in the district court of the United States of Louisiana, under the act of congress of the 2d of March 1807 ; after a decree of condemnation below, but pending the appeal of this court, the sheriff of New Orleans went on, with the consent of all the parties to the proceedings, to sell the persons of color, as slaves, and $65,000, the proceeds, were deposited in the registry of the court, to await the final disposal of the law.
By the 10th section of the act of 30th of April 1818, the first six sections of the act are repealed, and no provision is made by which the condition of the persons of color found on board a vessel hovering on the coast of the United States is altered from that in which they were placed
under the act of 1807, no power having been given to dispose of them otherwise than to appoint some one to receive them ; the 7th section of the act of 1818, confirms no other sales, previously'or subsequently made, under the state laws, but those for illegal importation, and does not comprise the case of a condemnation under the 7th section.
The final condemnation of the persons on board the Josefa Segunda took place in this court, on the 13th of March 1820, after congress had passed the act of the 3d of March 1819, entitled “ an act in addition to an act prohibiting the slave trade,” by the provisions of which, persons of color, brought in under any of the acts prohibiting the traffic in slaves, were to be delivered to the President of the United States, to be sent to Africa ; it could not affect them. In admiralty cases, a decree is not final, while an appeal from the same is depending in this court,
and any statute which governs the case must be an existing valid statute, at the time of confirming the decrees below; if, therefore, the persons of color, who were on board the Josefa Segunda, when captured, had been specifically before the court, on the 13th of March 1820, they must have been delivered up to the President of the United States, to be sent to Africa, under the provisions of the act of the 23d of March 1819, and therefore, there is no *claim to the proceeds of their sale, under the law of Louisiana, which appropriated the same.1 J The court do not mean to intimate, that the United States are entitled to the money,
for they had no power to sell the persons of color, p. 65.
Appeal from the District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana. The brig Josefa Segunda, a Spanish vessel, proceeding with a cargo of negroes, from the coast of Africa to the island of Cuba, was captured, on the 11th day of February 1818, off St. Domingo, by a regularly commissioned Venezuelan privateer, and on the 24th of the following April, she was seized in the river Mississippi, by custom-house officers of the United States, carried to New Orleans, and there the vessel and negroes were libelled, at the suit of the United States, in the district court of the United States for the Louisiana district.
The libel alleged, that the negroes were unlawfully brought into the United States, with an intent to dispose of them as slaves, contrary to the provisions of the act of congress, passed March 2d, 1807, entitled an act to prohibit the importation of slaves, &c. (2 U. S. Stat. 426.) The libel was tiled on the 29th of April 1818, and a claim was put in by the Spanish owners, alleging an unlawful capture of the brig ; that the brig put into the Balize, in distress, and without any intention to infringe or violate a law of the United States. The district court condemned the brig and effects found on board to the United State's, and the claimants appealed to this court. At February term 1820, of this court, the sentence of the district court of Louisiana was affirmed ; the court having been of opinion, that “ the alleged unlawful importation could not be excused, on the plea of distress and that “ where a capture is made by a regularly commissioned captor, he acquires a title to the captured property, which can only be divested by [p. 37] re-capture, or by the sentence of a competent tribunal; and the captured property is subject to capture for a violation by the captors, of the revenue, or other municipal laws of the neutral country into which the prize may be carried. (5 Wheat. 338.)
1
A repealing act totally abrogates the law forfeiture or liability incurred under such repealed, except as to such rights as became statute, unless the repealing act shall so experfect under it. Pruseux v. Welch, 2 West. pressly provide, and such statute shall be L. Mo. 209. But if a perfect right of action treated as still remaining in force for the pur-has accrued, on a contract authorized by pose of sustaining any proper action or pros-statute, a repeal of the statute does not ecution for the enforcement of such penalty, affect it, or a suit pending for its enforcement. forfeiture or liability. R. S. § 13. But this Pacific Mail Steamship Co. v. Joliffe, 2 Wall. does not apply to the legislature of a territory; 450; Union Paper-bag Machine Co. v. Newell, it is confined to the acts of congress itself. 11 Bl. C. C. 379. It is now provided by law, Dakota v. Wintermute, 7 Chicago Leg. News that the repeal of any statute shall not have 202. the effect to release or extinguish any penalty,
*After the decree of the district court of Louisiana had been pronounced, and before the appeal to this court, the negroes found on L board of the captured brig were, under the provisions of the fourth section of the act of congress, and under the act of the state of Louisiana, passed the 13 th of March 1818, delivered by the collector of the port of New Orleans, to the sheriff of the parish of New Orleans ; and they were by him sold for $68,000, and the proceeds lodged in the Bank of the United States, subject to the order of the district court. Upon the return of the cause to the district of Louisiana, from this court, Mr. Roberts, an inspector of the revenue, and others, who alleged that they had made “ military seizures ” subsequent to that of the officers of the customs, filed claims to the moneys which were the proceeds of the sale of the brig and “ effects,” and of the negroes. Mr. Chew, the collector, conjointly with the naval officers, filed a like claim, and the court having dismissed the claims of Roberts and the asserted “ military captors,” and allowed those of the collector and other officers of the customs, the cause was again brought before this court. (10 Wheat. 312.)
This court, at February term 1825, decided, that “ the district court, under the slave-trade acts, have jurisdiction to determine who are the actual captors, under a state law made in pursuance of the fourth section of the slave-trade act.” The court also decided, that “ under the 7th section of this act of the 2d of March 1807, ch. 77, the entire proceeds of the vessel are forfeited to the use of the United States, unless the seizure be made by armed vessels of the navy, or by revenue officers ; in which case, distribution is to be made in the same manner as prizes taken from the enemy.” The court also decided, “that under the act of the state of Louisiana, of the 13th of March 1828, passed to carry into effect the fourth section of the act of 1807, and directing the negroes imported contrary to the act to be sold, and the proceeds to be paid, ‘ one moiety for the use of the commanding officer of the capturing vessel, and the other moiety to the treasurer of the charity hospital of New Orleans, for the use and benefit of the said hospital,’ no other *person is entitled to the first moiety than the commanding ri{ officer of the navy, or revenue cutter, who may have made the L seizure, under the 7th section of the act of congress.”
The case having returned again to the district court of Louisiana, Mr. Preston, as attorney-general of that state, filed a claim on behalf of that state, setting forth the illegal importation of the negroes, that the greater part of them had been delivered over to the sheriff of New Orleans, that the sheriff had disposed of them, under the law of the legislature of Lousiana, that the proceeds of the sale, $68,000, were brought into the district court, by the order of the court, and that part of the same remains deposited in court. He insisted, 'that the money belonged to the state, and had been brought into court contrary to law and the rights of the state, and prayed for an account, and that the said money might be paid over to him, so far as the same had not been disposed of, conformable to the laws of Louisiana.
In the district court, this claim was opposed, on behalf of the United States. The decree of the court was in favor of the claim, and an appeal was taken by the district-attorney of the United States to this court.
The case was argued by JBerrien, Attorney-General, and Livingston, for the United States ; and by Jones, for the appellee.
For the appellants, it was contended : 1. That the proceedings in the district conrt of Louisiana, upon the claim of the appellee, were irregular, the matter being of admiralty jurisdiction, and they should, therefore, have been by libel and monition. 2. That all proceedings relative to the matter in dispute had been regularly terminated by a final judgment of the supreme court of the United States. 3. That by the judgment of the supreme court, the whole beneficial interest in the proceeds in question has been adjudged to the United States. 4. That with regard at the moiety of the proceeds, which, *by the law of Louisiana, was directed to be paid over to the
J treasurer, or the charity hospital of New Orleans, the proper claimant was the treasurer. 5. That any claim of the attorney-general of Louisiana to the money in the district court is unfounded ; the sale of the negroes having been made without authority, and therefore void, and the whole amount of the sales having been paid without consideration ; and as no title to the negroes was acquired by the purchase, the money belongs to those who paid the same to the sheriff of New Orleans. Upon this last point, and on no other, the opinion of the court was given.
For the United States, it was argued, upon this point, that as the decision of this court, in the case of The Josefa Segunda, reported in 5 and 10 Wheaton, had established the principle which ruled the case, that in reference to negroes brought into the United States, under the circumstances attending their capture and introduction, they were not placed under the power of the legislature of Louisiana, but for the purpose of being received by the sheriff of New Orleans for safe-keeping ; the sale made by the sheriff was invalid and without authority.
The provisions of the 7th section of the act of 1807 are repealed by the act of congress of 1819, “an act in addition to acts prohibiting the slave trade.” (3 U. S. Stat. 532.) By this act, a change in the regulations before adopted by the United States, in relation to persons of color illegally introduced into the United States, was established. The power,given by the act of 1807 to the states to pass laws for the disposition of those persons, was repealed by the act of 1819. The United States had, before that time, been unwilling to direct the mode in which those persons* should be treated ; and it was considered most proper to refer the same to the legislation of the particular states into which they might be brought. By the act of 1819, all such persons, so found in the United States, were directed to be transported to Africa. That act authorizes the president so to remove all negroes brought into the United States, contrary to the act of 1807, and repeals all [p. 39] the United States, not as the property of the United States, or of Louisiana, but under their care. No rights were vested, or could vest, by the decree of the district court, as the appeal suspended the operation of that decree, until affirmed by this court in 1820. The sale of the negroes did not, and could not, become valid, by any consent of the parties before the district court. Until condemnation, undisturbed by an appeal, no rights existed in the court, to order, or in the parties, to consent to or authorize, the sale.
*
prior acts repugnant to its provisions.* Before the passage of the -* act of 1819, the negroes who were on board the Josefa Segunda had not been finally condemned ; as there was an appeal from the decree of condemnation in the district court, depending and undecided, until February 1820. Until the final condemnation by this court in 1820, the negroes remained in the hands of the sheriff of New Orleans, under the protection of
When the case was disposed of in this court, in 1820, the whole of the authority of the district court of Louisiana, which had been exercised in 1818, was at an end, and that court could not legally proceed in the case. The act of 1819 authorized the appointment of an agent, and provided funds for the purpose of removing all such persons, under the direction of the president of the United States, to Africa. It was a necessary consequence of this change in the policy of the government, that all the provisions of the law of 1807, repugnant to its purposes, should bo repealed, and they were repealed. The powers given to the courts to condemn, and the powers given to the states to legislate in reference to those persons, ceased, at the passage of the law of 1819 ; and that law, notwithstanding the sale made by the sheriff, found those negroes among its objects, and it operated upon them, fully and effectually. This court has decided, that no effective disposition of them had been, or could be, made by the legislature of Louisiana, and they were, consequently, in the condition stated, and were the objects of the bountiful and liberal provisions of that law.
It cannot be maintained, that the sale was authorized, either by the act of 1807, or by the law of Louisiana. The act of *1807 gave no power to the court to consent to or order the sale, and Louisiana could not L interfere, until after a sentence of condemnation, which should be final. The claimant, the Spanish owner of the brig, could not give the right to sell. Such is the nature, and such are the effects, of admiralty proceedings. It follows, therefore, that the money now in controversy was paid without consideration ; it belongs to the purchaser of the negroes ; and it cannot, therefore, under any circumstances, belong to the state of Louisiana.
The sale has been made in the execution of a special power delegated congress to the legislature of Louisiana. It is fully established by the decisions of this court, that special powers must be strictly pursued and cannot be exceeded. The act gave no other powers, and did not give this power; If the negroes, instead of being sold, had been distributed among the parties, to await the final decree, and after the act of 1819 had passed, the district court of Louisiana had ordered them to be delivered to the sheriff of New Orleans for sale; looking to the provisions of the act of 1819 ; to the repeal of the act of 1807, giving the legislature of the states power to order a sale of those persons ; to the provisions of the act of 1819, securing to them the privileges of freemen, to be returned to their native country ; to the terms of that act, which embraces negroes delivered to the officers of the United States before or after the date of this law ; could those persons be delivered to slavery ? Would they not rather be subject to the order of the president to be returned to Africa ? Can an illegal sale change the rights of the negroes ?
Jones, for the appellee, contended, that on the admissions of the counsel for the United States, if the act of 1819 did not operate on the case, one
United States v, Preston.
moiety of the money in dispute belonged to the charity hospital of New Orleans. The provisions of the act of 1807, taken together, forfeited the negroes, and gave the property in them, or the proceeds of their sale, to the state of Louisiana, by placing them at the disposition of the state. By that law, the negroes were to remain subject to such regulations as the state may make *for the disposal of them. This gave the property in them to
J the state. Placing property at the disposal of a state, necessarily gives the state the property. This flows essentially from the sovereign character of a state. The provisions of the 7th section of the act of 1807, provide for the corporal delivery of the negroes to the state officers. In the custody of those officers, they remained, until condemnation, which, as soon as it occurs, reverts to the time of seizure. It gives no right, but ascertains it. The judicial proceedings confirm and improve it, but do not create it. The act of congress having declared to whose benefit the forfeiture incurred by the violation of its provisions shall accrue, and that being the state, the condemnation does but confirm it.
As to the invalidity of the sale, it was contended, that if the admiralty court had power to order a sale, pendente lite, the agreement that the sale would be made, was operative and equally effectual. The right of an admiralty court to do so, exists under special circumstances ; but consent supplied the necessity of such circumstances. It is to be presumed, that there was an order of court to confirm the sale, as the money arising from it was deposited in the court under its order.
The property in the negroes having thus become that of the state of Louisiana, under the law of 1807 ; that state having appointed an officer to take charge of them, and legislated as to the disposal of them, under the authority of that act; the district court having condemned the negroes, before the law of 1819, and that condemnation having established judicially the right of the state at the time of seizure; the provisions of the law of 1819 could not affect rights thus given, vested and executed.
Johnson, Justice, delivered the opinion of the court.—The case of The Josefa Segunda has been twice already before this court; the first time, upon the question of condemnation; the second, upon the application of several claimants to be preferred in the distribution of the proceeds. It now comes up upon a claim to the proceeds of the sale of the persons of color * , found on board at the time of the ^seizure, interposed by the law-
J officer of the state of Louisiana.
The vessel was condemned, under the 7th section of the act of 1807, passed to abolish the slave-trade. By the 4th section of the act, the state of Louisiana was empowered to pass laws for disposing of such persons of color as should be imported or brought into that state, in violation of that law. The offence, under the 7th section, on which this condemnation was founded, is not that of importing or bringing into the United States, but that of hovering on the coast, with intend to bring in, persons of color, to be disposed of as slaves, contrary to law; and although it forfeits the vessel, and any goods or effects found on board, it is silent as to disposing of the colored persons found on board, any further than to impose a duty upon officers of armed vessels, who may capture them, to keep them safely, to be [p. 41] delivered to the overseers of the poor, or the governor of the state, or persons appointed by the respective states to receive the same.
The state of Louisiana passed an act, on the 13th of March 1818, which recites the provisions of the 4th and 7th sections of the act of congress, and authorizes and requires the sheriff of New Orleans to receive any colored persons designated under either of those sections, and the same to keep, until the district or circuit court of the United States shall pronounce a decree upon the charge of illegal importation. The 2d section makes provision for selling them, upon receiving a certificate of such decision, and enjoins a distribution of the proceeds ; one-half to the commanding officer of the capturing vessel, the other to the treasurer of the charity hospital of New Orleans. In pursuance of this law of the state, it appears, that after the decree of condemnation below, but pending the appeal in this court, the sheriff went on to sell, with the consent, it is said, of all paities; and $65,000, the sum now in controversy, was deposited in the registry of the court below, to await the final disposal of the law.
The 20th of April 1818, congress passed another act on *this subject, by the 10th section of wThich, the first six sections of the act of '• 1807 are repealed; but their provisions are re-enacted with a little more amplitude ; and the 5th section of this act, which professes to reserve to the states the powers given in the former act, as well as the language of the repealing clause, in the saving wThich it contains as to offences, still confines all their provisions to the case of illegal importation ; thus leaving the 7th section in force, but without any express powei* to dispose of the colored persons, otherwise than to appoint some one to receive them. And so likewise, the 7th section of the act of 1818, which professes to confirm sales previously or subsequently made undex* the state laws, confines its provisions to sales made under condemnation for illegal importation ; thus not comprising the cases of condemnation under the 7th section of the act of 1807, at least, so far as relates to this offence.
The final condemnation in this court took place, March 13th, 1820 ; but previous to that time, was passed the act of March 3d, 1819, entitled, an act in addition to an act, prohibiting the slave-trade ; by which a new arrangement is made as to the disposal of persons of color seized and brought in under any of the acts prohibiting the traffic in slaves. By the latter act, they are deliverable to the orders of the president; not of the states. And the repealing clause repeals all acts and parts of acts w’hich may be repugnant to this act. So that, if in the disposal of persons of color brought into the United States, the provisions of this act embrace the case of such persons, w’hen brought in under the 7th section of the act of 1807, the power to deliver them to the order of the states was taken away, before the final decree of this court.
Such, in the opinion of the court, is the effect of the act of 1819. And then the question is, how does it affect the present controversy? Ever since the case of Yeaton v. United States, 5 Cranch 286, the court has uniformly acted under the rule established in that case ; to wit, that in admiralty causes, a decree was not final, while it was depending here. And any *statute which governs the case, must be an existing valid statute, at the time of affirming the decree below. Whatever was the extent of the legal power of the state over the Africans, it is clear, that such power
United States Bank v. Swan.
could not be exercised finally over them, at any time previous to the final decree of this court; we must, therefore, consider, whether, if they had been specifically before the court, at the date of that decree, they must have been delivered up to the state, or the United States : clearly to the United States. And then this claim of the state cannot be sustained. We would not be understood to intimate, that the United States are entitled to this money ; for they had no power to sell; nor do we feel ourselves bound to remove the difficulties which grow out of this state of things.
With regard to the ground of irregularity : if not abandoned by the attorney-general, it was but slightly touched upon, and we know of no other mode, in the existing state of things, in which the rights of the parties could be reached, according to the course of the admiralty, but that here pursued.
On the question, whether the* decision in the second cause, in which the subject of this seizure was before us, was not final as to the rights of the United States, we are clearly of opinion, that it was not, as against this party. Although this question might then have been raised by the state, and could as well then have been settled ; yet it was not raised, nor was it the interest of any of the parties then before the court, that it should be raised. The decree below must be reversed.
This cause came on to be heard, on the transcript of the record from the circuit court of the United States for the eastern district of Louisiana, and was argued by counsel: On consideration whereof, it is ordered and decreed by this court, that the decree of the said circuit court in this cause be and the same is hereby reversed, and that the said cause be and the same is hereby remanded, for further proceedings to be had therein, according to law and justice, and in conformity to the opinion of the court.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access