United States v. Gooding, 25 U.S. (12 Wheat.) 460 (1827)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
United States v. Gooding, 25 U.S. (12 Wheat.) 460 (1827)
Full caption
United States v. Gooding.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1827
United States v. Gooding.
Slave-trade.—Indictment.—Burden of proof.
Upon an indictment under the slave-trade act of the 20th of April 1818, ch. 373, against the owner of the ship, testimony of the declarations of the master, being a part of the res gestoe, connected with acts in furtherance of the voyage, and within the scope of his authority, as agent of the owner, in the conduct of the guilty enterprise, is admissible in evidence against the owner.1 Upon such an indictment against the owner, charging him with fitting out the ship, with intent to employ her in the illegal voyage, evidence is admissible, that he commanded, authorized and superintended the fitment, through the instrumentality of his agents, without being personally present.
It is not essential, to constitute a fitting out, under the acts of congress, that every equipment, necessary for a slave-voyage, or any equipment peculiarly adapted to such a voyage, should be taken on board; it is sufficient, if the vessel is actually fitted out, with intent to be employed in the illegal voyage.
In such an indictment, it is not necessary to specify the particulars of the fitting out; it is sufficient, to allege the offence in the words of the statute.
Nor is it necessary, that there should be any principal offender to whom the defendant might be aiding and abetting; these terms in the statute do not refer to the relation of principal and accessory in cases of felony; both the actor, and he who aids and abets the act, are considered as principals.
It is necessary, that the indictment should aver, that the vessel was built, fitted out, &c., or caused to sail, or be sent away, within the jurisdiction of the United States.
An averment that the ship was fitted out, &c., “ with intent that the said vessel should be employed ” in the slave-trade, is fatally defective, the words of the statute being, “ with intent to employ ” the vessel in the slave-trade, and exclusively referring to the intent of the party causing the act.
Objections to the form and sufficiency of the indictment may, in the discretion of the
J court, be discussed and decided, during the trial before the jury ; but, generally speaking, they ought regularly to be considered only upon a motion to quash the indictment, or in arrest of judgment, or on demurrer.
In criminal proceedings, the onus probandi rests upon the prosecutor, unless a different provision is expressly made by statute?
Certificate of Division from the Circuit Court of Maryland. This was a prosecution in the circuit court of Maryland, against the defendant, Gooding, under the slave-trade act of the 20th of April 1818, ch. 373. The indictment alleged :
1. That the said Gooding, being a citizen of the United States, after the passing of the act of the congress of the United States, entitled, “ an act in addition to an act to prohibit the introduction of slaves into any port or place within the jurisdiction of the United States, from and after the first day of January, in the year of our Lord 1808, and to repeal certain parts of the same,” that is to say, after the 20th of April 1818, to wit, on the 30th day of September, in the year 1824, at the district of Maryland, did fit out, for himself, as owner, in the port of Baltimore, within the jurisdiction of the United States, and within the jurisdiction of this court, a certain vessel called the General Winder, with intent to employ the said vessel, the General Winder, in procuring negroes from a foreign country, to wit, from the p. 293continent of Africa, to be transported to another place, to wit, to the Island of Cuba, in the West Indies, to be sold as slaves, contrary to the true intent and meaning of the act of congress in such case made and provided ; to the evil example of all others in like case offending, and against the peace, government and dignity of the said United States.
1
See The Kate, 2 Wall. 350; The Sarah, Id. mony, as, circumstantial evidence of an alibi, 366; The Weathergage, Id. 875 ; The Reindeer, there arose a reasonable doubt of the defend-Id. 883. ant’s guilt, he should be acquitted. Tanner v.
2. That the said Gooding, a citizen of the said United States, and residing therein, to wit, at the district aforesaid, after the passing of the act of congress aforesaid, to wit, on the day and year last aforesaid, within the jurisdiction of this court, at the district aforesaid, did, for himself, as owner, send away from the port of Baltimore, within the jurisdiction of the United States, a certain other vessel, called the General Winder, with intent to employ the said vessel, the General Winder, in procuring negroes from a foreign country, *to wit, from the continent of Africa, to be transported to another place, to wit, to the Island of Cuba, to be sold t as slaves, contrary to the true intent and meaning of the act of congress in such case made and provided ; to the evil example of all others in like case offending, and against the peace, government and dignity of the United States.
3. That the said Gooding, a citizen of the said United States, and residing therein, after the passing of the act of congress aforesaid, to wit, on the day and year last aforesaid, at the district aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did aid in fitting out, for himself, as owner, in the port of Baltimore, within the jurisdiction of the United States, to wit, at the district aforesaid, a certain other vessel, called the General Winder, with intent that the said vessel, the General Winder, should be employed in procuring negroes from a foreign country, to wit, from the continent of Africa, to be transported to another place, to wit, to the Island of Cuba, to be sold as slaves, contrary to the true intent and meaning of the act of congress in such case made and provided ; to the evil example of all others in like case offending, and against the peace, government and dignity of the said United States.
4. That the said Gooding, a citizen of the said United States, and residing therein, after the passing of the act of congress aforesaid, to wit, on the day and year last aforesaid, at the district aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did abet the taking on board, from one of the coasts of Africa, divers negroes, to wit, 290, not being inhabitants, nor held to service by the laws of either of the states or territories of the United States, of a certain other vessel, called the General Winder, for the purpose of selling such negroes as slaves, contrary to the true intent and meaning of the act of congress in such case made and provided ; to the evil example of all others in like case offending, and against the peace, government and dignity of the said United States.
5. That the said Gooding, a citizen of the United States, and residing therein, after the passing of the act of congress aforesaid, to wit, on the day and year last aforesaid, at the district aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, *did, for himself, as owner, cause to sail from the port of Baltimore, within the jurisdiction of the United States, a certain *• other vessel, called the General Winder, with intent that the said vessel, the General Winder, should be employed in procuring negroes from a foreign country, to wit, from the continent of Africa, to be transported to another p. 294place, to wit, to the Island of Cuba, to be sold as slaves, contrary to the true intent and meaning of the act of congress in such case made and provided; to the evil example of all others in like case offending, and against the peace, government and dignity of the said United States.
6. That the said Gooding, a citizen of the United States, and residing therein, after the passing of the act of congress aforesaid, to wit, on the day and year last aforesaid, at the district aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did, for himself, as owner, cause to be sent away from the port of Baltimore, within the jurisdiction of the United States, a certain other vessel, called the General Winder, with intent that the said vessel, the General Winder, should be employed in procuring negroes from a foreign country, to wit, from the continent of Africa, to be transported to a certain other place, to wit, to the Island of Cuba, to be sold as slaves, contrary to the true intent and meaning of the act of congress, in such case made and provided; to the evil example of all others in like case offending, and against the peace, government and dignity of the said United States.
7. That the said Gooding, a citizen of the United States, and residing therein, after the passing of the act of congress aforesaid, to wit, on the day and year last aforesaid, at the district aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this court, did, for himself, as owner, or for other persons, as factor, fit out, equip, load or otherwise prepare, a certain other ship or vessel, called the General Winder, in the port of Baltimore, within the jurisdiction of the United States, to wit, at the district aforesaid, or did cause the same ship or vessel, the General Winder, to be so fitted out, equipped, loaded or otherwise prepared, with intent that the said ship or vessel, the General Winder, should be employed in procuring negroes, mulattoes or persons of color, from a foreign kingdom, place or country, to wit, from the continent of Africa, *4R41 transported to another port or place, to wit, to *the Island of
J Cuba, in the West Indies, to be there sold, or otherwise disposed of as slaves, or held to labor or service, contrary to the true intend and meaning of the act of congress in such case made and provided; to the evil example of all others in like case offending, and against the peace, government and dignity of the said United States.
At the trial in the circuit court, the United States offered evidence that the defendant purchased of one McElderry, the vessel called the General Winder, in the indictment mentioned, and that said vessel was built in the port of Baltimore, also in the said indictment mentioned. They further offered in evidence, that at the time said purchase was made, the said vessel was not completely finished, and that the same was finished, under the superintendence of a certain Captain John Hill, who was appointed by the defendant, master of said vessel, on her then intended voyage. They also offered in evidence, that the defendant was, at the time when the offence laid in the indictment was charged to have been committed, and at the time of his purchase of the said vessel, and ever since had been, a citizen of the United States, and had constantly, from the time of the purchase of the said vessel, till the present period, been an actual resident of the said port of Baltimore.
They further offered evidence, that after the said purchase, and after the appointment of the said Captain Hill as master, as aforesaid, the said Hill ordered various fitments for the said vessel, at the said port of p. 295Baltimore, which said fitments were furnished for said vessel, and afterwards, on the order of said Hill, were paid for by the defendant. They also offered in evidence, that some of these fitments were peculiarly adapted for the slave-trade, and are never put on board any other vessels than those intended for such trade ; a part of such fitments, so ordered by Captain Hill and paid for by the defendant, to wit, three dozen of brooms, eighteen scrapers, and two trumpets, were actually put on board the General Winder, in the port of Baltimore, the residue of the equipments on board the General Winder, at the time of her departure, being such as are usual on board vessels carrying on trade between said port and the West Indies; and the rest of such fitments, peculiar to the slave-trade as *aforesaid, were shipped at the said port of Baltimore, on board another vessel called the Pocahon- •- tas, chartered by the defendant. That the said vessel called the General Winder, sailed from the port of Baltimore, fitted as aforesaid, and with the said Hill as master, on or about the 21st day of August 1824, having cleared for the island of St. Thomas, in the West Indies. That the other vessel, called the Pocahontas, also sailed for St. Thomas, from the port of Baltimore, with the part of the said fitments put on board her as before mentioned, some time in the month of September following. They also gave evidence that both the said vessels, the General Winder and the Pocahontas, afterwards arrived at St. Thomas, and that, at that island, the said peculiar fitments, shipped as aforesaid in the Pocahontas, were there transshipped from said vessel to the General Winder, the said Hill still being the master of the last-mentioned vessel. They also further offered in evidence, that the defendant, about six or seven months after the sailing of the General Winder from the said port of Baltimore, declared in the presence of a competent witness, that the General Winder had made him a good voyage, having arrived with a cargo of slaves, the witness thought he said 290, and that he also declared in the presence of the same witness, at another time, that he, the defendant, was the sole owner of the said vessel, called the General Winder. They also offered in evidence, by another witness, that the defendant, had, at another time, declared in the presence of this other witness, that the said witness, who was a creditor of the defendant, should be paid one-half his debt, on the arrival of the General Winder at Trinidad de Cuba. The United States, further to support the said indictment, offered to give in evidence to the jury, by a certain Captain Peter L. Coit, that he, Captain Coit, was at St. Thomas, while the General Winder was at that island, as before stated, in September 1824, and that he was frequently on board the said vessel, at that time, at St. Thomas ; that the said Captain Hill, the said master of the General Winder, then and there proposed to the said witness, Captain Coit, to engage on board the General Winder, as mate, for the voyage *then in progress, and described the same to be _ a voyage to the coast of Africa for slaves, and thence back to Trini- L dad de Cuba. That he offered to the said witness $70 per month, and five dollars per head for every prime slave which should be brought to Cuba. That on the witness inquiring who would see the crew paid, in the event of a disaster attending the voyage, Captain Hill replied, “uncle John,” meaning (as witness understood) John Gooding, the defendant.
The defendant’s counsel objected to the admissibility of this evidence, p. 296and the judges divided in opinion upon its admissibility. They also moved the court for its opinion upon the following points :
1. That on the charges contained in the 1st, 2d, 3d, 5th and 6th counts in the indictment, it is incumbent on the United States to prove, that the vessel, named or mentioned in the indictment, was fitted out, sent away, caused to sail, or caused to be sent away, with intent to transport negroes from the coast of Africa to the Island of Cuba.
2. That evidence, that the defendant caused the vessel in question to be fitted out by Captain John Hill, or any one else, will not support the first count in the indictment, in which he is charged with fitting her out himself.
3. That the first count charges a fitting out in the port of Baltimore, which, according to the true legal interpretation of the words in an indictment, means a complete equipment; and that evidence of a partial preparation here, and a further equipment at St. Thomas, will not support the charge contained in this count.
4. That the defendant cannot be convicted on the first count, because no offence is legally charged in the said count, it being necessary to specify the particular equipments in the indictment, in order that the defendant may have notice of the particular charge against him.
5. That the defendant cannot be convicted upon the third and fourth counts, because these counts do not charge any offence to have been committed by any principal, to whom the defendant was or could be aiding or abetting ; also, that he cannot be convicted upon the fourth count, unless he was actually or constructively present when the negroes were *taken on board on the coast of Africa ; and if the defendant was in
J Baltimore, at the time the said negroes were taken on board, on the coast of Africa, he could not aid or abet, within the meaning of the fourth section of the act of congress of 20th of April 1818, upon which he was indicted.
6. That the defendant cannot be convicted on the 2d, 5th and 6th counts in the indictment, because no legal offence is charged in either of these counts, the said counts not charging that the General Winder was built, fitted, equipped, loaded, or otherwise prepared, within the jurisdiction of the United States ; and that the said 5th and 6th counts are also defective, in charging the defendant with intent that the vessel should be employed in the slave-trade, instead of charging him with intent to employ her.
7. That the defendant cannot be convicted on the 3d, 4th, 5th and 6th counts, unless there be a previous conviction of the principal in the offence, in the said counts mentioned.
The opinions of the judges being divided upon these points, and also upon the question of allowing objections to the form and sufficiency of the indictment to be discussed at the trial before the jury, the questions were certified to this court for final determination.
March 12th and 13th, 1827. The cause was argued by the Attorney-General and Coxe, for the United States ; and by Taney and Mitchell, for the defendant.
March 16th. Story, Justice, delivered the opinion of the court.—This is the case of an indictment against Gooding for being engaged in the slave-trade, contrary to the prohibitions of the act of congress of the 20th of
April 1818. It comes before us upon a certificate of division of opinions in the circuit court of the district of Maryland, upon certain points raised at the trial. We take this opportunity of expressing our anxiety, lest by too great indulgence to the wishes of counsel, questions of this sort should be frequently brought before this court, and thus, in effect, an appeal in ♦criminal cases become an ordinary proceeding, to the manifest obstruction of public justice, and against the plain intendment of the acts of congress. Cases of real doubt and difficulty, or of extensive consequence as to principle and application, and furnishing matter for very grave deliberation, are those alone which can be reasonably presumed to have been within the purview of the legislature, in allowing an appeal to this court upon certificates of division. In this very case, some of the questions certified may have been argued and decided in the court below, upon the motion to quash the indictment; and there are others, upon which !t is understood, that the circuit court had no opportunity of passing a deliberate judgment.
The first question that arises is upon the division of opinions whether, under the circumstances of the case, the testimony of Captain Coit to the facts stated in the record, was admissible. That testimony was to the following effect: that he, Captain Coit, was at St. Thomas, while the General Winder was at that island, in September 1824, and was frequently on board the vessel, at that time ; that Captain Hill, the master of the vessel, then and there proposed to the witness to engage on board the General Winder as mate, for the voyage then in progress, and described the same to be a voyage to the coast of Africa, for slaves, and thence back to Trinidad de Cuba; that he offered to the witness $70 per month, and five dollars per head for every prime slave which should be brought to Cuba ; that on the witness inquiring who would see the crew paid in the event of a disaster attending the voyage, Captain Hill replied, “ Uncle John,” meaning (as the witness understood) John Gooding, the defendant.
It is to be observed, that, as preliminary to the admission of this testimony, evidence had been offered to prove that Gooding was owner of the vessel, that he lived at Baltimore, where she was fitted out, and that he appointed Hill master, and gave him authority to make the fitments for the voyage, and paid the bills therefor ; that certain equipments were put on board peculiarly adapted for the slave-trade ; and that Gooding had made declarations that the vessel had been engaged in the slave-trade, and had made him a good *voyage. The foundation of the authority of the master, the nature of the fitments, and the object and accomplishment t of the voyage, being thus laid, the testimony of Captain Coit was offered as confirmatory of the proof, and properly admissible against the defendant. It was objected to, and now stands upon the objection, before us. The argumant is, that the testimony is not admissible, because, in criminal cases, the declarations of the master of the vessel, are not evidence to charge the owner with an offence ; and that the doctrine of the binding effect of such declarations by known agents, is, and ought to be, confined to civil cases. We cannot yield to the force of the argument. In general, the rules of evidence in criminal and civil cases are the same. Whatever the agent does, within the scope of his authority, binds his principal, and is deemed his act. It must, indeed, be shown, that the agent has the authority, and that the act is within its scope ; but these being conceded or proved, either by the course of p. 298business, or by express authorization, the same conclusion arises, in point of law, in both cases. Nor is there any authority for confining the rule to civil cases. On the contrary, it is the known and familiar principle of criminal jurisprudence, that he who commands, or procures a crime to be done, if it be done, is guilty of the crime, and the act is his act. This is so true, that even the agent may be innocent, when the procurer or principal may be convicted of guilt, as in the case of infants or idiots, employed to administer poison. The proof of the command or procurement, may be direct or indirect, positive or circumstantial; but this is matter for the consideration of the jury, and not of legal competency. So, in cases of conspiracy and riot, when once the conspiracy or combination is established, the act of one conspirator, in the prosecution of the enterprise, is considered the act of all, and is evidence against all. Each is deemed to consent to, or command, what is done by any other, in furtherance of the common object. Upon the facts of the present case, the master was just as much a guilty principal as the owner, and just as much within the purview of the act, by the illegal fitment. *¿£»701 The ev^ence here offered was not the mere declarations *of the
J master, upon other occasions, totally disconnected with the objects of the voyage. These declarations were connected with acts in furtherance of the objects of the voyage, and within the general scope of his authority as conductor of the enterprise. He had an implied authority to hire a crew, and do other acts necessary for the voyage. The testimony went to establish, that he endeavored to engage Captain Coit to go as mate, for the voyage then in progress, and his declarations were all made with reference to that object, and as persuasives to the undertaking. They were, therefore, in the strictest sense, a part of the res gestae, the necessary explanations attending the attempt to hire. If he had hired a mate, the terms of the hiring, though verbal, would have been part of the act, and the nature of the voyage, as explained at the time, a necessary ingredient. The act would have been so combined with the declarations, as to be inseparable, without injustice. The sume authority from the owner which allows the master to hire the crew, justifies him in making such declarations and explanations as are proper to attain the object. Those declarations and explanations are as much within the scope of the authority, as the act of hiring itself. Our opinion of the admissibility of this evidence proceeds upon the ground, that these were not the naked declarations of the master, unaccompanied with his acts in that capacity, but declarations coupled with proceedings for the objects of the voyage, and while it was in progress. We give no opinion upon the point, whether mere declarations, under other circumstances, would have been admissible. The principle which we maintain is stated with great clearness by Mr. Starkie, in his Treatise on Evidence (2 Stark. Evid. part 4, p. 60) : “ Where,” says he, “ the fact of agency has been proved, either expressly or presumptively, the act of the agent, co-extensive with the authority, is the act of the principal, whose mere instrument he is, and then, whatever the agent says, within the scope of his authority, the principal says, and evidence may be given of such acts and declarations, as if they had been actually done and made by the principal himself.”(a)
(a) See also 2 Stark. Evid. part 4, p. 403,404.
*The other questions arise from the instructions or opinions prayed for by the defendant, at the trial, upon matters of law, upon which also the judges were divided in opinion.
The first instruction prayed puts the point, whether the burden of proof of the offences charged in the indictment did not rest upon the United States. Without question, it does, in all cases where a party stands charged with an offence, unless a different provision is made by some statute; for the general rule of our jurisprudence is, that the party accused need not establish his innocence ; but it is for the government itself to prove his guilt, before it is entitled to a verdict or conviction. This question has been abandoned at the argument here, and is too plain for controversy, since there is no statutable provision altering the general principle in this particular.
The second instruction is conceived in very general terms, so general, indeed, that it cannot be supported, if it is to be understood in its obvious sense. It asks the court to instruct the jury that evidence that the defendant caused the vessel to be fitted out by Captain Hill, or any one else, will not support the first count in the indictment, in which the defendant is charged with fitting her out himself. This obviously covers the case, where the fitting out is by the instrumentality of any other persons, however innocent of his design, even though the defendant himself should be personally present, either really or constructively, and superintending the whole operations. To this extent, it is clearly unmaintainable. But, in a more restrictive sense, it involves the question, whether evidence, that the owner commanded, authorized and superintended the fitment, through his agents, without his personal presence, would support this count. We are of opinion, in the affirmative. The act of congress does not require that the fitting out should be by the owner personally, without the assistance or agency of others. The act itself is of a nature which forbids such a supposition. The fitment of a vessel is, ordinarily, and, indeed, must be done, through the instrumentality of others. It is not a single act, but a series of subordinate operations, requiring the co-operation of persons in various trades and arts, all conducing to the same end. It would be against the plain sense of the *legislature, to interpret its language to mean, that the act which it *• punishes, and which must or may be done by many, in the ordinary course of business, shall only be punishable, when the extraordinary fact occuks of its being done by one person. If done by others, under the command and direction of the owner, with his approbation and for his benefit, it is just as much, in contemplation of law, his own act, as if done by himself. To this extent, at least, the maxim may be safely applied, quifacit per alium,facit per se. And it cannot be material, whether it be done in his absence from, or his presence in, the scene. Especially, there can be no doubt, that the principle ought to be applied with increased force, where the owner resides at the same port or neighborhood, and superintends the course of the operations, even if he does not see them. Even in the highest crimes, those who are present, aiding and commanding, or abetting, are deemed principals ; and, if absent, in treason and in misdemeanors, they are still deemed principals ; though it may be necessary, in treason, to lay the overt acts precisely according to the fact, from considerations peculiar to that offence. This instruction ought, therefore, to have been refused.
The third instruction turns upon the point, whether the fitting out, in the sense of the act of congress, means a complete equipment, so that a partial equipment only will extract the case from the prohibitions of the statute. This objection appears to us to proceed from a mistaken view of the facts applicable to the case. If the vessel actually sailed on her voyage from Baltimore, for the purpose of employment in the slave-trade, her fitment was complete, for all the purposes of the act. It is by no means necessary, that every equipment for a slave-voyage should have been taken on board at Baltimore ; nor, indeed, that any equipments exclusively applicable to such a voyage, should have been on board. The presence of such equipments may furnish strong presumptive proof of the object of the voyage, but they do not constitute the offence. The statute punishes the fitting out of a vessel, with intent to employ her in the slave-trade, however innocent the equipment may be, when designed for a lawful voyage. It is the act, combined with the intent, and not either, separately, which is punishable. *. h -] Whether the *fitting out be fully adequate for the purposes of a slaveJ voyage may, as matter of presumption, be more or less conclusive ; but if the intent of the fitment be to carry on a slave-voyage, and the vessel depart on the voyage, her fitting out is complete, so far as the parties deem it necessary for their object, and the statute reaches the case.
But we are also of opinion, that any preparations for a slave-voyage, which clearly manifest or accompany the illegal intent, even though incomplete and imperfect, and before the departure of the vessel from port, do yet constitute a fitting out, within the purview of the statute. This was held by this court, upon full consideration, in the cases of The Emily and The Caroline, 9 Wheat. 381, and The Plattsburg, 10 Ibid. 133. Those cases, indeed, arose upon the construction of the slave-trade acts of 1794, 1800 and 1807 ; but the language of those acts is almost literally transcribed into the statute of 1818, and the construction adopted therein must govern the present case. In either view, therefore, our answer to the third prayer is, that a complete equipment is not necessary to be proved, but any partial preparation, which demonstrates or accompanies the illegal intent, will bring the case within the statute, and support the charge in the first count of the indictment.
The fourth instruction respects the sufficiency of the averments of the first count; and it is contented, that there ought to have been a specification of the particulars of the fitting out, and that it is not sufficient, to allege the act itself, without them. The indictment, in this respect, follows the language of the statute, and is as certain as that is. We cannot perceive any good reason for holding the government to any greater certainty in the averments of the indictment. The fitting out of a vessel may, and must, consist of a variety of minute acts and preparations, almost infinite in their detail, and the enumeration would answer no valuable purpose to the defendant, to assist him in his defence, and subserve no public policy. The fitting out of a vessel is a sort of business, which is as clear and definite as any other; and we might just as well, in an indictment upon the act for building a ship with the illegal intent, require that the government ♦a*74.1 *should particularize the acts of building, through their whole details, ■* as those of equipment. The building of a ship is not an act more certain in its nature, than the fitting out of a ship. The particular prepara-
1827] OF THE UNITED STATES 474
tions are matters of evidence, and not of averment. Every man may well be presumed to know, what are the fitments of a vessel for a voyage, without more particularity. The objection proceeds upon the supposition, that ordinary equipments only, though combined with the illegal intent, are not within the act; and that extraordinary equipments only, for such a voyage, are provided for. This has been already shown to be an incorrect exposition of the statute. It imputes no guilt to any particulars of the equipment, but to the act, combined with the illegal intent.
In general, it may be said, that it is sufficient certainty in an indictment, to allege the offence in the very terms of the statute. We say, in general, for there are doubtless cases where more particularity is required, either from the obvious intention of the legislature, or from the application of known principles of law. At the common law, in certain descriptions of offences, and especially of capital offences, great nicety and particularity are often necessary. The rules which regulate this branch of pleading were sometimes founded in considerations which no longer exist, either in our own or in English jurisprudence; but a rule being once established, it still prevails, although if the case were new, it might not now be incorporated into the law. So, again, in certain classes of statutes, the rule of very strict certainty has sometimes been applied, where the common law furnished a close and appropriate analogy. Such are the cases of indictments for false pretences, and sending threatening letters, where the pretences and the letters are required to be set forth, from the close analogy to indictments for perjury and forgery. Courts of law have thought such certainty not unreasonable or inconvenient, and calculated to put the plea of autrefois acquit, or convict, as well as of general defence at the trial, fairly within the power of the prisoner. But these instances are by no means considered as leading to the establishment of any general rule. On the contrary, the course has been to leave every class of cases to be decided *very much upon its own peculiar circumstances. Thus, in cases of „ conspiracy, it has never been held necessary to set forth the overt *- acts or means, though these might materially assist the prisoner’s defence. So, in cases of solicitation to commit crimes, it has been held sufficient, to state the act of solicitation, without any averment of the special means. And in endeavors to commit a revolt, which is, by statute, in England, made a capital offence, it has always been deemed sufficient, to allege the offence in the words of the statute, without setting forth any particulars of the manner or the means. These cases approach very near to the present; and if any, by way of precedent, ought to govern it, they well may govern it. The case of treason stands upon a peculiar ground ; there, the overt acts must, by statute, be specially laid in the indictment, and must be proved as laid. The very act, and mode of the act, must, therefore, be laid as it is intended to be proved. If the party be only constructively a principal, as an absent and distant coadjutor or leader, it may be necessary to aver the fact accordingly. There is great good sense in the rule which has been laid down, that where the offence is made up of a number of minute acts, which cannot be enumerated upon the record, without great prolixity and inconvenience, and the danger of variance, they ought to be dispensed with. The present case is a fit illustration of the rule ; the fitting out is a compound of various minute acts, almost incapable of exact specification.
The fifth instruction turns upon a doctrine applicable to principal and accessory in cases of felony, either at the common law or by statute. The present is the case of a misdemeanor, and the doctrine, therefore, cannot be applied to it; for in cases of misdemeanors, all those who are concerned in aiding and abetting, as well as in perpetrating the act, are principals. Under such circumstances, there is no room for the question of actual or constructive presence or absence ; for whether present or absent, all are principals. They may be indicted and punished accordingly. Nor is the trial or conviction of an actor indispensable to furnish a right to try the person who aids or abets the act; each, in the eye of the law, is deemed guilty as a p. 303fitted out, &c., as its antecedent, or the relative “ such ” can have no meaning at all. The word is sensible in the place where it occurs, and it is the duty or the court, when it can, to give effect to every word in every enactment, if it can be done, without violating the obvious intention of the legislature. This is a penal act, and is to be construed strictly, that is, with no intendment or extension beyond the import of the words used. There is no certainty that the legislature meant to prohibit the sailing of any vessel on a slave-voyage, which had not been built, fitted out, &c., within the jurisdiction of the United States. If a foreign vessel, designed for the slave-trade, and fully fitted out for that purpose, were, by accident or design, to anchor in our ports, it would not be reasonable to suppose, that the legislature could have intended the sailing of such a vessel from our ports to be an offence, within the purview of our laws. Yet, if the construction contended for on behalf of the United States be adopted, that would be the result.
*
.„„-1 principal. In the *present indictment, the offence is in the third and J fourth counts laid, by aiding and abetting, in the very terms of the act of congress. If the crime, therefore, could be supposed to be of an accessorial nature, it is truly alleged, according to the fact, and not merely ^according to the intendment of law. We do not consider, that the terms " aid ” and “ abet,” used in this statute, are used as technical phrases belonging to the common law, because the offence is not made a felony, and therefore, the words require no such interpretation. The statute punishes them as substantive offences, and not as accessorial, and the words are, therefore, to be understood as in the common parlance, and import assistance, co-operation and encouragement. These remarks furnish an answer to the seventh instruction, which must share the fate of the fifth. The sixth instruction is that which has presented the most difficulty. It embraces two propositions; the first is, that the second, fifth and sixth counts in the indictment, ought to have contained an averment that the vessel was built, fitted out, &c., within the jurisdiction of the United States; the second is, that the fifth and sixth counts do not allege the offence in the words of the statute, those words being, “with intent to employ the vessel” in the slave-trade, &c., whereas, each of these counts avers, “with intent that the said vessel should be employed ” in the slave-trade, which imports a very different state of facts. In order to understand these exceptions, it is necessary to attend carefully to the very words of the act of congress. The second section enacts, “ that no citizen or citizens, &c., shall, after the passing of this act as aforesaid, for himself, themselves, or any other person or persons whatsoever, either as master, factor or owner, build, fit, equip, load, or otherwise prepare, any ship or vessel, in any port or place within the jurisdiction of the United States, nor cause any such ship or vessel to sail from any port or place whatsoever, within the jurisdiction of the same, for the purpose of procuring any negroes, &c., to be transported, &c., as slaves.” The third section enacts, “ that every person or persons so building, fitting out, equipping, loading, or otherwise preparing, or sending away, or causing any of the acts aforesaid to be done, with intent to employ * *such ship or vessel in such trade or business, after the passing of this J act, contrary to the true intent and meaning thereof, or who shall in anywise be aiding or abetting therein, shall severally, on conviction thereof by due course of law, forfeit, &c. The first point turns upon the interpretation of the words “ such ship or vessel,” in each of these sections. To what do they refer ? The only ship or vessel spoken of in either section, is such as have been built, fitted out, &c., in some port or place of the United States. “ Such ship or vessel ” must, therefore, refer to a ship or vessel so built,
But it is sufficient to say, that the word “ such ” has an appropriate sense, and can be reasonably referred only to the ship or vessel previously spoken of; and such ship or vessel is not merely one built, fitted out, &c., but one built, fitted out, &c., in a port or place within the United States. The whole description must be taken together. If we were to adopt any other construction, we should read the words as if “ such ” were struck out, and the clause stood, “ any ship or vessel.” Such a course would not be defensible in construing a penal statute. It is remarkable, that in the slave-trade acts of 1794 (1 U. S. Stat. 347), and of 1807 *(2 Ibid. 426), the word “ such ” is omitted, and seems to have been introduced into the act of 1818, ex industrial. NVe must take the law as we find it, and, upon examination of its language, we are of opinion, that this exception is well taken. The cases of the United States n. Lacoste, 2 Mason 129, and United States v. Smith, Ibid. 143, have been cited at the bar as containing a different opinion expressed in the circuit court in Massachusetts. I owe it, in candor, to acknowledge, that the fact is so ; but I have no recollection that the point was made at the argument, and I am confident, that it never was insisted upon in the view which has been presented by the argument in this court. My own error, however, can furnish no ground for its being adopted by this court, in whose name I speak on the present occasion.
The other point is equally fatal. There is a clear distinction between causing a vessel to sail, or to be sent away, with intent to employ her in the slave-trade, and with intent that she should be employed in that trade. The former applies to an intent of the party causing the act, the latter to the employment of the vessel, whether by himself or a stranger. The evidence may fully support these counts, and yet may not constitute an offence within the act of congress; for the employment by a mere stranger would not justify the conviction of the party charged with causing her to sail, or to be sent away, with intent to employ her in the slave-trade, as owner. There is no reason, in criminal cases, why the court should help any such defective allegations. The words of the statute should be pursued.
It remains only to consider the point, whether these objections to the sufficiency of the indictment could be properly taken at this stage of the proceedings. Undoubtedly, according to the regular course of practice, objections to the form and sufficiency of an indictment ought to be discussed, p. 304upon a motion to quash the indictment, which may be granted or refused in the discretion of the court, or upon demurrer to the indictment, or upon a motion in arrest of judgment, which are matters of right. The defendant has no right to insist that such objections should be discussed or decided, *4'701 during the trial of the facts by the jury. It would *be very inconJ venient and embarrassing, to allow a discussion of such topics, during the progress of the cause before the jury, and introduce much confusion into the administration of public justice. But, we think, it is not wholly incompetent for the court to entertain such questions, during the trial, in the exercise of a sound discretion. It should, however, be rarely done, and only under circumstances of an extraordinary nature. The circuit court, in the present case, did allow the introduction and discussion of these questions, during the trial, and were divided upon the propriety of the practice. We can only certify, that the court possessed the authority, but that it ought not to be exercised except on very urgent occasions. A certificate will be sent to the circuit court of the district of Maryland, according to this opinion.
Certificate.—This cause came on, &c. : On consideration whereof, it is ordered and adjudged, that the following opinions be certified as the opinions of this court on points of division to the circuit court aforesaid.
1. That the testimony of Peter L. Coit, set forth in the record, was, under the circumstances of the case, admissible as competent evidence against the defendant, Gooding. 2. That the opinions prayed for by the counsel for the defendant, Gooding, in the first and sixth prayers, set forth in the record, were correct in law, and ought to have been given by the court. 3. That the opinions prayed for in all the other prayers of the defendant, were incorrect in law, and ought to have been refused. 4. That the objections taken to the form and sufficiency of the indictment by the defendant’s counsel, were not matters of right, which the defendant might insist upon, and discuss, and require to be decided, during the trial of the issue by the jury ; and that the same should, according to the regular course of practice, have been discussed on a motion to quash the indictment, or on demurrer, or on motion in arrest of judgment; but that the court had, nevertheless, *4801 *comPe^en^ authority, in the exercise of a sound discretion, to permit
J such objections to be discussed and decided, during the trial.
United States v. Marchant and Colson *
Criminal law.—Separate trials.
Where two or more persons are jointly charged, in the same indictment, with a capital offence, they have not a right by law, to be tried separately, without the consent of the prosecutor, but such separate trial is a matter to be allowed in the discretion of the court.
Certificate of Division from the Circuit Court of Massachusetts.1
March 12th, 1827. The opinion of the court in this case was delivered by Story, Justice.—The question, which comes before us upon a certificate of a division of opinion of the judges of the circuit court of Massachusetts, is this, whether two or more persons, jointly charged, in the same indictment, with a capital offence, have a right, by the laws of the country, to be tried severally, separately and apart, the counsel for the United States objecting thereto, or whether it is a matter to be allowed in the discretion of the court. We have considered the question, and are of opinion, that it is a matter of discretion in the court, and not of right in the parties. And it has become my duty briefly to expound some of the reasons which urge us to that conclusion.
The subject is not provided for by any act of congress ; and therefore, if the right can be maintained at all, it must be as a right derived from the common law, which the courts of the United States are bound to recognise and enforce. The crimes act of 1790, ch. 9, provides, in the 29th section, for the fight of peremptory challenge in capital cases ; and this right, to the extent of the statute, must, *in all cases, be allowed the prisoners, . * whether they are tried jointly or separately. Upon a joint trial, each L prisoner may challenge his full number, and every juror challenged as to one, is withdrawn from the panel as to all the prisoners on the trial, and thus, in effect, the prisoners in such a case possess the power of peremptory challenge to the aggregate of the numbers, to which they are respectively entitled. This is the rule clearly laid by Lord Coke, Lord Hale and Sergeant Hawkins, and, indeed, by all the elementary writers. Hawk. P. C. b. 2, ch. 41, § 9; 2 Hale H. P. C. 268 ; Co. Litt. 156 ; Beauchamp's Case, 9 Edw. IV. folio 27, pl. 40 ; Plowd. 100 ; Kelyng 9.
One consequence of this, in ancient times, was, that embarrassments often arose at trials at the assizes, on account of a defect of sufficient jurors. Ihe statute of Westminster IL, c. 38, ordained, “ that in one assize, no more shall be returned than twenty-four.” The common practice under this statute used to be, for the sheriff to return forty-eight jurors, although the precept named but twenty-four. It was, indeed, held, at an early period, that the statute of Westminster did not apply to criminal cases; but, notwithstanding this, the usual practice prevailed, unless the court directed a larger number to be returned. And it was not until the reign of George IL, that a larger number was required by law to be returned at the assizes. The
For the opinion of Judge Story, in the cir- Hom. 489 ; Commonwealth v. Manson, 2 Ash. cuit court, see 4 Mason 158. And see United 81; Commonwealth v. Skupinski, 9 Leg. Int. States v. Gibert, 2 Sumn. 20 ; United States v.
34. In New York, it is provided by statute,
Kelly, 4 W. C. C. 628 ; United States v. Wilson,
that in such cases, a separate trial shall be a
Said. 78 ; United States v. Collyer, Wharton
history of this branch of the subject is very clearly stated in 3 Bac. Abr. tit. Juries, B., 6, and in Kelyng 16. (a) It is obvious, that on joint panels, returned for joint trials, at the assizes, a defect of jurors might, from this limitation, often take place. And it became a question, in very early times, whether, under such circumstances, the court had power, against the will of the prisoners, to sever the panel, and to try them severally, if they insisted upon their right of several challenge. It was decided, upon full consideration, that the court had this power. To this effect are the cases in Plowd. 100, in Dyer 152 6, and in Kelyng 9 ; and the doctrine has received the sanction p. 307been any known right in the prisoner to control this election, it seems incredible, that so accurate and learned an author should not have stated it, when the occasion indispensably required him to take notice of a qualification so important to his text. His silence is, under such circumstances, very significant.
*
_ of Lord Hale, and other writers of the highest authority. *Whether, -• then, prisoners, who are jointly indicted, can, against their wishes, be tried separately, does not admit of a doubt.1 It remains to consider, whether they can insist upon a several trial. The sole ground upon which this claim can rest must be, if maintainable at all, that they have a right to select their jury out of the whole panel, and that as, upon a joint trial, one may desire to retain a juror who is challenged by another, and, if challenged by one, he must be withdrawn as to all, this right of selection is virtually impaired. But it does not appear to us, that this reasoning can, upon the principles of the common law, be supported. The right of peremptory challenge is not, of itself, a right to select, but a right to reject jurors. It excludes from the panel those whom the prisoner objects to, until he has exhausted his challenges, and leaves the residue to be drawn for his trial, according to the established order or usage of the court. The elementary writers nowhere assert a right of this nature in the prisoner, but uniformly put the allowance of peremptory challenges upon distinct grounds. Mr. Justice Blackstone, in his Commentaries (4 Bl. Com. 353), puts it upon the ground, that the party may not be tried by persons against whom he has conceived a prejudice, or who, if he has unsuccessfully challenged them for cause, may, on that account, conceive a prejudice against the prisoner. The right, therefore, of challenge, does not necessarily draw after it the right of selection, but merely of exclusion. It enables the prisoner to say who shall not try him; but not to say who shall be the particular jurors to try him. The law presumes, that every juror sworn in the case is indifferent and above legal exception ; for otherwise he may be challenged for cause. What jurors, in particular, shall try the cause, depends upon the order in which they are called ; and the result is a mere incident following the challenges, and not the absolute selection of the prisoner, resulting from his power of challenge. This view of the general principle of the common law is very much confirmed by other considerations. It is laid down by Hawkins (Pl. C. b. 2, ch. 41, § 8), that where several persons are arraigned on the same indictment, and severally plead not guilty, it is in the election of the prosecutdr
*
e^^er take out joint venires against them all, or several *against -* each of them. This plainly supposes that it is in the election of the prosecutor, whether there should be a joint or separate triads If there had (a) See also, 2 Hale H. P. C. 263.
But a still more direct conclusion against the right may be drawn from the admitted right of the crown to challenge in criminal cases, and the practice under that right. We do not say, that the same right belongs to any of the states in the Union ; for there may be a diversity in this respect as to the local jurisprudence or practice;’ the inquiry here is, not as to what is the state prerogative, but, simply, what is the common-law doctrine as to the point under consideration. Until the statute of 33 Edw. I., the crown might challenge peremptorily any juror, without assigning any cause ; but that statute took away that right, and narrowed the challenges of the crown to those for cause shown. But the practice, since this statute, has uniformly been, and it is clearly settled, not to compel the crown to show cause, at the time of objection taken, but to put aside the juror, until the whole panel is gone through. Hawkins, on this point, says (Pl. C. b. 2, ch. 43, §§ 2, 3), “if the king challenge a juror, before the panel is perused, it is agreed, that he need not show any cause of his challenge, till the whole panel be gone through, and it appears that there will not be a full jury, without the person so challenged. And if the defendant, in order to oblige the king to show cause, presently challenge, touts paravaUe; yet it had been adjudged, that the defendant shall be first put to show all his causes of challenge, before the king need to show any.” And the learned author is fully borne out by the authorities which he cites, and the same rule has been recognised down to the present times. Hale H. P. C. ch. 36, p. 271; 3 Bac. Abr. Jury, E, 10 ; jRea; v. Conigsmarke, 9 How. St. Tr. 1 ; Hex n. Stapleton, 3 Ibid. 502 ; Rex v. Borosky, 9Ibid. 1 ; Rexv. Gray,TiAA. 127, s. c. T. Raym. 473 ; Rex v. Grahme, 12 How. St. Tr. 646 ; Rex v. Cook, 13 Ibid. 311 ; Rex v. Home Tooke, 25 Ibid. 1, 24 ; 1 Chit. Cr. Law 533 ; Rex v. Campion, 1 How. St. Tr. 1050.
*This acknowledged right of peremptory challenge existing in the crown, before the statute of 33 Edw. I., and the uniform practice L which has prevailed, since that statute, to allow a qualified and conditional exercise of the same right, if other sufficient jurors remained for the trial, demonstrate, as we think, that no such power of selecting his jury belongs, or was ever supposed to belong, by the common law, to the prisoner ; and that, therefore, he could not demand, as matter of right, a separate trial to enable him to exercise it. In a separate or joint trial, he could, at any time, be defeated by the crown of such choice, by its own admitted prerogative.
The circumstances already alluded to, of the right of each prisoner, on a joint trial, to exercise his full right of peremptory challenge, and the small number of jurors usually returned on the panel at the assizes, accounts in a very satisfactory manner for the language used in some of the cases, as to the necessity of directing separate trials, where the prisoners refused to p. 308join in their challenges. The plain reason was, that otherwise there could bo no trial at all, for defect of jurors, at the same assizes ; and therefore, the court, in furtherance of public justice, were accustomed, without the consent of the prisoners, to direct a separate trial. In this way the reason of the practice is understood by Lord Hale (2 Hale P. C. ch. 34, p. 263), and by Hawkins (Hawk. P. C. b. 2, ch. 41, § 9), and by other more recent writers on common law. (a) In this manner, the language of Lord Holt in Charnock's Case (12 Howell’s State Trials 1454; s. c. 3 Salk. 81), is to be interpreted; for it is manifest, that he could not intend, that there could not be a joint trial, where the prisoners challenged separately, for no rule was better settled in his time than that they could. Indeed, in Rex v. Grahme (12 Howell’s State Trials, 646, 673), the same learned judge uses similar language in a sense which admits of no other interpretation; and this was the answer given to it, when cited in a later case for the like purpose.
1
United States v. Douglass, 2 Bl. C. C. 207; the panel is exhausted; Zell v. Commonwealth, Nelson, J. In Pennsylvania, the prosecution is 94 Penn. St. 258; even in cases of misdemean-not required to assign cause of challenge, until or. Haines v. Commonwealth, 12 W. N. C. 193, (a) 1 Chitty’s Crim. Law 535 See Starkie’s Crim. Pl. 35.
*That case is Rex v. Noble and others, in 1713, before Lord Chief
J Justice Parker, and reported in the State Trials (9 Harg. St. Tr. 1 ; s. c. 15 Howell’s St. Tr. 731). In that case, which was an indictment for murder, Noble moved the court for a separate trial, and the motion was denied. He was convicted, and when brought up for judgment, he moved in arrest of judgment this very matter, that there was a mis-trial, because (to use his own words) “ we were severed in our challenges, and yet were tried together by the same jury and he relied upon the language of Lord Holt in Charnock's Case, as in point. The court overruled the objection, and stated, that Lord Holt’s language referred solely to the public inconvenience, on account of a probable defect of jurors, and not to any matter of right in the prisoners. Sentence was accordingly passed upon the prisoner, and he was executed. There is a curious and learned commentary appended in a note to this trial, which was printed before the execution of Noble, in which an attempt was made to question the correctness of the decision. But it is therein admitted, that Noble’s counsel declined to argue the point, though requested ; from which we cannot but infer, that they thought the objection unfounded. The decision itself has never since been questioned or denied. We have, therefore, in the present case, not merely the absence of any authority in favor of the matter of right, but the course of practice, and the general reasoning deducible from the prerogative of the crown against it; and lastly, a direct authority, in times when the administration of criminal justice was unsuspected, on the very point.
Such is the substance of the reasons which induce us to decide against the claim as a matter of right. In our opinion, it is a matter of sound discretion, to be exercised by the court with all due regard and tenderness to prisoners, according to the known humanity of our criminal jurisprudence. A certificate is, accordingly, to be sent to the circuit court.
Certificate.—This cause came on, &c. : On consideration whereof, it *4361 *s ordered an^ adjudged by this court, *that it be certified to the said J circuit court, that where two or more persons are jointly charged, in the same indictment, with a capital offence, such persons have not a right, by the laws of the country, to be tried severally, separately and apart, the p. 309counsel for the United States objecting thereto ; but that such separate trial is a matter to be allowed in the discretion of the court before whom the indictment is tried. All which is ordered to be certified, &c.
1
Reported below, 1 Paine 409.