California v. San Pablo & Tulare Ratlroad Co., 149 U.S. 308 (1893)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
California v. San Pablo & Tulare Ratlroad Co., 149 U.S. 308 (1893)
Full caption
CALIFORNIA v. SAN PABLO AND TULARE RATLROAD COMPANY.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
May 10, 1893
CALIFORNIA v. SAN PABLO AND TULARE RATLROAD COMPANY.
ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOE THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA.
No. 257. Argued April 24, 1893. —Decided May 10,1893.
If, pending a writ of error to reverse a judgment for the defendant in an action by a State to recover sums of money for taxes, the defendant offers to the plaintiff, and deposits in a bank to its credit, the amount of those sums, with penalties, interest and costs, which by a statute of the State have the same effect as actual payment and receipt of the money, the writ of error must be dismissed.
This was an action, brought March 10, 1886, by the State of California against the San Pablo and Tulare Railroad Company, a corporation of California, in the Superior Court of the city and county of San Francisco, (and thence removed by the defendant into the Circuit Court of the United States, upon the ground that it was a suit arising under the Constitution and laws of the United States,) to recover taxes assessed by the State Board of Equalization, under sections 4 and 10 of article 13 of the constitution of California, (which are copied in the margin,1) as state and county taxes for the year July 1,
1 Sec. 4. A mortgage, deed of trust, contract or other obligation, by which a debt is secured shall, for the purposes of assessment and taxation, be deemed and treated as an interest in the property affected thereby. Except as to railroad and other quasi public corporations, in case of debts so secured, the value of the property affected by such mortgage, deed of trust, contract or obligation, less the value of such security, shall be assessed and taxed to the owner of the property; and the value of such security shall be assessed and taxed to the owner thereof in the county, city or district in which the property affected thereby is situate. The taxes so levied shall be a lien upon the property and security, and may be paid by either party to such security; if paid by the owner of the security, the tax so levied upon the property affected thereby shall become a part of the debt so secured; if the owner of the property shall pay the tax so levied on such security, it shall constitute a payment thereon, and to the extent of such payment a full discharge thereof: Provided, that if any such security or indebtedness shall
1885, to June 30,1886, upon the defendant’s franchise, roadway roadbed, rails and rolling stock in the counties of Alameda, Contra Costa and San Joaquin.
The defendant, in its answer, filed March 19, 1886, and averring the facts necessary to present the question, set up the following defence: “The provision of section 4 of article 13 of the constitution of the State of California, providing for the assessment of the property of railroad and other quasi public corporations, is in contravention of the provisions of the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution of the United States, in that it discriminates against such corporations; in this, that whereas under said section 4 of said article 13 of the constitution of the State of California, if the property of natural persons, or corporations not quasi public, has a mortgage, lien or incumbrance thereon, they are not liable to assessment or taxation upon such property, but only upon the value of their interest in such property over and above the value of such mortgage, lien or incumbrance; whereas, in the case of the property of railroad and other quasi public corporations, no such allowance or deduction is made, had or allowed with respect to any mortgage, lien or incumbrance there may be upon such property ; and also in this, that while section 10 of article 13 of the constitution of the State of California provides the same mode for the assessment of the franchise, roadway, roadbed, rails and rolling stock of all railroads operated in more than one county, whether such property be owned by
be paid by any such debtor or debtors, after assessment and before the tax levy, the amount of such levy may likewise be retained by such debtor or debtors, and shall be computed according to the tax levy for the preceding year.
Sec. 10. All property, except as hereinafter in this section provided, shall be assessed in the county, city, city and county, town, township or district in which it is situated, in the manner prescribed by law. The franchise, roadway, roadbed, rails and rolling stock of all railroads operated in more than one county in this State shall be assessed by the State Board of Equalization, at their actual value; and the same shall be apportioned to the counties, cities and counties, cities, towns, townships and districts in which such railroads are located, in proportion to the number of miles of railway laid in such counties, cities and counties, cities, towns, townships and districts.
railroad or other quasi public corporations or by private corporations or by natural persons, yet section 4 of article 13 of said constitution permits or allows indebtedness secured by mortgage, trust deed, or otherwise, to be deducted from the value of such property, only when it is owned by natural persons or corporations not quasi public, and denies such deduction when the property is owned by railroad or other quasi public corporations.”
On July 14, 1886, the attorneys for the parties filed in this and three similar cases the following stipulation in writing:
“ It is hereby stipulated that jury trials in the above entitled actions are hereby waived, and that said causes may be submitted to the court upon the testimony referred to in the stipulation this day made and filed in the case of The People of the State of California v. The Cent/ral Pacific Railroad Company, subject to the same terms and conditions. It is hereby further stipulated that special findings of facts in all of the above entitled actions are waived. It is hereby further stipulated and agreed that the said case of The People of the State of California v. The Central Pacific Railroad Company shall by the losing party be taken to the Supreme Court of the United States; and that the decision of said court in said case shall be applicable to and be treated by each party as the decision of said court in the above entitled actions; it being the intention and desire of the parties hereto to save the expense of separate writs of error; and that all the above entitled actions shall abide the final decision of said Supreme Court of the United States in the said case of The People of the State of California v. The Cent/ral Pacific Railroad Company, provided the said decision shall be made upon points involved therein; and if not so made, then the judgments in any of the above cases in which the point is not involved shall be set aside and findings of fact therein shall be made.”
On July 15, 1886, the Circuit Court gave judgment for the defendant in the present case.
In the case of Cal/ifornia v. Cent/ral Pacific Railroad, referred to in that stipulation, this court did not decide the question now presented, but on April 30, 1888, reversed the p. 311judgment of the Circuit Court on other grounds. 127 U. S. 1, 45.
On March 6, 1889, the parties, by another stipulation in writing, agreed that the previous judgment of the Circuit Court in the present case be set aside, and the case submitted to the Circuit Court upon an agreed statement of facts, “ on which findings shall be made and conclusions of law drawn by the court.”
On September 6, 1889, the Circuit Court, pursuant to this stipulation, ordered its former judgment to be set aside, and made and filed findings of fact in accordance with the agreed statement.
By these findings of facts, it appeared that, before and at the time of the assessment of these taxes, the defendant owed a debt secured by mortgage of its railroad, its franchise and its rolling stock and appurtenances, to the amount of more than $3000 a mile; that the State Board of Equalization valued and assessed the defendant’s franchise, roadway, roadbed, rails and rolling stock, not separately, but together, (and not including any other kind of property,) at their full value, without deducting the value of* the mortgage or any part thereof, although knowing of its existence, and did not deem or treat the mortgage as an interest in the property, and assessed the whole value of the property to the defendant as if there had been no mortgage thereon, but made the assessment upon the same basis for valuation as all other property in the State was valued for the purpose of taxation ; and that there were at that time divers railroads in the State, owned and operated by corporations other than railroad corporations, and by individuals and partnerships.
Upon the facts found, the Circuit Court concluded, as matter of law, that the defendant was entitled to judgment. Judgment was entered accordingly, and the State of California sued out this writ of error.
The Attorney General of the State admitted in his brief, und, when this case was called for argument, stated in open court, the following fact:
“ In the year 1893, the defendant offered and tendered to
Mr, William H. H. Hart, for the State of California.
the plaintiff a sum of money equal to the taxes, penalties, interest and attorney’s fee, to recover which this action was brought, and costs of suit, which offer and tender have not been accepted; but the money has been deposited by the defendant in bank, in accordance with the provisions of section 1500 of the Civil Code of California, which reads as follows: i An obligation for the payment of money is extinguished by a due offer of payment, if the amount is immediately deposited in the name of the creditor, with some bank of deposit within this State of good repute, and notice thereof is given to the creditor? ”
Mr. William, II. II. Hart, Attorney General for the State of California, after stating the fact of the offer and deposit of money as aforesaid, said:
I respectfully submit that this offer should not prevent the hearing of this cause and a decision of the constitutional question involved.
There are other cases depending upon the determination of this. It will be seen in the record, that there was a stipulation in this case, and three others, that the decision that might be made in this court in the case of The People of the State of California v. The Central Pacific Railroad Co., should be treated as a decision in all of the cases, provided the decision should be upon points involved therein, and if not so made, then the judgment of the Circuit Court in any of these cases should be set aside and findings of fact therein made. That case having been decided against the State because the assessment included steamboats and federal franchise, (see 127 U. S. 1,) and the question made in the present case under the Fourteenth Amendment not having been passed upon, counsel of the parties signed a stipulation to have the judgment set aside in this case, and to submit the same to the Circuit Court upon the facts stated in the stipulation, and it was accordingly thus submitted and decided by the Circuit Court, the design of the stipulation thus submitting the case being to obtain a decision which would also dispose of the remaining two cases embraced
• Opinion of the Court.
in the stipulation first made, that stipulation having been made to carry out the design of the first, that is, to obtain a decision that will dispose of all these cases.
Therefore, nothing short of a payment of what is claimed in those two cases, as well as in this, should be regarded as dispensing with a decision of the constitutional question raised in this case, and which is the same in the three cases.
It is of the utmost importance to the people of the State of California, that it be determined whether an assessment of the property of railroad corporations in the manner required by the constitution of California is valid, so it may be known, when these assessments are made, whether they can be included in the sources of revenue that can be relied upon in the administration of the government of that State, or whether such corporations are at liberty to decline to pay taxes, and to pay only what sums and when they may choose, merely as voluntary contributions to the public funds of California.
The court declined to hear further argument.
Mr. George A. Johnson, a former Attorney General of the State of California, and Mr. Samuel Shellabarger and Mr. Jeremiah M. Wilson also submitted briefs for the plaintiff in error.
Mr. George F. Edmunds, Mr. Harvey S. Brown and Mr. Greed Haymond submitted briefs on the merits for the defendant in error. •
«
Mr. Harvey S. Brown also submitted a brief on a motion to dismiss the writ of error.
Mr. Justioe Gray delivered the opinion of the court.
Upon the fact most properly and frankly admitted in open court by the Attorney General of the State of California, there can be no doubt that this writ of error must be dismissed, because the cause of action has ceased to exist. Any obligation of the defendant to pay to the State the sums sued for in this case, together with interest, penalties and costs, has been p. 314extinguished by the offer to pay all these sums, and the deposit of the money in a bank, which by a statute of the State have the same effect as actual payment and receipt of the money. And the State has obtained everything that it could recover in this case by a judgment of this court in its favor. The duty of this court, as of every judicial tribunal, is limited to determining rights of persons or of property, which are actually controverted in the particular case before it. When, in determining such rights, it becomes necessary to give an opinion upon a question of law, that opinion may have weight as a precedent for future decisions. But the court is not empowered to decide moot questions or abstract propositions, or to declare, for the government of future cases, principles or rules of law which cannot affect the result as to the thing in issue in the case before it. No stipulation of parties or counsel, whether in the case before the court or in any other case, can enlarge the power, or affect the duty, of the court in this regard.
The case at bar cannot be distinguished in principle from previous cases in which writs of error have been dismissed by this court under similar or analogous circumstances. Lord n. Veazie, 8 How. 251, 255 ; Cleveland v. Chamberlain, 1 Black, 419; Wood Paper Co. v. Heft, 8 Wall. 333 ; San Mateo County v. Southern Pacific Railroad, 116 U. S. 138 ; Little v. Bowers, 134 U. S. 547; Singer Manuf. Co. v. Wright, 141 U. S. 696. See also Elgin v. Marshall, 106 U. S. 578.
Writ of error dismissed.
DALZELL v, DUEBEB WATCH CASE MANUFACTURING COMPANY.
SAME v. SAME.
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK.
Nos. 213, 214. Argued April 18, 19, 1893. — Decided May 10,1893.
An oral agreement for the sale and assignment of the right to obtain a patent for an invention is not within the statute of frauds, nor within section 4898 of the Revised Statutes requiring assignments of patents to be in writing ; and may be specifically enforced in equity, upon sufficient proof thereof.
A manufacturing corporation, which has employed a skilled workman, for a stated compensation, to take charge of its works, and to devote his time and services to devising and making improvements in articles there manufactured, is not entitled to a conveyance of patents obtained for inventions made by him while so employed, in the absence of express agreement to that effect.
Specific performance will not be decreed in equity, without clear and satisfactory proof of the contract set forth in the bill.
Where, at the hearing in equity upon a plea and a general replication, the plea, as pleaded, is not supported by the testimony, it must be overruled, and the defendant ordered to answer the bill.
These were two bills in equity, heard together in the Circuit Court, and argued together in this court.
On March 31, 1886, Allen C. Dalzell, a citizen of the State of New York, and the Fahys Watch Case Company, a New York corporation, filed a bill in equity against the Dueber Watch Case Manufacturing Company, a corporation of Ohio, for the infringement of two patents for improvements in apparatus for making cores for watch cases, granted to Dalzell, October 27/1885, for the term of which he had, on January 21,1886, granted a license, exclusive for three years, to the Fahys Company.
To that bill the Dueber Company, on June 4, 1886, filed the following plea: “That prior to the grant of the said p. 316letters patent upon which the bill of complaint is based, and prior to the application therefor, and prior to any alleged invention by said Dalzell of any part, feature or combination described, shown or claimed in either of said letters patent, the said defendant, being then engaged in the manufacture of watch cases in the city of Newport in the State of Kentucky, and the said Dalzell having been in its employ as a tool-maker for a year preceding, it, said defendant, at the request of said Dalzell, reemployed said Dalzell at increased wages to aid in experimenting upon inventions upon machinery and tools to be used in the manufacture of various portions of watch cases; that said Dalzell did then and there agree with said defendant, in consideration of said increased salary as aforesaid to be paid to him, and which was paid to him by this defendant, to dedicate his best efforts, skill and inventive talent and genius towards the perfecting and improvement of watch-case machinery and such other devices as this defendant should direct and order, and in experimenting under the direction of this defendant for this purpose, and further agreed that any inventions or improvements made or contributed to by him, said Dalzell, should be patented at the expense of this defendant, and for its benefit exclusively, and that said Dalzell should execute proper deeds of assignment, at the expense of this defendant, to be lodged with the applications for all such patents in the United States Patent Office, and .said patents were to be granted and issued directly to this defendant; that, in pursuance of said agreement, said Dalzell entered upon said employment, and while thus employed at the factory of this defendant, and while using its tools and materials, and receiving such increased wages from it, as aforesaid, the said alleged inventions were made; that said patents were applied for, with the permission of this defendant, by the said Dalzell; and that all fees and expenses of every kind, necessary or useful for obtaining said patents, including as well Patent Office fees, as fees paid the solicitor employed to attend to the work incident to the procuring of said patents and drawing said assignments to this defendant, were paid by this defendant; and that, notwithstanding the foregoing, said Dalzell di p. 317not sign the said deeds, although he had promised so to do, but fraudulently and secretly procured the said patents to be granted to himself; of all of which this defendant avers the complainant the Fahys Watch Case Company had notice, at and prior to the alleged making of the license by said Dalzell to it, more particularly referred to in the bill of complaint; and defendant avers that by reason of the premises the title in equity to said patents is in this defendant.”
The plea, as required by Equity Rule 31 of this court, was upon a certificate of counsel that in his opinion it was well founded in point of law; and was supported by the affidavit of John C. Dueber, that he was the president of the Dueber Company, that the plea was not interposed for delay, and that it was true in point of fact.
After a general replication had been filed and some proofs taken in that case, including depositions of Dueber and of Dalzell, the Dueber Company, on January 17, 1887, filed a bill in equity against Dalzell and the Fahys Company, for the specific performance of an oral contract of Dalzell to assign to the Dueber Company the rights to obtain patents for his inventions, and for an injunction against Dalzell and the Fahys Company, and for further relief.
This bill contained the following allegations:
“That heretofore, to wit, prior to November 1, 1884, the said defendant Dalzell was in the employment of your orator, making and devising tools to be used in the construction of watch cases; that on or about said last-mentioned date, at the request of said Dalzell, his wages were raised, in consideration of a promise then made by said Dalzell to your orator that in the future his services would be of great value in the devising and perfecting of such tools; that, in pursuance of said promise and contract, the said Dalzell continued in the employ of your orator, and wholly at its expense, to devise and construct various tools to be used in your orator’s watch-case factory in the manufacture of various parts of watch cases; that said Dalzell was so employed for a great length of time, to wit, a whole year, a large part of which time he was assisted by various workmen employed and paid by your orator to assist p. 318him, the said Dalzell, in constructing such tools and in the experiments incident thereto.”
“ That subsequently thereto, and when said tools were completed, said Dalzell requested your orator to apply for letters patent for the various inventions embodied in all of said tools, for the use and benefit of your orator, representing to your orator that he, said Dalzell, had made valuable discoveries and inventions while engaged in designing and constructing said tools, and further representing that, if your orator did not secure the exclusive right to said inventions by letters patent, in all probability some of the workmen employed at your orator’s factory, who were familiar with the said inventions and the construction of said tools, might go to some other and rival watch-case company, and explain to it the construction of such tools, and make similar tools for such other company, in which case your orator would be without remedy.”
“ That said Dalzell then and there, and as a further inducement to your orator to have letters patent applied for for said inventions, voluntarily offered to your orator that, if your orator should permit him, Dalzell, to apply for letters patent, and your orator pay all the expenses incident to obtaining such letters patent, such letters patent might be taken for the benefit of your orator, and that he, Dalzell, would not ask or require any further or other consideration for said inventions and such letters patent as might be granted thereon, which proposition was then and there accepted by your orator, and it was then fully agreed between said parties that said Dalzell should immediately proceed, through a solicitor of his own selection, to procure said patents for and in the name of your orator, and that your orator should pay all bills that might be presented by said Dalzell or such solicitor as might be selected to attend to the business of procuring said patents.”
This bill further alleged that Dalzell did, in pursuance of that agreement, select a solicitor and apply for the two patents mentioned in the bill for an infringement, and three other patents; that, when some of the patents had “passed for issue,” the solicitor employed by Dalzell sent blank assign ments thereof to the Dueber Company with a request that
Counsel for Appellee.
Dalzell sign them, and thus transfer the legal title in the inventions to the Dueber Company, and enable the patents to be granted directly to it; that it exhibited these assignments to Dalzell, and requested him to sign them; that Dalzell replied that he would postpone signing them until all the patents had “passed for issue,” and would then sign all together, to all which the Dueber Company assented; that the Dueber Company paid all the fees and expenses necessary or useful in obtaining the patents; but that Dalzell fraudulently procured the patents to be granted to himself, and refused to assign them to the Dueber Company, and, as that company was informed and believed, conveyed, with the intention of defrauding it, certain interests in and licenses under the patents to the Fahys Company, with knowledge of the facts; and that Dalzell and the Fahys Company confederated and conspired to cheat and defraud the Dueber Company out of the patents, and, in pursuance of their conspiracy, filed their bill aforesaid against the Dueber Company.
Annexed to this bill was an affidavit of Dueber that he had read it and knew the contents thereof, and that the same was true of his own knowledge, except as to the matters therein stated on information and belief, and that as to those matters he believed it to be true.
To this bill answers were filed by Dalzell and the Fahys Company, denying the material allegations; and a general replication was filed to these answers.
By stipulation of the parties, the evidence taken in each case was used in both. After a hearing on pleadings and proofs, the Circuit Court dismissed the bill of Dalzell and the Fahys Company ; and entered a decree against them, as prayed for, upon the bill of the Dueber Company. 38 Fed. Rep. 597. Dalzell and the Fahys Company appealed from each decree.
J. E. Bowman and Mr. Edmund Wetmore for appellants.
James Moore for appellee.
Mr. Justice Gray, after stating the substance of the pleadings and decrees, delivered the opinion of the court.
The more important of these cases, and the first to be considered, is the bill in equity of the Dueber Watch Case Manufacturing Company to compel specific performance by Dalzell of an oral agreement, alleged to have been made by him while in its employment, to assign to it the right to obtain patents for his inventions in tools for making parts of watch cases.
An oral agreement for the sale and assignment of the right to obtain a patent for an invention is not within the statute of frauds, nor within section 4898 of the Revised Statutes requiring assignments of patents to be in writing; and may be specifically enforced in equity, upon sufficient proof thereof. Somerby v. Buntin, 118 Mass. 279; Gould v. Banks, 8 Wend. 562; Burr v. De la Vergne, 102 N. Y. 415; Blakeney v. Goode, 30 Ohio St. 350.
But a manufacturing corporation, which has employed a skilled workman, for a stated compensation, to take charge of its works, and to devote his time and services to devising and making improvements in articles there manufactured, is not entitled to a conveyance of patents obtained for inventions made by him while so employed, in the absence of express agreement to that effect. Ilapgood v. Hewitt, 119 U. S. 226.
Upon the question whether such a contract was ever made by Dalzell, as is alleged in the bill of the Dueber Company, the testimony of Dalzell and of Dueber, the president and principal stockholder of the Dueber Company, is in irreconcilable conflict.
Dalzell was a skilled workman in the manufacture of various parts of watch cases, and was employed by the Dueber Company, first for eight months as electroplater and gilder, and then for a year in its tool factory, at wages of twenty-five dollars a week, from February, 1883, until November, 1884, and thenceforth at wages of thirty dollars a week, until January 19, 1886, when he left their employment, and immediately entered the employment of the Fahys Company, and executed to that company a license to use his patents.
The matters principally relied on by the Dueber Company, as proving the contract sought to be enforced, are a conversation between Dalzell and Dueber at the. time of raising his wages in November, 1884 ; another conversation between them, in the spring of 1885 ; and oral promises said to have been made by Dalzell in the summer of 1885, to assign to the Dueber Company his rights to obtain patents. It will be convenient to consider these matters successively.
The bill alleges that Dalzell’s wages were raised in Novemher, 1884, at his request, “ and in consideration of a promise then made by said Dalzell to ” the Dueber Company “ that in the future his services would be of great value in the devising and perfecting of such tools,” and that, “ in pursuance of said promise and contract,” Dalzell continued in the company’s employ, at its expense, and with the assistance of its workmen, to devise and construct such tools.
Dueber’s whole testimony on this point appears in the following question and answer: “ Qu. Please state the circumstances which induced your company to increase Mr. Dalzell’s wages at the time they were increased. Ans. Mr. Dalzell came to me in the office, and he says, i Mr. Dueber, a year is now up since I worked for you in this factory. I suppose you are satisfied with the improvements I have made, and I have come to have my wages raised, and I will show you that, if you raise my wages, the improvements I will make this year will justify you in doing so.’ I asked him what wages he wanted; he said ‘ thirty dollars per week,’ and he was paid that until the time he left. When that year was up, nothing was said about wages.”
This testimony tends to show no more than that Dalzell expressed a confident belief that, if his wages should be raised, the improvements which he would make during the coming year would justify the increase. It has no tendency to prove any such promise or contract as alleged in the bill, or any other promise or contract on Dalzell’s part. So far, therefore, no contract is proved, even if full credit is given to Dueber’s testi mony.
As to what took place in the spring of 1885, the bill alleges
VOL. CXLIX—21
that, subsequently to the aforesaid interview, “ and when said tools were completed,” Dalzell requested the company to apply, for its own use and benefit, for patents for inventions which he represented that he had made “ while engaged in designing and constructing said tools,” and which, he suggested, might, if not secured by letters patent, be made known and explained by some of the workmen then employed there to rival companies; and, as a further inducement to the company to have such patents applied for, voluntarily offered, if the company would permit him to do so, and would pay all expenses of obtaining patents, to apply therefor, for the benefit of the company, and “ not ask or require any further or other consideration for said inventions and such letters patent as might be granted thereon; ” and that this proposition was “ then and there accepted by ” the company, and “ it was then fully agreed between said parties ” that Dalzell should immediately proceed, through a solicitor of his own selection, to procure the patents in the name of the company, and the company should pay the necessary expenses.
Upon this point, Dueber’s testimony was as follows : “Qu. Who first suggested the idea of patenting these devices, and when? Ans. Mr. Dalzell, in the spring of 1885. Qu. Please state all that took place at that time. Ans. Mr. Dalzell came to me and said, ‘ Mr. Dueber, we have got a very good thing here; let us patent this for the benefit of the concern; we have some men here, who may run away and carry those ideas with them.’ I objected at first; finally he says, ‘ If you will pay for getting them out, I don’t want anything for them.’ I then said, ‘ Let us go over to Mr. Layman to-morrow, and attend to it? He said he knew a more competent lawyer than that, that he would send for.” Dueber also testified that, when Dalzell first suggested taking out letters patent, Dueber told him that he did not think the improvements of sufficient value to justify taking out patents and paying for them; and that “about all” that Dalzell replied was, “We have a good many men here who may carry off these ideas into other shops, and I want to retain them for this concern.”
All this testimony of Dueber was given in September, 1886,
before the filing of the bill for specific performance. Being recalled, after this bill had been filed, he testified, on cross-examination, that he now considered the' inventions covered by the patents sued on as valuable, because the company had spent a great deal of money on them; and he declined or evaded giving any other reason.
Bearing in mind that there was no proof whatever of any previous agreement between the parties on the subject, the contract as alleged in the bill and testified to by Dueber, by which Dalzell is said to have voluntarily offered, with no other motive than to prevent workmen from injuring the Dueber Company by communicating the inventions to rival companies, and for no other consideration than the payment by the Dueber Company of the expenses of obtaining patents, and without himself receiving any consideration, benefit or reward, and without the company’s even binding itself, for any fixed time, to pay him the increased wages, or to keep him in its service, is of itself highly improbable; and it may well be doubted whether, if such a contract were satisfactorily proved to have been made, a court of equity would not consider it too unconscionable a one between employer and employed, to be specifically enforced in favor of the former against the latter. Cathcart v. Robinson, 5 Pet. 264, 276; Mississippi eft Missouri Railroad v. Cromwell, 91 U. S. 643; Pope Manuf. Co. v. Gormully, 144 U. S. 224.
Moreover, Dueber throughout manifests extreme readiness to testify in favor of the theory which he is called to support, and much unwillingness to disclose or to remember any inconsistent or qualifying circumstances. The record shows that he has at different times made oath to four different versions of the contract:
1st. On March 16, 1886, when the Dueber Company filed a petition in the superior court of Cincinnati against Dalzell to compel him to assign his patents to it, Dueber made oath to the truth of the statements in that petition, one of which was that, at the time of the making of application for said patents, it was agreed, for a valuable consideration before that tlme Paid, that said patents and inventions were the property p. 324of this plaintiff, and should be transferred to it immediately upon the issue thereof, and prior to the grant of the patents.”
2d. On June 4, 1886, he made oath that the plea was true in point of fact, which stated that the whole contract, both for an increase of Dalzell’s wages and for his assignment to the Dueber Company of his rights to patents for his inventions, was made “prior to any alleged invention by said Dalzell,” and in consideration of an increase of wages to be thereafter paid.
3d. In September, 1886, he testified that the increase of wages was made upon the mere statement of Dalzell that he would show that the improvements he would make during the coming year would justify the increase; and that the subsequent contract to assign the patent rights was after the inventions had been made.
4th. On January 17, 1887, he made oath to the truth, of his own knowledge, of this bill, which alleged that Dalzell’s wages were raised “ in consideration of a promise ” by Dalzell “ that in the future his services would be of great value in the devising and perfecting of such tools,” and also alleged that the agreement to assign the patent rights was made after the inventions.
Dalzell, being called as a witness in his own behalf, directly contradicted Dueber in every material particular; and testified that the real transaction was that, after his inventions had been made, and shown to Dueber, the latter was so pleased with them that he, of his own accord, raised Dalzell s wages, and offered to furnish the money to enable him to take out patents. There is much evidence in the record, which tends to contradict Dalzell in matters aside from the interviews between him and Dueber, and to impeach Dalzell’s credibility as a witness. But impeaching Dalzell does not prove that Dueber’s testimony can be relied on.
What took place, or is said to have taken place, after these interviews may be more briefly treated.
Whitney, the solicitor employed at Dalzell’s suggestion, applied for and obtained the patents in Dalzell’s name, an was paid his fees and the expenses of applying for the patents p. 325by the Dueber Company with Dalzell’s knowledge. In the summer of 1885, before the patents were issued, he sent blank assignments thereof to the Dueber Company to be signed by Dalzell, which Moore, the general manager of the company, as well as Dueber, in the absence of each other, asked Dalzell to sign.
Upon what Dalzell then said, as upon nearly every material point in the case, the testimony is conflicting. Dueber and Moore testified, in accordance with the allegations in the bill, that Dalzell replied that he would not sign any of them until all the patents had “ passed for issue,” and would then sign all together. But the manner in which they testified to this does not carry much weight.. And Dalzell testified that he positively refused to assign the patents until some arrangement for compensating him had been agreed upon.
Parts of a correspondence of Whitney with Dueber, and with Dalzell, during the summer of 1885, were put in evidence, which indicate that Whitney, while advising Dalzell as to his interests, sought to ingratiate himself with the Dueber Company. But they contain nothing to show any admission by Dalzell that he had agreed, or intended, to assign the patent rights to the Dueber Company, without first obtaining some arrangement whereby he might be compensated for his inventions.
The Circuit Court, in its opinion, after alluding to various matters tending to throw discredit on the testimony of each of the principal witnesses, said, “The case is one on which different minds may well reach a contrary opinion of the merits.” 38 Fed. Rep. 599. We concur in that view; and it affords of itself a strong reason why the specific performance prayed for should not be decreed.
From the time of Lord Hardwicke, it has been the established rule that a court of chancery will not decree specific performance, unless the agreement is “ certain, fair and just in aU its parts.” Buxton v. Lister, 3 Atk. 383, 385; Underwoo I
Hitchcox, 1 Ves. Sen. 279; Franks v. Martin, 1 Eden, 309.
323. And the rule has been repeatedly affirmed and acted on by this court. In Colson v. Thompson, Mr. Justice p. 326Washington, speaking for the court, said: “ The contract which is sought to be specifically executed ought not only to be proved, but the terms of it should be so precise as that neither party could reasonably misunderstand them. If the contract be vague or uncertain, or the evidence to establish it be insufficient, a court of equity will not exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction to enforce it, but will leave the party to bis legal remedy.” 2 Wheat. 336, 341. So this court has said that chancery will not decree specific performance, “ if it be doubtful whether an agreement has been concluded, or is a mere negotiation,” nor “ unless the proof is clear and satisfactory, both as to the existence of the agreement and as to its terms.” Carr v. Duval, 14 Pet. 79, 83; Nickerson v. Nickerson, 127 U. S. 668, 676; Hennessy v. Woolworth, 128 IT. S. 438, 442.
For these reasons, we are of opinion that the contract set forth in the bill for specific performance has not been so clearly and satisfactorily proved as to justify a decree for specific performance of that contract; and that the decree for the plaintiff on the bill of the Dueber Company must, therefore, be reversed, and the bill dismissed.
The decree sustaining the plea to the bill against the Dueber Company for an infringement, and ordering that bill to be dismissed, is yet more clearly erroneous; for none of the evidence introduced by either party tended to prove such a contract as was set up in that plea. The only issue upon the plea and replication was as to the sufficiency of the testimony to support the plea as pleaded; and as the plea was not supported by the testimony, it should be overruled, and the defendant ordered to answer the bill. Stead v. Course, 4 Cranch, 403, 413; Fa/rley v. Kittson, 120 U. S. 303, 315, 318; Equity Rule 34.
It is proper to add that the question whether the Dueber Company, by virtue of the relations and transactions between it and Dalzell, had the right, as by an implied license, to use Dalzell’s patents in its establishment, is not presented by either of these records, but may be raised in the further proceedings upon the bill against the Dueber Company for an infringement.
Syllabus.
Decrees reversed, and cases rema/nded to the Circuit Court, with directions to dismiss the hillfor specific performance, and to overrule the plea to the other hill, and order the defendant to answer it.
Me. Justice Brewer dissented.
WADE v. CHICAGO, SPRINGFIELD AND ST. LOUIS
RAILROAD COMPANY.
AMERICAN LOAN AND TRUST COMPANY v. WADE.
APPEALS FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR
THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS.
Nos. 247,248. Submitted April 21, 1893. — Decided May 10,1893.
The “ after-acquired property ” clause in a railroad mortgage covers not only legal acquisitions, but also all equitable rights and interests subsequently acquired either by or for the railroad company, the mortgagor.
Where negotiable paper has been put in circulation, and there is no infirmity or defence between the antecedent parties thereto, a purchaser of such securities is entitled to recover thereon, as against the maker, the whole amount, irrespective of what he may have paid therefor.
A railroad company contracted with a construction company to build and complete its railroad on a line designated on a map of the same, and to furnish and equip it, agreeing to pay for the same in stock and mortgage bonds, to be issued from time to time as sections should be completed. A mortgage was made of the road and property then existing and afterwards to be acquired. The construction company began work and completed a small section, for which it received the stipulated pay in stock and bonds. It parted with the latter for a good consideration, and they eventually came by purchase into the possession of W. No further section was completed, but work was done at various points on the line, and the construction company acquired for the railroad company rights of way through nearly or quite the entire route. Subsequently another railroad company acquired these properties through the construction company, and completed the road. Held, that W., being a bona fide holder of the bonds secured by the first mortgage, who had purchased the bonds in good faith, had through the mortgage a prior lien on the whole line
for the full amount of the face of his bonds, which was not affected by the fact that the new company acquired its rights and property, not directly from the first company, but through intervening conveyances.
The case is stated in the opinion.
Mr. Frederick N. Judson, Mr. Charles 8. Taussig and Mr. Samuel P. Wheeler for Wade and Hopkins, Trustees, appellants in Ho. 247 and appellees in No. 248.
Mr. Adrian H. Joline for Pratt, Trustee, the Mercantile Trust Company and the Central Trust Company, appellees in No. 247; and for Pratt,Trustee, appellant in No. 248.
Me. Justice Jackson delivered the opinion of the court.
The appellants, Belle N. B. Wade and Warner M. Hopkins, testamentary trustees of the estate of Robert B. Wade, as holders of fifty first-mortgage bonds of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, on January 27,1887, filed their bill in the United States Circuit Court for the Southern District of Illinois, for the purpose of enforcing a mortgage lien upon the property and railway of said company, extending from Springfield, Illinois, to East St. Louis, Illinois. The material facts of the case, as set out in the bill and as disclosed by the record, are as follows:
The Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company was incorporated January 17, 1883, under the general laws of Illinois, to build and operate a proposed line of railroad from Springfield to East St. Louis in that State. After surveying the route and designating the same on a map filed in the office of the company, and after securing certain rights of way on the line of the road, on March 3, 1883, it entered into a contract with the Empire Construction Company, of which one Wing was president and sole stockholder, to build, finish, and equip the proposed railway of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company within a stipulated time. The contract provided as follows:
“ These articles of agreement made and entered into this p. 329third day of March a. d. 1883, by and between the Empire Construction Company, a corporation of the State of Illinois, party of the first part, and the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, a railroad corporation of the same State, party of the second part, witnesseth j-
“ That for and in consideration of the covenants and payments hereinafter recited to be made by said party of the second part, said party of the first part, hereby for itself, its successors and assigns, covenants and agrees to furnish all the material and labor necessary to construct, iron, bridge, and complete the railroad of said party of the second part, as now surveyed and designated on a map filed in the office of the party of the second part, which railroad commences at a point on the Gilman and Clinton branch of the Illinois Central Railroad at the city of Springfield, and extends by way of Litchfield and Mount Olive to the bridge junction at East St. Louis, Illinois, a distance of about ninety-eight (98) miles, passing through the towns of Pawnee, Litchfield, Mount Olive, Alhambra, Marine, Troy, and Collinsville, with four and one-half (4|) miles of side track, (necessary to the places marked on said map for the business of the line at the time of the opening,) and to furnish the said railroad with depots, water tanks, and turn-tables, and to equip the same with engines and cars as hereinafter provided.
“ The road and side tracks hereby agreed to be constructed are those on said map marked and specified only, and said map is hereby referred to for further particulars in this behalf; and the said road and side tracks are to be built in manner and according to the specifications and conditions following; and the bridges, depots, water tanks, turn-tables, engines, and cars are to be those only also hereinafter mentioned in the specifications.”
Certain specifications were made a part of the contract, but they need not be recited.
In consideration of the premises and of the undertakings of the construction company thus set forth, the railroad company agreed to pay therefor, in its negotiable bonds to be issued thereafter, the amount of $2,500,000, and $990,000 of its p. 330capital stock fully paid and non-assessable. The bonds were to be secured by a trust deed or mortgage in proper form and duly executed by the company upom all its property, real or personal, owned by it or afterwards acquired, including its franchises of every kind. The construction company, its successors or assigns, were to receive from the trustee twenty-five bonds to the amount of $25,000, and eighty shares of capital stock of the value of $8000, as each mile of the road was constructed and completed, and on the chief engineer’s certificate obtained therefor.
The contract further provided that the construction company, its successors or assigns, for the purpose of construction, should have the right to the full and free possession, use, and control of' said railway, equipment, and property of the railroad company, as constructed, made or furnished under the agreement, or otherwise obtained, together with the right to use and operate said railway in the name of the railroad company under its franchises necessary thereto, for the transportation of persons and property, until the final and ultimate completion and acceptance of said railroad, without charge therefor by the railroad company, and also at its own cost keep said railroad in good repair and condition, ordinary wear and tear excepted.
The contract further provided that if at any time a change of the route of the said road was necessary to be made, it was agreed that the same might be done on certificate of the chief engineer and approval of the president of the construction company, and thereupon all of the terms and conditions ot the contract as to said modified route were to be the same as agreed in respect to the route then specified on the map.
In pursuance of this contract, and under proper authority of law, by vote of the stockholders of the railroad company, its board of directors was authorized to issue bonds of the company in the sum of $2,500,000, to pay for the building of the road, and to execute to the Central Trust Company of New York a mortgage upon all the properties and franchises, which were particularly described in the mortgage, as follows:
“All and singular the several pieces or parcels of land p. 331forming the track or roadway of said railroad company from a point on the Gilman and Clinton branch of the Illinois Central railway at the city of Springfield and extending by way of Litchfield and Mt. Olive to the bridge junction at East St. Louis, Illinois, a distance of about-ninety-eight miles, passing through the towns of Crow’s Mills, Pawnee, White Oak, Litchfield, Mt. Olive, Alhambra, Nervine, Troy, and Collinsville, and being in or through the counties of Sangamon, Montgomery, Macoupin, Madison, and St. Clair, whether the same is now-acquired and owned by said railroad company or may be hereafter acquired and owned by said company; also the railroad of said party of the first part and any and all its branches thereof, and any and all switches and turnouts thereof, together with all the rails, bridges, depots, stations, station-houses, section-houses, fences, and other structures and appurtenances thereto belonging now owned by said railroad company, or that may hereafter be constructed, completed, finished, acquired, or owned by said company; also, all the tolls, income, issues, and profits and alienable franchises of said party of the first part, connected with its railroad or relating thereto, including its rights and franchises as a corporation; and also, all and singular the property of every kind hereinafter mentioned, whether now owned or that may hereafter be acquired and owned by said railroad company, that is to say, all the rolling stock of every description, all the machine shops, car shops, and blacksmith shops, all the machinery, stationary engines, and all articles used in the construction, replacing, and repairing thereof, together with all the tools and materials, and any and all other property now owned or hereafter to be acquired by said party of the first part.”
This mortgage was duly executed and properly recorded near that date in the several counties through which the railroad was located and was to be constructed. The bonds secured thereby were 2500 in number, of the denomination of $1000 each, redeemable in gold May 1, 1913, with interest-bearing coupons attached, payable semiannually at the American Exchange National Bank, New York. These bonds p. 332were delivered to the trustee, to be by it delivered to the construction company in amounts of $25,000, on the certificate of the engineer of the railroad company as each mile of the road was completed, under and in accordance with the terms of the contract of the construction company with the railroad company. And in addition to the bonds to be thus delivered eighty shares of non-assessable stock of the railroad company, at the par value of $8000, were to be delivered to the construction company upon the same conditions.
The construction company under, and in pursuance of, this contract commenced the construction of the railroad, and in July, or early in August, 1883, had completed two miles of the road, and thereafter, in October, 1883, received from the Central Trust Company, upon certificate of ~the chief engineer of that fact, fifty of the mortgage bonds.
These bonds, so received by the construction company, were deposited on November 5, 1883, by Wing, the representative of said company, with a trustee as collateral security to secure the payment of the sum of $35,000, evidenced by the note of said Wing, and endorsed by Robert B. Wade for the accommodation of Wing and the said construction company. By the terms of the pledge of these bonds the trustee was authorized, upon the failure of Wing or the construction company, to pay said note at maturity, to sell said bonds, which sale it was agreed might be made without notice to Wing or to the construction company, and by express terms Wade was to have the same power or privilege of purchasing at said sale as any other person. Demand was made upon Wing at the maturity of the note to pay the same, which he failed to do, and thereupon the trustee holding the collateral, on due notice of time, place, and terms of sale, sold the bonds. They were purchased by the testamentary trustees of Wade, he having died in the meantime, for the sum of $20,000, which amount was credited upon a judgment on the note, previously confessed by Wing, and the balance of the indebtedness was subsequently collected by process of law. Under this purchase the appellants became the holders of the bonds.
These bonds, amounting to $50,000, were all that were ever
actually issued under the above-described mortgage of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, for while the construction company graded considerable portions of the road, and acquired for the railroad company rights of way throughout a large part, if not the entire route, it failed to complete any other mile or miles of the road so as to become entitled to additional bonds.
In April, 1885, the railroad company becoming satisfied that the construction company was unable to execute its contract, or would fail to perform the same, the stockholders authorized its board of directors to “ make such arrangements with said company or other parties as will secure the construction of this road and preserve the rights of all parties interested, and that they be authorized to modify or change said contract or make a new contract with the Empire Construction Company if they think necessary to secure the building of this road, maintaining the legal rights of all parties concerned, and upon the surrender of all outstanding bonds said directors may satisfy the present mortgage, and issue new bonds and secure same by mortgage on the property and franchises of this road.”
Acting under this authority the railroad company on April 29, 1885, entered into a new contract with the construction company, which need not, however, be specially noticed, as it was vacated and cancelled on May 23, 1885, in compliance with the request of said construction company.
Wing, who was the chief promoter of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, and the sole stockholder and owner of the Empire Construction Company, after suspending operations under the contract of the latter with the railroad company, organized and caused to be incorporated on May 19, 1885, the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company. This company was incorporated to construct a railroad from Litchfield to Springfield in Illinois on the line of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, .and on May 26, 1885, a few days after the organization of the new company and after the construction company had been released from its contract with the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad p. 334Company, the said construction company by Wing, as its president, conveyed and transferred to H. H. Cooley & Company, a firm composed of a brother and a brother-in-law of Wing, for the consideration of $142,015.11 the following-described property: All right of way acquired by the Empire Construction Company for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company between Litchfield, Illinois, and Springfield, Illinois, estimated, as per voucher, to be of the value of $4785.40; all cross-ties between Litchfield and Springfield, Illinois, on the side (site) of survey made for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, estimated, per voucher, to be of the value of $2546; all embankments, excavations, trestle-work, tiling, and all other work done in the building and construction of a railroad on the line of survey between Litchfield and Springfield, Illinois, done and constructed by the Empire Construction Company, estimated, per voucher, to be of the value of $72,134.22; all contracts for right of way guaranteed the Empire Construction Company for the Chicago-Springfield Railroad Company, estimated, per voucher, at the sum of $19,000; all right of way contracted for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company by the Empire Construction Company, estimated, per voucher, at the sum of $12,000 ; all right of way in Litchfield acquired by the Empire Construction Company for the right of way for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, estimated to be of the value of $10,000; all engineering services and engineering in tile construction, location, surveys, estimates, and superintendence of construction in the work done between Litchfield and Springfield, Illinois, estimated, as per voucher, at $4672.93 ; all estimates, rights, and advantages accrued to the Empire Construction Company by reason of any contract heretofore existing, and all rights in the Empire Construction Company resulting from work done, material furnished, money expended, and included in the term “ miscellaneous,” as per vouchers, $16,876.56; all surveys, contracts, profiles, books, and all property belonging to the Empire Construction Company, except that of like nature as above enumerated, on the line of the Chicago, Springfield and St. p. 335Louis Railroad Company south of the line of the Indianapolis and St. Louis Railroad Company.
This conveyance was duly recorded in Montgomery County, Illinois, May 27, 1885. On the same day the above conveyance was executed, H. H. Cooley & Company, "by deed, duly recorded in Montgomery County, Illinois, transferred the same property to the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company in consideration of one dollar, and of a contract entered into that day by H. H. Cooley & Company with the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company to build a line of railroad north from Litchfield to Springfield, a distance of about forty-five miles. This road was completed in 1886 on the same line substantially as that surveyed for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, and described in the conveyance of the Empire Construction Company to H. H. Cooley & Company. The St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company, on July 1, 1885, executed a mortgage to the Mercantile Trust Company of New York to secure an issue of its bonds to the amount of $500,000, which bonds were put in circulation and are outstanding. The mortgage securing the bonds was duly recorded in each of the counties through which the said railroad extended.
It further appears from the record, and the findings of fact in the decree of the court below, that, on June 12, 1886, the Empire Construction Company conveyed to the said firm of H- H. Cooley & Company, for the express consideration of $5000, all the real estate and personal property, rights, and easements acquired by said construction company for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company south of the Indianapolis and St. Louis Railway, and between Litchfield and Alhambra, Illinois, over the line surveyed, and on the rights of way acquired, for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, together with all embankments, excavations, trestle-work, and all other work done in the build-and construction of a railroad on the line of said Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company south of Litchrid; and on the same date, June 12, 1886, the firm of Cooley ompany, for the express consideration of $75,000, conveyed p. 336the same property and rights to the Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Company, which the said Wing and associates also organized and incorporated, under the laws of Illinois, for the purpose of completing the road of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company between Litchfield and East St. Louis. This line was constructed between Litchfield and Mount Olive, a distance of about ten miles, but the new corporation appropriated the rights acquired for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company between Litchfield and Alhambra. The Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Company executed a mortgage to the Central Trust Company of New York for the purpose of securing $200,000 of bonds. It is claimed by the complainants that this mortgage was cancelled and discharged, but that does not distinctly appear from the record, and is not deemed material in the view we take of the case.
The Central Trust Company, as trustee of the mortgage of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, executed in 1883, and also as trustee of the mortgage of the Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Company, executed in 1886, when applied to by the complainants, declined to institute foreclosure proceedings upon the first mortgage, and thereupon the complainants filed their bill making the three above-described railroad companies and the trustees of the mortgages executed by them, respectively, defendants to the bill. The complainants claim that, under the foregoing facts, the fifty bonds held by them are a lien upon the entire line originally surveyed, and partially constructed, for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, by whom said bonds were issued, and that said company had made default in the payment of the same, and the interest coupons thereto attached, which matured May 1, 1884, and all interest coupons maturing since that date.
The bill'was answered by the three railroad companies, viz., the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company, and the Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Company. Each of the companies admitted in its separate answer the execution of the various p. 337mortgages ; that complainants were the holders of the fifty mortgage bonds issued by the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company ; that said company had made default in the payment of the bonds and coupons as stated in the bill; and that said railroad company was insolvent; but they each denied that any of the insolvent company’s property was in the possession of the other defendants.
The Central Trust Company, in its answer, admitted that the complainants had applied to it to file a bill to foreclose the mortgage made by the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, and that it had refused to do so, and declared its purpose of resigning its trusteeship under both of the mortgages aforesaid; that before the actual commencement of this suit it resigned its trusteeship under each of these mortgages, and that the reasons for so doing were that it was advised by counsel that, owing to its trust relation to holders of bonds-secured by each mortgage, it ought not to take part on behalf of one or the other in any controversy between such bondholders; and that the rights of the complainants could be fully protected in any suit or suits brought by said complainants in their own names.
The answer of the Mercantile Trust Company admitted the execution of the mortgage to it of the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company, but denied that it accepted the trust therein with notice and subject to the prior rights of the complainants as holders of the fifty bonds of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company; and as to other allegations of the bill it answered that it had no knowledge or information.
Proofs were taken upon the issues thus made, and the court below, on August 5,1889, rendered its decision in the premises, dismissing the bill as to the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company, and its trustee, the Mercantile Trust Company, and ordered and adjudged that the defendant, the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, or some one in its behalf, pay to the complainants, within ninety days, the sum of $22,976.59, being the said sum of $20,000 for which said bonds were bid off by complainants, and six per cent interest thereon
VOL. CXLIX—22
until paid, with costs of the suit to be taxed; and that in default of said payment all the right, title, interest, and equity of redemption of said Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, and of the Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Company, and the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company, in and to that portion of the property described in said mortgage, and lying south of the Indianapolis and St. Louis railroad, originally surveyed and laid out for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, (which is specially described,) be sold by a special master without any equity of redemption, and that out of the proceeds of said sales, after the payment of costs and expenses attending the execution of the decree, the complainants be paid the amount decreed, with interest thereon at the rate of six per cent from the date of the decree.
After this decree was passed, the American Loan and Trust Company made application to intervene in the case as a trustee under a mortgage made April 1, 1887, by the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company to secure bonds to the amount of $1,100,000, which the intervenor claimed was a lien on that portion of the railroad line and property south of Litchfield, on which the decision of the court below had awarded a lien to the complainants. This application of the American Loan and Trust Company was allowed, and by order of the court it was “ made a defendant to this cause, with all rights of exceptions, appeal and the prosecution of writs of error, the said American Loan and Trust Company hereby entering its appearance and adopting and accepting the answer of the defendant, the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, as its answer herein, and agreeing that the replication to said answer heretofore filed shall stand as the replication to said answer as adopted by said American Loan and Trust Company, and it being further provided that this order shall not make it necessary to retake any of the evidence in this cause or to set aside any interlocutory proceedings or orders heretofore had or entered therein.”
It appears from the proof that pending complainants’ suit
the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company had, in some way, acquired or been consolidated with the Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Company, and that the mortgage to the American Loan and Trust Company covered the whole line, both north and south of Litchfield.
The complainants appeal from so much of the decree of the Circuit Court as denied them a recovery upon the entire issue of bonds held by them — $50,000 and interest—and in denying them a prior lien upon the entire line of railroad, described in the bill as extending from Springfield to East St. Louis; and the American Loan and Trust Company appeal from so much of the decree as awarded complainants a lien for $22,976.59 on the Litchfield and St. Louis branch of the road, lying south of Litchfield. These constitute, in substance, the errors assigned by the respective appellants. The corporate existence of the American Loan and Trust Company having terminated during the pendency of these appeals, Dallas B. Pratt was substituted as trustee, and, by order of this court, has become a party to the record in place of his predecessor in the trust.
The testimony clearly establishes that the completed road. south of Litchfield to Mount Olive was the same road surveyed, located and mapped for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, which was located over the right of way acquired partly by the railroad company and partly by the construction company, under contract, for the railroad company. The court below found, as the proof clearly establishes, that “the Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Company took possession of the said uncompleted line of railroad and mingled other work and material therewith, and, upon a survey made and in accordance with plats and profiles thereto made for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, did complete a line of railroad from Litchfield to Mount Olive, Illinois, and did also appropriate the rights acquired by and for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company between Mount Olive and Alhambra, Illinois.”
It is further established by the proof that the defendant, the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company, built and constructed p. 340its road a distance of about eighteen miles on that portion of the line of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis railroad north of Litchfield, on the surveyed route and located line, and upon rights of way which had been theretofore acquired by and for the latter road. The rest of the line of the St. Louis and Chicago railway to Springfield, while slightly divergent from the line of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis railroad, was substantially the same, so that there is no practical difference between those portions of the line, either north or south of Litchfield.
It is further clearly established by the recitals in the conveyances made by the Empire Construction Company to H. H. Cooley & Company, and from said firm to the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company, and to the Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Company — all of which conveyances were duly recorded — that the newly-organized railway companies, and their mortgagees were affected with full notice of the rights, properties, and interests which the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company had in, to, and over the lines of road which the newly-organized roads completed under their contracts with Cooley & Company, as the successors or assignees of the Empire Construction Company.
It is clear, therefore, that the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company and the Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Company must be held to occupy, in respect to the complainants, the same position which H. H. Cooley & Company and the Empire Construction Company would have occupied if the roads in question had been completed by either of them without the organization or incorporation of the two railroad companies which now claim and assert title to said lines of railway. Being charged with full notice and knowledge of the fact that the lines which they were completing belonged to the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, and with the further notice that that company had issued and put in circulation for value $50,000 in bonds, secured by its mortgage of 1883, they must be held to have acquired and to hold their rights in said lines in subordination to the rights of complainants. It may be true that all the rights of way, ease-
Opinion of the Court. ,
ments, embankments, and appurtenances which the Empire Construction Company acquired for the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company under the contract between those parties did not invest that railroad company with a perfect legal title thereto; but it cannot be questioned that all the rights thus acquired conferred upon or gave to the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company an equitable title and interest therein which would be .covered by the “after-acquired clause ” of its mortgage, and that the construction company had no right to transfer such interests over to third parties, especially as against the bonds in question, which the railroad company had issued for value, and the construction company had put in circulation.
The “ after-acquired clause ” in the mortgage of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, under the decisions of this court, covers all acquisitions made to that property by either the construction company or others acquiring rights under it. Dunham v. Cincinnati, Peru dec. Railway Co., 1 Wall. 254; Galveston Railroad v. Cowdrey, 11 Wall. 459; Porter v. Bessemer Steel Co., 122 U. S. 267; Toledo <&c. Railroad v. Hamilton, 134 U. S. 296; Central Trust Co. v. Kneeland, 138 U. S. 414. In this latter case it- was held that the “after-acquired property clause” of a mortgage will cover not only legal acquisitions, but all equitable rights and interests subsequently acquired by or for the mortgagor.
If the two newly-organized corporations, which have appropriated the line of road, rights of way, and easements of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, had taken their transfers directly from the latter, it would admit of no question that the lien of complainants’ bonds would extend over the whole line; and this result is not, and cannot be, changed by the fact that they have acquired their rights through the intervention and conveyances of the Empire Construction Company to Cooley & Company, and by that firm to the newly-organized companies, as those conveyances, together with the mortgage of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, put them in full notice of the rights of the latter company, and also of the rights of its mortgagee. Joy ▼. St. Louis, 138 U. S. 1.
It cannot be assumed, therefore, that the St. Louis and Chicago and the Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Companies, or their mortgagees, are such bona fide transferees or purchasers for value of the partially constructed Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis railroad as to cut off the rights of bondholders secured by the prior mortgage of the latter company. Their acquisitions of the rights and interests of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company have in no way displaced the lien of complainants’ mortgage, which had previously attached, not only to all of said partially constructed road, but to all accessions which might be made thereto, either by the mortgagor or others succeeding to its rights.
Under the facts in this case the newly-organized railway companies are in legal effect the successors of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company cum onere, and the mortgage lien held by the complainants upon the franchises and all property acquired in completing their mortgagor’s railroad between the original termini, whether by itself or its successors, remains in full force; it follows, therefore, that the decree of the court- below was erroneous in limiting the complainants to a lien on that portion of the road lying south of Litchfield, completed in the name of the Litchfield and St. Louis Railway Company. The same principles and consideration which entitle the complainants to a lien on that portion of the road lying south of Litchfield apply with equal force to the line lying north of Litchfield, and under the facts of the case, as already stated, they should have had their lien declared upon that portion of the railroad north as well as south of Litchfield. The complainants’ lien has a clear and undoubted priority over the lien of the mortgage executed by the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company to the American Loan and Trust Company on April 1, 1887, as that mortgage was executed pendente lite after the filing of complainants’ bill herein.
The remaining question to be considered is whether complainants are entitled to a decree for the full amount of their bonds and interest, instead of the price they paid therefor p. 343when the bonds were sold under pledge made by Wing, president of the construction company. The pleadings do not raise the question as to whether complainants were entitled to the full amount of their bonds. There was no issue presented on that question, and it was not proper, therefore, on the proof, even if the proof had warranted it, to have reduced the complainants’ claim to the amount which they paid for the bonds when sold under the pledge thereof. The bonds were valid securities in the hands of the trustee for the protection of Wade as accommodation endorser for Wing, or the construction company, by whom they were pledged, and the pledgee or purchaser thereunder succeeded to the rights of the pledgor, and upon no principle could such purchaser, as against the maker, be restricted to what he might pay for the bonds. Negotiable securities once put in circulation for value may be transferred for less than their face, but the maker and those claiming under him cannot limit the right of a subsequent holder to a recovery of what he may have paid therefor.
In the case of Cromwell v. County of Sac, 96 U. S. 51, 60, in which it was held that the holder of such negotiable securities, regularly issued, is not limited to the amount which he may have paid therefor, it is said by the court, speaking by Mr. Justice Field: “We are of opinion that a purchaser of a negotiable security before maturity, in cases where he is not personally chargeable with fraud, is entitled to recover its full amount against its maker, though he may have paid less than its par value, whatever may have been its original infirmity. We are aware of numerous decisions in conflict with this view of the law; but we think the sounder rule, and one in consonance with the common understanding and usage of commerce, is that the purchaser, at whatever price, takes the benefit of the entire obligation of the maker. Public securities, and those of private corporations, are constantly fluctuating in price in the market, one day being above Par and the next below it, and often passing within short periods from one-half of their nominal to their full value. Indeed, all sales of such securities are made with reference to prices current in the market, and not with reference to their p. 344par value. It would introduce, therefore, inconceivable confusion if bona fide purchasers in the market were restricted in their claims upon such securities to the sums they had paid for them.”
The same general principle is held in Fowler n. Strickland, 107 Mass. 552; Moore v. Baird, 30 Penn. St. 138; Bange v. Flint, 25 Wisconsin, 544; Bank of Michigan v. Green, 33 Iowa, 140; Baily v. Smith, 14 Ohio St. 396. By the decisive weight of authority in this country, where negotiable paper has been put in circulation, and there is no infirmity or defence between the antecedent parties thereto, a purchaser of such securities is entitled to recover thereon, as against the maker, the whole amount irrespective of what he may have paid therefor.
This was the position occupied by the complainants in respect to the bonds in question, which were regularly issued for value, and constituted bona fide debts against the mortgagor in the hands of Wade, or of the construction company before they were pledged. The testimony in respect to that pledge and the price at which the complainants purchased the bonds was objected to as incompetent, and it should have been excluded on two grounds : first, because there was nothing in the pleadings to warrant its introduction; and secondly, because nothing disclosed thereby authorized the scaling of the bonds, as was done by the decree. We are, therefore, of opinion that the decree was wrong in limiting complainants right of recovery to the amount, and interest thereon, for which they purchased the bonds.
It is urged on behalf of Pratt that the principal of the bonds was not due; but in becoming a party to the cause the American Loan and Trust Company (to whose rights Pratt has succeeded) was required to adopt, and did adopt, the answer of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company, which admitted by its answer that it was in default in the payment of the bonds, and a similar admission was made by the St. Louis and Chicago Railway Company, under whose mortgage said trustee claims his rights were acquired. But aside from this, it is by no means certain, under the terms p. 345of the Chicago, Springfield and St. Louis Railroad Company’s mortgage, that the complainants did not have the right to foreclose, both for principal and for interest on their bonds.
This mortgage contained the provision “ that upon default made in the payment of either interest or principal upon any one hundred of said bonds for the period of sixty days, then each and all of said bonds shall become absolutely due at the option of the majority in interest of the holders of said one hundred bonds in default; and upon decree rendered as aforesaid, judgment shall be made for the whole of said indebtedness thus due upon default of the part of said indebtedness as if all were absolutely due according to the terms of said bond.” It was further provided that in the event of a sale the proceeds thereof, after defraying expenses incident thereto, should be applied in paying the several holders of the then outstanding bonds and coupons, secured by the mortgage, the amount of principal and interest, which might be due and unpaid, and in case of a deficiency in the fund to pay the same in full, then to distribute the fund pro rata among such holders. But the defendants having admitted that the bonds were in default, we do not feel disposed, in view of the fact that $50,000 constituted the entire issue, to reverse or modify the decree on the doubtful point as to whether the principal of the bonds under the terms of the mortgage could properly be treated as due.
Our conclusion is that there is no error in the decree of the Circuit Court of which the American Loan and Trust Company, or its successor, Pratt, can complain; and further, that the decree of the Circuit Court was erroneous in not allowing the complainants the full amount of their bonds, and in not declaring said bonds a lien upon the entire line of completed road from Springfield to Mount Olive.
The decree is accordingly reversed in this respect, a/nd the cause remanded to the Circuit Court with directions to enter a decree in conformity with this opinion, and it is accordingly so ordered.
Mr. Justice Field did not sit in this case, and took no part in its decision.