Braun v. Sauerwein, 77 U.S. (10 Wall.) 218

Case details
Bluebook Citation
Braun v. Sauerwein, 77 U.S. (10 Wall.) 218
Full caption
Braun v. Sauerwein.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Braun v. Sauerwein.
1. Although the running of a statute of limitations to the right of suing may be suspended by causes not mentioned in the statute itself, as, for example, by the fact that the plaintiff, without default of his own, has been disabled by a superior power from the capacity to sue; still, when by the removal of the disabling power the right reverts, the question in a case where the statute is afterwards set up to bar a suit, will be, “ How long did the suspension which it caused continue?” And the operation of the statute will not be prevented for a longer time than that during which the suspension was an enforced one.
Ex. gr. Where an act of Congress, which took effect August 1st, 1866, enacted that no suit to recover a tax once paid should be maintained, until appeal had been duly made to the Commissioner of Interna Revenue, and his decision had, unless such suit was brought within six months from the time of such decision, &c.
Held—in a case where suit was brought February 18th, 1868, to recovers tax that had been paid February 2d, 1864, and where appeal to the com missioner had been made August 20th, 1867, and decided by him Jam1 [p. 219] ary 11th, 1868,—that a statute of the State where the suit was brought which barred such suits, unless brought within three years from the time when the right of action accrued, operated; the plaintiff’s appeal having been pending only from August 20th, 1867, to January 11th, 1868 (four months and twenty-two days), and the time which he permitted to elapse between August 1st, 1866 (when the act took effect), and August 20th, 1868 (when he appealed), having been lost by his own delay, and not taken from him by any superior power. And it thus appearing that, deducting the time during which the appeal was pending (four months and twenty-two days), and during which alone he was disabled from the four years and sixteen days that elapsed between the inception of his right to sue and the commencement of his suit, there remained much more than three years, in which he was under no legal disability.
*
Loring et al. v. Marsh et al., 2 Clifford, 320; Wadleigh v. ^ea^. Sumner, 165; White v. Whitman, 1 Curtiss, 494; Lyman v. Brown, 559; The Paul Boggs, 1 Sprague, 369; The Highlander, 1 Id. 510. j- Murray v. Lovejoy, 2 Clifford, 197; S. 0. 3 Wallace, 16.
2. This view is not altered by the fact that the replication to the plea setting up the statute of limitations, averred that the appeal was “ duly ” made, its date not being set forth ; the rejoinder first setting forth the date of the appeal and of the decision of it.
3. The effect of such a replication (which might have been demurred to), was only to aver that the statute was suspended for a time; nothing more being well pleaded by it.
Error to the Circuit Court for the District of Maryland; the case being thus:
An act of Congress, passed July 13th, 1866,* and which by its terms took effect on the 1st of August of that year, enacts:
‘ That no suit shall be maintained in any court, for the recovery of any tax alleged to have been erroneously or illegally assessed or collected, until appeal shall have been duly made to the ommissioner of Internal Revenue, according to the provisions 0 law in that regard, and the regulations of the Secretary of t e Treasury established in pursuance thereof, and a decision of said-commissioner shall be had thereon, unless such suit shall be fought within six months from the time of said decision, or within six months from the time this act takes effect. Provided, thV decision shall be delayed more than six months from e ate of such appeal, then said suit may be brought at any ime within twelve months from the date of such appeal.”
thi8 8^u^e force, Braun, on the of February,
’ rought suit in one of the State courts of Maryland
* 2 19,14 Stat, at Large, 152.
against Sauerwein, a collector of internal revenue, to recover a sum of money alleged to have been illegally exacted by him, in virtue of his office, from the plaintiff.
The defendant pleaded a statute of limitation of the State of Maryland, which bars actions of this nature unless brought within three years from the time when the right of action accrued. The plaintiff’ replied, that after the defendant had received the money for which the suit was brought, the plaintiff duly appealed from the assessment and collection thereof made by the defendant, to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue of the United States, according to the provisions of law and in conformity to the regulations of the Secretary of the Treasury; that a decision of his appeal was not made until on or about the----- day of February, 1868, and that his suit was brought within six months from that daté. But the replication, it will be observed, did not aver when the appeal was taken, nor the day when it was decided. The case being removed after this into the Circuit Court of the United States, under certain acts of Congress,* the defendant rejoined, averring that the money alleged to have been taken, was received on the 2d day of February, 1864, and not afterwards, and that the appeal of the plaintiff to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue was taken on the 20th of August, 1867, and not before; and that the decision of the appeal by the commissioner was made on the 11th o January, 1868. To this rejoinder the plaintiff then demurred. The court overruled the demurrer, and judgment went for the defendant.
The case, therefore, as worked out by the pleadings, an with its facts arranged in order of time, stood thus: The collector took the money and the cause of action arose, February 2,1864. The act of Congress took effect, . . . • • August 1, 186 The appeal to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue
wL taken, . . . '....................................August 20,1W The commissioner decided the appeal, .... January 1, The suit was brought, .............................................February,
It thus appeared that more than three years had elapsed
* See 12 Stat, at Large, 756; 14 Id. 46.
Argument for the taxpayer.
after the cause of action accrued before the suit was brought, and more than three years before the appeal was taken to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue; that the statute began to run on the 2d of February, 1864, and supposing that nothing intervened to suspend its operation, that the bar would have been complete on the 2d of February, 1867.
The question was, whether the act of Congress of the 13th of July, 1866, had, under the facts of this case, worked such a suspension as that the suit, though thus brought four years and sixteen days after the cause of action accrued, was still wnbarred by the Maryland statute.
The court below, in overruling the demurrer, decided that it had not; and the correctness of that view was the only important point now here on error.
Messrs. Brent, Crittenden, and Hughes, for the plaintiff in error:
As we could not sue after the 13th July, 1866 (the date of the act of Congress), until an appeal taken and a decision thereon, and as our replication avers that the appeal was duly made (a matter not denied in the rejoinder), the appeal must be taken to have been in time. The rejoinder then shows a decision of that appeal on the 11th day of January, 1868, and this suit being brought on the 19th February, 1868, some thirty-nine days after the appeal, it results that if we deduct the whole term between the 13th July, 1866, and 11th January, 1868 (date of the decision), we have only two years, five months, and twenty days left between the receipt of the money on the 2d February, 1864, and the ringing of this suit on the 19th February, 1868. The State statute of three years could not therefore bar the action.
We make, no point as to whether the suit was properly transferred under any act of Congress, though, possibly, one might be raised.
r* C. H. Hill, Assistant Attorney- General, contra.
Mr. Justice STRONG delivered the opinion of the court, of r i8.un?oubtedly a general principle, that when a statute ° imitation has begun to run, a disability to sue [p. 222] subsequently intervening does not stop its running, even though the disability be one of those expressly recognized in the statute itself. Notwithstanding this, however, the courts in this country have engrafted upon such statutes at least one implied exception. Thus, in Hopkins v. Bell* this court held that the treaty of peace of 1783, by which the independence of the United States was acknowledged by Great Britain, prevented the operation of a Virginia statute of limitations upon debts due to British subjects, and contracted before the treaty was made. In that case, though the statute had begun to run before the commencement of the war in 1775, the time during which it had thus run was not allowed to be added to any time subsequent to the treaty. This, perhaps, is not to be regarded as a clearly judicial exception, incorporated into the Virginia statute. It was rested upon the force of the treaty which declared that creditors on either side (British or American), should meet with no lawful impediment to the recovery of the full value, in sterling money, of all bonafide debts theretofore contracted. The treaty, however, wras not the act of Virginia, and the suspension of the statute’s operation was by something outside of the statute itself. But in Hanger v. Abbott^ it was ruled, after grave consideration, that the time during which the courts oi the recently rebellious States were closed to the citizens of other States, is, in suits brought by such citizens, to be excluded from the computation of the time fixed by statutes of limitation, within which only suits may be brought, and this, though the statutes contain no such exception. In other words, it was held that the statutes of limitations of the insurrectionary States were suspended, while the courts in those States were closed by the war. Similar decisions have been made in the State courts. ‘ They all rest on the ground that the creditor has been disabled to sue, by a su perior power, without any default of his own, and, theie fore, that none of the reasons which induced the enactmen of the statutes apply to his case; that unless the statutes
* 3 Grand, 454. f 6 Wallace, 532.
cease to run during the continuance of the supervening disability, he is deprived of a portion of the time within which the law contemplated he might sue.
It seems, therefore, to be established, that the running of a statute of limitation may be suspended by causes not mentioned in the statute itself. Assuming, then, that the act of Congress did, for a time, stop the running of the Maryland statute against the plaintiff, the inquiry remains, how long did the suspension continue ? To this there can be but one answer. Manifestly, only so long as he was prevented from suing by the act of Congress. The act, speaking from August 1st, 1866, prohibited a suit until he should appeal to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, and until bis appeal should be decided, unless the decision should be postponed longer than six months, in which case he was at liberty to sue within a year from the time when his appeal was taken. The interval between the appeal and its decision, then, was the entire period during which he was disabled by the act. If, in fact, he was disabled a longer time, the prolonged disability was caused by his own neglect to appeal. The replication to the defendant’s pleas fail to state when the appeal was made. True, the averment is, it was “duly” made, but that is pleading a conclusion of law rather than a fact. The time when the appeal was taken was material to show how long the statute of limitation was suspended. The effect of the replication was only to aver that the statute was suspended for a time. Nothing more was well pleaded by it. Instead of meeting it by a demurrer, however, the defendant rejoined, setting forth the date of the appeal, and the date of its decision, and the plaintiff demurred to the rejoinder. It is thus admitted that the plaintiff’s appeal was pending only from August 20th, 1867, to January 11th, 1868, four months and twenty-two days. The act of Congress denied to him a right to sue during that period, and iio longer. The time which he permitted to elapse between
ugust 1st, 1866 (when the act of Congress took effect), and ugust 20th, 1868, when he appealed, was not taken from niu by any controlling power. He lost it by his own delay. [p. 224] It would be giving a most unreasonable construction to the act were we to hold, that by merely delaying to appeal, when it was all the time in his power, he could have suspended the running of the statute indefinitely. Deducting, then, the four months and twenty-two days, during which his appeal was pending, and during which he was disabled, from the four years and sixteen days that elapsed between the inception of his right to sue and the commencement of his suit, there remain much more than three years in which he was under no disability, except such as was imposed by himself. The judgment of the Circuit Court on the demurrer was, therefore, correct.
It remains only to add that the case was well removed into the Circuit Court of the United States.*
Judgment affirmed with costs.
Hornsby et al. v. United States.
1. Grants of the public domain of Mexico, made by governors of the de' partment of California, were of three kinds: 1st, grants by specific boundaries, where the donee was entitled to the entire tract described; 2d, grants by quantity, as of one or more leagues situated at some designated place, or within a larger tract described by out-boundanes, where the donee was entitled out of the general tract only to the quantity specified; and 3d, grants of places by name, where the donee was entitled to the tract named according to the limits, as shown by its settlement and possession, or other competent evidence.
2 Grants of the second class,—those by quantity,—passed from the government to the grantees, upon their execution, the right to the quantity of land specified therein, to be afterwards laid off by official authority at the place or within the larger tract designated.
8. Under Mexico the measurement and segregation from the public domain of the quantity, specified in this class of grants, could only be made by the officers of the government. A measurement by the grantee was inoperative for any purpose. Although a general possession of t e
* Hodgson v. Milward, 3 Grant, 412 and 418; Bigelow v. Forrest, 9 Wallace, 339.
Dec. 1869.] Hornsby v. United States. *.**
land ceded was permitted in California before tbe official measurement, the grantee acquired by such possession no absolute right to the tract occupied, or any interest which could control the action of the officers of the government in the segregation of the land.
4 Although the regulations of 1828, which were adopted to carry into effect the colonization law of 1824, provided that a map of the land solicited should accompany the petition for a grant, a compliance with the provision was not exacted in all cases. The governors exercised a discretionary power of dispensing with it under special circumstances. No motive existed for insisting upon its presentation when the information, which it was designed to impart, was already in the public archives open to the inspection of the governor; and such information existed there in the present case.
6. Although the regulations provided that the governor, upon receiving a petition for land, should proceed to obtain the necessary information as to the qualifications of the petitioner and the character of the land; they did not prescribe any particular mode by which this information should be acquired. It might have been obtained by the governor from his own investigations, or he might, as stated in the regulations, if that course were preferred, consult the appropriate municipal authority, which was that of the district, whether any objection existed to making the grant. Formal reference to the local magistrate, and a report from him, were not essential to give the information required, although this course was usually adopted.
6. A clause in the grant in this case, subjecting it to the approval of the departmental assembly, did not prevent the title from passing to the grantees upon the execution of the instrument. Such approval was not a condition precedent to the vesting of the title. According to the regulations of 1828 the authority to make grants of land in California was lodged solely with the governor. It was not shared by him with the assembly. That body only possessed the power to approve or disapprove of grants made by him. Until such approval the estate granted was subject to be defeated. "With such approval the grant became, as it was termed in the regulations, “definitively valid,” that Is, it ceased to be defeasible, and the estate was no longer liable to be divested, except by proceedings for breach of its other conditions.
i. It was the duty of the governor, and not of the grantee, to submit to the assembly grants issued by him for its approbation. His neglect in this respect supended the definitive validity, as it was termed, of the grants ; that is, it prolonged the liability of the estate to be defeated by the action of the assembly, and of the supreme government thereon, to which the matter was referred in case the approval of the assembly was not obtained; and no other consequence followed. His neglect was not permitted to operate to divest the grantees of the estate already vested in them.
• In passing upon claims under Mexican grants in California, the question is, what right did tbe grantees acquire in the land from the Mexican
VOL. X, 15
authorities ? This court cannot inquire into any acts or omissions by them since those authorities were displaced. It is not authorized to pronounce a forfeiture for anything done, or anything omitted by them since that period.
9. The political department of the government having designated the 7th of July, 1846, as the period when the conquest of California was completed, the judiciary follows the action of the political department. On that date, therefore, the authority and jurisdiction of Mexican officials in California, are considered as having terminated.
10. The grant in this case was for the surplus land remaining in two places after satisfying out of those places two previous grants to other parties, including other lands within the jurisdiction of the same pueblo to make up the amount of nine leagues; and to it were annexed conditions, the second of which provided that the grantees should solicit the proper judge to give them juridical possession of the land; and it was here objected to the confirmation of the claim, that the grantees had forfeited their rights under the grant by not applying for such possession, and. never entering upon the land. The objection was answered: 1st, by the fact, that between the date of the grant and the displacement of the authority of Mexican officials only sixty-one days had elapsed, and that within a period so limited juridical possession was seldom delivered after the issue of a grant; 2d, by the fact, that it was impossible for the magistrate to deliver such possession until the previous grants in the same general locality had been surveyed and severed from the public domain, and no such survey and severance were had, nor was any action ever taken by the previous grantees to have the quantity granted to them segregated previous to the conquest; and the grantees in this case could not of themselves have lawfully intruded upon the possessions of the previous grantees, and undertaken themselves to determine what part of the general tract should be set apart to those previous grantees, and appropriate the balance as the surplus to which they were entitled, 3d, by the fact, that mere neglect to comply with the condition, even if unreasonably prolonged, did not of itself work a forfeiture of the grantees right under the Mexican law, but only left the land open to denouncement by other parties. Some formal and regular proceedings were required to effect a divestiture of a grantee’s interest under the Mexican law, and these had their inception in what is termed a denouncement by a party desirous of obtaining the land. An investigation then followed whether or not the condition had been complied with or so disregarded as to justify a decree of forfeiture. Without sue inquisition and decree the title did not revert to the government, nor was the land subject to be regranted.
11 The interest which passed by the grant in this case, whether it be regarded as a legal title, imperfect in its character, and to be perfec e by a subsequent official survey and segregation of the quantity desig nated, or as a mere equitable or inchoate title, constituted property which the United States were bound to protect by the stipulations o
the treaty of cession. By the term property, as applied to lands, all titles are embraced, legal or equitable, perfect or imperfect.
Appeal from the District Court of California.
This case was brought by the appellants, Hornsby and Roland, for the confirmation of a claim made by them under a Mexican grant for nine square leagues of land, situated in California, under the act of Congress of March 3d, 1851, to ascertain and settle private land claims in that State.* The grant was issued to Luis Arenas (whose interest had since passed to the claimant Hornsby) and Jose Roland, May 6th, 1846, by Pio Pico, then governor of the Department of California.
Some years before the issue of this grant, a grant of two square leagues in the place called Las Animas had been made to one Thomas Brown, from whom the property by mesne conveyances had passed to a certain Charles Weber; and a grant of about the same quantity in the place called Canada de Paia had been made to Jose Bernal and others. For the surplus land remaining in these places, after satisfying the previous grants, including lands of the Cerro Colorado, within the jurisdiction of the same pueblo, to make up the amount of nine leagues, Arenas and Roland, on the 5th of May, 1846, presented their petition to the governor. No map of the land accompanied this petition, but the parties in the petition offered to present a map to the governor at a convenient time.
On the margin of the petition, the governor made an order that a decree of concession be issued, and the title (the grant) be delivered to the parties for their protection. On the following day, the 6th, the governor made a full and formal decree of concession, in which he stated that in the exercise of the powers with which he was invested by the supreme government, and in the name of the Mexican nation, he declared the petitioners owners of the land so located, and directed that the title (titulo—the grant) be issued which would secure to them the property.
* 9 Stat, at Large, 631.
The formal grant then issued; in it the governor recited the petition, and then stated that the “necessary steps having been taken, and inquiries made,” he had, by a decree of that day in the exercise of the powers with which he was invested by the supreme government in the name of the Mexican nation, declared, and did then declare the petitioners “owners in full property” of the land, describing it as in the petition, in conformity with the law of the 18th of August, 1824, and the regulations of November 21st, 1828, “ subject to the approval of the departmental assembly, and under the following conditions:
“ 1st. They (the grantees) may inclose it without injuring the passes, roads, and servitudes, and may enjoy it fully and exclusively, appropriating it to such use as may suit them.
“2d. They shall solicit the proper judge to give them juridical possession by virtue of this decree, and he shall mark the boundaries with the proper landmarks.
“ 8d. The land hereby granted is nine leagues of the largest size, and is situated in the surplus or vacant lands of the ranchos of Don Carlos Weber and Don Jose de Jesus Bernal, including the lands of the Cerro Colorado towards the valley. The judge who shall give the possession, shall have it measured in conformity to law, in view of the map which will be presented by the parties interested.”
Traced copies of the petition, the marginal order, the decree of concession, and of the draft of the grant, from the archives of the Department of California, in the custody of the Surveyor-General of the United States for California, and the original grant issued to the petitioners, were produced before the board of land commissioners, and in the District Court. No question appears to have been made in either tribunal as to their genuineness. The grant issued bore the signatures of the governor, Pio Pico, and of t e acting secretary of state at the time, Moreno. The genuine ness of these signatures was proved by a witness produce by the claimants before the commissioners; but they rejec e the claim on the ground that there was no evidence that t e grant was ever approved by the departmental assembly, or [p. 229] that juridical possession was ever given, or that the grantees were ever in possession of the land, or occupied it in any manner; and that the description of the land was too vague and indefinite to enable the commissioners to describe it with any degree of certainty. The commissioners, without making the fact a distinct ground of rejection, also observed, in their opinion, that the governor, the day following the receipt of the petition, had, “ without, so far as appears from the record, making any inquiries or investigations in relation to the matter, entered a decree of concession, and directed the title to be issued and delivered to the interested parties.”
From the decree of the board of land commissioners an appeal was taken to the District Court. Whilst the case was pending in that court, the parties entered into a stipulation that certain depositions of Pio Pico, of Moreno, and of Rufus C. Hopkins, taken in another case in which Roland was also a claimant, might be used in this case. In his deposition thus used, Pico testified to the genuineness of his signature to the grant in this case, and also that it was customary to take informes (that is, to have an official report upon the subject) as to the qualifications of applicants and upon the land solicited before making a concession, but that it was not indispensable, and that it was not unusual for a petition to be signed, a marginal order and a decree of concession made, and a title issued on the same day; that often a number of concessions were made on the same day; and in the assembly a number of concessions were often confirmed °n the same day.
Moreno, in his deposition, also testified to the genuineness 0 his own signature, and that of Pico, to the grant in this case.
opkins, the keeper of the Mexican archives in California, *n his deposition, testified that he had made the archives of ^.e former Spanish and Mexican governments in California is special study for the then last preceding seven years;
at there was no book of record in the archives showing petitions presented for land, and grants made with maps of [p. 230] the lands granted, as required to be kept by the regulations of November, 1828, and that there was no trace whatever amongst the archives of the existence of any such book at any former time; that the nearest approach to any such record were the espedientes on file in the archives; that these espedientes were the various proceedings in reference to individual grants, written upon sheets of paper and stitched together, and, when concluded, indorsed and numbered by the secretary, and filed in the archives.
In answer to the question as to what evidence, if there was no record, did the archives furnish of the fact of the issue of any grant whatever since 1828, the witness stated, “ That the only evidences to be found in the archives of the issuance of grants since 1828, are 1st, the espedientes already referred to; 2d, a book in which titles (the grants) are recorded, which were issued in 1833, ’34, and ’35; 3d, the index known as the ‘ Jemino Index,’ embracing grants made from 1833 to 1844, inclusive; 4th, a Toma de Razon, or registry of grants issued in 1844, ’45; 5th, an index known as the ‘ Hartnell Index;’ 6th, Toma de Razon, kept by prefects in 1843; 7th, journals of the departmental assembly, from 1829 to 1846; 8th, official correspondence in which grants are referred to; 9th, some loose maps and borradors in reference to grants.” He continued:
“ The record I have referred to, of 1833 to 1835, contains a copy of the entire grant or titulo—without the previous proceedings or maps;” and with respect to grants issued in 1846, he testified that “ the only evidence the archives furnish of grants made in 1846, are the espedientes referred to, jouiiials of the departmental assembly, the Hartnell index, an official correspondence, borradors, &c.”
The District Attorney of the United States admitted in writing in the District Court, that the grant in this case was issued by Governor Pico on the 6th of May 1846; and t a the extent of the surplus lands for which it was issued ha not then been ascertained. „
The District Court affirmed the decree of the boar laud commissioners and rejected the claim, but the isr
Dec. 1869.] Hornsby v. United States. 281
judge states in his opinion below, that the genuineness of the papers produced from the archives and of the title produced by the claimants, was not disputed by the counsel of the United States. The rejection of the claim was placed on the ground that no investigation was had by the governor as to the condition of the land, or the qualification of the parties; that the whole proceeding was commenced and consummated within two days; and that no evidence was offered to show that either of the grantees ever settled or attempted to settle on the land, or that any surplus lands existed for which the grant called.
Of the regulations for the colonization of the territories of Mexico, adopted November 21st, 1828, the following are those which bear upon the questions raised in this case.*
1st. The governors (Gefes Politicos) of the territories are authorized (in compliance with the law of the General Congress, of the 18th of August, 1824, and under the conditions hereafter specified) to grant vacant lands, in their respective territories, to such contractors (empressariosf families, or private persons, whether Mexicans or foreigners, who may ask for them, for the purpose of cultivating and inhabiting them.
2d. Every person soliciting lands, whether he be an empressario, head of a family, or private person, shall address to the governor of the respective territory a petition, expressing his name, country, profession, the number, description, religion, and other circumstances of the families, or persons, with whom e wishes to colonize, describing, as distinctly as possible, by means of a map, the land asked for.
3d. The governor shall proceed immediately to obtain the oessary information, whether the petition embraces the require conditions, required by said law of the 18th of August, both tio e^ar^8 land and the candidate, in order that the petispect1 a^.once be attended to ; or, if it be preferred, the reive municipal authority may be consulted, whether there be any bjeaion to making the grant or not. _ This being done, the governor will accede, or not, to such
in frOm ^le translation in Rockwell’s Spanish and Mexican Law
11 o mines and titles to real estate, vol. i, p. 453.
petition, in exact conformity to the laws on the subject, and especially to the before mentioned one of the 18th of August, 1824.
5th. The grants made to families, or private persons, shall not be held to be definitively valid without the previous consent of the territorial deputation, to which end the respective documents (espedientes) shall be forwarded to it.
6th. When the governor shall not obtain the approbation of the territorial deputation, he shall report to the supreme government, forwarding the necessary documents for its decision.
7th. The grants made to empressarios, for them to colonize with many families, shall not be held to be definitively valid, until the approval of the supreme government be obtained, to which the necessary documents must be forwarded along with the report of the territorial deputation.
8th. The definitive grant asked for being made, a document signed by the governor shall be given to serve as a title to the party interested, wherein it must be stated that said grant is made in exact conformity with the provisions of the laws, m virtue whereof possession shall be given.
9th. The necessary record shall be kept in a book destined for the purpose, of all the petitions presented and grants made, with the maps of the lands granted, and the circumstantial report shall be forwarded quarterly to the supreme government.
Messrs. M. Blair and F. A. Dick, for the appellants.
Mr. Wills, contra.
Mr. Justice FIELD delivered the opinion of the court.
As we have had occasion to observe in several instances, grants of the public domain of Mexico, made by goveinois of the department of California, were of three kinds. Is, grants by specific boundaries, where the donee was entit e to the entire tract described; 2d, grants by quantity, as o one or more leagues situated at some designated place, or within a larger tract described by out-boundaries, where donee was entitled out of the general tract only to the quai
». United States, 8 [p. 233] tity specified; and 3d, grants of places by name, where the donee was entitled to the tract named according to the limits, as shown by its settlement and possession, or other competent evidence.
*
Higueras v. United States, 5 Wallace, 828; Alviso r. Id. 339.
The greater number of the grants which have come before this court for examination have belonged to the second class. They have usually designated the land ceded by the general name of the valley or locality where situated, with a clause annexed that the concession was limited to the specific quantity mentioned, and that the magistrate of the vicinage, of whom possession was to be solicited, should cause the same to be surveyed, and that any surplus existing should be reserved for the use of the nation.
When the first grant of this kind was presented for the consideration of this court, in the Fremont case,* which was for ten leagues within a tract of much greater extent, it was objected that the grant was void for uncertainty of description, and that no interest passed to the grantee until the quantity was surveyed and severed by known boundaries from the public domain; but the court held the objection untenable, and that, as between the government and the grantee, the latter had a vested interest in the quantity of land mentioned. “The right to so much land,” said the Chief Justice, in delivering the opinion of the court, “to be aftei wards laid off by official authority in the territory described, passed from the government to him by the execution of the instrument granting it.” And in support of the principle asserted, the court cited the case of Rutherford v.
^ene s Heirs, reported in 2d Wheaton,f which arose upon an act of the State of North Carolina, passed in 1782, prop lnS that twenty-five thousand acres of land should be alo e and given to General Greene and his heirs, within 1 ‘d ^ln^S a tract reserved for the use of the army, to be 1 0. ^7 commissioners appointed for that purpose. The
fiv^th18SiOnerS’ Pursuance °f’ the act? allotted the twenty_ °usand acres, and caused the quantity to be surveyed
f Page 196.
off, and the survey to be returned to the proper office, and the question upon which the case turned related to the validity of the title of General Greene, and the date at which it commenced. The court held that the general gift of twenty-five thousand acres lying in the territory reserved, became by the survey a particular gift of the quantity within the survey, and concluded an elaborate examination of the title by stating, that it was the clear and unanimous opinion of the court, that the act of 1782 vested a title in General Greene to the twenty-five thousand acres to be laid off within the boundaries designated, and that the survey, made in pursuance of the act, gave precision to that title, and attached it to the land surveyed.
And this court, in deciding the Fremont case, observed in reference to this case of Rutherford v. Greene’s Heirs, that “it recognizes as a general principle of justice and municipal law, that such a grant for a certain quantity of land by the government, to be afterwards surveyed and laid off within a certain territory, vests in the grantee a present and immediate interest. In the language of the court, the general gift becomes a particular gift when the survey is made; and when this doctrine has been asserted in this court, upon the general principles which courts of justice apply to such grants from the public to an individual, good faith requires that the same doctrine should be applied to grants made by the Mexican government, where a controversy arises between the United States and the Mexican grantee.”*
Under Mexico the measurement and segregation from t e public domain of the quantity, specified in this class of grants, could only be made by the officers of the government, measurement by the grantee was inoperative for any Pu pose. Although a general possession of the land ceded was permitted in California before the official measurement, t ® grantee acquired by such possession no absolute right to tract occupied, or any interest which could control the action of the officers of the government in the segregation o t
land. A private survey was as ineffectual under the former government as under the present government. The right, which the former government reserved to itself over the survey, passed, with all other public rights, to the United States upon the cession of the country, and is now to be exercised in pursuance of their laws.*
Now, if we consider the present case in the light of these views, we shall find little difficulty in its disposition. The grant here, like the one in the Fremont case, is a grant by quantity. It was made under the same law and regulations, and like that, was subject to the approval of the departmental assembly, and has certain conditions annexed. It was issued to Luis Arenas and John Roland, on the sixth of May, 1846, by the then governor of California. A petition for the land had been presented by them to him on the fifth of May, and the same day he made an order on its margin directing a decree of concession, and the issue of a grant to the parties. On the subsequent day, the sixth, a formal decree was signed by him declaring the petitioners owners of the land, and directing a grant to be issued, which would secure to them the property. The grant followed. The petition, the marginal order, the decree of concession, and the diaft of the grant, are in the Mexican archives now in the custody of the Surveyor-General of the United States for Caliornia. Traced copies of these instruments, and the original giant issued, were produced by the claimants before the land commissioners and in the District Court. Their genuineness and authenticity wrere not disputed in either tribunal.
e issue of the grant by the governor was admitted in the wiitten stipulation of the counsel of the government. I eveial years previous to the issue of this grant to RoArenasJ a grant of two square leagues in the place fro 6 been made to one Thomas Brown,
OiU °m ^ie ProPerV by various mesne conveyances had
Se *° <-De Charles Weber; and a grant of about the e <luantity in the place called Canada de Paia had been
made to José Bernal and others. For the surplus land remaining in these places, after satisfying the previous grants, including lands of the Cerro Colorado within the jurisdiction of the same pueblo, to make up the amount of nine leagues, the petition of Roland and Arenas was presented, and the grant to them was issued. Ko map of the land solicited accompanied the petition, but the petitioners offered to furnish a map to the governor at a convenient time, that is, whenever there might be occasion for its use.
The grant, after reciting the petition, and that the necessary steps had been taken and inquiries made, proceeds to state, that the governor, by a decree of that day, in the exercise of the powers with which he was invested by the supreme government, and in the name of the Mexican nation, had declared and-did declare the parties owners in full property of the land solicited, describing it as in the petition, in conformity with the law of 1824 and the regulations of 1828, subject to the approval of the departmental assembly and certain conditions annexed.
The instrument purports on its face to transfer a full title to the property solicited. If valid when issued, it passed, according to the decision in the Fremont case, to the grantees a present and immediate interest in the quantity of land specified, to be subsequently laid off by official authority. And this brings us to the questions, whether there was anything in the action of the governor or of the grantees pluvious to its issue, which impaired its validity; and if the instrument was valid when issued, whether there was any such subsequent disregard of its conditions as to work is forfeiture.
That the governor, under Mexico, was authorized to ma grants of land in the department of California is not ques tioned; and that the instrument produced in this case^.^ genuine and was issued by him is admitted. But it is that the grantees did not accompany their petition w map of the land solicited, and that the governor di no make any inquiries as to the qualifications of the petitioner, and the condition of the land, as required by the regulation [p. 237] of 1828, which were adopted to carry into effect the colonization law of 1824.
It is true, that the regulations provided that a map of the land solicited should accompany the petition, but a compliance with the provision was not exacted in all cases. The governors exercised a discretionary power of dispensing with it under special circumstances. No motive existed for insisting upon its presentation when the information, which it was designed to impart, was already in the public archives open to the inspection of the governor; and such information existed there in the present case. At any rate, the governor was satisfied with the offer of the petitioners to furnish a map at the proper time subsequently. As was said in the Fremont case, in answer to an objection of a similar character, “ the court could not, without doing injustice to individuals, give to the Mexican laws a more narrow and strict construction than they received from the Mexican authorities who were intrusted with their execution.”*
It is also true that the regulations provided that the governor, upon receiving a petition for land, should proceed to obtain the necessary information as to the qualifications of the petitioner and the character of the land. But they did not prescribe any particular mode by which this information should be acquired. It might have been obtained by the governor from his own investigations, or he might, as stated in the legulations, if that course were preferred, consult the appiopriate municipal authority, which was that of the district, whether any objection existed to making the grant, n some instances, as in the case of Sutter, the character of e petitioner, and of the land solicited, were matters of notoriety.j- The objection appears to proceed upon e i ea ^at a formal reference to the local magistrate, and a report fiom him, were essential to give the information quire. This course was usually adopted, but it was not
* 17 Howard, 561. t United States v. Sutter, 21 Id. 172; The Sutter Case, 2 Wallace, 563. [p. 238] essential. The grant in this case recites that the necessary steps had been taken, and inquiries made, and something more than mere surmises at this day are necessary to show that the recital is false.*
There is nothing in these objections which touches the validity of the instrument at the time it issued. And the clause subjecting the grant to the approval of the departmental assembly did not prevent the title from passing to the grantees upon the execution of the instrument. Such approval was not a condition precedent to the vesting of the title. According to the regulations of 1828, the authority to make grants of land in California was lodged solely with the governor. It was not shared by him with the assembly. That body only possessed the power to approve or disapprove of grants made by him. Until such approval the estate granted was subject to be defeated. With such approval the grant became, as it was termed in the regulations, “ definitively valid,” that is, it ceased to be defeasible, and, the estate was no longer liable to be divested, except by proceedings for breach of its other conditions.
Besides it was the duty of the* governor, and not of the grantee, to submit to the assembly grants issued by him for their approbation. His neglect in this respect suspended the definitive validity, as it was termed, of the grants; that is, it prolonged the liability of the estate to be defeated by the action of the assembly, and of the supreme government thereon, to which the matter was referred in case the approval of the assembly was not obtained; and no other consequence followed. His neglect was not permitted to operate to divest the grantees of the estate already vested in them.f In many instances years elapsed before the approval was obtained, although the grantees were in the meantime in the possession and enjoyment of the property; and in many instances no approval was had previous to the conquest.
*
United States v. Johnson, 1 Wallace, 329. . i United States v. Reading, 18 Howard, 4; United States v. aca, 556; United States v. Larkin, lb. 558; United States v. Cruz Cervan > lb. 553; United States v. Johnson, 1 Wallace, 329.
The grant being valid at the time of its issue, has there been any such disregard of the conditions annexed as to work its forfeiture? The objection taken is that the grantees never applied to the proper magistrate for official delivery of possession, as provided in the second condition; and that they never entered upon the land. The objection applies only to the period intervening between the date of the grant, and the time when the country passed under the jurisdiction of the United States. - The question is, what right did the grantees acquire in the land from the Mexican authorities. The court cannot inquire into any acts or omissions by them since those authorities were displaced. It is uot authorized to pronounce a forfeiture for anything done, or anything omitted by them since that period. Now the military forces of the United States took possession of Monterey, an important town of California, on the 7th of July, 1846, and within a few weeks afterwards occupied the principal portions of the country; and this occupation continued until the treaty of peace. On that date, therefore, the authority and jurisdiction of Mexican officials are considered as having terminated. The political department of the government, at least, has designated that day as the period when the conquest of California was completed, and the judiciary in this respect follows the action of the political department.*
etween the date of the grant under consideration, and tie period thus designated, only sixty-one days elapsed.
ere are very few instances of grants in California where a juridical possession was delivered to the grantees within a period as limited as this after their issue. In many ine ances years elapsed before this proceeding was had; and m many instances no juridical possession was ever delivered previous to the conquest. j ,.n case bar it was impossible for the magistrate to andVJ SUCh.-Possessi°n until the previous grants to Weber erua^’ 'n ^be same general locality, had been surveyed
* United States v. Torba, 1 Wallace, 423.
and severed from the public domain. It was for the surplus in that territory, remaining after the quantities granted to them had been satisfied, that the present grant called. What part of the general tract occupied by the previous grantees would be finally set apart to them, could not be known until the official measurement. The grantees in this case were therefore necessarily compelled to await the action of the elder grantees; and no action was ever taken by them to segregate the quantity granted to them previous to the conquest.
This want of segregation of the quantities claimed by the previous grantees furnishes also an excuse to the grantees here for not entering upon the land without the delivery of juridical possession. To have made such entry would have been to intrude upon the possessions of others. They could not of themselves have undertaken to determine what part of the general tracts should be set apart to the earlier grantees, and appropriate the balance as the surplus to which they were entitled.
But independent of the considerations stated, it is a sufficient answer to the objection to say, that mere neglect to comply with the condition did not of itself work a forfeiture of the grantees’ right under the Mexican law. The neglect of a grantee to apply for or to take possession, if unreasonably prolonged, only left the land open to denouncement by other parties. The interest of a grantee could not be divested under the Mexican law any more than at the common law, upon mere allegations or surmises. Some formal an regular proceedings were required to effect such divestiture, and under the Mexican law these had their inception in what is termed a denouncement by a party desirous of o taining the land. An investigation then followed whet er or not the condition had been complied with or so isr® garded as to justify a decree of forfeiture. Without sue inquisition and decree the title did not revert to the gover ment, nor was the land subject to be regranted. .
The object of the colonization laws and regulations Mexico was the settlement of the vacant lands o
public, and grants were usually made to accomplish this purpose without other consideration. But the public, as observed in the Fremont case, “ had no interest in forfeiting them even in these cases, unless some other person desired, and was ready to occupy them, and thus carry out the policy of extending its settlements.”*
The several cases cited by counsel, where the absence of possession and the omission of proceedings usually taken in obtaining concessions of land, are noticed and made grounds» of objection to a confirmation, have no application. They are cases, where the grants produced were unaccompanied by any archive evidence, and the attempt was made to uphold them by evidence of the recollections of witnesses. Thus, in the Cambuston case,f the alleged grant produced was unknown to any person beside the grantee and an interested party until July, 1850, although bearing date in May, 1846, and no trace of its existence was found in the archives of the country. So in the Castro case,| the instrument produced as a grant first made its appearance in June, 1849, though dated in April, 1846, and was not sustained by a single document in the archives. The absence of all traces of the grants, where evidence would usually be found, if it a existed, naturally created a strong presumption against t eir validity, which could not be overcome by testimony on the uncertain recollections of Mexican officials.
ere having been no forfeiture of the grantees’ interest 1U t e present case, nor any such disregard of the conditions annexe to their grant as to have justified a forfeiture, the aimants under the grant are entitled to a confirmation. ira PasseJ by the grant, whether it be re-
Pfe as a legal title, imperfect in its character, and to be the 60 6 • a 8Uksequent official survey and segregation of title^Uantlty designated, or as a mere equitable or inchoate bound^f118^11*^ ProPerty which the United States were That t • ° Pr°tec^ by the stipulations of the treaty of cession.
ea y piovides for the protection of the rights of [p. 242] property of the inhabitants of the ceded territory. And, independent of the treaty, they were entitled to such protection by the law of nations, according to which, as said by thia court in Strother v. Lucas,* “ the rights of property are protected even in the case of a conquered country, and held sacred and inviolable when it is ceded by treaty, with or without any stipulation to such effect.”
1
H°Ward» 561- f 20 Id. 59. J 24 Id. 346. VOL. X.
By the term property, as applied to lands, all titles are embraced, legal or equitable, perfect or imperfect. It was so held by this court in the case of Soulard v. The United States,^ when considering the import of the term in a stipulation contained in the treaty by which Louisiana was acquired, providing that the inhabitants of that territory should be protected jn the enjoyment of their property. “It comprehends,” said the court, “ every species of title, inchoate or complete. It is supposed to embrace those rights which are executory as well as those which are executed. Iu this respect the relation of the inhabitants to their government is not changed. The new government takes the place oi that which has passed away.”
It follows from the views we have expressed that the appellants possessed under the grant in this case, at the date of the cession of California to the United States, a right of property in the land granted, and, as a consequence, that their claim is valid and should be confirmed.
The decree of the District Court must, therefore, be re - versed, and the cause remanded, with directions to enter a decree
Confirming the claim of the petitioners.
Mr. Justice DAVIS, with whom concurred CLIFFORD and SWAYNE, JJ., dissenting.
I am unable to concur in the decree of the court in this case, and as the claim embraces a large tract of conn ry which is a part of the public domain, if this claim is n0
j- 4 Id. 511-
sustainable, I think it proper to state as briefly as possible the grounds of my dissent. Similar claims have been so frequently before the court, that any extended discussion of the general rules of law applicable to them is not necessary, as these rules have been so often explained in our reported decisions. It is clear that valid claims should be confirmed, and equally clear that those of a contrary character should be rejected. Tested by the rules of law established by this court in analogous cases, I am of opinion that the claim of the appellants is invalid. The Mexican authority was overthrown in California on the 7th of July, 1846, but the history of the.times made it clear to every intelligent man for a considerable period before this date, that the country would pass to the jurisdiction of the United States. During this period grants of land were made very freely by Pio Pico, the acting governor, and the records of this court show that many of these grants were invalid and fraudulent. Doubtless, grants were made by him within that time which were valid, but all must agree, I think, that every grant which bears his signature should be examined with the most careful scrutiny. By the record in this case, it appears that the petition for this grant is dated the 5th day of May, 1846, and the grant, if any were made, was on the following day, and did not comply with the requirements of the law conferring power on the Governor of California to grant lands. The Mexican law, to make a title valid, required it to be evidenced by certain written instruments
which taken together constitute an expediente. The expe-
diente, when complete (as decided by this court), consisted
o a petition, with a diseno or map annexed; a marginal de-
ci ee leferring the petition to a local officer to report whether
t e land was vacant and grantable, and the petitioner a
proper person to obtain the bounty of the government; the
°f that officer on these subjects, called an informe;
e ecree of concession and the copy or duplicate of the grant, as the original was delivered to the petitioner. It express terms required by the Mexican law, that the i ions for lands, and the grants, with maps annexed, [p. 244] should be recorded.* It was insisted that the papers which were produced in this case before the commissioners, constituted such an expediente, but if it be conceded the papers are of Mexican authority, they do not contain any diseno or map, or reference to the local officer, or his report thereon. There could be no record of the petition and grant with the map of the land granted, because no map of any kind was annexed to the petition, and there is no evidence in the record that any part of the expediente was recorded as required by Mexican law. Grants of this kind were made subject to the approval of the departmental assembly, but there is nothing to show an attempt, even, to comply with this requirement. On the contrary, there is every reason to conclude that it never was presented to that assembly, as it is well known that there were a large number of grants made about that time which were presented and approved, and as this one was not approved, the inference is fair and reasonable that it was never presented for approval. It also appears that no judicial measurement of the land was made, nor possession of it taken by the supposed grantees, as required by the Mexican law, and the conditions of the grant.
The documents offered in evidence are not shown by any competent proof to be Mexican documents. The court in its opinion describes them as having been produced from the public archives, and this statement might create the impression that the expediente under consideration came from the Mexican archives. This cannot be so, as the number of the expediente proves beyond a doubt that it is one of those papers found in the custom-house at Monterey the latter part of the year 1847, or the fore part of the year 1848, which were subsequently included in Hartnell’s Index.
This index is not, and never has been regarded as a Mexican document.! Since the decision of Castro’s case,J this court, until now, as I suppose, has adhered to the principle, that whoever claims title to land in California under a gran [p. 245] from a Mexican governor, must, as a general rule, produce the grant and show that it came from the public archives of land titles in the proper office of that department, or that it was found in Jimeno’s Index, or that it was recorded in the Toma de Razon. It is true, in that case, Chief Justice Taney said that secondary evidence could be received, when it appeared that the grant had been properly made, and that the papers, or some of them, in the office where they were kept, had been lost or mislaid, but the court held, that a party setting up a grant by such proofs, must also show that there was a judicial survey of the land, and that the supposed grantees took actual possession of it, and exercised acts of ownership over it, before the change of jurisdiction.
There are a number of cases in which the same rule is laid
down (some of earlier and others of later date than Castro’s
case), and it seems to me they ought to control the decision
of this case.*
No possession of any kind is proved in this case, and the
authenticity of this grant, covering an area of over forty
thousand acres of land, depends on the testimony of a single
witness, unsupported by any proof, except the imperfect or
mutilated expediente, found among a mass of loose papers
on the floor of one of the rooms of the custom-house at
onterey, after the Mexican officials had fled, on the ap-
proach of our forces.
Possession is essential in such a case to establish an equity,
an as none is proved, the claimant has no equity, and in my
jo gment the decree ought to be affirmed.
Fuente6 v’ Cambuston, 20 Howard, 59; United States v. Suf«, 45 ’ United States v. Bolton, 23 Id. 341; White v. United
te8’ 1 WaI1ace, 660; United States v. Pico, 2 Id. 279.
The Columbia.
A steamer crossing another so as to involve risk of collision, condemned in
a case of collision:
1st. For violation of the regulation, then existing, that when steam-vessels were so crossing, the one which had the other on her own starboard should keep clear.
2d. For not keeping clear, being the following vessel.
Appeal from the Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York.
The owners of the propeller Jersey Blue libelled the steamship Columbia, one of the Charleston line of steamers, in the District Court for the Southern District of that State, on account of a collision which occurred in the harbor of New York, on the afternoon of the 7th of January, A.D. 1860. The case, as assumed by the court on the testimony, was thus:
The propeller started on a voyage from the coal docks in Jersey City across the Hudson to the East River. The tide was strong ebb, and there was very little wind. From her start her course was nearly towards the Battery, New York, somewhat south of east, and she kept on that course until almost immediately before the collision. Her rate of speed was probably not far from six miles an hour. Soon after she left the docks the steamship Columbia pushed out from pier No. 4, on the New York side of the Hudson, to commence her voyage to Charleston. There was at that time a body of floating ice, extending outward from the piers six or eight hundred feet, but beyond the ice the river was clear. As the ship hauled out into the stream her bow was swung by the tide downward, and her helm was put to the star board. Whether she had cleared the ice-fields before s e headed down the bay, was a matter somewhat disputed, but not one of importance. If she had not entirely cleared it, she had so far done so as that only her port wheel was m the ice-field when she met the propeller. All was open on her starboard side. She proceeded down the river, m course nearly parallel with the outer ends of the piers, pro [p. 247] ably just on the outer edge of the ice-field, and at the rate of not less than four miles an hour. When she came to a point nearly opposite Castle Garden, and a little below the Battery, she collided with the propeller, her starboard wheel
mounting the deck of the propeller about midships, on the oaid side, and walking over it forty or fifty feet, doing onsi erable damage. There were other important circum^anees preceding the collision. The Columbia was seen and* 6 ProPeller soon after she hauled out from the pier the C.°1mmenee^ swinging down the river. The propeller ven1 eW °ne w^s^e» which was not answered. When the peap6 1 aPProached each other and danger of collision apthat61? 6 ProPe^er aSa^n blew one whistle, thus signalling e intended to pass on the right. This second signal [p. 248] was not answered. But when they came within six or seven hundred feet of each other the pilot of the Columbia hailed that he could not stop, and the engine of the propeller was immediately reversed, and she commenced backing. The backing was continued until the collision, entirely stopping the headway of the propeller, and swinging her head somewhat outwards from New York. On the other hand, the propeller was seen from the Columbia when the latter was only about one hundred yards from pier No. 4, and before she had taken her course down the river. She was seen to be heading from Jersey City about towards the Battery, and to be, at most, about half a mile distant. She was off the starboard bow of the Columbia, and only her port side could be seen. It was apparent that her course must cross any course the Columbia could take. After the latter had headed down the river and had come within six or seven hundred feet of the propeller, her helm was put to the starboard, so that she headed inside of Governor’s Island, instead of west of the island, her proper course out to sea. She then hailed, but did not stop her engine, or certainly not, until the collision had taken place.
Thus far there was very little controversy in regard to the facts. Most of them appeared in the answer to the libe, and from the testimony of the pilot of the Columbia.
But the libellants relied, for the condemnation of the steamer, on another fact, which they conceived that the evidence showed; the fact, namely, that the Columbia was the following vessel, and so by the rules of navigation bound to keep out of the propeller’s way. On this part of the case, Chadsey, the captain of the Jersey Blue, testified that e first saw the Columbia when his own vessel was sout o pier No. 1, and two or three hundred yards distant; that e saw her over his left shoulder as he was standing at t e wheel; that she was then just coming out of pier No. ,aa swinging down the river. This was evidently before s e had straightened on her course. If this was so, the Columia must have been above, namely, further up the river, an e following vessel. Captain Chadsey’s testimony was corro [p. 249] orated by that of Green, the engineer, Taylor, a deck hand, and by the testimony of Klickner and Pritchard, shipwrights, who repaired the propeller after the collision. The shipwrights both testified that “the character of the injuries showed that the steamship must have struck her and worked forward on her;” “that the motive force must have come from aft forward;” that the chain-bolts of the propeller were bent forward; and that this could not have been, but on the contrary, the exact reverse, unless the Columbia overtook the propeller and struck her from aft.
The evidence offered to rebut this was that of Hutchinson, the engineer of the Columbia, who stated that when he saw the propeller she was some two hundred yards distant, headed obliquely to the Columbia, and as he thought, above. He added immediately: “However, my not being on the deck to notice the compass, everything appeared abeam to me.” Kelso, the pilot, stated that when he first saw the propeller (his own ship being one hundred yards out from pier Ko. 4) she was half a mile distant, and his impression was that she was above at the time, though he adds, “Z cannot swear she was above; the boats were angling towards one another.” There was no other testimony given to prove that the Columbia was not the following vesse
The District Court dismissed the libel, but on appeal to the Circuit Court the decree was reversed, and judgment given against the Columbia. The case was now here on appeal from that decree.
Mr. Benedict, for the appellant; Mr. Donohue, contra.
Mr. Justice STRONG, having stated the case, delivered he opinion of the court.
From those facts which appear in the answer to the libel, au from the testimony of the pilot of the Columbia, and a out which there is very little controversy, it is not difficult o etei mine where the fault of the collision in this case lies.
e propeller was all the time, from the moment she was rs seen, off the starboard side of the Columbia. It was [p. 250] therefore the duty of the latter to keep out of the way. The regulations then existing required that when two steam vessels were crossing, so as to involve risk of collision, the one which had the other on her own starboard should keep clear. Plainly she had no right to expect the propeller to change her course. It was therefore a fault in the Columbia that she did not port her helm and go astern of the other vessel. And the fault was the more inexcusable because she knew, even before she had settled on her course, that the course of the propeller must take her across any line the Columbia could take in going directly out to sea. There was nothing, then, to prevent her adopting such a course as would have avoided all danger of a collision. Instead of that she went straight down the river, in a line nearly parallel with the ends of the piers and very near to them, and, as the vessels approached each other on converging lines, she swung to port, so as to come more directly into the line of the propeller’s course. This was the exact opposite of what she should have done.
We think also the evidence establishes that the Columbia was the following vessel, and, if she was, another regulation required her to keep out of the way of the propeller. There is no satisfactory evidence to rebut the testimony of Captain Chadsey as to the positions of the vessels, and it is corrobo rated by the testimony of Green, the engineer, Taylor, a deck hand, and of both the shipwrights who repaired t e propeller. They both testify that the force of the collision must have come from aft forward. The chain-bolts of t e propeller were bent forward, which could not have been unless the Columbia overtook the propeller and struck er from aft. The testimony given to prove that the Colum was not the following vessel manifestly tends to prove t e contrary. Maps have been exhibited to us describing situation of the piers and the course of the propellei ,iorn the coal docks to the place of collision. If they are to relied upon, and if the propeller was not more than a ¿ mile from the Columbia when Kelso (the pilot) saw her, 8 must have been below pier No. 1, as the evidence oi [p. 251] libellant shows she was, when the Columbia was only one hundred yards from pier Ko. 4. It seems to be satisfactorily established, therefore, that the Columbia was the following vessel. Of course the fault of the collision was hers. She had two courses before her, either of which would have avoided the disaster. Had she put farther out from her pier, where she had clear water, before heading down the river, or if, after heading down, she had ported her helm, as the regulations required, instead of starboarding, or even if she had stopped when she saw danger of collision, she would have passed astern of the propeller and no injury would have been done. By so doing she would have pursued her most direct course out to sea. But she did neither. She made no attempt to slacken her speed when the danger became imminent, and by starboarding she precipitated herself % directly upon the libellant’s vessel.
Decree of the Circuit Court affirmed, with interest
AND COSTS.
Deming’s Appeal.
Motion to reinstate a supposed legal tender case denied on the ground c iefly of laches; notwithstanding consent of the other side, the United States.
atham and Deming being entitled, each of them, to recover a certain sum of money from the United States for w°i done prior to the act of February 25th, 1862, known a8 e first of the “ Legal Tender Acts,” appealed, after the passage of the acts, to the Treasury for payment. They t^^ded coin, but were offered and accepted paper; “pro-ing, when receiving the paper, against such mode of then brought, each of them, a suit in the
° against the government to recover the fo eie^Ce value between the coin which they had asked nj. Paper which they accepted. The Court of
1118 ecided against them, and they both appealed to [p. 252] this court. The cases were supposed to involve the question of the constitutional validity of the paper circulation issued by the United States under the acts of Congress named, and known as legal tender notes. And as Mr. Hoar, then Attorney-General, had asked for the argument of them in order expressly that the question adjudged against the notes in Hepburn v. Griswold* might be reconsidered, the argument of them both was a matter to which public and professional attention was largely directed.
On the 1st of April last, the argument was fixed for the 11th of that month. When the 11th came, the hearing, owing to the engagement elsewhere of the appellants’ counsel, was adjourned till the 18th, and on the 18th, another case being then on, till the 20th. On the 20th, Wednesday, Mr. Chatfield, of New York, counsel for Latham, and Mr. Merryman, of Washington, D. C., counsel for Deming, appeared, and “ feeling no desire,” as they stated in a paper filed and signed by them, “ to trouble this court any further with the consideration of the cases, took the occasion to withdraw them from the docket, and respectfully asked that they might be dismissed.” Mr. Hoar, who stated that he had come to the court all ready to argue the cases, opposed the dismissal. But the court, after a short conference, decided, unanimously, that an appellant had the right to withdraw his own suit, and the appeals were accordingly dismissed. The Chief Justice immediately afterwards, on that Wednesday, 20th, announced that the court would not hear arguments after the following Tuesday (the 26th); that motions for the only Friday (regular motion day) remaining would be heard on that Tuesday, and that the court would adjourn on Saturday the 30th. All the proceedings were published under the ordinary head of “ The Courts,” in the Washington and some other newspapers of the next day. On Tuesday, the 26th, the court adjourned till the 30th, an then it met on the 30th, delivered opinions and adjourne till Monday, October 31st.
* 8 Wallace, 603.
On the 5th of May, the mandate issued to the Court of Claims to carry the judgment into execution.
The court having met again on Monday, 31st of October, Mr. Lander, new counsel in the matter, now, Friday, the 4th November, stated his desire to appear as counsel for the purpose of moving to reinstate Deming’s appeals, and asked leave to appear for that purpose. The court held the motion under advisement until Monday, 7th. On that Monday it gave him leave to appear; and having appeared, he immediately moved the reinstatement. Mr. Merryman, the former counsel, by note to Mr. Deming filed in the case, expressing his unwillingness, “ under the peculiar circumstances of the case, to remain counsel any longer in the matter,” suggesting the employment of Mr. Lander, and withdrawing personally from the case.
The ground of the motion now made by Mr. Lander to reinstate was an affidavit ex parte by Deming to the effect that his former counsel, Mr. Merryman, had been ill for some time prior to the already mentioned 20th April; that he went to court on that day in order to argue the case, but was met by Latham and persuaded by him to sign the motion to dismiss; that Latham had a power of attorney from him, Deming, to sell and assign his (Deming’s) claim, and informed Mr. Merryman that his own (Latham’s) counsel ad resolved to dismiss that claim, and desired Deming’s to e also dismissed, “ saying that he had made such arrangements as would secure a successful prosecution of the said two claims in Congress,” and that Deming’s claim would certainly be paid; that Mr. Merryman not being able to see 1fn (-Deming), and believing that Latham from his supposed e ations with the said claim of Deming also represented hs wishes |n the matter, signed the motion for dismissal; la w ile it was true that a power had been given to Latham sc and assign the claim, yet “ that the purpose for which
^ven kad failed,” and that Latham had no the a dictate” as to the appeal then pending, and that
Or ,er„°f dismissal was made without the knowledge or c°nsent of the affiant.
The affidavit further stated that the affiant was informed of the dismissal “ soon thereafter” by his attorney, who upon hearing the true state of facts and the wishes of the affiant to have a decision of this court on the case, made application to the then Attorney-General, Mr. Hoar, for his consent to an application to rescind the order of dismissal, which consent was obtained upon the proviso that the cause could then be argued, but that as that was not practicable, by reason of the close approach of the adjournment of the court for the summer, the motion had been necessarily postponed till now.
The consent of the now Attorney-General, Mr. Akerman, to the restoration was given by him in person, and also by writing filed.
Ab depositions of Mr. Merryman, or of Latham, or of Leming, were taken, nor was the power of attorney from Leming to Latham produced, or evidence given that it had been inquired for.
Mr. Lander, in support of his motion, adverting to the questionable power of an attorney to dismiss in this way, under any circumstances, and to the admitted power which every court had over its own proceedings during the term, relie on the facts set forth in the affidavit; and the fact (obvious as he conceived by the minutes of the court), that Deming was guilty of no laches; not a week having passed between the dismissal (on the 20th), unknown to him until some time afterwards, and the actual adjournment, the adjournment for business purposes (on the 26th), and he having proceede at this the adjourned session at the very earliest moment practicable; Fridays being the only regular or proper mo tion days.
Even if there had been laches, the consent of the Attorney^ General to restore, given personally and by writing, cure them. The party interested to set up laches, if theie wa any, admitted that there was none; that there had been mistake. But there were no laches. On the contiary, Deming had been as prompt as possible.
Mr. Justice SWAYNE delivered the opinion of the court. A motion has been made on behalf of Deming to reinstat [p. 255] this case upon the calendar. The suit was originally instituted in the Court of Claims. A judgment was rendered in favor of the United States, and the plaintiff brought the case into this court by appeal. That case and the case of
0. B. and 0. S. Latham v. The United States, also brought into this court by appeal from the judgment of the Court of Claims, were supposed to involve the question of the constitutional validity of the paper circulation issued by the United States, known as legal tender notes. On the 1st of April, during this term, both these cases were set for argument on the 11th of that month. On that day the argument was postponed until the 18th of April. The hearing was further postponed to the 20th of April. On that day the counsel for the Lathams and the counsel of Deming united in a written motion that both appeals should £>e dismissed.
The court recognizing the right of the counsel to have this done, thereupon dismissed the appeals. No reason was given for this step, and no explanation was made by either counsel, except the statement that they did not wish further to trouble the court in relation to the cases. The court continued to sit until the 30th of April. The long vacation then commenced. No motion was made prior to that time by Deming, to set aside the dismissal of his appeal. On the 5th of May the mandate of this court was sent to the Court of Claims to carry the judgment into execution. This motion was filed on the 7th of November, instant. It appears y the affidavit of Deming that he was aware of the dismissal very shortly after the order was made. This must necessarily have been so. It was announced in the pro-cee mgs of the court published the next day. Nothing is pro uced from his counsel who made the motion. Deming a es in his affidavit, that the counsel acted without his aft°W or consent. Granting this to be so, his silence am^ t 6 ^ac^s canie to his knowledge, must be held to the°Unt *° acTu^escence and ratification. The dismissal of of th^n' judgment of the Court of Claims in favor
nited States in full force. They can sustain no [p. 256] prejudice by the overruling of this motion. We therefore lay out of view, as an element to be considered, the consent of the Attorney-General that the order of dismissal shall be rescinded.
The motion is addressed to the discretion of the court. Under the circumstances, we are all of the opinion that it oughttobe Denied.
New Orleans Railroad v. Morgan.
The appellee filed his petition in the Circuit Court of the United States averring that he was the holder of a large amount of bonds and coupons, secured by mortgage executed by the appellant. He prayed for executory process. Execution was awarded, and the appellant was ordered to pay the amount, of said bonds and coupons.
The appellant failing to pay on demand, the railroad and its appurtenances were sold by the marshal, and the appellee became the purchaser. The appellant then filed his petition in the said court, in the nature of an audit& querelft—averring that the award of execution had been made without notice; that the executory process, as recognized by the practice of Louisiana, could not be enforced in the courts of the United States; and that the appellee’s claim could only be enforced on the equity side of the court.
The record showed the following entry :
“The court having duly considered the ‘petition and exhibits submitted by the petitioner in this cause, and being satisfied that the prayer thereof cannot be granted, it is ordered and decreed that the said petition be dismissed with costs.’ Judgment rendered June 14th, 1869. Judgment signed June 18th, 1869. E. H. Durell, Judge.” On motion to dismiss the writ of error, held, that this was sufficiently formal, and that it was a final judgment to which a writ of error would lie.
On motion to dismiss writ of error.
The New Orleans, Opelousas, and Great Western Railroad Company issued, on the 1st April, 1859, two thousand bonds, redeemable in 1889, for $1000 each, with interest, payable semi-annually; and to secure the payments a mortgage was executed upon the road (eighty miles), together with the depots and lands appertaining to them, &c.
On 23d February, 1869, Charles Morgan filed his petition [p. 257] in the Circuit Court of the United States for Louisiana, averring that he was the holder of a certain number of these bonds, and of coupons on them overdue.
On .this petition an order was made, 30th March, 1869, directing the company to pay, on three days’ notice, $316,840, and in default of payment the mortgaged property to be seized and sold for the whole debt.
[The reader will observe that this proceeding, known in the civil code of Louisiana as executory process, is wholly ex parte. The mortgage is held to be in the nature of 4» confession of judgment, and the judge grants the execution, upon the application of the party, as a matter of course, upon the production of authentic evidence of the mortgage, and bonds or notes.]
The company, being in a great state of embarrassment, was unable, thus summarily called on, to pay the large amount required by the order, and a seizure of their property was made by the marshal, and notice thereof served on the 5th April.
On the same day the company filed its bill on the equity side of the said Circuit Court, asking that for causes therein assigned the proceedings in the executory process should be stayed, and Morgan be required to file a bill on the chancery side of the court, to which all the creditors might be made parties, &c.
The motion for the injunction on this bill was heard 27th April, 1869.
The property was advertised to be sold under a writ of seizure, on 25th May, 1869, and it was not until the day before this sale, to wit, on 24th May, 1869, that the judge entered the following order:
For reasons orally assigned, it is ordered and decreed that t e prayer for an injunction be denied, with costs.”
At the sale on the 25th May, Morgan, in the absence of p e other creditors, became the purchaser of this very large
vol. x. -fl
Argument in support of the motion.
On the 1st June, 1869, the company for the first time appeared on the law side of the said Circuit Court, and filed its petition in the nature of an auditd querela; averring that the executory process could not be legally ordered without notice; that the order was made without notice; without proper evidence and parties; that the subject of the suit was only cognizable in chancery, &c., and prayed an award of “a writ to Charles Morgan, expressing a willingness to hear this complaint,” that the validity of the said proceedings might be examined, and that they be restrained and suspended by writ until a final order herein.
Exceptions were filed on the 8th June by Morgan, and on the 14th June the following order and entry was made:
The court having duly considered the petition and exhibits submitted by the petitioner in this cause, and being satisfied that the prayer cannot be granted, it is ordered and decreed that the said petition be dismissed with costs.
Judgment rendered 14th June, 1869. Judgment signed 18th June, 1869. E. H. Durele, Judge.
From this judgment the present writ of error was prosecuted in this court.
The Judiciary Act, as most readers will remember, gives this court power to re-examine on writs of error, and reverse or affirm “final judgments in civil actions or suits” rendered in a Circuit Court, where the matter in dispute exceeds the sum or value of $2000.
Mr. Jenckes now moved to dismiss this writ, chiefly on the following grounds:
1. Because the record contained no bill of exceptions; nor any agreed statement of facts; nor any special verdict, demurrer to a material pleading, or demurrer to evidence.
2. Because the judgment exhibited in the record was not a final judgment.
In support of his motion, Mr. Jenckes argued, that unless a bill of exceptions was tendered to the judge for his ru mgs [p. 259] thereon, and allowed; or unless an agreed statement of facts, or a special verdict, or demurrer to a material pleading, or demurrer to evidence be shown, there was nothing disclosed for this court to review.* And as there was thus no case made here upon which the judgment of the court could be given, and no final judgment of the court below set forth which could be affirmed, the proper course was to dismiss the writ of error, f
Mr. P. Phillips, contra:
Want of jurisdiction and irregularity of the writ, are the only grounds for a dismissal. Wherever error is apparent on the record, it is open to revision, whether it be made to appear by bill of exceptions or otherwise. In the present case the judgment is passed upon the allegations of the petition and exhibits, as though a formal demurrer had been filed by the defendant, and the action of the court, in either sustaining or overruling a demurrer, may be examined by writ of error, without a bill of exception.|
The proceeding instituted on the 1st June, 1869—a petition in the nature of an auditd quereld—is beyond controversy a “civil action,” or “ suit,” and the judgment rendered on 14th, and signed 18th June, was obviously final, inasmuch as it entirely disposed of the claim to relief set up in said “civil action” or “suit” and decreed costs. The motion is, therefore, plainly unfounded every way.
Mr. Justice CLIFFORD delivered the opinion of the court.
Two principal causes are assigned in support of the motion to dismiss the writ of error:
1. That the record contains no bill of exceptions nor any agreed statement of facts or any special verdict, demurrer to a material pleading, or demurrer to evidence.
Per Clifford, J., Pomeroy’s Lessee v. Bank of Indiana, 1 Wallace, 592; Thompson v. EiggS) 5 Id> 663
t Burr v. The Des Moines Company, 1 Id. 99. I Bogers v. Burlington, 3 Wallace, 661.
2. That the supposed judgment exhibited in the record is not a final judgment.
Express jurisdiction is conferred upon this court by the twenty-second section of the Judiciary Act to re-examine, upon writ of error, and reverse or affirm final judgments in civil actions rendered in a Circuit Court, where the matter in dispute, exclusive of costs, exceeds the sum or value of two thousand dollars, whether the same was brought there by original process or was removed there from courts of the several States, or from a District Court.*
Such a writ of error, when issued to a Circuit Court, removes the whole record into this court, and if all the proceedings in the suit were correct, it follows, if not from the very words of the section, certainly from the necessary construction of the same, that the judgment must be affirmed.!
Error may be shown in such a case by a bill of exceptions or by a demurrer to the declaration, or a material pleading, or it may appear by an agreed statement of facts, if made a part of the record, or in a special verdict, if put in due form; but even when all these are wanting it is no cause for dismissing the suit, because the writ of error issued to a Circuit Court under that section brings up the whole record, and their absence only shows that there is no error in the proceedings; and if there is no error in any part of the record the prevailing party in the Circuit Court is entitled to an affirmance of the judgment.^
Cases brought here by writ of error to a State court, issued under the twenty-fifth section of the Judiciary Act, stand upon a very different footing, as in such a case it must appear on the face of the record in express terms or by necessary implication, that some one, at least, of the questions described in that section did arise in the State couit, an that the question so appearing in the record was decided in the State court, as required in that section; and if it oes not so appear in the record, then this court has no juris«, ic
* 1 Stat, at Large, 84. f Taylor v. Moreton, 2 Black, 484. + Minor et al. v. Tillotson, 1 Howard, 287; Stevens v. Gladding, 1» • [p. 261] tion of the case, and in that event the writ of error must be dismissed; as this court, under those circumstances, has no power either to reverse or affirm the judgment rendered in the State court.*
Certain errors in judicial proceeding can only be examined in an appellate court when they are shown by a bill of exceptions,—as'where proper testimony is rejected or where improper testimony is admitted,—but there may be error in the proceedings of a subordinate court apparent in the record for which the judgment will be reversed in an appellate tribunal, although they are not shown by a bill of exceptions and do not appear in an agreed statement of facts or by demurrer or in a special verdict,—as where the original process was unauthorized by law, or where the defendant was not served with process, or where the proceedings under the process were irregular and void. Such were the rules of the common law, and they have been adopted and applied in this court in repeated cases.f
Whatever the error may be and in whatever stage of the cause it may have occurred it must appear in the record or proceedings, as before explained, or be shown by a bill of exceptions, agreed statement of facts, demurrer, or special verdict.1
Two thousand bonds for the sum of one thousand dollars each were, on the first of April, 1859, issued by the plaintiffs in error, falling due in thirty years, with interest at eight per cent, payable semi-annually in coupons for the proper amount. Their road was completed at that time from Algiers, opposite the city of New Orleans, to Berwick Bay, a ustance of eighty miles, and they mortgaged the same, together with the road-bed of the main track and branches [p. 262] and the depots and the lands appertaining thereto, to secure the payment of the bonds. On the twenty-third of February, 1869, Charles Morgan filed his petition in the Circuit Court, averring that he was the holder of a certain number of these bonds and of a large number of coupons which were past due, and an order was made on that petition, on the thirtieth of March following, that the corporation plaintiffs, on three days’ notice, pay to the petitioner, the defendant in error, two hundred and sixteen thousand dollars, and the cost of the proceedings, and that in default of such payment the mortgaged property might be seized and sold according to law for the whole of the debt secured by the mortgage. Payment, as thus summarily ordered, was not made, and thereupon a writ of seizure was issued by the court, and the whole of the mortgaged property was seized by the marshal and sold, and the petitioner became the purchaser of the same at the sale.
*
Suydam v. Williamson, 20 Id. 440; Taylor v. Moreton, 2 Black, 483;
1
Stat. at Large, 85. t Slacum v. Pomeroy, 6 Cranch, 221; Garland v. Davis, 4 Howard, 131; net v. Butterworth, 11 Id 669; Cohens v. Virginia, 6 Wheaton, 433; Suydam v. Williamson, 20 Howard, 433. Eliason,h16tpe°tersP1291lnS’ 431 ’ *1 Tidd s practice, 586; United States «.
It is contended by the plaintiffs that the process and all the proceedings in the Circuit Court were irregular and void and that the same should be set aside, but the court will not determine that question at this stage of the controversy, because it is clear that if the views of the plaintiffs are correct, and the judgment is a final one, it must be reversed. Questions of reversal or affirmance appertain to the merits of the controversy, and will not be determined upon a motion to dismiss.
But the defendant insists that the judgment is not a final one, and that the writ of error should be dismissed on that ground.
On the first of June, 1869, the plaintiff's for the first time appeared on the law side of the Circuit Court, and filed their petition in the nature of an audita, querela, averring that the executory process could not be legally ordered without notice; that the order was made without notice and without proper evidence and parties; that the subject of the suit was only cognizable in equity, and prayed that the validity of «aid proceedings may be examined, and that they be restrained and suspended by a writ until a final order herein.
Hearing was had on the petition and the court having duly considered the petition and exhibits submitted by the petitioner in this cause, and il being satisfied that the prayer thereof cannot be granted, it is ordered and decreed that the said petition be dismissed with costs.”
Judgment rendered June 14th, 1869. Judgment signed June 18th, 1869.
The forms of verdicts and judgments, it is true, are not controlled, even in Louisiana, by the State law, but there must be some variation from the form of a judgment as at common law to render it appropriate to the form of the process adopted in that circuit. Common law suits as well as suits in equity are commenced in that court by petition, and the judgment in this case is in a form not unusual in that court. It is called a judgment in the record and treated as such by the court and the parties, and in our opinion the writ of error ought not to be dismissed for either of the reasons assigned in the motion.
Motion denied.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access