Union Ins. Co. v. United States, 73 U.S. (6 Wall.) 759

Case details
Bluebook Citation
Union Ins. Co. v. United States, 73 U.S. (6 Wall.) 759
Full caption
Union Insurance Company v. United States.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Union Insurance Company v. United States.
1. The act of August 6th, 1861, “to confiscate property used for insurrectionary purposes ’ ’—(which act declares that such property shall be the lawful subject of prize and capture, and that such prizes and captures shall be condemned in the District or Circuit Court . .. having jurisdiction, or in admiralty, in any district in which they may be seized, or into which they may be taken, and that the attorney-general “ may institute the proceedings of condemnation ”),—extended to all descriptions of property, real or personal, on land or on water.
2. The Circuit Court has jurisdiction, under that act, of proceedings for the condemnation of real estate or property on land ; and such proceedings may be shaped in general conformity to the practice in admiralty; that is to say, they may be in the form and modes analogous to those used in admiralty. But issues of fact, on the demand of either party, must be tried by jury; such cases differing from cases of seizure made on navigable waters where the course of admiralty may be strictly observed.
3. Such proceedings, having forms and modes but analogous to those used in admiralty, and issues of fact being to be tried by a jury, do not necessarily constitute “ a cause in admiralty.”
4. Where a proceeding, under the act, to enforce the forfeiture of real estate, was carried on in a Circuit Court by libel, monition, claim interposed, and testimony taken in conformity with the practice of courts of admiralty, and without a jury anywhere, jurisdiction of the decree was taken by this court on appeal, but only for the purpose of reversing the decree as irregular, and directing a new trial.
5. The proceedings in cases of the seizure of real estate should, in respect to trial by jury and exceptions to evidence, be conformed to the course of proceedings by information on the common-law side of the court, in cases of seizure on land.
6. An owner of real property in New Orleans, who leased it during the late rebellion to a firm publicly engaged in the manufacture of arms for the rebel confederacy—the lease stating, in terms, that the lessees intended to establish “engines, machinery,” &c., in the property leased—was presumed to have made the lease knowing the purpose for which the property was to be used, and consenting to it. And his interest in the pioperty was held to be rightly confiscated under the act of 6th August, 1861.
7. But the presumption was held to he otherwise in regard to a party taking a mortgage from the owner before the lessees took possession, and where there was no proof of consent by the mortgagee to the use made of the premises, beyond the fact of his having taken a mortgage. And the interest of such mortgagee was held not confiscable under the act. 8. The forfeiture was incurred when the lessees went into actual use of the premises under lease, and the subsequent seizure for condemnation divested all intermediate liens.
This was an appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for the Eastern District of Louisiana; the case being thus:
An act of Congress, of August 6th, 1861, passed during the late rebellion, and entitled “ An act to confiscate property used for insurrectionary purposes,” provides, in different sections, as follows:
The first section provides that property used in aid of the rebellion, with consent of the owner, shall be the “ lawful subject of prize and capture wherever found,” and makes it the duty of the President to cause it “to be seized, confiscated, and condemned.”
The second section provides that such “ prizes and captures shall be condemned in the District or Circuit Court of the United States having jurisdiction of the amount, or in admiralty, in any district in which the same may be seized, or into which the same may be taken and proceedings commenced.”
The third section provides that “the attorney-general, or any district attorney of the United States, in which said property may at the time be, may institute the proceedings of condemnation, and in such cases they shall be wholly for the benefit of the United States; or any person may file an information with such attorney, in which case the proceedings shall be for the use of such informer and the United States in equal parts.”*
With this statute in force, a square of ground in New Orleans, with the buildings upon it, was leased, on the 17th of September, 1861, by one Leonce Burthe to a firm, Cook & Brother, who, in October or November, established on the premises a manufactory of arms for the rebel government, and [p. 761] continued the business until the occupation of the city by the national forces in the spring of 1862.
On the 8th of October, 1861, the Union Insurance Company of New Orleans took a mortgage from Burthe upon three undivided twenty-fifths of the property to secure the payment of a note for $3500, due from him to the company.
Subsequently, suit was instituted upon the mortgage, and in due course a decree of sale was rendered, under which the insurance company became purchasers of the mortgaged premises for $1400, and on the 26th of February, 1864, received the sheriff’s deed of the property.
In April, 1864, the company obtained a judgment for $2735, being the balance due on the note of Burthe, and was about to sell the residue of the property, when further proceeding was arrested by a military order.
It appeared further from the evidence that three minors of the Burthe family were legal owners of four thirty-sixths of the property on which the gun factory was established.
The Cooks, to whom Burthe made the lease, were well-known manufacturers of arms on a large scale for the rebel government, and the lease stated the fact that they intended to establish in the property leased “ engines, machinery,” &c.
At the time, however, when the insurance company took its mortgage, the Cooks had not taken possession of the property, nor was it proved otherwise than as the mere taking of the mortgage proved it, that the company had consented to the use which the Cooks meant to make of the premises.
On the 4th of April, 1865, the District Attorney for the Eastern District of Louisiana, filed in the Circuit Court of the United States for that district, a libel of information against the property thus leased. The libel described the case as one of seizure and forfeiture, and after reciting the already mentioned act of Congress of August 6th, 1861, which declared the property of all persons who should knowingly use or employ it, or consent to the use and employment of it in aid of the rebellion, to be lawful subject of prize and capture, proceeded to allege that the property leased had been [p. 762] so used and employed, and asked a decree for its condemnation and forfeiture to the use of the United States and the informant.
Upon the filing of this libel, notice was given, monition was published, claims were interposed, and testimony was taken in general conformity with the practice of courts of admiralty.
The Circuit Court condemned the whole property as forfeited to the United States, except the four thirty-sixths, called in the decree four twenty-fifths, of the minors.
An appeal was taken by the Union Insurance Company, and another claimant, who abandoned the prosecution of his appeal. Ko appeal was taken by the United States from that part of the decree which exempted the interests of the minors from condemnation.
Three points were made in this court on the appeal:
1. That the Circuit Court had no jurisdiction under the act of 1861; that the proceedings were in admiralty form throughout,—a form dispensing with jury; that the Constitution securing to the citizen trial by jury, Congress had no power to convert into a “ case in admiralty,” and so to bring into admiralty jurisdiction, eases which were not admiralty cases, and were not liable to be brought within that jurisdiction when the Constitution was made, and that such a purpose was not to be presumed; that it was impossible to regard the proceeding in this case—one against real estate in the midst of a great city, and under a statute of municipal forfeiture—as an “ admiralty case,” in any true definition of those terms.
2. That the proceeding should have been by the course of the common law, and with a jury, when the decree of the court below would have come up by writ of error, which form of bringing the matter here, and not appeal, was the proper form.
3. That on the merits the decree was wrong.
Mr. Durant, for the appellants; Mr. Stanbery,A. Gr., and Mr. Ashton, special counsel of the United States, contra.
The CHIEF JUSTICE delivered the opinion of the court. The first questions in this cause relate to jurisdiction.
It was urged in argument, that the act of Congress does not authorize the proceedings instituted in the Circuit Court.
The answer to this proposition must be determined by the construction of the act.
It is sufficiently obvious that the general object of the enactment was to promote the suppression of rebellion by subjecting property employed in aid of it with the owner’s consent, to confiscation. It extended to all descriptions of property, real or personal, on land or on water. All alike were made subjects of prize and capture, and, under the direction of the President, of seizure, confiscation, and condemnation.
The act must be construed with reference to this general purpose. In ordinary use the words “prizes and capture” refer, doubtless, to captures on water as maritime prize; but in the section under consideration here they plainly refer to property taken on land as well as on water, and the duties prescribed to the President include the taking of this property by civil process as well as by naval or military force, and sanction proceedings for confiscation and condemnation in civil courts without regard to the mode of seizure.
The second and third sections of the statute prescribe the action to be taken in the courts. This action is described, generally, in the third section, as “ proceedings for condemnation,” to be instituted by the attorney-general, or any district attorney. And jurisdiction of these “proceedings” is given to the District or Circuit Court having jurisdiction of the amount, or in admiralty, in any district where the property is seized or into which it may be taken.
This language is certainly not clear. But we think that the construction which, as we understand, has been generally adopted in the District and Circuit Courts in cases of proceedings for the condemnation of real estate or property on land, is substantially correct. That construction treats the grant of jurisdiction in admiralty as a grant of jurisdiction of the “ proceedings of condemnation” to the Circuit or [p. 764] District Court according to the amount in suit; with power to both courts to shape those “ proceedings ” in general conformity to the practice in admiralty.
Such proceedings do not necessarily constitute a cause in admiralty. When instituted for condemnation of property on land, they have relation exclusively to matters which, in their nature, are not of admiralty cognizance. But Congress may, doubtless, give jurisdiction of such proceedings to the Circuit as well as to the District Courts, and may authorize the exercise of this statutory jurisdiction in the form and modes analogous to those used in admiralty. And this, we think, was the purpose of the act.
The difficulty of construction arises from the terms in which jurisdiction is granted “ to any District or Circuit Court having jurisdiction of the amount, or in admiralty, in any district where the property is found.” It is said that the use of the disjunctive “ or” restricts the jurisdiction in admiralty to the District Courts. And this view is certainly not without some warrant in the phraseology of the act. But when we look beyond the mere words to the obvious intent we cannot help seeing that the word “or” must be taken conjunctively; and that the sense of the law is’that both the Circuit and the District Courts shall have jurisdiction “ according to the amount” and “ in admiralty.”
This construction impairs no rights of parties. In cases of seizures on land the right of trial by jury is not infringed. In such cases the proceeding must be in general conformity to the course in admiralty; but issues of fact, on the demand of either party, must be tried by jury.* Where the seizure is made on navigable waters, the course of admiralty may be strictly observed.
That this construction carries into effect the true intention of Congress sufficiently appears on reference to the act of July 17th, 1862,j" in which it is provided expressly that proceedings for confiscation shall conform as nearly as may be to proceedings in admiralty or revenue cases.
t 12 Stat, at Large, 591, § 7.
* The Sarah, 8 Wheaton, 394.
We think, therefore, that the Circuit Court had jurisdiction of the cause.
It remains to be considered whether the decree of the court can be reviewed here on appeal. Ko appeal is expressly provided by the act of 1861. The Constitution, however, gives to this court appellate jurisdiction in all cases of which the inferior courts of the United States have original jurisdiction, subject to such exceptions and regulations as Congress shall make; and the act of 1803* provides, generally, for appeals from decisions in admiralty. Some of the judges think it a reasonable construction of the act that it was not intended to except decrees under it from the appellate jurisdiction of this court; but that it was intended to apply to them the general regulations of admiralty proceedings in respect to appellate as well as to original jurisdiction; while a majority of the court is of opinion that appellate jurisdiction may be taken of the cause, because the proceedings below, though in a case of common law jurisdiction, were substantially according to the course in admiralty; but only for the purpose of reversing the decree of the Circuit Court as irregular, and directing a new trial.f We proceed then to the questions arising upon the merits.
There is no reasonable doubt that the Cooks established their manufactory of arms on the ground leased by him to them with the full knowledge and consent of Leonce Burthe. It thus became within the express terms of the act the lawful subject of prize and capture from the time of that establishment.
The evidence in respect to the rights of the insurance company is not so clear. To the extent of the interest created by the mortgage the company may, doubtless, be properly regarded as owner. But there is no direct proof of consent to the unlawful use; and, indeed, no proof at all, except the fact of taking the mortgage, and it does not appear that the Cooks had taken possession under their lease
* 2 Stat, at Large, 244. f The Sarah, 8 Wheaton, 891. [p. 766] before the execution of the mortgage. We do not think this evidence of consent sufficient to support a forfeiture.
The counsel for the company very properly abandoned any claim under the judgment recovered for the balance due on the mortgage note. The forfeiture was incurred when the Cooks went into actual use of the premises under the lease, and the subsequent seizure for condemnation divested all intermediate liens.
The decree of the Circuit Court must be reversed as irregular, and the cause remanded for new trial in conformity with this opinion. The property seized having been real estate, the proceedings on the new trial must be conformed in respect to trial by jury and exceptions to evidence to the course of proceeding by information on the common law side of the court in cases of seizure upon land.*
Armstrong’s Foundry.
1. A full pardon and amnesty by the President for all offences committed by the owner of property seized under the act of Congress of August 6th, 1861, “ to confiscate property used for insurrectionary purposes,” and which makes property used in aid of the rebellion, with the consent of the owner, subject to seizure, confiscation, and condemnation, relieves such owner from the forfeiture of the property seized so far as the right accrues to the United States. 2. The proceedings under the act relating to a seizure of land, present a case of common law jurisdiction, the proceedings in which are to be conformed, in respect to trial by jury and exceptions to evidence, to the course of the common law, and a final decision in which can be reviewed here only on writ of error.
Appeal from the Circuit Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana, the proceeding below being one for condemnation of property as used in aid of the rebellion, and resembling in its general features the case just disposed of. It was thus:
An act of Congress passed August 6th, 1861, “to [p. 767] confiscate property used for insurrectionary purposes,”* enacted that property used in aid of the rebellion with consent of the owner, should be the lawful subject of prize and capture wherever found, and made it the duty of the President to cause it “ to be seized, confiscated, and condemned.” It enacted further that “ such prizes and captures shall be condemned in the District or Circuit Court of the United States having jurisdiction of the amount, or in admiralty in any district in which they may be seized, or into which they may be taken,” &c. And the attorney-general or any district attorney was to institute proceedings of condemnation himself, or by aid of an informer.
Under this act a libel of information was filed in the Circuit Court of the United States for the Eastern District of Louisiana, in which it was charged that certain property in New Orleans, known as Armstrong’s Foundry, had been seized as forfeited to the United States by reason of having been used, with the consent of the owner, in aid of the rebellion. This libel closed with the usual prayer for condemnation. A claim was interposed by John Armstrong as owner, and another claim was interposed by the Citizens’ Bank as mortgagee. Armstrong also pleaded the amnesty offered by President Lincoln, and his acceptance of it and compliance with the terms. On the hearing the plea of pardon was rejected, and a decree of condemnation was rendered. Armstrong alone appealed.
Subsequently, and while the cause was pending in this court, the President of the United States granted to “ the said John Armstrong a full pardon and amnesty for all offences by him committed, arising from participation, direct or implied, in the said rebellion, conditioned as follows.” Certain conditions were annexed. At this term Armstrong was allowed, in conformity with the usual course in admiralty cases, to plead the new matter, and to file with his plea a statement of facts agreed between his counsel and the Attorney-General, showing, among other things, that he had complied with all thè conditions of the pardon granted to him.
* 12 Stat, at Large, 319.
Argument for condemnation.
The question now on the appeal was, whether this pardon relieved from forfeiture the property seized.
Mr. Stanbery, Attorney-General, and Mr. Ashton, special counsel for the United States:
1. “A pardon,” this court declared in Ex parte Garland,* “ reaches both the punishment prescribed for the offence and the guilt of the offender; and when the pardon is full, it releases the punishment, and blots out of existence the guilt, so that in the eye of the law the offender is as innocent as if he had never committed the offence. The effect of this pardon, then, is to relieve the petitioner from all penalties and disabilities attached to the offence of treason committed by his participation in the rebellion.” But this is the extent of a pardon. It cannot reach a forfeiture of property imposed, in virtue of the unlawful predicament in which the property may be found.
Now, the act of August 6th, 1861, does not affect property with liability to condemnation as a punishment for any offence of the owners, but as a means of suppressing the insurrection, then flagrant, by depriving those engaged therein of property subject to their control, and dedicated to their uses. The property is made the “lawful subject of prize and capture wherever found.” These words draw the property in question within the category of enemy property, and establish a rule of capture.
2. But however affecting the interest of the United States, it cannot operate to remit the moiety which accrues to the informer. He has acquired a property in his part of the penalty, f
3. Under a statute of municipal forfeiture, such as this, proceedings for the condemnation of property seized on land, without the admiralty and maritime jurisdiction of the United States, are, ex necessitate rei, according to the course
* 4 Wallace, 380. , n-f 4 Blackstone’s Commentaries, 309; 2 Hawkins, 6, 392; Oomyn s i gest, Pardon, F.
of the common law.* If reversed, the proceedings should follow that course.
Mr. Humphrey Marshall, contra.
The CHIEF JUSTICE delivered the opinion of the court.
Upon the case presented, it is necessary to consider a single question only.
It was insisted, in argument, that the pardon pleaded by the appellant cannot avail to relieve him from the forfeiture of the property seized, because the liability to seizure arose, under the statute, from the mode in which the property was employed, and was not to be regarded as a penal consequence of the act of the owner.
We are unable to conchr in this view. We think it clear that the statute regarded the consent of the owner to the employment of his property in aid of the rebellion as an offence, and inflicted forfeiture as a penalty. The general pardon of Armstrong, therefore, relieved him of so much of the penalty as accrued to the United States. We think it unnecessary to express any opinion at present in relation to the rights of the informer.
The proceedings below related to a seizure of land, and though conducted under the statute in the forms of admiralty, must be regarded as a case of common law jurisdiction, a final decision in which can be reviewed here only on writ of error
The decree of the Circuit Court, therefore, must be re - versed as irregular, and the cause remanded, with directions to allow a new trial, the proceedings in which shall be conformed, in respect to trial by jury and exceptions to evidence, to the course of the common law.
Mr. Justice MILLER dissented.
* 1 Kent’s Commentaries, 376; La Vengeance, 3 Dallas, 297; United States v. Sally, 2 Cranch, 406; United States v. Betsy, 4 Id. 443; The Samuel, 1 Wheaton 9; The Octavia, Id. 20; The Sarah, 8 Id. 391.
vol. vi. 49
Note.
At the same time with the two preceding cases was decided, on appeal from the same circuit (Jfr. Durant, for the appellant), the case of St. Louis Street Foundry; not distinguishable,—as the Chief Justice stated was the opinion of the court,—in principle from them.
It appeared in it that Cronan, in the Circuit Court, pleaded the amnesty proclaimed by President Lincoln on the 8th of December, 1863, and the oath taken by himself in pursuance of the proclamation; but there was no averment in this plea that Cronan was not within any of certain exceptions made by that proclamation.*
The CHIEF JUSTICE delivered the opinion.
The plea was properly overruled.
Upon proper pleading and proof, however, the claimant of property seized under the act of August 6th, 1861, is entitled to the benefit of amnesty to the same extent as, under like pleading and proof, he would be entitled to the benefit of pardon.
The decree of the Circuit Court must be reversed as irregular, and the cause remanded, with directions to allow a new trial, the proceedings in which shall be conformed, in respect to trial by jury and exceptions to evidence, to the course of the common law.
*
See the Gray Jacket, 5 Wallace, 368.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access