Case details
Bluebook Citation
Mason v. Gamble, 62 U.S. (21 How.) 390
Full caption
John T. Mason, Plaintiff in Error, v. Joseph C. Gamble and David Gamble.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
John T. Mason, Plaintiff in Error, v. Joseph C. Gamble and David Gamble.
The act of Congress passed on the 3d of May, 1844, (5 Stat, at L., 658,) author izes a writ of error, at the instance of either party, upon a final judgment in a Circuit Court in any civil action brought by the United States for the enforce ment of the revenue laws, or for the collection of duties due or alleged to be due, without regard to the sum or value in controversy.
But this law does not include a case where an action was brought against the collector for the return of duties paid under protest, and where the recovery was for a less sum than two thousand dollars. Such a case must be dismissed for want of jurisdiction.
This case was brought up by writ of error from the Circuit Court of the United States for the district of Maryland.
The case is stated in the opinion of the court.
A motion was made by Mr. Campbell to dismiss the writ of error for want of jurisdiction, which was opposed by Mr. Black, (Attorney General.)
Mr. Chief Justice TANEY delivered the opinion of the court.
A motion has been made to dismiss this case for want of ju risdiction, upon the ground that the sum in dispute does not exceed $2,000.
The case is this: The plaintiff in error is the collector of the port of Baltimore, and, as such, demanded a certain amount of duties on goods imported by the defendants in error, which they believed was greater, than the amount imposed by law.
Richmond n. City of Milwaukie.
The duties demanded were paid under protest, and this suit was brought to recover back the amount alleged to be over paid. At the trial, the jury, under the instruction of the court, found a verdict in favor of the defendants in error for the sum of $193.88, upon which a judgment was entered against the collector; and this writ of error is brought on that judgment.
The act of Congress which is supposed to give jurisdiction in cases of this description is the act of May 31st, 1844, (5 Stat., 658.) This act authorizes a writ of error, at the instance of either party, upon a final judgment in a Circuit Court in any civil action brought by the United States for the enforce ment of the revenue laws, or for the collection of duties due or alleged to be due, without regard to the sum or value in con troversy. And it is true, that the same reasons which induced the Legislature to give the writ of error in the cases mention ed in the law, apply with equal force to suits against a collect or to recover back duties which he alleged to be due, and had already collected. The questions are of the same character, and the interests of the United States the same in either case.’ And it is most probable that suits against the collecter were omitted in the act of Congress by some oversight or accident.
But, however that may be, the writ of error is authorized in those cases only in which the United States are plaintiffs in the suit. The language of the law is too plain to admit of doubt, and the words cannot by any reasonable or fair con struction be extended to suits brought by the importer against the collector; and as the sum or value in controversy does not exceed $2,000, and the case is not provided for by the act of Congress referred to, the writ must be dismissed for want of jurisdiction in this court.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access