Lindo v. Gardner, 5 U.S. (1 Cranch) 343 (1803)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Lindo v. Gardner, 5 U.S. (1 Cranch) 343 (1803)
Full caption
Lindo v. Gardner.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1803
Lindo v. Gardner.
Action of debt on promissory note.
Debt will not lie, in Maryland, upon a promissory note. Queers? Whether the statute of limitations can be given in evidence, on nil debet?1
This was an action of debt brought by the administrators of Archibald Gardner against Abraham Lindo, upon a promissory note, in the Circuit Court of the district of Columbia, sitting in Washington. The act of congress respecting the district of Columbia had adopted the laws of Maryland as the law of this part of the district. In Maryland, the statute of 3 & 4 Anne, c. 9, respecting promissory notes, had been “ introduced, used and practised by the courts of law,” and thereby, and *by virtue of the . declaration of rights, section 3d, it became the law of the land; and *- the courts of Maryland, in their construction of that statute, had always respected the adjudications of the English courts. In the court below, there was a verdict and judgment for the plaintiffs; to reverse which judgment, the defendant sued out the present writ of error.
The declaration was, “of a plea that he render to them $336.97, money of account of the United States of America, for that the defendant, on the 5th of October 1795, at, &c., by his certain note in writing, of that date, subscribed with his proper manuscription, and now here shown to the court, acknowledged himself to owe to Archibald Gardner the said sum of $336.97, which the said defendant promised to pay the said Gardner, and to the order of the said Gardner, at sixty days after the date of the said note in writing, it being in consideration of value received.” It then averred the non-payment, &c., and made &profert of the letters of administration, which were averred to be “ in due form.”
The defendant in the court below pleaded nil debet; and after verdict against him, moved in arrest of judgment, because, 1. An action of debt cannot be maintained upon the promissory note set forth in the declaration. 2. It does not appear that the plaintiffs had obtained such letters of administration, as to entitle them to maintain an action upon the said note. 3. The declaration is in the debet and detinet, and ought to be in the detinet only, (a)
There was also a bill of exceptions stating the refusal of the court to suffer the defendant to give the statute of limitations in evidence on the plea of nil debet. The note was in these words :
(a) The capias, which, in Maryland, is considered as part of the record, was in the detinet only. The declaration was in neither the debet nor detinet, having omitted those words altogether.
1
Every statute of limitation must be specially pleaded, unless it be otherwise provided. Heath v. Page, 48 Penn. St. 130.
Hodgson v. Dexter
“Philadelphia, October 5, 1796.
At sixty days, I promise to pay to the order *of Mr. Archibald, Gardner, three hundred and thirty-six dollars and ninety-seven cents value received. i A. Lindo.”
Peacock, for the plaintiff in error, was about to produce authorities on the first point, when he was stopped by Chase, J., who said, that an action of debt will not lie, in Maryland, upon a promissory note.1
No opposition being made on the part of the defendant in error, judgment was afterwards reversed, without argument, (a)