Conrad v. Griffey, 57 U.S. (16 How.) 38
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Conrad v. Griffey, 57 U.S. (16 How.) 38
Full caption
Frederic D. Conrad, Plaintiff in error, v. David Griffey.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Frederic D. Conrad, Plaintiff in error, v. David Griffey.
t'ff ^80, it is said, “ Where a witness was examined for the plaini, and the defendant offered in evidence declarations which he had made a contradictory character, and then the plaintiff offered to give in evice others, affirmatory of the first, these last afflrmatory declarations re not admissible, being made at a time posterior to that at which he made Thp e..C°nJ.ra • tOr^ declarations given in evidence by the defendant.”1
no Cas5 havmg been remanded to the Circuit Court under a venire facias de unde e P gave in evidence, upon the new trial, the deposition taken snhiJ r®cent commission, of the same witness whose deposition was the aivp in ° • i e f°rmer *examination, when the defendant offered to r*oo formpr fV- i nCe th6 same affirmatory declarations which upon the t rial were offered as rebutting evidence by the plaintiff.
169C°Atrta’ ?rookb^nk v. State, 55 Ind.,
Herrick v. Smith, 13 Hun (N. Y446.
mav i2nterior consistent statements
N C ™F0oed- State v. Larton, 78 Hayes v. Cheatham, 6 Lea (Tenn.), 1;
Where 21 Kan” 54- and in such a case the party calling witness on 8 S0Ught to discredit a the witness may sustain him by proof ests at thp « e groun.d that his inter- of general good character for truth. prompted h?”6 ?1S evidence was given
memTe m8V fii make a false 'tate-
v. Pilcher, 28 Gratt. (Va.), 299; Haley
Conrad v. Griffey.
The object of the defendant being to discredit and contradict the deposition of the witness taken under the recent commission, the evidence was not admissible. He should have been interrogated respecting the statements, when he was examined under the commission.2 If his declaration had been made subsequent to the. commission, a new commission should have been sued out, whether his declarations had been written or verbal.
This case was brought up by writ of error, from the Circuit Court of the United States for the Eastern District of Louisiana.
It was before this court at December term, 1850, and is reported in 11 How., 480.
In order to give a clear idea of the point now brought up for decision, it may be necessary to remind the reader of some of the circumstances of that case.
Griffey was a builder of steam-engines, in Cincinnati, and made a contract with Conrad, a sugar planter, in Louisiana, to put up an engine upon his plantation for a certain sum. Disputes having arisen upon the subject, Griffey brought his action against Conrad to recover the amount claimed to be due.
Upon the trial, in 1849, the testimony of Leonard N. Nutz, taken under a commission, was given in evidence. He was the engineer who was sent by Griffey to erect and work the machine. The deposition was taken on the 1st April, 1847. This evidence being in favor of Griffey, the counsel for Conrad offered the depositions of three persons to contradict the evidence of Nutz. Griffey then produced, as rebutting evidence, a letter written by Nutz to him, under date of April
2 A foundation for the impeachment Id., 82; State v. Glynn, 51 Vt., 577; must always be laid by asking the State v. McDonald, 8 Oreg., 113; Hart
v. Hudson River Bridge Co., 84 N. Y.,
witness whether he made the statements. Howland v. Conway, 1 Abb. 56; Thompson v. Territory, 1 Wash. 1., U. S, 281; Many v. Jagger, 1 Blatchf,n. s., 547; McKinney v. State, 8 rex.
App, 626; Griffith v. State, 37 Ark.,
324', 329, 330. If the alleged ialse
statement is in writing, the writing
East River Nat. Bank, 2 Sweeny
must be shown to the witness. Cava-
(N. Y.), 82; State v. Collins, 32 Iowa,
State, 8 Tex. App., 75; and if a part
of it is claimed to be false or cont
Weigant, 5 Bradw. (Ill.), 643; Peck v.
dictory, the remainder may be read to
corroborate the witness. State v. zi
bert, 73 Mo., 347. Where the witness
Ann., 407; Yauke v. State, 51 Wis.,
sought to be thus impeached is a party
464.
to the suit, his attention need not be
It is also necessary to ask him as
called to time, place, &c., as is ne
to the time, place, and person to whom
sary with an ordinary witness Col
the statements were made. Spaun-
Uns v. Mack, 31 Ark, 684, Ecker v
Bomberger, 80 Pa. St., 59.
Iowa, 294; State v. McLaughlin, 44
Conrad v. Griffey.
3,1846, which was admitted by the court below, and the propriety of which admission was the point brought before this court in 11 Howard. This court having decided that the letter ought not to have been received in evidence, the cause was remanded under an order to award a venire facias de novo.
Before the cause came on again for trial, Griffey took the testimony of Nutz again under a commission, on the 28th of June, 1852, when the following proceedings were had, and bill of exceptions taken.
Be it known, that on the trial of this cause, the plaintiff
having read in evidence the deposition of Leonard N. Nutz,
taken under commission on the 28th June, 1852, and filed on
the 9th July, 1852, the defendant then offered in evidence a
letter of Leonard N. Nutz, dated at New Albany, on the 3d
April, 1846, with an affidavit annexed by said Nutz of the
same date, all addressed to the plaintiff in this cause; and as
preliminary proof to the introduction of said letter, the de-
fendant adduced the bill of exceptions *signed upon a
former trial of this cause, and filed on the 23d Febru- •-
ary, 1849, and the indorsement of the clerk upon said letter
of its being filed, showing that said letter had been produced
by the plaintiff in said former trial, and read by his counsel
in evidence as the letter of said Nutz in support of a former
deposition of the same witness. And the said letter and affi-
davit were offered by said defendant to contradict and dis-
credit the deposition of said witness taken on the said 28th
thoh’ 1$$$’ but upon objection of counsel for the plaintiff
at the said witness had not been cross-examined in refer-
ence to the writing of said letter, or allowed an opportunity
° explaining the same, and that upon the former trial the
counsel for defendant had objected to the same document as
e\i ence, (and the objection had been sustained by the Su-
^•e!ne, ,ou!^ the United States,) the court sustained the ^ objections, and refused to allow the said letter and affij 'I1 .ani}exe^ t° be read in evidence; to which ruling the
• fen an^ tdkes this bill of exceptions, and prays that the
answers of said Nutz, taken on the said
th qj UA* e’the said letter and affidavit annexed, of date
thp co wjth the indorsement of the clerk of filing
arv 184q ’ excepfi°ns filed on the 23d Febru-
exppnGnJ e i ^a^en an(i deemed as a part of this bill of
exceptions and copied therewith accordingly.
Theo. H. McCaleb, U. 8. Judge. [seal.]
P this exception, the case came up again to this court.
Conrad v. Griffey.
It was argued by J£r. Benjamin, for the plaintiff in error, and by J/r. (xilbert, for the defendant in error.
Mr. Benjamin, for plaintiff in error.
From this bill of exceptions, it appears that the defendant in error, who was plaintiff in the cause below, offered in support of his case the testimony of Leonard N. Nutz, taken in St. Louis, on the 18th June, 1852, under a commission issued by the Circuit Court on the 5th of the same month. This testimony is found at p. 14 of the reCord.
After the testimony of Nutz had been read, the defendant offered in evidence a letter of Nutz, dated 3d April, 1846, with his affidavit of the truth of the statements contained in the letter, in order, as stated in the bill of exceptions, “to contradict and discredit his deposition taken on the 28th June, 1852.”
The evidence thus offered by defendant, was rejected on two grounds: 1st. That “ the witness had not been cross-examined in reference to the writing of said letter, or allowed an opportunity of explaining the same ”; and 2d. That “ upon the former trial, the counsel for defendant had objected *411 the same *document as evidence, and that the ob-
J jection had been sustained by the Supreme Court of the United States.”
On the first ground, the objection to the evidence proceeds on a misapprehension of a rule of practice in relation to the cross-examination of a witness. The rule and its reason are so clearly set forth in 1 Greenl. on Ev., § 462 (6th ed.), and the authorities there cited, that comment on it is unnecessary. The witness was not under cross-examination; his testimony was not taken in court in the presence of the parties where i was possible to give him an opportunity of explanation, was impossible for the defendant, in New Orleans, to know in advance what answers the witness would make in St. oui to the questions propounded to him ; and when those were read on the trial, it was perfectly legitimate to o er former written and sworn statements of the witness on subject-matter, to contradict and discredit his la er s
On the second ground, it is sufficient to say that eviden. is frequently admissible against a party that he is no a to offer in his own favor; that it is frequently a mi- . one period of the trial, when not admissible at ano it is frequently admissible for one^ purpose, when no ble for another; and that the decision of the> bup pstion in 11 Howard, did not determine that the evidence q
Conrad v. Griffey.
was totally inadmissible for any purpose by either party, at any time, but only that it was not admissible for the plaintiff in the cause for the purpose for which he offered it. An array of authorities in support of these elementary principles of the law of evidence, would be deemed disrespectful to the court.
Jfr. Gilbert, for defendant in error, made the following points:
First. To authorize proof of previous acts or declarations of a witness, for the purpose of invalidating his testimony, the witness must, previous to the introduction of such evidence, be examined as to the matter. The attention of the witness, Nutz, not having been called to the letter offered in evidence, and no opportunity allowed to explain what he intended by it, such letter was inadmissible in evidence to discredit him.
A witness should always be allowed to explain what he has said or done concerning the matter under investigation, otherwise his reputation might suffer wrongfully. If his attention is not called, by cross-examination, to the supposed contradiction, he will have no opportunity to explain seeming contradictions, or errors, by making more full statements, or showing the connection of things, or defining his meaning of expressions and the terms he may have used. No man always conveys his ideas in the same language. Many, even of the most learned, fail to *express themselves clearly and [-*49 properly. In such case, a few explanatory words may *- reconcile seeming contradictions. It would be unjust that e party should suffer where he has no means of giving an explanation, which may be most ample; and cruel to a witness to discredit him, thereby injuring his character, without a owing him an opportunity to show that he has committed no ault. .Hence the rule that contradictory statements and C-J ° an lncoijsistent character cannot be given in evidence, 1 out preparing the way for its admission by cross-exam in-as supposed contradictory statements. np 1 T?? ?V’’ P’ says: “Thus it appears that a wittnrv to regularly cross-examined as to the contradicformo a eme.n^s supposed to have been made by him on a admii-f ^c?asi°u, before such contradictory statements can be And th' in1eY<^erJce to impeach the credit of his testimony, torv Rtat TU 6 x 1 been extended not only to such contradicand nota^11611 iS’ b,11? a^so to other declarations of the witness, words ” °ne by hlm through the medium of declarations or
scoe, Crim. Ev., p. 182, says: “But in order to let in
Conrad v. Griffey.
this evidence, in contradiction, a ground must be laid for it in the cross-examination of the witness who is to be contradicted. When a witness has been examined as to particular transactions, if the other side were permitted to give in evidence declarations made by him respecting those transactions at variance with his testimony, without first calling the attention of the witness to those declarations, and refreshing his memory w’ith regard to them, it would, as has been observed, have an unfair effect upon his credit.”
In the Queen’s case, 2 Brod. & B., 312, (6 Com. Law, 130, 131,) Abbott, C. J., said: “ If the witness admits the words or declarations imputed to him, the proof on the other side becomes unnecessary ; and the witness has an opportunity of giving such reason, explanation, or exculpation of his conduct, if any there may be, as the particular transaction may happen to furnish.”
In Angus v. Smith, 1 Moo. & M., 473, (22 Com. Law, 360,) Tindal, C. J., said : “I understand the rule to be, that before you can contradict a witness by showing that he has at some other time said something inconsistent with this present evidence, you must ask him as to the time, place, and person involved in the supposed contradiction.” Cowen & Hills Notes, 774, 775; Williams v. Turner, 7 Ga., 348; Doc v. Reagan, 5 Blackf. (Ind.), 217; Johnson v. Kinsey, 7 Ga., 428; Franklin Bank v. Steam Nav. Co., 11 Gill & J. (Md.), 28, Palmer v. Haight, 2 Barb. (N. ¥.), 210, 213; McKinney v. *.0-1 Neil, 1 McLean, *R., 540; Moore v. Battis, 11 Humph.
-* (Tenn.), 67; The United States v. Dickinson, 2 McLean, 325; Chapin n. Siger, 4 McLean, 378, 381; Wienzorpflm n. State, 7 Blackf. (Ind.), 186; Check n. Wheatley, 11 Humph. (Tenn.), 556 ; Beebe v. DeBaun, 3 Eng. R., 510; McAteerV' McMulen. 2 Barb. (N. Y.), 32; Clementine v. State U Mo. 112; Regnier v. Cabot, 2 Gilm. (Ill.), 34; King v. Wicks, M Ohio, 87. ,
The rule is the same whether the evidence offered by way of contradiction rests in parol, or is in writing. In Roscoe Crim. Ev., p. 182, he says: “So, what has been said ten by a witness at a previous time maybe given in evi e to contradict what he has said on the trial, if it rela e ° matter in issue.” . . . “But in order to let in this evidence in contradiction, a ground must be laid for *n * c,cr b amination of the witness who is to be contradicte.
3 Stark. Ev., 1740, 1741. “Where the question is so nected with the point in issue that the witness may tradicted by other evidence, if he deny the facL e., jn requires that the question should be put to e
Conrad v. Griffey.
order to afford him an opportunity for explanation, although the answer may involve him in consequences highly penal.” Same, p. 1753, 1754. The Queen’s case, 2 Brod. & B., 284, (6 Eng. Com. L., p. 112,) proceeds throughout upon this principle.
Green., vol. 1, p. 579, in relation to laying a foundation by cross-examination, before offering contradictory evidence, says: “This course of proceeding is considered indispensable, from a sense of justice to the witness; for as the direct tendency of the evidence is to impeach his veracity, common justice requires that by first calling his attention to the subject he should have an opportunity to recollect the facts, and, if necessary, to correct the statement already given, as well as by a reexamination to explain the nature, circumstances, meaning, and design of what he has proved elsewhere to have said. And this rule is extended, not only to contradictory statements by the witness, but to other declarations, and to acts done by him through the medium of verbal communications, or correspondence, which are offered with a view either to contradict his testimony in chief, or to prove him a corrupt witness himself, or to have been guilty of attempting to corrupt others.”
In Carpenter v. Wall, 11 Adol. & E., 803, (39 Eng. Com.
Penman, C. J., the other judges concurring, said:
When words are to be proved as having been uttered by a witness, it is always expected that he shall have an opportunity to explain.” Regina N. St. George, 9 Car. & P., 483, (38 Eng. Com. L., 198) : Johnson v. Todd, 5 Beav., 600, 602, cited
1 Greenl. on Ev., p. 579, in note beginning at the . bottom of the page, where it is said the rule in the L 44 yueen s case is adopted in the United States, except in Mame and Massachusetts, and cites 2 Cowen & Hill’s notes on Phil. Ev., p. 774.
Jenkins v. Eldridge, 2 Story, 181, 284, Story, J. says: “If one party should keep back evidence which the other might p am, and thereby take him by surprise, the court will give bp i tUch evidence, without first giving the party to co e° u an °PPoltunity of controverting it. This fine i a one in cases where otherwise gross injustice may be done.” 6
v. Car. & P., 789 (32 Com. Law, 737). wri finer neSS rna(^e a previous contradictory statement, in
on a 1Pa^.er relevant to the issue, he may be asked,
his hand Jta^lnat10n\ wither the paper containing it is in
1 mg; and if he admit it, that will entitle the
Conrad v. Griffey.
other side to read it; and if he contradicts the evidence of the witness, he may be called back to explain it.” 4 Har. Dig., 2948, No. 11.*
Yeos v. The State, 9 Ark., 42. “Where a witness has made a different statement from the one made by him on the trial, he is not thereby discredited, unless the discrepancy is wilful.”
Story v. Saunders, 8 Humph. (Tenn.), 663. “When the deposition of a witness is taken, evidence of his having made contradictory statements are not admissible to impeach his testimony, unless an opportunity to explain had been first offered him.”
The contradictory statement offered in this case was the witness’s testimony on a previous trial.
In Everson v. Carpenter, 17 Wend. (N. Y.), 419, referring to the requisites for admitting a written instrument by way of contradiction, Cowen, J., said: “ It was introduced, with the proper preliminary question to the witness, whether he had made the indenture and the representation about to be imputed to him. He answered with such explanations as occurred to him. Here was all the precaution required by this kind of examination by the Queen's case and others.
In Kimball v. Davis, 19 Wend. (N. Y.), 437, Nelson, C. J., considered this question at length, in a case where the defendant offered to prove that witnesses who had been examined under a commission, had subsequently made statements contradicting their written testimony. The marginal note of this decision is in these words :
“ The declarations of witnesses whose testimony has been taken under a commission, made subsequent to the taking o their testimony, contradicting or invalidating their testimony as Contained in the depositions, is inadmissible in evi
-* deuce, if objected to ; the only way for the party 0 avail himself of such declarations, is to sue out a second com mission ; such evidence is always inadmissible until the wi ness whose testimony is thus sought to be impeache, a been examined upon the point, and his attention paiticu ai y directed to the circumstances of the transaction, so as to nish him an opportunity for explanation or exculpation.
This case went to the Court of Errors, and is repor e the 25th of Wend. (N. Y.), 259, where it was affirmed, vva worth, Chancellor, there said : “ I concur with the up Court in the opinion that it was improper to give ,ie tions of the witnesses in evidence without giving ,elH’ first place, an opportunity to explain ; and the ac _ witnesses had been examined under a commission i
Conrad v. Griffey.
vent the operation of the principle upon which the rule is founded.”
Edwards, Senator, said he was satisfied with Chief Justice Nelson’s reasoning on this question.
Howell v. Reynolds, 12 Ala., 128. “ The rule that a witness cannot be contradicted by proof of previous counter declarations, either written or verbal, applies to testimony taken by deposition, and if such supposed contradictory declarations exist at the time the deposition is taken, the witness, must have an opportunity afforded him of explaining it, if in his power. “ The reason of the rule is, that he may have it in his power to explain the apparent contradiction, and the rule is the same, whether the declaration of the witness supposed to contradict his testimony be written or verbal.” 3 Stark. Ev., 1741. “ The question is usually made when the witnesses are examined orally in open court, and in our opinion it must also apply to testimony taken by deposition, as the deposition is a mere substitute for the witness ; and we can perceive no reason why a witness testifying in this should not be entitled to the same protection as if he had testified orally, in the presence of the court and jury. If this paper existed when the plaintiff was notified that the deposition of the witness was to be taken, and was informed by the interrogatories of the testimony the witness was expected to give, it was his uty to give him an opportunity of explaining it, if he could, an reconciling it with the evidence he then gave, if there was any real or apparent contradiction between them.”
Tk* dus^ce McLEAN delivered the opinion of the Court.
is is a writ of error to the Circuit Court of the United states, tor the Eastern District of Louisiana.
18 a^i°n was brought to recover the balance of three
10u^d seven hundred and eighty-one dollars and p \ cents, claimed to be due under a contract to *- anf118 V lveF’an(l set up, on the plantation of the defend-mill 1? -i e Par}sh M Baton Rouge, a steam-engine and sugarsarv er8’ w^ee\8’ cane carriers, and all other things neces-
Tbp^r uSar"miL ; all which articles were duly delivered, defence ° endan^ *n answer set up several matters in
bv thp T ariges on the rejection of evidence offered Pears in th^h-u^ Pn ^ie before the jury, and which apthe dpnn«u; 1 It excePtions. The plaintiff read in evidence on the 28thO1rOT Leonard N. Nutz, taken under a commission ing. Tit Hp°/ iln€2 11852’ and filed the 9th of July succeed-
Vol xvt eia an^ ^en °^ere^ evidence a letter of the
Conrad v. Griffey.
witness dated at New Albany, on the 3d April, 1846, with an affidavit annexed by him of the same date, addressed to the plaintiff Griffey. As preliminary proof to the introduction of said letter, the defendant adduced the bill of exceptions signed upon a former trial of this cause, and filed on the 23d February, 1849, showing that the letter had been produced by the plaintiff in the former trial, and read by his counsel in evidence as the letter of Nutz, in support of a former deposition made by him. And the said letter and affidavit were offered by the defendant to contradict and discredit the deposition of the witness taken the 28th June, 1852; but upon objection of counsel for the plaintiff that the witness had not been cross-examined in reference to the writing of said letter, or allowed an opportunity of explaining the same, it was rejected.
At the former trial the letter was offered in evidence by the plaintiff in the Circuit Court, to corroborate what Nutz, the witness, at that time had sworn to; and the letter was admitted to be read for that purpose by the court. On a writ of error, this court held that the Circuit Court erred in admitting the letter as evidence, and on that ground reversed the judgment. Conrad v. Griffey, 11 How., 492.
The rule is well settled in England, that a witness cannot be impeached by showing that he had made contradictory statements from those sworn to, unless on his examination he was asked whether he had not made such statements to the individuals by whom the proof was expected to be given. 1 the Queen’s case, 2 Brod. & B., 312; Angus v. Smith, 1 M°°’ & M., 473 ; 3 Stark. Ev., 1740,1753,1754 ; Carpenter v. Wall, 11 Ad. & El., 803. . . .
This rule is founded upon common sense, and is essen ia to protect the character of a witness. His memory is reires e by the necessary inquiries, which enables him to explain ie *171 *statements referred to, and show they were
J under a mistake, or that there was no discrepancj tween them and his testimony.
This rule is generally established in this as. England. Doe v. Reagan, 5 Blackf. (Ind.), 217; ran Bank v. Steam Nav. Co., 11 Gill & J- (Md.), 28; a m Haight, 2 Barb. (N. Y.), 210, 213; 1 McLean s, 540; 1 •’ 325; 4 Id., 378, 381; Jenkins v. Eldridge, 2 Story, 1«1, ’ Kimball v. Davis, 19 Wend. (N. Y.), 437; 2 •’ “ The declaration of witnesses whose testimony taken under a commission, made subsequent to .e ‘ .jmony their testimony, contradicting or invalidating tieir ,. as contained in the depositions, is inadmissi e,
Conrad v. Griffey.
to. The only way for the party to avail himself of such declarations is to sue out a second commission.” “Such evidence is always inadmissible until the witness, whose testimony is thus sought to be impeached, has been examined upon the point, and his attention particularly directed to the circumstances of the transaction, so as to furnish him an opportunity for explanation or exculpation.”
This rule equally applies whether the declaration of the witness, supposed to contradict his testimony, be written or verbal. 3 Stark. Ev., 1741.
A written statement or deposition is as susceptible of explanation, as verbal statements. A different rule prevails in Massachusetts and the State of Maine.
The letter appears to have been written six years before the deposition was taken which the letter was offered to discredit. This shows the necessity and propriety of the rule. It is not probable that, after the lapse of so many years, the letter was in the mind of the witness when his deposition was sworn to. But, independently of the lapse of time, the rule of evidence is a salutary one, and cannot be dispensed with in the courts of the United States. There was no error in the rejection of the letter, under the circumstances, by the Circuit Court; its judgment is therefore affirmed, with costs.
ORDER.
This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of the record from the Circuit Court of the United States for the
astern District of Louisiana, and was argued by counsel.
’ c?nsiderati°n whereof, it is now here ordered and ad-
jucged, by this court, that the judgment of the said Circuit
o . 8 cause be, and the same is hereby, affirmed, with as s and interest, until paid, at the same rate per annum a. similar judgments bear in the courts of the State of Louisiana.