Sarchet v. United States, 37 U.S. (12 Pet.) 143 (1838)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
Sarchet v. United States, 37 U.S. (12 Pet.) 143 (1838)
Full caption
Edward Sarchet and others, Appellants, v. United States.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1838
*Edward Sarchet and others, Appellants, v. United States. [*143
Appellate jurisdiction.
The United States instituted a suit, on a bond for duties, in the district court of the southern district of New York ; and after a trial and verdict for the United States, judgment was given against the defendant; who thereupon prosecuted a writ of error to the circuit court, for the southern district of New York, where the judgment of the district court was affirmed ; the defendant then appealed to the supreme court: Held, that cases at law can only be brought from the circuit court by writ of error, and cannot be brought by appeal. In cases at law, removed from the district to the circuit court, the judgment of the circuit court is final and conclusive; it is otherwise, in cases of admiralty and maritime jurisdiction. United States v. Hudson, 7 Cranch 108; and the several cases, 7 Ibid. 287 ; and 2 Wheat. 248, 395, cited.
Appeal from the Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York.
Butler, Attorney-General, moved to dismiss the appeal, on two grounds
1. That this was originally a proceeding at law, on a bond for duties, in the district court of New York for the southern district; and was, after a judgment of that court for the United States, taken by a writ of error to the circuit court for the southern circuit, by the defendant: where the judgment of the district court was affirmed. The judgment of the circuit was final in such a case. 2. This is a proceeding at law ; and the defendant has brought the case from the circuit court by an appeal, and not by a writ of error. Butler cited United States v. Goodwin, 7 Cranch 108 ; 7 Ibid. 287 ; 3 Wheat. 248, &c.
Sarchet, opposed the motion, in person : cited, 3 Dall. 171 ; 2 Wheat. 259.
Taney, Ch. J., delivered the opinion of the court.—In this case, an action was brought by the United States against Edward Sarchet and others, in the district court for the southern district of New York, upon a bond for duties charged by the collector upon certain iron imported into the United States. The duties *claimed were contested by the defendants, upon the ground, that iron of the description imported was not by law chargeable with that duty, and that the bond was, therefore, improperly taken. The judgment in the district court was against the defendants; and they removed it, by writ of error, to the circuit court for the southern district of New York, in the second circuit,-where the judgment of the district court was affirmed ; and the case is now brought here by appeal from the judgment of .the circuit court. The attorney-general has moved to dismiss the case for want of jurisdiction in this court: and we think the appeal cannot be sustained.
It has been repeatedly determined that, under the acts of congress regulating the appellate jurisdiction of this court from the circuit courts, casei must be brought here by writ of error, and cannot be brought here by appeal And as this was a suit at law on a bond, it could not, under any circum- [p. 102] 144 SUPREME COURT [J«fy
Scott v. Lloyd.
stances, legally come before us on appeal; but must come up by writ of error in order to give us jurisdiction to try it.
There is also another objection, equally fatal to this proceeding. In cases at law, removed from the district court to the circuit court, the judgment of the circuit court is final between the parties. It is otherwise in cases in equity, and of admiralty and maritime jurisdiction ; and although the reason for this distinction may not be entirely obvious, yet it is our duty to conform to the provisions of the law : and this court have repeatedly decided, that, in civil cases at law, the judgment of the circuit court is final, where the case is removed by writ of error, from the district court to the circuit court. The point was fully considered .and decided in the case of the United States v. Goodwin, 7 Cranch 108 ; and the opinion there given has been since re-affirmed in several cases. Ibid. 287 ; 2 Wheat. 248, 395. The question must be regarded as too well settled to be now open for argument; and as this court would not have jurisdiction, in any form of proceeding, to review the judgment in this case by the circuit court; it would be evidently improper to hear an argument on the question decided there, or to express any opinion concerning them. The appeal is, therefore, dismissed.
Appeal dismissed.
1
It is now provided by statute, that in the ment by, the testator, intestate or ward, unless courts of the United States, no witness shall be called to testify thereto by the opposite party, excluded, in any civil action, because he is a or required to testify thereto by the courts. party to, or interested in, the issue to be tried : In all other respects, the laws of the state in provided, that in actions by or against execu- which the court is held shall be the rules of tors, administrators or guardians, in which decision as to the competency of witnesses in ludgment may be rendered for or against them, the courts of the United States, in trials at neither party shall be allowed to testify against commorf law, in equity, and in admiralty. 1 the other, as to any transaction with, or state R. S. ^858. See Texas v. Chiles, 21 Wall. 488
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access