Ben jamix J. Knapp v. Banks, 43 U.S. (2 How.) 73 (1844)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Ben jamix J. Knapp v. Banks, 43 U.S. (2 How.) 73 (1844)
Full caption
Ben jamix J. Knapp, Plaintiff in error, v. J Edmund Banks.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1844
*-,0-1 * Ben jamix J. Knapp, Plaintiff in error, v.
J Edmund Banks.
Where the plaintiff in the court below claims $2000 or more, and the ruling of the court is for a less sum, he is entitled to a writ of error.1 But the defendant is not entitled to such writ where the judgment against him is for a less sum than $2000 at the time of the rendition thereof.2
This was a case brought up by writ of error from the Circuit Court of the United States for the southern district of New York.
Banks had recovered a judgment in that court, against Knapp, for $1,720.
Ogden moved to dismiss the case for want of jurisdiction, which was opposed by Benedict upon the ground that adding interest upon the judgment down to the time when the writ of error was brought, would make it exceed $2000; and he cited 3 Peters, 32, to show that the amount in controversy in this court determined the jurisdiction.
Mr. Justice STORY delivered the opinion of the court.
1
See. Western Union Tel. Co. v. Rog- Where the matter in controversy was ers, 3 Otto, 567 ; Sizer n. Many, 16 the right to the mayoralty of a city for How., 98 ; Parker v. Latey, 12 Wall., the term of two years at a salary of 390. $1000 per annum, jurisdiction was as-The amount in dispute must exceed, sumed notwithstanding the salary was not merely equal $2,000. Walker v. payable monthly. United States ex United States, 4 Wall., 163. When rel. v. Addison, 22 How., 174. the sum in controversy is large enough 2 Followed. Walker v. United to give the court jurisdiction, such States, 4 Wall., 165. Cited. Thomp-jurisdiction will be retained notwith- son n. Butler, 5 Otto, 695 ; United standing a subsequent reduction of the States v. Watkinds, 6 Fed. Rep., 157; sum below the amount requisite. s. c. 7 Sawy., 90. S. P. Troy v. Cooke v. United States. 2 Wall., 218. Evans, 7 Otto 1.
Knapp v. Banks.
We entertain no doubt whatsoever upon this question. The amount in controversy is to be decided by the sum in controversy at the time of the judgment, and not by any subsequent additions thereto, such as interest. The distinction constantly maintained is this: Where the plaintiff sues for an amount exceeding $2000, and the ad damnum exceeds $2000, if by reason of any erroneous ruling of the court below, the plaintiff recovers nothing, or less than $2000, there, the sum claimed by the plaintiff is the sum in controversy for which a writ of error will lie. But if a verdict is given against the defendant for a less sum than $2000, and judgment passes against him accordingly, there it is obvious that there is, on the part of the defendant, nothing in controversy beyond the sum for which the judgment is given; and consequently he is not entitled to any writ of error. We cannot look beyond the time of the judgment in order to ascertain whether a writ of error lies or not.
ORDER.
Mr. Ogden, of counsel for the defendant in error, moved the court to dismiss this writ of error for the want of jurisdiction, because the matters or sum in controversy, exclusive of costs, did not exceed $2000; which was opposed by Mr. Benedict, of counsel for the plaintiff in error, who contended that [-*74 although the judgment of the Circuit *Court was only L ‘ for $1720, yet that the interest on that sum added thereto would make it exceed $2000. To which Mr. Ogden rejoined, that the right of the party to a writ of error, was controlled by the amount at the rendition of the judgment and could not be. enlarged by time. On consideration whereof, It is the opinion of this court that where the plaintiff in the court below claims $2000 or more, and the ruling of the court is for a less sum, that he is entitled to a writ of error: but that the defendant in the court below is not entitled to such writ where the judgment against him is for a less sum than $2000 at the time of the rendition thereof—that this is the settled practice of this court. Whereupon it is now here ordered and adjudged by this court that this writ of error be and the same is hereby dismissed for the want of jurisdiction.
February Zd.
Vol. ii.—5 G5
Stockton et al. v. Bishop.
1
Distinguished. Hogan v. Ross, is true where the citation is not served 11 How., 296. Followed. Slaughter- before the return day of the writ. house cases, 10Wall., 273,292. Cited. City of Washington v. Dennison, 6 French v. Shoemaker, 12 Wall., 100. Wall., 495. So, also, where a copy of S. P. United States ex rel. v. Addi- the writ is not lodged for the adverse son, 22 How., 174. party within ten days, Sundays exclu-Where an appeal was taken in a sive, after judgment or decree. Rail-common law case instead of a writ of road Co. v. Harris, 1 Wall., 574; error, and after the lapse of ten days O'Dowd v. Russell, 14 Id., 402. the plaintiff issued an execution upon But under the act of June 1st, 1872, his judgment, and the defendant then § 11, it is not necessary, in order to sued out a Wilt of error, the writ was make the writ a supersedeas, that it sued out too late to stay execution and be served within ten days, the super-the court below erred in quashing the sedeas bond may be filed and the writ execution. Saltmarsh n. TuthiU, 12 served at any time within sixty days How., 387. after the rendition of judgment. Tele-Where the writ is not sealed until graphs Co. n. Eyser, 19 Wall., 419. eleven days after rendition, of judg- And see Doyle v. Wisconsin, 4 Otto., ment, there is no stay, and the same 50.