Case details
Bluebook Citation
Hedgebeth v. North Carolina, 334 U.S. 806 (1948)
Full caption
HEDGEBETH v. NORTH CAROLINA.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
June 14, 1948
HEDGEBETH v. NORTH CAROLINA.
CERTIORARI TO THE SUPREME COURT OF NORTH CAROLINA.
No. 674. Argued April 27,1948.—Decided June 14,1948.
1. The state supreme court having affirmed dismissal of a habeas corpus proceeding involving a claim of federal constitutional right on the ground that the full record was not before it, the writ of certiorari granted to review that judgment is dismissed because the judgment can rest on an adequate non-federal ground. P. 807. 2. A state prisoner’s rights under the Federal Constitution must be pursued in accordance with the state procedure or, in default of relief by available state procedure, by a new claim of denial of federal right for want of such relief. P. 807. 228 N. C. 259,45 S. E. 2d 563, certiorari dismissed.
Petitioner sued in a state court for habeas corpus to secure release from imprisonment under a conviction alleged to have denied his federal constitutional rights. A judgment dismissing the writ was affirmed by the state supreme court. 228 N. C. 259, 45 S. E. 2d 563. This Court granted certiorari. 333 U. S. 854. Dismissed, p.807.
By special leave of Court, Wilford L. Whitley, Jr., pro hac vice, argued the cause and filed a brief for petitioner.
Ralph Moody, Assistant Attorney General of North Carolina, argued the cause for respondent. With him on the brief was Harry McMullan, Attorney General, and T. W. Bruton, Assistant Attorney General.
Per Curiam.
After a conviction for robbery, petitioner sued out a writ of habeas corpus in a Superior Court of North Carolina claiming that the sentence he is serving involved a denial of his rights under the Fourteenth Amendment. The writ was dismissed and the dismissal affirmed by the Supreme Court of North Carolina. 228 N. C. 259, 45 S. E. 2d 563. If petitioner’s allegations, with supporting affidavits, in the habeas corpus proceedings controlled the issue before us, they would establish circumstances that make the right to assistance of counsel an ingredient of the Due Process Clause. While the Supreme Court of North Carolina recognized the right of an accused to the benefit of counsel under appropriate circumstances, it held that in the proceedings on the habeas corpus the trial court had before it not merely the petitioner’s allegations but “the oral testimony of the sheriff, which was not sent up.” In short, there was before the North Carolina Supreme Court only a partial record of the proceedings in the Superior Court. In reviewing a judgment of a state court, we are bound by the record on which that judgment was based. Since the North Carolina Supreme Court went on the ground that it did not have the full record before it, we are constrained to dismiss this writ because the judgment below can rest on a non-federal ground. Petitioner’s rights under the Federal Constitution must be pursued according to the procedural requirements of North Carolina or, in default of relief by available North Carolina proceedings, by a new claim of denial of due process for want of such relief. Foster v. Illinois, 332 U. S. 134, 139.
Mr. Justice Douglas and Mr. Justice Rutledge are of the opinion that the judgment should be reversed.
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
DECISIONS PER CURIAM AND ORDERS FROM APRIL 27, 1948, THROUGH JUNE 21, 1948.
May 3, 1948.
Per Curiam Decisions.
No. 397. International Brotherhood of Team - sters, Chauffeurs, Warehousemen & Helpers Union et al. v. Denver Milk Producers, Inc. et al. Appeal from the Supreme Court of Colorado. Argued January 9, 1948. Decided May 3, 1948. Per Curiam: Because of the inadequacy of the record, we decline to decide the constitutional issues involved. The appeal is dismissed without prejudice to the determination in further proceedings of any questions arising under the Federal Constitution. Cf. Rescue Army n. Municipal Court, 331 U. S. 549 (1947). Dissenting: Mr. Justice Black and Mr. Justice Murphy. Herbert S. Thatcher argued the cause for appellants. With him on the brief were J. Albert Woll and Philip Hornbein, Jr. Kenneth W. Robinson argued the cause and filed a brief for appellees. Robert D. Charlton was also of counsel. By special leave of Court, George K. Thomas, Assistant Attorney General, argued the cause for the State of Colorado, as amicus curiae, urging affirmance. With him on the brief was H. Lawrence Hinkley, Attorney General. Reported below: 116 Colo. 389,183 P. 2d 529.
No. 733. Schmitt v. Wilder, Director of Licensing, et al. Appeal from the Supreme Court of South Dakota. Per Curiam: The appeal is dismissed for the want of a substantial federal question. Ashley Sellers and Kenneth L. Kimble for appellant. Ray F. Drewry, Assistant Attorney General of South Dakota, for appellees. Reported below: 71 S. Dak. 575, 27 N. W. 2d 910.
792588 0—48-----56 809
May 3, 1948. 334 U. S.
No. 741. Finley et al. v. City of Tarrant et al. Appeal from the Supreme Court of Alabama. Per Curiam: The motion to dismiss is granted and the appeal is dismissed for the reason that the judgment of the court below is based upon a nonfederal ground adequate to support it. Mr. Justice Black took no part in the consideration or decision of this case. George D. Finley for appellants. Douglass P. Wingo, Peyton D. Bibb and Needham A. Graham, Jr. for appellees. Reported below: 250 Ala. 19,32 So. 2d 806.
Miscellaneous Orders.
No. 337. Connecticut Mutual Life Insurance Co. et al. v. Moore, Comptroller of the State of New York, 333 U. S. 541. Rehearing denied. The petitions of the States of Connecticut and Vermont for leave to intervene are therefore also denied.
No. 361, Mise. Davis v. Nierstheimer, Warden; and No. 469, Mise. Fook v. Clemmer, Director. The motions for leave to file petitions for writs of habeas corpus are denied.
Certiorari Granted.
No. 621. United States v. Kansas City Life Insur - ance Co. Court of Claims. Certiorari granted. Solicitor General Perlman for the United States. Ray B. Lucas for respondent. Reported below: 109 Ct. Cl. 555, 74 F. Supp. 653.
No. 195, Mise. Young v. Ragen, Warden. Circuit Court of Randolph County, Illinois. Certiorari granted. Petitioner pro se. George F. Barrett, Attorney General of Illinois, and William C. Wines, Assistant Attorney General, for respondent.
334U.S. May 3, 1948.
Certiorari Denied.
No. 611. Loew’s, Inc. et al. v. William Goldman Theatres, Inc. C. C. A. 3d. Certiorari denied. Wm. A. Schnader, Bernard G. Segal, J. Pennington Straus, Joseph M. Proskauer and Louis J. Goffman for petitioners. William A. Gray, Francis T. Anderson, Lester J. Schaffer and Robert Dechert for respondent. Reported below: 164 F. 2d 1021.
No. 642. New York, New Haven & Hartford Rail - road Co. v. Reconstruction Finance Corporation. C. C. A. 2d. Certiorari denied. Hermon J. Wells and H. H. Corbin for petitioner. Solicitor General Perlman, Robert L. Stern, Robert W. Ginnane, W. Meade Fletcher and Joseph A. Woolman for respondent. Reported below: 164 F. 2d 466.
No. 663. United States v. Cold Metal Process Co. et al. C. C. A. 6th. Certiorari denied. Solicitor General Perlman for the United States. Clarence B. Zewadski and Howard F. Burns for respondents. Reported below: 164F. 2d 754.
No. 682. Harang v. United States. C. C. A. 5th. Certiorari denied. Arthur A. Moreno for petitioner. Solicitor General Perlman, Assistant Attorney General Caudle, Sewall Key and Hilbert P. Zarky for the United States. Reported below: 165 F. 2d 106.
No. 688. Beavers v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue. C. C. A. 5th. Certiorari denied. Robert Ash for petitioner. Solicitor General Perlman, Assistant Attorney General Caudle, Sewall Key and Hilbert P. Zarky for respondent. Reported below: 165 F. 2d 208.
No. 698. In re Gordon. Supreme Court of California. Certiorari denied. David W. Louisell for petitioner.
May 3, 1948. 334 U. S.
No. 699. Capitol Meats, Inc. et al. v. United States. C. C. A. 2d. Certiorari denied. Irving J. Roth for petitioners. Solicitor General Perlman, Assistant Attorney General Quinn, Robert S. Erdahl and Beatrice Rosenberg for the United States. Reported below: 166 F. 2d 537.
No. 714. SCHATTE ET AL. V. INTERNATIONAL ALLIANCE of Theatrical Stage Employees & Moving Picture Operators et al. C. C. A. 9th. Certiorari denied. Zach Lamar Cobb for petitioners. Matthew M. Levy and Michael G. Luddy for the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees & Moving Picture Operators et al.; and Homer I. Mitchell for the Association of Motion Picture Producers, Inc. et al., respondents. Reported below: 165 F. 2d 216.
No. 686. Samett v. Reconstruction Finance Cor - poration. C. C. A. 10th. Certiorari denied. The Chief Justice took no part in the consideration or decision of this application. Fred S. Caldwell for petitioner. Solicitor General Perlman, Assistant Attorney General Morison, Paul A. Sweeney and Harry I. Rand for respondent. Reported below: 165 F. 2d 605.
No. 694. Waite v. Overlade, Warden. C. C. A. 7th. Certiorari denied. Mr. Justice Murphy and Mr. Jus - tice Rutledge are of the opinion the petition should be granted. Benjamin G. Cox for petitioner. Solicitor General Perlman, Assistant Attorney General Quinn, Frederick Bernays Wiener, Robert S. Erdahl and Beatrice Rosenberg for respondent. Reported below: 164 F. 2d 722.
No. 307, Mise. Harrison v. Illinois. Supreme Court of Illinois. Certiorari denied. Reported below: 395 Ill. 463, 70N.E. 2d 596.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access