Meerleer v. Michigan, 329 U.S. 663 (1947)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Meerleer v. Michigan, 329 U.S. 663 (1947)
Full caption
De MEERLEER v . MICHIGAN.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Feb. 3, 1947
De MEERLEER v . MICHIGAN.
CERTIORARI TO THE SUPREME COURT OF MICHIGAN.
No. 140. Argued January 6, 1947.—Decided February 3, 1947.
On the same day that an information was filed in a state court charging him with murder, a 17-year-old defendant was arraigned, convicted on his plea of guilty, and sentenced to life imprisonment. He had no counsel and none was offered or assigned; the court did not apprise him of the consequences of his plea of guilty; no evidence was offered in his behalf and none of the State’s witnesses were cross-examined. Held that he was deprived of rights essential to a fair hearing under the Federal Constitution. P. 665. 313 Mich. 548, 21 N. W. 2d 849, reversed.
A state court in which he had been convicted and sentenced for murder denied petitioner’s motion for leave to file a delayed motion for a new trial. The state p. 664supreme court affirmed. 313 Mich. 548, 21 N. W. 2d 849. This Court granted certiorari. 329 U. S. 702. Reversed, p. 665.
David W. Louisell argued the cause and filed a brief for petitioner.
Edmund E. Shepherd, Solicitor General of Michigan, argued the cause for respondent. With him on the brief were Eugene F. Black, Attorney General, and Daniel J. O’Hara, Assistant Attorney General.
Per Curiam .
In conformity with Michigan procedure, petitioner moved for leave to file a delayed motion for new trial in the court in which he had been convicted of first-degree murder. Serious impairment of his constitutional rights at the arraignment and trial were asserted as grounds for the motion. The trial court denied the motion, and the Supreme Court of Michigan on appeal affirmed that ruling. 313 Mich. 548, 21 N. W. 2d 849. We granted certiorari because of the importance of the constitutional issues presented.
The facts are not in dispute. On May 16, 1932, an information was filed in the Circuit Court of Lenawee County, Michigan, charging petitioner, then seventeen years of age, and one Virgil Scott with the crime of murder. On the same day, petitioner was arraigned, tried, convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life imprisonment. The record indicates that petitioner was without legal assistance throughout all these proceedings and was never advised of his right to counsel. The court did not explain the consequences of the plea of guilty, and the record indicates considerable confusion in petitioner’s mind at the time of the arraignment as to the effect of such a plea. No p. 665evidence in petitioner’s behalf was introduced at the trial and none of the State’s witnesses were subjected to cross-examination.
After reviewing the foregoing facts, the Supreme Court of Michigan determined that the record revealed no deprivation of petitioner’s constitutional rights. The court indicated that it had given consideration to the case of Hawk v. Olson, 326 U. S. 271 (1945), and the authorities cited therein, but concluded that the rule of the Michigan cases was determinative. See People v. Williams, 225 Mich. 133, 195 N. W. 818 (1923). In this there was error.
Here a seventeen-year-old defendant, confronted by a serious and complicated criminal charge, was hurried through unfamiliar legal proceedings without a word being said in his defense. At no time was assistance of counsel offered or mentioned to him, nor was he apprised of the consequences of his plea. Under the holdings of this Court, petitioner was deprived of rights essential to a fair hearing under the Federal Constitution. Powell v. Alabama, 287 U. S. 45 (1932); Williams v. Kaiser, 323 U. S. 471 (1945); Tomkins v. Missouri, 323 U. S. 485 (1945); White v. Ragen, 324 U. S. 760 (1945); Hawk v. Olson, supra. See Betts v. Brady, 316 U. S. 455 (1942).
Reversed. p. 666DECISIONS PER CURIAM, ETC., THROUGH
FEBRUARY 3, 1947.*
No. 105. United State s ex rel . Goodm an v . Hearn , Commandi ng General . Certiorari, 328 U. S. 833, to the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. September 7, 1946. Dismissed pursuant to Rule 35. Harry Mesard for petitioner. Solicitor General McGrath, Robert S. Erdahl and Irving S. Shapiro for respondent. Reported below: 153 F. 2d 186.
No. 246. Connect icut Compa ny v . Walling , Wage & Hour Admini strat or . On petition for writ of certiorari to the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. October 7, 1946. Dismissed on motion of counsel for the petitioner. H. L. Filer for petitioner. Solicitor General McGrath, William S. Tyson and Morton Liftin for respondent. Reported below: 154 F. 2d 552.
No. 440. Unite d States et al . v . New York et al . Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the Northern District of New York. October 7, 1946. Dismissed on motion of counsel for the appellants. Attorney General Clark, Solicitor General McGrath, Assistant Attorney General Berge, Edward H. Miller, David O. Mathews, Daniel W. Knowlton and J. Stanley Payne for appellants.
*
For orders on petitions for certiorari, see post, pp. 694, 713; rehearing, post, pp. 817,818.
667
727731 0—47---- 48
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
Decisions Per Curiam, Etc. 329 U. S.
No. 210. Whit more v . Ormsbee , Comm is si oner of the Bureau of Revenue ;
No. 211. KGFL, Inc . v . Ormsbee , Commis si oner of the Bureau of Revenue ; and
No. 212. Houck et al . v . Ormsbee , Commis sioner of the Bureau of Reve nue . Appeals from the District Court of the United States for the District of New Mexico. October 14, 1946. Per Curiam: The motions to affirm are granted and the judgments are affirmed. (1) Hillsborough v. Cromwell, 326 U. S. 620, 623; Matthews v. Rodgers, 284 U. S. 521, 525; (2) Union Brokerage Co. n . Jensen, 322 U. S. 202. Lake J. Frazier for appellants. Arthur W. Scharfeld and Fred E. Wilson for appellee. Reported below: 64 F. Supp. 911.
No. 276. General Transp ortati on Co . et al . v . Unite d States et al . Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the District of Massachusetts. October 14, 1946. Per Curiam: The motion to affirm is granted and the judgment is affirmed. §§5(2) (a), 203 (a) (14), 212 (a), Interstate Commerce Act, as amended, 49 U. S. C. §§ 5, 303 (a) (14), 312 (a). Michael Carchia for appellants. Solicitor General McGrath and Daniel W. Knowlton for the United States and the Interstate Commerce Commission, appellees. Reported below: 65 F. Supp. 981.
No. 296. Evans , trading as Otis Evans Truck Line , v. United States et al . Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the Western District of Virginia. October 14, 1946. Per Curiam: The motion to affirm is granted and the judgment is affirmed. Alton Railroad Co. v. United States, 315 U. S. 15, 25; United States v. Carolina Freight Carriers Corp., 315 U. S. 475, 484, 490; p. 669Mississippi Valley Barge Line Co. v. United States, 292 U. S. 282, 286-7. Rutledge C. Clement for appellant. Solicitor General McGrath and Daniel W. Knowlton for the United States and the Interstate Commerce Commission, appellees. Reported below: 65 F. Supp. 183.
No. 318. Moff ett et al . v . Commerce Trust Co . et al . Appeal from the Supreme Court of Missouri. October 14, 1946. Per Curiam: The motion to dismiss is granted, and the appeal is dismissed for the reason that the decision of the state court sought here to be reviewed was based upon a non-federal ground adequate to support it. Enterprise Irrigation District v. Farmers Canal Co., 243 U. S. 157, 165; Utley v. St. Petersburg, 292 U. S. 106, 111. Martin J. O’Donnell for appellants. Charles M. Blackmar, John T. Harding, R. C. Tucker, Walter A. Raymond and B. C. Howard for appellees. Reported below: 354 Mo. 1098,193 S.W. 2d 588.
No. 338. Kut v. Bureau of Unemployment Comp en - sati on et al . Appeal from the Supreme Court of Ohio. October 14, 1946. Per Curiam: The motion to dismiss is granted, and the appeal is dismissed for the reason that the decision of the state court sought here to be reviewed was based upon a non-federal ground adequate to support it. Berea College v. Kentucky, 211 U. S. 45. Murray Seasongood and Lester A. Jaffe for appellant. E. G. Schuessler for appellees. Reported below: 146 Ohio St. 522, 66 N. E. 2d 643.
No. 374. Gallup v . Towns hip of Lower Merion . Appeal from the Superior Court of Pennsylvania. October 14, 1946. Per Curiam: The motion to dismiss is p. 670granted, and the appeal is dismissed for want of a substantial federal question. Hadacheck v. Los Angeles, 239 U. S. 394; New Orleans Public Service v. New Orleans, 281 U. S. 682. G. Harry Ditter for appellant. Harold Evans for appellee. Reported below: 158 Pa. Super. 572, 46 A. 2d 35.
No. 424. Memp his Natural Gas Co . v . Mc Canles s , Commis sio ner of Fina nce & Taxat ion , et al . Appeal from the Supreme Court of Tennessee. October 14,1946. Per Curiam: The motion to dismiss is granted and the appeal is dismissed for want of jurisdiction. § 237 (a), Judicial Code, as amended, 28 U. S. C. § 344 (a). Treating the papers whereon the appeal was allowed as a petition for writ of certiorari as required by § 237 (c) of the Judicial Code, as amended, 28 U. S. C. § 344 (c), certiorari is denied. Edward P. Russell for appellant. W. F. Barry, Jr. for appellees. Reported below: 183 Tenn. 635, 194 S.W. 2d 476.
No. 220. Bailey v . United States . On petition for writ of certiorari to the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. October 14, 1946. Per Curiam: The Court having given consideration to the Government’s confession of error, the petition for writ of certiorari is granted and the judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals is reversed. Theodore Lockyear and Paul Wever for petitioner. Solicitor General McGrath, W. Marvin Smith, Robert S. Erdahl and Andrew F. Oehmann for the United States. Reported below: 155 F. 2d 184.
No. 10, original. Unite d States v . Wyoming et al . October 14,1946. The report of the Special Master herein is received and ordered filed.