Peltz v. Clarke, 30 U.S. (5 Pet.) 481 (1831)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
Peltz v. Clarke, 30 U.S. (5 Pet.) 481 (1831)
Full caption
Alexander M. Peltz et al., Plaintiffs in error, v. Joseph S. Clarke, Defendant in error.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1831
* Alexander M. Peltz et al., Plaintiffs in error, v. Joseph S. [*481
Clarke, Defendant in error.
Mortgage.
It is undoubtedly well settled, as a general rule, that a court of law will not permit an outstanding satisfied mortgage to be set up against the mortgagor; yet the legal title is not technically released by receiving the money. This rule must then be founded on an equitable exercise by courts of law over parties in ejectment; it would be contrary to the plainest principles of equity and justice, to permit a stranger, who had no interest in the mortgage, to set it up, when it had been satisfied by the mortgagor himself, to defeat his title; but if this stranger had himself paid it off—if this mortgage had been bought in by him—he would be considered as an assignee, and might certainly use it for his protection.
The defendant in the circuit court was the owner of the equitable estate, and had paid off the mortgage, on his own account, and for his own benefit; the incumbrance, under these circumstances, was the property of him to whom the estate belonged in equity. The reason of the rule does not apply to such a case.1 Peltz v. Clarke, 2 Cr. C. C. 703, affirmed.
Error to the Circuit Court of the District of Columbia, for the county of Washington.
In the circuit court, the plaintiffs in error instituted an action of ejectment, for the recovery of a lot of ground in the district of Columbia. It appeared in evidence, that under a decree of the circuit court for the county of Washington, the estate of John Peltz, deceased, had been sold by Charles Clover and John Davis, trustees appointed for the purpose of making sale of the same, for the payment of his debts ; and that the defendant in error nad purchased at the sale, the property in controversy. No deed had been made by the trustees to the purchaser, in consequence of the loss of some title papers ; but he had paid the greater portion of the purchase-money.
John Peltz, the ancestor of the plaintiffs in error, had, previously, to his decease, mortgaged the estate in controversy to Frederick Gammar; who
Peltz v. Clarke.
proceeded on the mortgage, in chancery, against the trustees, Charles Glover and John Davis, and against Alexander and Michael Peltz, as heirs of John Peltz ; and obtained a decree of foreclosure, and for a sale of the mortgaged premises. The defendant in error, after the decree, having been so advised * , by the mortgagor, paid to *him, with the consent and approbation,
J and in the presence of Mr. Glover, one of the trustees, the whole amount due upon the mortgage ; the sum paid being considered as part of the purchase-money due under the purchase from the trustees. On this payment being made, the mortgagor gave to the defendant in error, a receipt for the amount of the mortgage, and an order to enter the suit on the mortgage “ settled.” On the docket of the court, an entry was made in the mortgage suit, “ settled, says complainant, see order.”
The plaintiffs claimed the property as the heirs-at-law of John Peltz.
The plaintiffs prayed the court to instruct the jury, that the mortgage so paid was not outstanding and subsisting, so as to bar the plaintiffs’ right to recover ; which the court refused to do ; to which the counsel for the plaintiffs excepted ; and judgment having been entered on the verdict for the defendant, the plaintiffs prosecuted this writ of error.
Key, for the plaintiffs in error, contended, that although the defendant might have a good defence in equity, for the mortgage money paid by him, he had no defence at law. He cited Runnington on Ejectment 119 ; Esp. N. P. 457-8 ; 6 Johns. 34 ; 2 Har. & McHen. 9, 17 ; 3 Ibid. 399.
Jones, for the defendant, said, that on the plaintiffs’ own showing, there is a mortgage in fee, a forfeiture, and a decree of foreclosure. If a mortgage is satisfied by the mortgagor, it is admitted, that the mortgage cannot be set up ; but here, the purchaser, before he received a deed from the trustees, under their sale, paid off the mortgage ; and he sets it up for his protection. Having paid the amount of his purchase from the trustees, within a small sum, the defendant stands on his possession, and having paid for his own benefit the outstanding mortgage.
Marshall, Ch. J., delivered the opinion of the court.—This was an ejectment, brought by the plaintiffs in error against the defendant, in the * -| circuit court of the United States for the district of Columbia. *The
' J plaintiffs, who are the heirs of John Peltz, gave the title of their ancestor in evidence.
The defendant then proved, that the land for which this ejectment was brought, was sold under a decree of the circuit court for the district of Columbia, and purchased by him, he being the highest bidder. That he gave his notes to Charles Glover and John Davis, the trustees appointed to make the sale under the decree ; was put into possession of the premises by them ; had paid nearly all the purchase-money, and declared his readiness to pay the residue, on receiving a title. He also gave in evidence a deed of mortgage, executed by John Peltz, in his lifetime, conveying the premises to Frederick Gammar.
The plaintiffs then proved, that a decree for the foreclosure and sale of the mortgaged premises had been obtained by the representatives of the mortgagee. The defendant, acting under the advice of one of the trustees,, appointed to execute this decree, paid in part for his purchase, the money
OF THE UNITED STATES. 483 1831]
duo upon the mortgage, and the return showed the admiss.on of the mortgagee^ that it was fettled. The plaintiffs prayed the court to fury, that this mortgage was not an outstanding title which could bar the plaintiffs’ right to recover. The court refused to give this instruction, and the plaintiffs excepted toils opinion. The jury found a verdict for th defendant, and the judgment rendered on that verdict has been removed into this court by writ of error. .
It is undoubtedly well settled, as a general principle, that a court of law will not permit an outstanding satisfied mortgage to be set up against the mortgagor. This is fully proved by the cases cited in argument by the counsel for the plaintiffs. Yet the legal title is not technically released, by receiving the money. This rule must then be founded on an equitable control exercised by courts of law over parties in ejectment. It would be contrary to the plainest principles of equity and justice, to permit a ganger, who had no interest in the mortgage, to set it up, when it had been satisfied y the mortgagor himself, to defeat his title. But if this stranger had himself paid it off, if this mortgage had been bought in by him, he would be considered as an assignee, and might certainly use it for his protection, *In the case at bar, the defendant is the owner of the equitable ^484 estate, and has paid off the mortgage, on his own account, and for. his own benefit. This incumbrance, under these circumstances, is the property of him to whom the estate belongs in equity. The reason of the rule does not apply to the case. We do not think, that the mortgagor, his interest having been sold under a decree of court, could demand a reconveyance from the mortgagee to himself, the mortgage being satisfied by the purchase under that decree. There is no error in the judgment of the circuit court ; and it is affirmed, with costs.
This cause came on to be heard, on the transcript of the record from the circuit court of the United States for the district of Columbia, holden in and for the county of Washington, and was argued by counsel: On consideration whereof, it is considered, ordered and adjudged by this court, t at t e ju g ment of the said circuit court in this cause be and the same is ere y affirmed, with costs.
*
Townsend B. Peyton and others, Appellants, v. Joseph Stith, [ 485 Appellee. Land-law of Kentucky.—Adverse possession.—Landlord and tenant. Constructive possession. Jenkin Phillips, on the 18th May 1780, “ enters one thousand acres on the south-west side of Licking creek, on a branch called Buck-lick creek, on the lower side of said creek, beginning at the mouth of the branch, and running up the branch for quantity, including three cabins; * a survey was made on this entry, the 20th November 1795, taking Buck-lick branch reducea to a straight line as its base, and laying off the quantity in a rectangle on the nort-wes o Buck-lick; a patent was granted to'Phillips on this survey,on the 26th June, 1796 This entry is sufficiently descriptive, according to the well-established principles of this and t e cour s o Kentucky, and gave Phillips the prior equity to the land, which has been duly followe up an consummated, by a grant, within the time required by the laws of Virginia and Kentucky, without any laches which can impair it. The proper survey under this entry was to make the line following the general course of Buck-lick the centre instead of the base line o t e survey, Peyton v. Stith. and to lay off an equal quantity on each side, in a rectangular form, according to the rule established by the court of appeals in Kentucky, and by this court. Peyton claimed the land, under an entry made by Francis Peyton, and a survey on the 9th October 1784, and a patent on the 24th December 1785, so that the case was that of a claim of the prior equity, against the elder grant, which it was admitted, carried the legal title. Stith took possession, as tenant of the heirs of Peyton, under an agreement for one year, at twenty dollars per year; possession was afterwards demanded of him, on behalf of the lessors, which he refused to deliver—and a warrant for forcible entry and detainer was, on their complaint issued against him, according to the law of Kentucky, and on an inquisition, he was found • guilty; but on a traverse of the inquisition, he was acquitted, and an ejectment was brought against him by the lessors ; eight days after the finding of the inquisition, Stith purchased the land from Phillips. This is the case of on unsuccessful attempt by a landlord, to recover possession from an obstinate tenant, whose refusal could not destroy the tenure by which he remained on the premises, nor impair any of the relations which the law established between them ; the judgment on the acquittal concluded nothing but the facts necessary to sustain the prosecution, and which could be legally at issue; title could not be set up as a defence; Stith could not avail himself of the purchase from Phillips. A judgment for either party left their rights of property wholly unaffected, except as to the mere possession; the acquittal could only disaffirm the forcible entry, as nothing else was at issue; the tenancy was not determined Peyton was not ousted; and the possession did not become less the possession of the landlord by any legal consequences resulting from the acquittal. In the case of Willison v. Watkins, 3 Pet. 44, this court considered and declared the law to be settled—that a purchase by a tenant of an adverse title, claiming under or attorning to it, or any other disclaimer of tenure, with the knowledge of the landlord, was a forfeiture of his term ; that his possession became so far adverse, that the act of limitations would begin to run in his favor, from the time of such forfeiture, and the landlord could sustain an ejectment
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
appellee. The relief sought by the complainant in the circuit court was founded on the allegation, that one Jenkin Phillips, under whom he claimed, made the first entry on the land in controversy; although it was admitted, that the plaintiffs in the ejectment held under the eldest patent.
The circuit court decreed a perpetual injunction, as to so much of the land as fell within a certain location made under a survey ordered by that court, within the bounds of Jenkin Phillips, conveyed to the complainant. From the decree, the respondents appealed to this court. The facts are fully stated in the opinion of the court.
*The case was argued by Taylor and Jones, for the appellants ; and by Bibb and Daniels, for the appellees. *-
Baldwin, Justice, delivered the opinion of the court.—The subject of this controversy is a tract of land, situated on Kingston fork of Licking creek, and Buck-lick creek, a branch thereof. Stith, the complainant below, claims title under an entry made by Jenkin Phillips, on the 18th of May 1780, in the following words. “ Jenkin Phillips enters one thousand acres on the south-west side of Licking creek, on a branch called Buck-lick creek, on the lower side of said creek ; beginning at the mouth of the branch, and running up the branch for quantity, including three cabins.” A survey was made on this entry, on the 20th November 1795, taking Buck-lick branch, reduced to a straight line, as its base, and laying off the quantity in a rectangle on the north-west side of Buck-lick. A patent was granted to Phillips on this survey, on the 26th of June 1796, who, on the 8th of February 1814, conveyed to Stith 666 acres thereof, including the land in controversy. Stith was then in possession of the land, under the circumstances which will be hereafter referred to.
The appellant claimed under an entry made by Francis Peyton for 1000 acres, a survey on the 9th of October 1784, and a patent on the 24th of December 1785 ; so that the case presented was, of Stith claiming the prior equity against the elder grant, which, it is admitted, carried the legal title. No question arose on the validity of Peyton’s entry, as his elder grant was conclusive, unless an equity arose in Phillips, by his prior entry ; but the validity of this entry was questioned by the appellant, on several grounds, involving no general principles which are necessary to be settled by the court, but only those arrismg on matters of fact and detail, which have no bearing on the merits of the case. We entertain no doubt of the validity of the entry : its calls are sufficiently descriptive, according to the well-estab-ished principles of this, and the courts of Kentucky, and give Phillips the prior equity to the land, which has been duly followed up and consummated a grant, within the time required by the *laws of Virginia and Kentucky, without any laches which can impair it. *- $$
This entry was much contested, both parties objecting to the survey as executed in November 1795. The circuit court were of opinion, that the entry ought to be so surveyed, as to make the line following the general course of Buck-lick, the centre, instead of the base line of the survey, and o lay off an equal quantity on each side, in a rectangular form, according to ® PU^e es^a^Kshed by the court of appeals in Kentucky, in Hardin 59, 2 W 1 Bibb ?9’ 107 ’ 2 Ibid’ 122 ; 4 Ibid. 153, 383 ; and in this court, in heat. 323, with which we fully concur. As the survey of 1795, and the [p. 314] one directed by the circuit court, both embrace all the land in dispute about which any contest arises, it is unnecessary to not ce them minutely, as in our opinion, the entry and survey of Phillips gave him an equitable title which attached to the land, elder than Peyton’s, and would entitle the complainant to a decree ; unless the case discloses such facts as, independent of the original titles, present a bar to the relief he asks.
It is alleged by the appellant, that one Jeremiah Wilson, in the year 1792 or 1793, came to the land in question, within the lines of Peyton’s patent, and resided there until the month of March 1795, when he took a lease for five years from the agent of Peyton, and continued to reside there for some years ; that from Wilson’s first settlement, there was a continued uninterrupted possession of the land by tenants, and persons holding under Peyton and his heirs, till Stith, the complainant, took possession, as tenant of Peyton’s heirs, under an agreement with one Mitchell, who acted as their agent, under a verbal authority from some of them ; and that he remained there until December 1813, when possession was demanded of him on behalf of the appellants, which he refused to deliver up. Whereupon, a warrant of forcible entry and detainer was, on their complaint, issued by a justice of peace, on the 27th of January 1814, and an inquisition taken on the 1st of February, finding Stith guilty; but that on a traverse of the inquisition, in April following, he was acquitted. An ejectment was then brought against him by the appellants, and judgment rendered for the plaintiffs, at the * 1 November term of the circuit court *1816 ; when the present bill was J filed, praying for an injunction against further proceedings on the ejectment, and a conveyance of the legal title to the land recovered. An injunction was ordered. The respondents, in their answer, allege, that the complainant was put into possession, as the tenant of their ancestor, by his agent; but afterwards took protection under Jenkin Phillips, with the fraudulent purpose of cheating and defrauding him.
To this answer, a special replication was put in by the complainant, averring that he did not enter as tenant aforesaid ; and sets up the proceedings of forcible entry and detainer, and his acquittal; and relies on them for further replication in bar of the allegation. An amended answer was, by leave of the court, and on terms, afterwards filed, averring that the complainant rented the land and entered thereon as the tenant of Peyton, and continued to reside as such tenant, until he purchased from Phillips; and that he ought not to be permitted to set up any adverse title, until he would surrender possession to the respondents. They rely on their uninterrupte possession, plead the act of limitations of 1809 as a bar to the relief sought by the bill, and aver, that the bill ought not to be sustained, as the complainant is colluding with another, contrary to every principle of morality.
To this amended answer, the complainant demurred : 1. Because the act of 1809 was a violation of the compact between the states of Virginia an Kentucky. 2. If the law is not void, the respondents cannot avail them selves of it, as they were not, and the complainant was, settled on an. actually in possession of the premises in question, when the bill was fi e< , holding and claiming under the title set forth in his bill. 3. That t e respondents had not the actual and continual possession for the number o years required by the law, next preceding the filing of the bill, but were ousted and possession held by complainant. 4. That the complainant an [p. 315] respondent were in actual litigation, in the action of ejectment, of their relative rights under their titles, on the 1st January 1816, and long before, and until the filng of this bill. On these pleadings, and a great mass of depositions taken in the cause, the circuit court rendered a decree for the complainant.
On a careful examination of the whole record, we are *abundantly
•7 - . “ | *490
satisfied, that the appellants have fully established the fact of the L tenancy of Stith, at the time he entered on the land, It is positively sworn to by three witnesses, and contradicted by none. His demurrer to the amended answer admits it most distinctly; as well as the continuance of the tenancy down to his purchase from Phillips. If this part of the case rested only on the evidence in the cause, unsupported by the demurrer, we should require nothing more to satisfy our minds ; but connected with the solemn admission on record, it presents a case cleared of all possible doubt. The agreement by which he rented the land, was for one year, at a rent of twenty dollars, payable in November 1811. By continuing in possession, he remained a tenant from year to year, his possession being, in law, the possession of Peyton or his heirs, with all the relations of landlord and tenant subsisting between them in full force.
It appears, that Stith refused to surrender up the premises, on a demand made by the agent of Peyton, in December 1813 ; inconsequence of which, he instituted a proceeding before a justice of the peace, in pursuance to the law of Kentucky relating to forcible entry and retainer. 4 Litt. Laws 182. This law contains provisions similar to the statutes of Ric. III., adopted or substantially re-enacted in all the states ; and authorizes the same proceedings against tenants, who, after the expiration of their term, refuse to restore the possession to the landlord. On this proceeding, an inquisition was found against Stith, on the 1st of February 1814 ; but he was acquitted on a traverse tried in April following. The record does not state explicitly the object of this process, whether it was to proceed for the forcible entry, or only for the detainer; the warrant is in the form directed by the second section of the law, embracing both, which are charged as having been committed on the 22d of December 1813. This, connected with the proof in the cause, and the admission of the tenancy of Stith, in his demurrer to the amended answer to the bill, leaves no doubt, that the proceeding was against him as a tenant holding over, and coming within the provisions of the 16th section of the law. This is the more apparent, when there appears no evidence, that prior to the purchase from Phillips, eight days after the finding of the inquisition, Stith has done any act disavowing his p tenancy, except the refusal to surrender possession. Thus considered, the case is an unsuccessful attempt by a landlord, to recovei' possession from an obstinate tenant; whose refusal could not destroy the tenure by which he remained on the premises, nor impair any of the relations which the law established between them. The effect of the acquittal extended no further than to deprive the landlord of the benefits expected from this process, and turn him round to the ejectment which he afterwards brought. The judgment on the acquittal concluded nothing but the facts necessary to sustain the prosecution, and which could be legally in issue. If a case is made out, within the 16th section of the lav/, it declares, “the tenant shall . adjudged guilty of a forcible detainer and this was the matter to be inquired into. Title could not be set up as a defence; Stith could not avail [p. 316] himself of the purchase from Phillips ; a judgment for either party left their rights of property wholly unaffected, except as to the mere possession ; and the acquittal could only disaffirm the forcible detainer, as nothing else was in issue. It was conclusive on the landlord as to that; but in all other respects, the rights and relations of the parties remained as before the institution of the process. The tenancy was not determined ; Peyton was not ousted, and the possession did not become less the possession of the landlord, by any legal consequences resulting from the acquittal; unless the relative situation of the parties as landlord and tenant became changed by the purchase from Phillips, after the inquisition and before the traverse.
In the case of Willison v. Watkins, 3 Pet. 44, decided at the last term, this court considered and declared the law to be settled, that a purchase by a tenant of an adverse title, claiming under or attorning to it, or any other disclaimer of tenure, with the knowledge of the landlord, was a forfeiture of his term ; that his possession became so far adverse, that the act of limitations could begin to run in his favor, from the time of such forfeiture; and the landlord could sustain ejectment against him, without notice to quit, at any time before the period prescribed by the statute had expired, by the mere force of the tenure, without any other evidence than the proof of the * .. tenancy ; but that the tenant could in no case contest the *right of J his landlord to possession, or defend himself by any claim or title
adverse to him, during the time which the statute has to run. If the landlord suffers it to run out, without making an entry, or bringing a suit, each party may stand upon their right ; but until then, the possession of the tenant is the possession of the landlord.
Tested by these principles, the purchase from Phillips, in 1814, can have no effect on the merits of this case. Though the possession of Stith became, from that time, adverse for these specified purposes, it remained fiduciary for all others. He could not assert an adversary title, without surrendering possession. The law recognises him as having no rights of property in the lands, unless such as grow out of his tenure; his title must remain dormant, while he retains possession for a less term than prescribed by law ; it may become active, whenever he abandons the possession, or it is protected by the limitation. The same principles which would prevent a tenant from contesting his landlord’s title in a court of law, would apply with greater force in a court of equity, to which he would apply, for the quieting of a tortious possession, and a conveyance of the legal'title. If the relations subsisting between them could deprive him of defence at law, a court of chancery could not afford him relief as a plaintiff, during their continuance. Before he can be heard in either, in assertion of his title, he must be out of possession, unless it has become legalized by time ; and even then, there may be cases where an equitable title had been purchased, under such circumstances as would justify a court of equity in withholding their aid to a maid fide purchaser.
It is not necessary to decide, whether this is such an one, since we are very clear, that the present complainant can, on no principle of law or equity, have any claims on the interference of this court, to prevent t e respondents from obtaining, by their judgment in ejectment, a restoiation of the demised premises. This is his right, by the terms and effect o t e tenure ; on the faith of which the one party gave, and the other receive [p. 317] possession. As the possession of the plaintiff has been continuous, from the first entry, as a tenant, his remaining, after the purchase from Phillips, is neither an ouster *nor disseisin of Peyton, so as to put him to the assertion of his right under his patent. The possession of Stith must *- be interrupted, and its continuity broken, before he can be permitted to sustain any proceeding, founded on the equitable title thus acquired. For, admitting his possession to be so far adverse, that the limitation began to run from February, 1814, the right of the plaintiffs in the ejectment to possession, on the termination 'of the tenancy, remains unimpaired, and is as much to be respected in a court of equity as of law ; it being an attribute and incident of the tenancy which attaches to it, notwithstanding any act of the tenant, short of a voluntary restoration of the premises, or undisturbed occupation for seven years, by the law of 1809.
This view of the case is fatal to the proceeding in equity, commenced while the complainant is residing on the land demised, and before the expiration of three years from the commencement of his disclaimer, or adversary holding with the knowledge of Peyton.
There is another objection to the relief sought for by the complainant, which seems to the court to be conclusive. On an attentive examination of the evidence returned with the record, we are of opinion, that a continued and uninterrupted possession for twenty years in Peyton and his heirs, prior to the filing of the bill, has been fully proved. There appears to have been no point of time, since the first entry of Wilson, in 1792 or 1793, within which the premises have been unoccupied by him ; as Peyton held the legal title, the possession under him extends to the bounds of his survey ; and is as complete to the whole, as if the actual occupation was co-extensive with his grant.
It is proved, without contradiction, that the land was in the woods, wholly unimproved, when Wilson first entered ; and there is no evidence to show that, when he leased from Peyton, in March 1795, any other person was upon the ground. His patent gave him legal seisin, and constructive possession, of all the land within his survey. Harr v. Gratz, 4 Wheat. 222 ; Green v. Liter, 8 Cranch 250. Though Wilson’s first entry was without claim of title in himself or any other, his attornment to the title of Peyton, in 1795, will make his possession relate back to his first entry ; *and ■.* connected with the legal possession, give to Peyton all the benefits of ■- actual occupation, from that time. But even confining him to the period of actual occupation under his title ; it appears, that twenty-one years and eight months had elapsed, before the filing of the complainant’s bill. This would afford at law a complete bar to an ejectment under the title of Phillips ; and courts of equity adopt the same rule by analogy. Hughes v. Edwards, 9 Wheat. 489 ; Elmendorf v. Taylor, 10 Ibid. 152.
The continuity of the possession does not apppear to have been broken ; there is evidence of an attempt made by Phillips, and Riley, his son-in-law, to tamper and collude with the tenants to attorn him ; and some of the witnesses speak of declarations of some of the tenants, of their having some sort ^connection with his title ; but in what way does not satisfactorily appear, nere is no evidence of any agreement between him and any of them ; on e contrary, there is clear evidence of the tenancy of all the occupants
under Peyton, from the entry of Wilson down to the lease to Stith ; and [p. 318] no fact is disclosed, in any of the depositions, which would in law amount to a disclaimei’ of the tenure, by any of the tenants, an attornment to Phillips, or possession adverse to the landlord. There seems nothing which would make out such an adverse possession in Phillips, as would interrupt that of Peyton ; and though there are some circumstances in evidence, of an equivocal character, they cannot amount to a disseisin or ouster, nor dissolve the relations resulting from the original acknowledged relations between him and his tenants, which continued until the filing of the bill. Such continued possession for twenty years, under the legal title of Peyton, constitutes a complete bar to all the relief prayed for in the bill.
It is, therefore, the opinion of the court, that the decree of the circuit court be reversed, and that the cause be remanded, with instructions to dismiss the bill of the complainants, with costs, but without prejudice to the right of the complainant, accruing or vested in him by any deed or contract with Luckett, or any other person, in relation to any part of the land contained in either of the surveys of Peyton.
Decree reversed.
1
A bill for an account lies only when an are all on one side, and no discovery is sought or required. Gloninger v. Hazard, 42 Penn. St. action of account lies at law, and the case 389, See Bank of Kentucky v. Schuylkill comes under some appropriate head of equity jurisdiction. Baker v. Biddle, Bald. 394. To Bank, 1 Pars. 180.
2
See Coopers. Hatton, 12 Price 602; Moses sustain a bill for an account, there must be v. Lewis, Ibid.; Parrot v. Palmer, 3 Myl. & & mutual demands. Porter ®. Spencer, 2 Johns. 632; Kingv. Rosset, 2 Y. & J. 33; Hemings»'. Oh. 169; Dinwiddie v. Bailey, 6 Ves. 141. Equity has no jurisdiction, when the accounts Pugh, 4 Giff. 456.
*
against him, without notice to quit, at any time before the period prescribed by the statute J had expired, by the mere force of the tenure; without any other evidence than the proof of, the tenancy; but that the tenant could in no case contest the right of his landlord to possession, or defend himself by any claim or title adverse to him, during the time which the statute had to run. If the landlord, under such circumstances, suffers the time prescribed by the statute of limitations to run out, without making an entry or bringing a suit, each party may stand upon their right; but, until then, the possession of the tenant is the possession of the landlord. From the time of the purchase by Stith from Phillips, although it became adverse for the specified purposes, it remained fiduciary for all others. The same principles which would prevent a tenant from contesting his landlord’s title in a court of law, would apply with greater force in a court of equity, to which he would apply for the quieting of a tortious possession, and a conveyance of the legal title; if the relations existing between them could deprive them of defence at law, a court of chancery would not afford him relief as a plaintiff, during their continuance; before he can be heard in either, in assertion of his title, he must be out of possession, unless it has become legalized by time; and even then, there may be cases where an equitable title had been purchased, under such circumstances as could justify a court of equity in withholding their aid to a maid, fide purchaser.1 A patent for unimproved lands, no part of which was in the possession of any one, at the time it issued, gives legal seisin and constructive possession of all the land within the survey. Courts of equity adopt the same rule as to possession, to bar a recovery in ejectment, as courts of law. Appeal from the Circuit Court of Kentucky. In that court, Joseph Stith, the appellee, filed a bill for an injunction, to stay perpetually proceed-by the appellants, on a judgment obtained by them, in an ejectment instituted by them, as the devisees of Francis Peyton, against Joseph Stith, the
1
It is the settled law of the country, that a faith between landlord and tenant.” Galloway tenant shall not resist the recovery of his land- v. Ogle, 2 Binn. 473. And in the same case, Judge Yeates says, that to permit him to do lord, by virtue of an adverse title acquired so is manifestly against good faith, and tends during his lease. Chief Justice Tilghman says, “this principle is founded on sound policy, to great immorality. Id. 473. because it tends to encourage honest and good
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access