N.Y. Life Ins. Co. v. Gamer, 303 U.S. 161 (1938)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
N.Y. Life Ins. Co. v. Gamer, 303 U.S. 161 (1938)
Full caption
NEW YORK LIFE INSURANCE CO. v. GAMER, EXECUTRIX.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Feb. 14, 1938
NEW YORK LIFE INSURANCE CO. v. GAMER,
EXECUTRIX.
CERTIORARI TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE
NINTH CIRCUIT.
No. 323. Argued January 13, 1938.—Decided February 14, 1938.
A life insurance company stipulated to pay double indemnity (twice the face of the policy) upon receipt of due proof that death of the insured resulted, directly and independently of ail other causes, from bodily injury effected solely through extemal, violent and accidentai means, but that double indemnity should not be payable if the death resulted from self-destruction. The insured died of a rifle shot. In an action on the policy in which only the right to the additional payment was in controversy, the issue raised by the pleadings was whether the death was accidentai, the company claiming suicide. Held:
1. That the burden was upon the plaintiff to prove by a prépondérance of the evidence that the death was accidentai. P. 171.
2. -The presumption that the death was due to accident rather than suicide lost its application to the case when evidence was introduced sufficient to sustain a finding that death was not due to accident. Id.
3. This presumption requiring the inference of accident rather than suicide in a case of violent death is a rule of law; it is not evidence and may not be given the weight of evidence. Id.
Travellers’ Insurance Co. v. McConkey, 127 U. S. 661, distinguished.
90 F. (2d) 817, reversed.
Certiorari, 302 U. S. 670, to review the affirmance of a judgment recovered by the présent respondent in an action on a life insurance policy. See also 76 F. (2d) 543.
Mr. J. A. Poore, with whom Messrs. M. S. Gunn and Charles R. Leonard were on the brief, for petitioner.
The physical facts show suicide. It is unnecessary to show motive. New York Life Ins. Co. v. Trimble, 69 F. (2d) 849, 851; Aetna Life Ins. Co. v. Tooley, 16 F. (2d) 243, 244; Burkett v. New York Life Ins. Co., 56 F. (2d)
53383°—38-------11
Argument for Petitioner. 303 U. S.
105, 107, 108; but in the record there is evidence of motive.
Surmise or conjecture of accident will not sustain the judgment. Pennsylvania Ry. Co. v. Chamberlain, 288 U. S. 333; New York Life Ins. Co. v. Anderson, 66 F. (2d) 705, 709; Frankel v. New York Life Ins. Co., 51 F. (2d) 933, 935; Aetna Life Ins. Co. v. Tooley, 16 F. (2d) 243, 245; New York Life Ins. Co. v. Alman, 22 F. (2d) 98, 101; Burkett v. New York Life Ins. Co., 56 F. (2d) 105, 108; Stevens v. White City, 285 U. S. 195.
The District Court should hâve sustained the motion for a directed verdict for the défendant.
The complaint allégés that the death of the insured “resulted directly and independently of ail other causes from bodily in jury effected solely through external, violent and accidentai' means and . . . that the death of said insured did not resuit from self-destruction (but) resulted directly from the accidentai discharge of a fire-arm, to-wit: a rifle. . .
The answer déniés that the death of insured resulted from the accidentai discharge of a rifle, and allégés that the death of the insured resulted from self-destruction.
This is not a suit for death, but for death by accident. The défendant at ail times offered to pay the death claim, and tendered the money in exchange for a full release, which was refused.
The burden is upon-the plaintiff to prove her cause of action, “death by accident,” which proof would négative death by intention. U. S. Fidelity & Guaranty Co. v. Blum, 270 Fed. 946; Travelers’ Ins. Co. v. Wilkes, 76 F. (2d) 701; (International Life Ins. Co. v. Carroll, 17 F. (2d) 42, 43, distinguished) ; Jefferson Standard Life Ins. Co. v. Clemmer, 79 F. (2d) 724; Fédéral Life Ins. Co. v. Zebec, 82 F. (2d) 961, 963; New Amsterdam Casualty Co. N. Breschini, 64 F. (2d) 887, 890; Fidelity & Casualty Co. v. Driver, 79 F. (2d) 713, 714.
161 Argument for Petitioner.
It seems clear that if the plaintiff must show death by accident, it must négative death by intentional means, such as suicide; and if the défendant must prove death by suicide, it must likewise négative death by accident. Travelers’ Insurance Co. v. McConkey, 127 U. S. 661, distinguished.
The cause of death being unexplained, a presumption arises in accordance with human expérience that it was not caused by suicide, and this presumption temporarily aided the plaintiff on whom was the burden of persuasion. This required the défendant to go forward with its evidence, or the issue of suicide would go against it, but did not place the burden on défendant of proving suicide, or change the burden of proof resting on the plaintiff. Mobile v. Turnipseed, 219 U. S. 35.
The proper construction and interprétation to be placed upon the McConkey case has given rise to much contrariety of opinion. See Jefferson Standard Life Ins. Co. v. Clemmer, 79 F. (2d) 724, 731.
The Circuit Court of Appeals erred in sustaining the instructions to the jury that the presumption of law is that the death was not voluntary; that this presumption has the weight and effect of evidence, and is binding on the jury and they must find according to the presumption until it is overcome by evidence, and that the burden of overcoming such presumption is on the defendant. Mobile v. Turnipseed, 219 U. S. 35; Western & A. R. Co. v. Henderson, 279 U. S. 639; Heiner v. Donnan, 285 U. S. 312; Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Ford, 287 U. S. 502; Del Vecchio v. Bowers, 296 U. S.
280. [Citing many cases in the Circuit Courts of Appeals, including Ariasi v. Orient Insurance Co., 50 F. (2d) 548, from the Ninth Circuit.] Also: Thayer, Preliminary Treatise on Evidence, pages 314, 336, 337, 339; 5 Wigmore on Evidence, 2d ed., §§ 2487-2498, and chap. 88; Jones’ Commentaries on Evidence, 2d ed. 1926, §§ 30, 256.
Mr. William Meyer, with whom Mr. Francis P. Kelly was on the brief, for respondent.
It is our contention that upon the trial plaintiff was required to prove that Gamer died on the morning of April lOth and that he died as a resuit of external and violent means. This proof was then aided by the presumption of law that his death was accidentai, which, in the absence of contradictory proof, was sufficient to take the case to the jury. The evidence in this case was sufficient to take the case to the jury, if indeed it did not justify a directed verdict for plaintiff. Gunning v. Cooley, 281 U. S. 90; Small Company v. Lamborn, 267 U. S. 248; Murray Co. v. Harrill, 51 F. (2d) 883, 884; Pythian Knights v. Beck, 181 U. S. 49. See also, Missouri State Life Ins. Co. v. West, 67 F. (2d) 468; Fidélity & Casualty Co. v. Pittinger, 63 F. (2d) 880; Home Benefit Assn. v. Sargent, 142 U. S. 691; Gamer v. New York Life Ins. Co., 76 F. (2d) 543.
It is generally held that the defense that death resulted from causes which by the terms of the policy relieve the insurer from liability, is an affirmative defense, to be alleged by insurer in its answer. Sullivan-v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co., 96 Mont. 254, 266; 29 P. (2d) 1064; Kingsland v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co., 97 Mont. 558, 569; 37 P. (2d) 335; Vicars N. Aetna Life Ins. Co., 158 Ky. 1; 164 S. W. 106; Dènt v. National Life & Accident Ins. Co., 6 S. W. (2d) 195; American Central Life Ins. Co. v. Alexander, 39 S. W. (2d) 86.
It is for the jury to décidé whether death was accidentai, as neither suicide nor murder will be presumed from the killing of an individual. McClur v. New York Life Ins. Co., 50 F. (2d) 972; Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Broyer, 20 F. (2d) 818, 820; Wells Fargo Co. v. Mutual Life Ins. Co., 66 F. (2d) 890, 893; Connecticut Life Ins. Co. v. Maher, 70 F. (2d) 441.
The decision upon the first appeal is now the law of the case.
Travelers’ Insurance Co. v. McConkey, 127 U. S. 661, has not been disapproved by this Court.
[Counsel invited attention to certain statutes of Montana defining presumption, and to Montana decisions; State N. District Court, 72 Mont. 213; 232 Pac. 201, 203
(3) ; Arnold v. Genzberger, 31 P. (2d) 296, 305; Renland v. First National Bank, 90 Mont. 424; 4 P. (2d) 488; McMahon v. Cooney, 95 Mont. 138; 25 P. (2d) 131; Nichols v. New York Life Ins. Co., 88 Mont. 132, 292 Pac. 253; Maki v. Murray Hospital, 91 Mont. 251; 7 P. (2d) 228, 232; State v. Nielson, 57 Mont. 137; 187 Pac. 639; Union Bank & Trust Co. v. State Bank, 103 Mont. 260; 62 P. (2d) 677, 684; also to many California cases.]
Mr. Justice Butler delivered the opinion of the Court.
April 10, 1933, the deceased died by gunshot. Petitioner had insured his life by a policy in which it agreed to pay his executors ten thousand dollars upon proof of death without regard to its cause, or twenty thousand dollars in case of death resulting from accident as defined by a provision the pertinent parts of which follow. “The Double Indemnity . . . shall be payable upon receipt of due proof that the death of the Insured resulted directly and independently of ail other causes from bodily injury effected solely through external, violent and accidentai means . . . Double Indemnity shall not be payable if the Insured’s death resulted from self-destruction, whether sane or insane.”
Respondent sued petitioner in a state court for twenty thousand dollars. There being diversity of citizenship, défendant removed the case to the fédéral court for the district of Montana. The complaint allégés that the death of the insured resulted directly and independently of ail other causes from bodily injury effected solely through external, violent and accidentai means and did not resuit from self-destruction but directly from the accidentai discharge of a rifle.
Defendant’s answer concédés that plaintiff is entitled to the face of the policy, and allégés a deposit of that amount with interest in court. It déniés that death resulted from bodily injury effected through accidentai means; and specifically déniés that it resulted from the accidentai discharge of a rifle or other fire-arm. And “as an affirmative defense,” it allégés that the death of the insured resulted from self-destruction by intentionally discharging a loaded rifle into his body with intent to take his life.
The case came on for trial and, at the close of the evidence, the judge on motion of défendant directed the jury to return a verdict in its favor. Plaintiff appealed; the circuit court of appeals held that the question whether the death was accidentai should hâve been submitted to the jury, and reversed the judgment. 76 F. (2d) 543. At the second trial plaintiff went forward; at the close of ail the evidence défendant requestëd the court to direct a verdict in its favor, insisting that plaintiff had failed to prove accidentai death and that the evidence showed death was caused by self-destruction, and was not sufficient to sustain a verdict for the plaintiff. The court denied the motion and submitted the case to the jury.
Its charge contained the following:
“In this case the défendant allégés that the death of E. Walter Gamer was caused by suicide. The burden of proving this allégation by a prépondérance, or greater weight of the evidence is upon the défendant. The presumption of law is that the death was not voluntary and the défendant . . . must overcome this presumption and satisfy the jury by a prépondérance of the evidence that his death was voluntary.
“Ordinarily ... in the absence of a plea by the défendant of suicide or self-destruction the burden would be upon, and it still is upon the plaintiff in this case to prove that Walter Gamer died from external, violent and p. 167accidental means, but by its answer . . . the . . . Company has admitted that . . . [he] died through external and violent means. . . . The question remains as to whether the death was accidentally caused, or the meanS of the death was accidentai or whether it was suicide. But when the défendant took the position that it takes here it assumed the burden of proving to you by a prépondérance of the evidence that Walter Gamer killed himself voluntarily. . . .
“The presumption of law is that the death was not voluntary and the défendant in order to sustain the issue of suicide . . . must overcome this presumption and satisfy the jury, by a prépondérance of the evidence, that his death was voluntary . . .”
The jury gave plaintiff a verdict for twenty thousand dollars with interest, and the court entered judgment in her favor for that amount. Défendant appealed, alleging that the trial judge erred in denying its motion for a directed verdict and in giving each of the quoted instructions. The circuit court of appeals affirmed. 90 F. (2d) 817. This Court granted a writ of certiorari.
There are presented for decision, questions whether the trial court erred in refusing to direct a verdict for défendant or in giving any of the instructions quoted above.
The circuit court of appeals has twice held the evidence sufîicient to sustain a verdict for plaintiff. It found that the facts brought forward at the second trial are not substantially different from those presented on the first appeal. There is no substantial controversy as to the principal evidentiary circumstances upon which dépends decision of the controlling issue, whether the death of the insured was accidentai. As we are of opinion that the trial court erred in giving the challenged instructions, and the judgment is to be reversed and the case remanded to the district court where another trial may be had, we p. 168refrain from discussion of the evidence. We find it sufficient to sustain a verdict for or against either party. Defendant was not entitled to a mandatory instruction.
The form and substance of the challenged instructions suggest that the trial judge followed those brought before this Court in Traveïlers’ Ins. Co. v. McConkey, 127 U. S. 661. The opinion of the circuit court of appeals reads that case to require approval of the instructions here in question. As it has not been uniformly interpreted, we shall examine its principal features. There the accident policy sued on covered bodily injuries effected through external, violent and accidentai means when such injuries alone occasioned death or disability. A proviso declared that no claim should be made under the policy when the death or injury had been caused by suicide, or by intentional injuries inflicted by the insured or by any other person. The complaint alleged that the insured had been accidently shot by a person or persons unknown to plaintiff, by reason of which he instantly died. The answer denied that death was occasioned by bodily injuries effected through external, violent and accidentai means, and alleged that it was caused by suicide, or by intentional injuries inflicted either by the insured or by some other person.
The statement of the case quotes the following instructions (pp. 663-664) :
“The plaintiff . . . gives evidence of the fact that the insured was found dead . . . from a pistol shot through the heart. This evidence satisfies the terms of the policy with respect to the fact that the assured came to his death by ‘external and violent means,’ and the only question is whether the means by which he came to his death were also ‘accidentai.’
“It is manifest that self-destruction cannot be presumed. . . . The plaintiff is therefore entitled to recover unless the défendant has by competent evidence overcome p. 169this presumption and satisfied the jury by a prépondérance of evidence that the injuries which caused the death of the insured were intentional on his part.
“Neither is murder to be presumed . . .; but if the jury find . . . that the insured was in fact murdered, the death was an accident as to him ... If . . . the injuries of the insured . . . were not intentional on his part the plaintiff has a right to recover. . . . The inquiry . . . is resolved into a question of suicide, because if the insured was murdered the destruction of his life was not intentional on his part.
“The défendant, in its answer, allégés that the death of the insured was caused by suicide. The burden of proving this allégation by a prépondérance of evidence rests on the défendant.”
This Court held that the trial judge erred in charging that if the insured was murdered plaintiff was entitled to recover and on that ground reversed the judgment and remanded the case with directions to grant a new trial.
It was not necessary to consider any other question. But, for guidance of the trial ordered, the Court discussed other parts of the charge.
At the outset the opinion déclarés that under the issue presented by the general déniai it was incumbent on plaintiff to show that the death was the resuit not only of extemal and violent, but also of accidentai means. It states that the two “principal facts to be established were external violence and accidentai means, producing death. The first was established when it appeared that death ensued from a pistol shot through the heart of the insured. The evidence on that point was direct and positive; . . . Were the means by which the insured came to his death also accidentai? If he committed suicide, then the law was for the company, because the policy . . . did not extend to . . . self-destruction . . .”
The opinion proceeds (p. 667) : “Did the court err in saying to the jury that, upon the issue as to suicide, the p. 170law was for the plaintiff, unless that presumption was overcome by competent evidence? This question must be answered in the négative. The condition that direct-and positive proof must be made of death having been caused by external, violent, and accidentai means, did not deprive the plaintiff, when making such proof, of the benefit of the rules of law established for the guidance of courts and juries in the investigation and détermination of facts.”
The statement just quoted, lacking somewhat of the précision generally found in opinions of the Court prepared by its eminent author, has been variously construed. The question it propounds does not fully reflect the substance of the charge which put on the défendant the burden of proving suicide by prépondérance of the evidence. However, the opinion shows that the burden was on plaintiff to prove death by accident as defined in the contract. It contains nothing to suggest that the court deemed the issue as to burden of proof arising on general déniai to be affected by defendant’s allégation of suicide. It held that if the insured committed suicide, plaintiff had no claim; that, from the fact of death by violence, accident would be presumed, and that unless the presumption was overcome by evidence the law was for plaintiff. The opinion does not indicate the quantum of proof required to put an end to the presumption. It is consistent with, if indeed it does not support, the rule that the presumption is not evidence and ceases upon the introduction of substantial proof to the contrary. Thayer, Preliminary Treatise on Evidence, p. 346. Mobile, J. & K. C. R. Co. v. Turnipseed, 219 U. S. 35,43. Western & Atlantic R. Co. v. Henderson, 279 U. S. 639, 642, 644. Heiner v. Donnan, 285 U. S. 312, 329. Atlantic Coast Line v. Ford, 287 U. S. 502,
506. Del Vecchio v. Bowers, 296 U. S. 280, 286. Nichols v. New York Life Ins. Co., 88 Mont. 132, 139 et seq.; 292 P. 253. The opinion did not definitely sustain any of p. 171the charges to which it referred. It falls far short of sustaining the instructions challenged in the présent case.
Under the contract in the case now before us, double indemnity is payable only on proof of death by accident as there defined. The burden was on plaintiff to allégé and by a prépondérance of the evidence to prove that fact. The complaint alleged accident and negatived self-destruction. The answer denied accident and alleged suicide. Plaintiff’s négation of self-destruction taken with defendant’s allégation of suicide served to narrow the possible field of controversy. Only the issue of accidentai death vel non remained. The question of fact to be tried was precisely the same as if plaintiff merely alleged accidentai death and défendant interposed déniai without more. Travelers’ Ins. Co. N. Wilkes, 76 F. (2d) 701, 705. Fidelity & Casualty Co. v. Driver, 79 F. (2d) 713, 714. Cf. Home Benefit Assn. v. Sargent, 142 U. S. 691.
Upon the fact of violent death without more, the presumption, i. e., the applicable rule of law, required the inference of death by accident rather than by suicide. As the case stood on the pleadings, the law required judgment for plaintiff. Travellers’ Ins. Co. v. McConkey, supra, 665. It was not submitted on pleadings but on pleadings and proof. In his charge the judge had to apply the law to the case as it then was. The evidence being sufficient to sustain a finding that the death was not due to accident, there was no foundation of fact for the application of the presumption; and the case stood for decision by the jury upon the evidence unaffected by the rule that from the fact of violent death, there being nothing to show the contrary, accidentai death will be presumed. The presumption is not evidence and may not be given weight as evidence. Despiau v. United States Casualty Co., 89 F. (2d) 43, 44. Jefferson Standard Life
Black, J., dissenting. 303 U. S.
Ins. Co. v. Clemmer, 79 F. (2d) 724, 730. Travelers’ Ins. Co. v. Wilkes, supra, 705. Fidelity & Casualty Co. n. Driver, supra, 714. Frankel v. New York Life Ins. Co., 51 F. (2d) 933, 935. Océan Accident & Guarantee Corp. v. Schachner, 70 F. (2d) 28, 31. But see: New York Life Ins. Co. v. Ross, 30 F. (2d) 80. Tschudi v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co., 72 F. (2d) 306, 308, 310. Nichols v. New York Life Ins. Co., supra.
In determining whether by the greater weight of evidence it has been established that the death of the insured was accidentai, the jury is required to consider ail admitted and proved facts and circumstances upon which the détermination of that issue dépends and, in reaching its decision, should take into account the probabilities found from the evidence to attend the daims of the respective parties.
The challenged instructions cannot be sustained.
Judgment reversed.
Mr. Justice Cardozo and Mr. Justice Reed took no part in the considération or decision of this case.
Mr. Justice Black, dissenting.
The judgment below rests upon an Insurance policy contract made in Butte, Montana. Plaintiff filed suit for more than $3,000 in a Montana state court, and the Insurance company—because it was not a Montana corporation—was able to remove the suit to the Fédéral District Court. Plaintiff’s judgment in the District Court was affirmed by the Court of Appeals. This Court now reverses plaintiff’s judgment because the District Court instructed the jury that—evidence having established the death of the insured by violent and external means—the law presumed from these facts that the death “was not voluntary and . . . the défendant must overcome this presumption and satisfy the jury by a prépondérance of p. 173161 Black, J., dissenting.
the evidence, that his death was voluntary. . . The policy of insurance was a Montana contract and even though the company was able to remove plaintiff’s case to a Fédéral court, I believe the plaintiff’s rights should be determined by Montana law. Under Montana law I believe the above instructions were proper.
The Suprême Court of Montana has said:1
“Where, as here, death is shown as thé resuit of externat and violent means and the issue is whether it was due to ^accident or suicide, the presumption is in favor of accident”
The majority agréé with the Montana law up to this point, saying:
“Upon the fact of violent death without more, the presumption, i. e., the applicable rule of law, required the inference of death by accident rather than by suicide.” At this point, agreement ends between the rule here declared by the majority and the law of Montana.
Under Montana law the presumption that violent death was accidentai and not suicidai continues and does not disappear unless the evidence “ail points to suicide . . . with such certainty as to preclude any other reasonable hypothesis” ; and the presumption continues for the jury’s considération except “. . . when the evidence points overwhelmingly to suicide as the cause of death.”2
2
Nichols v. New York Life Ins. Co., supra, at 141. In a case involving an action on an insurance policy, in which. the McConkey case, supra, was followed, the Suprême Court of Montana said: “The testimony as to the incidents connected with the death of the insured is slight, but is sufficient to establish the death of insured by extemal and violent means. . . . “. . .if plaintiff had ‘shown by the fair weight of the evidence that the assured came to his death as the resuit of a pistol shot . . ., then the law will présumé that the shot was accidentai, and that it was not inflicted with murderous or suicidai intent. And under such circumstances the burden will be upon the défendant to overcome this presumption, and to show that the death was not caused by accidentai means.’ “It is apparent, therefore, that under the great weight of authority plaintiff’s evidence made a prima fade case. As said by this court in numerous decisions, when a prima fade case is made by plaintiff, the défendant must rebut the case so made, or fail in the action.” Withers n. Pacific Mutual Life Ins. Co., 58 Mont. 485, 491, 492, 493, 494; 193 P. 566, 568. “Testimony constituting a mere contradiction of the facts established presumptively by the prima fade case does not necessarily suffice to overthrow the same. . . . the prima fade case must not only be contradicted but overcome as well. When such case is made, contradictory testimony merely amounts to a conflict in the evidence, with the ultimate facts to be determined by the court or jury, as the case may be.” State v. Nielsen, $7 Mont. 137, 143; 187 P. 639, 640. Cf. Johnson N. Chicago, M. & St. P. Ry. Co., 52 Mont. 73; 155 P. 971. See, Renland v. First National Bank, 90 Mont. 424, 437; 4 P. 2d 488.
Black, J., dissenting. 303 U. S.
Contrary to this clear statement by the Montana Suprême Court is the different rule clearly announced by the majority here in holding that the presumption disappears after the Insurance company introduced evidence merely “suffident to sustain a finding that the death was not due to accident.”
This Court does not find that the evidence in this case excludes every other reasonable hypothesis but suicide or that ail of the evidence points “unerringly to suicide as the cause of death.”3 On the contrary the majority opinion States:
“We find it [the evidence] sufficient to sustain a verdict for or against either party. Défendant was not entitled to a mandatory instruction.”
It is obvious that the majority here déclaré a rule based neither on Montana law nor fédéral statute. This fédéral judicial rule must none the less be followed in suits on insurance policies tried in fédéral courts. The resuit p. 175161 Black, J., dissenting.
is that suits on policies for less than $3,000 tried in state courts will frequently be decided by rules different from the rule which govems similar suits tried in fédéral courts because they involve more than $3,000. In an orderly and consistent System of jurisprudence, it is important that the same law should fix and control the right of recovery on substantially identical contracts made in the same jurisdiction and under the same circumstances. Neither the company nor the policyholder should obtain an advantage by the application of a different law governing the contract merely because the case can be removed to a fédéral court.
It was to avoid such results—among other reasons—that § 725, U. S. C., Title 28, was passed. It provides:
“The laws of the several States, except where the Constitution, treaties, or statutes of the United States otherwise require or provide, shall be regarded as rules of decision in trials at common law, in the courts of the United States, in cases where they apply.”
In this case, the law determining the burden of proof as to suicide affects the substantial rights of the parties.4 Substantial rights arising from an Insurance contract are governed by the law of the state where the contract is made.6 Since the court below instructed the jury in accordance with the law of Montana, I do not believe the charge constituted réversible error.
Nor can I agréé that we should approve a general rule governing trials in fédéral courts which in my judgment transfers jury junctions to judges. The effect of the decision here is to give the trial judge the right to décidé when suffident evidence has been introduced to take jrom the jury the right to find accidentai death from proof of
Black, J., dissenting. 303 U. S.
death by violent and external means. This inevitably follows if the presumption, or right of the jury to infer death by accident, “disappears” whenever the judge believes sufficient evidence of suicide has been introduced.
Stripped of discussions of legal formulas designated as “presumptions” and “burden of proof,” the net resuit of thei rule of “disappearing presumptions” is that trial judges in fédéral courts (irrespective of state rules) hâve the power to détermine when sufficient “substantial evidence” has been produced to justify taking from the jury the right to render a verdict on evidence which—had the judge not found it overcome by contradictory evidence—would hâve justified a verdict. The judge exercises this power as a “trier of fact” although evidence, previously introduced and sufficient to support a verdict, has neither been excluded nor withdrawn.
Proof of death by external and violent means has uniformly been held to establish death by accident. The extreme improbability of suicide is complété justification for a finding of death from accident under these circumstances. While it has been said that this proof of accidentai death was based on “presumption,” in reality—whatever words or formulas are used—what is meant is that a litigant has offered adéquate evidence to establish accidentai death. To attribute this adequacy of proof to a “presumption” does not authorize or empower the judge to say that this “adéquate proof” (identical with legal “presumption”) has “disappeared.” If the evidence offered by plaintiff provides adéquate proof of accidentai death upon which a jury’s verdict can be sustained, mere contradictory evidence cannot overcome the original “adéquate proof” unless the authority having the constitutional power to weigh the evidence and décidé the facts believes the contradictory evidence has overcome the original proof. The jury—not the judge—should décidé when there has been “substantial” evidence which overcomes p. 177161 Syllabus.
the préviens adéquate proof. Here, this Court holds that at the conclusion of plaintiff’s evidence the jury had adéquate proof upon which to find accidentai death, and which would authorize a verdict that insured died as a resuit of accident, but also holds that, after subséquent contradictory evidence of défendant, the judge (not the jury) could décidé that plaintiff’s adéquate proof (presumption) had “disappeared” or had been overcome by this subséquent contradictory testimony. This took from the jury the right to décidé the weight and effect of this subséquent contradictory evidence. Such a rule gives parties a trial by judge, but does not preserve, in its entirety, that trial by jury guaranteed by the Seventh Amendment to the Constitution. I cannot agréé to a conclusion which, I believe, takes away any part of the constitutional right to hâve a jury pass upon the weight of ail of the facts introduced in evidence.
I believe the judgment of the court below should be affirmed.