Com. Credit Co. v. United States, 276 U.S. 226 (1928)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
Com. Credit Co. v. United States, 276 U.S. 226 (1928)
Full caption
COMMERCIAL CREDIT COMPANY v. UNITED STATES
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Feb. 20, 1928
COMMERCIAL CREDIT COMPANY v. UNITED STATES
CERTIORARI TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
No. 258. Argued November 21, 22, 1927.—Decided February 20, 1928.
1. Upon review by certiorari, no questions will be considered except those on which the petition for the writ was based. P. 229. 2. Where a person discovered in the act of unlawfully transporting intoxicating liquor in a vehicle is proceeded against as prescribed by § 26 of the Prohibition Act, and convicted of the unlawful possession incident to the transportation, the vehicle must be disposed of under that section also, which provides protection for the interests of innocent owners or lienors, and not under Rev. Stats. § 3450, which does not provide such protection. P. 232. 17 F. (2d) 902, reversed.
Certiorari, 275 U. S. 511, "to a judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals, which affirmed a decree of the District Court, forfeiting a motor vehicle under § 3450 of the Revised Statutes upon the ground that it had been used [p. 227] in the removal, deposit and concealment of intoxicating liquor, with intent to defraud the United States of the tax thereon. The present petitioner intervened in the libel proceedings to assert its title to the car.
Mr. Duane R. Dills, with whom Messrs. Frank H. Towsley, John J. Kennett, and Charles W. Haswell were on the brief, for petitioner.
Solicitor General Mitchell, with whom Assistant Attorney General Mabel Walker Willebrandt and Mr. Mahlon D. Kiejer, Chief Attorney, Department of Justice, were on the brief, for the United States.
There is no direct conflict between § 26 and § 3450. Section 26 may be construed to make forfeiture proceedings under it permissive, not mandatory. A provision in one statute authorizing forfeiture of guilty interests in a car used for illegal transportation, is not in direct conflict with another statute providing that the whole value of the vehicle may be forfeited if its use is in violation of the Revenue or Customs Laws.
A conviction of the individual for illegal possession, or any other offense, excepting illegal transportation, under the National Prohibition Act, is no bar to a proceeding in rem for forfeiture of the vehicle for tax evasion under § 3450. Such a proceeding is not a prosecution within the meaning of § 5 of the Supplemental Act. There is no such offense as “ possession in transportation.” Where a [p. 228] conviction for possession occurs, no forfeiture of a vehicle under § 26 is entailed, and that section does not come into operation.
The finding of the District Court that an internal-revenue tax was due and unpaid is not open to question here, because not raised in the application for certiorari. See United States v. One Ford Coupe, supra; Port Gardner Investment Company case, supra; United States v. 385 Barrels of Wine, 300 Fed. 565.
Mr. Justice Sanford delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is a libel brought by the United States in November, 1925, in the Federal court for the Western District of Washington, under § 3450 of the Revised Statutes,1 to forfeit a Ford coupe upon the ground that it had been used in the removal, deposit and concealment of intoxicating liquor, with intent to defraud the United States of the tax thereon. The Commercial Credit Co. intervened as claimant, asserting title to the car and alleging that it had no knowledge that the car was used or intended to be used in violation of law.
By stipulation of the parties the case was heard by the district judge without the intervention of a jury. The evidence showed that in October a customs inspector who, in consequence of reports that this car was being used to distribute Canadian liquor about the city of Seattle, had [p. 229] watched its movements for some days, discovered one Campbell—who had purchased the car under a conditional sale—in the act of backing the car out of an alley in the rear of his house, stopped the car, searched it, found that it contained thirteen quarts of whiskey and gin, arrested Campbell, and seized the car. The liquor bore labels indicating that it was of foreign manufacture, and there were no stamps on the bottles showing the payment of duty or internal revenue taxes. It was also stipulated at the hearing that Campbell was prosecuted in the District Court under the National Prohibition Act2 on the charges of “ unlawful possession and transportation of liquor and plead guilty to unlawful possession, whereupon the Government dismissed as to the transportation, and that covers the identical transaction here involved.” Thereafter the Government brought the libel to forfeit the car.3 At the close of the evidence the claimant moved to dismiss the libel, on the ground, among others, that the United States had elected to proceed under the National Prohibition Act and was barred from proceeding under § 3450. The district judge denied this motion, and entered a decree condemning and forfeiting the car to the United States. This was affirmed by the Circuit Court of Appeals, which held that as Campbell’s conviction of unlawfully possessing intoxicating liquor was under § 3 of Title II of the Prohibition Act and did not entail a disposition of the car under § 26 of that Title, the Government was at liberty to proceed under § 3450 for the forfeiture of the car. 17 F. (2d) 902.
1
U. S. C., Tit. 26, § 1181. This section provides that: “Whenever any goods or commodities for or in respect whereof any tax is or shall be imposed . . are removed, or are deposited or concealed in any place, with intent to defraud the United States of such tax, . . every vessel, boat, cart, carriage, or other conveyance whatsoever . . used in the removal or for the deposit or concealment thereof, respectively, shall be forfeited.”
The petition for the writ of certiorari was based solely on the ground that under § 26 of the Prohibition Act the [p. 230] Government was barred from proceeding to forfeit the car under § 3450; and no other question will be considered. Alice State Bank v. Houston Pasture Co., 247 U. S. 240, 242; Webster Co. v. Splitdorj Co., 264 U. S. 463, 464; Steele, Executor, n. Drummond, 275 U. S. 199.
2
41 Stat. 305, c. 85; U. S. C., Tit. 27.
3
This appeared inferentially and, we understand, is admitted.
Sec. 26 provides that: “When the commissioner, his assistants, inspectors, or any officer of the law shall discover any person in the act of transporting in violation of the law, intoxicating liquors in any wagon, buggy, automobile, water or air craft, or other vehicle, it shall be his duty to seize any and all intoxicating liquors found therein being transported contrary to law. Whenever intoxicating liquors transported or possessed illegally shall be seized by an officer he shall take possesion of the vehicle . . and shall arrest any person in charge thereof. Such officer shall at once proceed against the person arrested under the provisions of this title in any court having competent jurisdiction; but the said vehicle or conveyance shall be returned to the owner upon execution by him of a good and valid bond . . approved by said officer and . . conditioned to return said property to the custody of said officer on the day of trial to abide the judgment of the court. The court upon conviction of the person so arrested . . unless good cause to the contrary is shown by the owner, shall order a sale by public auction of the property seized, and the officer making the sale, after deducting the expenses of keeping thé property, the fee for the seizure, and the cost of the sale, shall pay all liens, according to their priorities, which are established, by intervention or otherwise at said hearing or in other proceeding brought for said purpose, as being bona fide and as having been created without the lienor having any notice that the carrying vehicle was being used or was to be used for illegal transportation of liquor, and shall pay the balance of the proceeds into the Treasury of the United States as miscellaneous receipts.”
The essential distinction between § 26 and § 3450 in so far as relates to the forfeiture of a vehicle is that where § 26 is the only applicable provision for its forfeiture the interests of innocent owners and lienors are not forfeited, but where it may be forfeited under § 3450 by reason of its use to evade the payment of a tax the interests of those who are innocent are not saved. United States v. One Ford Coupe, 212 U. S. 321, 325.
In Port Gardner Co. v. United States, 272 U. S. 564, 566, which came to this Court on a certificate of the Circuit Court of Appeals, the driver of an automobile, seized by prohibition agents, had been charged with possession and transportation of intoxicating liquor in violation of the Prohibition Act, and had pleaded guilty to both charges and been sentenced. In answering one of the questions presented by the certificate we held that the “ prosecution with effect ” of the driver of a car under the National Prohibition Act constituted “ an election by the Government to proceed under § 26 of that Act,” and thereby prevented the forfeiture of the car under § 3450. As to this we said: “The disposition of the automobile prescribed in § 26 became mandatory after ” the driver’s “ conviction^ and being inconsistent with the disposition under § 3450 necessarily precluded resort to proceedings under the latter section.”
The claimant states that the question here presented is that which was referred to in a concurring opinion in the Port Gardner Co. case, 567, namely, “whether the prohibition officer discovering one in the act of transportation may disregard the plain and direct commands of § 26 to proceed against the vehicle as there directed ”; and on that assumption the arguments have been largely directed to the question whether, whenever an officer discovers a person in the act of transporting intoxicating liquor in a vehicle, the provisions of § 26 become mandatory in such sense as to furnish the exclusive remedy for the forfeiture [p. 232] of the vehicle.4 But, since it appears that the officer in fact seized the vehicle and arrested Campbell, who was in fact proceeded against under the Prohibition Act, the question of the officer’s duty to proceed under i§ 26 is not here involved.
In this case Campbell was prosecuted both for the unlawful possession and the unlawful transportation of the intoxicating liquors. These are made criminal offenses by § 3 of Title II of the Prohibition Act, and are punishable under § 29 of that Title. Sec. 26—although not in itself making either of these acts a criminal offense—provides that when an officer discovers a person in the act of unlawfully transporting intoxicating liquor in a vehicle, he shall seize both the vehicle and the intoxicating liquors “ transported or possessed illegally,” arrest such person, and proceed against him under the Prohibition Act; and that if such person is convicted the vehicle shall be disposed of as therein prescribed.
The stipulation in this case, read in the light of the evidence, shows that the unlawful possession for which Campbell was prosecuted, and of which he pleaded guilty, was not a separate possession antecedent to and independent of the transportation—which would not have entailed a forfeiture of the car under § 26—but was the possession involved in and incidental to the transportation itself, that is, the “ possession in transportation ” referred to in United States n. One Ford Coupe, supra, 334.
Campbell’s conviction on the charge of such possession, following his arrest when discovered in the act of transportation, required, we think, a disposition of the car under the provisions of § 26. That section, read in its entirety, governs the disposition of the car where the [p. 233] 226 Syllabus.
4
This question was not involved in United States v. One Ford Coupe, supra, 334, in which it did not appear that any person had been discovered in the act of transporting intoxicating liquor in the car.
person in charge of the vehicle is convicted of the unlawful possession incidental to the transportation, as well as where he is convicted of the unlawful transportation itself. Therefore, under the doctrine of the Port Gardner Co. case, the disposition of the car under § 26 becoming mandatory after Campbell’s conviction “ and being inconsistent with the disposition under § 3450, necessarily precluded resort to a proceeding under the latter section.”
This renders it unnecessary to consider whether, if Campbell had not been convicted of the unlawful possession, the Government’s voluntary dismissal of the charge of unlawful transportation, before trial, would likewise have precluded a resort to § 3450.
The decree of the Circuit Court of Appeals is reversed; and the cause will be remanded to the District Court with instructions to dismiss the libel.
Reversed.
Mr. Justice Stone did not sit in this case.
HELLMICH, COLLECTOR, v. ISADORE N. HELLMAN.
SAME v. MILTON C. HELLMAN.
CERTIORARI TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT.
Nos. 299, 300. Argued January 4, 5, 1928.—Decided February 20,
1. Under the Revenue Act of 1918, amounts distributed to the stockholders of a liquidating corporation out of earnings and profits accumulated by the corporation since February 28, 1913, are not to be treated as “dividends,” which, under § 201 (a), are exempt from normal tax, but as payments made by the corporation in exchange for its stock, which are taxable “ as other gains or profits.” § 201 (c). P. 236.
2. The objection that this results in double taxation, cannot prevail over the clearly expressed intention of the statute. P. 237. 18 F. (2d) 239, 244, reversed.
Certiorari, 275 U. S. 513, to review two judgments of the Circuit Court of Appeals sustaining recoveries of money paid under protest as income taxes.
Assistant Attorney General Mabel Walker Willebrandt, with whom Solicitor General Mitchell and Mr. Sewall Key, Attorney in the Department of Justice, were on the brief, for petitioner
Mr. Henry H. Furth for the respondents.
Mr. Justice Sanford delivered the opinion of the Court.
The two Hellmans brought these suits against the Collector to recover additional income taxes assessed against them for the year 1919, under Title II of the Revenue Act of 1918,1 and paid under protest. They recovered judgments in the District Court, which were affirmed by the Circuit Court of Appeals. 18 F. (2d) 239 and 244.
The question here is whether the gains realized by stockholders from the amounts distributed in the liquidation of the assets of a dissolved corporation, out of its earnings or profits accumulated since February 28, 1913, were taxable to them as other “gains or profits,” or whether the amounts so distributed were “dividends” exempt from the normal tax.
Sec. 201(a) of the Act defined the term “dividend” as “ any distribution made by a corporation . . to its shareholders . . , whether in cash or in other property . . , out of its earnings or profits accumulated since February 28,1913 . . ” Sec. 201(c) provided that: “Amounts dis-
140 Stat. 1057, 1058, c. 18.
tributed in the liquidation of a corporation shall be treated as payments in exchange for stock or shares, and any gain or profit realized thereby shall be taxed to the distributee as other gains or profits.” Sec. 216(a) provided that for the purpose of determining the “ normal tax ” upon the net income of an individual (§ 210), there should be allowed as a credit the “ amount received as dividends from a corporation which is taxable . . upon its net income.”
Treasury Regulations 45, which were promulgated under the Act, stated on the one hand, in Art. 1541, that for the purpose of the statute “dividends” comprise distributions made by a corporation to its stockholders “ in the ordinary course of business, even though extraordinary in amount;” and, on the other hand, in Art. 1548, that: “ So-called liquidation or dissolution dividends are not dividends within the meaning of the statute, and amounts so distributed, whether or not including any surplus earned since February 28, 1913, are to be regarded as payments for the stock of the dissolved corporations. Any excess so received over the cost of his stock to the stockholder, or over its fair market value as of March 1, 1913, if acquired prior thereto, is a taxable profit. A distribution in liquidation of the assets and business of a corporation, which is a return to the stockholder of the value of his stock upon a surrender of his interest in the corporation, is distinguishable from a dividend paid by a going corporation out of current earnings or accumulated surplus when declared by the directors in their discretion, which is in the nature of a recurrent return upon the stock.”2 These Regulations, with a change made in 1921 as to the second sentence of Art. 1548,3 are still in effect so far as distributions in liquidation under the Act are concerned.
8 By Treas. Dec. 3206 the following sentences were substituted for the second sentence: “Any excess so received over the cost of his stock to the stockholder constitutes income to such stockholder.
Each of the Hellmans owned one-half of the capital stock of a corporation which had a net surplus of $46,- 466.27, of which at least $31,545.58 consisted of earnings and profits accumulated since February 28, 1913. In 1919, the corporation was dissolved and liquidated and its assets were distributed to the stockholders. In this liquidation each of the Hellmans realized a gain of $15,004.55 in the distribution made out of the earnings and profits accumulated since February 28, 1913. Each in his income tax return claimed that this was a “dividend” which under § 216(a) was to be credited on his net income for the purpose of the normal tax. The Commissioner of Internal Revenue, ruling these were gains subject to the normal tax, disallowed the claims and made the additional assessments here involved.
The decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals in this case is in direct conflict with that of the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit in Langstaff v. Lucas (C. C. A.) 13 F. (2d) 1022.
The controlling question is whether the amounts distributed to the stockholders out of the earnings and profits accumulated by the corporation since February 28, 1913, were to be treated under § 201(a) as “ dividends,” which were exempt from the normal tax; or, under § 201(c) as payments made by the corporation in exchange for its stock, which were taxable “ as other gains or profits.”
It is true that if § 201(a) stood alone its broad definition of the term “dividend” would apparently include distributions made to stockholders in the liquidation of a
However, if such stock was acquired prior to March 1, 1913, and the fair market value as of such date was greater than the cost but less than the amount so distributed, the taxable income is the excess over such fair market value of the amount received, but no gain is recognized if the amount received, although more than cost, is less than the fair market value of the stock on March 1, 1913.” 23 Treas. Dec. Int. Rev., 763, 769.
corporation—although this term, as generally understood and used, refers to the recurrent return upon stock paid to stockholders by a going corporation in the ordinary course of business, which does not reduce their stock holdings and leaves them in a position to enjoy future returns upon the same stock. See Lynch v. Hornby, 247 U. S. 339, 344r-346; and Langstaff v. Lucas (D. C.) 9 F. (2d) 691, 694.
However, when § 201(a) and § 201(c) are read together, under the long-established rule that the intention of the lawmaker is to be deduced from a view of every material part of the statute, Kohlsaat v. Murphy, 96 U. S. 153, 159, we think it clear that the general definition of a dividend in § 201(a) was not intended to apply to distributions made to stockholders in the liquidation of a corporation, but that it was intended that such distributions should be governed by § 201(c), which, dealing specifically with such liquidation, provided that the amounts distributed should “be treated as payments in exchange for stock” and that any gain realized thereby should be taxed to the stockholders “ as other gains or profits.” This brings the two sections into entire harmony, and gives to each its natural meaning and due effect. The Treasury Regulations correctly interpreted the Act as making § 201(a) applicable to a distribution made by a going corporation to its stockholders in the ordinary course of business, and § 201(c) applicable to a distribution made to stockholders in liquidation of the corporation. And this is in accord with the rulings of the Board of Tax Appeals. Appeal of Greenwood, 1 B. T. A. 291, 295; Appeal of Chandler, 3 B. T. A. 146, 149.
The gains realized by the stockholders from the distribution of the assets in liquidation were subject to the normal tax in like manner as if they had sold their stock to third persons. The objection that this results in double taxation of the accumulated earnings and profits is no more
Statement of the Case. 276U.S.
available in the one case than it would have been in the other. See Merchants’ L. & T. Co. v. Smietanki, 255 U. S. 509; Goodrich v. Edwards, 255 U. S. 527. When, as here, Congress has clearly expressed its intention, the statute must be sustained even though double taxation results. See Patton v. Brady, 184 U. S. 608; Cream of Wheat Co. v. Grand Forks, 253 U. S. 325, 330.
The decree is
Reversed.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access