Lewellyn v. Frick, 268 U.S. 238 (1925)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Lewellyn v. Frick, 268 U.S. 238 (1925)
Full caption
LEWELLYN, FORMER COLLECTOR OF INTERNAL REVENUE, v. FRICK ET AL.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
May 11, 1925
LEWELLYN, FORMER COLLECTOR OF INTERNAL REVENUE, v. FRICK ET AL.
ERROR TO THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA.
No. 681. Argued April 16, 1925.—Decided May 11, 1925.
1. Acts of Congress are to be construed, if possible, so as to avoid grave doubts of their constitutionality. P. 251.
. 2. The provisions of the Revenue Act of February 24, 1919, purporting to include policies insuring the life of a decedent in the p. 239238 Argument for Plaintiff in Error.
gross value of his estate as a basis for fixing the transfer tax thereon, though the policies be payable to beneficiaries other than the estate, and allowing the executor to recover from such beneficiaries their proportions of such tax and making them personally responsible therefor if not paid when due, are to be construed as inapplicable to transactions antedating the passage of the act. P. 251. 3. A declaration in an act that a provision in it shall be retroactive helps the conclusion that the same provision in an earlier act, lacking such declaration, was not retroactive. P. 252. 298 Fed. 803, affirmed.
Error to a judgment recovered in the District Court by the defendants in error in an action to recover the amount of taxes collected by duress.
Mr. James A. Fowler, Special Assistant to the Attorney General, with whom the Solicitor General, Messrs. Nelson T. Hartson Solicitor of Internal Revenue, and Merrill E. Otis, Special Assistant to the Attorney General, were on the briefs, for plaintiff in error.
Section 402 (f) of the Revenue Act of 1918 provides a reasonable measure of an excise tax imposed upon a transmission of a decedent’s property by death. The tax is not a direct tax but an excise measured by the value of the net estate. New York Trust Co. v. Eisner, 256 U. S. 345; Greiner v.- Lewellyn, 258 IL S. 384; Edwards v. Slocum, 264 U. S. 61; Y. M. C. A. v. Davis, 264. U. S. 47; United States v. Woodward, 256 U. S. 632. Congress has provided a measure for that tax based not solely upon the transfer of the decedent’s property, but upon transactions, whether transfers from a decedent or not, which accomplished the same results as testamentary dispositions would accomplish. Pennsylvania Company v. Lederer, 292 Fed. 629; McElligott v. Kissam, 275 Fed. 545; Farmers’ Loan & Trust Co. v. Winthrop, 238 N. Y.
488. A measure which bears a reasonable relation to the subject matter of the tax is constitutional although the
Argument for Plaintiff in Error. 268 U. S.
property affording the measure could not itself be taxed. Maxwell v. Bugbee, 250 U. S. 525; Flint v. Stone Tracy Co. 220 U. S. 107; Greiner v. Lewellyn, supra; Plummer v. Coler, 178 U. S. 115; ^United States v. Perkins, 163 U. S. 625; Orr v. Gilman, 183 U. S. 278; Bullen v. Wisconsin, 240 U. S. 625. The measure of the tax bears a reasonable and proper relation to the occasion of the tax. Penn Mutual Life Ins. Co. v. Lederer, 252 U. S. 523.
It can hardly be questioned that a deposit by A in a Savings Bank to be paid with accumulations to B on A’s death would constitute a gift intended to take effect in possession or enjoyment at or after A’s death, and therefore be properly included in A’s gross estate under § 402 (c) of the Act. Shukert v. Allen, 300 Fed. 754. Differences between a savings deposit and the taking out of a life insurance policy on one’s own life for the benefit of another, are superficial, when used to differentiate such a contract from a gift intended to take effect in possession or enjoyment at or after death. It is, of course, true that the beneficiary has a vested interest in the policy. But the ownership of the policy as such is worthless. Its only value is the assurance that at the death of the insured a certain sum will be paid. There is no true 11 possession or enjoyment ” of a policy. The possession or enjoyment attaches when, and only when, the money is paid. It is held that gifts are taxable, regardless of the vesting of title or of the right to' future enjoyment, if the actual enjoyment of the property which comprised the present right to the earnings, income, and avails thereof is postponed until the donor’s death. People v. Kelley, 218 Ill. 509; Re Cornell, 170 N. Y. 423; State v. Probate Court, 102 Minn. 268; American Bd. Comm’rs v. Bugbee, 98 N. J. L. 84, 118 Atl. 700; People v. Shaffer, 291 Ill. 142; People v. Danks, 289 Ill. 542; In re Felton’s Estate, 176 Cal. 663; Harber v. Whelchel, 156 Ga. 601.
Assuming for the purposes of argument that the transfer of title to the insurance policies is the subject of the p. 241238 Argument for Plaintiff in Error.
tax, the act is not unconstitutional. New York Trust Co. v. Eisner, supra; Knowlton v. Moore, supra; Cohen v. Brewster, 203 U. S. 543; Stockdale v. The Insurance Companies, 20 Wall. 323; Billings v. United States, 232 U. S. 261; Magoun v. III. Trust & Sav. Bank, 170 U. S. 283; Flint v. Stone Tracy Co., 220 U. S. 107, 145, 158, 169; Keeney v. New York, 222 U. S. 525, 536. The provisions effecting the collection of the tax do not affect its nature or render the act unconstitutional. There is nothing to indicate that any change in the nature of the tax was contemplated; none of the sections concern the imposition of the tax; they are merely details deemed proper for the effectual and practical operation of the law. Flint v. Stone Tracy Co., supra; In re Inman’s Estate, 101 Ore. 182, 199 Pac. 615. The matter of who pays the tax is not primarily important. It is a matter which does not concern the Government. New York Trust Co. v. Eisner, supra; Edwards v. Slocum, 264 U. S. 61.
State cases holding retroactive excise laws unconstitutional are not in point. In the first place, such cases are decided under constitutional restrictions applicable to States but not to Congress. A State may not so legislate, whether in the form of taxation or otherwise, as to impair a vested right. To do so is to violate the constitutional limitations which prohibit the State from impairing the obligations of a contract. It is doubtful that this limitation prevents the imposition of a retroactive excise by a State. Nickel v. Cole; 256 U. S. 222. Certainly there is no such limitation upon the power of Congress. Its power to tax is exhaustive, and if the imposition be a tax, then, although it impair the obligations of contracts or interfere with vested rights, it is, neverthless, valid. License Tax Cases, 5 Wall. 462; United States v. Singer, 15 Wall. Ill; Knowlton v. Moore, supra; Patton v. Brady, 184 U. S. 608; Me Cray v. United States, 195 U. S.
55627°—25------ 16
Argument for Plaintiff in Error. 268U.S.
27; Flint v. Stone Tracy Co., supra; Billings v. United States, supra; Brushaber v. Union Pac. R. R. Co. 240 U. S. 1; United States v. Doremus, 249 U. S. 86.
The statute by its expressed words does not tax the transfer of policies. Furthermore, neither the policies nor their value are included in the gross estate. Their transfer, issuance, or assignment are entirely immaterial. What is included is the 11 amount receivable ”—the money. Regardless of who owned the policies at the date of Mr. Frick’s death, the moneys received were in substance the decedent’s money, for it was the decedent’s money that purchased the right to receive them, and that right was contingent upon the decedent’s death. The amounts thus received were included under the statute, whether received by the beneficiaries or by the estate, the only difference being that when received by beneficiaries a part is exempt. The correct theory is that the decedent makes a gift, .not of the policy but of his money (invested in insurance, it is true), and the gift is not complete until the money is received. For the purpose of measuring or levying a tax upon the transfer of the net estate, the moneys received by Mrs. and Miss Frick were a part of the Frick estate. They were accumulated or purchased by Henry C. Frick in his lifetime. The right to their possession and enjoyment was generated by his death precisely the same as the right to possession and enjoyment of a trust estate created by a testator to take effect upon his death is so generated. One can not receive money or property unless another part with it. A receipt is a part of a transfer. These moneys were in fact transferred after and because of Mr. Frick’s death from the insurance companies to his wife and daughter. The statute does not say when the transfer shall occur, or from and to whom the moneys or property shall pass. It certainly does not contemplate that it shall pass from the decedent at the moment of and because of his death. p. 243238 Argument for Plaintiff in Error.
True, the transfer mentioned is that of the estate of the decedent, but the decedent’s estate is that which is made up of the elements expressly designated in the statute. Knowlton v. Moore, supra. The tax is levied oh neither the policies nor their value, nor the moneys received under the insurance contracts. It is levied “ upon the transfer of the net estate,” and the generating cause—the cause which justifies the tax and to which it is attached—is the death of the decedent.
The provision of the act of 1918 (40 Stat., chap. 18, sec. 402(f), p. 1098) applies to the proceeds of policies issued before the passage of the act. Shwab v. Doyle, 258 U. S. 529; Union Trust Co. v. Wardell, 258 U. S. 537. It certainly can not be insisted with reason that the proceeds of policies issued before the enactment of the statute and made payable to the executors were not intended to be included in the gross estate. That being true, the date of the issuance of the policy is immaterial; the determinative event is when the money is received. The requirements that there shall be included in the gross estate the amounts received by the executors as insurance and those received as insurance “ by all other beneficiaries ” in excess of $40,000, are in the same sentence, and there is not a word in the provision which contains a suggestion that a different rule was intended to be observed as to the two classes of funds derived from insurance. In fact, if the provision does not apply to insurance policies issued before the passage of the act, it could have had but little practical effect for a number of years after its passage. Such a construction would practically postpone for years its going into effect. Policies are issued only to those who are physically fit and have a long expectancy of life, and but few policies mature within the early years after their issuance.
There are two lines of cases relating to the modification of the language of legislative acts by subsequent
Argument for Defendants in Error. 268U.S.
legislation. The one line proceeds upon the theory that Congress intended to include a casus omissus from the previous act, and the other upon the theory that Congress intended to remove any doubt that might otherwise exist as to the inclusion of the case in the previous act. Apparently the distinction between the two lines of decisions is this: If the inserted word change the meaning of the language of the previous statute, or add something thereto when construed according to the obvious and usual meaning of its language, it will then be assumed that the inserted words were intended as an amendment; but if the words inserted accord with the plain and obvious meaning of the language of the previous statute, they are taken to define and make more certain its meaning. Bailey v. Clark, 21 Wall. 284; Johnson v. So. Pac. Co. 196 U. S. 1; Wetmore v. Markoe, 196 U. S. 68; United States v. Coulby, 251 Fed. 982; Matter of Reynolds’ Estate, 169 Cal. 600; Abstract & Title Guaranty Co. v. State, 173 Cal. 691.
Mr. George B. Gordon, with whom Messrs. John G. Buchanan, Miles H. England, and >8. G. Nolin, were on the briefs, for defendants in error.
The policies were property belonging, not to Mr. Frick’s estate, but to the beneficiaries. Tyler, Administratrix, v. Treasurer and Receiver General, 226 Mass. 306; Elliot’s Appeal, 50 Pa. 75; Anderson’s Estate, 85 Pa. 202; Matter of the Transfer Tax upon the Estate of Andrew Carnegie, 203 App. Div. (N. Y.) 91; Neary v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. 103 Atl. 661, (Conn. 1918); Holden v. Insurance Co. 11 So. Car. 299; Matter of Parson’s Estate, 102 N. Y. Supp. 168; In re Voorhee’s Estate, 193 N. Y. Supp. 168; Lloyd v. Royal Union Mutual Life Ins. Co. 245 Fed. 162. See especially Washington Central Bank v. Hume, 128 U. S., 195.
The reservation of a power by the donor which was never exercised does not affect the vesting of the estate p. 245238 Argument for Defendants in Error.
in the donee. Jones v. Clifton, 101 U. S. 225; Matter of the Transfer Tax upon the estate of Andrew Carnegie, supra; Matter of Miller, 236 N. Y. 290; Dolan’s Estate, 279 Pa. 582. An attempt was made in the court below to show that the existence of these options and powers, which were never exercised, prevented the “ estate ” from vesting in the beneficiary. We are at a loss to see what application this contention has to the case; for it is the estate of the beneficiary that is being taxed here. That estate, whether you call it vested or contingent, came into being when the contract which created the obligation to pay the policy to the beneficiary was made, and continued unmodified by the exercise of options or powers right down to the death of the insured, when the policy became payable at once to the owner of the estate. It is perfectly clear that Mr. Frick’s so-called rights were no “ conditions of the vesting of the estate ” (if we must use this inaccurate expression) but were simply conditional limitations. In authorities as old as Littleton we find the illustration that an estate to A if he returns from Rome is a conditional estate. It does not vest any right in him until and unless he returns from Rome; but an estate to A until B returns from Rome is a vested estate in A. It is simply a conditional limitation upon, not a conditional vesting of the estate. Bennett v. Robinson, 10 Watts, 348; Irvine v. Sibbetts, 26 Pa. 477; Cooper v. Pogue, 92 Pa. 254; McArthur v. Scott, 133 U. S. 340; Girard Trust Co. v. McCaughn, 3 Fed. (2d), 618. Mrs. Frick’s right (estate) became her property (vested) when the policy was issued or the assignment thereof was made, and could only be divested by a subsequent event (the failure to pay a premium, or the exercise of a power), which never happened. In 'this connection it is well to bear in mind that the beneficiaries had the right to pay the premiums and thus to prevent the policies from lapsing..,
Neither these insurance policies nor the assignments thereof comply with the requirements of the Pennsyl-
Argument for Defendants in Error. 268 U. S.
vania statute on wills; therefore they are not wills. An insurance policy is the antithesis of a will. It is primarily and fundamentally a provision for his dependents, made by a man in his lifetime. It is, as we have shown, their property both by form of contract and by statute, and the proceeds of the policy are not subject to the financial vicissitudes of the insured. It is not a part of his estate; it is not liable for his debts; it does not pass under his will; nothing new vests in the beneficiaries by reason of the insured’s death.
The assessment of this tax under the provisions of § 402 (f) of the Revenue Act of 1918 was illegal because that section of the act is not retroactive. In addition to what for all other purposes is regarded as constituting a decedent’s estate, this act includes in the gross estate, as it defines it, certain items of property which, though not unconnected with the past activities of the decedent’s lifetime, are not at the time of his death part of his estate for the payment of debts, or for distribution, or for any other than the artificial purpose of determining the tax in accordance with the language of the act. Those items are: (1) gifts and trusts made by the decedent in contemplation of death, or to take effect at death; (2) property conveyed to the decedent and some other person and held by them at the time of the decedent’s death as joint tenants or tenants by the entireties, with the right of survivorship; (3) policies of life insurance taken out by the decedent on his own life and made payable to persons other than the decedent’s executors. The three provisions of the Act which accomplish this extraordinary classification of property are very similar in their terms and are identical in the fact that, as originally enacted, they did not contain any language that required them to have a retrospective application. They contained no hint that they were to be applied to any trusts, gifts, entireties, or life insurance poli- p. 247238 Argument for Defendants in Error.
cies other than those made after the passage of the Act. This is the natural meaning of the language used. And that such was the meaning that Congress actually had in mind when it enacted the statute is shown by the fact that since the provisions were originally enacted Congress has from time to time added to one or another of the clauses language making it retroactive, until finally in the Act of 1924 it introduced language making them all retroactive. But this is not all. The first two of the three original provisions have already been passed upon by this Court and have been construed not to be retroactive. Shwab v. Doyle, 258 U. S. 259; Union Trust Co. v. Wardell, Id. 537; Levy v. Wardell, Id. 542; Knox v. McElligott, Id. 546.
By making subdivision (g), the language of which is exactly the same as that of subdivision (f) of § 402 of the Acts of 1918 and 1921, applicable to all transfers, etc., made before the enactment of the Act of 1924, Congress conceded that the language of the earlier acts did not apply to the proceeds of policies taken out before this Act went into effect. Shwab v. Doyle, supra; Smietanka v. First Trust & Savings Bank, 257 U. S. 602; "United States v. Field, 255 U. S. 257. The conclusion that the provisions of § 402 (f) are not applicable to the proceeds of insurance policies taken out and assigned long before this Act was passed is further supported by numerous decisions in this and other courts holding, as was held in Shwab v. Doyle, supra, that tax laws are to be strictly construed in favor of the taxpayer. United States v. Merriam, 263 U. S. 179; Gould v. Gould, 245 U. S. 151; Eidman v. Martinez, 184 U. S. 578. See Reynolds v. McArthur, 2 Pet. 417, 434. An established practice of this Court is to avoid giving to a statute a construction which involves constitutional difficulties. Panama R. R. Co. v. Johnson, 264 U. S. 375.
Even though it be deemed that the Act was intended by Congress to be retroactive, the tax was illegally levied
Argument for Defendants in Error. 268 U. S.
(a) because such a tax is a direct tax and (b) because it is not due process of law. A retroactive tax is not an excise tax but a direct tax requiring apportionment, since a tax cannot be an excise unless “ the element of absolute and unavoidable demand is lacking.” Thomas v. United States, 192 U. S. 363, 371; Flint v. Stone Tracy Co., supra; Singer v. United States, 15 Wall. Ill, 120; Patton v. Brady, 184 U. S. 608, 623. The tax must therefore be either a direct tax upon the person, imposed by reason of his past acts, or a direct tax upon the property transferred. It is a direct property tax within the definitions adopted in: Pollock Case, 157 U. S. 429; Dawson v. Kentucky Distilleries Company, 255 U. S. 288. Eisner v. Macomber, supra; Nicol v. Ames, 173 U. S. 509; In re Pell, 171 N. Y. 48.
A tax in any form, imposed upon the creation or transfer of property rights at a time long past, is in substance not a tax but an imposition so arbitrary and unreasonable as to amount to a confiscation of property within the prohibition of the Fifth Amendment. Brushaber v. Union Pacific R. R. Co. 240 U. S. 1; Child Labor Tax Case, 259 U. S. 20; Hill v. Wallace, 259 U. S. 44.
The Constitution requires duties, imposts and excises to be uniform throughout the United States, Art I, § 8. United States v. Singer, 15 Wall. 111.
It was not due process of law to compel the executors to pay an estate transfer tax on property which was not part of the decedent’s estate, but which belonged to others. Such a tax is unconstitutional because—(1) It is unequal; it is a deprivation of property without due process of law. (2) The remedy over sought to be given to' the executors against the beneficiaries is inadequate,
(a) Because a mere cause of action to1 recover is not the equivalent to immunity from taxation; and (b) Because the act attempts to give the right to recover only a part of the amount which the estate has to pay. That the p. 249tax is an excise tax founded, upon the termination of Mr. Frick’s title has been expressly held by this court in cases involving the application of that act. Y. M. C, A. v. Davis, 264 U. S. 47; Edwards v. Slocum, 264 U. S. 61. See Knowlton v. Moore, 178 U. S. 41.
Our proposition that you cannot include in the value of the taxable thing the value of some other thing is a fundamental point in the following cases: Pullman’s Palace Car Co. v. Pennsylvania, 141 U. S. 18; Delaware, L. Ac W. R. R. Co. v. Pennsylvania, 198 U. S. 341; Union Refrigerator Co. v. Kentucky, 199 U. S. 194; Sou. Pac. Co. v. Kentucky, 222 U. S. 63; Wallace v. Hines, 253 U. S. 66; Air-Way Corp. v. Day, 266 U. S. 71; Wardell v. Blum, 276 Fed. 226; Chanler v. Kelsey, 205 U. S.
466. A tax cannot be made the means of imposing upon one man the burden which should be borne by another. United States v. B. & 0. R. R. Co., 17 Wall. 322; Knowlton v. Moore, supra; Loan Association v. Topeka, 20 Wall. 655.
Messrs. Ira J. Williams Jr., A. Carson Simpson, Ira J. Williams and Francis Shunk Brown; Isaac B. Lipson; Frederick Geller and Russell L. Bradford; William B. Sears and Alexander Lincoln; Tyson S. Dines, Peter H. Holme, Harold D. Roberts and Charles E. Works; and William Marshall Bullitt, filed briefs as amici curiae, by special leave of court.
Mr. Justice Holmes delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is a suit by the executors of Henry C. Frick to recover the amount of taxes collected by duress under the supposed authority of the Revenue Act of February 24, 1919, c. 18; 40 Stat. 1057, on the ground that the Act is unconstitutional so far as it purports to tax the matters here concerned. The District Court gave p. 250judgment for the plaintiffs for the whole sum demanded. 298 Fed. 803. The case was tried without a jury and the Court adopted as its findings among others the following facts which were agreed: Henry C. Frick died on December 2, 1919, and his will was admitted to probate on December 6. There were outstanding policies upon his life, four payable to his wife and seven to his daughter. The total amount received under them was $474,629.52, and as his estate apart from this was more than ten million dollars, an additional tax of $108,657.88, or twenty-five per cent, of the sum received less the statutory deduction of $40,000, was required to be paid. All the policies were taken out before the Revenue Act was passed. The largest one, for $114,000 dollars, was a paid-up policy issued in 1901, payable to Mrs. Frick without power in Mr. Frick to change the beneficiary. Another, similar so far as material, was for $50,000. Others were assigned or the beneficiary named (Frick’s estate) was changed to Frick’s wife or daughter before the date of the statute. All premiums were paid by Mr. Frick, and some seem to have been paid after the statute went into force.
The tax imposed by the Act is, a tax ‘ upon the transfer of the net estate ’ of the decedent. § 400; 40 Stat. 1096. * For the purpose of the tax the value of the net estate shall be determined ’ by deducting certain allowances from the gross estate. § 403. By § 402 “ the value of the gross estate of the decedent shall be determined by including the value at the time of his death of all property . . . (f) To the extent of the amount receivable by the executor as insurance under policies taken out by the decedent upon his own life; and to the extent of the excess over $40,000 of the amount receivable by all other beneficiaries as insurance under policies taken out by the decedent upon his own life.” These last words are the ground of the Collector’s claim.
By § 408; 40 Stat. 1100, “If any part of the gross estate consists of proceeds of policies of insurance upon the life of the decedent receivable by a beneficiary other than the executor, the executor shall be entitled to recover from such beneficiary such portion of the total tax paid as the proceeds, in excess of $40,000, of such policies bear to the net estate.” By § 409 a personal liability is imposed upon the beneficiaries if the tax is not paid when due. The defendants in error say that if these policies are covered by the statute these sections show that the beneficiaries are taxed upon their own property, under the guise of a tax upon the transfer of his estate by Mr. Frick, and that this is taking their property without due process of law, citing Matter of Pell, 171 N. Y. 48, and other cases. In view of their liability the ob-1 jection cannot be escaped by calling the reference to their receipts a mere measure of the transfer tax. The interest of the beneficiaries is established by statutes of the States controlling the insurance and is not disputed. It also is strongly urged that the tax would be a direct tax. In view of our conclusion it is not necessary to state the position of the defendants in error more in detail.
We do not propose to discuss the limits of the powers of Congress in cases like the present. It is enough to point out that at least there would be a very serious question to be answered before Mrs. Frick and Miss Frick could be made to pay a tax oh the transfer of his estate by Mr. Frick. There would be another if the provisions for the liability of beneficiaries were held to' be separable and it was proposed to make the estate pay a transfer tax for property that Mr. Frick did not transfer. Acts of Congress are to be construed if possible in such a way as to avoid grave doubts of this kind. Panama R. R. Co. v. Johnson, 264 U. S. 375, 390. Not only are such doubts avoided by construing the statute as referring only
Syllabus. 268 U. S.
to transactions taking place after it was passed, but the general principle “that the laws are not to be considered as applying to cases which arose before their passage ” is preserved, when to disregard it would be to impose an unexpected liability that if known might have induced those concerned to avoid it and to use their money in other ways. Schwab v. Doyle, 258 U. S. 529, 534. This case and the following ones, Union Trust Co. v. Wardell, 258 U. S. 537, Levy. v. Wardell, 258 U. S. 542, and Knox v. McElligott, 258 U. S. 546, go far toward deciding the one now before us. They also indicate that the Revenue Act of 1924, c. 2, § 302(h); 43 Stat. 250, 305, making (g) (the equivalent of (f) above) apply to past transactions, does not help but if anything hinders the Collector’s construction of the present law. Smietanka v. First Trust de Savings Bank, 257 U. S. 602.
Decree affirmed.
STATE OF OKLAHOMA v. STATE OF TEXAS, UNITED STATES, INTERVENER.
IN EQUITY.
No. 13, Original. Argued April 20, 1925. Decided May 11, 1925.
1. Description of a boundary in field notes and patent as “up the river ”, construed, in the light of connected surveys and a plat, as calling for the river as a boundary. P. 255. 2. A natural boundary like a river controls courses and distances. Id. 3. A river bank boundary, whether private or public, changes with erosion and accretion. P. 256. . 4. Only where conduct or statements are calculated to mislead a party and are acted upon by him in good faith to his prejudice can he invoke them as a basis of an estoppel; and if they relate to a real property title the condition of which is known to both parties, or both have the same means of ascertaining it, there can be no estoppel. Id.
On exceptions to the special master’s report on conflicting claims to royalty interests in proceeds held by the receiver in this cause derived from oil wells in a parcel of land on Red River in Texas. Exceptions overruled.
Mr. C. F. Greenwood for Durfee Mineral Company, in support of exceptions.
Mr. A. H. Carrigan for Roberts and Britain, contra.
Mr. Justice Van Devanter delivered the opinion of the Court.
As an incident of the receivership in this cause it becomes necessary to determine conflicting claims to the royalty interest in the impounded proceeds of the oil taken from wells Nos. 152, 153 and 154. 258 U. S. 574, 581. These wells are immediately south of the south bank of Red River, and therefore in the State of Texas. 261 U. ST 340. The claimants are T. P. Roberts and A. H. Britain on the one hand and the Durfee Mineral Company on the other. Both claims are founded on Texas surveys—that of Roberts and Britain on the Lewis Powell survey made in 1861 and patented in 1868, and that of the Durfee Mineral Company on the A. A. Durfee survey made in 1886 and patented in 1889.
The principal question is whether the Powell survey extended northward to the south bank of Red River, leaving nothing between it and the bank, or stopped short of the bank, leaving a narrow wedge-shaped strip between it and the bank. The Durfee survey was made 25 years later on the assumption that the Powell survey left such a strip there. The three wells are in the wedge-shaped strip or land accreted 'to it. A secondary question is whether, if the Powell survey included this strip, the present owners of that survey are estopped from claiming the strip, and therefore the royalty interest, as against the Durfee Mineral Company.
Opinion of the Court. 268U.S.
January 19, last, the conflicting claims were referred to a special master with directions to take the evidence and report the same with findings of fact, conclusions of law and recommendations for a decree. 267 U. S. 7, par. 8. The master made his report with findings, conclusions and recommendations favorable to the claim of Roberts and Britain; the Durfee Mineral Company excepted; and both claimants have been heard in briefs and oral argument on the report and exceptions.
The master found that the Powell survey fronted on the river and had the south bank as its northerly boundary. In the exceptions it is insisted that this finding rests on an erroneous interpretation of the survey. For reasons which will be explained, we think it rests on a right interpretation.
The Powell was one of five surveys made by the same surveyor on the same day—May 8, 1861. These surveys were contiguous and were in the form required of surveys fronting on a stream like Red River.1 They were also so tied together that the interpretation of one involves an examination of the others.
The surveyor began with the easterly one and proceeded westerly until he had finished all five. His field notes described all as “ on the south bank of Red River,’’ and the drawings or plats accompanying the field notes represented all as fronting on the river and having its irregular line as a northerly boundary. The field notes of all, excepting the Powell, also described the northerly line as beginning at the northwest corner of the adjoining survey on the east and running “ thence up the river with its meanders ” in a stated direction a given distance to a stake or mound“ in the bottom ” or “ on the bluff ” at the other end. The Powell was the fourth survey in the line, and so was between others the field notes of which said
1
Vernon’s Sayles’ Civ. Stat. §§ 5338, 5339.
“ thence up the river with its meanders.” The field notes of the Powell transmitted to the state land office, and on which the patent issued, were like the others, save that they said “ thence up the river ” and omitted “ with its meanders.” But the field notes entered in the appropriate local records said “ thence up the river with its meanders.” Doubtless the discrepancy resulted from a clerical error in preparing the duplicate sent to the state land office.
We put aside the question of the effect to be given to the entry in the local records; for the phrase “ thence up the river ” in the field notes sent to the state land office and in the patent evidently mean up the natural course of the river. Schnackenberg v. State, 229 S. W» 934, 937; Stover n. Gilbert, 247 S. W. 841, 843; Brown v. Huger, 21 How. 305, 320. Of course, that phrase must be read with the declaration that the survey was on the south bank of the river and in the light of the drawing or plat representing the river as the northern boundary.
We think it apparent that the survey was intended to call, and did call, for the river as a boundary and that controlling influence must be given to that call rather than to the course and distance given for that boundary. The courts of Texas, in common with other courts, recognize and apply this rule of interpretation. Anderson v. Stamps, 19 Tex. 460, 465-466; Stafford v. King, 30 Tex. 257, 271-272; Schnackenberg v. State, supra; Stover v. Gilbert, supra, and cases there cited; Cordell Petroleum Co. v. Michna, 276 Fed. 483. The evidence, as pointed out by the master, does not admit of the conclusion that the surveyor mistook a bayou or other body of water for the river, or that the river was not in immediate proximity to the upper corners of the survey when it was made (see United States v. Lane, 260 U. S. 662); so authorities rejecting an obviously mistaken call for a river or lake are not in point. See Jeems Bayou
Opinion of the Court. 268U.S.
The master next found that the land lying between the south bank as now existing and that bank as existing at the time of the Powell survey is accretion to the bank, and therefore part of the Powell tract. Exception is taken to this finding on grounds that are not made very clear. A short statement of what the evidence tends to show in this connection will make it plain that the exception must be overruled. During the 25-year period intervening between the Powell survey and the Durfee survey there was a large addition to the south bank, but in later years most of that addition was cut away. At present the bank extends a little farther northward than it did when the Powell survey was made. These changes all resulted from the natural and gradual processes of accretion and erosion, which are rather pronounced in Red River. Its currents and channels shift from one side of its wide bed to the other, gradually cut away one bank and build up the other, and later on reverse that action. Where, as here, a boundary bank is changed by these processes the boundary, whether private or public, follows the change. Oklahoma v. Texas, 260 U. S. 606, 636; Oklahoma v. Texas, 265 U. S. 493, 499.
The necessary result of the two findings we have mentioned is that there was no public land between the Powell tract and the river to which the Durfee survey and patent could give any right.
The next exception is to the master’s conclusion that there was no sufficient evidence on which to invoke an estoppel against the assertion by Roberts and Britain of title to the strip in controversy or to the royalty interest arising therefrom.
The grounds on which an estoppel is invoked are that Specht, from whom Roberts acquired the Powell tract, had theretofore made and distributed a plat of that tract, p. 257along with others, whereon it was represented as not extending to the river bank; that Roberts after getting the title made and distributed a plat with a like representation of the northern boundary; that Roberts pointed out to the Durfee Company and its predecessors as the northern boundary a line running south of the land in dispute; and that, acting upon those plats and Roberts’ statement, the Durfee Company and its predecessors purchased the land in dispute from a claimant under the Durfee survey and paid a valuable consideration for it. The evidence bearing on the asserted estoppel is in several respects conflicting. It is fully and fairly reviewed by the master in his report and need not be restated here. The master concluded, and we agree with him, that as a whole the evidence shows that the Durfee Company and its predecessors purchased with full knowledge of the record title, including the surveyor’s field notes before described; that the plats made by Specht and Roberts were too vague to have been relied upon as a representation of the nature or location of the northern boundary; that the conveyance from Specht to Roberts, which was part of the record title, described the Powell tract as extending to the meanders of the river; that the Durfee Company and its -predecessors in purchasing did not in fact rely upon the Specht and Roberts plats or any statement of Roberts, but upon a report made by their attorneys based on the record title, including the field notes; and that the alleged statement by Roberts to them, if made, was made after they had purchased, gone into possession and paid the purchase price. In this situation the asserted estoppel must fail. Only where conduct or statements are calculated to mislead a party and are acted upon by him in good faith to his prejudice can he invoke them as a basis of such an estoppel. And if they relate to the title of real property “ where the condition of the title is known to both parties, or both have the same means of
55627°—25’——17
Syllabus. 268 U.S.
ascertaining the truth, there can be no estoppel.” Brant v. Virginia Coal & Iron Co., 93 U. S. 326, 336-337; Crary v. Dye, 208 U. S. 515, 521; Westbrook n. Guderian, 3 Tex. Civ. App. 406; Hunter v. Malone, 49 Tex. Civ. App. 116, 121; Bender v. Brooks, 130 S. W. 653, 657; Barclay v. Dismuke, 202 S. W. 364, 365; Pomeroy’s Eq., 4th ed., sec. 807. There was no laches on Roberts’ part in asserting his claim after the company purchased. He soon went to the land with a surveyor to run out his lines and make his claim known, but was prevented from doing -so by an armed guard. With reasonable promptness he brought a suit in a court of competent jurisdiction to enforce his rights. Proceedings in that suit were soon suspended by reason of this receivership, and he promptly asserted his claim here.
An order will be entered overruling the exceptions, confirming the master’s report and directing payment of the royalty interest to Roberts and Britain. The costs will be adjusted in the order.
Claim of Roberts and Britain sustained. Claim of Durfee Mineral Company denied.