Biddle v. Luvisch, 266 U.S. 173 (1924)

266 U.S. 173
45 S. Ct. 88
69 L. Ed. 229
1924 SCDB 37
1924 U.S. LEXIS 2906
US-DOC-27825522
locator
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Biddle v. Luvisch, 266 U.S. 173 (1924)
Full caption
BIDDLE, WARDEN OF THE UNITED STATES PENITENTIARY AT LEAVENWORTH, KANSAS, v. LUVISCH.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Nov. 17, 1924
BIDDLE, WARDEN OF THE UNITED STATES
PENITENTIARY AT LEAVENWORTH, KANSAS, v. LUVISCH.
CERTIFICATE FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT.
No. 96. Argued October 21, 1924.—Decided November 17, 1924. .
A certificate from the Circuit Court of Appeals should submit definite questions of law arising upon the record and not send up in effect the whole case. Only substantial matters in approved form should be so presented.
Certificate dismissed.
Certificate from the Circuit Court of Appeals asking instructions, in a case of habeas corpus appealed to it from the District Court. The body of the certificate is given below in a footnote.1
1
The appellee had been indicted in the District Court of the United States for the Eastern District of Michigan in three counts, to which he entered a plea of guilty, and thereupon was sentenced to confinement in the United States Penitentiary at Leavenworth, Kansas, for five years. While in prison he applied to the District Court of the United States for the District of Kansas for a writ of habeas corpus, and upon a hearing of the petition a judgment was entered discharging him from imprisonment on the ground that none of the three counts in the said indictment to which he had entered a plea of guilty and was sentenced, constituted a violation of any law of the United States. Each of the three counts is based upon the same facts, except that the first count charges the making of a plate to be in the likeness and similitude of certain plates designed •by the Dominion of Canada, a foreign government, for the printing of the genuine issues of certain obligations and securities of said Government. The second count charges him with possession of that plate, and the third count charges him with the sale of 1,200 counterfeit prints from said plate in the likeness and similitude of the genuine obligations and securities of that foreign Government. The description of these securities and obligations of the Dominion of Canada is set out in each count, and for this reason we deem it appears first the word ‘ cent ’ and then ‘ bottled in bond under excise supervision, Deputy Minr. Inland Revenue.’ ” It is further certified that the following question of law is presented by the appeal prosecuted by the warden of said penitentiary,* the respondent in the court below, the decision of which is indispensable to a determination of the case, and to the end that this court may properly discharge its duty, it desires the instruction of the Supreme Court upon it: Do the counts of the indictment, or any of them, charge the commission of a criminal offense against the United States as in violation of §§ 147 and 161 of the Act of March 4, 1909 (35 Stat. 1088) known as the Penal Code of 1910? to land owners of proceedings to assess for benefits and adjudged that the notice published, read with the statute, sufficiently described the lands affected, held, that contentions that the statute did not provide due process of law were too insubstantial to support a writ of error. P. 176.
Mr. Assistant Attorney General Donovan, with whom Mr. Solicitor General Beck and Mr. Harry S. Ridgely were on the brief, for Biddle, Warden.
Mr. I. J. Ringolsky, with whom Mr. L. S. Harvey, Mr. M. L. Friedman and Mr. Wm. G. Boatright were on the briefs, for Luvisch.
Mr. Justice McReynolds delivered the opinion of the Court.
This certificate fails to meet often announced requirements and must be dismissed. It does not submit one
only necessary to set out the first count of the indictment, which differs from the other counts only as stated. That count, omitting the jurisdictional allegations, charges that the defendant “ did then and there unlawfully, wilfully, feloniously and knowingly, and without lawful authority, cause and procure to be made and engraved a certain zinc half-tone plate in the likeness and similitude of certain plates and impressions designated by a certain foreign government, to wit, the Dominion of Canada, for the printing of the genuine issues of certain obligations and securities of the said foreign government, to wit, certain inland excise stamps of the denomination of one cent, bearing the following words and figures, to wit: The numerals ‘ 1912 ’ at each end and in the center of said stamp, and the words ‘Certified manufactured in the year’; and the signature of, to wit, ‘ J. W. Vincent,’ and a large scroll numeral ‘ 1,’ all on the left side of the center of said stamp, and in the center thereof the word ‘ Ottawa ’ above the numerals ‘ 1912,’ and beneath said numerals the word ‘ Canada,’ and on the right of the center of said stamp [p. 175] 173 Syllabus.
The constantly increasing demands upon us make it highly important that only matters which are both substantial and in approved form should be presented.
Certificate dismissed.
HOUSE v. ROAD IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT NO. 2, OF CONWAY COUNTY, ARKANSAS, ET AL.
HOUSE v. ROAD IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT NO. 5, OF CONWAY COUNTY, ARKANSAS, ET AL.
ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.
Nos. 92 and 93. Argued October 17, 20, 1924.—Decided November 17, 1924.
1. Where the decision of a State Supreme Court construed a road district statute as allowing twenty-eight days’ notice by publication
2
The objection that a statute assessing lands for a road improvement is arbitrary and void as to plaintiff because the improvement could not benefit his lands while other lands actually benefited were not included in the district assessed, held clearly without merit. P. 177. Writs of error to review 158 Ark. 330, 357, dismissed.
These were two suits to enjoin collection of special road taxes assessed on plaintiff’s lands in Arkansas. Plaintiff prosecutes error to the decrees of the Supreme Court of that State affirming the decrees of the Chancery-Court of Conway County, which denied her the relief prayed.
Mr. Joseph M. Hill, with whom Mr. Henry L. Fitzhugh was on the brief, for plaintiff in error.
Mr. G. B. Rose and Mr. Lasker Ehrman, with whom Mr. Chas. T. Coleman, Mr. D. H. Cantrell, Mr. J. F. Loughborough and Mr. A. W. Dobyns were on the briefs, for defendants in error in No. 92.
Mr. G. B. Rose, with whom Mr. W. P. Strait, Mr. D. H. Cantrell, Mr. J. F. Loughborough and Mr. A. W. Dobyns were on the briefs, for defendants in error in No. 93.
Mr. Justice McReynolds delivered the opinion of the Court.
Both of these writs must be dismissed.
No. 92.
The only ground suggested to sustain the writ in this cause is that Act No. 245, Arkansas Legislature, 1919, which established Road District No. 2 of Conway County, was duly challenged as repugnant to the Fourteenth Amendment. Such a challenge must be distinct and substantial.
The act undertook to create the district with boundaries which include plaintiff’s lands and specified the proceedings for assessing benefits to meet necessary costs. Her lands were assessed as provided. Some months thereafter, by a bill in equity, she claimed insufficient notice and asked relief from both assessment and consequent [p. 177] penalties; also that the commissioners’ plans should be declared null and she be heard as to the merits of any assessment. She offered to pay any sum the court might find just and equitable.
The bill alleges that the statute authorized and the commissioners gave only seventeen days’ notice of the assessment, by publication, that she had no actual notice, and that the publication failed sufficiently to' describe her lands. For these reasons she maintained the act did not provide due process of law and violated the Fourteenth Amendment.
The Supreme Court, having considered the objections, held that the statute allowed twenty-eight days after the first publication during which time petitioner might have objected to the assessment, and declared this was adequate; also that when read in connection with the statute the notice sufficiently described the lands. Plaintiff in error now insists that the act is null because it prescribes insufficient notice and description of the assessed lands.
Accepting the statute as construed by the state court, the suggested objections to its validity appear to us wholly wanting in merit.
No. 93.
This cause grew out of the creation of District No. 5, Conway County, by Act No. 245, and assessment for benefits thereunder. With one exception the questions now raised are the same as those in cause No. 92. As an additional ground for challenging the statute plaintiff in error claims that it is arbitrary and beyond the power of the Legislature because the proposed improvement could not benefit plaintiff’s lands, while other lands actually benefited were not included. The record does not show that this objection was placed upon any federal ground in the courts below; but, assuming that the point was properly made, we think it is* clearly without merit. [p. 178] Houck v. Little River Drainage District, 239 U. S. 254, 265; Miller & Lux v. Sacramento Drainage District, 256 U. S. 129, 130; Valley Farms Co. v. Westchester, 261 U. S. 155, 163, 164.
Writs of Error Dismissed.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access