John v. Paullin, 231 U.S. 583 (1913)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
John v. Paullin, 231 U.S. 583 (1913)
Full caption
JOHN, GUARDIAN, v. PAULLIN.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Dec. 22, 1913
JOHN, GUARDIAN, v. PAULLIN.
ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF
OKLAHOMA.
No. 105. Argued December 8, 9, 1913.—Decided December 22, 1913.
No Federal right is denied by an appellate court of a State in dismissing an appeal from a lower court, because its jurisdiction was not invoked in accordance with the laws of the State, and this court cannot review such a judgment under § 709, Rev. Stat., now Judicial Code, §237.
It rests with each State to prescribe the jurisdiction of its appellate courts, and the mode of invoking it, and their rules are equally applicable when Federal, as when only local, rights are involved.
Section 12 of the act of March 3, 1905, 33 Stat. 1048, 1081, providing for the review of judgments of the courts temporarily established in the Indian Territory, related only to such judgments and has no application to judgments rendered by the state courts after Statehood.
The method of subjecting the judgments of a subordinate state court to review by appellate courts of the State is a matter of local concern and not within the control of Congress. Coyle v. Smith, 221 U. S. 559.
In this case, as nothing was decided but a preliminary question of the jurisdiction of a state appellate court which turned entirely upon a question of local law, the writ of error is dismissed. Writ of error to review 24 Oklahoma, 636, dismissed.
The facts, which involve the jurisdiction of this court under § 237 of the Judicial Code to review a judgment of the appellate court of a State dismissing an appeal from an inferior court, are stated in the opinion.
Mt. Edward F. Colladay, with whom Mr. Napoleon B. Maxey was on the brief, for plaintiff in error.
Mr. W. T. Sprowls, Mr. V. B. Hays and Mr. Robert Crockett, for defendants in error, submitted.
Mr. Justice Van Devanter delivered the opinion of the court.
Our jurisdiction in this case is challenged by a motion to dismiss. The case was begun in the United States Court for the Central District of the Indian Territory, and was pending in that court when the Territory of Oklahoma and the Indian Territory were admitted into the Union as the State of Oklahoma. Under the combined operation of the Oklahoma Enabling Act (June 16,1906, 34 Stat. 267, c. 3335; March 4, 1907, Id. 1286, c. 2911) and the state constitution (see Benner v. Porter, 9 How. 235, 246) the case was then transferred to the district court of Bryan County, where a trial resulted in a judgment determining the matters in controversy, which turned in part upon the validity, under the laws of the United States, of certain deeds and leases executed by an Indian allottee, since deceased. The guardian of two minor heirs of the allottee had intervened in the cause, had asserted the invalidity of all the deeds and leases, and p. 585had set up a claim to the property in question as against the other parties; but this claim was rejected, and the guardian sought to have the judgment reviewed and reversed by the Supreme Court of the State. That court held that some of the parties below, whose presence in the appellate proceeding was essential, had not been brought into that proceeding, or voluntarily appeared therein, in accordance with the law of the State, and upon that ground dismissed the proceeding. 24 Oklahoma, 636. The guardian then sued out the present writ of error.
As the Supreme Court of the State did not pass upon the merits of the case or upon the correctness of any of the rulings below, but, on the contrary, held that it was powerless to do so because its appellate jurisdiction was not invoked in accordance with the laws of the State, we do not perceive any theory upon which its judgment of dismissal may be reviewed by us consistently with the familiar limitations upon our authority. See Rev. Stat., § 709; Judicial Code, § 237. Certainly no Federal right was denied by that court, and if, as was held by it, its appellate jurisdiction was not properly invoked, no Federal question was before it for decision.
Without any doubt it rests with each State to prescribe the jurisdiction of its appellate courts, the mode and time of invoking that jurisdiction, and the rules of practice to be applied in its exercise; and the state law and practice in this regard are no less applicable when Federal rights are in controversy than when the case turns entirely upon questions of local or general law. Callan v. Bransford, 139 U. S. 197; Brown v. Massachusetts, 144 U. S. 573; Jacobi v. Alabama, 187 U. S. 133; Hulbert v. Chicago, 202 U. S. 275, 281; Newman v. Gates, 204 U. S. 89; Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co. v. McDonald, 214 U. S. 191,195.
But it is said that the proceedings by which it was attempted to secure a review of the judgment of the trial court should have been tested by the act of Congress of p. 586March 3, 1905, 33 Stat. 1048, 1081, c. 1479, § 12, and that the Supreme Court of the State erred in holding otherwise. We cannot accede to the contention. The act of 1905, § 12, related to the review of judgments rendered in the courts temporarily established by Congress in the Indian Territory, and had no application to judgments rendered after statehood in the courts of the State. Besides, the mode of subjecting the judgments of the State’s subordinate courts to review in its Supreme Court was a matter of local concern only and not within the control of Congress. See Coyle v. Smith, 221 U. S. 559.
The state constitution provided (Art. 7, § 8) that the appellate jurisdiction of the Supreme Court should be invoked in the manner prescribed by the laws of the Territory of Oklahoma, until the state legislature should provide otherwise, and also (Art. 25, § 2) that the laws of the Territory of Oklahoma, not repugnant to the state constitution or locally inapplicable, should be extended over the new State, which embraced the Indian Territory as well as the Territory of Oklahoma. When the State was admitted into the Union the Territory of Oklahoma had a full complement of laws regulating appellate proceedings. Wilson’s Rev. & Ann. Stat. 1903, §§ 4732 et seq. It was by these constitutional provisions and laws that the Supreme Court tested the appellate proceedings in this instance, with the result that they were adjudged inadequate because they had not brought before the court, within the time prescribed (Wilson’s Stat., §§4736,4748), parties whose presence was essential to enable it to review the judgment below.
Thus it appears that nothing was decided but the preliminary question of the court’s jurisdiction to pass upon the controverted matters shown in the record, and that this question was resolved according to what the court deemed to be the true construction and effect of applicable provisions of the constitution and laws of the State. In p. 587short, the judgment of dismissal turned entirely upon a question of local law.
As particularly apposite, we quote the following from the opinion in Newman v. Gates, supra, a case in which this court declined to review a like judgment of dismissal by a state court:
“Had the appeal been properly taken it would have been the duty of the Supreme Court of Indiana to pass upon the questions presented by the record before it, including, it may be, a Federal question, based upon the due faith and credit clause of the Constitution, which, on various occasions, was pressed upon the attention of the trial court. In legal effect, however, the case stands as though no appeal had been prosecuted from the judgment rendered by the trial court. As the jurisdiction of this court to review the judgments or decrees of state courts when a Federal question is presented is limited to the review of a final judgment or decree, actually or constructively deciding such a question, when rendered by the highest court of a State in which a decision in the suit could be had, and as for the want of a proper appeal no final judgment or decree in such court has been rendered, it results that the statutory prerequisite for the exercise in this case of the reviewing power of this court is wanting.”
Writ of error dismissed.
BAKER v. WARNER.
SAME v. SAME.
ERROR TO THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.
Nos. 41, 42. Argued November 5, 1913.—Decided December 22, 1913.
Motions in arrest of judgment are not favored.
In considering a motion in arrest the plaintiff will be given the benefit of every implication that can be drawn from the pleading liberally construed; and even if the allegations are defectively set forth or improperly arranged, if they show facts constituting a good cause of action the motion will be denied.
Where the defendant in a suit for libel is put on notice of extrinsic facts surrounding the publication, and does not demur but joins issue and goes to trial, a verdict against him cures the defects in the complaint and a motion to arrest should not be granted.
The strict rules announced in earlier decisions in this respect have been modified by modem and more liberal rules of pleading.
Where plaintiff in error in this court succeeded in the trial court and was reversed in the intermediate appellate court, this court is not limited to a consideration of the points presented but must enter the judgment which should have been rendered by the court below on the record before it.
Although this court reverses the order to arrest the judgment, it affirms the ruling of the intermediate appellate court that there should be a new trial on account of erroneous instructions on material matters. Where the words are not libelous per se and can only be construed as such in the light of extrinsic facts, it is for the jury not only to determine whether the extrinsic facts exist but also whether the words have the defamatory meaning attributed to them.
36 App. D. C. 493, reversed.
The plaintiff, Baker, United States District Attorney for the District of Columbia, sued the defendant, Warner, for libel. Briefly stated, the complaint charges that
The Washington Jockey Club owned a race track in p. 589the District where races were run and bets were made and in January, 1908, the plaintiff, as District Attorney, had obtained from the Grand Jury an indictment charging one Walters with betting at this race track, contrary to the statute against gaming in the District. A demurrer was filed which was sustained on March 11, 1908,—the court holding that the laying of bets on horse races, at this track, was not a violation of the act of Congress, which as appears by reference to the statute (March 3, 1901, c. 854, 31 Stat. 1189,1331, §869) only prohibited such betting and bookmaking within one mile of the boundaries of the cities of Washington and Georgetown. The plaintiff immediately took an appeal from this judgment in order that the Court of Appeals might determine whether such betting at such place was a violation of the gaming law of force in the District.
Shortly after the appeal, the Spring Meet of the Jockey Club began, being advertised to continue until April 14. On the opening days of the Meet there was book-making and betting; but the complaint alleges that the plaintiff “ conforming himself, as it was his duty to do, to the law as judicially construed by the Supreme Court of the District, did not issue warrants for the arrest of or present to the Grand Jury any persons for betting on the horse races.”
It is further alleged that, at this time, Warner was a candidate against Pearre for the nomination for Congress from Maryland, and, on March 28, Warner composed and published, of and concerning the plaintiff and of and concerning the office of the plaintiff, in a Washington newspaper, a certain false and defamatory libel. The article need not be set out at length, but the communication, after characterizing a speech by his opponent as undignified, proceeded to say that it was not wanting m dignity so much as for a Judge of the District, “who, with the United States District Attorney (meaning the p. 590plaintiff) went to Rockville (meaning the town of Rockville, County of Montgomery, State of Maryland) last Saturday (meaning Saturday, the 21st day of March, A. D. 1908) to attend a conference of Mr. Warner’s (meaning defendant’s) enemies and determine what ammunition was needed to defeat him.
“The question now is, Where does the money come from in the contest against Mr. Warner? (meaning the defendant).
“How about the race track?
Lawyer.”
“meaning thereby, . . . that the said plaintiff entered into a conference with others for the purpose of determining what funds were necessary, and how same should be raised, to be used in the campaign on behalf of Pearre, and meaning . . . that the plaintiff was and is corrupt, in not presenting to the Grand Jury and prosecuting before the courts of the District, persons laying bets upon the contests at the race track, in consideration of contributions of money in the contest against the defendant from some company or person interested in the race track or the contests carried on thereon.”
The defendant filed a general denial, and, after a trial, there was a verdict in favor of the plaintiff. Motions for a new trial and in arrest of judgment were overruled and the case taken to the Court of Appeals, which held not only that reversible error had been committed, but that the judgment should have been arrested. In No. 41 the case is here on a writ to review that ruling. To avoid any question as to the finality of that judgment of the Court of Appeals plaintiff sued out another writ of error (No. 42) after the judgment had been arrested in the trial court.
Mr. Frank J. Hogan and Mr. Henry E. Davis for plaintiff in error.
Mr. W. C. Sullivan and Mr. J. J. Darlington for defendant in error.
Mr. Justice Lamar, after making the foregoing statement of facts, delivered the opinion of the court.
The plaintiff, who was United States District Attorney for the District of Columbia, sued the defendant in an action for libel and recovered a verdict for 810,000. The Court of Appeals (36 App. D. C. 493) held that the judgment should have been arrested, for the reason that the publication was not libelous per se and was not shown to be defamatory by any averment of fact in the Inducement or in the Colloquium.
The publication was not libelous per se. The meaning of the article and person to whom it referred were so ambiguous that, in order to constitute a cause of action, it was necessary to set out extrinsic facts, which, when coupled with the words, would show that the writer charged the plaintiff with corruption in office. Accordingly, the plaintiff in the Inducement averred that he was District Attorney, charged with the duty of prosecuting violators of the law against gaming, and had procured an indictment against one for betting at the Washington Jockey Club, which indictment had been quashed and, pending the appeal and conforming to the ruling of the court, he had instituted no other prosecutions: That, under these circumstances, the defendant had published of and concerning the plaintiff, the article which is set out in the complaint.
There were general allegations that the article was written concerning the plaintiff in his office as District Attorney, together with general statements in the Innuendo that the defendant meant to charge him with corruption in office. There was, however, no distinct averment as to the meaning of those particular phrases in the p. 592publication on which the cause of action was really based. The Court of Appeals thereupon sustained the defendant’s contention that the complaint was defective because of the failure specifically to allege what, as a fact, the words meant and to whom they referred. It further held that the absence of such specific averments was not supplied by the general statement in the Innuendo that the defendant meant to charge the plaintiff with a crime. This was based on the rule that it is not the office of the Innuendo to set out facts, but rather to explain what is ambiguous, or to state a conclusion which, to be effective, must be supported by averments, definitions, references or other facts alleged in traversible form in Inducement and Colloquium. It is, however, unnecessary to discuss the sufficiency of the complaint which, even if defective, was amendable. The defendant did not demur, but joined issue, the case was tried by a jury, a verdict for the plaintiff was rendered, judgment was entered and the defendant then moved in arrest.
Such motions are not favored. In considering them, courts liberally construe the pleadings, giving the plaintiff the benefit of every implication that can be drawn therefrom in his favor. Sentences and paragraphs may be transposed. The allegations in one part of the complaint may be aided by those in another and if taken together, they show the existence of facts constituting a good cause of action, defectively set forth or improperly arranged, the motion in arrest will be denied.
In the present case the defendant was put on notice of the extrinsic facts surrounding the publication. The statements in the Innuendo, even if misplaced, may after verdict, be treated as substantive allegations of fact given by transposition, their proper position in Inducement or Colloquium. The verdict cured the defects, if any, in the complaint and made it improper to arrest the judgment. Stanley v. Brit, 8 Tennessee, 222; Mo
Caughry v. Wetmore, 6 Johns. 82; Brittain v. Allen, 13 N. Car. 120, 124; Tuttle v. Bishop, 30 Connecticut, 80; Nestle v. Van Slyck, 2 Hill, 282. In answer to these decisions the defendant cites Ryany. Madden, 12 Vermont, 51, 55, and other cases, to support his contention that the motion in arrest should have been granted. But those decisions announce what, in Bloss v. Toby, 2 Pick. 320, was admitted to be a hard and technical rule—one which, we think, has been modified by modern and more liberal rules of pleading and practice in the Federal courts and in those of most of the States.
The plaintiff, Baker, had a judgment in the trial court. The defendant, Warner, took the case to the Court of Appeals on various grounds, most of which were sustained. The plaintiff then brought the case here, assigning error on some of those rulings but not on others. We are not limited, however, to a consideration of the points presented by the plaintiff, but, this being a writ of error from an intermediate appellate tribunal, must enter the judgment, which should have been rendered by the court below on the record then before it.
While we reverse the order to arrest the judgment, we affirm the ruling of the Court of Appeals that there was an erroneous instruction on a matter material to the case and harmful to the defendant. The trial judge, summariziing the facts, charged that if the jury found from the evidence that plaintiff was District Attorney; that in the District there was a race track where races were run and bets were made, which some claimed could have been prevented by prosecutions instituted by the plaintiff and that he did not, in fact, prosecute such persons; if Warner was a candidate for Congress and the plaintiff supported Pearre, his opponent, and the defendant, Warner, wrote and procured the publication of the article set out in the complaint, “then you are instructed, as matter of law, that the said article is libelous and your von, ccxxxi—38 p. 594verdict should be for the plaintiff, and the only question for your determination is what amount of damages the plaintiff is entitled to recover by reason of the publication of said article.”
This was error, since it was for the jury and not for the court to determine the meaning of ambiguous language in the published article. Where words are libelous per se the Judge can so instruct the jury, leaving to them only the determination of the amount of damages. Where the words are not libelous per se and, in the light of the extrinsic facts averred could not possibly be construed to have a defamatory meaning, the Judge can dismiss the declaration on demurrer, or, during the trial, may withdraw the case from the jury. But there is a middle ground where though the words are not libelous per se, yet, in the light of the extrinsic facts averred, they are susceptible of being construed as having a defamatory meaning. Whether they have such import is a question of fact. In that class of cases the jury must not only determine the existence of the extrinsic circumstances, which it is alleged bring to light the concealed meaning, but they must also determine whether those facts when coupled with the words, make the publication libelous. Van Vechten v. Hopkins, 5 Johns. 219. The meaning of the words was in dispute, and as that issue of fact was not submitted to the triers of fact, a new trial must be ordered.
This conclusion makes it unnecessary to consider the other questions in the case.
The judgments of the Court of Appeals are reversed and the cases are remanded to that court with directions to reverse the judgments of the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia and to remand the case to that court with directions to grant a new trial and for further proceedings in conformity with this opinion.