Case details
Bluebook Citation
Hooe v. Jamieson, 166 U.S. 395 (1897)
Full caption
HOOE v. JAMIESON.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Apr. 5, 1897
HOOE v. JAMIESON.
error to the circuit court of the united states for the
WESTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN.
No. 374. Submitted March 1, 1897.—Decided April 5, 1897.
A citizen of the District of Columbia cannot maintain an action against a citizen of Wisconsin, on the ground of diverse citizenship, in a Circuit Court of the United States in that State; even though a competent person be joined with him as co-plaintiff. The case is stated in the opinion.
Mr. A. B. Bushnell for plaintiffs in error.
Mr. S. S. Barney for defendants in error.
Mr. Chief Justice Fitller delivered the opinion of the court.
This was an action of ejectment brought in the Circuit Court of the United States for the Western District of Wisconsin, by the complaint in which plaintiffs in error alleged that they resided in and were citizens of the city of Washington, D. C., and that defendants all resided in and were citizens of the State of Wisconsin. Defendants moved to dismiss the action on the ground that the Circuit Court had no jurisdiction as the controversy was not between citizens of different States. The Circuit Court ordered that the action be dismissed unless plaintiffs within five days thereafter should so amend their complaint as to allege the necessary jurisdictional facts. Plaintiffs then moved for leave to amend their complaint by averring that three of them were when the suit was commenced, and continued to be, citizens of the District of Columbia, but that one of them was a citizen of the State of Minnesota, and that each was the owner of an undivided one fourth of the lands and premises described in the complaint, and that they severally claimed damages and demanded judgment. This motion was denied and the action dismissed. Plaintiffs sued out this writ of error under the act of March 3, 1891, c. 517, § 5, and the Circuit Court certified to this court these questions of jurisdiction :
“ First. Whether or not said complaint sets forth any cause of action in which there is a controversy between citizens of different States, so as to give said Circuit Court jurisdiction thereof:
“ Second. Whether or not said complaint as so proposed to be amended would, if so amended, set forth any cause of action in which there is a controversy between citizens of different States, so as to give said Circuit Court jurisdiction thereof.”
The judicial power extends under the Constitution to con-
troversies between citizens of different States, and the Judiciary Act of 1789 provided,as does the act of March 3, 1887, as corrected by the act of August 13, 1888, 25 Stat. 433, c. 866, that the Circuit Courts of the United States should have original cognizance of all suits of a civil nature at common law or in equity in which there should be a controversy between citizens of different States.
We see no reason for arriving at any other conclusion than that announced by Chief Justice Marshall in Hepburn v. Ellzey, 2 Cranch, 445, February term, 1805, “that the members of the American confederacy only are the States contemplated in the Constitution ” ; that the District of Columbia is not a State within the meaning of that instrument; and that the courts of the United States have no jurisdiction of cases between citizens of the District of Columbia and citizens of a State.
In Strawbridge v. Curtiss, 3 Cranch, 267, it was held that if there be two or more joint plaintiffs and two or more joint defendants, each of the plaintiffs must be capable of suing each of the defendants in the courts of the United States in order to support the jurisdiction; and in Smith v. Lyon, 133 IT. S. 315, Strawbridge v. Curtiss was followed, and it was decided that under the acts of 1887 and 1888 the Circuit Court has not jurisdiction, on the ground of diverse citizenship, if there are two plaintiffs to the action who are citizens of and residents in different States and the defendant is a citizen of and resident in a third State, and the action is brought in the State in which one of the plaintiffs resides.
New Orleans v. Winter, 1 Wheat. 91, was an action in ejectment brought by two plaintiffs claiming as joint heirs, and it appeared that one of them was a citizen of the State of Kentucky, and that the other was a citizen of the Territory of Mississippi. It was held that jurisdiction could not be maintained, and Chief Justice Marshall, delivering the opinion of the court, said: “Gabriel Winter, then, being a citizen of the Mississippi Territory, was incapable of maintaining a suit alone in the District Court of Louisiana. Is his case mended by being associated with others who are capable of suing in [p. 398] that court? In the case of Strawbridge n. Curtiss, it was decided, that where a joint interest is prosecuted, the jurisdiction cannot be sustained, unless each individual be entitled to claim that jurisdiction. In this case it has been doubted, whether the parties might elect to sue jointly or severally. However this may be, having elected to sue jointly, the court is incapable of distinguishing their case, so far as respects jurisdiction, from one in which they were compelled to unite.”
In Peninsular Iron Co. v. Stone, 121 IT. S. 631, the interests of the parties being separate and distinct, but depending on one contract, plaintiffs elected to sue on the common obligation, and the case was dismissed under the rule in New Orleans v. Winter,
In Barney v. Baltimore, 6 Wall. 280, 287, which was a bill for partition, it appeared that some of the defendants were citizens of the District of Columbia and some of them citizens of Maryland, and, in dismissing the case for want of jurisdiction, the court, through Mr. Justice Miller, said: “In the case of Hepburn v. Ellzey, it -was decided by this court, speaking through Marshall, C. J., that a citizen of the District of Columbia was not a citizen of a State within the meaning of the Judiciary Act, and could not sue in a Federal court. The same principle was asserted in reference to a citizen of a Territory, in the case of New Orleans v. Winter, and it was there held to defeat the jurisdiction, although the citizen of the Territory of Mississippi wras joined with a person who, in suing alone, could have maintained the suit. These rulings have never been disturbed, but the principle asserted has been acted upon ever since by the courts when the point has arisen.”
Many other decisions are to the same effect, and in the late case of Merchants' Cotton Press Co. v. Insurance Co., 151U. 8. 368, 384, the rule in New Orleans v. Winter was applied and it was held that “the voluntary joinder of the parties has the same effect for purposes of jurisdiction as if they had been compelled to unite.”
In the case at bar no application was made for leave to discontinue as to the three plaintiffs who were citizens of the
Counsel for Plaintiff in Error.
District of Columbia, and to amend the complaint and proceed with the cause in favor of that one of the plaintiffs alleged to be a citizen of Minnesota. Jurisdiction of the case as to four plaintiffs could not be maintained on the theory that when the trial terminated it might be retained as to one. The Circuit Court was right and its judgment is
Affirmed.
Hooe v, Werner. No. 373. Submitted with No. 374, above,
and on the same briefs.
The Chief Justice : The only difference between this case and that just decided is that the proposed amendment was allowed and the action then dismissed for want of jurisdiction. For the reasons above given, this case must take the same course as that.
Judgment affirmed.
MARTIN v. ATCHISON, TOPEKA AND SANTA FÊ RAILROAD COMPANY.
ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE TERRITORY OF NEW
MEXICO.
No. 170, Submitted January 25, 1897. —Decided April 5, 1897.
The plaintiffin error was in the employment of the defendant in error as a common laborer. While on a hand car on the road, proceeding to his place of work, he was run into by a train, and seriously injured. It was claimed that the collision was caused by carelessness and negligence on the part of other employés of the company, roadmaster, foreman of the gang of laborers, conductor, etc. Held, that the co-employés whose negligence was alleged to have caused the injury were fellow-servants of the plaintiff, and hence that the defendant was not liable for the injuries caused by that negligence.
The case is stated in the opinion.
NeiU £. Field for plaintiff in error.
Mr. E. D. Kenna and Mr. Robert Dunlap for defendant in error.
Me. Justice Peckham delivered the opinion of the court.
This action was brought by the plaintiff in error to recover damages for injuries sustained by him by being run over by a train on a railroad belonging to the defendant, near Albuquerque, New Mexico. The case was tried before a jury in the District Court of the Second Judicial District of that Territory, and resulted in a verdict for the plaintiff in the sum of $8000. Judgment having been entered, the railroad company took the case, by writ of error, to the Supreme Court of the Territory, which court reversed the judgment, and directed judgment for the railroad company, and for costs against the plaintiff, who thereupon sued out a writ of error from this court, and the case is now here for review.
On the trial evidence was given showing substantially the following facts: The plaintiff had been employed by the railroad company at Albuquerque, New Mexico, as a common laborer, “ fixing the road, straightening out the rails and fixing ties wherever required he was about thirty-nine years of age and had been so employed by the company, through one of its section foremen, for several months prior to the happening of the accident. He was under the orders of the section foreman and was to do what the foreman told him. The section foreman was employed by the roadmaster and the foreman employed the men; the roadmaster directed the section foremen what work to do and where to do it; he laid out the work for them and told them what to do. The section foreman employed the men and saw that they did the work properly. If the foreman thought a man ought to be discharged, he would see the roadmaster or send him a request that the man should be discharged, and the roadmaster had the power to discharge him. The men under the section foreman, like the plaintiff, were paid by the agents of the company, who came along the line in a pay car.
On June 5, 1889, while the plaintiff was thus employed, he
came to the station at Albuquerque about 6.45 o’clock in the morning for the purpose of going to his work on a hand car with one Mares, his co-laborer, and Charles Smith, his section foreman. The place where they were to work was about eight or nine miles north from Albuquerque on the line of the road. A few minutes before seven the party, consisting of the section foreman, Mares and the plaintiff, started on a hand car for the place where they were to work during the day. They went north upon the road for three or four hundred yards and there the car was stopped, and the men got off and procured a barrel of water, which was placed on the car, and the men again started north to continue their ride. All three men worked the crank on the hand car, but just as they started Mares said to the foreman that he thought the work train seemed to be starting from Albuquerque towards them. The track at that point was straight and the view to the station was unobstructed. Plaintiff then turned his head backwards towards the station, when the foreman told him not to do that; that he had no business to do it, and that it was not his business to watch for trains, and that he, the foreman, would take care of that. Plaintiff thereupon turned his head away from the station and continued to look north, the way they were going. They worked the crank so that the car was going as rapidly as they could make it, all three men having their heads turned towards the north. In the meantime a work train backed out from the station at Albuquerque, going north, and continued backing rapidly until it was moving at the rate of seventeen or eighteen miles an hour. Before the men on the hand car had proceeded very far along the road they were overtaken by the work train, which ran over them, killing the foreman and badly injuring the plaintiff and Mares. Neither of the latter had heard the approach of the train ; it was under the management of a conductor, and at that time there was a roadmaster on the train who had control of the line of road where the accident occurred. He was not in charge of the running of the train, but the train went to different points on the road as he had occasion to visit them for working purposes. Some of the hands on the work train saw the
VOL. CLXVI—26
hand car a short distance before it was struck, and one of them tried to communicate with the engineer of the train, but failed. No one on the hand car was looking backward or saw the approach of the work train.
It was claimed in the petition on the part of the plaintiff that the accident occurred from the neglect of the conductor and of the hands on the work train, and also by reason of the neglect of the section foreman on the hand car with the plaintiff in ordering plaintiff to face north while working the car, and in not keeping a lookout himself for the approach of the train from behind.
The defendant had filed a plea of not guilty.
Upon the trial of the action, after the evidence for both sides had been introduced and each side had rested the case, the defendant moved the court “ to instruct the jury to find for the defendant upon the ground that the negligence, if any, through which the plaintiff was injured was the negligence of the fellow-servants of the plaintiff, for which the defendant is not liable.” After hearing arguments, the court overruled the defendant’s motion, and counsel for the defendant then and there excepted.
After the verdict for plaintiff had been rendered and judgment entered thereon, the defendant obtained a writ of error from the Supreme Court of the Territory to review the rulings of the District Court. Various assignments of errors were made, and among them was the eighth, which reads as follows: “ The court erred in not sustaining defendant’s motion to instruct the jury to find a verdict in favor of the defendant, and the defendant not guilty.”
The Supreme Court held that whatever negligence was proved, as against the employes of the defendant, such negligence was that of fellow-servants with the plaintiff, and on that ground the judgment was reversed and judgment ordered in favor of the defendant, with costs.
The plaintiff seeks here a reversal of the last judgment. We think the decision of the Supreme Court was right and that the judgment entered thereon must be affirmed.
The cases of Baltimore de Ohio Railroad Company v. Baugh, [p. 403] 149 U. S. 368; Northern Pacific Pailroad Company v. Rambly, 154 U. S. 349; Northern Pacific Railroad Company v. Peterson, 162 U. S. 346; and Northern Pacific Railroad Company n. Charless, 162 U. S. 359, cover this case in all its aspects, and render it entirely clear that the employes of the defendant herein, whose negligence caused the injury to the plaintiff, were his fellow-servants at that time, and hence the defendant cannot be held liable to plaintiff for the injuries sustained by him as a result of that negligence.
The counsel for the plaintiff has argued before us that the defendant must be held responsible because the plaintiff had been directed by the foreman, under whose orders he was placed, to look north while he was on the car, and had received the foreman’s assurance that he (the foreman) would warn him of. the approach of danger, and that as the foreman failed to do so it was the failure of the defendant to do something which it was bound as a master to do in furtherance of the obligation it was under to see that the plaintiff had a reasonably safe place in which to perform his work. We do not perceive that the doctrine as to the duty of the master to furnish a safe place for the servant to work in has the slightest application to the facts of this case. There is no intimation in the evidence nor is any claim made that the hand car upon which the plaintiff was riding was not properly equipped and in good repair, and in every way fit for the purpose for which it was used. It was a perfectly safe and proper means of transit in and of itself from the station at Albuquerque to the point where the plaintiff was going to work. The negligence of the section foreman in failing to note the approaching train and to give the proper warning, so that the car might be taken from the track, was not the neglect of the defendant in regard to the performance of any duty which as master it owed the plaintiff. If the car were rendered unsafe, it was not by reason of any lack of diligence on the part of the defendant in providing a proper car, but the danger arose simply because a fellow-servant of the plaintiff failed to discharge his own duty in watching for the approach of a train from the south.
Syllabus.
Upon an examination of the cases above cited it will be found that the principles therein laid down clearly and plainly cover this case.
The judgment must be
Affirmed.
Mb. Justice Hablan dissented.
1
The docket title of this case is : The Cunard Steamship Company (limited') owner of the Steamship Umbria v. Cyprien Fabre, Manager of the Compagnie Française de Navigation à vapextr.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access