McElroy v. United States, 164 U.S. 76 (1896)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
McElroy v. United States, 164 U.S. 76 (1896)
Full caption
McELROY v. UNITED STATES.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Nov. 2, 1896
McELROY v. UNITED STATES.
ERROR TO THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THB WESTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS.
No. 402. Submitted October 13,1896. — Decided November 2, 1896.
G., B., H., C., S. and J. were indicted April 16 for assault with intent to kill EM.; also, on the same day, for assault with intent to kill SM.; also, May 1, for arson of the dwelling house of EM.; and, on the same 16th of April, G., B. and H. were indicted for arson of the dwelling house of BM. The court ordered the four indictments consolidated. All the defendants except J. were then tried together, and the trials resulted in separate verdicts of conviction, and the prisoners so convicted were severally sentenced to terms of imprisonment. Held, that the several charges in the four indictments were for offences separate and distinct, complete in themselves, independent of each other, and not provable by the same evidence; and that their consolidation was not authorized by Rev. Stat. § 1024.
Such a joinder cannot be sustained where the parties are not the same, and where the offences are in nowise parts of the same transaction, and depend upon evidence of a different state of facts as to each or some of them.
The case is stated in the opinion.
Mr. William, M. Cravens for plaintiffs in error.
Mr. Assistant Attorney General Dickinson for defendants in error.
Mr. Chief Justice Fuller delivered the opinion of the court.
George McElroy, John C. W. Bland, Henry Hook, Charles Hook, Thomas Stufflebeam and Joe Jennings were indicted in the district Court for the Western District of Arkansas for assault with intent to kill Elizabeth Miller, April 16, 1894, the indictment being numbered 5332; also for assault with intent to kill Sherman Miller, on the same day, the indictment being numbered 5333; also for arson of the dwelling house of one Eugene Miller, May 1, 1894, the indictment being numbered 5334. Three of these defendants, namely,
George McElroy, John C. W. Bland and Henry Hook, were also indicted for the arson of the dwelling house of one Bruce Miller, April 16, 1894, the indictment being numbered 4843. It does not appear that Jennings was tried. The court ordered the four indictments consolidated for trial, to which each of the five defendants duly excepted. Trial was then had and resulted in separate verdicts finding the defendants guilty, and, after the overruling of motions for new trial and in arrest, they were severally sentenced on each indictment to separate and successive terms in the penitentiary, and sued out this writ of error.
The consequence of this order of consolidation was that defendants Stufflebeam and Charles Hook were tried on three separate indictments against them and three other defendants, consolidated with another indictment against the other defendants for an offence with which the former wTere not charged, while an indictment for feloniously firing the dwelling house of one person on a certain day was tried with an indictment for arson committed a fortnight after in respect of the dwelling house of another person.
Section 1024 of the Revised Statutes is as follows: “ When there are several charges against any person for the same act or transaction, or for two or more acts or transactions connected together, or for two or more acts or transactions of the same class of crimes or offences, which may be properly joined, instead of having several indictments the whole may be joined in one indictment in separate counts ; and if two or more indictments are found in such cases, the court may order them to be consolidated.”
The order of consolidation under this statute put all the counts contained in the four indictments in the same category as if they were separate counts of one indictment, and we are met on the threshold with the inquiry whether counts against five defendants can be coupled with a count against part of them or offences charged to have been committed by all at one time can be joined with another and distinct offence committed by part of them at a different time.
The statute was much considered in Pointer v. United States, [p. 78] 151 U. S. 396, 403. In that case the defendant was charged in different counts with two murders alleged to have been committed on the same day and in the same county and district, and moved to quash on that ground, which motion was denied. Before the case was opened to the jury for the government the defendant moved that the district attorney be required to elect on which count of the indictment he would claim a conviction. The motion was overruled, and he was required to go to trial upon all the counts. Upon the conclusion of the evidence the defendant renewed the motion that the government be required to elect upon which count of the indictment it would prosecute him, but this motion was overruled. The jury found separate verdicts of guilty of each murder as charged in the appropriate count. This court, speaking through Mr. Justice Harlan, said: “While recognizing as fundamental the principle that the court must not permit the defendant to be embarrassed in his defence by a multiplicity of charges embraced in one indictment and to be tried by one jury, and while conceding that regularly or usually an indictment should not include more than one felony, the authorities concur in holding that a joinder in one indictment, in separate counts, of different felonies, at least of the same class or grade, and subject to the same punishment, is not necessarily fatal to the indictment upon demurrer or upon motion to quash or on motion in arrest of judgment, and does not, in every case, by reason alone of such joinder, make it the duty of the court, upon motion of the accused, to compel the prosecutor to elect upon what one of the charges he will go to trial.” It was decided that it could not be held from anything on the face of the indictment that the trial court erred or abused its discretion in overruling the defendant’s motion to quash the indictment, or his motions for an election by the government between the two charges of murder. The indictment showed that the two murders were committed on the same day, in the same county and district, and with the same kind of an instrument, and these facts justified the trial court in forbearing at the beginning of the trial to compel an election. And when the evidence was closed it appeared [p. 79] therefrom that the two murders were committed at the same place, on the same occasion, and under such circumstances that the proof in respect of one necessarily threw light upon the other; and that “ there was such close connection between the two felonies, in respect of time, place and occasion, that it was difficult, if not impossible, to separate the proof of one charge from the proof of another.” As it was apparent that the substantial rights of the accused were not prejudiced by the action of the trial court, we declined to reverse on the ground of error therein.
It will be perceived that the two offences were charged against one and the same defendant, and that the case disclosed such concurrence as to place, time and circumstances as rendered the proof the same as to both, and made the two alleged murders substantially parts of the same transaction.
In the case at bar, the two indictments for assault with intent to kill on April 16, 1894, and the indictment for arson on May 1, 1894, were against all of the defendants, while the indictment for arson committed'April 16, 1894, the same day of the alleged assaults with intent to kill, was against three of the defendants and not against the others.
On the face of the indictments there was no connection between the acts charged as committed April 16 and the arson alleged to have been committed two weeks later, on which last occasion the government’s testimony, according to the record, showed that the two defendants Charles Hook and Thomas Stufllebeam were not present. The record also discloses that there was no evidence offered tending to show that there had been or was a conspiracy between defendants, or them and other parties, to commit the alleged crimes.
The several charges in the four indictments were not against the same persons, nor were they for the same act or transaction, nor for two or more acts or transactions connected together; and in our opinion they were not for two or more acts or transactions of the same class of crimes or offences which might be properly joined, because they were substantive offences, separate and distinct, complete in themselves and independent of each other, committed at different times and [p. 80] not provable by the same evidence. In cases of felony, the multiplication of distinct charges has been considered so objectionable as tending to confound the accused in his defence, or to prejudice him as to his challenges, in the matter of being held out to be habitually criminal, in the distraction of the attention of the jury, or otherwise, that it is the settled rule in England and in many of our States, to confine the indictment to one distinct offence or restrict the evidence to one transaction. Young v. The King, 3 T. R. 98, 106; Reg. v. Heywood, Leigh & Cave C. C. 451; Tindal, C. J., O' Connelly. Reg., 11 Cl. & Fin. 241; Reg. v. Ward, 10 Cox C. C. 42; Rex v. Young, Russ. & Ry. 280; Reg. v. Lonsdale, 4 Fost. & Fin. 56; Goodhue v. People, 94 Illinois, 37; State v. Nelson, 8 N. H. 163; People v. Aiken, 66 Michigan, 460; Williams v. State, 77 Alabama, 53 ; State v. Hutchings, 24 S. C. 142; State v. McNeill, 93 N. C. 552; State v. Daubert, 42 Missouri, 242; 1 Bish. Cr. Proc. § 259. Necessarily where the accused is deprived of a substantial right by the action of the trial court, such action, having been properly objected to, is revisable on error.
It is clear that the statute does not authorize the consolidation of indictments in such a way that some of the defendants may be tried at the same time with other defendants charged with a crime different from that for which all are tried. And even* if the defendants are the same in all the indictments consolidated, we do not think the statute authorizes the joinder of distinct felonies, not provable by the same evidence and in no sense resulting from the same series of acts.
Under the third clause relating to several charges “for two or more acts or transactions of the same class of crimes or offences,” it is only when they “may be properly joined” that the joinder is permitted, the statute thus leaving it for the court to determine whether in any given case a joinder of two or more offences in one indictment against the same person “ is consistent with the settled principles of criminal law,” as stated in Pointer's case.
It is admitted by the government that the judgments against Stufflebeam and Charles Hook must be reversed, but it is contended that the judgments as to the other three defendants
Syllabus.
should be affirmed because there is nothing in the record to show that they were prejudiced or embarrassed in their defence by the course pursued. But we do not concur in this view. While the general rule is that counts for several felonies of the same general nature, requiring the same mode of trial and punishment, may be joined in the same indictment, subject to the power of the court to quash the indictment or to compel an election, such joinder cannot be sustained where the parties are not the same and where the offences are in nowise parts of the same transaction and must depend upon evidence of a different state of facts as to each or some of them. It cannot be said in such case that all the defendants may not have been embarrassed and prejudiced in their defence, or that the attention of the jury may not have been distracted to their injury in passing upon distinct and independent transactions. The order of consolidation was not authorized by statute and did not rest in mere discretion.
Judgment reversed as to all the defendants and cause remanded with directions to grant a new trial and for further proceedings in conformity with this opinion.
Mr. Justice Brewer and Mr. Justice Peckham concurred in the reversal as to Stufflebeam and Charles Hook only.
UNITED STATES v. McMAHON.
McMAHON v. UNITED STATES.
ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT.
Nos. 856, 857. Argued October 21, 1896. —Decided November 2,1896. The fees to which a marshal is entitled, under Rev. Stat. § 829, for attending criminal examinations in separate and distinct cases upon the same day and before the same commissioner, are five dollars a day; but when he attends such examinations before different commissioners on the same day he is entitled to a fee of two dollars for attendance before each commissioner.
A special deputy marshal, appointed under Rev. Stat. § 2021, to attend vol. clxjv —6
before commissioners and aid and assist supervisors of elections, is entitled to an allowance of five dollars per day in full compensation for all such services.
The marshal of the Southern District of New York, who transports convicts from New York City to the state penitentiary in Erie County in the Northern District of New York is entitled to fees at the rate of ten cents per mile for the transportation, instead of the actual expense thereof.
A marshal is not entitled to a fee of two dollars for serving temporary and final warrants of commitment.
These were writs of error sued out by both parties, to review a judgment of the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, affirming, except in one particular, a judgment of the Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York for $4843.60 in favor of the petitioner McMahon, for fees and disbursements as marshal for that district, from July 7, 1885, to January 12, 1890. The opinion of the Court of Appeals is found in 26 U. S. App. 687.
The assignments of error filed by both parties are set out in the opinion of the court.
Mr. Assistant Attorney General Dodge for the United States. Mr. Felix Brannigan was on his brief.
Mr. Richard Randolph McMahon for McMahon.
Mr. Justice Brown delivered the opinion of the court.
In these cases the government assigns as error —
1. The allowance of a charge of two dollars per day for attending criminal examinations in separate and distinct cases upon the same day; these examinations being on some days all before the same commissioner.; and on others before different commissioners. The evidence does not disclose how much of this amount is applicable to each class of cases.
By Rev. Stat. § 829, the marshal is allowed “ for attending the Circuit and District Courts, . . . and for bringing in and committing prisoners and witnesses during the term, five dollars a day,” and “ for attending examinations before a commissioner, and bringing in, guarding and returning prisoners [p. 83] charged with crime, and witnesses, two dollars a day; and for each deputy, not exceeding two, necessarily attending, two dollars a day.” If the fee were two dollars for attending examinations simply, it might well be held that he was entitled to that amount for each examination, though there were a dozen in a single day; but as the allowance is not for each examination but for each day, we think it clear that the marshal is only entitled to a single fee. It is scarcely possible to suppose that he would be allowed but five dollars for attending court, irrespective of the number of cases disposed of or of the number of prisoners brought in and committed, and yet be allowed separate fees in each case before a commissioner, which in the aggregate might be double the amount allowed for attending court. McCafferty v. United States, 26 C. Cl. 1.
But when a marshal attends examinations before two different commissioners on the same day, we think he is entitled to his fee of two dollars for attendance before each commissioner. In the case of United States v. Erwin, 147 U. S. 685, we held that a district attorney was entitled to charge a per diem for services before a commissioner upon the same day that he was allowed a per diem for attendance upon court; and the argument controlling our opinion in that case is equally applicable here. It is true that in that case the charge was for attending before the court and before a single commissioner upon the same day; but where the officer attends before two or more commissioners, who may hold their sessions at a distance from each other, we see no reason why he should not be entitled to a fee in the case of each commissioner.
2. The allowance of two dollars per day to special deputy marshals for attendance before a commissioner on November 2, 1886, “said day being an election day.” The finding is that for his service upon this day each deputy marshal received a per diem of five dollars. It is not directly found by the Circuit Court that these special deputies were appointed pursuant to Rev. Stat. § 2021, Title XXVI, but as it is so admitted in the briefs of counsel, and as this title makes the [p. 84] only provision for the appointment of special deputies, we may assume that to be the fact. The duties of such special deputies, who are appointed by the marshal to aid and assist the supervisors of election, are fixed by §§ 2021, 2022 and 2023. They are in general to keep the peace, support and protect the supervisors of the election in the discharge of their duties, preserve order, to arrest and take into custody any person offending against the law, when (§ 2023) “the person so arrested shall forthwith be brought before a commissioner . . . for examination of the offences alleged against him.” By § 2031, “ there shall be allowed and paid to . . . each special deputy marshal who is appointed and performs his duty under the preceding provisions, compensation at the rate of five dollars per day for each day he is actually on duty, not exceeding ten days.”
As it appears by these sections that the attendance of the deputy before the commissioner is incidental to his service in arresting the fraudulent voter and taking him before the commissioner, we think it is covered by the per diem provided by § 2031. The allowance of five dollars per day was evidently intended to be full compensation for all services performed by him as such deputy. The assignment is well taken.
3. Exception is also taken to the allowance of fees at the rate of ten cents per mile for transporting convicts from New York City to the state penitentiary in Erie County, in the Northern District of New York, instead of the actual expense of such transportation. By Rev. Stat. § 829, the marshal is allowed “ for transporting criminals, ten cents a mile for himself and for each prisoner and necessary guard,” with the following exception: “for transporting criminals convicted of a crime in any District or Territory, where there is no penitentiary available for the confinement of convicts of the United States, to a prison in another District or Territory designated by the Attorney General, the reasonable actual expense of the transportation of the criminals, the marshal and the guards, and the necessary subsistence and hire.” It appears that no prison in the State of New York has been expressly designated by the Attorney General for the [p. 85] confinement of Federal convicts, but by the state law it is the duty of the keepers of state prisons to receive and keep such convicts, when sentenced to imprisonment therein by any court of the United States sitting within the State. Literally, the service charged for in this case does not fall within the second paragraph of the above section, since it does not appear that there is no penitentiary available within the Southern District of New York, nor does it appear that the penitentiary in Erie County has been designated by the Attorney General for the confinement of Federal convicts.
There are other provisions of law, however, which it is necessary to consider in this connection. By Rev. Stat. §5540, originally enacted in 1856, “where a judicial district has been or may hereafter be divided (New York was originally a single district, act of September 24, 1789, c. 20, 1 Stat. 73), the Circuit and District Courts of the United States shall have power to sentence any one convicted of an offence punishable by imprisonment at hard labor to the penitentiary within the State, though it be out of the judicial district in which the conviction is had.” Moreover, by Rev. Stat. § 5541, originally enacted in 1865, “ in every case where any person convicted of any offence against the United States is sentenced to imprisonment for a period longer than one year, the court . . may order the same to be executed in any state jail or penitentiary within the District or State where such court is held,” etc., and by Rev. Stat. § ^542 a similar provision is made where the convict is sentenced to imprisonment and confinement to hard labor.
By a subsequent act of July 12, 1876, c. 183, 19 Stat. 88, amending Rev. Stat. § 5546, convicts “ whose punishment is imprisonment in a District or Territory where, at the time of conviction, . . . there may be no penitentiary or jail suitable for the confinement of convicts, or available therefor, shall be confined . . . in some suitable jail or penitentiary in a convenient State or Territory to be designated by the Attorney General,” in which case the marshal is only allowed . e reasonable actual expenses of transportation, etc.; “ but if, m the opinion of the Attorney General, the expense of [p. 86] transportation from any State ... in which there is no penitentiary, will exceed the cost of maintaining them in jail in the State, . . . then it shall be lawful so to confine them therein for the period designated in their respective sentences.” We see no reason to suppose that this act was intended to repeal Rev. Stat. §§ 5540, 5541 and 5542, since the act is a mere reenactment of original § 5546, enacted in 1864 (one year before § 5541), except that it permits the place of confinement of the convict to be changed, whenever the penitentiary to which he is sentenced becomes unsuitable or unavailable at any time during the term of imprisonment ; and by a further clause, permission is given the Attorney General to change the place of imprisonment whenever it is necessary for the preservation of the health of the prisoner, or the place of confinement becomes insecure, or the prisoner is cruelly or improperly treated.
Upon the other hand, it appears to us that it was the intention of Congress that these several provisions should be read together, and that the restriction of the marshal to his expenses of transportation was only designed to apply where the Attorney General has found that there is no available penitentiary within the district, and has designated a prison in another district for that purpose. It does not necessarily follow that, because a portion of his travel was outside his district, he is limited to his expenses, since the first paragraph of § 829, above quoted, is a general provision allowing him mileage with the exception provided for in the next paragraph. As the travel was actually made, the marshal is presumed to have earned his mileage, and the burden is upon the government to show that the transportation falls within the excepted clause. While the authority of the marshal, as such, is confined to his district, it may be lawfully extended by the United States to other districts for special purposes, such, for instance, as the service of a subpoena, for which it has usually been held the marshal was entitled to mileage, though the service was made outside his district.
Sections 5540 to 5542 were apparently designed to apply to cases where the State contains more than one district, while
§ 5546 was probably intended, notwithstanding the use of the words “ District or Territory,” in the first clause, to apply to the not infrequent cases where there is no suitable penitentiary within the State, in which case the court is authorized to commit the convict to some suitable penitentiary “ in a convenient State or Territory, to be designated by the Attorney General.” This power has been frequently exercised by courts of the Western States by committing prisoners to penitentiaries in the Northern or Eastern States. Where the penitentiary is located in the same State, it would seem reasonable that the marshal should be entitled to his mileage, though the state prison may happen to be in another district, since it may be in fact quite as near to the place where his court is held, as it is to the place where the court is held in the district of its actual location.
Why these convicts were sent to a penitentiary outside the district in which they were tried does not appear, but we are bound to presume that the action of the court in that particular was taken for a good and sufficient reason, and was dictated by what it conceived to be the best interests of the government. As, under §§ 5541 and 5542, it was within the discretion of the court to sentence the convicts to any penitentiary within the State, the mileage was properly allowed.
4. The last item to which exception is taken by the government is to a charge of two dollars for serving temporary and final warrants of commitment. As the court had previously disallowed a charge of $503 for serving temporary warrants of commitment, the allowance of this item was probably an oversight. In United States v. Tanner, 147 U. S. 661, we held that the marshal was not entitled to charge for mileage in serving warrants of commitment, upon the ground that he was allowed ten cents mileage for his own transportation and that of his prisoner, and that the delivery of such warrants to the warden of the penitentiary was not a “ service ” within the meaning of § 829. We have seen no reason to change our views in that particular. The word “service” in this connection ordinarily implies something in the nature of an [p. 88] act or proceeding adverse to the party served, or of a notice to him, and we think was not intended to cover the case of a warrant deposited with the warden of a penitentiary as a voucher or authority for detaining the prisoner. Moreover, it is scarcely possible that Congress could have intended to allow the marshal ten cents a mile for his own travel when accompanying a prisoner, and at the same time to allow him six cents for carrying the warrant of commitment with him; or to allow him fifty cents for a commitment of the prisoner and also two dollars for serving a warrant of commitment, when the commitment would not be valid without the warrant, and the commitment and service of the warrant are contemporaneous acts. As the per diem of the marshal for attendance before the court or commissioner includes “ the bringing in, guarding and returning prisoners charged with crime,” and as, by § 1030, “ no writ is necessary to bring into court any prisoner or person in custody, or for remanding him from the court into custody; but the same shall be done on the order of the court or district attorney, for which no fee shall be charged by the clerk or marshal,” and no such warrant appears to be necessary under the practice in the State of New York, the issue of such warrants, except perhaps the first one, appears to be unnecessary.
In the case of the writ sued out by McMahon the plaintiff assigns as error the action of the Court of Appeals in rejecting a charge for serving temporary warrants of commitment issued by a commissioner; but as this is covered by the point last decided, it is unnecessary to consider it.
It results that in the case of the United States v. HcMahon the judgment of the Court of Appeals must be reversed, and the case remanded for a new judgment in conformity with this opinion.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access