United States v. Rodgers, 150 U.S. 249 (1893)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
United States v. Rodgers, 150 U.S. 249 (1893)
Full caption
UNITED STATES v. RODGERS.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Nov. 20, 1893
UNITED STATES v. RODGERS.
CERTIFICATE OF DIVISION IN OPINION FROM THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN.
No. 30. Submitted April 21,1893. —Decided November 20,1893.
The term “high seas,” as used in the provision in Rev. Stat., § 5346, that “every person who, upon the high seas, or in any arm of the sea, or in any river, haven, creek, basin, or bay, within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States, and out of the jurisdiction of any particular State, on board any vessel belonging in whole or part to the United States, or any citizen thereof, with a dangerous weapon, or with intent to perpetrate any felony, commits an assault upon another shall be punished,” etc., is applicable to the open, unenclosed waters of the Great Lakes, between which the Detroit River is a connecting stream.
The courts of the United States have jurisdiction, under that section of the Revised Statutes, to try a person for an assault with a dangerous weapon, committed on a vessel belonging to a citizen of the United States, when such vessel is in the Detroit River, out of the jurisdiction of any particular State, and within the territorial limits of the Dominion of Canada.
The limitation of jurisdiction by the qualification that the offences punishable are committed on vessels in any arm of the sea, or in any river, haven, creek, basin, or bay “without the jurisdiction of any particular State,” which means without the jurisdiction of any State of the Union, does not apply to vessels on the “high seas” of the lakes, but only to vessels on the waters designated as connecting with them ; and so far as vessels on those seas are concerned, there is no limitation named to the authority of the United States.
In February, 1888, the defendant, Robert S. Rodgers and others, were indicted in the District Court of the United States [p. 250] for the Eastern District of Michigan for assaulting, in August, 1887, with a dangerous weapon, one James Downs, on board of the steamer Alaska, a vessel belonging to citizens of the United States, and then being within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States, and not within the jurisdiction of any particular State of the United States, viz. within the territorial limits of the Dominion of Canada.
The indictment contained six counts, charging the offence to have been committed in different ways, or with different intent, and was remitted to the Circuit Court for the Sixth Circuit of the Eastern District of Michigan. There the defendant Rodgers .filed a plea to the jurisdiction of the court, alleging that it had no jurisdiction of the matters charged, as appeared on the face of the indictment, and to the plea a demurrer was filed. Upon this demurrer the judges of the Circuit Court were divided in opinion, and they transmitted to this court the following certificate of division:
“ Certificate of Division of Opinion.
“ United States of America. The Circuit Court of the United States for the Sixth Circuit and Eastern District of Michigan. “ The United Sates i
VS. > Robert S. Rodgers.)
“ The defendant in this cause was indicted on the twenty-fourth day of February, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and eighty-eight, in the District Court of the United States for the Eastern District of Michigan, together with John Gustave Beyers and others, charged, under section 5346 of the Revised Statutes of the United States, with having made an assault with dangerous weapons upon one James Downs, the assault having taken place on the steamer Alaska, a vessel owned by citizens of the United States, while such vessel was in the Detroit River, out of the jurisdiction of any particular State of the United States and within the territorial limits of the Dominion of Canada, and the said Robert S. Rodgers, and the others indicted with him, having first, after [p. 251] the assault, come into the United States in the Eastern District of Michigan.
“On the twentieth day of September, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and eighty-nine, the defendant Rodgers was arrested, and on the same day the indictment was, on motion of the United States attorney for the Eastern District of Michigan, and by order of the District Court for such district, remitted to the Circuit Court for such district, and, with all proceedings theretofore taken, certified to such Circuit Court.
“ On the twenty-third day of September, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and eighty-nine, the defendant, on being called upon to plead in the Circuit Court of the United States for the Eastern District of Michigan, by permission of the court pleaded in abatement to the jurisdiction of the court, claiming that under section 5346 of the Revised Statutes of the United States the courts of the United States have no jurisdiction of offences committed in the Detroit River on a vessel of the United States within the territorial limits of ■the Dominion of Canada.
“The United States, by C. P. Black, United States attorney, and Charles T. Wilkins, assistant United States attorney for the Eastern District of Michigan, demurred to such plea, and the defendant joined on demurrer.
“ The matter of the plea of the jurisdiction coming on to be heard in the Circuit Court of the United States for the Eastern District of Michigan, on the third day of October, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and eighty-nme, before the circuit and district judges, and the defendant being present in court, the said circuit and district judges were divided in opinion on the question: ‘ Whether the courts of the United States have jurisdiction, under section 53j6 of the Revised Statutes of the United States, to try a person for an assault, with a dangerous weapon, committed on a vessel helong%ng to a citizen of the United States, when such vessel is in the Detroit River, out of the jurisdiction of a/ny particular State and within the territorial limits of the Dominion of Canada?
i And so, at the request of the defendant and of the United [p. 252] States attorney for this district, the circuit and district judges do hereby at the same term state this point upon which they disagree, and hereby direct the same to be certified under the seal of the Circuit Court of the United States for the Eastern District of Michigan to the Supreme Court of the United States at its next session, for its opinion thereon.
“ Howell E. Jackson, Circuit Judge. “ Henry B. Brown, District Judge?
Section 5346 of the Revised Statutes, upon which the indictment was found, is as follows:
u Sec. 5346. Every person who, upon the high seas, or in any arm of the sea, or in any river, haven, creek, basin, or bay, within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States, and out of the jurisdiction of any particular State, on board any vessel belonging in whole or part to the United States, or any citizen thereof, with a dangerous weapon, or with intent to perpetrate any felony, commits an assault on another shall be punished by a fine of not more than three thousand dollars and by imprisonment at hard labor not more than three years.”
The statute relating to the place of trial in this case is contained in section 730 of the Revised Statutes, which is as follows:
“ Sec. 730. The trial of all offences committed upon the high seas or elsewhere, out of the jurisdiction of any particular State or district, shall be in the district, where the offender is found or into which he is first brought.”
jlfr. Assistant Attorney General Parker for the United States.
No appearance for Rodgers.
Mr. Justice Field delivered the opinion of the court.
Several questions of interest arise upon the construction of section 5346 of the Revised Statutes, upon which the [p. 253] indictment in this case was found. The principal one is whether the term “ high seas,” as there used, is applicable to the open, unenclosed waters of the Great Lakes, between which the Detroit River is a connecting stream. The term was formerly used, particularly by writers on public law, and generally in official communications between different governments, to designate the open, unenclosed waters of the ocean, or of the British seas, outside of their ports and havens. At one time it was claimed that the ocean, or portions of it, were subject to the exclusive use of particular nations. The Spaniards, in the 16th century, asserted the right to exclude all others from the Pacific Ocean. The Portuguese claimed, with the Spaniards, under the grant of Pope Alexander VI., the exclusive use of the Atlantic Ocean west and south of a designated line. And the English, in the 17th century, claimed the exclusive right to navigate the seas surrounding Great Britain. Woolsey on International Law, § 55.
In the discussions which took place in support of and against these extravagant pretensions the term “high seas” was applied, in the sense stated. It was also used in that sense by English courts and law writers. There was no discussion with them as to the waters of other seas. The public discussions were generally limited to the consideration of the question whether the high seas, that is, the open, unenclosed seas, as above defined, or any portion thereof, could be the property or under the exclusive jurisdiction of any nation, or whether they were open and free to the navigation of all nations. The inquiry in the English courts was generally limited to the question whether the jurisdiction of the admiralty extended to the waters of bays and harbors, such extension depending upon the fact whether they constituted a part of the high seas.
In his treatise on the rights of the sea, Sir Matthew Hale says: “ The sea is either that which lies within the body of a county, or without. That arm or branch of the sea which lies within the/awces terræ, where a man may reasonably discern between shore and shore, is, or at least may be, within the body of a county, and, therefore, within the jurisdiction of the [p. 254] sheriff or coroner. That part of the sea which lies not within the body of a county is called the main sea or ocean.” De Jure Maris, c. iv. By the “main sea” Hale here means the same thing expressed by the term “ high sea ” — “ mare altumf or “ le haul meer”
In Waring v. Clarke, 5 How. 440, 453, this court said that it had been frequently adjudicated in the English common law courts since the restraining statutes of Richard II. and Henry IV., “that high seas mean that portion of the sea which washes the open coast.” In UnitedStates v. Crush, 5 Mason, 290, it was held by Mr. Justice Story, in the United States Circuit Court, that the term “ high seas,” in its usual sense, expresses the unenclosed ocean or that portion of the sea which is without the fauces terras on the sea coast, in contradistinction to that which is surrounded or enclosed between narrow headlands or promontories. It was the open, unenclosed waters of the ocean, or the open, unenclosed waters of the sea, which constituted the “ high seas ” in his judgment. There was no distinction made by him between the ocean and the sea, and there was no occasion for any such distinction. The question in issue was whether the alleged offences were committed within a county of Massachusetts on the sea coast, or without it, for in the latter case they were committed upon the high seas and within the statute. It was held that they were committed in the county of Suffolk, and thus were not covered by the statute.
If there were no seas other than the ocean, the term “ high seas ” would be limited to the open, unenclosed waters of the ocean. But as there are other seas besides the ocean, there must be high seas other than those of the ocean. A large commerce is conducted on seas other than the ocean and the English seas, and it is equally necessary to distinguish between their open waters and their ports and havens, and to provide for offences on vessels navigating those waters and for collisions between them. The term “ high seas ” does not, in either case, indicate any separate and distinct body of water; but only the open waters of the sea or ocean, as distinguished from ports and havens and waters within narrow headlands [p. 255] on the coast. This distinction was observed by Latin writers between the ports and havens of the Mediterranean and its open waters — the latter being termed the high seas.1 In that sense the term may also be properly used in reference to the open waters of the Baltic and the Black Sea, both of which are inland seas, finding their way to the ocean by a narrow and distant channel. Indeed, wherever there are seas in fact, free to the navigation of all nations and people on their borders, their open waters outside of the portion “ surrounded or enclosed between narrow headlands or promontories,” on the coast, as stated by Mr. Justice Story, or “without the body of a county,” as declared by Sir Matthew Hale, are properly characterized as high seas, by whatever name the bodies of water of which they are a part may be designated. Their names do not determine their character. There are, as said above, high seas on the Mediterranean, (meaning outside of the enclosed waters along its coast,) upon which the principal commerce of the ancient world was conducted and its great naval battles fought. To hold that on such seas there are no high seas, within the true meaning of that term, that is, no open, unenclosed waters, free to the navigation of all nations and people on their borders, would be to place upon that term a narrow and contracted meaning. We prefer to use it in its true sense, as applicable to the open, unenclosed waters of all seas, than to adhere to the common meaning of the term two centuries ago, when it was generally limited to the open waters of the ocean and of seas surrounding Great Britain, the freedom of which was then the principal subject of discussion. If it be conceded, as we think it must be, that the open, unenclosed waters of the Mediterranean are high seas, that concession is a sufficient answer to the claim that the high seas always denote the open waters of the ocean.
Whether the term is applied to the open waters of the [p. 256] ocean or of a particular sea, in any case, will depend upon the context or circumstances attending its use, which in all cases affect, more or less, the meaning of language. It may be conceded that if a statement is made that a vessel is on the high seas, without any qualification by language or circumstance, ? will be generally understood as meaning that the vessel is upon the open waters of one of the oceans of the world. It is true, also, that the ocean is often spoken of by writers on public law as the sea, and characteristics are then ascribed to the sea generally which are properly applicable to the ocean alone; as, for instance, that its open waters are the highway of all nations. Still the fact remains that there are other seas than the ocean whose open waters constitute a free highway for navigation to the nations and people residing on their borders, and are not a free highway to other nations and people, except there be free access to those seas by open waters or by conventional arrangements.
1
“ Insula portum Efficit objectu laterum, quibus omnis ab alto Frangitur, inque sinus scindit sese unda reductos.” — The ^Eneid, Lib. 1, v. 159-161.
As thus defined, the term would seem to be as applicable to the open waters of the great Northern lakes as it is to the open waters of those bodies usually designated as seas. The Great Lakes possess every essential characteristic of seas.- They are of large extent in length and breadth; they are navigable the whole distance in either direction by the largest vessels known to commerce; objects are not distinguishable from the opposite shores; they separate, in many instances, States, and in some instances constitute the boundary between independent nations; and their waters, after passing long distances, debouch into the ocean. The fact that their waters are fresh and not subject to the tides, does not affect their essential character as seas. Many seas are tideless, and the waters of some are saline only in a very slight degree.
The waters of Lake Superior, the most northern of these lakes, after traversing nearly 400 miles, with an average breadth of over 100 miles, and those of Lake Michigan, which extend over 350 miles, with an average breadth of 65 miles, join Lake Huron, and, after flowing about 250 miles, with an average breadth of 70 miles, pass into the river St. Clair, thence through the small lake of St. Clair into the Detroit
River; thence into Lake Erie and, by the Niagara River, into Lake Ontario; whence they pass, by the river St. Lawrence, to the ocean, making a total distance of over 2000 miles. Ency. Britannica, vol. 21, p. 178. The area of the Great Lakes, in round numbers, is 100,000 square miles. Ibid. vol. 14, p. 217. They are of larger dimensions than many inland seas which are at an equal or greater distance from the ocean. The waters of the Black Sea travel a like distance before thev come into contact with the ocean. Their first outlet is through the Bosphorus, which is about 20 miles long and for the greater part of its way less than a mile in width, into the sea of Marmora, and through that to the Dardanelles, which is about 40 miles in length and less than four miles in width, and then they find their way through the islands of the Greek Archipelago, up the Mediterranean Sea, past the Straits of Gibraltar to the ocean, a distance, also, of over 2000 miles.
In the Genesee Chief case, 12 How. 443, this court, in considering whether the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States extended to the Great Lakes, and speaking, through Chief Justice Taney, of the general character of those lakes, said: “ These lakes are, in truth, inland seas. Different States border on them on one side, and a foreign nation on the other. A great and growing commerce is carried on upon them between different States and a foreign nation, which is subject to all the incidents and hazards that attend commerce on the ocean. Hostile fleets have encountered on them, and prizes been made; and every reason which existed for the grant of admiralty jurisdiction to the general government on the Atlantic seas applies with equal force to the lakes. There is an equal necessity for the instance and for the prize power of the admiralty court to administer international law, and if the one cannot be established, neither can the other.” (p. 453.)
After using this language, the Chief Justice commented upon L.e inequality which would exist, in the administration of justice, between the citizens of the States on the lakes, if, on account of the absence of tide water in those lakes, they were not entitled to the remedies afforded by the grant of
VOL. CL—17
admiralty jurisdiction of the Constitution, and the citizens of the States bordering on the ocean or upon navigable waters affected by the tides. The court, perceiving that the reason for the exercise of the jurisdiction did not in fact depend upon the tidal character of the waters, but upon their practical navigability for the purposes of commerce, disregarded the test of tide water prevailing in England as inapplicable to our country with its vast extent of inland waters. Acting upon like considerations in the application of the term “ high seas” to the waters of the Great Lakes, which are equally navigable, for the purposes of commerce, in all respects, with the bodies of water usually designated as seas, and are in no respect affected by.the tidal or saline character of their waters, we disregard the distinctions made between salt and fresh water seas, which are not essential, and hold that the reason of the statute, in providing for protection against violent assaults on vessels in tidal waters, is no greater but identical with the reason for providing against similar assaults on vessels in navigable waters that are neither tidal nor saline. The statute was intended to extend protection to persons on vessels belonging to citizens of the United States, not only upon the high seas, but in all navigable waters of every kind out of the jurisdiction of any particular State, whether moved by the tides or free from their influence.
The character of these lakes as seas was recognized by this court in the recent Chicago Lake Front case, where we said: “These lakes possess all the general characteristics of open seas, except in the freshness of their waters, and in the absence of the ebb and flow of the tide.” “ In other respects,” we added, “ they are inland seas, and there is no reason or principle for the assertion of dominion and sovereignty over and ownership by the State of lands covered by tide waters that is not equally applicable to its ownership of and dominion and sovereignty over lands covered by the fresh waters of these lakes.” llU/nois Central Railroad v. LlU/nois, 146 U. S. 387, 435.
It is to be observed also that the term “ high ” in one of its significations is used to denote that which is common, open, [p. 259] and public. Thus every road or way or navigable river which is used freely by the public is a “ high ” way. So a large body of navigable water other than a river, which is of an extent beyond the measurement of one’s unaided vision, and is open and unconfined, and not under the exclusive control of any one nation or people, but is the free highway of adjdining nations or people, must fall under the definition of “ high seas” within the meaning of the statute. We may as appropriately designate the open, unenclosed waters of the lakes as the high seas of the lakes, as to designate similar waters of the ocean as the high seas of the ocean, or similar waters of the Mediterranean as the high seas of the Mediterranean.
The language of section 5346, immediately following the term “ high seas,” declaring the penalty for violent assaults when committed on board of a vessel in any arm of the sea or in any river, haven, creek, basin, or bay, within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States, and out of the jurisdiction of any particular State, equally as when committed on board of a vessel on the high seas, lends force to the construction given to that term. The language used must be read in conjunction with that term, and as referring to navigable waters out of the jurisdiction of any particular State, but connecting with the high seas mentioned. The Detroit River, upon which was the steamer Alaska at the time the assault was committed, connects the waters of Lake Huron (with which, as stated above, the waters of Lake Superior and Lake Michigan join) with the waters of Lake Erie, and separates the Dominion of Canada from the United States, constituting the boundary between them, the dividing line running nearly midway between its banks, as established by commissioners, pursuant to the treaty between the two countries. 8 Stat. 274, 276. The river is about 22 miles in length and from one to three miles m width, and is navigable at all seasons of the year by vessels 0 the largest size. The number of vessels passing through it each year is immense. Between the years 1880 and 1892, ^elusive, they averaged from thirty-one to forty thousand a year, having a tonnage varying from sixteen to twenty-four [p. 260] millions.1 In traversing the river they are constantly passing from the territorial jurisdiction of the one nation to that of the other. All of them, however, so far as transactions had on board are concerned, are deemed to be within the country of their owners. Constructively they constitute a part of the territory of the nation to which the owners belong. Whilst they are on the navigable waters of the river they are within the admiralty jurisdiction of that country. This jurisdiction is not changed by the fact that each of the neighboring nations may in some cases assert its own authority over persons on such vessels in relation to acts committed by them within its territorial limits. In what cases jurisdiction by each country will be thus asserted and to what extent, it is not necessary to inquire, for no question on that point is presented for our consideration. The general rule is that the country to which the vessel belongs will exercise jurisdiction over all matters affecting the vessel or those belonging to her, without interference of the local government, unless they involve its peace, dignity, or tranquillity, in which case it may assert its authority. Wildenhus’s case, 120 U. S. 1, 12; Halleck on International Law, c. vii, § 26, p. 172. The admiralty jurisdiction of the country of the owners of the steamer upon which the offence charged was committed is not denied. They being citizens of [p. 261] the United States, and the steamer being upon navigable waters, it is deemed to be within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States. It was, therefore, perfectly competent for Congress to enact that parties on board committing an assault with a dangerous weapon should be punished when brought within the jurisdiction of the District Court of the United States. But it will hardly be claimed that Congress by the legislation in question intended that violent assaults committed upon persons on vessels owned by citizens of the United States in the Detroit River, without the jurisdiction of any particular State, should be punished, and that similar offences upon persons on vessels of like owners upon the adjoining lakes should be unprovided for. If the law can be deemed applicable to offences committed on vessels in any navigable river, haven, creek, basin, or bay, connecting with the lakes, out of the jurisdiction of any particular State, it would not be reasonable to suppose that Congress intended that no remedy should be afforded for similar offences committed on vessels upon the lakes, to which the vessels on the river, in almost all instances, are directed, and upon whose waters they are to be chiefly engaged. The more reasonable inference is that Congress intended to include the open, unenclosed waters of the lakes under the designation of high seas. The term, in the eye of reason, is applicable to the open, unenclosed portion of all large bodies of navigable waters, whose extent cannot be measured by one’s vision, and the navigation of which is free to all nations and people on their borders, by whatever names those bodies may be locally designated. In some countries small lakes are called seas, as in the case of the Sea of Galilee, in Palestine. In other countries large bodies of water, greater than many bodies denominated seas, are called lakes, gulfs, or basins. The nomenclature, however, does not change the real character of either, nor should it affect our construction of terms properly applicable to the waters of either. By giving to the term “ high seas ” the construction indicated, there is consistency and sense in the whole statute, but there is neither if it be disregarded. If the term applies to the open, unenclosed waters of the lakes, the [p. 262] application of the legislation to the case under indictment cannot be questioned, for the Detroit River is a water connecting such high seas, and all that portion which is north of the boundary line between the United States and Canada is without the jurisdiction of any State of the Union. But if they be considered as not thus applying, it is difficult to give any force to the rest of the statute without supposing that Congress intended to provide against violence on board of vessels in navigable rivers, havens, creeks, basins, and bays, without the jurisdiction of any particular State, and intentionally omitted the much more important provision for like violence and disturbances on vessels upon the Great Lakes. All vessels in any navigable river, haven, creek, basin, or bay of the lakes, whether within or without the jurisdiction of any particular State, would some time find their way upon the waters of the lakes; and it is not a reasonable inference that Congress intended that the law should apply to offences only on a limited portion of the route over which the vessels were expected to pass, and that no provision should be made for such offences over a much greater distance on the lakes.
1
The following statement, furnished by Colonel O. M. Poe, of the Engineer Corps, shows the traffic through Detroit River for the years indicated: Year. Number of Registered Year. Number of RegisteredTonnage. Vessels. Tonnage. Vessels. 1880............ 40,’521 20,235,249 1886............38,261 18,968,065 1881............ 35,888 17^572^240 1887............38,125 18,864,250 1882............ 35,199 17,872,182 1888............31,404 19,099,060 1883............ 40,385 17,695,174 1889............32,415 19,646,000 1884............ 38,742 18^045^949 1890............ 35'640 21,684,000 1885 ..... 34,921 16^777,828 1891............ 34,251 22,160,000 1892............ 33'860 24,785,000 Colonel Poe adds: “ This statement does not include Canadian vessels, a large number of which use this channel, nor does it include any vessels not clearing from the various custom houses. Were these included, a consider ably greater showing could be made. They are not included because t e statistics cannot be obtained.”
Congress in thus designating the open, unenclosed portion of large bodies of water, extending beyond one’s vision, naturally used the same term to indicate it as was used with reference to similar portions of the ocean or of bodies which had been designated as seas. When Congress, in 1790, first used that term the existence of the Great Lakes was known; they had been visited by great numbers of persons in trading with the neighboring Indians, and their immense extent and character were generally understood. Much more accurate was this knowledge when the act of March 3, 1825, was passed, 4 Stat. 115, c. 65, and when the provisions of section 5346 were reenacted in the Revised Statutes in 1874. In all these cases, when Congress provided for the punishment of violence on board of vessels, it must have intended that the provision should extend to vessels on those waters the same as to vessels on seas, technically so called. There were no bodies of water in the United States to any portion of which the term “high seas” was applicable if not to the open, [p. 263] unenclosed waters of the Great Lakes. It does not seem reasonable to suppose that Congress intended to confine its legislation to the high seas of the ocean, and to its navigable rivers, havens, creeks, basins, and bays, without the jurisdiction of any State, and to make no provision for offences on those vast bodies of inland waters of the United States. There are vessels of every description on those inland seas now carrying on a commerce greater than the commerce on any other inland seas of the world. And we cannot believe that the Congress of the United States purposely left for a century those who navigated and those who were conveyed in vessels upon those seas without any protection.
The statute under consideration provides that every person who, upon the high seas or in any river connecting with them, as we construe its language, within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States, and out of the jurisdiction of any particular State, commits, on board of any vessel belonging in whole or in part to the United States, or any citizen thereof, an assault on another with a dangerous weapon or with intent to perpetrate a felony, shall be punished, etc. The Detroit River, from shore to shore, is within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States, and connects with the open waters of the lakes — high seas, as we hold them to be, within the meaning of the statute. From the boundary line, near its centre, to the Canadian shore it is out of the jurisdiction of the State of Michigan. The case presented is therefore ■directly within its provisions. The act of Congress of September 4, 1890, 26 Stat. 424, c. 874, (1 Sup. to the Rev. Stat, chap. 874, p. 799,) providing for the punishment of crimes subsequently committed on the Great Lakes, does not, of course, affect the construction of the law previously existing.
We are not unmindful of the fact that it was held by the supreme Court of Michigan in People v. Tyler, 7 Michigan, 161, that the criminal jurisdiction of the Federal courts did n°t extend to offences committed upon vessels on the lakes. The judges who rendered that decision were able and distinguished; but that fact, whilst it justly calls for a careful consideration of their reasoning, does not render their [p. 264] conclusion binding or authoritative upon this court. Their opinions show that they did not accept the doctrine extending the admiralty jurisdiction to cases on the lakes and navigable rivers, which is now generally, we might say almost universally, received as sound by the judicial tribunals of the country. It is true, as there stated, that, as a general principle, the criminal laws of a nation do not operate beyond its territorial limits, and that to give any government, or its judicial tribunals, the right to punish any act or transaction as a crime, it must have occurred within those limits. We accept this doctrine as a general rule, but there are exceptions to it as fully recognized as the doctrine itself. One of those exceptions is that offences committed upon vessels belonging to citizens of the United States, within their admiralty jurisdiction, (that is, within navigable waters,) though out of the territorial limits of the United States, may be judicially considered when the vessel and parties are brought within their territorial jurisdiction. As we have before stated, a vessel is deemed part of the territory of the country to which she belongs. Upon that subject we quote the language of Mr. Webster, while Secretary of State, in his letter to Lord Ashburton of August, 1842. Speaking for the government of the United States, he stated with great clearness and force the doctrine which is now recognized by all countries. He said: “ It is natural to consider the vessels of a nation as parts of its territory, though at sea, as the State retains its jurisdiction over them; and, according to the commonly received custom, this-jurisdiction is preserved over the vessels even in parts of the sea subject to a foreign dominion. This is the doctrine of the law of nations, clearly laid down by writers of received authority, and entirely conformable, as it is supposed, with the practice of modern nations. If a murder be committed on board of an American vessel by one of the crew upon another or upon a passenger, or by a passenger on one of the crew or another passenger, while such vessel is lying in a port within the jurisdiction of a foreign State or sovereignty, the offence is cognizable and punishable by the proper court of the United States in the same manner as if such offence had [p. 265] been committed on board the vessel on the high seas. The law of England is supposed to be the same. It is true that the jurisdiction of a nation over a vessel belonging to it, while lying in the port of another, is not necessarily wholly exclusive. We do not so consider or so assert it. For any unlawful acts done by her while thus lying in port, and for all contracts entered into while there, by her master or owners, she and they must, doubtless, be answerable to the laws of the place. Nor, if her master or crew, while on board in such port, break the peace of the community by the commission of crimes, can exemption be claimed for them. But, nevertheless, the law of nations, as I have stated it, and the statutes of governments founded on that law, as I have referred to them, show that enlightened nations, in modern times, do clearly hold that the jurisdiction and laws of a nation accompany her ships not only over the high seas, but into ports and harbors, or wheresoever else they may be water-borne, for the general purpose of governing and regulating the rights, duties, and obligations of those on board thereof, and that, to the extent of the exercise of this jurisdiction, they are considered as parts of the territory of the nation herself.” 6 Webster’s Works, 306, 307.
We do not accept the doctrine that, because by the treaty between the United States and Great Britain the boundary line between the two countries is run through the centre of the lakes, their character as seas is changed, or that the jurisdiction of the United States to regulate vessels belonging to their citizens navigating those waters and to punish offences committed upon such vessels, is in any respect impaired. Whatever effect may be given to the boundary line between the two countries, the jurisdiction of the United States over the vessels of their citizens navigating those waters and the persons on board remains unaffected. The limitation to the jurisdiction by the qualification that the offences punishable are committed on vessels in any arm of the sea, or in any nver, haven, creek, basin, or bay “ without the jurisdiction of any particular State,” which means without the jurisdiction of any State of the Union, does not apply to vessels on the “ high
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
seas ” of the lakes, but only to vessels on the waters designated as connecting with them. So far as vessels on those seas are concerned, there is no limitation named to the authority of the United States. It is true that lakes, properly so called, that is, bodies of water whose dimensions are capable of measurement by the unaided vision, within the limits of a State, are part of its territory and subject to its jurisdiction, but bodies of water of an extent which cannot be measured by the unaided vision, and which are navigable at all times in all directions, and border on different nations or States or people, and find their outlet in the ocean as in the present case, are seas in fact, however they may be designated. And seas in fact do not cease to be such, and become lakes, because by local custom they may be so called.
In our judgment the District Court of the Eastern District of Michigan had jurisdiction to try the defendant upon the indictment found, and it having been transferred to the Circuit Court, that court had jurisdiction to proceed with the trial, and the demurrer to its jurisdiction should have been overruled. Our opinion, in answer to the certificate, is that
The courts of the United States have jurisdiction, under section 53J/J6 of the Revised Statutes, to try a person for an assault, with a da/ngerous weapon, committed on a vessel belonging to a citizen of the United States, when such vessel is in the Detroit River, out of the jurisdiction of any particular State, and withi/n the territorial lirMts of the Dominion of Canada; and it will he returned to the Circuit Court of the United States for the Sixth Circuit a/nd Eastern Dist/rict of Michigan, and it is so ordered.
Mb. Justice Geay dissenting.
The opinion of the majority of the court is avowedly based upon the hypothesis that the open waters of the Great Lakes are “ high seas,” within the meaning of section 5346 of the Revised Statutes, on which the indictment in this case is founded.
That hypothesis I am unable to accept. It appears to me
Dissenting Opinion: Gray*, J.
to be inconsistent with the settled meaning of the term “ high seas,” in our law, and in common speech, and especially as used in the Crimes Acts of the United States, as" heretofore uniformly expounded by this court, and by the justices thereof.
According to all the authorities, without exception, “the high seas” denote the ocean, the common highway of all nations—sometimes as including, sometimes as excluding, bays and arms of the sea, or waters next the coast, which are within the dominion and jurisdiction of particular States — but never as extending to any waters not immediately connecting with the sea.
The first Crimes Act of the United States provided, in section 8, for the punishment of murder or other capital offence committed “ upon the high seas, or in any river, haven, basin ?r bay, out of the jurisdiction of any particular State; ” and, in section 12, for the punishment of any person who should “ commit manslaughter upon the high seas,” but not mentioning in that section any other waters. Act of April 30, 1790, c. 9; 1 Stat. 113, 115. In United States v. Wiltberger, decided by this court in 1820, it was adjudged that manslaughter committed by the master upon one of the seamen, on board a mer- • chant vessel of the United States, below low water mark of a river flowing into the sea in China, was not “ manslaughter upon the high seas,” nor within the act of 1790; and Chief Justice Marshall, in delivering judgment, said : “ If the words be taken according to the common understanding of mankind, if they be taken in their popular and received sense, the ‘ high seas,’ if not in all instances confined to the ocean which washes a coast, can never extend to a river about half a mile, wide, and in the interior of a country.” 5 Wheat. 76, 94.
In United States v. Brailsford, this court held that the words “ out of the jurisdiction of any particular State,” in section 8 of the act of 1790, meant a State of the Union, and not a foreign State; and that a ship lying at anchor in an open roadstead, within a marine league of a foreign shore, and not ui a river, haven, basin or bay, might be found by a jury to ue on the high seas. 5 Wheat. 184, 189, 200. A similar
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
decision had been previously made by Mr. Justice Story. United States v. Ross, 1 Gallison, 624.
In United States v. Hamilton, Mr. Justice Story held that larceny in an enclosed dock, within the ebb and flow of the tide, in a foreign port, was not larceny “ upon the high seas,” under section 16 of the act of 1790. 1 Mason, 152. In United States v. Morel, it was held by Mr. Justice Baldwin and Judge Hopkinson, that an indictment on the same section was not sustained by proof of stealing in a land-locked harbor of one of the Bahama Islands; the court saying: “ The open sea, the high sea, the ocean, is that which is the common highway of nations, the common domain within the body of no country, and under the particular right or jurisdiction of no sovereign, but open, free and common to all alike, as a common and equal right.” 13 American Jurist, 279, 282. And in United States v. Jackson, a like decision was made by Mr. Justice Thompson and Judge Betts as to larceny in the harbor of Vera Cruz, because “ the high seas were, properly speaking, within the territory of no State or country.” 2 N. Y. Leg. Obs. 3, 4.
In United States v. Robinson, 4 Mason, 307, which was an indictment on the act of March 26,1804, c. 40, (2 Stat'. 290,) for destroying a vessel “ on the high seas” with intent to defraud the underwriters, Mr. Justice Story held that a land-locked bay in Bermuda could not be considered as the high seas. And, under the same statute, Mr. Justice Nelson and Judge Betts held that a vessel in the East Biver, or western extremity of Long Island Sound, was not upon the high seas. United States v. Wilson, 3 Blatchford, 435.
The Crimes Act of March 3, 1825, c. 65, was drafted by Mr. Justice Story, to supply the defects of former acts, x Story’s Life of Story, 297, 437, 439, 440; 2 ib. 402. That act, in sections 4, 6-8, 11 and 22, provided for the punishment of murder, of assaults with a dangerous weapon or with intent to kill, and of various other crimes, “ upon the high seas, or in any arm of the sea, or in any river, haven, creek, basin or bay,” thus covering all tide waters, including a dock or basin, or a land-locked bay, in which the tide ebbs and flows from
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
the sea, though in a foreign State, if “ within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States, and out of the jurisdiction of any particular State ” of the Union. 4 Stat. 115-118,122.
In United States v. Grush, 5 Mason, 290, which was an indictment on the provision of section 22 of the act of 1825, (reenacted in the very section of the Revised Statutes now in question,) for an assault with a dangerous weapon and with intent to kill, Mr. Justice Story, in deciding that a place in Boston Harbor within the body of a county was a bay or haven or arm of the sea, but was not the high seas, said: “There cannot, I think, be any doubt as to what is the true meaning of the words ‘ high seas ’ in this statute. Mr. Justice Blackstone, in his Commentaries, (1 Com. 110,) uses the words 1 high sea ’ and ‘ main sea ’ (altum mare, or le haut meer) as synonymous; and he adds, ‘ that the main sea begins at the low water mark.’ But though this may be one sense of the terms, to distinguish the divided empire, which the admiralty possesses between high water and low water mark, when it is full sea, from that which the common law possesses, when it is ebb sea; yet the more common sense is, to express the open, unenclosed ocean, or that portion of the sea, which is without the fauces terras on the sea-coast, in contradistinction to that, which is surrounded, or enclosed between narrow headlands or promontories.” And, after referring to United States v. Wilt-Merger, above cited, and other authorities, he concluded: “ From this view of the subject, I am entirely satisfied, as well upon the language of the authorities, as the descriptive words in the context, that the words ‘ high seas ’ in this statute are used in contradistinction to arms of the sea, and bays, creeks, &c., within the narrow headlands of the coast; and comprehend only the open ocean, which washes the sea-coast, or is not included within the body of any county in any particular State.” 5 Mason, 297-299.
Here we have the deliberate opinion of Mr. Justice Story, who had drafted the act, who had taken part in all the previous decisions of this court upon the subject, and who had often considered it at the circuit, that the words “ high seas ” in the very enactment now before us “ comprehend only the
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
open ocean, which washes the sea-coast, or is not included within the body of any county in any particular State.”
So Chancellor Kent says: “ The high seas mean the waters of the ocean without the boundary of any county, and they are within the exclusive jurisdiction of the admiralty up to high water mark when the tide is full. The open ocean which washes the sea-coast is used in contradistinction to arms of the the sea enclosed within the fauces terras, or narrow headlands and promontories: and under this head are included rivers, harbors, creeks, basins, bays, &c., where the tide ebbs and flows.” 1 Kent Com. 367.
If we turn to the principal American dictionaries, we find the following definitions of “ high seas ” : In Worcester, “ A^A seas, the open ocean.” In Webster, “high seas, (law) the open sea; the part of the ocean not in the territorial waters of any particular sovereignty, usually distant three miles or more flom the coast line.” In the Century Dictionary, “ high seas” are defined as “ the open sea or ocean; the highway of waters; ” and, in law, either (1) the waters of the ocean to high water mark, or (2) those “ not within the territorial jurisdiction of any nation, but the free highway of all nations, the waters of the ocean exterior to a line parallel to the general direction of the shore and distant a marine league therefrom; ” and it is added : “ The Great Lakes are not deemed high seas.”
A fortnight after the passage of the act of 1825, this court, speaking by Mr. Justice Story, decided that the general admiralty jurisdiction of the courts of the United States was limited to tide waters. The Thomas Jefferson, 10 Wheat. 428. That decision was followed in-1833 in Peyroux v. Howard, 7 Pet. 324, in 1837 in The Orleans, 11 Pet. 175, and in 1847 in Waring v. Clarke, 5 How. 441. For more than half a century after the adoption of the Constitution, Congress took no step towards extending the admiralty jurisdiction beyond such waters. In the act of February 26, 1845, c. 20, extending that jurisdiction, in matters of contract and tort, “upon the lakes and the navigable waters connecting the same,” Congress clearly treated those lakes and waters as distinct from, and not included within, “ the high seas or tide waters.” 5 Stat. 726.
UNITED STATES v. RODGERS. 27t
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
And Congress never indicated any intention to extend the criminal jurisdiction of the courts of the United States “to the Great Lakes and the connecting waters ” until three years after the assault alleged in the indictment in this case. Act of September 4, 1890, c. 874; 26 Stat. 424.
The judgment of this court in 1851, in The Genesee Chief, 12 How. 443, overruling The Thomas Jefferson and the cases which followed it, and holding the act of 1845 to be constitutional, did not proceed upon any assumption that the Great Lakes were “ high seas; ” but upon the broad ground that “the lakes and the waters connecting them are undoubtedly public waters,” and therefore “ within the grant of admiralty jurisdiction in the Constitution of the United States.” 12 How. 457. Chief Justice Taney, in delivering that judgment, clearly distinguished the Great Lakes from the high seas. This appears in his statement of the question whether “ the admiralty jurisdiction, in matters of contract and tort, which the courts of the United States may lawfully exercise on the high seas, can be extended to the lakes, under the power to regulate commerce; ” as well as in his pregnant observations, “These lakes are, in truth, inland seas. Different States border on them on one side, and a foreign nation on the other.” 12 How. 452, 453.
So in The Eagle, 8 Wall. 15, in which it was decided that the admiralty jurisdiction over all navigable waters, having been declared in The Genesee Chief to depend upon the Constitution, and not upon any act of Congress, extended to the British side of the Detroit River, Mr. Justice Nelson, speaking for this court, observed the same distinction, saying that the District Courts could take cognizance of “ all civil causes of admiralty jurisdiction upon the lakes and waters connecting them, the same as upon the high seas, bays, and rivers navigable from the sea.” 8 Wall. 21.
The lakes are not high seas, for the very reason that they a^e inland seas, within the exclusive jurisdiction and control o those countries within whose territories they lie, or between ose territories they are the boundary; and therein essenially differ from “ the high seas, where the law of no particu-
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
lai State has exclusive force, but all are equal.” Bradley, J., in The Scotland, 105 U. S. 24, 29.
The distinction is familiar and well established in international law.
As was said by Sir William Scott: “ In the sea, out of the reach of cannon shot, universal use is presumed; in rivers flowing through conterminous States, a common use to the different States is presumed.” The Twee Gebroeders, 3 C. Rob. 336, 339.
In a case in which a municipal seizure under the Customs Act of March 2, 1799, c. 22, § 29, (1 Stat. 649,) in the St. Mary’s River, then forming the boundary between the United States and the Spanish territory, of a vessel bound up that river to the Spanish waters and Spanish possessions, was held unlawful, Mr. Justice Story, speaking for this court, said that, “ upon the general principles of the law of nations, the waters of the whole river must be considered as common to both nations, for all purposes of navigation, as a common highway, necessary for the advantageous use of its own territorial rights and possessions;” and he distinguished the waters of the river, common to the two nations between whose dominions it flowed, from “ the ocean, the common highway of all nations.” The Apollon, 9 Wheat. 362, 369, 371.
Vattel says: “The open sea is not of a nature to be possessed, no one being able to settle there so as to hinder others from passing over it.” Vattel, lib. 1, c. 23, § 280. “No nation, therefore, has the right to take possession of the open sea, or to claim the sole use of it, to the exclusion of other nations. § 281. “ Every lake, entirely included in a country, belongs to the nation owning the country, which in possessing itself of a territory is considered as having appropriated to itself everything included in it; and, as it seldom happens that the property of a lake of considerable size falls to individuals, it remains common to the nation. If this lake is situated between two States, it is presumed to be divided between them at the middle, so long as there is neither title, nor constant and manifest custom, to determine otherwise.” c. 22, § 274.
Wheaton says: “ The sea cannot become the exclusive prop*
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
erty of any nation. And consequently the use of the sea, for these purposes,” (navigation, commerce, and fisheries,) “ remains open and common to all mankind.” Wheaton’s International Law, (8th ed.,) § 187. “ The territory of the State includes the lakes, seas and rivers, entirely enclosed within its limits. The rivers which flow through the territory also form a part of the domain, from their sources to their mouths, or as far as they flow within the territory, including the bays or estuaries formed by their junction with the sea. Where a navigable river forms the boundary of conterminous States, the middle of the channel is generally taken as the line of separation between the two States, the presumption of law being that the right of navigation is common to both; but this presumption may be destroyed by actual proof of prior occupancy and long undisturbed possession, giving to one of the riparian proprietors the exclusive title to the entire river.” §192.
Phillimore, after observing that “ no difficulty can arise with respect to rivers and lakes entirely enclosed within the limits of a State,” and discussing the rights in rivers which flow through more than one State, and the rights in the open sea, in narrow seas or straits, and in portions of the sea next the coast or between headlands, says: “With respect to seas entirely enclosed by the land, so as to constitute a salt-water late, the general presumption of law is, that they belong to the surrounding territory or territories in as full and complete a manner as a fresh-water lake. The Caspian and the Black Sea naturally belong to this class.” And he proceeds to show that the rights of other nations than Turkey and Russia to navigate the Black Sea from the Mediterranean rest upon treaties only. 1 Phillimore’s International Law, (3d ed.) c. 5, §155; c. 8, 205, 205a. See also Wheaton, § 182 and note ;
reaty of 1862 of the United States with the Ottoman Empire, art- 11,12 Stat. 1216. The Mediterranean Sea, opening directly into the Atlantic
cean at the Straits of Gibraltar, and washing the shores of ®any countries of different sovereigns, has, excepting such portions thereof as the Gulf of Venice or the Straits of Mes-
VOL. CL—18
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
sina, been recognized and considered by all nations for centuries as part of the high seas, free to all mankind. Martens, Précis du Droit des Gens, § 42; Wheaton, § 190. And it was the one sea familiarly known to the ancients as altum mare, the deep sea or “ high sea,” or simply altum, the deep.
The freedom of the Baltic Sea, and of the Sound connecting it with the North Sea, long and earnestly controverted, was finally established in 1857 by a treaty of the five powers whose territories bordered thereon with other European nations, and by a separate treaty between the United States and Denmark. Wheaton, §§ 183-185, 187 note; 1 Phillimore, c. 5, § 179; c. 8, § 206; 11 Stat. 719.
As to the Great Lakes of North America, there has never been any doubt. They are in the heart of the continent, far above the flow of the tide from the sea. Lake Michigan is wholly within the limits and dominion of the United States, and of those States of the Union which surround it. Illinow Central Railroad v. Illinois, 146 U. S. 387 ; 6 Opinions of Attorneys General, 172. The middle line of Lakes Superior, Huron, Erie and Ontario, and of the waters connecting them, forms part of the boundary between the United States and the State of Michigan and other States of the Union, on the one hand, and the British possessions in Canada, on the other. Treaties of Paris in 1783, art. 2, and of Ghent in 1814, art. 6, and Decision of Commissioners under this article; 8 Stat. 81, 221, 274; Charters and Constitutions, 994, 1453, 2026. No other nation has the right to navigate them, except by the permission, and subject to the laws, of the United States and Great Britain, respectively. The controversy between the United States and Great Britain as to, the right of navigating the river St. Lawrence turned upon the effect to be given to the fact that one side of the Great Lakes and of the waters connecting them belonged to each country, as against the fact that both shores of the St. Lawrence below belonged to Great Britain; and it was never suggested that any third nation had a free and common right of navigation of the lakes and their connecting waters. On the contrary, the exclusive right o the United States and Great Britain to navigate the lakes was
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
made the basis of the American claim to the navigation of the river. On June 19, 1826, Mr. Clay, Secretary of State under President John Quincy Adams, in a letter to Mr. Gallatin; then Minister to England, said: “The United States and Great Britain have, between them, the exclusive right of navigating the lakes. The St. Lawrence connects them with the ocean. The right to navigate both (the lakes and the ocean) includes that of passing from the one to the other through the natural link.” Congressional Documents, 1827-28, No. 43, p. 19; Wheaton, § 205. The right of citizens of the United States to navigate the St. Lawrence, as well as a right to British subjects to navigate Lake Michigan, was secured by treaties between the two countries in 1854 and 1871. 10 Stat. 1091; 17 Stat. 872. See also Act of July 26, 1892, c. 248, 27 Stat. 267; 1 Wharton’s International Law Digest, §§ 30, 31.
No instance has been produced, in which the words “high seas” have been used to designate fresh inland waters, the entire jurisdiction and control of which belong to those nations within whose territories they lie, or between whose territories they form the boundary.
The conclusion seems to me inevitable that no part of the Great Lakes can be held to be “ high seas,” within the meaning of section 5346 of the Revised Statutes.
The language of this section, immediately following the term “ the high seas,” is “ or in any arm of the sea, or in any river, haven, creek, basin or bay.” It is quite clear that the Detroit River is not an “ arm of the sea,” or a “ haven, creek, basin or bay.” Is it a “ river,” within the meaning of this enactment ?
Upon this point I agree with the rest of the court that the language used must be read in conjunction with the term “ the high seas,” and as referring to waters connecting with the high seas mentioned; and that Congress cannot be supposed to have intended to include fresh-water rivers, and not to include the lakes from or into which they flow, and which, together with them, form a continuous passage for vessels. But if the lakes are not “ high seas,” nor included in the act, the consequence would seem to bethat the word “river” cannot be held to mclude a river connecting two of the lakes.
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
The question now before the court is not one, arising in a civil proceeding, of the extent of the general and comprehensive grant in the Constitution of “admiralty and maritime jurisdiction” to the courts of the United States. But it is a question, arising in a criminal prosecution, of the construction of particular words in a penal statute, which cannot be extended by the court to a similar or analogous case, not within their natural and obvious meaning.
The place in the Detroit River within the territorial limits of the Dominion of Canada, where this offence is alleged to have been committed, was doubtless “ within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States,” under the decision in The Genesee Chief; and was “ out of the jurisdiction of any particular State,” under the decision in United States v. Brailsford, 5 Wheat. 184, 189, 200, already cited. Nor is there any doubt of the power of Congress to punish crimes committed on American vessels, wherever they may be afloat. United States v. Furlong, 5 Wheat. 184, 194; Orapo v. Kelly, 16 Wall. 610, 624-626.
But, in order to come within the statute, it is not enough that the offence was committed “ within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States;” and “out of the jurisdiction of any particular State ” of the Union; and upon a vessel belonging in whole or in part to the United States, or to a citizen thereof. It must also be covered by the description, “ upon the high seas, or upon any arm of the sea, or in any river, haven, creek, basin or bay.”
The leading words of this description are applicable to nothing but the ocean and its adjacent waters within the ebb and flow of the tide; every word in the description aptly designates tide waters; all the words, taken together, point to tide waters; and no other waters come within their natural and obvious meaning, in the connection in which they are used. The evident intention of Congress, to be collected from the words it employed, was to punish offences upon the sea, and upon any waters forming part of the sea, or immediately connecting with it, as far as high water mark, and not within the jurisdiction of any State of the Union; and the whole object
Dissenting Opinion: Gray, J.
and effect of adding, after the “ high seas,” the words “ or in any arm of the sea, or in any river, haven, creek, basin or bay,” were to cure the defects of earlier statutes in this respect, and to include all waters within the ebb and flow of the tide, which are estuaries or approaches of the high seas or open ocean.
Upon this part of the case, the decision of this court in United States v. Bevans, 3 Wheat. 336, is much in point. That was an indictment for a murder committed by a marine upon another enlisted man on a ship of war of the United States lying in the harbor of Boston, and so within the territorial jurisdiction of the State of Massachusetts, and therefore, as the court held, not coming within the description in section 8 of the act of April 30, 1790, c. 9, “upon the high seas, or in any river, haven, basin or bay, out of the jurisdiction of any particular State.” But the jurisdiction of the Circuit Court of the United States was also sought to be maintained under the provision of section 7 of the same act, for the punishment of murder committed “ within any fort, arsenal, dockyard, magazine, or other place or district of country, under the sole and exclusive jurisdiction of the United States.” 1 Stat. 113. It was argued that a ship of war of the United States was “a place under the sole and exclusive jurisdiction of the United States,” and therefore within the act. But this court, speaking by Chief Justice Marshall, held otherwise; and, while waiving a decision of the question whether any court of Massachusetts would have jurisdiction of the offence; and recognizing as unquestionable the power of Congress to punish an offence committed by a marine on board a ship of war, wherever she may be ; nevertheless held that Congress had not exercised that power by the provision last quoted, because the objects with which the word “ place ” was associated — “ fort, arsenal, dockyard, magazine,” and “ district of country”—being all fixed and territorial in their character, “ the construction seems irresistible that, by the words other place ’ was intended another place of a similar character with those previously enumerated, and with that which follows,” and “ the context shows the mind of the legislature
Dissenting Opinion : Gray, J.
to have been fixed on territorial objects of a similar character.” 3 Wheat. 390, 391.
Applying the same rule of construction, noscitur a sociis, to the enactment now before the court, the conclusion seems irresistible that, as the preceding words, “ upon the high seas, or in any arm of the sea,” as well as the succeeding words, “ haven, creek, basin or bay,” designate tide waters of or adjoining the ocean, the words “ any river ” must be held to designate waters of a similar character, that is to say, those rivers only where the tide ebbs and flows, and which are immediately connected with the sea or with one of the other waters enumerated, and cannot be extended to a fresh-water river in the interior of the continent, because the context shows the mind of the legislature to have been fixed on tide waters.
Should there be any doubt of the soundness of this construction, that doubt, in interpreting a penal statute, should be solved in favor of the defendant.
In United States v. Wiltberger, cited at the beginning of this opinion, in which, as in United States v. Bevans, just cited, and in the case at bar, the question was of the meaning of words, not defining the elements of the crime itself, but only describing the place of its commission, Chief Justice Marshall expounded the rule of construction of penal statutes as follows: “ The rule, that penal laws are to be construed strictly, is perhaps not much less old than construction itself. It is founded on the tenderness of the law for the rights of individuals; and on the plain principle that the power of punishment is vested in the legislative, not in the judicial department. It is the legislature, not the court, which is to define a crime, and ordain its punishment.” “ Though penal laws are to be construed strictly, they are not to be construed so strictly as to defeat the obvious intention of the legislature. The maxim is not to be so applied as to narrow the words of the statute to the exclusion of cases which those words, in their ordinary acceptation, or in that sense in which the legislature has obviously used them, would comprehend. The intention of the legislature is to be collected from the words they employ. “ To determine that a case is within -the intention of a statute,
Dissenting Opinion: Brown, J.
its language must authorize us to say so. It would be dangerous, indeed, to carry the principle, that a case which is within the reason or mischief of a statute is within its provisions, so far as to punish a crime not enumerated in the statute, because it is of equal atrocity, or of kindred character, with those which are enumerated.” 5 Wheat. 95, 96. And in answer to the suggestion made in that case (which has been repeated in this) of “the extreme improbability that Congress could have intended to make those differences with respect to place, which their words import,” the Chief Justice said: “We admit that it is extremely improbable. But probability is not a guide which a court, in construing a penal statute, can safely take. We can conceive no reason why other crimes, which are not comprehended in this act, should not be punished. But Congress has not made them punishable, and this court cannot enlarge the statute.” 5 Wheat. 105.
For these reasons, with all deference to the opinion of my brethren, I am constrained to conclude that the question certified should be answered in the negative.
Mr. Justice Brown dissenting.
I am also constrained to dissent from the opinion of the court in this case, which appears to me to inaugurate a wholly new departure in the direction of extending the jurisdiction of the Federal courts. It is a matter of regret to me that this departure should be made in a case in which the defendant was represented neither by brief nor oral argument — a fact which suggests, at least, an unusual degree of caution in dealing with the question involved.
I had supposed that, in criminal cases, the accused was entitled to the benefit of any reasonable doubt, not only with regard to the evidence of guilt, but with regard to the jurisdiction of the court; in other words, that penal statutes should he construed strictly ; and that the facts that the Supreme bourt of Michigan, in a very carefully considered case some t irty years ago, People v. Tyler, 7 Michigan, 161, had decided t at the criminal jurisdiction of the Federal courts did not
Dissenting Opinion: Brown, J.
extend to the lakes; that the same question had been decided the same way by Judge Wilkins in Miller's case, Brown’s Adm. 156; that the Federal courts upon the lakes had uniform-ally acquiesced in these decisions; and that no case is reported to the contrary, would of itself make a case of reasonable doubt, to the benefit of which the prisoner would be entitled.
I fully concur in all that has been stated in the opinion of the court with regard to the magnitude of the commerce upon the lakes; and if that question were pertinent here, it would doubtless be controlling. Having lived for thirty years within sight of this commerce, it would ill become me to depreciate its importance; but it occurs to me that if this were a consideration at all it would be equally applicable to our jurisdiction over the Hudson, the Ohio, and the Mississippi, upon all of which the commerce is of great magnitude. I had assumed that the question at issue involved simply the construction of a statute, and not the magnitude of the commerce upon the lakes.
My own views on this question were so fully set forth in the case of Byers, 32 Fed. Rep. 404, that I can add but little to what was there said. Revised Statutes, § 5346, under which this indictment was framed, limits the jurisdiction of the District Court to “ cases arising upon the high seas, or in any arm of the sea, or in any river, haven, creek, basin or bay within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States, and out of the jurisdiction of any particular Stated
The first question which arises, then, is as to whether the lakes are “ high seas,” and as to that I had supposed, until reading the opinion of the court in this case, there could be but one answer.
The term “high seas” has never been regarded by any public writer or held by any court to be applicable to tentorial waters, and, like the word “ highways,” presupposes the right of the public to make free use of them, and excludes the idea of private ownership. Of the sea, Lord Hale says (De Jure Maris, chapter 4) : “ The sea is either that which lies within the body of the county or without. That arm or branch of the sea which lies within the fauces terra, where
Dissenting Opinion: Brown, J.
a man may reasonably discern between shore and shore, is, or at least may be, within the body of a county, and therefore within the jurisdiction of the sheriff or coroner. The part of the sea which lies not within the body of a county, is called the main sea or ocean.”
Azuni, an Italian publicist of the last century, in writing of the maritime law of Europe, says (Part 1, chapter 1, section 12): “The sea belongs to no one; it is the property of all men; all have the same equal right to its use as to the air they breathe, and to the sun that warms them. Seas are the great highways traced by nature between the different parts of the world, to facilitate and expedite communication between the various nations who inhabit it. If a nation seizes on these highways, if it arrogates to itself the exclusive privilege of traversing them without opposition, and repels, by the fear of being plundered, all those who wish to make the same use of them, it is no better than a nation of robbers.” Section 14: “The liberty of navigation and of fishing is derived from natural law, and the law of nations, as well as from the civil law. For these reasons, the high seas ought to remain as common to the human race as air and light. The use of those elements, unquestionably, can never belong to any one nation, to the exclusion of others.” Section 15 : “ From these principles, it follows, that the right of prior occupancy cannot give to a nation the absolute empire of the high sea, and for the reason already mentioned, that this element is not susceptible of individual appropriation.”
Valin, in his commentary on the Marine Ordinance, observes: “For in short the ocean belongs to no one, and the conclusion undoubtedly to be drawn from this is that all nations are permitted to navigate it.”
So Vattel, in speaking of the sea (Book 1, chapter 23, section 281): « But this,” speaking of private property, “ is not the case with the open sea, on which people may sail and fish without the least prejudice to any person whatsoever, and without putting any one in danger. No nation, therefore, has a right to take possession of the open sea, or claim the sole nse of it, to the exclusion of other nations. . . . Nay,
Dissenting Opinion: Brown, J.
more, a nation, which, without a legitimate claim, would arrogate to itself an exclusive right to the sea, and support its pretensions by force, does an injury to all nations; it infringes their common right; and they are justifiable in forming a general combination against it, in order to repress such an attempt.”
So Chancellor Kent, in speaking of jurisdiction over the seas, Part 1, Lecture 2, says: “ The open sea is not capable of being possessed as private property. The free use of the ocean for navigation and fishing is common to all mankind, and the public jurists generally and explicitly deny that the main ocean can ever be appropriated. The subjects of all nations meet there, in times of peace, on a footing of entire equality and independence. No nation has any right or jurisdiction at sea, except it be over the persons of its own subjects in its own public and private vessels.” 1 Kent Com. 26.
From time immemorial the term “ high seas ” has been used to import the unenclosed and open ocean without the fauces terroe. In United States v. Bevans, 3 Wheat. 336, a homicide had been committed upon an American man-of-war lying at anchor in the main channel of Boston harbor, to which there is at all times a free and unobstructed passage to the open ocean. The language of the statute was practically the same as in this case; but it was held by this court, speaking through Chief Justice Marshall, that to bring the defendants within the jurisdiction of the courts of the Union the murder must have been committed in a river, etc., out of the jurisdiction of any State, and that as the jurisdiction of a State was coextensive with its territory and with its legislative power, the courts of Massachusetts had exclusive jurisdiction of the crime. It was further held that whatever might be the constitutional power of Congress, it was clear that this power had not been exercised so as to confer upon its courts jurisdiction over any offences committed within the jurisdiction of any particular State. In United States v. Wiltberger, 5 Wheat. 76, it was held that the courts of the United States had no jurisdiction of a manslaughter committed on a merchant vessel of the United States lying in the river Tigris, in the Empire of China. It
Dissenting Opinion: Brown, J.
was held in this case that the homicide was not committed on the “ high seas.”
In United States v. Jackalow, 1 Black, 484, it was said by this court that to give a Circuit Court of the United States jurisdiction of an offence not committed within its district, it must appear that the offence was committed out of the jurisdiction of any State, and not within any other district of the United States. This was applied to an offence committed in Long Island Sound, one and a half miles from the Connecticut
shore at low water mark.
So in Miller’s case, 1 Brown’s Adm. 156, it was held by
Judge Wilkins of Michigan that while it was within the con-
stitutional competency of Congress to define and punish
offences when committed upon other waters than the high
seas, it had not done so, and that Lake Erie was not a part of
the high seas. This was applied, to a shocking case of an
attempt to burn a passenger steamer upon Lake Erie.
But it seems to me, without going further into the authori-
ties, that the term “ high seas ” is accurately defined by the
statute under which this indictment is framed as “ waters
within the admiralty and maritime jurisdiction of the United
States and out of the jurisdiction of any particular State’’
The underlying error of the opinion of the court in this case
appears to me to consist in a total ignoring of the last qualifi-
cation. That the term “ high seas ” extends to what are
known as the great oceans of the world there can be no doubt.
I presume it also extends to the Mediterranean Sea, for the
reason that, bordering so many nations as it does, a division of
the waters between these nations would be impracticable.
Whether, as stated in the opinion of the court, the term also
extends to the Black Sea, there seems to be grave doubt; but
n it does, it is because the waters of the Black Sea are not
proprietary waters, are not claimed by Russia or Turkey as
being a part of their territory. The very idea of giving to
tne courts of all nations jurisdiction over the high seas arises
primarily from the fact that they belong to no particular sover'^Qty. If it be true that the lakes are high seas, it logically °hows that any European power may punish a crime com-
Dissenting Opinion: Brown, J.
mitted upon the lakes in their own courts, whenever it is able to lay hands upon the offender. It would also follow that other nations than England and America would have the right to navigate these seas without any local restrictions, and even to send their fleets there and perhaps to engage in hostilities upon its waters. In the case of The Genessee Chief, 12 How. 443, this court did not hold that the lakes were high seas, but that the limitation of the admiralty jurisdiction in civil cases to tide waters did not apply to this country, or to the interior lakes, a doctrine in which I fully concur, and one that has met with the practically unanimous approval of the profession.
The difficulty of applying the term “ high seas ” to the lakes arises not from the fact that they are not large enough, that the commerce which vexes their waters is not of sufficient importance, but from the fact that they are within the local jurisdiction of the States bordering upon them. By the treaty of peace between this country and Great Britain, of 1783, the boundary line between the United States and Canada was fixed in the middle of Lake Ontario, Niagara River, Lake Erie, Detroit River, Lake Huron, St. Mary’s River, and Lake Superior, and by the treaty of 1814 this line was recognized and subsequently designated by commissioners appointed for that purpose. So in the acts admitting Illinois, Wisconsin, and Michigan into the Union the boundarv lines of these States were fixed at the middle of Lake Michigan, and as to the State of Michigan at the boundary line between the United States and Canada. Acting upon this theory, the State of Michigan has assumed jurisdiction of all crimes committed upon her side of the boundary line, and provided for their punishment in certain counties irrespective of the question whether the crimes were committed within the limits of a particular county.
But even if the lakes were to be considered as high seas, that term surely cannot be applied to a river twenty-two nue in length and less than a mile in width, connecting the w0 lakes.
The further question then arises whether the locality 1
Dissenting Opinion: Brown, J.
question is covered by the words u in any arm of the sea, or in any river, haven, creek, basin, or bay within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States and out of the jurisdiction of any particular State.” As the western half of the Detroit and St. Clair rivers is within the territorial jurisdiction of Michigan, it only remains to consider whether the fact that the eastern half of these rivers is within the territorial jurisdiction of Canada meets the requirements of the statute. I may say that this question was elaborately considered by the Supreme Court of Michigan in the case of People v. Tyler, 7 Michigan, 161, which was also the case of an assault committed on the Canadian side of the boundary line, in which the Federal court, without an investigation of the question, had convicted Tyler. The Supreme Court of Michigan were unanimous in the opinion that the jurisdiction did not exist. Separate opinions were delivered by three of the judges, in which every possible case bearing upon the question was cited and criticised. I have no doubt whatever of the power of Congress to extend its jurisdiction to crimes committed upon navigable waters. Indeed, since the decision in Byers' case, and on September 4, 1890, Congress did pass an act providing for the punishment of crimes committed anywhere upon the lakes. 26 Stat. 424, c. 874. 1 Supp. Rev. Stat. 799.
But, considering that, at the time the act of Congress in question was passed, viz., in 1790, the lakes were far beyond the bounds of civilization and possessed no commerce, except such as was carried on in canoes, it seems impossible to say that Congress intended that the words “ arm of the sea, or river, haven, creek, basin, or bay ” could have been intended to apply to the lakes when the word “ lakes ” might just as well have been used, had the interior waters of the country been included. It seems to me entirely clear that the words alluded to, following immediately the words “high seas,” aPply only to such waters as are connected immediately with the high seas, and have no application to the Great Lakes. his was evidently the view taken by Congress in the enactment of 1890.
I may add in this connection that the act of 1790, under
Dissenting Opinion: Brown, J.
which this indictment was framed, was before Congress at the time of the passage of the Crimes Act of 1825, and also at the time of the adoption of the Revised Statutes, and no effort was made to change the language of the act by inserting the word “ lakes,” and no such change was ever made until after the offence in this case had been committed.
The conclusion seems to me irresistible that, considering the words high seas are followed by the wTords “ in any arm of the sea, or in any river, haven, creek, basin, or bay within the admiralty jurisdiction of the United States and out of the jurisdiction of any particular State,” they should be limited to such waters as are directly connected with the high seas. It is incredible that if Congress had intended to include the lakes in either of these acts it would have drawn a line through the centre, and given to the Federal courts jurisdiction upon one side of that line, and not upon the other, when it was equally within its competency to confer full jurisdiction over all crimes committed upon American vessels upon the entire lakes. Especially is this true in view of the fact that it is often impossible to locate the ship at the time the crime is committed upon one side or the other of the boundary line.
It is beyond question in this case that the crime charged was committed within the waters of the Province of Ontario; that the courts of such Province had jurisdiction of the cause, and in my opinion such jurisdiction was exclusive.
Syllabus.
UNITED STATES TRUST COMPANY v. WABASH
WESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY.
WABASH WESTERN RAILWAY COMPANY v.
UNITED STATES TRUST COMPANY.
APPEALS FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI.
Nos. 81, 87. Argued October 23,24,1893. — Decided November 20, 1893.
On the 10th of February, 1879, the Council Bluffs and St. Louis Railway Company leased their projected railway from Council Bluffs to the state line to the St. Louis, Kansas City and Northern Railway Company for the term of 91 years. Together the lines formed the Omaha Division of the Wabash system. On the 15th of February, 1879, the lessee issued bonds to the amount of $2,350,000, secured by a mortgage to the United States Trust Company, to complete and equip the division. In November, 1879, the lessee was consolidated with the Wabash Railway Company, under the name of the Wabash, St. Louis and Pacific Railway Company. The new corporation assumed all the obligations of the old ones, entered into possession of all the property, issued bonds to the amount of $17,000,000, secured by a general mortgage to the Central Trust Company, and other bonds, and continued to operate the property down to May, 1884, when it filed a bill alleging its own insolvency, and asking the court to appoint receivers of all its property, which was done. A preferential indebtedness was recognized by the court to the extent of $4,378,233.49, which the receivers were directed to pay. The rentals and interest amounted to $2,175,062, of which $82,250 was for the rent of the Omaha Division. These also were ordered to be paid by the receivers. It turned out, practically, that so far from being able to make all these payments out of earnings, they were never enough to pay the preferential debts, and that the Omaha Division was operated at an actual loss, without taking the rental into account. These facts were made known to the court by the receivers in March, 1885, whereupon it ordered, in April, 1885, that the subdivisional accounts be kept separately, and that no rent or subdivisional interest be paid where a subdivision earned no surplus. It also ordered the preferential debts to be paid before rentals. The instalment of rent or interest on the Omaha Division due in April, 1885, not being paid, a bill was filed to foreclose the mortgage upon it, and when a default took place in the payments due in October, 1885, a receiver was asked for. In the following March a receiver was appointed
Syllabus.
as asked for, and the Omaha Division was surrendered to him by the general receivers of the Wabash system. He intervened in the Wabash suit, praying for payment by the general receivers of the overdue rent on the Omaha Division, amounting to $222,075.77. A decree of foreclosure and sale of the Wabash system, under the general mortgage, was entered, which reserved specially all rights under the Omaha Division, and under this decree a sale was made and the property was transferred to a new corporation called the Wabash Western Railway Company. The petition for the payment of rent of the Omaha Division, after reference to a master and report by him, resulted in a decree for the payment of one month’s rent with interest, instead of 16 months, as prayed for. Held, (1) That the court was bound to take into consideration the peculiar circumstances under which the receivers took possession of and operated the Wabash system;
(2) That, following Quincy, Missouri &c. Railroad v. Humphreys, 145
U. S. 82, the court did not bind itself or its receivers to pay the agreed rent eo instanti by the mere act of taking possession, but that reasonable time had to be taken to ascertain the situation of affairs;
(3) That the order made by the court below to pay the rents only after the discharge of the preferential debts was correct;
(4) That the owners of the Omaha branch, or the trustees of its mortgage, knowing that that branch was in the hands of the general receivers, might have intervened in that suit for the protection of their property, and were bound by the order for payment of the preferential debts; as it is settled that whenever, in the course of a receivership, the court makes an order which the parties to the suit consider injurious to their interests, it is their duty to file a motion at once asking the court to cancel or to modify it;
(5) That the petition of the receivers of March, 1885, and the order of the court thereupon touching subdivision earnings, was notice to the branch lines that they must not expect payment of their rent, when the subdivision earned nothing beyond operating expenses;
(6) That as the mortgage to the United States Trust Company did not convey the income or earnings of the road to it, but only authorized it to take possession in case of default, the trustee could only secure the earnings by taking possession in such case;
(7) That until the mortgagee asserted its rights under the mortgage to the possession of the road by filing a bill of foreclosure and by demanding possession, it had no right to receive the earnings and profits;
(8) That the judgment of the court below, awarding a recovery of only one month’s rent, was right.
The general rule applicable to this class of cases is, that an assignee or receiver is not bound to adopt the contracts, accept the leases, or [p. 289] otherwise step into the shoes of his assignor, if, in his opinion, it would be unprofitable or undesirable to do so.
In such case a receiver is entitled to a reasonable time in which to elect whether he will adopt or repudiate such contracts.
If a receiver in a suit for foreclosing a railway mortgage elects to adopt a lease, he becomes vested with the title to the leasehold interest, and a priority of estate is thereby created between the lessor and the receiver, by which the latter becomes liable upon the covenant to pay rent.
These were cross appeals from a final decree entered September 25, 1889, overruling the exceptions of the appellant, the United States Trust Company, to a master’s report, overruling in part the exceptions of the appellant, the Wabash Western Railway Company, to the same report, and adjudging that the Trust Company, as trustee under the mortgage of what is known as the Omaha Division of the Wabash, St. Louis and Pacific Railway, recover from the Wabash Western Railway Company the sum of $13,708.33, with interest thereon from January 6,1886, amounting in all to $16,765.51, as rental for that division during the period in which it was operated by the receivers of the Wabash Company.
At the time the petition in this case was filed, the Wabash, St. Louis and Pacific Railway Company, a corporation formed by the consolidation of a large number of railway companies, extending from Detroit and Toledo in the East to Omaha and Kansas City in the West, with a total mileage of 3600 mil as, of which railway the St. Louis, Kansas City and Northern Railway was a branch, was in process of winding up and reorganizing under two bills, namely: 1. A bill filed May 27, 1884, by the Wabash, St. Louis and Pacific Railway Company itself, wherein it set forth its own insolvency, its inability to meet various pressing debts, including interest due June 1,1884, on its general mortgage and certain other of its bonds; the consequent danger of a breaking up of its system of railroads, and the irreparable damage that might result from its disrupion, and praying for the appointment of receivers to take possession of, preserve, and operate its lines of railroad for the enefit of its creditors, according to their respective legal and equitable rights. To this bill the Central Trust Company of ew York and James Cheney, trustees under the Wabash
VOL. CL—19
general mortgage; the United States Trust Company of New York, trustee of the Omaha Division mortgage, as well as the trustees in all the underlying and divisional mortgages on the various lines of the Wabash system, were made defendants. 2. A cross-bill filed June 9, 1884, by the trustees of the Wabash Company, under its general mortgage, for the foreclosure of that mortgage and appointment of receivers of the mortgaged premises.
The petition in this case was filed April 23, 1886, and the case referred to a master upon a stipulation as to the facts, of which the following is a summary: On February 10,1879, the Council Bluffs and St. Louis Railway Company, an Iowa corporation, the owner of a projected railway sixty-five miles in length from Council Bluffs, Iowa, in a southeasterly direction to a point on the state line between Iowa and Missouri, leased its road to the St. Louis, Kansas City and Northern Railway Company, the owner of another railway extending from that point on the state line about seventy-eight miles to Pattonsburg, Missouri, for the term of ninety-one years. These roads formed a line from Pattonsburg, Missouri, to Council Bluffs, Iowa, and are known in this litigation as the Omaha Division of the Wabash system. On the 15th day of February, 1879, the said St. Louis, Kansas City and Northern Railway Company, for the purpose of raising funds necessary to complete and equip the Omaha Division, issued and sold $2,350,000 in bonds, or at the rate of $16,000 for each mile, and to secure the payment thereof mortgaged its interest and estate in the whole of such division, being an estate in fee in that portion of the line situated in Missouri and its leasehold estate in that part located in Iowa, to the United States Trust Company.
In November, 1879, the St. Louis, Kansas City and Northern Railway Company of Missouri was consolidated with the Wabash Railway Company, under the corporate name of the Wabash, St. Louis and Pacific Railway Company. By the terms of such consolidation the new corporation assumed all the obligations of both the constituent companies. Immediately upon such consolidation the Wabash, St. Louis and Pacific Railway Company entered upon the sole use of the [p. 291] UNITED STATES TRUST CO. v. WABASH RAILWAY. 201
premises demised by said lease, and on June 1, 1880, issued $17,000,000 of what were known as its general mortgage bonds, secured by a mortgage to the Central Trust Company of New York and James Cheney as trustees. This mortgage covered all its railway, leasehold, and other property. By a later mortgage, dated May 1, 1883, to the Mercantile Trust Company of New York, 11,089 shares of stock of the Council
Bluffs and St. Louis Railway Company were pledged with a
large amount of other property to secure $10,000,000 of what
were called the collateral trust bonds of the Wabash Company.
From 1879 to May 27, 1884, the Omaha Division was suc-
cessfully and profitably operated, and the terms of the lease
were complied with. Upon presentation to the court of the
first bill above stated, filed by the Wabash Company, alleging
its own insolvency, and on May 27,1884, an order was entered
appointing Solon Humphreys and Thomas E. Tutt receivers of
all the property of the said Wabash Company. This order
appointing the receivers directed them to take possession of,
operate, and preserve all of said lines of railroad, and from
their earnings pay their operating expenses; the balance due
to other railroad and transportation companies growing out
of the interchange of traffic during the preceding six months;
all rentals' accrued, or which should thereafter accrue, on all
leased lines for the use of terminals or track facilities; and
for all rentals due or to become due upon rolling stock
theretofore purchased by the company and partially paid for;
likewise, all just claims and accounts for labor, supplies,
professional services, salaries of officers, and employes that
had been earned or matured during the preceding six months.
The receivers were also directed by the order to keep such
accounts as might be necessary to show the sources from which
all such incomes and revenues were derived, with reference to
t e interest of all parties to the suit and the expenditures made
hy them.
On June 26, 1884, within one month after their appoint-
ment, the receivers made a report and petition to the court, in
'' ich they stated to the best of their information and belief
at each and all of certain lines of railroad constituting the [p. 292] consolidated Wabash, St. Louis and Pacific Railway Company had “ at all times during the five years last past, or ever since their construction, earned more than enough to pay their operating expenses, the cost of maintenance, and interest upon the several series of bonds ” that were secured upon them by their mortgages or deeds of trust, and prayed the court to instruct them as to what they should do with respect to the payment of interest, as the same from time to time matured, on the mortgage bonds on the several lines and divisions of the road as they existed at and before the date of the consolidation. On June 28, two days after the filing of this petition, the court ordered the receivers, from the incoming rents and profits of the property, after meeting such other obligations as they had been directed to discharge by former orders, to pay from whatever balance might remain in their hands the interest maturing upon the bonds or other mortgage obligations on the several lines or divisions of the Wabash Company before its consolidation. Under this order the rental for the use of the Omaha Division, falling due on October 1, 1884, and amounting to $82,250, was paid by the receivers. Rentals and interest on other lines accruing for the same and various subsequent periods, and aggregating $2,175,062, were paid under the same order.
The record shows that at the time the receivers were appointed the labor and supply claims and other preferential indebtedness of the Wabash Company, which the receivers were, by their order of appointment, directed to pay, amounted to $4,378,233.49. It also appeared that the net earnings of all the lines operated by the receivers were never sufficient to discharge the preferential debts.
On March 20, 1885, the receivers made another application to the court, in which they set forth in detail the earnings and expenses of the various lines of the system up to November 30, 1884, and prayed the court for instruction with respect to the future operation by them of the several branch lines that had failed to earn their operating expenses. Notice was given to the solicitor of the trustee of the Omaha Division that this petition would be called up on the 14th of April. In the [p. 293] application it was stated that the expenses of operating the Council Bluffs and St. Louis Railway, that is, the Omaha Division, had exceeded its earnings by $5288.64, not including any charge for rental, and, including such charge, there was a deficit of $87,538.64. On April 16 the court made an order upon this petition to the effect that subdivisional accounts should be kept separately; that “ where a subdivision earns no surplus, simply pays operating expenses, no rent or subdivisional interest will be paid. If the lessor or subdivisional mortgagee desires possession or foreclosure, he may proceed at once to assert his rights. While the court will continue to operate such subdivision until some application be made, yet the right of a lessor or mortgagee whose rent or interest is unpaid to insist upon possession or foreclosure will be promptly recognized.”
The semi-annual instalment of interest or rent of the Omaha Division falling due April 1, 1885, being unpaid, a bill for the foreclosure of the mortgage upon that division was filed by the intervenor in the Circuit Court of Pottawatomie County, Iowa. The Wabash receivers were made defendants to the bill. This suit was removed to the Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of Iowa. Another default occurring October 1, 1885, the intervenor filed a second petition, and requested the transfer of the division to a receiver.
On December 2, 1885, the United States Trust Company filed another petition, in which it recited the defaults which had occurred in the payment of interest on the bonds secured on the Omaha Division, and prayed that the receivers of the Wabash system, Humphreys and Tutt, be ordered to surrender to the receivers, appointed or to be appointed in the foreclosure suits of the Omaha Division, all its property.
On January 6, 1886, the matter was called to the attention of the court, and the court thereupon entered an order direct-lug the receivers, Humphreys and Tutt, to surrender within thirty days the Omaha Division to the United States Trust Company, or to any person or receiver appointed at their instance by the Circuit Court for the Southern District of [p. 294] Iowa, or by the state courts. There was a further clause in the order which authorized Humphreys and Tutt to retain possession of the Omaha Division for an additional thirty days, if the Wabash, St. Louis and Pacific Railway Company, or any one on its behalf, would pay to the United States Trust Company $13,708.33, which sum was equal to the interest for-one month on the Omaha bonds. That amount was paid by the receivers, and there is no controversy here concerning it.
On March 3, 1886, Thomas McKissick was appointed receiver of the Omaha Division, and on March 6 the division was surrendered to him by Humphreys and Tutt. On April 23 the petition in this case was filed by the intervenor for the rental which accrued from October 1, 1884, to February 6, 1886, amounting to $222,075.77.
On the same day the order of surrender was made, namely, January 6, 1886, a decree of foreclosure and sale under the Wabash general and collateral mortgages was entered. This sale specially reserved all rights under the Omaha Division and other leases and mortgages, and adjudged that the receivers’ surrender of any leased branch terminated the lease as of the date of the surrender. The sale of the road having been made and confirmed, the receivers were directed to transfer all the property to the Wabash Western Railway Company, a new corporation organized to take the property, the latter company agreeing to pay all claims and demands “ growing out of the operation by said receivers of the railway property lately in their charge, which have been or may be adjudged to be superior in equity to the mortgages foreclosed by said decree.” The transfer of the entire property was thereupon made to that company, and it has since assumed the defence of the intervenor’s claim.
The master to whom the petition of the Trust Company for rent was referred made two reports. By the first report, the Trust Company was allowed a rental of $77,237.06, being a sum equal to the interest on the bonds from October 1, 1884, (the date of the last payment,) to April 16,1885,. the date on which the court ordered that no rent or subdivi-
Argument for the United States Trust Company.
sional interest would be paid on lines that did not earn a surplus.
To this report the receivers filed exceptions which were sustained by the court, and the case referred back to the master with instructions to report, first, whether the Omaha Division had been retained by the receivers at the instance or for the benefit of the mortgagees under the Wabash general mortgage, after the United States Trust Company had demanded possession thereof; and, second, to ascertain and report what would be a reasonable rental for the line for the time it was so withheld. In his second report the master reviewed at some length the record in the case, and concluded that the value of the use and occupation of the property during the time it was withheld from the intervenor was the pro rata amount of the rental provided for in the lease, namely, $13,708.33 per month; that the intervenor had received the rental for thirty days of the period of detention, and was entitled to receive pay for two months more, or the sum of $27,416.66.
To this report both parties, the receivers and the Trust Company, excepted, and these exceptions having been filed, the court, on September 25, 1889, entered a decree that the exceptions should be sustained in so far as the report found that the intervenor was entitled to recover two months’ rent of the mortgage property at the rate of $13,708.33 per month; but in so far as the report found that the intervenor was entitled to recover one month’s rent, it was confirmed, and a final decree was entered for $13,708.33 and interest from January 6, 1886, making an aggregate amount of $16,765.51.
From that decree both parties appealed to this court.
Edward W. Sheldon and J/k Theodore Sheldon for the United States Trust Company.
I. Where receivers elect to retain possession of property, real or personal, held under a contract of lease, they become liable, whether as equitable assignees of the lease or by virtue solely °i such election, for the stipulated rent during the period of their possession.
Argument for the United States Trust Company.
This statement of the law is axiomatic, and includes all classes of receivers. In the case of statutory receivers, liquidators and assignees in bankruptcy, the doctrine proceeds on the ground that on the election being made, the receiver or assignee becomes vested with the title to the leasehold interest, and a privity of estate is thereby created between the lessor and the receiver or assignee, by virtue of which the latter becomes liable on the covenants running with the “land.” Matter of Otis, 101 N. Y. 580, 585. If any distinction is to be drawn in the case of chancery receivers appointed to preserve property pendente lite, while the courts are not always agreed in their reasoning, the liability is said to rest not on the theory of an equitable assignment to the receivers of the unexpired term, but on the fact of their adoption of an existing contract. Many authorities for this proposition might be cited, but the following will serve as illustrations: Turner v. Richardson, 1 East, 335; Thomas v. Pemberton, I Taunt. 206; In re Oak Pits Colliery Co., 21 Ch. D. 322; In re Silkstone As Podworth Coal As Iron Co., 17 Ch. D. 158; In re North Yorkshire Iron Co., 7 Ch. D. 661; Ex parte Faxon, 1 Lowell, 404; Woodruff n. Erie Railway Co., 93 N. Y. 609; People v. TJni/versal Life Ins. Co., 30 Hun, 142; Martin v. Black, 9 Paige, 641; Commonwealth v. Franklin Ins. Co., 115 Mass. 278; People v. National Trust Co., 82 N..Y. 283, 288; In re International Marine Hydropathic Co., 28 Ch. D. 470; In re National Arms and Ammunition Company, 28 Ch. D. 474; In re Blackburn As District Benefit Building Sloe:, 42 Ch. D. 343.
This court has recently recognized the doctrine in its relation to both assignees in bankruptcy and chancery receivers. Sparhawk v. Yerkes, 142 IT. S. 1. See also Sunfiower OU Co. v. Wilson, 142 U. S. 313; Quincy, Missouri As Pacific RaUr road v. Humphreys, 145 U. S. 82; Peoria As Pekin Union Railway v. Chicago, Pekin & Southwestern Railroad, 121 IT. S. 200; Thomas v. Western Car Co., 149 IT. S. 95.
II. The facts of the present case establish the election of the Wabash receivers to assume the lease of the Omaha Division. from May 29, 1884, to March 6, 1886.
Argument for the United States Trust Company.
This period naturally divides itself as follows: (1) From. May 29, 1884, to October 1, 1884. Here the intervenor’s claim was recognized, and payment of the rental received; (2) From October 1, 1884, to April 16, 1885. All the reasons which justified the payment of October, 1884, govern this second period; and (3) From April 16, 1885, to March 6, 1886.
With the announcement made by the court in April, 1885, our opponents contend that explicit notice was given that rent would only be paid when earned. On our side we contend, first, that the Omaha Division was, both by contemporaneous and subsequent action of court and receivers, exempted from the operation of this announcement; and, second, that the announcement itself never possessed the significance claimed for it.
Underlying the scheme of the bill in this case, as well as of the other pleadings, and the orders, petitions, and opinions filed in the cause, is the constant suggestion of the pressing need and paramount value of maintaining the congeries of roads as a system. That may be said to have been the basis, if not the justifying cause, of this extraordinary receivership. It was not from any philanthropic motive that these leasehold estates were included in the sequestrated property; nor was it until a much later period of the receivership that the theory of an obligation to the public to maintain every railroad which the receivers had undertaken to operate, found expression. Estates held by the Wabash Company on the condition of rent payments, need only have been regarded in the light of ordinary investments. If deemed unprofitable ventures, they could have been omitted from the list of property subjected to the receivership, or at any time thereafter surrendered by the receivers to the respective lessors. Only one conclusion is possible from this positive recognition of the leases, namely, that the continued operation of the leased lines was regarded as beneficial to the system. No occasion exists for speculation as to the receivers’ motives. They have definitely expressed their intention and beliefs, and the result s spread upon the record. If their persistent determination
Argument for the United States Trust Company.
to retain the Omaha Division did not constitute an election, it would indeed be difficult to imagine how, in a case like this, an election could be demonstrated.
III. No special differentiating circumstances prevent the necessity of the application of the general rule to the present case.
IV. On the theory of a quantum valebat, also, the intervenor is entitled to recover, since the retention of the Omaha Division inured directly to the benefit of the receivership property, and to an extent in excess of the intervenor’s claim.
It appears from the testimony that from October 1,1884, to March 6, 1886, the net revenue from business exchanged between the Wabash railroad and the Omaha Division was $1,551,919.25, of which the sum of $1,123,260.13 was set apart to the Wabash Company, and the remainder, $428,659.12, to the Omaha Division. The cost of hauling, the only expense to the Wabash Company in the case of a greater part of this business, was, in the estimation of the Wabash general manager, less than seventy per cent, and may not have exceeded fifty per cent of the revenue received. We thus ascertain that the clear net earnings from the use of the Omaha Division, during the period in question, were, at their lowest estimate, and this a hostile one, about $336,978.04, the equivalent of thirty per cent of $1,123,260.13, and may have equalled $561,630.06. Furthermore, the retention of the division made it possible to operate at a profit and pay the rentals on two adjoining leased lines, the Brunswick and Chillicothe and St. Louis, Council Bluffs and Omaha roads. Such a result gave practical justification to the attitude of the Wabash receivers in opposing the surrender or withdrawal of the division, and in instructing their counsel to “ keep the road in the system if possible.”
While the receivers’ reports declared that the Omaha Division for a period of two years and a half barely earned its operating expenses, when the facts are known, we find that in addition to the earnings credited to it in the reports, it exchanged independent business with the Wabash Company [p. 299] which brought into the treasury of that company a clear profit ranging from $336,000 to $561,000, and enabled it to keep possession of and successfully operate eighty additional miles of leased roads. Under such conditions cannot equity be successfully invoked to secure a just compensation for the use of property which has demonstrated its value ?
V. The income collected by the receivers is primarily charged with the payment of these claims, with recourse, if necessary, to the corpus of the property.
VI. The decree of the Circuit Court should be modified by increasing the judgment in favor of the intervenor from $16,765.51 to $222,075.77 with interest from February 6, 1886.
Mr. F. W. Lehmann for the Wabash Western Railway Company.
Mr. Wells H. Blodgett filed a brief for the Wabash Western Railway Company.
Mr. Thomas H. Hubbard filed a brief for the Wabash Western Railway Company.
Mr. Justice Brown, after stating the case, delivered the opinion of the court.
Stripped of its complications, this case involves to a certain extent the same question disposed of by this court in Quincy, Missouri & Pacific Railroad v. Humphreys, 145 U. S. 82, namely, whether the receivers of the Wabash system took possession of the leased lines under such circumstances as to charge them with the payment of the agreed rental so long as they retained possession of the lines.
The general rule applicable to this class of cases is undisputed that an assignee or receiver is not bound to adopt the contracts, accept the leases, or otherwise step into the shoes °f his assignor, if in his opinion it would be unprofitable or undesirable to do so; and he is entitled to a reasonable time [p. 300] to elect whether to adopt or repudiate such contracts. If he elect to adopt a lease, the receiver becomes vested with the title to the leasehold interest, and a privity of estate is thereby created between the lessor and the receiver, by which the latter becomes liable upon the covenant to pay rent. Sparhawk v. Yerkes, 142 U. S. 1, 13; Sunflower Oil Company v. Wilson, 142 U. S. 313, 322; Woodruff v. Erie Railway, 93 N. Y. 609; In re Otis, 101 N. Y. 580, 585.
In this case, however, wTe are bound to consider the somewhat peculiar circumstances under which the receivers took possession of and operated the branch lines of the Wabash system. The bill was not an ordinary bill of foreclosure, but a bill filed by the mortgagor corporation for the purpose of preventing the disruption of the system, and securing a winding up of the old corporation and the organization of a new one, to which the various properties of the road should be transferred. The bill, which w7as certainly one of unusual character, purported to be filed not only for the benefit and in the interest of the mortgagor and the mortgagee, but also in the interest of the large number of branch corporations which were operated under one general management, and were a part and parcel of the Wabash system. Indeed, the bill expressly averred that defaults in the payment of interest were anticipated, and as soon as they should occur a number of suits would be commenced for the appointment of receivers under the original sectional mortgages executed by the leased corporations; that under the terms of such leases the lessor companies would declare a forfeiture of the rights of the complainant; that its road would be broken into fragments and would ultimately be sold in small sections, and a reestablishment of its unity rendered impossible.
This court has already held in Quincy dec. Railway Co. v. Humphreys, 145 U. S. 82, 101, that after the appointment of receivers made in pursuance of the prayer of this bill “the court did not bind itself or its receivers ” to pay the agreed rentals of a leased line “ eo instanti by the mere act of taking possession. Reasonable time necessarily had to be taken to ascertain the situation of affairs. The Quincy Company,
(and the same remark may be made of the Omaha Division,) “as a quasi public corporation, operating a public highway, was under a public duty to keep up and maintain its railroad as a going concern, as was the Wabash Company under the contract between them; but the latter had become unable to perform the public services for which it had been endowed with its faculties and franchises, and which it had assumed to discharge as between it and the other company. Its operation could only be continued under the receivers, whose action in that respect cannot be adjudged to have been dictated by the idea of keeping the property in order to sell it, or using it to the advantage of the creditors, or doing otherwise than ‘ abstain from trying to get rid of the property.’ ” On May 27, 1884, Humphreys and Tutt were appointed receivers of the property and were directed to pay certain preferred claims, including rentals accrued or which might thereafter accrue, upon leased lines. On «Tune 26, the receivers reported to the court that, from the incoming rents and profits of the property, they were unable to pay on June 1 the interest falling due upon certain divisional bonds, and prayed the advice of the court as to paying the interest on these bonds, and as to how they should dispose of the earnings of the other lines or divisions which had not and would not for the present be enough to pay the operating expenses, the cost of maintenance, and the interest upon the bonds. This petition was referred to a master, who made a report on June 28, upon which an order of court was entered that the receivers, “ from the incoming rents and profits of said property, after meeting such other obligations as they have been directed to discharge by the former order of this court, pay from whatever balance niay remain in their hands the interest, as the same may from time to time mature upon the following bonds,” including those of the Omaha Division.
If this order of June 28 had been, as the court below seems at first to have construed it, ^Central Trust Co. v. Wabash &c. Railwayy 34 Fed. Rep. 259, 266,) “couched in such language that the intervenor had a right to rely upon it, and expect the payment of his rent, until some other order was made,” there [p. 302] would be strong reason for saying that the receivers would be obligated to pay this interest as it matured. But upon a more careful examination of this order, upon a rehearing, the court came to the conclusion that it was not an absolute order to pay, but only an order to pay after the preferential debts had been discharged. 38 Fed. Rep. 63. We have no doubt of the correctness of this conclusion. The language of the order was that the receivers, “ from the incoming rents and profits of said property, after meeting such other obligations as they have been directed to discharge by the former order of this court, pay from whatever balance may remain in their hands.” The other obligations they had been directed to discharge were fixed by the order of their appointment of May 27, as traffic balances, rentals accrued or to accrue upon leased lines, and for the use of terminal facilities and rolling stock, claims for labor, supplies, professional services, and salaries, maturing within six months before making the order, and current expenses for the operation of the road. It is true, as argued by the intervenors, that among the preferred claims mentioned in this order were the rentals due and to become due on leased lines, and that there was no order of payment or relative rank fixed between the preferred claims themselves, the court evidently supposing that the income of the road would be sufficient to pay all the preferred debts. It was impossible, however, for the court, in making the order of June 28, to have contemplated that the rental due the Omaha Division should be a preferred claim, inasmuch as the whole object of the order of June 28 was to provide for the payment of the interest due upon the bonds of this division, after the payment of preferred claims. There is an apparent incongruity between the two orders, but we think it clear that the object of the order of June 28 was, as stated, to pay only from the balance after the payment of the preferred claims, not including as a preferred claim the claim for rental.
The owners of the leased lines were fully apprised by this order of the fact that payment of interest upon their bonds was conditional upon such balance existing; and the fact was that, after paying the operating expenses of the lines and the [p. 303] labor and supply debts of the Wabash Company, there was never a balance in the hands of the receivers out of which they could pay either interest or rentals. In fact, the preferential indebtedness which the receivers were, by the order of May 27, directed to pay, amounted to over $4,000,000, and the total gross earnings of all the lines of the system, from the day the receivers were appointed to the time the Omaha Division was surrendered to its trustee, lacked over $2,000,000 of being sufficient to pay the operating expenses and the labor and supply7 debts of the Wabash Company. The receivers did in fact pay the agreed rental of the Omaha Division up to October 1, 1884, to the amount of $82,250. Now, if the owners of the Omaha branch or the trustees of its mortgage, knowing as they did that the system of which their road was a part had gone into the hands of receivers, and was being operated by them, had desired to repossess themselves of their property, or to object to the order of June 28, they should have intervened and asked the court to protect their interests. While they may not have been parties to this order directly, they were parties to the bill, and were bound to know that their property, in the hands of the receivers would or might be affected by orders which the court would make in the course of the administration of the insolvent estate, and should have made themselves parties io the proceedings that their rights might be protected. As was said in Miltenberger v. Logansport Railway, 106 U. S. 286, of certain mortgage creditors who had intervened to claim that certain expenditures had been made by receivers without authority, “ it did not comport with the principles of equity for the appellants to lie by and see the court and the receiver dealing with the property in the manner now complained of, and content themselves with merely protesting generally and disclaiming all interest under the receivership, and yet assert . . . that the other property acquired by the receiver, and now alleged to have been acquired by him without authority, was subject to the lien of the first mortgage, and now claim the proceeds of all that property, without paying the debts incurred in acquiring it.
court of equity, however it might act on the question of [p. 304] original authority or discretion, if presented in season and under circumstances of good faith, will not visit upon innocent parties dealing with a receiver within the authority of its orders, consequences which result from the inequitable negligence and supineness of a party to the suit, or of those represented by him.” So in Meyer v. Johnson, 53 Alabama, 237, 350, it is stated, inferentially at least, that whenever, in the course of a receivership, the court makes an order which the parties to the suit consider injurious to their interests, it is their duty to file a motion at once asking the court to cancel or modify it. See also Wallace v. Loomis, 97 U. S. 146; Post v. Dorr, 4 Edw. Ch. 1st ed. 412; 2d ed. 425.
It is well understood that, in the foreclosure of railroad mortgages, it often becomes necessary to provide for the payment of preferred claims, and to postpone all rights of ordinary creditors, and even of mortgagees, to these preferred classes, and that this is sometimes done from the necessities of the case without notice to all who may be affected thereby.
Nor is this aspect of the case changed by the fact that the earnings on the Omaha Division had previously been sufficient to pay the operating expenses, cost of maintenance, and interest upon its bonds, and that the receivers thought and believed such earnings would be sufficient to pay the interest as well as the preferred claims. Various things had occurred or might occur, such as failure of crops, injury from floods, or other disasters, to affect its earning capacity, and the trustees were bound to know that the insolvency of the entire system of which their road was a part could hardly fail to affect the value of their securities.
On March 20,1885, the receivers filed another petition, stating that the earnings of many of the lines had not been sufficient to pay the operating expenses, interest on bonds, and the rentals contracted to be paid, among which lines was the Omaha Division,' the expenses of which, not including any charge for rental, had exceeded its earnings by $5288.64, and praying the court to make such orders with respect to the future operation of such lines and the payment of the respective rentals as should seem proper to the court. In response thereto, the [p. 305] court, on April 16, ordered that subdivisional accounts should be kept separately; that where any subdivision earned a surplus over expenses, the rental or subdivisional interest would be paid to the extent of the surplus; where it earned no surplus, but simply operating expenses, no rent or subdivisional interest would be paid; and where not only was no surplus earned, but an actual deficiency existed, operating expenses would be reduced to a minimum. At the time this order was granted there was some conversation between counsel, in which it was said to be the wish of the receivers not to include in this proceeding the Omaha Division ; but it was qualified by the express statement of the receivers that they did not wish to be understood as promising the bondholders the payment of the interest on the bonds within a short period of time under the circumstances.
This order was certainly notice to the branch lines that they must not expect payment of their rental where the subdivision earned nothing beyond operating expenses. The Trust Company, however, did not at this time see fit to intervene and demand possession of the property, but upon default in the payment of the interest due April 1, 1885, filed a bill of foreclosure in the state court, making the receivers parties to the bill. This suit was removed, upon petition of the receivers, to the Circuit Court of the United States. It was not until December 2 that the Trust Company petitioned the court for the surrender of the property. Under these circumstances, we do not think the receivers are chargeable with the unpaid rent. It is possible that the Trust Company acted under a misapprehension of its rights, but it is more probable that they expected the earnings of the road would be sufficient to entitle them to their interest under the orders of June 28 and April 16. There appears to have been no good reason why demand was not made long before for the surrender of the property. It is true the receivers filed in the state court an answer consist-of a single sentence denying generally the allegations of the bill, and in November following they removed the case to the Circuit Court of the United States; but there Was nothing in all this to prevent the Trust Company from
VOL. CL—20
applying to the United States court for possession of the property.
There is another reason, however, why the Trust Company is not entitled to the rental of this property prior to demanding possession thereof in its bill of foreclosure. The petition avers that by reason of the defaults in the payment of the rentals the receivers “are indebted to your petitioner for the use and occupation of the said demised premises under the said lease.” But the mortgage or deed of trust to the Trust Company, the petitioner, did not purport to convey any of the incomes or earnings of the road, but provided that if default should at any time occur in the payment of interest, the trustee should, when requested so to do, take possession of the mortgaged property and operate the same, and collect and receive all the tolls and income thereof. It was also provided that, until such default, the mortgagors should be entitled to have and to hold the possession of the railroad, and collect, receive, and retain all the revenues arising from its use.
There was also a guaranty mortgage executed by the Council Bluffs and St. Louis Railroad Company to the same trustee, conveying all its right, title, interest, and estate in the demised premises with all the mortgagor’s rights, privileges, and franchises, acquired or to be acquired, subject only to the lease. Now, if the mortgage had covered the earnings and rentals of the property, and those had constituted a part of the estate conveyed to the Trust Company as security for the bonds, there would be some reason for saying that it would be entitled to recover these earnings and rentals in this action before it demanded possession of the road. But where the mortgage provides that the mortgagor shall remain in possession until default, but when default occurs the trustee may enter, this court has held that the trustee can only secure the earnings of the mortgaged property by taking or demanding possession. And in Galveston Hallway v. Cowdrey, 11 Wall. 459, 483, it was held that, even where the mortgage covered the tolls, income, and profits of the railroad, whenever the company should be in default of payment, but a subsequent clause provided that in case the company should be in default [p. 307] in payments of principal or interest for three months, the trustees should take possession of the road, and collect and receive the tolls, income, and profits, etc., it was held that, until regular demand was made for the payment of tolls and income, the defendants were not bound to account therefor. So in Gilman v. Illinois de Mississippi Telegraph Co., 91 U. S. 603, the trustee in a mortgage, which covered a road with its revenues and incomes, sought to recover as against a general creditor a fund that had been earned before the trustee took possession of the mortgaged property. The deed of trust in that case provided that if default occurred in the payment of interest, the trustee' might take possession, and receive the income and earnings of the road, and apply them to the debt secured. The court held that the trustees had no claim upon the fund. In delivering the opinion of the court, Mr. Justice Swayne observed: “ It is clearly implied in these mortgages that the railroad company should hold possession and receive the earnings until the mortgagee should take possession, or the proper judicial authority should interpose. Possession draws after it the right to receive and apply the income. ... In this condition of things, the whole fund belonged to the company, and was subject to its control. It was, therefore, liable to the creditors of the company as if the mortgages did not exist. They in nowise affected it. If the mortgagees were not satisfied, they had the remedy in their own hands, and could at any moment invoke the aid of the law or interpose themselves without it.”
In American Bridge Co. v. Heidelbach, 94 U. S. 798, the mortgage included the rents, issues, and profits of a certain bridge, in so far as the same were not necessary to pay its operating expenses and the cost of keeping it in repair. The question in the case was whether earnings that had accrued from the use of the bridge before the bill of foreclosure was oiea by the trustee were covered by the mortgage and prevailed over the rights of a judgment creditor. In this case it Was said that “ the mortgage could have no retrospective effect as to previous income and earnings. The bill of the trustees does not affect the rights of the parties. It is an [p. 308] attempt to extend the mortgage to what it cannot be made to reach. Such a proceeding does not create any new right. It can only enforce those which exist already.”
The substance of these rulings is that until the mortgagee asserts his rights under the mortgage to the possession of the road by filing a bill of foreclosure, or, if the road be in the hands of a third party, by demanding possession of such party, he has no right to its earnings and profits. In other words, there is no privity of contract or of estate between the mortagee and lessee, at least until the mortgagee has taken possession of the property, and become the assignee of the rights of the mortgagor.
On December 2, 1885, the Trust Company made formal application to the court for the transfer and surrender of the Omaha Division to a receiver to be appointed in the suits then pending for the foreclosure of the mortgage. The motion was called to the attention of the court on December 8, and was opposed by counsel for the Central Trust Company of New York, the trustee of the Wabash general mortgage, upon the ground that the application should be postponed until January 4, 1886, when the decree in the Wabash suit would be presented to the court for settlement, and the matter of this petition, as well as all other questions, could be presented and passed upon. This application for the postponement was resisted by the counsel for the United States Trust Company, but was granted by the court, which expressed an unwillingness to permit the further disintegration of the system. No order was made at this time with respect to the rental. Upon the renewal of the application, on January 6, the court ordered a surrender to be made within thirty days, with an option to the Wabash receivers to retain the division for an additiona thirty days, on the payment of one month’s rent, namely,
$13,708.33. The receivers availed themselves of this option, and paid the rent, with the hope that during that time some arrangement might be made to keep the line within the system, so that the surrender did not actually take place until March, 1886. As the rent for the last thirty days was paid, the sole remaining questions are as to the rent from December 9 to February 6.
The master to whom the case was referred reported that the Trust Company was entitled to the two months’ rental at $13,708.33 per month. But the court, upon hearing exceptions to such report, was of the opinion that, while the receivers were liable for the first month’s rental, namely, from December 7 to January 6, upon the ground that the delay upon the consideration of the motion was opposed by the counsel of the Trust Company, the further delay of thirty days was with their consent, hence, that they were equitably estopped from claiming rental for the second month.
We agree with the court below in this conclusion. When the motion was called up, on December 6, the Trust Company insisted upon its right to have an immediate surrender of the road, and opposed even a postponement of thirty days. Possession of the road being withheld from them without their assent, they are equitably entitled to rent for this month. But the order entered on January 6, directing the receivers at the expiration of thirty days from that date to surrender possession to a receiver to be appointed by the United States Circuit Court, having been entered by consent of the parties — in other words, the Trust Company having waived the delivery of the road for thirty days, it ought not now to insist upon payment for that period. Indeed, as the receiver of the Omaha Division had not then been appointed, it is difficult to see to whom the road could have been immediately turned over.
As bearing upon the general equities of the case, it may be remarked that, while the proceedings in the foreclosure of the Wabash mortgage did undoubtedly result in the detention of the road from its lawful owners for about fifteen months without the payment of the agreed rent, the road during this time earned nothing beyond its operating expenses, and there [p. 310] is nothing to indicate that it would have done so in the hands of its owners, so that in fact they lost nothing. Indeed, it is scarcely credible that they would have delayed so long to demand possession of the road if in their opinion it could have been operated at a profit.
The decree of the court below is, therefore,
Affirmed.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access