Arave v. Hoffman, 552 U.S. 117 (2008)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Arave v. Hoffman, 552 U.S. 117 (2008)
Full caption
ARAVE, WARDEN v. HOFFMAN
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Jan. 7, 2008
ARAVE, WARDEN v. HOFFMAN
certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the ninth circuit
No. 07–110. Decided January 7, 2008
Respondent was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death in state court. Finding that he had received ineffective assistance of counsel during his trial’s sentencing phase but not during plea bargain ing, the Federal District Court subsequently granted habeas relief, or dering that he be resentenced. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the judg ment with respect to sentencing and reversed with respect to plea bargaining.
Held: Respondent’s motion to vacate and dismiss as moot the Ninth Cir cuit’s judgment, to the extent it addressed his plea bargaining claim, is granted. He wishes to abandon that claim so that he may proceed with the resentencing ordered by the District Court. The Ninth Circuit is directed to instruct the District Court to dismiss the relevant claim with prejudice.
Motion granted; 455 F. 3d 926, vacated in part and remanded.
Per Curiam.
Respondent Maxwell Hoffman was convicted of first degree murder and sentenced to death. See State v. Hoff man, 123 Idaho 638, 851 P. 2d 934 (1993). Hoffman sought federal habeas relief on the grounds that, inter alia, his counsel had been ineffective during both pretrial plea bar gaining and the sentencing phase of his trial. The District Court, finding that Hoffman had received ineffective assist ance of counsel during sentencing but not during plea bar gaining, granted Hoffman’s federal habeas petition in part and ordered the State of Idaho to resentence him. Civ. Ac tion No. 94–0200–S–BLW (Mar. 30, 2002), App. to Pet. for Cert. 38, 65. The Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the District Court’s decision regarding ineffective p. 118118 ARAVE v. HOFFMAN
Per Curiam
assistance of counsel during sentencing,* but reversed with respect to the ineffective-assistance claim during plea negoti ations. 455 F. 3d 926, 942 (2006). The Ninth Circuit thus granted the writ, ordering the District Court to direct the State either to release Hoffman or to “offe[r] [him] a plea agreement with the ‘same material terms’ offered in the original plea agreement.” Id., at 943. The State sought, and we granted, certiorari. Post, p. 1008.
Hoffman now abandons his claim that counsel was ineffec tive during plea bargaining. See Respondent’s Motion to Vacate Decision Below and Dismiss the Cause as Moot. He “no longer seeks or desires the relief ordered by the Court of Appeals with respect to the plea offer.” Id., at 3. Rather, Hoffman now “wishes to withdraw his claim of ineffective assistance of counsel in connection with plea bargaining” and asks this Court to dismiss his appeal with prejudice on that issue so that he may proceed with the resentencing ordered by the District Court. Ibid.
The State, in its response, notes that Hoffman’s requested relief is “virtually identical to the request made by the state in its Petition for Certiorari.” Response to Respondent’s Motion to Vacate Decision Below and Dismiss the Cause as Moot, p. 3. The State therefore agrees that the instant mo tion to vacate and dismiss with prejudice moots Hoffman’s claim of ineffective assistance of counsel during plea negotia tions and asks that the motion be granted.
We grant respondent’s motion. Because his claim for inef fective assistance of counsel during pretrial plea bargaining is moot, we vacate the judgment of the Court of Appeals to the extent that it addressed that claim. The case is re manded to the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth
*
The State initially cross-appealed the District Court’s grant of Hoff man’s habeas petition for ineffective assistance of counsel at sentencing. The State, however, subsequently withdrew that cross-appeal, leaving in place the District Court’s order granting habeas relief as to Hoffman’s death sentence. 455 F. 3d 926, 931 (CA9 2006).
Cite as: 552 U. S. 117 (2008) 119
Per Curiam
Circuit with directions that it instruct the United States Dis trict Court for the District of Idaho to dismiss the relevant claim with prejudice. Deakins v. Monaghan, 484 U. S. 193, 200–201 (1988); United States v. Munsingwear, Inc., 340 U. S. 36, 39–40 (1950).
It is so ordered.