United States v. Smith, 18 U.S. (5 Wheat.) 153 (1820)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
United States v. Smith, 18 U.S. (5 Wheat.) 153 (1820)
Full caption
THE UNITED STATES v. SMITH
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1820
THE UNITED STATES v. SMITH.
The act of the 3d of March, 1819, c. 76, s. 5, refer¬ ring- to the law of nations for a definition of the crime of piracy, is a constitutional exercise of the power of Congress to define and punish that crime.
The crime of piracy is defined by the law of na¬ tions with reasonable certainty.
Robbery, or forcible depredation, upon the sea, animo f urandl, is piracy by the law of nations, and by the act of Congress.
This was an indictment for piracy against the prisoner, Thomas Smith, before the 154] Circuit Court of Virginia, on the act of Congress of the 3d of March, 1819, c. 76.'
The jury found a special verdict as follows: “We, of the jury, find, that the prisoner, Thomas Smith, in the month of March, 1819, and others were part of the crew of a private armed vessel, called the Creollo (commissioned by the government of Buenos Ayres, a colony then at war with Spain), and lying in the port of Margaritta; that in the month of March, 1819 the said prisoner and others of the crew muti¬ nied, confined their officer, left the vessel, and in the said port of Margaritta, seized by violence a vessel called the Irre.sistible, a private armed ves¬ sel, lying in that port, commissioned by the gov-
1.— Which provides (s. 5), “That if any person or persons whatsoever, shall, on the high seas, coinmit the crime of pii’acy, as defined by the law of na¬ tions, and such offender or offenders shall after¬ wards be brought into, or found in, the United States, every such offender or oifenders shall, upon conviction thereof, before the Circuit Court of the United States for the district into which he or they may be brought, or in which he or they shall be found, be punished with death.”
Wheat. 5.
ernment of Artigas, who was also at war with Spain; that the s:iid prisoner and others, hav¬ ing so posses, sed themselves of the said vessel, the Irresistible, appointed their officers, pro¬ ceeded to sea on a eruise, without any docu¬ ments or commission whatever; and while on that cruise, in the month of April, 1819, on the high seas, committed the offense charged in the indictment, by the plunder and robbery of the Spanish vessel therein mentioned. If the plunder and robbery aforesaid be piracy under the act of the Congress of the United States, entitled, ‘An act to protect the commerce of the *United State.s, and punish the
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
crime of piracy,’ then we find the said prisoner guilty; if the plunder and robbery above stated be not piracy under the said act of Con¬ gress, then we find him not guilty.”
The Circuit Court divided on the question whether this be piracy as defined by the law of nations, so as to be punishable under the act of Congress, of the 3d of March, 1819, and there¬ upon the quesfion was certified to this court for its decision.
The Attorney-General, tor the United States contended, that Congress, by referring to the law of nations for a definition of the crime of piracy, had duly exercised the power given them by the constitution, “to define and pun¬ ish piracies and felonies committed on the high seas, and offenses against the law of nations. ” By this reference they adopt the definition of the offense given by the writers on public law. All these writers concur in defining it to be de¬ predation on the seas, without the authority of a commission, or beyond its authority.^ If there be any defect of precision or slight un¬ certainty in the definitions of the crime of piracy given by different writers on the law of nations, it is no more than what is to be found in common law writers on the crime of mur¬ der. Yet we are constantly referred *by
the legislature to the common law for the defi¬ nition of murder and other felonies which are mentioned in statutory provisions. But there is no defect in the definition of piracy by the authorities to which we are referred by this act. The definition given by them is certain, con¬ sistent, and unanimous ; and pirates being hodes Immani yemr is, &!•& Tpnnishahle in the tribunals of all nations. All nations are engaged in a league against them for the mutual defense and safety of all. This renders it the more fit and proper that there should be a uniform rule as to the definition of the crime, which can only be drawn from the law of nations, as the only code universally known and recognized by the people of all countries.
Mr. Webster, contra, argued, that the special verdict did not contain sulflcient facts to enable the court to pronounce the prisoner guilty of the offense charged. The facts found do not necessarily infer his guilt, but, on the contrary, are consistent with his innocence; inasmuch as it appears that lie was one of the crew of a ves¬ sel belonging to Buenos Ayres, although not
3.— Grotiusde J. B. ac. P.,1,3, c.l5, s. 5; Puffendorf,
1. 3, c. 2, s. 10; Vattel, Droit des Gens, 1. 3, c. 15, s.
226; Bynk. Q. J. Pub., 1. 1 ; Duponceau’s Trans, p. 127; Marten’s Hist, of Privateers, p. 2; Horne’s Trans. Molloy, b. 1, c. 4, s. 5; 3 Bro. Civ. and Adm. Law, 461; 2Azuni, 351; Johns. Trans., and the au¬ thorities there cited.
57
156
SUFKBME OnUKT OP THE UNITED STATES.
1820
acting at the time when the supposed offense was committed under the commission of that colony, hut acting as a non-commissioned cap- tor, and as such, seizing the property of Span¬ ish subjects on the high seas. But even sup¬ posing the offense to he well found hy the special verdict, it cannot he punished under this act, because the law i.s not a constitutional exercise of the power of Congress to define the crime of piracy. Congress is hound to detine 157] itin terms, and is not at liberty to leave it to he ascertained by judicial interpretation. To refer to the law of nations for a definition of the crime, is not a definition; for the very thing to be ascertained by the definition, is the law "of nations on the .subject. The constitu¬ tion evidently presupposes that this crime, and other offenses committed on the high seas, were not defined with sufficient precision by the law of nations, or any other law, to form a rule of conduct; or it would merely have given Con¬ gress the power of punishing tliese offenses, without also imposing upon it th^ duty of de¬ fining them. The wu-iters on public law do not define the crime of piracy with precision and certainty. It was this very defect which ren¬ dered it necessary that Congress .should define, in terms, before it jiroceeded to exercise the power of punishing the offense. Congress must define it as the constitution has defined treason, not by referring to the law of nations in one case, or to the common law in the other, but by giving a distinct, intelligible explana¬ tion of the nature of the offense in the act it¬ self.
Mr. Ju&tice Story delivered the opinion of the court : The act of Congress upon which this indictment is founded provides, “that if any person or persons whatsoever, shall upon the high seas, commit the crime of piracy, as defined by the law of nations, and such offend¬ er or offenders shall be brought into, or found in the United States, every such offender or of¬ fenders shall, upon conviction thereof, &c., be punished with death. ”
• 158] The first point made at the bar is, whether this enactment be a constitutional exer¬ cise of the authority delegated to Congress upon the subject of piracies. The constitution declares that Congress shall have power “ to define and punish piracy and felonies committed on the high seas, and offenses against the law of na¬ tions.” The argument which, has been urged in behalf of the prisoner is, that Congress is bound to define, in terms, the offense of piracy, and is not at liberty to leave it to be ascertained by judicial interpretation. If the argument be well founded, it seems admitted by the counsel that it equally applies to the 8th section of the act of Congress of 1790, ch. 9, whicli declares, that robbery and murder committed on the high seas shall be deemed piracy ; and yet, not¬ withstanding a series of contested adjudica¬ tions on this section, no doubt has hitherto been breathed of its conformity to the constitution.
In our judgment, the construction contended for proceeds upon too narrow a view of the language of the constitution. The power given to Congress is not merely “to define and pun¬ ish piracy;” if it were, the words “to define” would seem almost superfluous, since the pow¬ er to punish piracies would be held to include 58
the power of ascertaining and fixing the defini¬ tion of the crime. And it has been very justly observed, in a celebrated commentary, that the definition of piracies might have been left with¬ out inconvenience to the law of nations, though a legislative definition of them is to be found in most municipal *codes.' But
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
the power is also given ‘ ‘ to define and punish felonies on the high seas, and offenses against the law of nations.” The term “felonies” has been supposed, in the same work, not to have a very exact and determinate meaning in relation to offenses at the common law com¬ mitted within the body of a county. How¬ ever this may be, in relation to offenses on the high seas, it is necessarily somewhat indeter¬ minate, since the term is not used in the crim¬ inal jurisprudence of the admiralty in the tech¬ nical sense of the common law.^ Offenses, too, against the law of nations, cannot, with any ac¬ curacy, be said to be completely ascertained and defined in any public code recognized by the common consent of nations. In respect, therefore, as well to felonies on the high seas as to offenses against the law of nations, there is a peculiar fitness in giving the power to de¬ fine as well as to punish ; and there is not the slightest reason to doubt that this consideration had very great weight in producing the phra¬ seology in question.
But suppo.sing Congress were bound in all the cases included in the clause under consid¬ eration to define the offense, still there is noth¬ ing which restricts it to a mere logical enumera¬ tion in detail of all the facts constituting the offense. Congre.ss may as well define by using a term of a known and determinate meaning as by an express enumeration of all the par¬ ticulars included in that term. That is cer¬ tain *which is by necessary reference [*1G0 made certain. When the act of 1790 declares, that any person who shall commit the crime of robbery, or murder, on the high seas,' shall be deemed a pirate, the crime is not less clearly ascertained than it would be by using the defini¬ tions of these terms as they are found in our treatises of the common law. In fact, by such a reference, the definitions are necessarily in¬ cluded, as much as if they stood in the text of the act. In respect to murder, where “malice aforethought ” is of the essence of the offense, even if the common law definition were quoted in express terms, we should still be driven to deny that the definition was perfect, since the meaning of “malice aforethought” would re¬ main to be gathered from the common law. There would then be no end to our difficulties, or our definitions, for each would involve some terms which might still require some new ex¬ planation. Such a construction of the con,stitu- tion is, therefore, wholly inadmissible. To define piracies, in the sense of the constitution, is merel}^ to enumerate the crimes which shall constitute piracy ; and this may be done either by a reference to crimes having a technical name, and determinate extent, or by enumera¬ ting the acts in detail, upon which the punish¬ ment is inflicted.
It is next to be considered, whether the crime of piracy is defined by the law of nations
1. — The Federalist, No. 42, p. 276.
2. — See 3 Inst. 112; Hawk. P. C., ch. 37 ; Moore, 576.
Wheat. 5.
1820
The United States v. Smith.
160
with reasonable certainty. What the law of nations on this subject is, may be ascertained by consulting the works of jurists, writing pro¬ fessedly on public law; or by the general usage 1 0 1 ] and practice of nations ; or by j ud icial de- cisions recognizing and enforcing that law. There is scarcely a writer on the law of nations who does not allude to piracy as a crime of a settled and determinate nature; and whatever may be the diversity of definitions, in other re¬ spects, all writers concur in holding that rob¬ bery, or forcible depredations upon the sea, animo furandi, is piracy. The same doctrine is held by all the great writers on maritime law, in terms that admit of no reasonable doubt.' The common law, too, recognizes and punishes piracy as an offense, not "against its own municipal code, but as an offense against the law of nations (which is part of tlie com¬ mon law), as an offense against the universal law of society, a pirate being deemed an enemy of the human race. Indeed, until the statute of 28th of Henry VIII., ch. 15, piracy was punishable in England only in the admiralty as a civil law offense; and that statute, in changing the jurisdiction, has been universally admitted not to have changed the nature of the offense.^ Sir Charles Hedges, in his charge at the admiralty sessions, in the case of Rex v. Dawson (5 State Trials), declared in emphatic 162] terms, that “ piracy is only a sea term for robbery, piracy being a robbery committed within the jurisdiction of the admiralty.” Sir Leoline Jenkins, too, on a like occasion, de¬ clared that “ a robbery, when committed upon the sea, is what we call piracy;” and he cited the civil law writers, in proof. And it is mani¬ fest from the language of Sir William Black- stone,® in his comments on piracy, that he considered the comrhon law definition as dis¬ tinguishable in no essential respect from that
1. — Santerna (lib. 4, note 50), for instance, says,
“• Inter piratam et latronem, non sit alia differentia, nisi quia pirati depredator est in mari et potest dici fur et latro inaris, quia latrocinluni et furtum sicuttitin terra, sic fit in mari.” And Emerig'on (1 Enierig. Assur. ch. 12, s. 29, p. 523) : “ La piraterie est un brigandage sur iner. Le Brigandage, sur terre est appelle vol ou rapine.” So Straccha “ Pu-atae sunt latrones maritimi.”
2. — Hawk. P. C. ch. 37, s. 2, 3 Inst. 112.
3. -4 Bl. Conun. 73.
4. — To show that piracy is deiined by the law of
nations, the following citations are believed to be sufficient.
Grotius (lib, .3, c. 3, s. 1,) says : “ Supra dicere in- cepimus justum bellum apud probos auctores dici saepe, non ex causa unde oritur, noque ut alias ex rerum gestarum magnitudine, sed ob peculiarea quosdam juris effectus. Quale autem sit hoc bel¬ lum optime Intelligitur ex hostium definitione apud liomanos jurisconsultos : Hostes sunt, qui nobis, aut quibus nos publiee bellum decernimus; cmteri latrones aut priudones sunt, ait Pomponius (Dig. Lib. 50, tit. 16, 1. 118), nec aliter Ulpianus, (Dig. lib. 49, tit. 15, 1. 24), hostes sunt, quibus bellum publiee populus Rornanust decrevi, vel ipsi populo Romano ; ea?teri latrunculi vel prmdones appel- lantur. Et ideo, qui dlatronibus captus est servus latronum non est, nec postliminium illi, necessa- rlum est. Ab hostibus autem captus ; puta d Ger- manis et Parthis et servus est hostium, et postlimi- nio statum pristinum recuperat. EtPaulus (Dig. lil>. 49, tit. 15, 1. 19, s. 2). A piratis aut latronibus capti liberi permanent. Accedat illud Ulpiani ; in civlli- bus dissentionibus quamvissmpe per eas respublica Imdatur, non tamen in exitium relpublicas eonten- ditur; qui in alterutras partes discedent, vice hos- tinm non sunt eorum, inter quos juracaptivitatum aut postliminiorum fuerint ; et ideo captos, et
Wheat. 5.
of the law of nations. So that, whether we advert to writers ou the common law, or the maritime law, or the law of nation.^, we .shall find that they universally treat of piracy a.s an offen.se against the law of nations, and that its true definition by that law is robbery upon the sea. And the general practice of all nation.s in punishing all persons, whether natives or for¬ eigners, who have committed this offen.se against any persona whatsoever, with whom they are in amity, is a conclusive proof that the offense is supposed to depend, not upon the particular provisions of any municipal code, but upon the law of nations, both for its definition and pun¬ ishment. We have, therefore, no he.sitation in declaring that piracy, by the law of nations, is robbery upon the sea, and that it is suflieiently and constitutionally defined by the fifth section of the act of 1819.
Another point has been made in this case, which is, that the special verdict does not con¬ tain sufficient facts upon which the court can pronounce that the*prisoner is guilty of
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
piracy. We are of a different opinion. The special verdict finds that the prisoner is guilty of the plunder and robbery charged in the in¬ dictment ; and finds certain additional facts from which it is most manifest that he and his associates were, at the time of committing the offense, freebooters upon the sea, not under the acknowledged authority, or deriving protec¬ tion from the flag or commission of any gov¬ ernment. If, under such circumstances, the offense be not piracy, it is difficult to conceive any which would more completely fit the defi¬ nition.
It is to be certified to the Circuit Court, that upon the facts stated, the case is piracy, as de¬ fined by the law of nations, so as to be punish¬ able under the act of Congress of the 3d of March. 1819.“*
v'enimdatos, posteaque mauumissos placuit super- vacuo repetere a priucipe ingen uitatem, quam nulla captivltate amlserant. (Dig, lib. 49, tit. 15, 1. 321, s. 2.”)
Grotius adds (s. 2) : “ Illud tantum notandum,sub exemplo populi Romani quemvls Intelligi, qui in civltate summum imperium habeat.”
Again, he says (s. 2), “ Non autem statim respub¬ lica aut civitas esse desinlt, si quid admittat injus- tum, etiam communiter; nec coetus piratarum aut latronum civitas est, etiamsi forte sequalitatem quandam inter se servent, sine cjua nullus coetus posset consistere. Nam hi oriminis causa socian- tur; illi etsi interdum delicto non vacant juris tamen fruendi causa sociati sunt, et exteris jusred- dunt, si non per omnia secundum jus naturm, quod multos apud populos ex-parte (juasi obliteratum alibi ostendimus, certe secundum pacta cum qui¬ bus que inita, aut secundum mores.”
Again, he says (s. 2) : “A latronibus captos capi- entium non tieri, supi-a dicentem audivinius Ulpi- anuin. Idem captos A Germanos ait libertatem amittere. Atqui apud Germanos latrocinia, qute extra ci vitatis cujusque tines tlebant, nullam habe- bant infamiani, <iuie verba sunt Caesarls, etc. Idam alibi Cattos nobilem Germanias populum latrocinia agitasse dicit. Apud eundem Gai’amantes latroci- niis facunda gens; sed gens tamen. Illyrici sine discrimine maris pi'oedas agere soliti ; delis tamen triumphus fuit; Pompeio de piratis non fuit. Tan¬ tum discrimen e.st inter populum quantumvis sce- loratuni et inter eos, qui, cum populus non sint, scalei'is causa coiunt.”
Again, he says (lib. 3, c. 9, s. 16) : “ Eae vexo res quffi intra presldia perductiu nondum sunt, quan- quam ab hostibus oocupatm, ideo postlimlnii non ogent, quia dominum nondum mutarunt, ex gen¬ tium jiu’e. Et qute piratm aut latrones nobis eri- puerunt non opus habent postliminis, ut Ulpianus et Javolenus responderunt ; quia jus gentium illis
59
164
Supreme Court of the United States.
1830
164J Mr. Justice Livingston dissented. In a case affecting life, no apology can be nec- 165 ] essary for expressing iny dissent from the opinion which has just been delivered.
1 66] The only question of any importance in this case is, whether the act of the 3d of 167] March, 1819, be a constitutional ex¬ ercise of the power delegated to Congress of 1 68] ‘ ‘defining and punishing piracies. ” The act declares, that any person who shall commit on the high seas the crime of piracy as defined 169] by the law of nations, shall be punish¬ ed with death. The special power here given
non concessit ut jus domini mutare possint, &c. Itaque res ab illis captie ubicunque reperiunter vindicaii possunt, nisi quod ex naturall jui’e alibi censulinus ei qui suo sumtu possessionem rei adep- tus est tantum esse reddendum, quantum dominus ipse ad rem recuperandam libenter impensurus fuerat.”
And (Id. s. 17), “Potest tamen lege clvili aliud constitui ; sicutl lege Hispanica naves a piratis captte eorum flunt, qui eas eripiunt piratis ; neque enim iniquum est, ut privata res publicae utilitati cedat, presertim in tanta recuperandi difficultate. Sed lex talis non obstabit exteris, quo minus res suas vindicent.”
Ag'ain, he says (lib. 2, c. 17, s. 20) : “ Ex neglectu tenuntur reges ac magistratus, qui adinhibenda latrocinia et piraticam non adhibeut ea quae pos¬ sunt ac debent remedia ; quo nomine damnati olim ab Amphictionlbus Scyrii. Quae potestatem pre- darum in marls ex hoste agendaruin per codleillos plurimis dedissent, et eorum nonnulll res amico- rum rapuissent, desertaque patriae inari vagaren- tur ac ne revocati quidem redlrent an rectores eo nomine tenerentur, aut quod malorum hoininum usiessent opera, aut quod cautionem non exigis- sent. Dlxl eos in nihil ampllus tenerl, quam ut noxios, si reperiri possent, punlrent, aut dederent ; praetere a in bona raptorum jus reddi curarent.”
Again, he says (Id. c. 18, s. 2, 3/ : “ Plratoe et la- trones qui civitatem non faciunt, jure gentium niti non possunt, &c. Sed interdum tales qui sunt jus legationis nanclscuntur fide data, ut olim fugi- tlvi in saltu Pyrenaeo.”
Again, (lib. 3, c. 13, s. 15) : “ Eepudiandus ergo Cicero (De Offlc. lib. 3, cap. 29), cum ait perjurium nullum esse predonibus pactum pro caplte pretium non adservatur, nec si juratum quidem sit ; quia pirata non sit ex perduellium numero desinitus, sed communis hostis omnium, eum quo nec tides esse debeat, nec jus jurandum commune, &c. At- que sicut in jure gentium constitute dift'ere hos- tem a pirata verum est, et a nobis infra ostendetur ; ita hie ea differentia locum habere non potest, pbi, etsl personae jus deficiat cum Deo negotium est; qua de causa juranientum voti nomine noncupa,- tur. Neque id quod sumit Cicero verum est, nul¬ lum esse cum praedone juris societatera. Nam de- positiim ex ipso gentium jure reddendum latroni, si dominus non apparet recte Tryphonlno respons- um est.”
These passages abundantly show the opinion of Grotius, that piracy by the law of nations is the same thing as piracy by the civil law ; and though he nowhere defines the crime, in precise terms, yet there seems to be no doubt as to what he under¬ stood to be comprehended in that crime. Piratae, latrones, prsedones, are used to denote the same class of offenders ; the first term being generally applied to robbers or plunderers on the sea, and the others to robbers or plunderers on land.
The terms are, indeed, convertible in many in¬ stances in the civil law. Thus, in the title, De Lege Khodia de Jactu (Dig. lib. 14, tit. 2, s. 3), it is said, “ Si navis a piratis redempta sit, Servius, Osilius, Labeo, omnes conferre debere alunt. Quod vero praedones abstulerint, cum perdere cujus fucrit, nec conferendum ei qui suas nierces redimerlt.”
Bynkershoek (Qutust. Jur. Pub. lib. c. 17), treat¬ ing on the subject of piracy, says, “ interest scire qui piratae ac latrones sunt, nam ab his capta do¬ minium non mutant necpie adeo postllminlo egent. Sic docet ratio ; sic auctorltas juris ini. 19, s. 2,1. 24 and 1. 27, de Capt. et Postliin, rev. (Dig. lib. 49, tit. 16), et sic ex pactis quarandam gentium supra probavi. Non est igitur ut addam auctoritates Grotil de Jure B. et. P. 1. 3, c. 9, s. 16. Alberici Gen- tilis de jure belli lib. 1, c. 4. Zoucheii de Jure feei-
60
to define piracy can be attributed *to
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
no other cause than to the uncertainty which it was known existed on this subject in the *law of nations, and which it must have
been the intention of the framers of the con¬ stitution to remove, *by conferring on
the national legislature the power which has been mentioned. It was well known to the *members of the Federal convention,
that in treatises on the law of nations, or in some of them at *least, detinitions of
r piracy might be found; but it must have been as well known to them that there *was
all, p. 2, s. 8, qu. 16, aliorumque plurium in eandem sententiam. Qui autem nullius principis auctori- tate sive marl sive terra, rapiunt, tiratarura prae- donumque vocabulo intelliguntur.”
Azuni (Part 2, c. 6, s. 3) says : “ .4 pirate is one who roves the sea in an armed vessel without any com¬ mission or passport from any prince or sovereign state, solel.y on his own authority, and for the pur¬ pose of seizing by force, and appropriating to him¬ self without discrimination, every vessel he may meet. For this reason pirates have always been compared to robbers. The only difference between them is, that the sea is the theatre of action for the one, and the land for the other.” Sec. 11. “Thus, as pirates are the enemies of the human race, piracy is justly regarded as a crime against the universal laws of society, and is everywhere punished with death. As they form no national body, as they have no right to arm, nor make war, and on ac¬ count of their indiscriminate xilunder of all vessels are considered only as public rf)bber8, every nation has a right to pursue, and exterminate them, with¬ out any declaration of war. For these reasons it is lawful to arrest them, in order that they may un¬ dergo the punishment merited by their crimes.” Sec. 12. “ Pirates having no right to make con¬ quests, cannot, therefore, acquire any lawful prop¬ erty in what they take ; tor the law of nations does not authorize them to deprive the true owner of his property, who always retains the right of re¬ claiming- it wherever it may be found. Thus, by the principles of common law, as well as the law of nature, at whatever perio^ or in whatever man¬ ner, things taken by a pirate may be recovered, they return again to their former owners, who lose none of their rights by such unjust usurpa¬ tion.” See Azumi, part. 2, c. 6, art. 3, p. 351, 361, Mr. Johnson’s translation.
Lord Bacon, in his dialogue De Bello Sacro, says : “ fndubitatum semxter fuit, bellum contra piratas juste geri posse per nationem quancumque, licet ab iis minime infestatum et laesam, &c., &c. Vera enim causa hujus rei haec est, ^uod piratfe com¬ munes humani generis hostes sint; quos idcirco omnibus nationibus persequi incumbit, non tarn propter metus proprios quam respectu foederis in¬ ter homines soelales. Sicut enim qumdam sunt feedera inscriptis et in tractatus redacta contra hostes particulares inita ; ita naturalis et tacita confeederatio inter omnes homines intercedit con¬ tra communes societatis humanm hostes.” (10 Bac. Works, 313, 314, edit. 1803.)
Martens, in his Essay on Privateers, Captures and Recaptures (e. 1, s. 1,) says ; “ L’armateur dltfere du Pirate (1), Le premier est muni d’une commission ou de lettres de marque dn souverain, dont le pi¬ rate est destitue. (2.) L’armateur suppose le cas d’une guerre (ou du moins celui de represailles), le pirate pille au seln de la isaix comme au milieu de la guerre. (3.) ^L’armateur s’oblige d’observer les ordonuances et les instructions qui lui ont 6te don- nees, et de n’attaquer qu’en consequence de celles ci de I’enneml, et oeux dcs valsseux neutres qui font un commerce illicite, le pirate pille indistlncte- ment les^vaisseiiux de toutes les nations, sans ob- sei-ver inline les loix de la guerre.”
Rutherforth (Inst. b. 2, c. 9, s. 9, p. 481), speaking- with reference to the law of nations, says : “ All wars of a nation against its external enemies are not public wars. To make a war a public one, both the contending parties must be public persons ; that is, it must be a war of one nation against an¬ other, &c. Where a nation makes war upon X)irate8 or other robbers, though those are external ene¬ mies, the war will be a mixed one : it is public on one side, because a nation or public xierson is one of the parties ; but it is private on the other side.
Wheat. 5.
1820
175
The United States v. Smith.
not such a coincidence on this subject as to render a reference to that code a desirable or 1 7 6] safe mode of proceedings in a criminal, and especially in a capital case. If it had been 1 7 7J intended to adopt the definition or de¬ finitions of this crime, so far as they were to be collected from the different commentators on 178] this code, with all the uncertainty and difficulty attending a research for that purpose, 1 7 9 I it might as well at once have been adopted as a standard by the constitution itself. 180] The object, therefore, of referring its definition to Congress was, and could have
because the parties on this side are private persons, who act togetlier occasionally, and are not united into a civil society. A band of robbers or a com¬ pany of pirates may in fact be united to one an- •other by compact, &c. Hut they are still, by tlie •law of nature, only a number of unconnected indi¬ viduals ; and consequently, in the view of the law of nations they ai’e not considered as a collective body or public pereou ; for the compact by which they unite thein8el%'es is void, because the matter of it is unlawful, &c., &c. The common benefit which a band of robbers or a company of pu-ates propose to themselves consists in doing harm to the rest of mankind.”
Woodeson (Lect. 34, vol. TI, 423); treating on capt¬ ures at sea, after stating that the law of nations is part of the laws of England, and that captures at .sea may happen either by pirates, or by way of re¬ prisal, or as prize of war, saj'S : “ Piracy, according to the law of nations, is incui'red by depredations on or near the sea, without authority from any prince or state.” He then quotes the opinion of yir Leoline Jenkins with approbation, that it is pi¬ racy, not only wlien a man robs without any com¬ mission at all, but when, having a commission, he ■despoils those with whom he is not wairanted to fight or meddle, such as are de leganiia vel amicitia ■of the prince or state which hath given him his ■commission. He then adds : “ But according to the judgments of our domestic tribunals, a bare as¬ sault without taking or pillaging something away does not constitute the crime, though Molloy pro¬ tends that by the law of nations it is otherwise. Yet it does not seem necessary that any person should be on board the pillaged vessel.” “ If these violations of property be perpetrated by any na¬ tional authorit.v, tliej' are the commencement of a public war ; if without that sanction, they are acts of piracy.” He then proceeds to state several cases which had arisen in the admiralty of England, and sums up his remarks as follow ; “ The foregoing particulars are the more deserving of considera¬ tion, because it seems agreed that when a ph-atical taking is ascertained, it becomes a clear and indis¬ putable consequence that there is no transmutation of property. No right to the spoil vests in the piratical captor : no ri;j-ht is derivable from them to any reoaptors in prejudice of the original own¬ ers. These piratical seizures being wholly unau¬ thorized, and highl.v criminal by the law of nations, is no pretense for devesting the dominion of the former proprietor. This principle, therefore, ‘ a pirutiif et hitronihm ca-pta d/imUiiiim non mutant,’ is the received opinion of ancient ci\'illans and more modern writers, on general jurisprudence. The same doctrine was maintained in our courts of common law long antecedent to the great cultiva¬ tion and improvements made in the science of the law of nations. And he remarks in a note, p. 427, note n : “ I ha\'e looked into the indictment
against Liike Ryan, tried at the admiralty sessions, March, 1782, for pirac.v, and who is alleged to have had a Dutch commission. He was indicted not for piracy generally by the law of nations, but foe tliat, being a natural born subject, he piratically, &c., against the form of the statute.” ITom the whole scope of Mr. Woodeson’s observations on the sub¬ ject of jiiracy, it is very clear that he considered piracy, as punishable by the law of the admlralt.v, to be no otlier than pirac.v b.v the law of nations. The definition of piracy, and Mr. Woodesnn's com¬ ments are cited with approbation by Mr. Gwillim in his late edition of Bacon’s Abridgment. 5 Bac. Abr. 310, edit. 1807, London.
Burlamaqui (Part. 2, c. 7, s. 41) says : “ Lastly, as to the wars of robbers and pirates, if they do not produce the elfocts above mentioned (transmuta-
Wheat. 5.
been no other than, to enable that body, to select from sources it might think proper, and then to declare, and with reasonable precision to define, what act or acts should constitute this crime ; and having done *so, to
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
annex to it such punishment as might be thought proper. Such a mode of proceeding W'ould be consonant with the universal practice in this country, and with those feelings of humanity which are ever opposed to the put¬ ting in jeopardy the life of a fellow-being, un¬ less for the contravention of a rule which has been previously prescribed, and in language so
tion of property on capture), nor give to those pi¬ rates a riglit of appropriating what they have taken, it is because they are robbers and enemies of mankind, and, consequently, peraons whose acts of violence are manifestly unjust, which authoi-izes all nations to treat them as enemies.”
Thus far, the authorities cited are such as profess to treat of piracy in terms according to the law of nations, the notion of which was manifestly de- nved from the civil law, “ on which,” as Sir William Scott observes (The Maria, 1 Rob. 340), “ great part of the law of nations is founded.” Indeed, in the law of England, it is treated altogether as a civil law offense, and referred to that law for its definition and punishment. Piracies and depredations at sea are capital offenses by the civil law. 5 Bac. Abr. Piracy, 311 ; Edit, uln supra, 3 Inst. 112 ; Hawk. P. C., c. 37 ; 2 East., P. C. 798 ; 4 Bl. Comm. 72. The commentaries of the common law writers on the subject of piracy will be more fully considered hereafter.
Let us now advert to the definition of the civil law and maritime writers.
In the Novels (Nov. 134, tit. 17, c. 13), it is declared : “ Pro furto autem nolumus omnlno quodlibet membrum abscindl, aut mori ; sed aliter eum cas- tigari. Fures autem vocamus qui occulte et sine armis hujusmodl delinquunt. Bos vero, qui vio- lonter aggrediuntur aut cum armis aut sino armis in domlbus aut itinerlbus aut in mart poenis eos legalibus subdi jubemus.”
Calvinus, in his Lexicon Juridicum, says : “ Pi- ratao dicuntur praedatores marini ; sic dioti vel a pirata, qui prius maria Infestavit, vel a Graeco •KF.pavu, id est, transeo, quod conspecta insula in illam transiront, jam praedaturi. Hinc piratica ars est, quam exercent,” In the French Code des Pri¬ ses (Edition of M. Dufriche Foulaines, Pai-is, 1804, tom. 1, 1). 8), the editor says : “ Le pirate est celui qui parcoiu't les mers avec une batiment arme sans commission ou jtatente d’aucune etat, dans la vue exclusive de s’approprler tous les navlres par la force. La piraterie est unassassinat ; tout puissance doitfaire arreter et juger des pareils brigands, eten purger la terre.” Emerigon (Assur. tom.l, c. 12, s. 28, p. 523), says : “ Les Pirates sent ceux qui courent les mers sans commission d’aucun Prince ni Etat souverain pour depreder les vaisseaux qu’ils ren- contrent.” “ Les Ennemis sont ceux, qui autorises par un prince, on etat souverain font la gueive dans la forme etablie par le droit des g'ens; an lieu (lue les Pirates sont de simples particuliers qui de- )redent le premier navire qu’ils recontrent.” “ Les lostilites se commettent de nation d nation ; an lieu quo la piraterie est un brigandage qui s’e.xerco sur mer par gens sans aveu, et d’une maniere fur¬ tive.” “ Les pli’ates sont ennemis du genre hu- main.” “ La piraterie, on le brigandage sur mer, est un debt centre la loi unlverselle des societies,” &c. And Emerigon fortifies his opinion on this subject, by citations from the civil law, from other maritime writers, and from Blackstone's Commen- ta»'ies. It is i)lain, therefore, that he considered piracy as defined in the civil law, the maritime law, and the common law of England, as the same crime.
Bouchard (cited in 1 Emerigon, c. 13, s. 28, p. .527) : “ Les pirates n’ont psis le droit des armes. Ce sont des voleurs et a.ssassins, qui ne forme pas un corps d’etat. Ennemis des toutes les nations eontre los- quelles ils exercent indistinctement lours brigand¬ ages, toutes les nations sont en droit de courir sus et de les exterminer sans declaration de guerre.”
M. Bonnemant, In his edition of the Chevalier De Habreu’s treatise on maritime captures (edit. 1802, Paris, part. 1, c. 1, s. 5, p. 15, note), says : “ Les pi-
61
181
Supreme Court op the United States.
1820
plain and explicit a.s not to be misunderstood by anyone. Can this be the case, or can a crime be said to be defined, even to a common intent, when those 'who are desirous of infor¬ mation on the subject are referred to a code, without knowing with any certainty where it is to be found, and from which even those to whom it may be accessible, can with difficulty decide, in many cases, whether a particular act be piracy or not? Although it cannot be de¬ nied that some writers on the law of nations do declare what acts are deemed piratical, yet it is certain that they do not all agree ; and if they
did, it would seem unreasonable to impose upon that class of men, who are the most liable to commit offenses of this description, the task of looking beyond the written law of their own country for a definition of them. If in criminal cases every thing is sufficiently certain, which by reference may be rendered so, which was an argument used at bar, it is not perceived why a reference to the laws of China, or to any other foreign code, would not have answered the purpose quite as well as the one which ha-s been resorted to. It is not certain, that on ex¬ amination, the crime would not be found to be
rates sont ceu.x dont la navigation, les actions et les entroprises ne sont antorisees ni avone6s par ancune puissance, qni agissent sur la propri6t6 publique et particuliere centre le voeu de toutos les nations.” And De Habreu himself {as translated by M. Bonnemant, parts, c. 6, s. 1, p. 100, 101), says: “Selonla definition de la prise, il paroit que le droit d’armer en course n’appartient qu k ceux qui sont ennemis auto¬ rises, apjielies, en Latin, hostes. D’ou il s’en- suit (Rie les brlgande et les pirates sont exclus de ce droit; qu’ils ne peuvent pretendre aux privile¬ ges que les loix de la guerre accorde aux ennemis, et qu’au contralre ils m6ritent d'etre punis rlgou- reusement comme les malfaiteurs, et qu’on est au- torls6 A se saislr de tous leurs biens.” “ De tous les terns les pirates ont et6 regardes comme des voleurs publics et des perturbateurs de la paix. C’est pour cela (lu’il est llbre A qulconque s’en salsit de leur 6ter la vie sans se rendre coupable d’injustice. La prejudice qu’ils causent li la tranquillite publique, a la llbertA du commerce, et A la suretA de la navi¬ gation, a fait que toutes les nations se sont accor- d6es A les poursuivre et A les punir avec la plus grande rigueur.”
Ferriere (Diet, du Droit, art. Pirates) says : “ Pi¬ rates sont des corsaires, ecumeurs de mer, qui font des courses sur mer sans aveu ni autoritO du Prince on du Souveraln.”
In the Encyclopedie des Sciences, &c. (Edit. 1765, art. Pirate), It is said: “On donne ce nom (Pirate) i des bandits, qui maitres d’une vaisseau vont sur mer attaquer les vaisseaux marchands pour les piller et les voler.”
VaUn (Traite des Prises, c. 3, s. 3, p. 39) says : “ Or la peine des pirates ou forbans est celle du dernier suppllce, suivant I’opinion commune ; pareeque ce sont des ennemis declarfe de la societe, des vio- lateurs de la foi publique et du droit des gens, des voleurs publiques A main arme et A force ouverte.”
Straccha (De Naut. Part. 3, n. 30) says: “Inter Piratam et Latronern nulla alia est differentia nisi quia Pirata depraedator est in mari.”
Casaregis (Disc. 64, n. 4) says : “ Proprie pirata ille discitur qui sine patentibus alien jus principls ex propria tantum et privata auctoritate per mare discurrlt depredendi causa.”
Dr. Brown (3 Civ. and Adm. Law, 461, 463) says: “Piracy is depredation without authority from any prince or state, or transgression of authority by despoiling beyond its warrant.” “Unlawful depredation is of the essence of piracy.”
Beawes (Le.x Mercatot ia art. Piracy, p. 3.50) says : “ A pirate is a sea thief, or an enemy of human kind, also aims at enriching himself by marine robberies committed either by force, fraud, or surprise, on merchants or other traders at sea.”
Molloy (b. 1, c. 4, s. 1) says : “ A pirate is a sea thief, or hontis humani generis, who, for to enrich himself either b.v surprise or open force, sets upon merchants or others trading at sea, ever spoiling their lading, if by possibility they can get the mastery.”
Marshall (Insur. c. 13, s. 11, p. .556) says ; "The crime of piracy or robbery on the high seas, is an offence against the universal law of society.”
It is also said in 16 Vlner’s Abridgment (art. Pirate and Piracy, A. p. ,558), and in Cowell’s Inter¬ preter (Pirate) : “ A pirate is now taken for one who maintains himself by pillage and robbery at sea.”
Comyns (Dig. Admiralty, E. 3) defines piracy thus: “Piracy is when a man commits robbery upon the sea;” and he cites as authority, 3 Inst. 113, and 1 Sir Leol, Jenk. 94.
Lord Coke (3 Inst. 113; Co. Litt. 891) says : “This word pirate, in Latin, pirata, from the Greek word
t>2
TTseparj^g, which again comes from irecpav as trans- cendo mare, of roving upon the sea ; and therefore, in English, is called a rover and robber upon the sea.”
SirLeolineJenkins, in his charge at the admiralty sessions in 1668, says : “You are, therefore, to in¬ quire of all pirates and sea rovers, they are in the law hostes humani generis, enemies, not of one na¬ tion, or of one sort of people only, but of all man¬ kind. They are outlawed as I may say, by the laws of all nations ; that is, out of the iirotectlon of all pi’inces, and of all laws whatsoever. Everybody IS commissioned, and is to be armed against them as rebels and traitoi's to subdue and root them out. That which is called robbing upon the highway, the same being done upon the water, is called pii’acy. Now, robbery as it is distinguished from thieving or larceny, implies not only the actual taking away of my goods, while I am, as we say, in peace, but, also, the putting me in fear by taking them by force and arms, out of my hands, or in my sight and presence. When this is done upon the sea, with¬ out a lawful commission of war or reprisals, it is downright piracy.” Vol. I., p. 86.
Again, in another'charge, he says (Vol. I., p. 94): “ The next sort of offenses pointed at in the statute 38 Hen. VIII., ch. 15, are robbei’ies; and a robbery, when it is committed upon the sea, is what we call pii’acy. A robber.v, when it is committed upon the land, does imply] three things: 1. That there be a violent assault. 3. That a man’s goods be actually taken from his person or possession. 3. That he who is despoiled be put in fear thereby. When this is done upon the sea, when one or more iiei’sons enter on board a ship with force and anns, and those in the ship have their ship carried away by violence, or their g-oods taken awa.v out of their possession, and are put in fright b.v the assault, this is piracy ; and he that does so is a pirate or a robber within the statute.”
The statute of Henry VIII. here referred to, does not contain any description of piracy. Before that statute, piracy was only cognizable b.v the civil law in the Admiralty Court. But the statute gave the High Commission Court (created by that statute) jurisdiction of “ all treasons, felonies, robberies, murder, and confederacies committed in, or on the sea,” &c. The term piracy is not found in the stat¬ ute, and it is only as a robbery upon the sea that the High Commission Court has jurisdiction of piracy. Sir Leoline Jenkins, therefore, refers to the civil law definition of the offense of piracy; for it is agreed on all sides that the statute of Henry Vlll. has not altered the nature of the offense. (See I Hawk. P. C. b. 1, c. 37.)
Targa (asl find him quoted .by his Spanish trans¬ lator, Gison, Reflex., c. 61 ; De los Corsarios o Pyra- tas, tor the original is not before me) says: “Esta (depredacion) so comete de dos modos, o por causa de guerra declarada entre dos naciones, &c., o por iiiodo de hurto vloleuto como Ladrones del Mar y como hacen los robos en terra los salteadores de caminos ; y esto se conipuela con la authentica del Derecho Civil, (*) que distingue la pyrateria del robo,” &c. Again: “A los pyratas como tambien a los salteadores de camino, eneinigos comunes, opresores de la libertad y comercio, y como a vloladores del derecho de las gentes, puede, qual- quiera oponerse y los ministrosy subditosdel prin- cipe pueden perseguir los y prender los aunque sea tuera del.doinlnio y se liayan refugiado a los estados conflnante.a, sin que per esso quede violada la juris- diceion ; y presas que sean, se pendran en poder de la justicia de aquel Prmcipe en cuyo estado han
*Dig. lib. 49, tit. 15, 1. 19, s. 3.
Wheat. 5.
1820
The Ijnited States v. Saitth.
181
more accurately defined in the code thus re¬ ferred to than in any writer on the law of 182] nations; but the objection to the refer¬ ence in both cases is the same; that it is the duty of Congress to incorporate into tlieir own statutes a definition in terms, and not to refer the citizens of the United States for rules of conduct to the statutes or laws of any foreign country, with which it is not to be presumed that they are acquainted. Xor does it make any difference in this case that the law of na¬ tions forms part of the law of every civilized country. This may be the case to a certain
extent; but as to criminal cases, and as to the offense of piracy in particular, the law of na¬ tions coidcl not be supposed of itself to form a rule of action; and, therefore, a reference to it in this instance, nm.st be regarded in the same light as a reference to any other foreign code. But, it is said that murder and robt)ery liave been declared to be punishable by tlie laws of the United States, without anj" definition of what act or acts shall con.stitute eitlier of these offenses. This may be; but both murder and robbery, with arson, burglary, and some other crimes, are defined by writers on tlie common
sido cogidos.” Again; “ Y assi concluyo, diciendo, que deben todos giiardarse en el mar de PjTataa, y en latierra de Ladrones ; y todo aquel, ^iiue en el mar, playa, Puerto, 6 otro seno de mar, 6 rio nav'i- gable, roba o apresa, j a sea amigo, esto es, enemigo no deolarado, y tambieu los pa.vsanos, 6 ouemigos propriamente tales, 6 con paten te, estandarte, 6 sin el, 6 con engano, 6 t'uerza, siempre es pyrata.”
Citations from civilians and maritime writers to the same effect mig-ht he multiplied ; but they would unnecessarily swell this note, it remains only to notice the doctrines which have been held by the tribunals of Great lirltain, and asserted by her common law writers on the subject of piracy.
Hawkins (P. C. b. 1, c. 3") says : “ A pirate at the common law is a person who commits any of tliose acts of pirac.v, robbery and depredation upon the high seas, which, if committed upon land, would have amounted to felony there.”
From the terms of this definition (if it may be so called), it might be sui)posed, that by piracy at the common law, something was meant ]ieculiar to that iaw, and not piracy by the civil law, or the law of nations. But that was certalnl.y not the mean¬ ing of the writer. For it is perfectly well settled that piracy is no felony at common law, being out of its jurisdiction ; and before the statute of 38 Henry VIII., c. 15, it was only punishalile bj' the civil law. That statute, however, does not (as has been alread.v stated) alter the nature of the offense in this respect ; and, therefore, a pardon of all felonies generally does not extend to it. 3 East’s P. C. 796; 1 Hawk. c. 37, s. 6, 8, 10 ; 1 Hale, 3.51; 2 Hale, 18; 3 Inst. 112. And it was also determined in Hex V. Morphes (Salk. 85), that “no attainder for piracy wrought eorrui)tion of blood, for it was no offense at common law. 2 East’s P. C. 796: Co. Litt. 391, a. The Intention of Hawkins must have been to use the phrase “at the common law ” in its most comprehensive sense ; in which sense the law of nations itself is a ])art of the common law ; since all offenses against the law of nations are punish¬ able by the criminal jurisprudence of England.
Blackstone, in the Commentaries (4 Comm. 71, 73), evidently proceeds upon this notion. He says :
“ The crime of pirac.y, or robber.\- and dei)redation upon the high seas, is an offense against the uni¬ versal law of society, a pirate being, according to Sir Edward Coke, humaiii generis.” He goes
on to remark, that every community hath a right to punish it, for it is a war against all mankind. He then gives the definition of iiiracj' Ity Hawkins, as the definition of the common law: and then states the several statutes made in England on the sub¬ ject of piracy, concluding thus: “These are the principal cases in which the statute law of Eng¬ land interposes to aid and inforce the law of na¬ tions as a part of the common law, by Intiiotlng an adequate punishment for offenses again.st that uni¬ versal law committed by private persons.”
The state trials for piracy in the reign of William III. are entitled to the great consideration, both from the eminent talents of the judges who con¬ stituted the tribunal and the universal approba¬ tion of the legal principles asserted by them. It is also worth.v of aemark, that in none of these indict¬ ments was there any averment that the lu’isoners were British subjects; and most of them were for piracies committed on foreign .subjects and vessels. They were all framed as indictments at common' law, or for general piracy, without reference to any British .statute.
tn Hex V. Dawson and others (8 William III. 1696; 5 State Trials, 1 edit. 1742), the court was composed of Sir Charles Hedges, Judge of the High Court of Admiralty (as in-esident), Ijord Chief Justice Holt, Lord Chief Justice Treby, Lord Chief Baron Ward, i
Wheat. 5.
Mr. Justice Rookby, Mr. Justice Turton, Mr. Ju.stice Byre, Mr. Baron Powis, and Doctors Lane, King, and Cook (civilians). Sir Charles Hodges delivered the charge to the grand jury, and among other things, directed them as follows: “ Now, piracy is only a sea term for robbery, piracy being a rob¬ bery committed within the jurisdiction of the ad- niiralty. If any man be assaulted within that juris¬ diction, and his ship or goods violently taken away without legal authority, this is robbery and piracy. If the mariners of a ship shall violently dispossess the master,and afterwards carryaway the ship itself, or any of the goods, or takle, apparel or furniture, with a felonious iutention, in any place where the Lord Admiral hath, ori)retenda to have, jurisdiction, this is also robbery and piracy. The in¬ tention will, in these cases, appear, by considering the end tor which the fact is committed, and the end will be known, if the evidence show you what hath been done. The King of England hath not only an empire or sovereignty over the British seas for the i)unishment of piracy, but in concurrence wii h other princes and states, an undoubted juris¬ diction and power in the most remote parts of the world. If any person, therefore, native or foreigner, Christian or Infidel, Turk or Pagan, with whose country we are in amity, trade or correspondence, shall be robbed or spoiled, in the narrow or other seas, whether the Mediterranean, Atlantic, or Southern, or any branches thereof, either on this or the other side of the line, it is a piracy, within the limits of your inquiry, and cognizable by this court.” It seems impossible to doubt that Sir Charles Hedges here understood piracy to be pun¬ ishable by all nations, as a crime against the law' of nations, and that its true definition is the same in the civil and common law as in the law' of nations, v'iz., robbery upon the seas ; and that, as such, it was punishable b.v the British courts in virtue of their general concurrent jurisdiction on the seas.
In Rex V. Dawson and others, there wei’e several indictments. 1. The first was for pirac.v in robbing and plundering the ship Gunsway, belonging to the Great Mogul and his subjects, in the Indian seas.
2. The second for pirao , in forcibly seizing and
feloniously taking, stealing, and carrying away a merchant ship called the Charles II., belonging to certain of His Majesty’s subjects unknown, on the high seas, about three leagues from the Gro.vne in Spain. 3. The third was for piracy on two Danish ships. 4. The fourth for (liracy on a Moorish ship. Dawson pleaded guilty, and the other prisoners not guilty, and were upon trial convicted, and all sen¬ tenced to death accordingly. It ajipeared in evi¬ dence that the prisoners were part of the crew of the Charles the II., and rose upon her near the Groyne, and afterwards ran away with her, and committed the piracies. The Solicitor-General, in stating the case to the jur.y, said: “The^ (the prisoners) are arraigned for a very high crime, a robbery upon the seas. These are crimes against the law of nations, and worse than robbery on land.” Lord Chief Justice Holt, in delivering the charge to the jury, said : “That there was a piracy committed on the ship Charles is most apiiarent by the evidence that hath been given ; that is, a force was put uimn the master, and some of the seaman on hoard her, who, because they would not agree to go on a piratical expedition, had liberty to depart and be set ashore, &c.. &c. So that I must tell you beyond all contradiction, the force put upon the captain, and taking away this ship, called the Charles II., is piracy.”
On the trial of Kidd and others for piracy, &c., in 13 of William III., 1713 (5 State Trials, edit. 1742), there were several indictments. 1. The first w'as I against AVilliam Kidd for the murder of one W.
63
183
Supreme Court of the United States,
1830
law, wliich is part of the law of every state in the Union, of which, for the most obvious rea¬ sons, no one is allowed to allege his ignorance in excuse for any crime lie may commit. Nor is there any hardship in this, for tlie great body of the community have it in their power to be¬ come acquainted with the criminal code under which they live; not so wlien acts which con¬ stitute a crime are to be collected from a variety of writers, either in different languages or un¬ der the disadvantage of translations, and from a code with whose provisions even professional 183J men are not always acquainted. By the same clause of the constitution. Congress have power to punish offenses against the law of nations, and yet it would hardly be deemed a fair and legitimate execution of this authority to declare that all offenses against the law of nations, without defining any one of them, should be punished with death. Such mode of legislation is but badly calculated to furnish that precise and accurate information in crim¬ inal cases, which it is the duty, and ought to be the object, of every legislature to impart.
Upon the whole, my opinion is, that there is not to be found in the act that definition of piracy which the constitution requires, and that, therefore, judgment on the special verdict ought to be rendered for the prisoner.
Certificate. — This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of the record of the Circuit Court of the United States for the dis¬ trict of Virginia, and on the question on which the judges of that court w'ere divided in opin¬ ion, and was argued by counsel. On consid¬ eration whereof, this court is of opinion that the offense charged in the indictment in this case, and found by the jury to have been com¬ mitted by the prisoner, amounts to the crime of piracy, as defined by the law of nations, so as to be punishable under the act of Congress, entitled, “an act to protect the commerce of the United ' States, and punish the crime of piracy.” All which is ordered to be certified to the Circuit Court for the district of Virginia. ’
Cited.— 9 How. 5T2 ; 2 Cliff. 416, 420 ; 1 Wood. & M. 438, 446, 461, 474.
1. — Vide Appendix, Note IV., for the new act of
Congress on the subject of piracy, passed May 15,
1820.
Moore, on the high seas, near the coast of Malabar, in avessel called the Adventure Galley, of which Kidd was commander. 2. The second was against all the prisoners for piracy in seizing and running away with a certain merchant ship called the Quedash Merchant, then being a ship of certain persons to the jurors unknown (notstated to be British sub¬ jects), upon the high seas about ten leagues from Cutshwen in th<f East Indies. In fact, the vessel and cargo appeared by the evidence to belong to A rme- nian merchants, and then on a voyage from Bengal to Surat. Lord Chief Baron Ward, in charging the jury on this indictment, said, “ the crime charged upon them (the prisoners) is piracy: that is, seizing and takinij' this ship and the goods in it piratically and feioniously. This ship belonged to people in amity with the King of England.” “ If this was a capture on the high seas, and these were the goods of persons in amity with the King, and had no French pass, then it is a plain piracy; and if you believe the witnesses, here is the taking of' the goods and ship of persons in amity, and converting them to their own use. Such a taking as this would be felony; and being at sea, it will be piracy.” The prisoners were convicted and sentenced to death. There were four other indictments, three for piracy on Moorish ships, and one tor piracy on a Portugese ship ; and all the prisoners were con¬ victed and sentenced. Mr. J ustice Turton, in
64
^[Constitutional Law, and Law of
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
Nations.]