Hope Ins. Co. of Providence v. Boardman, 9 U.S. (5 Cranch) 58 (1809)

Case details
Bluebook Citation
Hope Ins. Co. of Providence v. Boardman, 9 U.S. (5 Cranch) 58 (1809)
Full caption
THE HOPE INSURANCE COMPANY OF PROVIDENCE v. BOARDMAN, et al
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
1809
THE HOPE INSURANCE COMPANY OF PROVIDENCE v.
BOARDMAN, et al.
A corporation aggregate cannot be a citizen— and cannot litigate in the courts of the United States, unless in consequence of the character of the indi¬ viduals who compose the body politic, which char¬ acter must appear by proper averments upon the record.
•
ERROR to the Circuit Court for the District of Rhode Island, in an action upon a policy of insurance.
36
City of Wheeling v. Mayor of Baltimore, 1 Hugh, 90 ; Minor v. Phil. K. Co. 3 Abb., U. 8., 323.
In the case of a mere collective body, associated by voluntary articles, a joint stock association, the presumption that all its members are citizens of the state does not arise, and if it be not alleged in the bill that it is a corporation, or that the members thereof are citizens of the state, a demurrer will be sustained.
Dinsmore v. Phil. & Co., 1 L. & Eq. Reporter, 351.
A corporation that has appeared and answered generally cannot insist upon want of jurisdiction on the ground that it is not an inhabitant of the district.
A corporation created by the laws of a state, is, in suits in a federal court of that state, to be con¬ sidered a citizen of such state, whatever its citizen¬ ship in other states may be by legislation of those states.
Cranch 5.
1809 The Hope Insurance Company of Providence v. Boardman, et al. 58
aggregate from the federal courts. For if a
yet the subsequent decisions are all founded upon that case. The effect of that decision has been to exclude many cases upon nice questions of pleading, which would otherwise have been clearly within the jurisdiction of the courts of the United States. Ho exception was taken to the jurisdiction in thecourt below' ; and this court would not willingly turn us out of court, after encountering all the risk, expense, delay and labor of a jury trial, upon an exception, which, if taken in the first instance, might have pre¬ vented all that risk, expense and delay. In the case of Abercrombie v. Dupuis (ante, vol. 1, p. 343), the present Chief Justice (Marshall) inti¬ mated a doubt how the question would then have been decided if it were a new' case, and if the court was not bound by the case of Bingham v. Cabot. This doubt shows that the court was not then inclined to extend the principle farther than that case warrants. At the time the court de¬ cided the case of Bingham v. Cabot, the juris¬ diction of the courts of the United States w'as an object of jealousy, and there was probably a desire on the part of the court to remove all ground of suspicion, by deciding doubtful cases against the jurisdiction. This circumstance probably induced them to be over scrupulous 59*] upon that ^subject. But it is as much the duty of this court to exercise jurisdiction in cases w'here it is given by the constitution and laws of the United States, as to refuse to assume it where it is not given.
The person who drew the declaration in the present case seems to have been aware of the decision in the case of Bingham v. Cabot, and to have intended to describe the parties in such a manner as to give the court jurisdiction. The defendant is described as “a company legally incorporated by the legislature of the State of Rhode Island and Providence Plantations, and established at Providence in the said district.”
The term citizen could not with propriety be applied to a corporation aggregate. It could only be a citizen by intendment of law. It is only a moral person; but it may be a citizen quoad hoc, i. e., in the sense in which the term citizen is used in that part of the constitution w'hich speaks of the jurisdiction of the judicial power of the United States. The term is indeterminate in its signification. It has different meanings in different parts of the constitution. When it says “ the citizens of each state shall be' entitled to all privileges and immunities of citizens in the several states,” the term citizens has a meaning different from^that in which it is used in de¬ scribing the jurisdiction of the courts.
To say that all the individual members of a body corporate must be citizens of a certain de¬ scription, destroys the idea of a body politic. It is the body politic, the moral person, that sues, and not the individuals who compose the cor¬ poration. Its powers, its duties and capacities are different from those of the individuals of whom it is composed. It can neither derive benefit from the privileges, nor suffer injury by the incapacities, of any of those individuals.
Thus the infancy of any or even of all the members of a body corporate does not affect the validity of its acts. Nor does the alienage of GO*] the members ^prevent the body politic from holding lands. A majority of the members of the Bank of the United States are aliens.
The objection goes to exclude all corporations
Cranch 5.
corporation cannot be a citizen it cannot be an alien. And as the individual members are con¬ stantly changing by the transfer of stock, it is impossible to ascertain at any precise moment who are the individuals who constitute the cor¬ porate body; and itVould at any time be in the power of a corporation defendant to evade the jurisdiction of the court, by taking in a new member wdio should be of the same state with the plaintiff.
At all events it is an objection which ought to be pleaded in abatement according to the course of the common law, so that the plaintiff may have a better declaration; and by that means much expense, time and labor would be saved.
The reason of giving jurisdiction to the courts of the United States in cases between citizens of different states, applies with the greatest force to the case of a powerful moneyed cor¬ poration erected within, and under the laws of a particular state. If there was a probability that an individual citizen of a state could in¬ fluence the state courts in his favor, how much stronger is the probability that they could be influenced in favor of a powerful moneyed in¬ stitution which might be composed of the most influential characters in the state. What chance for justice could a plaintiff have against such a powerful association in the courts of a small state whose judges perhaps were annually elected, or held their offices at the will of the legislature?
If the jurisdiction of the federal courts is limited by the letter of the constitution, they have no jurisdiction in a case between a citizen of one state and a citizen of another state ; be¬ cause the constitution speaks of citizens, in the plural, so that there must *be more
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
(no text on this page in the source reporter)
than one plaintiff, and more than one defend¬ ant. So also there could be no jurisdiction i f one of the parties was a woman, because a wo¬ man cannot be a citizen ; which is a term ap¬ plicable only to a male.
It is not necessary that a person should be a citizen to commit treason : it may be committed by an alien.
Judge Jay, as an argument in favor of the suability of the states, urged that a corporation could undoubtedly be sued in the courts of the United States.1
The Court having, in the case of The Bank of the United States v. Deveaux el al., decided that the right of a corporation to litigate in the courts of the United States depended upon the character (as to citizenship) of the members which compose the body corporate, and that a body corporate as such cannot be a citizen, within the meaning of the constitution, re¬ versed the judgment, for want of jurisdiction in the court below.
Cited— 2 How. 23; 16 How. 318,350; 18 How. 348; 18 How. 361; 20 How. 233; 3 Sum. 473; 4 Biss. 126; 4 Wash. 597; Hemp. 424, 425.
1.— A similar question of jurisdiction being- in¬ volved in the case of The' Bank of the United States v. Deveaux et al., and the .counsel in that ease ex¬ pressing- a wish to be heard before this case should be decided, the court agreed to hear both cases at the same time ; the further arguments in this case were consequently blended with those in the other.
37
01 Supreme Court of the
THE BANK OF
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access