Law of Hybrid Securities, 23 Wash. U. L.Q. 182 (1938)

23 Wash. U. L.Q. 182
US-DOC-24852409
locator
Publication details
Country
United States
Journal
Washington University Law Quarterly
Volume
23
182 WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY LAW QUARTERLY [Vol. 23
THE LAW OF HYBRID SECURITIES
RUDOLF E. UHLMANt
The distinction between corporate creditors and stockholders is as old as the law of corporations itself. Although the principle of the limited liability of stockholders is of comparatively recent origin,' it has been recognized at all times that stockholders are members of the corporation, while corporate creditors are strangers to the corporate entity.2This is also true as to those creditors of the company who belong to the class of bondholders. They are investors in the corporate business like the stockholders, but their status is fundamentally different from that of members of the company. They do not share in the profits or losses of the company and have no part in the control or management of the corporation. Because of this difference in the status of bondholders and stockholders, certificates evidencing contributions to the corporate capital are of an essentially different nature depending on whether they constitute bond or stock certificates. If the certificate is a bond certificate, it represents an obligation of the corporation to pay a fixed sum with stated interest. If it is a stock certificate, it confers upon the holder a part ownership of the corporate assets and a right to participate in the surplus profits of the corporation and, on its dissolution, in the assets remaining after payment of the creditors.3
This distinction between stockholders and bondholders, simple and clear-cut as it was originally, has been obscured by virtue of the expansion of corporate financing during the last half century. The dispersion of stock ownership in the large corporations which was followed by the concentration of corporate control in the hands of minority groups has changed the position of the small stockholders in such corporations. Although remaining stockholders in name, they have surrendered many of their prerogatives as members of the corporation and have nearly ap-
f Research Fellow, Harvard Law School. J. U. D. (Tuebingen 1933), LL.B. (Cornell 1936).
1. Williston, History of the Law of Business Corporations Before 1800 (1888) 2 Earv. L. Rev. 149, 160.
2. Ber, The Vanishing Distinction Between Creditors and Stockholders (1928) 76 U. Pa. L. Rev. 814, 815.
3. Stevens, Corporations (1936) 362. proached the status of mere lenders of money. On the other hand, investors who purchase long-term bonds are just as intimately connected with the corporate business as the stockholders. "Interest return and ultimate payment of their money turn just as surely on the fidelity and business integrity of the management as do dividends and ultimate liquidation for stockholders."14Thus, the distinction between stockholders and bondholders, important as it is in theory, has lost much of its economical significance.
In legal theory the bondholder lends money to an enter-
Reproduced in limited form, for citation verification only. This work is protected by copyright, so only its first page appears here. For the full text, see the original publication.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access