Erickson v. Pardus, 551 U.S. 89 (2007)
Case details
Bluebook Citation
Erickson v. Pardus, 551 U.S. 89 (2007)
Full caption
ERICKSON v. PARDUS et al.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
June 4, 2007
ERICKSON v. PARDUS et al.
on petition for writ of certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the tenth circuit
No. 06–7317. Decided June 4, 2007
Petitioner filed suit alleging that respondents, Colorado prison officials, violated the Eighth Amendment when they terminated his hepatitis C treatment program, with life-threatening consequences. The District Court granted respondents’ motion to dismiss, and the Tenth Circuit affirmed, holding that petitioner’s allegations were too conclusory to es tablish for pleading purposes that he had suffered a cognizable inde pendent harm from the termination.
Held: Petitioner’s case cannot be dismissed on the ground that his harm allegations were too conclusory to put these matters in issue. The com plaint—which contains allegations that the decision to remove petitioner from his medication endangered his life, that the medication was with held shortly after he had commenced a 1-year treatment program, that he still needed the treatment, and that the prison officials were refusing it—was enough to satisfy Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8(a)(2), which requires only “a short and plain statement of the claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief.” Petitioner, in addition, bolstered his claim with more specific allegations in documents attached to the complaint and in later filings. The Tenth Circuit’s departure from Rule 8(a)(2)’s liberal pleading requirements is especially pronounced here, where peti tioner has been proceeding, from the litigation’s outset, without counsel. Whether the complaint is sufficient in all respects is yet to be deter mined, for respondents have raised multiple arguments in their motion to dismiss.
Certiorari granted; 198 Fed. Appx. 694, vacated and remanded.
Per Curiam.
Imprisoned by the State of Colorado and alleging viola tions of his Eighth and Fourteenth Amendment protections against cruel and unusual punishment, William Erickson, the petitioner in this Court, filed suit against prison officials in the United States District Court for the District of Colorado. He alleged that a liver condition resulting from hepatitis C required a treatment program that officials had commenced
Per Curiam
but then wrongfully terminated, with life-threatening conse quences. Deeming these allegations, and others to be noted, to be “conclusory,” the Court of Appeals for the Tenth Cir cuit affirmed the District Court’s dismissal of petitioner’s complaint. 198 Fed. Appx. 694, 698 (2006). The holding de parts in so stark a manner from the pleading standard man dated by the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure that we grant review. We vacate the court’s judgment and remand the case for further consideration.
Petitioner was incarcerated in the Limon Correctional Fa cility in Limon, Colorado, where respondents Barry Pardus and Dr. Anita Bloor were working as prison officials. After Dr. Bloor removed petitioner from the hepatitis C treatment he had been receiving, petitioner sued under Rev. Stat. § 1979, 42 U. S. C. § 1983, complaining, inter alia, that Dr. Bloor had violated his Eighth Amendment rights by demonstrating deliberate indifference to his serious medical needs. See, e. g., Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U. S. 97, 104–105 (1976) (“[D]eliberate indifference to serious medical needs of prisoners constitutes the unnecessary and wanton infliction of pain . . . proscribed by the Eighth Amendment,” and this includes “indifference . . . manifested by prison doctors in their response to the prisoner’s needs or by prison guards in intentionally denying or delaying access to medical care or intentionally interfering with the treatment once pre scribed” (footnotes and internal quotation marks omitted)); see also Helling v. McKinney, 509 U. S. 25, 35–37 (1993).
Petitioner based his claim on the following allegations, which we assume to be true for purposes of review here: Officials at Colorado’s Department of Corrections (De partment) diagnosed petitioner as requiring treatment for hepatitis C. After completing the necessary classes and otherwise complying with the protocols set forth by the Department, petitioner began treatment for the disease. The treatment, which would take a year to complete, in volved weekly self-injections of medication by use of a sy
Per Curiam
ringe. Soon after petitioner began this treatment, prison officials were unable to account for one of the syringes made available to petitioner (and other prisoners) for medical purposes. Upon searching, they found it in a communal trash can, modified in a manner suggestive of use for injec tion of illegal drugs. Prisoner Complaint in Civ. Action No. 05–CV–00405–LTB–MJW (D. Colo.), p. 3 (hereinafter Petitioner’s Complaint).
Prison officials, disbelieving petitioner’s claim not to have taken the syringe, found that his conduct constituted a vio lation of the Colorado Code of Penal Discipline for possession of drug paraphernalia. Letter from Anthony A. DeCesaro to William Erickson (Sept. 30, 2004), attached to Petitioner’s Complaint. This conduct, according to the officials, led to the “reasonable inference” that petitioner had intended to use drugs, so the officials removed petitioner from his hepati tis C treatment. Ibid. “The successful treatment of Hepa titis C is incumbent upon the individual remaining drug and alcohol free to give the liver a better chance of recovery,” they indicated, ibid., an explanation they later offered to de fend against petitioner’s allegations of cruel and unusual punishment, see Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss in Civ. Ac tion No. 05–CV–00405–LTB–MJW, p. 10. Assuming that a person in the course of this treatment takes illicit drugs, the prison’s protocol mandates a waiting period of one year followed by a mandatory drug education class lasting six months. Brief in Opposition 4. Petitioner therefore could face a delay of some 18 months before he would be able to restart treatment.
In his complaint petitioner alleged Dr. Bloor had “removed [him] from [his] hepatitis C treatment” in violation of Depart ment protocol, “thus endangering [his] life.” Petitioner’s Complaint 2. Petitioner attached to the complaint certain grievance forms. In these he claimed, among other things, he was suffering from “continued damage to [his] liver” as a result of the nontreatment. Colorado Dept. of Corrections
Per Curiam
Offender Grievance Form (June 30, 2004). The complaint requested relief including damages and an injunction requir ing that the Department treat petitioner for hepatitis C “under the standards of the treatment [protocol] established by [the Department].” Petitioner’s Complaint 8.
Three months after filing his complaint, and well before the District Court entered a judgment against him, peti tioner filed a Motion for Expedited Review Due to Imminent Danger in Civ. Action No. 05–B–405 (MJW) (D. Colo.). Indi cating it was “undisputed” that he had hepatitis C, that he met the Department’s standards for treatment of the disease, and that “furtherance of this disease can cause irreversible damage to [his] liver and possible death,” petitioner alleged that “numerous inmates” in his prison community had died of the disease and that he was “in imminent danger” himself “due to [the Department’s] refusal to treat him.” Ibid. He had identified similar allegations in an earlier filing, explain ing that “his liver is suffering irreversible damage” due to the decision to remove him from treatment and that he “will suffer irreparable damage if his disease goes untreated.” Plaintiff ’s Objections to the Magistrate’s Recommendations in Civ. Action No. 05–CV–00405–LTB–MJW (Feb. 27, 2005), p. 3.
Respondents answered these filings with a motion to dis miss. The Magistrate Judge recommended, as relevant, that the District Court dismiss the complaint on the ground it failed to allege Dr. Bloor’s actions had caused petitioner “substantial harm.” Recommendation on Defendants’ Mo tion to Dismiss (Feb. 9, 2006), p. 12. The District Court issued a short order indicating its agreement with the Mag istrate Judge and dismissing the complaint.
The Court of Appeals affirmed. It quoted extensively from the Magistrate Judge’s discussion of “substantial harm” before holding that petitioner had made “only conclusory allegations to the effect that he has suffered a cognizable independent harm as a result of his removal from the [hep
Per Curiam
atitis C] treatment program.” 198 Fed. Appx., at 698. Ac knowledging decisions by courts that have found Eighth Amendment violations when delays in medical treatment have involved “life-threatening situations and instances in which it is apparent that delay would exacerbate the prison er’s medical problems” (and that have, moreover, indicated the Eighth Amendment “protects against future harm to an inmate”), id., at 697 (internal quotation marks omitted), the court nevertheless found petitioner’s complaint deficient: Petitioner had, according to the court, failed to “allege that as a result of the discontinuance of the treatment itself shortly after it began or the interruption of treatment for approximately eighteen months he suffered any harm, let alone substantial harm, [other] than what he already faced from the Hepatitis C itself,” id., at 698 (internal quotation marks omitted). Having reached this conclusion, the court saw no need to address whether the complaint alleged facts sufficient to support a finding that Dr. Bloor had made her decisions with a “sufficiently culpable state of mind.” Id., at 697, 698 (internal quotation marks omitted).
It may in the final analysis be shown that the District Court was correct to grant respondents’ motion to dismiss. That is not the issue here, however. It was error for the Court of Appeals to conclude that the allegations in question, concerning harm caused petitioner by the termination of his medication, were too conclusory to establish for pleading purposes that petitioner had suffered “a cognizable inde pendent harm” as a result of his removal from the hepatitis C treatment program. Id., at 698.
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8(a)(2) requires only “a short and plain statement of the claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief.” Specific facts are not neces sary; the statement need only “ ‘give the defendant fair no tice of what the . . . claim is and the grounds upon which it rests.’ ” Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U. S. 544, 555 (2007) (quoting Conley v. Gibson, 355 U. S. 41, 47 (1957)). In
Per Curiam
addition, when ruling on a defendant’s motion to dismiss, a judge must accept as true all of the factual allegations con tained in the complaint. Bell Atlantic Corp., supra, at 555–556 (citing Swierkiewicz v. Sorema N. A., 534 U. S. 506, 508, n. 1 (2002); Neitzke v. Williams, 490 U. S. 319, 327 (1989); Scheuer v. Rhodes, 416 U. S. 232, 236 (1974)).
The complaint stated that Dr. Bloor’s decision to remove petitioner from his prescribed hepatitis C medication was “endangering [his] life.” Petitioner’s Complaint 2. It al leged this medication was withheld “shortly after” petitioner had commenced a treatment program that would take one year, that he was “still in need of treatment for this disease,” and that the prison officials were in the meantime refusing to provide treatment. Id., at 3, 4. This alone was enough to satisfy Rule 8(a)(2). Petitioner, in addition, bolstered his claim by making more specific allegations in documents attached to the complaint and in later filings.
The Court of Appeals’ departure from the liberal pleading standards set forth by Rule 8(a)(2) is even more pronounced in this particular case because petitioner has been proceed ing, from the litigation’s outset, without counsel. A docu ment filed pro se is “to be liberally construed,” Estelle, 429 U. S., at 106, and “a pro se complaint, however inartfully pleaded, must be held to less stringent standards than formal pleadings drafted by lawyers,” ibid. (internal quotation marks omitted). Cf. Fed. Rule Civ. Proc. 8(f) (“All pleadings shall be so construed as to do substantial justice”).
Whether petitioner’s complaint is sufficient in all respects is a matter yet to be determined, for respondents raised mul tiple arguments in their motion to dismiss. In particular, the proper application of the controlling legal principles to the facts is yet to be determined. The case cannot, however, be dismissed on the ground that petitioner’s allegations of harm were too conclusory to put these matters in issue. Certiorari and leave to proceed in forma pauperis are granted, the judgment of the Court of Appeals is vacated,
Thomas, J., dissenting
and the case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
It is so ordered.
Justice Scalia would deny the petition for a writ of certiorari.
Justice Thomas, dissenting.
I have repeatedly stated that the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment historically concerned only injuries relating to a criminal sentence. Farmer v. Brennan, 511 U. S. 825, 861 (1994) (opinion concur ring in judgment); Helling v. McKinney, 509 U. S. 25, 42 (1993) (dissenting opinion); Hudson v. McMillian, 503 U. S. 1, 18–20 (1992) (same). But even applying the Court’s flawed Eighth Amendment jurisprudence, “I would draw the line at actual, serious injuries and reject the claim that expo sure to the risk of injury can violate the Eighth Amend ment.” Helling, supra, at 42 (Thomas, J., dissenting). Consistent with these views, I would affirm the judgment of the Court of Appeals. I respectfully dissent.