Case details
Bluebook Citation
Duncan v. Thompson, 315 U.S. 1 (1942)
Full caption
DUNCAN v. THOMPSON, TRUSTEE.
Country
United States
Jurisdiction
Federal
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Decided
Jan. 12, 1942
DUNCAN v. THOMPSON, TRUSTEE.
CERTIORARI TO THE SPRINGFIELD COURT OF APPEALS OF MISSOURI.
No. 78. Argued December 16, 1941.—Decided January 12, 1942.
1. An agreement between an injured railway employee and the railway employer, made after the injury, whereby, in consideration of a payment “for living and other expenses pending further developments as to the extent and effect of said injuries and negotiations for settlement of [his] claim,” the employee agrees that he will endeavor, in good faith, to adjust and settle any claim he may have for his injuries without resorting to litigation, but that if his claim is not so adjusted, and he elects to bring suit, he will first return the sum paid and such return shall be a prerequisite to the filing and maintenance of any such suit, is void under § 5 of the Federal Employers Liability Act. P. 6.
2. Such an agreement is not a compromise or conditional compromise. P. 7.
146 S. W. 2d 112, reversed.
Certiorari, 314 U. S. 589, to review a judgment of the Springfield Court of Appeals which reversed a recovery for personal injuries secured by the present petitioner in a court of first instance in Missouri. An application to the supreme court of the State for a writ of certiorari was declined.
Mr. Harry G. Waltner, Jr., with whom Mr. John Moberly was on the brief, for petitioner.
447727°—42----- 1 J
Mr. John H. Flanigan, with whom Messrs. Thos. J. Cole and Allen McReynolds were on the brief, for respondent.
The contract was a covenant not to sue. A covenant not to sue is in the nature of a contract of release.
If the Federal Employers Liability Act does not prohibit an injured claimant from releasing his cause of action for a consideration, by parity of reasoning it ought to be held that the Act does not prohibit him from covenanting, for a consideration, not to sue on his cause of action.
Every court which has considered the question has come to the conclusion that the Congress, by § 5 of the Act, did not intend to prohibit an injured claimant from compromising his disputed claim and from releasing the same.
The courts and text writers are unanimous in saying that the purpose of Congress was to prohibit employer and employee, before injury of the latter, from contracting to exempt the employer from the liability created by the Act, and not to prevent the parties from contracting after injury.
Petitioner, having accepted the substantial sum of 8600 in consideration of his covenant not to sue, can not disaffirm his covenant and sue in violation of it while clinging to the fruits of the contract which he affects to disaffirm.
Mr. Justice Black delivered the opinion of the Court.
April 10, 1936, petitioner Duncan, while performing duties as respondent’s employee, fell from a locomotive and was injured. Since at the time he was working for a “common carrier by railroad” and in interstate commerce, the right to recover damages is governed by the [p. 3] Federal Employers’ Liability Act. 35 Stat. 65. Sixteen months later, August 13, 1937, Duncan was still suffering from his injuries, his wife was in the hospital, and he needed money. On that day, upon Duncan’s signing an instrument presented to him by the company’s claim agent, he was paid $600 “for living and other expenses pending further developments as to the extent and effect of said injuries and negotiations for settlement of [his] claim.” The instrument also stated that:
“In consideration of said payment of $600.00, I agree with said Trustee that I will endeavor, in good faith, to adjust and settle any claim I may have for my injuries without resorting to litigation, but I agree that if my claim is not so adjusted, and I elect to bring suit, I will first return the said sum of $600.00 to said Trustee and said return shall be a prerequisite to the filing and maintenance of any such suit.”
About eight months later, April 4, 1938, negotiations for settlement not having been successful, Duncan, without returning the $600, sued the respondent in a Missouri state court, charging that his injuries resulted from the negligence of the respondent’s servants or agents. Among other pleadings, the respondent filed a plea in abatement alleging that “this suit and action have been begun and commenced by plaintiff without the pre-requisite return to defendant trustee of said sum of $600, . . . and this action is pre-mature and should be dismissed by the Court.” Duncan replied that the agreement, so far as it purported to create a condition precedent to bringing suit, was void under § 5 of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, 35 Stat. 65, 66, which in part provides:
“Any contract, rule, regulation, or device whatsoever, the purpose or intent of which shall be to enable any common carrier to exempt itself from any liability created by this Act, shall to that extent be void . . .”
The trial judge held the agreement did not bar Duncan’s suit, but submitted the issues of negligence to the jury with instructions that if their verdict should be for him the railroad would be entitled to a credit of $600 and interest. The verdict was for Duncan and, after appropriate subtraction for the prior payment to him, judgment for $5,000 was entered in his favor. The Springfield Court of Appeals reversed, holding that the invalidating effect of § 5 does not extend to contracts made after an employee is injured, 146 S. W. 2d 112, and the Missouri Supreme Court declined to review its action.
In Philadelphia, B. & W. R. Co. v. Schubert, 224 U. S. 603,611, this Court referred to § 5 as follows:
“The evident purpose of Congress was to enlarge the scope of the section and to make it more comprehensive by a generic, rather than a specific, description. It thus brings within its purview ‘any contract, rule, regulation, or device whatsoever, the purpose or intent of which shall be to enable any common carrier to exempt itself from any liability created by this Act.’ It includes every variety of agreement or arrangement of this nature . . .” While this interpretation is broad enough to bring within § 5 contracts made after as well as before the injury, the agreement at issue in the Schubert case was made prior to the injury, and the actual decision therefore does not control agreements which, like that now before us, are made after the injury has occurred. Moreover, several state courts have expressed the view that contracts made after the injury has occurred are not invalidated by § 5. See, e. g., Ballenger v. Southern Ry. Co., 106 S. C. 200, 203, 90 S. E. 1019; Patton v. Atchison, T. & S. F. Ry. Co., 59 Okla. 155, 156, 158 P. 576; Lindsay v. Acme Cement Plaster Co., 220 Mich. 367, 377, 190 N. W. 275; Carlson v. Northern Pacific Ry. Co., 82 Mont. 559, 568, 268 P. 549.
Because of this divergence of judicial opinion as to the interpretation of § 5, and because the scope of § 5 is of fundamental importance in the administration of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, we granted certiorari.
Section 3 of the first Federal Employers’ Liability Act,1 passed by Congress in 1906, provided that “no contract of employment, insurance, relief benefit, or indemnity for injury or death entered into by or on behalf of any employee, nor the acceptance of any such insurance, relief benefit, or indemnity by the person entitled thereto, shall constitute any bar or defense to any action brought to recover damages for personal injuries to or death of such employee. . . .” The court below, taking the position that the word “contract” as used in § 3 referred only to contracts entered into before the injury occurred, concluded that § 5 of the present act is no broader in this respect, but merely includes contracts, rules, regulations, or devices in effect before the injury. In our opinion, the difference in the language of the two sections and the legislative history of the later one cannot be reconciled with this conclusion.
It is clear from the Congressional committee hearings and reports on the Federal Employers’ Liability Act now in force, not only that close study was made of the entire 1906 Act and in particular of § 3, but also that considerable attention was given to state employers’ liability acts and experience under them. Section 3 was incorporated verbatim in one of the two bills introduced in the Senate, but it was the bill containing the broader language of the present § 5 that survived consideration. See Hearings on S. 3080, February 20, 1908, p. 3, and compare Senate Report No. 460, 60th Cong., 1st Sess., p. 4. Without more, the change from “contract” to “any contract, rule,*
*34 Stat. 232. This act was declared unconstitutional in the Employers’ Liability Cases, 207 U. S. 463.
regulation, or device whatsoever” would seem to be an enlargement ample to include agreements made after the event of injury.
But there is more. Under the state acts there had been widespread attempts by employers to contract themselves out of the liabilities the acts were intended to impose. State legislatures had responded to this practice by adopting provisions which proscribed employer-employee agreements intended to deprive employees of the statutory benefits. These provisions varied in scope and language. Some declared agreements attempting to exempt employers from liability void only when they were part of contracts of employment. One state, although not limiting the statutory invalidation to contracts of employment, specifically restricted it to agreements “entered into prior to the injury.” Other states, presumably after experience had shown that narrower limitations were inadequate to stamp out ingenious evasions of the statutory responsibilities, adopted measures invalidating agreements of any type, regardless of when made, which attempted to exempt employers from liability. House Report No. 1386,60th Cong., 1st Sess., pp. 30-75.
The report of the House Judiciary Committee on the second Federal Employers’ Liability Act set out all of the state statutes then in effect. Because the various state measures directed against contractual arrangements intended to exempt employers from liability were thus laid before Congress, the rejection of the restrictive language of § 3 of the old act indicates a deliberate abandonment of the limitations of that section. And the adoption of § 5 of the present act, without adding any of the other limitations which some of the state statutes had embodied, argues persuasively that Congress wanted § 5 to have the full effect that its comprehensive phraseology implies.
Concluding that the phrase “any contract, rule, regulation, or device whatsoever” as used in § 5 comprehends the instrument signed by Duncan long after he had been injured, we turn to the remaining question: whether “the purpose or intent” of the instrument was to enable the respondent “to exempt itself from any liability created by [the] Act.” The instrument prepared by the respondent for Duncan’s signature purported to create a condition precedent to his bringing suit, the refunding of $600. By its terms, unless this condition were satisfied—and in view of Duncan’s straitened circumstances the probability of satisfaction would seem negligible—Duncan’s only means of enforcing such liabilities as should have beeiA assumed by the respondent would be taken from him. Hence, the agreement, if valid, would effectively exempt the respondent from liability under the act, no matter what the merits of Duncan’s claim.
The respondent contends, however, that § 5 does not invalidate compromises of disputed claims, and that the agreement here is in the nature of a conditional compromise. We need not here determine what limitations, if any, § 5 places upon the validity of agreements not to sue if made in consideration of a bona fide compromise and settlement of claims arising under the act, because the very language of the agreement indicates it is not a compromise and settlement. While the agreement does contemplate the possibility of future settlement, it expressly stated that the $600 was advanced “for living and other expenses pending further developments as to the extent and effect of . . . injuries and negotiations for settlement of [the] claim.” And the claim agent of the respondent testified that the agreement was in a form regularly used by the respondent when its employees “had a long disability period like he [Duncan] had had ... to tide
Statement of the Case. 315 U. S.
them over until they had their recovery before we negotiate final settlement.” We are unpersuaded, therefore, by any argument which depends upon treating the agreement signed by Duncan as a compromise.
The judgment of the Springfield Court of Appeals is
Reversed.
Mr. Justice Roberts took no part in the consideration or decision of this case.
EX PARTE TEXAS et al.
ON MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS.
No. —, Original. Argued December 8, 9, 1941.—Decided January 12, 1942.
1. In Lone Star Gas Co. v. Texas, 304 U. S. 224, this Court decided that the company, in support of its claim that gas rates fixed by the Texas Railroad Commission were confiscatory, was entitled to make proof of confiscation on the basis of services rendered by an integrated system—the basis on which the Commission fixed the rates in question; but did not decide that the rates were confiscatory or in anywise foreclose a trial of that issue in the state courts. Pp. 12-13.
2. Leave to file a petition for a mandamus directed to the Justices of the Supreme Court of a State, requiring them to conform their judgment to a decision of this Court determining federal questions earlier in the case, will not be granted where, by their return to the order to show cause, they show that the judgment of the state court was based not upon a misconception of this Court’s decision, as alleged and relied upon in the petition for mandamus, but upon a construction and application of state law. P. 14.
Motion denied.
Motion for leave to file a petition for a writ of mandamus against the Chief Justice and the Associate Justices of the Supreme Court of Texas, to bring a judgment of [p. 9] that court in conformity with a controlling mandate of this Court. The Lone Star Gas Company was here granted leave to intervene, 314 U. S. 582.
Mr. James P. Hart, with whom Mr. Gerald C. Mann, Attorney General of Texas, was on the brief, for petitioners.
Mr. Charles L. Black, with whom Messrs. Roy C. Coffee, Marshall Newcomb, Ogden K. Shannon, and Ben H. Powell were on the brief, for the Lone Star Gas Co., intervenor.
Messrs. James P. Alexander, John H. Sharp, and Richard Critz submitted, pro se.
Mr. Justice Frankfurter delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is a motion by the Attorney General and Railroad Commission of the State of Texas for leave to file a petition for a writ of mandamus against the Chief Justice and Associate Justices of the Supreme Court of Texas to bring a judgment of that Court into conformity with the controlling mandate of this Court. The foundation of the motion is the claim that in the proceedings following the remand by this Court to the Texas courts of the litigation in Lone Star Gas Co. v. Texas, 304 U. S. 224, the Supreme Court of Texas has misconceived the scope of our decision. The history of the litigation must therefore be summarized.
In 1934 the Railroad Commission of Texas brought an action in the District Court of Travis County, under Article 6059 of the Revised Civil Statutes of Texas, to enforce its order of September 13, 1933, fixing the rate to be charged by the Lone Star Gas Company, a Texas corporation operating pipe lines located in Texas and Oklahoma, [p. 10] for gas delivered to distributing companies in Texas. The Commission’s order treated the Company’s properties in both states as an “integrated” system. In its answer the Company attacked the order under the Commerce and Due Process Clauses. A trial was held before a jury, which found, from the evidence before it, that the Commission’s order was “unreasonable and unjust.” Accordingly, the District Court enjoined enforcement of the order. An appeal to the Court of Civil Appeals followed. That court sustained the Commission in treating the Company as an integrated enterprise and found against the Company upon the issue of confiscation. The burden was put upon the Company “to show by clear and satisfactory evidence a proper segregation of interstate and intrastate properties and business, and to show the value of the property employed in intrastate business or commerce and the compensation it would receive under the rate complained of upon such valuation. Having failed to make a proper segregation of interstate and intrastate properties, appellee [i. e., the Company] did not adduce the quantum and character of proof necessary to establish the invalidity of the rate as being confiscatory, or unreasonable and unjust.” 86 S. W. 2d 484, 502. The Court therefore dissolved the injunction of the District Court and declared the Commission’s order to be “just, reasonable, and valid in every particular.” 86 S. W. 2d 484, 506. The Supreme Court of Texas refused a writ of error and the case then came here.
We reversed the judgment of the Court of Civil Appeals, and remanded the cause “for further proceedings not inconsistent” with the opinion. 304 U. S. 224, 242. It was held: (1) The Commission’s order did not offend the Commerce Clause. The Commission was entitled to take into consideration the Company’s producing properties in Oklahoma and its transmission lines to Texas, because “the proved manner in which the gas from [p. 11] Oklahoma was treated and handled in Texas made it an integral part of the gas supplied to the Texas communities in appellant’s intrastate business.” 304 U. S. at 239. (2) On the issue of confiscation the Court of Civil Appeals had erred. The Company “could not be denied the right to introduce evidence as to its property and business as an integrated system and to have the sufficiency of its evidence ascertained by the criterion which the Commission had properly used in the same manner in reaching its conclusion as to the Texas rate.” 304 U. S. at 241-^42.
When the case came back to the Court of Civil Appeals, it held that “when viewed in the light of the over-all or unsegregated basis and evidence the legislative rate order is valid as a matter of law,” and that the validity of the order was established “factually from so overwhelming a weight and preponderance of the evidence as to require a reversal in the interest of justice.” And so it again dissolved the injunction and reinstated the Commission’s order. 129 S. W. 2d 1164. This time the Supreme Court of Texas granted a writ of error and sent the case back to the District Court for a new trial. 153 S. W. 2d 681.
In its extended opinion the Supreme Court of Texas reviewed these two rulings by the Court of Civil Appeals:
(1) Since Article 6059 of the Revised Statutes of Texas,1 governing judicial review of the Commission’s orders,*
‘Article 6059 provides: “If any gas utility or other party at interest be dissatisfied with the decision of any rate, classification, rule, charge, order, act or regulation adopted by the Commission, such dissatisfied utility or party may file a petition setting forth the particular cause of objection thereto in a court of competent jurisdiction in Travis County against the Commission as defendant. Said action shall have precedence over all other causes on the docket of a different nature and shall be tried and determined as other civil causes in said court. ... In all trials under this article the burden of proof shall rest upon the plaintiff, who must show by clear and satisfactory evidence that the rates, regulations, orders, classifications, acts or charges complained of are unreasonable and unjust to it or them.” [p. 12] makes the Commission’s findings of fact conclusive if supported by substantial evidence, and since the findings were supported by such evidence, the order was valid as a matter of law and left no question for the jury. (2) Even if Article 6059 required a trial de novo of all issues of fact, “the Gas Company failed, as a matter of law, to offer evidence sufficient to justify holding this gas rate order confiscatory, or unreasonable and unjust.” 153 S. W. 2d at 687.
The Supreme Court of Texas held that Article 6059 does require a trial de novo in the District Court. It added that “there is no escape from the conclusion that the United States Supreme Court did consider and did pass upon the sufficiency of the Gas Company’s evidence, when considered from the viewpoint of the Company’s entire properties, and did hold such evidence legally sufficient to sustain the verdict of the jury finding this rate order confiscatory.” 153 S. W. 2d at 689. Later in its opinion, the Texas Supreme Court stated “that such opinion [of the Supreme Court of the United States] decides that the evidence contained in this record is sufficient, in law, to invoke the fact finding jurisdiction of the district court. It follows that such matter has been foreclosed by the United States Supreme Court, and is not open for decision by this Court, and was not open for decision by the Court of Civil Appeals.” 153 S. W. 2d at 695.
It agreed with the Court of Civil Appeals that the trial court, to the prejudice of the Commission, had erroneously permitted the testimony of a Company witness and refused to exclude various Company exhibits. Immediately following this part of its opinion the Supreme Court of Texas wrote: “It is evident from our holdings above that this case must be remanded to the district court for a new trial.” 153 S. W. 2d at 699.
The petitioners read the opinion of the Supreme Court of Texas to mean that the claim of confiscation could no [p. 13] longer be contested in the Texas courts because this Court adjudicated that claim in the Company’s favor. Such was not the ruling of this Court. The merits of the claim of confiscation were not reviewed. All that was decided here was that the Company was entitled to make proof of confiscation on the same basis—namely, that of services rendered by an integrated system—as that on which the Commission fixed the rates. On their reading of the opinion of the Supreme Court of Texas, the petitioners were naturally eager for a prompt correction of the decision of that Court, even though it was not final, without waiting for this rate controversy, already eight years old, again to wind its measured way through the Texas courts and then to be brought here on an indubitably federal question, to wit, the proper construction of a mandate of this Court.
The petitioners claim that but for a misapplication of our mandate the Texas Supreme Court might have sustained the Court of Civil Appeals and the litigation could finally have come to an end. Since the opinion of the Texas Supreme Court, on its face, appeared to be susceptible of the construction given it by the petitioners, we issued a rule to show cause. 314 U. S. 579.
In their return, the Chief Justice and Associate Justices of the Supreme Court of Texas state that that court “would have rendered the same judgment if it had based the same solely upon its construction of the State statute and not at all upon its construction of the opinion of this Court.” The return further showed that in remanding the cause to the District Court for a new trial the Supreme Court of Texas acted entirely pursuant to state law: “The Court of Civil Appeals in this State has full power to set aside findings based on conflicting evidence and believed by it to be against the overwhelming weight and preponderance of the evidence and to remand the case for another trial; but it is without power to set aside findings based on [p. 14] conflicting evidence and then make its own findings and render judgment thereon.”
We read this return as a disclaimer by the judges of the Supreme Court of Texas of the construction placed upon their opinion by the petitioners insofar as it touches the scope of this Court’s ruling in 304 IT. S. 224 and the effect of that decision upon the future course of this litigation. Specifically, we read the return as a disavowal by the Supreme Court of Texas that its action in reversing the Texas Court of Civil Appeals and ordering a new trial implied that our decision adjudicated the claim of confiscation or in any wise forecloses trial of that issue. Therefore, when the litigation goes back to the District Court, it will not be imprisoned within an adjudication to be attributed to this Court which this Court never made. We must accept the return of the Texas judges regarding the scope of judicial review of orders of the Texas Railroad Commission, as well as their showing regarding the distribution of judicial power within the Texas judicial system. These are matters of local law.
The rule will therefore be discharged and the motion denied.
So ordered.
Mr. Justice Roberts heard the argument and agreed to the above disposition of the case, but through absence was unable to join in the opinion.
Mr. Justice Black, Mr. Justice Douglas and Mr. Justice Murphy concur in the result.
ProvenanceKnow exactly where this document came from.Members see the sourcing behind every authority on DocPost — so you can check the record yourself and cite with confidence.Request access